Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
R K Dharmik vs D/O Post on 5 March, 2020
OL # 3 nid D2 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, MUMBAT BENCH, CAMP AT NAGPUR.
O.A. 2144/2011Dated this Thursday the 05% day of March, 2020.
Administrative} .
Member f{ i, Dr. Bhagwan Saha 2 Ceram { By Advocate Ms.Shiba Thakur }.
Yereus « ae ro wo whe { By Advocate Shri R.G. Agrawal }.
17.02.2020 = Order reserved on ¢ * 05.03.2020, Order delivered on RD.B OR ry ss Ma Nae % arf &3 43 Go ap Ch.
mt yes a4 LOT SE Ae 4 we atm RAKE 1 a Lie he earaAre 4 i YA oN oe CATR & f wot Ses le Mabe ee wo eye Goby re Nae A. CREAR Nae x be 4 « got + y Gogper=: Pet ae us 4 i} Et on 4 vad yy i> aft '% w eo 8 OB fe 6 re oO Bot as = tf Ch eet ia m% SA : Evy vert co a ay < 4 KG he to Bes ibed aot co v ie _ 5 B & moe 6B OB OB oR 3 * i a ge 8 cl o ¢ o BA yn wo 8 @ i « Be Sd 2 i . - Le "ay! SoM 5 at ts oy on ~ " Q ged sot i Seg xn =} ern is 4 " 44 Gg % 5 so mC e © e << ond ' a 4 n eA 4 a iB ha n 2 as s on ie be ; ' : Seg oD w me ; = 3 : no So - . OO 5. mm & os mH o bef sae) ra ce a " Ht . & & % . a 'i th . i & 4 f o O to ¢ aa 3 8) 3 ' ord et ' Oy sot * oy oy) aw Ne 5 in , y, i wh 1g es Os wd ents " oe 5 34 " oe ; : w~* 4 o 43 Ch ea : a, , . Hom O Y So Be i * em nd " a "S . ua i a & th ets bs ne he vied Ay Gq 8 BQ rs wD es a foe - et ho ci "
i g ae 1 iB ti as) iG 4 vm & @ ' eS cm o é ? 3 eG % x : pon 6 w qi ay % @ S B S eB a ; 3 wy c 4 * 2 mn a ; 2g : @ + a oa Ay fe aa "et coe ry os f \ ved Cc 44 Ad 4 oh ra "3 Fe) & ' t ty oN 4 a mM & % fe 3 A fe et :
CoN we we Ls ed an 32 2% cys cn or "rey in " €. Ta c pat on ony the tA Fray tha "eh eeed ot yet 2 ve ' ® . git £4 Co u . eh, ry i 2 ; Gi 8) ' uy . a ved as Ad . iy oe ia 4 ee ". teh Sd tf wD xy bat wed Gh on c 4 S wy ve a - 5' ' ~; w ed cA ort rf a me « > oa co "ed 2 od ah o ; poe Q > 3 Cnt 4a 4 cH ¢ welt 7 o vA ii "S 3 * ; fag '9 ® Sed : ' w Q o> a b iB _l os g ' bh pe Oo sc % . ME a Ong bp tes i oO BW © @ me * So eh Vv Be ed w fre " > ok "74 co ai 54 red ay io - on 4 £ oh 2 Go ge Mi " ie 4 eed ey { A a ft ry . % . shew ad tha BS ans mg i Es ey O - os 2 3 ve és 4.3 "3 La 4 ea ot a a4 ' werk ae i o * " is 4 ; fei : et ei cw :
By ay os i Q me 3 a og i be CD . uy on is bes 3 Mel Se a "5 bs os 7 rs ss ° ~ So i te 33 " ry Ee w SS 3 a " & ° Se a kt "= o i a 4 uy o OB : ' * r ct wa thet iy * se) wi a ¢ a o ai . 4 ' i a 424 4 : ' co "A - ih 3 eA 5 cand o Cy ard uf} a : % ae ke. " oe pe i is) G cad os + a ® ms 4d > ' hy <3 a ie ord hed sed 3 be aS 6 fod v An 3 ie ah we a oO : ca vd ne oe ; 3 % Eat 4 Eel Got @ OC CC DP Fe OE ee : 98 o 5 : oS a ook eo agra " Cc " 5 43 stg ; hd 3 o ved & KA a oo @ wy 'O ant oi et en «3 " ei te Ad : e wt so 4 e od «a ra) pet a oy a ae "e cs re S4 B3 wn ° ¥ ee oak mA MS .
em a x os re i o re oo cS wm a 4 "74 ond Ne Ad VA oe rau AG on . ead a rt he x e oy ied ua C3 we w , 4 wy 15 wa '4 33 wh S ed el ° to a4 nt 2 m aed , o aed ied , oS > ort 9 x "4 Ss v o ms 3 Fy n 43 i mS "3 ~ gt BY Peony fo cK oe . on wd a a xd Go mn 4 peed a wo gent a ihe @ ey 0 ee 2 5 5 " CX gs 4 ot ae '4 rp DO re ee ye tk 40 0 it wo ts G we o oO AY rt 3 a wn ' 4 * wwe _ ™ <7, . ; bs ogee o> in ' Oo 6 vo ae a3 oy 4 is Pa o a a 3 ass $4 a Ry we et a od ee Gs vs Ch gs a Me fea ot a os sy ; % " { 3 i" oF ne ope A e " he wD Shed oO a? ae 4 rs 7 4 bed $y he w ih a ae > *e we bed 0 fe 3 i 0 Tg : BG "4 a som 8 wg » mG a, a « " vd os Lo ot ved 4 bs Hel os Mt kd 3 o i a od { a 42 MS a Ps oy , fs . ed 3 1 os i 3 o "a 7 ee Bk © rol "Ch a7 ~ bey 4 seed 4 ft a ' vs Oe "7 % oe a ¥ i> Yh ad ret ot pad, wo > 2 ts Ju oi G ' " ned e ( if SG re od re Ch , i n Bed c bea oa a > ' as Oo i ned ts iB 5 7 a rey sh ue vod " 4 fe . * Os cs a + 3 i "3 i Oh, "4 : om w 2 . 5 co a es O 3 nw end 3 oa a S y is = a Ra ' a 7 a ors om at or % 5 os ten Ba : a ; o o o Us 3. ow a3 C3 5 5 i hss - ; so Mo oO 3 ie a oo Frog + , io, 3d a G we u wo io D Saad 4 ch, x ' * " rs wn peed Boe iB a ee ~ 6 a WY vey Mh opt i Gi iS Feat £3 "0 : eo Ay ; od hed m4 TS e at * i eed ed ord ~ 44 ' he " -e-4 A as oe G s 4A Lo wy we i ™ v ba mn Ae; 43 ved m5 et ot J va 4 pos 4 a as 2 Ms ni te a Mi @ & cS +4 2 G6 oy BOD co i OS a 3 Soe ; 5 peed 6 m a i 4 a no 1 "
et ad bA a 4 "S ? oh cs ie a * wo "4 o a .; ; is ' S ao o St Get io aS 8 . Ge fet a3 4 ooo ' GQ Oh 2 OM ne ced oe i age "a Z, 4 : ood , , . uit a a ny te ba ne a o se a a Q 5 at rt £3 a c iS Se a rt ty QD te ried ved as a) on cot G a Pe, b. wh ee os % e 6 ib es wh n "3 wD #) wy . ~ we MS 3 « a3 He a vet sed 4 wy ved sel i eA ved $4 iE sd a w G gh ", " " 5 f e655 wr o ~ hd Su a ey bay Ae Ft iat a go : a pani ca 3 . Y ve weet * ey sy 6 4 . ae) 4 Go set S os oh, Yea fa sw a a. o G (a oe at MM . en Led uy BA by aes vl a < riek o ao re fo) ccd 3 - os 4 a en 3 he " 4 : Be Re 2 ext ord ad hy re ce a ros . «ft 3 4 mn rs ) faa J y of & 3 tb to eo a © 4 EY "3 i & *s 4 ot 43 ee rE No ee 44 o a my ne G ar ie =) cs * 3 a YY shed ag) 4 BY ee et an 5 e u a me , 4 ™ a ae be & c ee a es os 4 ° ee" i G o D4 : Bo ' 2 @ a @ ied x fh othe a x oo iD Qo e "4 G ai we mG os ¢4 oe " ¢ "4 = in ; ' the oo wd ip D <3 3 ve s ° Wd wm St 3 iF " ma 3 xed a wok aa «3 a peed vet i tee, w i g 43 BE a n eh "4 cp ua Be Or, o iv io see} ad % fe ied on er i ned $c end rou ri US . a ao if bes
- oc 44 45 Beg x5 gs nif o 3 aw. es & " fee "
. 3 Yt "e ' o ae hd + es m0 a $a of a ; oa a Oo i £6; ks " Oh bed a od re e 4 ib . ba :
we wD i = o a a tf a oh, oa 4 a Oo 4 whee ss, ub a3 a t a 4 fe fa oe a c ib ak B nm & Bo Bow * g " ¢ i '3 oo sh ~ ts Ch é on eed C a i "s 4 gs ee) "et : ' o ot us cs "4 . 4 Se nk a) oe pn ' 5 be evs
- AG tt ra] ea {3 ord es 4 et ved hed 43 4 ' ~ a . : ss mh OG O 12 "
Le v ty ; ped ms os iG hd ww a ib gS Ct "ny A 3 Si3 3 'a w 3 " 3 64 ees x ae i By "rd hs "ed 3 We Oo et ves ve O £ SS i commanes 2 mH OD HS . G th ved 43 co oY 2, ee 9 3 4 be G3 ty 3 cs "S Seq is
58) Sel D ig ib 5 wD va § oy ¢ a eo 3 & an re tel v o fy od ra Sep eke He @ - ® "4 as "rs aed a ea od as oh ip aA 3 oe 2 Sy fs m4 > o hi fy O 44 cS a 4 % wed Q wi B re be wo Ch, wm Fg i "ee thet ip O 'neor is} $3 4s & bn iG M4 ws iis iy ic) %} F KS ro] Ch Spek Gy, at Q, "3 WneOa RO pe eet on EEO LOOT LOOT OPT LENO EN UW ase an as, Net orEt wo eed c pert ks 1e4 om allowed £3 oF) % ou % um mh rad we S way oh SARS GR ae .
& 2 3 Shack 'at Ce n _ 2 ee sy Nan 9 QePe et & rood ve ee oN te ey a TS <3 2 + 4 i?
io) BES.
E 2 Pal 'Sh 2S o X ri 3 & Wik te OY 4 S bade we ¥ Te Fn AS Ne x « @ wn wi hy "F3 4 hat ms ah 4% . RS 8 oo Be 4 o weed "G ' y AG eed Ce . a @ ot a eat 58) 5 Jed Fea] aed Sushma Q oe of vert to ie) be rat 43) ws oe By oa cA Gh 5 Wy ay G oes werd ord . reek og ayo od Os Be i : z as 4 . : iy w :
fo . @ 4 pa ye i a a ty x . 4 " eb Fem my a a i se = ¢g , i . "4 ma ~ " & , 4 g 33 2) BB as ® ' os 5 a ws % o G @ an hd Ss a ag & G ad bef i' oy 4 ony Bg ea 4 pa cy oO mS & o Bs oS Oo ts « eo et wet ved a o pet pe ht Y BY fet i as y Ay "et a Z it o 1 m§ pes : ea a a ; oa sn fel "4 Yn e « - ' my 5 eC Se yg ay 8 ee ba ord cs Q 12 a oO BS r oe @ gy BO on "3 Gb & Py 3 "ct me oo on st #) S 6 ge od 2 * ; ote ds * ka het a oe bs) ot a4 g i srg fo uy Hi G3 seed at 3 u ey art o Sg mB . of pee a si " . 4 ro eo ay @ ct ut 2 a i sy SA oe on 43 0 i @ ra gy © ES cf ea & i o i m + ye 'g : hal wd a * » sD sed "7 M4 "4 ho "A < @ 2 3a t 3.3 "th ved i ed 4 £2 2 Eee Me ey i} La week Me a an s Z o gt a £5 "? w " 3 e Kes pe ue ee oy a oo ke 4 '7 aha ; a tg tp "
ta t a io wg ee te. oa es am i} ped a3 en} o % 5 eS Aes hea oo, % aed a 3 3 Cc a i 3 2 ee Ly os G tt ved re : 2 a A a os . bs o " Choc ka "4 we and ip ned 4 ' : "a fn * ey wt ce) S : £4 fo Gy un wh 44 vu bf O 8 7 © ef i > os Oo es Oy p 84 y 2 Gs a "gt 3 a) uy re) My 5 et Bo 4 @ oo > § " o a © 6 8 a @ « pO me bj 4 "
' ' ud = ea aw . 6 weed . ta a "PR An wet SY 3 we ~ & ard hs 8 a OG ww =~ a : e+) i 3 3 ert 5 ve fe U qo ig wa OG Rn 3 BOs UM a " ' vt "sd ct i & ® w % o> : . 4 my om ood 8 Newt ve So oC a 2 m4 a tS wD ci Ss - of : 3 "4 i i re @ ot 5 ag tae ert o o2y Ad C4 bey, Ld I fa oy yy G i rs se 34 a) tm & a 2) a, £ a 2 Sf a oS ay eet o i 5 aot 4 ba 7 we st on ' ¥ ¥ hAY + my de so uy aa v O ne a & a) ma m oy on 0 a a t '4c RE MLTR ET EPs tm 4 re tht oi ha rm oo we ip a3 syef im $d BB 8 wh +s F a r fs ms o fie a & a 4 i ; He & iN veya ory om ' ue Ad yy i 4 ~ 4 th 4, ten n g Se wD a 4 i on uw hy vi w Q ; ™ et , o ' TH is G " rye - ' os ay is Ea a 2) ws te oo apd wh 1G fea E ; 8 CS o3e ft Cs "
ot a 3 ub $4 4 a3 g gs "
cd J ms i 8 a 4S 4 A ay a Bog n v4 a ned bs Red ab x ot i 3 u i . * "gr * mo oy aNd 2 he . "4 ra t : hes 4+ ees ¢ * nt eS * : bbs oO Vb & aN Oy, RA Bet eta irs a wa fon ce ix .
ed m2 OF vga § a mo a on gs mG © --
in ca ah iN aa Z ty ted ; ' % e ete ay os iD yet > cS os aed ; Aa oo ih ao) £24 we ed gy 3 bos, .
Ms a i "4 54 % in ~ sn, yp 3 G ps Ao bet 4 4 Ss "yt + ae e sae Aad rm i Y 5 ut hee on = tea a 5 ot © cae co i ° oN oe tat ce he z Che > way ay ws % > rs "eed ay Gg i te 4 ix mG ELLE era os i whey aN :
5A, 07 mo ms a ony of s Thearetor a hae plica ax i PL h ¥ i wae < n 3 Py os Ch ay ried et ' n.
ify ry reed een = a wD ct on uy Om wy hat a St c .
J mB 18 et 3 4 eet mo te
e) CA 3 ed a4 CZ wz Cre oSy 4 = o ee JRE.
* ny E je ne g i] 274 "3 Stk).
vert HID i wy he per a ate or eee $i a re ENT 2 OMS oe gy reyy, a4 he & o $.
ee £ oNYY i wd bw] ?
3 3my Yet ond w) eae der, eran ft.
$4 ~ a "3 4 ; 4 4 :
oO me " oa te ie G : w G &4 hy ea et o t * 3 . bes ha Ca £3 ct C3 ct thy OG . o Pet J te} Sy ie a i 4 ' 3 Fred gu ay na oa * uy es sot co Cr os ee us At oa ( C i £5 a va ' vl 43 x 4 tad ; & 5s gg 8 oD et "<4 OE e went fe a 4 C 4 a + es fea Se
-- Oo a1 ws wi wt "ey i ° 9 @ 16 a 42 & a el Sod wes ay ted uy ts ~ . 7 a wo Ss yo At 0 o a Ea eg LJ 3 ie) ord th os uy ' G { we aa a aa wy is 43 ea sey a ; co a m3 ee ry rs gE 2 ¢ * tea he a is) * need Ses , em o bs aot i us '? a ned bt ot $4 Pra) KE 44 Oo red ue) ; 4H 3 ies fla ~ oe cn ne ol } bt a va ved i 0 vA a ci , i vs o B wa i 4 A i f& a4 mS ved 403 4 oy oe ae a "% a ¢ & 43 : 8 a vl a $a £ wef: has 4 : i ha a A " oA . % on i. 3 bay 6% Oo > fs G a SB ee : He wet ;
wn om - Oo " et @ "4 iL arf ¢ B D ne "a 43 * ved ma "et 4s ? es g a 0 my o "4 o iB 3 a c vt 2 * Sa : ° fe Boom oe 5 Gj 4g @ by ye «6 oo Og A pag rf te / 2 ey = ; +2 & oy " en
(i) 33 3% "a h my mt me, th ft bee C Se " + ys bt ed a Gs bi ag ~ 6 Q Lovd 43 we "4 Bh , a : a % t u "4 ; WO GE rs 5 % , Rs 5 en « ; ye a 3 $4 4) cs ' C3 i ye a) . SE co & , a a . " ' ea 4 wd ie om 43 be gs * : ope et "
OQ wy a de 3 sy 2 oj G O : ae ae 1 as 34 o ue uy Of Bo fe wi a ® & Ao mt ic $4 oC 4 4 a aed © ea, we ed 4 " ard : Ms r iG 0 - % von s . of re Fr ; bes 3 on 2 it, a, wr > is "4 Ct ie ue on © os j "ge od vet a be ae oe iG a Steed o - ke ® 4a om 4 as wel £2 i bee ved Seg 3 Ae ae ws Med a ke vt ioe a pe se te w Boy ed © . o eo qb Oe £4; o ver ro "4 "a pee eee thy at + "yet Ey 4 "a fF "4 tea iy ve hen Sat my 4 pe Ly. yet tae ott "4 ed Fs as 4° Ut ip bea ' nay u? "f : ee ot 4 iy i it , 4 i ee as ; wes m bo '3 £3 Gh, Sy 4s wt , u os mi wo ee i ne "ed vied a @ 4 C °C "4 . ; a! oe w a ¢ a . 3 ba > mM oA gi we gS ; 2 . ma a . 4 ae wD CO ap ad 4 ot yet ms Ma 4 ot us a Oy wy a 2g &, w = $e ved o oy re one ae wed i is:
o Dy AS tog ec © ie a " He ree oy nk S Ly % mf es ig i {O 54 3 bee é ort % AN me at Q = e fai oe cs ved os o 4, eat y, te di ge * ta "3. (fy Sey Raa 5, ag - ue oo ot Gh & ; : ? «5 4 . i ws us x 43 $3 oe a eA . q a} a cs G a ad ny @ + o rs) o es c - o oi "sf a Fos ra 4 et id seen jet ort fone 4 S wt peed ped aa s ; wet 4 . ' oe wy ot f or ten ey we as 2 44 "he? gS sed * pad af G a coe > LA oe oy fe a a) dl S pr ee be be "4 ha "
o + on 'e "gs oi o o c pa ce '3 5 t M "et cs Fe) : es uO "4 Ci oO i a cA ; i Y a & } ed ti & oC ci as) ca oa nt * pe SG Q g " ve Pies a re) if ' Se 4a a vd é ' 0 < kB 7 Fy i g pia te ¥. w 43 483 f, re 42 : 4 J See Ci apt ot ~ 5. co mS on wy : x ted 2 rs8) + 3 : vin ia ot * ws 6 ta ' ' " ; vy at Ct = cc ree ies} bebe a OF ep ot ry ws A head end a om QD <3 whee so 7 O 0 n 5 6 rt " d Be a Be ks O Mee sae G a a oS ee a ' | gy i st ee S Mt oo a seek rh Js if i bed Ba ot wy cy 1 rf " me a un ie Bo a B w Ch ry gy ft rg Si f {3 gS {8 a o a £3 cn oo, % e 6 "4 hed o aD ra G par Co 63 My Bel @ * re re ) gs xo . = tt oe " 3 6 os Oo A 2 a re 43 a " = U3 hee a "4 my a , = x Me * ~ te O re <4 3.3 mn tos tat srs rood 58 "ae ee ra) en LS, coat i t 3 ce "GS @ os od ee & ved roy aa "t ay Soa to oy he 4 ta ba srt & : 43 A cn a] i ie ay Bed ie in : ast oe eA ti wy y " °. oS eas ug me @ 64 ued < cy a OG 5 S oy OE i Y =O c , t ~ i 6h, @ O "f ts Lat . ee vet " we * a a a aS aa o c ker Cy os SS whe . ~} 4 sf fast ed es ver} wet sed eS o ~ ved ce) 4 Ly w fat 2 3 a gh es ny oe td 1G o * bes es rs ~ £3 Ee ~ é " 7 G oO o 0 ce ay " & ted oy bs os a oa ress Shed te ot ~ " ae $4 May O tn - x & ¢ a £3 ak. ¥ ay. vet ; . . 9) ran v & is) ot Bos tn md 44 ce) wh 4 oye ced 44 " fy & o4 Oo 4 ads moref dy :
ot at yy ae a v : * en 43 oe weed vad wed pel ED oes ced . ths cS ibe oH So J 44 t al 4 ; Mee ree an " fr mt Ci} 4 & 4 we, a <2 oe te, wy et ee x 0 we 2 55 3 a uy weed Bo : . foal . wot "4 BY CO . + +4 5 ns 4 sed ' vd 1 " C! a go ts we ' 3 om y 4 a ce i wo a a "
, "ft a Fi oy a " t * 4 @ (3 Shs 3 is "ey @ 44 "a bs 43 ' ; oy ye as "m4 14 o% Me - +3 t Ce i 4 cs a vy ro "A i i iy % wt ' ky eo a3 : x ' ses Ba Lo: a ft) m & co a es en ct hd a oes " ot i A ~ os : as . Ly tS ~ c : Oo :
ot ie wl (a Sy ne) - we ood Xs a ae 3 . ot UK ry wB % ed tos ats : art a I # e res te bed i Cr 7 % a} hed, oi ert bet dete * go we i ve oY Rh $4 She ae it 3 ~ MO Bord 3 6 go g O° 4 ah rt Yat & th @ 0 € a 4 Oo <4 ty ' i wy , 6 mp a & 8 @) eh ced oy 5 el oe ot ee 4d as i Sd 43 'et od 3 é GU my #6 ed mA 3S £3 ag hd © Oo 5 i ce et HB ; cS po g3 x ; 4 ms a sa ae St re te io SOS om S € BH 2 a8 a vel a ba ba a a 4 be "3 42 wy Be tS * ry a ne y : + "2 ~ . s : ve a 3 ie te . "os ci aw 1% "es % sat oA 'A os 43 3 its by red ed ' ea a Brel ts a Got "* 3 om gq) wo 4 a a rd fy i o cae vd M4 2 fot '3 4 vet + a o oh } BA ' 4 0 % *, Pea Re oO he st = oh & ws he 5 > i 2011 y ot dat C4 Ne a OAT 4, OL TASS "
Lon %:
Qe z Me
-
ae ' cc bes Coy Te re on ox x ye i Ge oo & ' 3 Sb.
of a LA yh bad aoe} peed.
te 4 ELEN nae et "
Eas & 3 dein Rea BUS RS Ae L,ter i Rae he oN eS mS so ie mo 8 2 $s Q 4 os * us! . uD & CO : mH ne & ri C +e = i "rf in Fa us ws u et et & moog . % so i : 8 ® ss on oo } G $3 . we 63 B ae wi . ts " g mn el C G eS 44 @ mM "A rd vee a er a . veh sy * 4 23 ved q) iG th a < beac fy by ' GB & © & GS Bo a & GC 2 on i ne: 6 a v o: ¢ © 2 . & 3 gm y 2 -€ s a g Py 7 $§ a "
aE = es on wn a * w es ws: cel G Ss iy Bs ny a oo Be ON OE Bog o 68 a a o " "+4 qo . o » ~~ gf & S Oo a 8 ee no n Cy » oe Go ~ 4 m fe et 2 beg " % & ie ¥ ad Pai & Bb 4 wt ot a % * wa a "s Bi al A ES s es ee @ 4 e BY " po Goa g B as °° " 3 g 2 GS rt Q we a Oe Ug ha ' % n 5 Aa i ca " we od ed oo het ; od io 0 a a 4 i 5 v4 mA irs sed i . Cc He eh 0 hy PS) 3 > 5 # 3 o Bo 4B 2% a o Py oe ; D oI by a ao " BO @ SF -- BN US So mW s ae: i a 3 * ee ak oy . + . ced if - 3 z fo € & 8 BS we fot i 6 G i & om Rg Ste cf pO :
ms 30 ry G , 8 ; ee x us a ae 43 o Q ea Qe ® ve co ie Fat a rt kes rs 3 i a n s % u 4 ¢ ow t ics 7 3 . a fhe oa ond on > * uy { . ¢ ¢ i et haa . + 4s 4 2 os Q : ut vy St i a © ri uw oy % 9 + 5 a bea : rie) co ard ie vd ig ry u i a4 Sen Gy M3 on ie " 2 : "St ps m Fra} @ eed sed can tt oO <e +d @ 6 8 Bs co & me Fos 3G (8 oom oo Oo @~ &§ @ 4B * » a " "2 Mt ~ Go 8 c m@ & ¢ = > 3 ee aed . * g ay 3 : ' ot ¥ Oo a O o G AA cc 4 @ ad i oe A M4 B et is & wh we SR ae , ' " 4 # 4 QA w =~ ft Bm rt oo GUO mw & OQ od om gS 8. 8B m8 Coo~ PO BF & ey " @ % " 1G 5 S 5 4 i ™ 4 & 2 cs "8 Bg 2 o Bo ~ j ee 3 ba . © £ € ¢ a es wa © 3 4 ns . ke & fo 3 ' 7 ch rt fag eS o a ~ 8 ® @ 4 ~ Gv HH ard co] ") pad i ft u , eget ¥ ; +4 rr <4 a so , rh & ow te fy gg TS at G 5 Goo et ma awe B33 "i et 'st 2 6x je fee eS; 6 , a i 4 > 6 € @ € « & a mo 8 GS am Gf p £ 5 EA G - G de toa net ' ed at qi rs 43 % Fy se B iS ee g t% mt 1S co hd 43 5 a " a a «et 8 ont & a he : $3 ¢ Fa, 4 nn ne Bo. & qa © & g 7 8 Q oo ot * 4g {> a bef fad o 4 5 ot 4 + bet 5 ~ wt % ae Res sg © ; Oo 6G & » fsa ua on a % "a % os m% we ~ a 4 itt i i wt ro ed $4 ' "of O a My on 7 4 :
0 M4 @ D rt i ved Q a G ant o vn a ved iS , ons ba g ees me "3 "4 i @ Mo te sad BO fe Bt ee a se OY te Boe xD is; as xt AS Hn ut aod G3 be boo oh a 3 vet * ed 43 ri) rs 6] eed r} iy ad he in} Ut a o £8 ted ip oy th o "<e a oF Hea ee iS ee @ ol ot vee a "ot 9 af rs 7 MS mo - , oO & uh Laie x g G ie cm tu = & 4 x He pa? 4 .
: r ay -
A 2 a + b Q oe fig a "3 " qe oS . a od uv : we Oo <p OF ; ower o = ef wo we ped word , g om @ coat gn ce co 0 A O ao ox ol oO od Cg AQ a o . w v *, oO S @ * . ; $3 a wD "Ch 3 es hn i Me ae 6 sm ao ~* S a me ; me 8 re 4 Pood uy ns ihend vba a ote:
Sng oy os o 3 . 3 7 be ord n a ad u Oo | o fe gw eo. 2. & ah 2 ow BS y o g g a 1 & Cy a 1 € w a : ' £ 4? 2 : ' ' a We Hea a fea n v4 "
ee a OF " go «=O Ro ee Voom BO mm . > o i] "rh gy o tA at 44 i ort Fa @ pool eG * 44 4 yt 3 , & og oe : aoe) iy wt ard he 3 me Seg a za i o - aa i Sy rt vi o ' " tt Q 2) a "Al = " S o 3 ks o mn . € ~~ tb , " om Wa ha ip G eo 4 Ka 3 a - 1 eet oc to boy 034 mi 1 i Q w Qo 2 i mm OE eR GS @ © & ' re yt cGy 33 ay 4 he asd ¥ i} " . Lath a im a 8 "4 a i, ce cs & So LE th ,
- * es ok Ry co 7 fe hed ve } peck s ot & go rm & a 8 @ rs Be ord rd . 8 os . & '3 Sis eS ae ay GoM gy MG "4 ri c ee <7 ot oe ard ay se & . i} x . cf 4 ! 4 > "3 o * ig ro » ad "4 " ot oh 4 O at a $j 43 . ae) ae 2 $ ao. Q Ao gy rons re Hoo 8G we "tM HS? - o 4% Say Bo OS a rr re oe gg S58 8 2 8 EP oy GE : a aS O * rs "3 ; 5 A a _ * ¢ @ . &§ an A y % oa A i G8 hm 6 ' B® ; ed , Aa , qo Eee ao) ue " 4 . ON 5 a 2 @ iG GS & OS 8 $B 3 on bi G8 gee -
my Pe 44 o KG ros" wt o ~ C3 t @ wt a Yo ef oh oO $4 v o & Da " " on & a t si tH i) & & : A | reek 3 . S g 5 8 > 5 28 F po" 6 @ @ § Boo 8 2 a e a © % x 8 OG o ff os QB @ 0 eB © ee ee my Oo 8 7% uD os mo a oh '6 oi 4+ ras @ id a & Os 1g va % * @ g q wa ® Hu rs ae M4 ey ee Bey vt 8 5 £ BB a gE ~~ Bm Gof n 6 ® oF f° ff © ~ @ « 8 oO CU # wm © 4 oe * © oP Bw nn 1% " in ort £5 S34 i oA Et mt A "4 } ry {2 oe oa a os C fon ; ~~ it 8 & cS fea + 3 o 4 Ea fo > @ wot 4 2 a 2 ay "rd mn " es pet mo ge ig tA 8 Bi sot B 4 vr sy La " wD Er. "re 3} oo Peng a je 6h EE a "3 & 6 i > ope © one 5 8 er ae eo 4 4 ee ref os a 3 :
thy a } oy gy D ' * t a4 red es i of : 3 oe 3 bo hate « rr . iw Be an * + o we 4 4 cc a a) a a oye4 ' oe - aoe 7 " - : . et vd me cs ~ zt g w~ " om » vel +e) . vet QO % a Ld i ad we rh ed ca us x so Ow 43 * a ° & i a ss a > ee 2 vt a 63) ~ Ge "~ B ae A rf 2 ane 2. es . ved oh i { oe i a weed ey 4a a i a ° > toe! Ch eyed oy ; a 3 oy ect rm os "5 3 .
i a i oi ¢ oo @ ° oa = 2 exes re cent New Bas "
ao =y i Ne dA tid t 3, $ 2 2 13 und y SO a o "
of 4 al me % ay vot ei "vt 3:3 Bel et sf, Sat.
seed & es $3 "
a) yf LT te CATE ED.
oa SS Aa! Se APN + i
-
foe 4 3 = Sy St a ¢:
v Stre <4 Ma i eo Ney poin we ~ i x a gre fa wire omer ine ad hi EN Bae Sa ;
bea eg of tue Qa Lor z fae whe LVa 5 woe he OS baat ae at * 2S c @ ba ong iat Foe os ord sed he rey vn eed cheb 4 or oh aed gt {> * , 4 G oy oes Be emt ud ; BS £ os 5 ri on ee KG Fret Ch a cS x -
Ch Q 8) 3 Sou > aot : i 8 a . oe) eit 3 So ne i oom 8 Pe e 6 " ny " het ay * 3 c* " my a re 2 gs el m fe sind os 9 M ra " a ie) o fos aA as 3 ch ind ol oy et a4 5 us i ie 33 5 e et @ ms % 5 i » 0 eo 2 a ' C3 =f 4 va 5 i "ed 63 te uM a , ey, a fo oe > eS aw a i my OB ; : on a ; *s apd . iQ wh at oy i i a te a 4 eS i'. : oD 4 na a " :
'Sep '. > % ee ve iy £ re é ied ted a rx ca) a ts Ad od. ay O ; bef Q re ae ho 4 Ms oy "4 Q a vied 3 ta oC Sf oe ee 4 ra Bae i i + O wh + "cs iv rs ss iS O $4 ay ' < 8 e £ OG @ "ed i 5 w 3 go YP B, Oa nes .
n Sed si PR Uped ay "
' ws i 4 oY iy ft er et iB Ba 0 ass ta 24 werd ; w 4 ce A rs o a rsa] OF a 4 ar 4 is . 's * art thy a ~ a ie a £3 yet @ ' oA 1d in a: " 2} c 3 uo ay 4 Pe ie vd a 44 "ed be Q : -
we o th Gs @ oa a reek 3 MH uy a ry . 3 tenet : w a Q wy a at my e ee '2 art $e. ree :
i es a C i co ay : Ce rs mn rn 3S 2 wf G i \ . = G aaa 4 o ft i 3 my mR ahs as w Ss , e a y 2 43 % Wed iw nen Sha C4 ah y f sed g au 4 a 2 os, ort Cy iG 4, wh Be | bed 4 4 ss @ ha id & : TR G bs ub i f «8 eh Et . " .
wy " cad org CD) id 1 te bd em ES % ee, es . ih me 3 8 Be ra . fm a Cs QB a ths bef a Aa a4 ae * ' 2 = 5 tS a 3 pe cae & ba LA eo ft my * ot ry % 4 ered . m4 ss oO She bd ra o cd ron ' "i 5 Reet we bas fa bsd 3) mt cy sg es zg ea " a " Oo a g Q on is o i re ho rt & £4 bs " by art Es '4 th he "ed ra od 4 " sot a ' .
- 2) oe dey wed c <A gy 4 3. 43 G to v4 > a 2 wn i oF Ri ms ea "4 oO ie sors + bes og re) . sed ba "4 4 185. om vr os fa te 7 * % oa gen 3 pe, : et ! &3 . a ag '4 3 wn ad eg a tt w ms Cb, " oO A i. Gee wn as A m3 ys vt a ba ted Rd rat a 4 ot é 3 a é & : ie - Q a fs ; a wi ise Und & a a 42 a a 5 OS " e o ths G ted by o C D a G 9 3 a 5 . E y oy oe Se be Oy, * Re By a : he in thd i & @ se} e ata St Ay set Sn rt i iD " r oe rood a $3 Sd foot fe a4 ped *. "y 4A 0 tet wed ee on 44 4 wm ip wi) ag od teh co G vad ~ os uD Q ug 2 i hy & aed ts uy ; pot bes © 583 33) Ths 4 ag a u } "bed Upet gt a net G mtg ge * ta a G Oo & 3 ved O ved A bet id os bet 1d ; nt 4.4 ra * : G} tts * ee t "oa i a3 5 ved "ey 52s " en a o x3 re) bt 4 i 4 a3 ra a ot me a :
pet oO 4 fe a 43 ape os be ts ey Fed e in ia , & o i es @ eo ue " AG Q cS a i S 8) ee bf sed vA . A Ch Seg G nS , , » Cc pes : 4 wy "4 75) " i « a wk = uw aS a & ct BS re Sh rs 4 2 Ma © - RG q "4 af fa ? _ 32 =p a ny re "G C She os SS ea e a Ot ves g5 a £. ioe we Ch ~~ 5 'bes 43 ma Aa " Fa) "3 4d sed o ai 5 iD nest o ho vs es ™ 6 we g ns, Sod Ka 3 ; s . a vd xi we at aD Le chet my 5 i {> $4 io . i vay x? & O @ ; os nara a ut (fy isi wD ay nt ce be an B 3 ey A. ai 4 ot * a3 " be 43 C3 ey yi me « aed 6 ore a $-t fe} o ard E-4 ig a ; £ ved 3 p i a Reg a iy 3 vn ad vs om a op hes uF a ot 3 ; ard eg ra) rend 3 © 4 tea be a , i . <2 wkd ae . aged Q wo ef ree tear wot jz w 2 3 ka - he mn ao "on 4 5 ved O ; 43 " wr 4 © a oO @ iB ed f B v yi ow we co "4 ; , : 'ed / ce val eA A 4 vod f & cd "es " tot eo rs "eg 7 . ses se 44 3 @ 4 ma ti P24 OAS144 4d er x a KO oat i t fd he, oot nei 43 bee HY) o ¥ et od 2, hs a Local Administration Department & Anr. V5. M. 23 owt Sevanayagam & Mumaravelu, Civil Appeal No. 2206/2006 if or 7 Cd on ee Awe o £ ere Le ih .
PRG % ay & (Or. Bhagwan Sahai) rves Member (A).
etme a oc a ;
x x o ie «