Andhra Pradesh High Court - Amravati
K D L V Subba Rao vs Union Of India on 20 March, 2025
Author: R Raghunandan Rao
Bench: R Raghunandan Rao
tot `````..
lN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMAR
(SPECIAI ORIGINAL JURISDICTIO.N)
THUR`SDAY, THE T\^/ENTIETH DAY OF MARCH,
I ll^/o THOUSAND AND ll^/ENTY FIVE
:PRESENT:
HONOURABLE SRI DHIRAJ SINGH THAKUR, THE CHIEF JU
AND
fpirfi=?
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO
wR!T PETITION NO: 23957 OF 2024 ALONG WITH
w.p.NoS.27302, 27773, 27917, 28028 & 3O585 OF 2024 E=
Jt
500018.
.:,=', LT+I
;.
+.
\ ..
)
. |T\
a
)
§!o venkata Ramana urthyl aged ifet3ut
20. a, Su[Bi c* Abdul Khadhar` gged about 73 yeersT
• F¥o EI6h
plot No+ 301, Tombs Road AIM, SB'
Bui[d{r!g§, §atye§< Col®r}¥;Sha]~kpetr Hydgr&bad ~
2i, SGlhriSt ASr lie!` Aged about 71 ¥eargI R/a Sai DatSa
Ftes'IdefiSy, 1 APT {01] MLA Ctoton¥] Road NB. 12,
B anjgfa 50co34.
a/a Rams Koifeswara Rae, aged>
I it!o. 90&, F[&{ No, 102, Sri Njlayaml Road
MadhHPur_. Hyderabad«
23. Kshira Sagara ao, s/a Raja Rao. aged about ?1 years,
FVG Bh8rgaV i mitre Enelavel Flat No,4$2, PIT CSlonyl
Dil8ukhna9ar, * ad 50ce6O
24. M, Vijer¥der. S/a Gopitt8th Mcaligi, aged atIOut 70 years, R/a D,Nc,.1S
124/222, 223 and 2$4, Sai Poornima Towerst Flat No. 303l
Saidabad Golony2 §aidatad,, Hyderabed 500C5g
25. Irukulla Suresh, a/a Late lfukulta Ramiah, aged about 73 years, R/a
T5 1401. L&T Raimree BoulevardI Sahakar Nagar, Bangatc,reI
Karnataka 560$92`
pracad, a/a fuadhava gaol
B£®ck E, Mahindraashvital
3& 5$0085`
{ s,a V.zS.a MurihyI
Flat No.S2`+ ijday
Hydgrabed 50OO44.
Nandakumar Redd¥I S/fl lLJafe
years. RIG 5/191,
Satyartarayana, S/a B. Chin
years, Ffyo a.No. 31913, Kaflnayya Kapu
Kakinada 5330O3.
S/o M. Ramanujulu* aged ats`en* 6g ygars>
a. z82838, Jyo{i Nagar, 9thStreet,
inivas Jammalamadaka] S/a J.
perTda[e Apartments, ®pp: Cigerate
00820 I
¥enkata Ready, S/a _Y. Thimma F3eald¥. Faro
a ayachoty. Annamayya D`lstrict 51626S.
33. S+ Raj8gOPal, a/a S.L Narasimha Rae, aged ab®H± ?2 year§S F#Q Plot
NQ. 2. Rajanagar Colony, H_No.15~44/1J Old Mirjaiaguda, MalKajgiri.
Hyderabad 500047.
Ramiredc}y, `S/S K<l €h,`mlla
+
.fflo. 1248§*j2, Aadarsh
fa Subrahman#a
.,rty~;co>`ev roqu,^t;fi'snckl,JI_7=*,~_.»;`h^.
urI§urana[thamz aged atiOut T3
I:ample Stres£* EIuru
&34iO2.
{f¢TR Co!ofiy,
Kumar, S/fr Jagannad#a fiat¥,
723?£2, Nages"ara RaQ Street* RamaFaQ PetJ
u Mu*h¥, S/a Late Surya
ahodara MansiQn,
Beach Roaci] Visakhapa{nam §38aq¥1
I. Satya Narayana Sastry, Sfo Venkata
&#ed about 88 yearsr R/a D.No. Plot No. 5,
M.I Colony Road No. 5, Hyderabad 500$40I
saradha Ramj Reddy, S/a K. Chinna about
ars, R/a D.No. Flat NS` 2Q4, Sai Sadam De{ux Aparirmeut§,
Apollo Hospital Road, Haranadhapuram& Ne'laore 524S$3
41. Gummuluru Shella Murthy, Sfo Gummu[uru G®p&ia KriShrta REuftfa¥®
Aged aboljt 67 years* R/a D'.No. Flat No. 606G4, !ndu Fortune Fteld§
G=ardsn, KPHB Phase 3, Hyderabadd §#0085.
Ramiah, Jnged abt2ut 71 years,
Di§trict~
F%ama Krisbna Babuji ¥uddagirit §/® Surya
?3 ¥Sarsl
I Sfo Btichi
105,Kakaria Live well
53. Atlijri S¥ama'a Ra©, §fo Subba lRas, Aged about 73 years!r Fer® B®N®.
7413"28* New R¥S Calanyt P&famata ls{ Cro_ss Road, VIja¥awada
52GO®7I
54_ M. Krishr¥aven#mma. W/a a.P Nagireeddy. Aged about ?1}pears. R/a
Apartments, E'urga Nagar Co{ony* Panjagutta±
H}'defabad 5QOO83.
55. Y. Ve8raraghaVulu , Sifo Y. Malakondiahl Aged about 72 years, RIG
2t South S,rinidh]t Residencyt Siva Jyothi Nagar, TirupaSi
517507.
56. Bommidala ¥enkafa REama Krishna RE,day. S/a Bommida'a §IVice,
70 years{ RID Plot No. 225, Vijayalakshmi Nagar. Opp+'
Teluguganga Colony, Ndlare 524GO4.
`'```
M varma¥ Aged abSut FO
Paradi§b. 2A Maiinr2ftD
Aged about 72 yaarst F¥o
pane raju streetra SJng Puram, Vijayawada 520011.
m M®han RacE, S/a Late ¥enkiah, Aged abotlt 72 years. R/a
a#o5, Sri Ram Nagar, Near: Po#ce Quarters Road, VIsaiak§*i
_ trfsakhanfitnam 53co43.
Sfo Late B.V Ftamana Murthy,
yearsl R/a D.No. 10L33] PIot No| 303, §a,Bhafatwaj& Apartmgn{s!
Flat No. i®1, Near. Police Quarters Road, Vi§a}aks£hi Nfagar,
Visattrfear,atnam 530043.
g3. K` Nehru, S/a Kandru Subbarao, aged about 72 ¥earsl RIG H.NQ+13
84gS, Sankara Venug®pala Rae Chalasa"' Nagar. Pantakaltlva
Road. Kanuru, Guntur 52QOO7.
64. §tiaik Naseem Ahmedl S/a Shaik Abdul Nab,Shaheb` Aged abc"t 71
years. RIG D`Na. Flat No` 40G, Hrudaya Enclave, Saptagiri Colony,
4th Strect, Near Sadhana School, Old Vedayapalem, NSllore ~
524004.
Kak§nada District
6g years. R/a S
R®a a,
Kukatpally,
69. AGVijaya A.G S+urendtrar+ Aged about 64 years, RJo
D.No.12_i3 "andi Po§i, SeGunderabad' 500061.
BLllLISu Aged about
70 yeaFSi RIG B. N@. 2Sa, B!oGk a. Prathyusha Residency,
Luxor Avenue, Masji daj Kondapur 500084.
71. T.Brahl T]iafa, Aged about 71 yearsS R/ft DINt2~
22_97/19 Nsh" Nagar7 Nandigama, Krishna
District 52¥ 18§I
72. AIIaka Aged about 75 yearsI Fare D.No.
455015, FIat No. 4G2j Jy®thi Prakash Residency, Akkayyarpa!em,
Visakhapatf*am ~ 53SO16,
S/a Late
~
tNo. 5O1. g
I Jai Jawany
nEVaSa tao. Sife
2, Ramky QJ]e
; Rao¢ S/a Late T
2, Srihari NilayamS
Distr!ct 524004.
Ya PTiakaSa Rae, S/a Rams Raol
131r8/1 I Sri Rama BhavaEn, Near,I
Btsimavaram 534201.
?7. Tejarao Kadambala, sfo iv}agathEl
M'G 400, APHB, Colt,ny, PM P,
hapatnam 530041.
rkupa'li RamachaJldra Prabhu, sfo c. Na
76 years, R/a Flat No. 13g, D.Not 4a
VIShntIPuram Colony, Poranki 521137.
. Krishna rae, s/o Late T.K. Swamy,aged abolft F* ¥eafsI R/a Flat
Q1] Sat Royal Aparinents, Bakkanor pa}emS
53co41.
80. W Ramana Murthy, S/a W Rama Murthyr
_ S
__;I I?I
villa No. 20, ARSE Green Villas€ shailj Gardens, yapra'.
Safnikpuri, Hyderabad 5OOO87.
es¥ _ as
soft 1*jff
Sfo
a ¥sftkatesyrara
Subfras ch8fldra
about 72 Rfo
NiihyasFee Apar{mgr!ts.
Gurunadfaa Rae, §fo Late
Ready_
road. V,§akhapatnam z 530808*
85. lan§jraffii, W/a V. Siv#ji, Aged about I
Towers3 Brindavan Colony! Labbipet,
Ramana M.urfhy, she Late
about 73 years, R/a D,No.
S, Akkayyapalem, Vlsakhapatnam 53Og16.
Sa nkara Rae, Sfo Late Surya
Kaka{iya Street. tNear: A1
EN@gar, Balajipet Junction, Rajahmundfy 533101.
givtry/ 88. Yerra Koteeswara Rae, Sfo Seshiah, Aggd about ?4 years, Rfo D,No.
*2147J arid Line, Chaitar]yapuri, sat Babs Food, 2r'd Line, Gurltwr ~
522OO7 .
.. Pet,*t!Loners
I rI ltrftyJ
AND
1. The Union of India through its Secretary (Financial Sector), Department
of Financial Services, Union Bank Bhavan, 239, Vidhan Bhavan Marg,
Nariman Point, Mumbai 400 021, Maharashtra, India.
2. The Union Bank of India through its Managing Director and CEO, 6th
Floor, Union Bank Bhavan, 239, Vidhan Bhavan Marg, Nariman Point,
Mumbai 400 021.
u.Respondents
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is filed praying that
in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may
be pleased to issue Writ, Order, or Direction one in the nature of WRIT OF
MANDUMUS quashing the Regulations 41A of the Union Bank of India
(Employeesl) Pension Regulations 1995, dated 29091995 the contrary to the
welfare and against the interest of retired employees as the commuted
amount of pension is being already recovered in just 9 years 10 months as per
the respective pension payment Orders issued under the Regulations, where
my commutation Factor @ 9.81, Commutation Amount and Commutation
Date, Commuted Value and Date of Restoration stipulated on my
superannuation. No interest is being charged on the Commutation Amount as
per the Regulations. But recovery of commuted value is being recovered
every month from the pension amount and to be continued to be recovered by
the respondents till completion of 15 years from the date of Commutation.
consequently, to hold the same to the illegal and arbitrary being ultra vires of
the constitution of India as well as on the ground that the same is causing in
undue enrichment to the respondents and it also doesn't have any rational
objective and intelligible differentia to be achieve and pass Such Other Order Or
orders may deem fit and proper in the circumstances of the case. It is also
further prayed that this H.on'b'e Court may be pleased to directing the
respondents to restore Petitioners' full pension immediately on expiry Of 9
years 10 months instead of 15 years as provided for in Regulations Chapter
vlll, Clause 41(5) of the Union Bank of India (Employees') Pension
Regulations,1995 since the amount already stands recovered in excess from
the petitioners may kindly be returned with interest.
IANO: 1 OF2024
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased to issue stay in the recovery of commuted value from pension beyond
the period of 9 years 10 months may kindly be stayed, pending disposal of
WP No. 23957 of 2024, on the file of the High Court.
The petition coming On for hearing, upon Perusing the Petition and the
affidavit filed in support thereof and the order of the High Court dated
aE
24.10.2024, 19.12.2024 & 20.02.2025 made herein and u,POn hearing the
arguments of sri A Radhakrishna, Advocate for the Petitioners, Sri Pasala
ponna Rao, Deputy Solicitor General of India, for the respondent No.1 and of
Ms.Dua Mani, Standing Counsel for the respondent No.2;
wp NO.. 27302 OF 2024:
YYr rvu: I, ®v£ `,r J[VJLV,
/
+
B`abbella.pati Rajya Lakshmi D/o Vent
.:i.a.toe . ..®®. I.. .
*amma`quzHia,I Visali=]1apatllanlT 5 3`OO :1` 3
\`
}flamm'rHt£`,~~Vij ay&Tiradat520$ 87 l~
a.:i.a.
r. i)
. .,`
I
|
/
+
AJ
E
__ r___ '=='=*
Road, LIC Cola_ny,
21. Mirza
D. INa. 32296A,
k, nana Mandir Strect,
at
22. S.S. Prasa*
aged about 73
Sri frdea§fr Th Centre ,
Praj asckthi RE~a
23. B.M. Pri 3 PSngesusara *¥a®,
aged about 5, R/a mat Ho. 306,
lrords cQtJ" meIIt, Ragfiu GalCleHSJ
Ashnk rvagari ", VijajraR7eda520SO7
2qL ¥enugu fasad S/a S{minachatan,
aged about a 3110'20,
FF IQ3, Sai Resid en€y,
VSEN Streetl mJ Vijay&wada52.OOO4.
25. Betfia NageS'ytnera Bads/a Ramu}u.,
aged about 72 years, R/a I IJ Gangothali Apartment,
•h\
I J \ +
Clinic Rond ,_
72 years, R/a D, No. 7lie,
Ne'ar Kanairfu TfrSpm,
i§ulu s/® Gas
yearsl R/a D.
I. Ffa]:lSfr~agrat Office* Pi1€rq517214.
A. Hen± Eabu a/a venkaifeswarfu7
± a1S¢rat 70 years, R/a Flat RTo. 2 H 8,
inns Gedavari Apts. , Asfick _Nagar,
Ede Pz¥pxpula MinS VijaJraWada52GG$7.
29. Sre€bhastiyan
a SBT RaJmanujaCbarysha, aged lab
$ 504, Sri Sat Heights, §riramacba
tareney NagarJ Vijayawada52coO8 , .,,
3®. YalamanLChili Shantaram S/a Y.EE. 'Mal
:a;g§d about 7O Years, R/a Flat RTo. 12,
Fhajitha Aparfuents , Darsipeta, Patamata,
VijayawErda520010.
$ 1. Yadla Ramesh Babu S/a Kegara Rag,
aged about 71 years, Flat No. A5,
#~iinnala Apartment.s i Curreney' Nagar,
Wijayawada52000 8.
32+ Pedarla Ravindranath Tagare S/ a i
asgd about 71 years, R/a 57~18/ il8,
Suvarchala Niwas, Prasanthi Nagar,
opp. Bharat Gas Office, Vijapfawada5£
33. D. Thoyajaksha rSaidu S/ a L`akshm_edain H'&idu,
aged about 72 years, 301, Sai Pri3ra: Heights,
D. RTo. 9355, Behind Balaji Cin€+ Villa,
Panta Kaluva Road, Poratiki, Vijayawada$21137.
= ... .`:.....: '. : .". .
I . i. I_ I||
: 73¥ears, R/o 201,
Axpartments, ~Beside R@dfaa
PraJsati
Fiat REo.
sS Piungimaneni
Vijaya"ada~ 5¥
r5iva Surya. F¥ali:ass fag
a Mrfu¥}
165rr:f9..I 1A, Balaji Hone SteSet#
13 Vijayawada~520OI2,
40. Kalakota cnandra Mohan
Ramatinga Ready, aged aI
D. No.1ql 16/ l= Flat JVo.
haavi RIaJiiatr, 4th road,
v araJaJ{SflmlPuram > Kanuru, vijayawada~52`OQ$7.
4 i , SlnyedevaIa Ramakri§hna prasad
S/a €tiidambai~a Rat,I aged about 73 years, ./.
a/S Plot INo. 219, Please.nt ville, KRCR COIQny RSat
Bathnpalky, Hyderabad 5OOO9G.
I
^|
1
/
I
/6 Haanife R&o>
rS. R/a ,1148/21/5,
Road RES. 2, xpELapet,
a Sesh& Chena Rae
aged about 74 years,
!28, REf3 C®1ony,.
ally, Hyderabad5OO$85.
a S/a .Rama Krishna Rae,
s, R/a H. RES. i8439/364,
i Apartments, Street Not 3!
Lirles Colcmy, Begump€t,
Rao
durartga Raoj pged about 71 years,
162~836/A/37, Street INo.13
I,I£ C®leKY, Saldabacl, IIyderabad500059
i=E= iH
49. a. B€lri7at±hi Mani W a Chandra§€kha¥aRa_o`
aged zitjSut 64 years, R a i.112358.
Road NQ. 13, Income Tax Colon}r,
ff¥derabad~ 5Q® 0 3 5`
'. ...`. .`. .. :
.. I._ . .= ....
R dRE 4G mIIIIC1 SKh
o| iL ...:. '' .
S/ a Sanje€vappa]
fo. 40.1,,
REHB CQhanyJ
a500a85
53. A. Radii S /a Srinivasa Murfty,
aged abGt£t R/cS D` Ha. 13i67/2,
I ran. , Hyderab&d`50SGIS.
W/a Jasti Ravi®
FJo. 301,
Set Prmthvi Bnc lava ,
rlydera bad
# '£ct&£ ndra Venhata Krishna Ranbabu
aged about 70 years,
5O2, Sat Keerthi,
a.thi RTagar, Hyderabad~50OO90.
56. EdiEa Satya `&rffiyana S / a Sreeiamulu..
aged about 69 3 tarS! R/a Flat ENo. ?72,
H. Ho. 56493, €oad No. 9, Vaidehi INagar,
Hyderabads ooo70.
57. Lakkavajhala `Mohan Rae S/ a Sri Ranla Mu]ttry,
age,d about 74 years7 R/a Fiat PJo. 202!
suj.atha Mansion, Road No. 5J RTC Colony,
I.B. NagarJ Hyderabad5OQO74.
®
rfupati panduranga Rae S/a Sut3ba Rae,
69 year, R/a ll5~`386, Road REc,, 10,
na:inteswaz'a C®hony! SarQor Nagar 2
62. Furatta 'Raifea S /a'Ranaiah ,
aged ahout 74 ¥ R/a F 3, Block1,
Marmthi TSwers ihara Nagar ,
V ij aya#ada~ 52
63. Yarlagadda Siva Prasad S /a VenkatramaialH,
aged about `73 years, R/a 59A21 / 18/21,
Dhan€iljals:§lrmli Heights, RIRI Gardens,
patafinja:ta. Vij ayaENada5200O7.
64. Faruchuri Venkata Siva Vara Prasad
S/a Subba Rae, aged about 69 years,
R/a Tg2/2. Vivekananda Nagar Colonyr
KiJhatPally, Hyderabad *SQOO72.
65. Ack± Surf Brahmaiak SIJo Ramadas,
aged 'about 77 years, R/a Flat No. 2O2,
sri sai Rana Nilayam, Chandramoulipuran ,
IJabbiPet , Vij ayswada~ 52001 a .
I
/
I
\r
Jj
i
:i........'..=.:.. .....;`i_._
.I| =± . = I_I I||
69. P
ageed (
Kaj Bt}r ,
7l. D. Laksfami rfe _Narayapgl Reddy$
aged abau£ 2?52/ 123/ 19 tQ 14, _,#`
Flat NI~o
ELuna Elegance ,
SBH C( H5id€rab&d~5 GOO 59 .
72. V€dantam PurraSfeo €nam
g/a VIV. Subt aged atsout 7O y€'ars,
R/S H, No. 5i
RE®ulaLAil ,
73. Kolisetty Sai S / a Venhateswarlu €/
aged about 70 ¥FrmS, S|1, Guptha's S}mphon}r Arts. ,
old Labour office FTLGad. Lap6apet, Ongol€523002.
~ \ 1
i
i
+
F|
Vat Street,
Kumaf S/a
's, R/a H.No
HanumanTempleJ >
Redd¥ S/G Ja:yar'a
63 y€ar§ R/ a Flat seo#3S`3!
Landmark Fowl
LJP Nagar Cross,
Siifeisrapur , Hyderabad500049.
¥8. M. Sas±Iar RIasad Gupta S/a E
figed about 72 years, P`/a 202±2,
Palakol53426O. W.a. Dt. A.P.
79_ A. Suresb Babu S/a Dr. D,i. RTl
aged about 71 years, k/o 63~596/
ENaveen Nagar.` Khalratabad West.. I
gO. K. Durga
rahout 64FTasad
years, S/a
R/aUmapath:
24~556/ Cr}
a rI a
EN¢. SOL, Sai Balaji Castle,
IN&gole Colon_v, H_yderabad§00102~
co H Raja Sinekfrar S/a RaLjalah,
m
about 64 years, R/a Flat REo. 215,
Eat Apartments, Road No. 5,
di, Nagar; Nagole, ffyderabad~`50006g,
82` Anne Usha W/ o Kanuri Venka.€a Subba Rae,
Aged about 66 years. 103, Lok€sh Towers,
Backside of Cross RoaLdS Restaurant,
Moghulraj apuram , Vij ayawi,ada520010 .
St2btla..RacS ,
Gut ¥4
anaJs
'tryf1" fP
years, a/S Boar MB.
Bands, R.I.
}eddam Damiel Rep S/a Albert*
about 7I years* R/a H` Nox 82£
36, B.IN. Reddy Colony, Road I4!
era HillsJ
emulapalli K€sava Rae S/a Verfata
about 7l years, R/a Flat FTo. 2O1,
65* Uttarayana, Road No. 9,
I,
a500081.
89. Aminnend Siva Sarfi£ara, Rao S/
aged about 72 years, R/a Block~9
Rain Tree Park, KPHB Colony,
Hyderabad~500085.
ESi..a.K*
tcI"€rS ,
Lcksrimalch I
;a Bazar.
Bala mkra±± KirishnamaGhar3nrfu a/,a
I ` I_`)
Ran# Mandiran,
Ready }
s, R/a Pint No. 66,
as R£ddy S/a Venkat Ready,
R/a 171391 /I/ 156,
1abad ,
. . . Pi=tition erg
AND
1. The Union of India, Through its Secretary (Fjnancjal Sector),
Department of Financial Services, Union Bank Bhavan, 239,
VidhanBhavanMarg, Nariman Point, Mumbai400O21, Maharashtra,
India.
2. The Union Bank of India, through its Managing Director and CEO, 6th
Floor, Union Bank Bhavan, 239, VidhanBhavanMarg, Nariman Point,
Mumbai400021, Maharashtra, India.
Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased may be pleased to i .. Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly one
in the nature issue of WRIT OF MANDAMUS quashing the Regulations 41A
and 41 (5) of the Union Bank of India (Employees) Pension Regulations 1995,
dated 29091995, being contrary to the welfare and against the interests of
the retired employees, as the commuted amount of Pension was already
recovered in just 9 years and 10 months as per the respective Pension
Payment Orders issued under the Regulations, where the Commutation
Factor @ 9.81, Commutation Amount and Commutation Date, Commuted
Value and Date of Restoration stipulated on Superannuation. No Interest is
being charged on the Commutation Amount as per the Regulations. But
Commuted Value is being recovered every month from the pension Amount
and still being continued to be recovered by the 2nd Respondent Bank till
completion of 15 years from the Date of Commutation. Consequently, to hold
the same to be illegal and arbitrary being ultra vires of the Constitution of
India, as well as on the ground that the same is resulting in `unjust enrichment
of private money to the respondents by recovering the Commutation Amount
on the ground that the above Pension Regulations stipulated the condllion of
recovery for 15 years and it also doesnot have any rationale objective and
intelligible differentia to be achieved and grant stay of the excess recovery and
direct the Respondents to restore Petitioners full Pension immediately on
expiry of 9 years 10 months instead of completion of 15 years as provided for
in Regulations Chapter VllI, Clause 41 (5) of the Union Bank of India
(Employees) Pension Regulations, 1995 since the amount already stands
recovered in excess from the petitioners may kindly be refunded with Interest
from the respective dates of recovery from each petitioner pending disposal of
the above writ petition;
`'' ``ts
#o
IA NO.. 1OF 2024:
of cpc ls filed praying that 'ln the
petition under sectlorf 151
circumstances stated ln the affidavit filed in support of the pet'ltion, the High
court may be pleased to grant stay 'ln the recovery of commuted value from
Basic PensIon beyond the Period Of 9 years 10 months, Pend®[ng disposal Of
wp No. 27302 of 2024, on the file Of the High Court.
The petition coming On for hearing, upon PeruSlng the Petition and the
affidavit filed in support thereof and the order of the High Court dated
26.ll.2024,19.12.2024 & 20.02.2025 made herein and upon hearing the
. ........
arguments of sri RIZWAN All SHAIK Advocate for the Petitioners and Of
DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL for the Respondent No.1 I,
WP.No .27773 of 2024..
tsco.ha`J
+
!B
i
18. V Pratgtp;
Rael ageti aban* 7C
ll.
}, §fo Kfishna ML,rifi#,
aged about FCad, F¥T€
12. A. Surya REara¥&FSa {PF NB, 32$2esjS a/a Satyanara¥anaI
&sed ahoLFL
?2 years. F3/a: g¥g8. F1`at N&.204, Green Park AIfenue. Kondapur,
Opp: 5th Gate, ghira scho!ar! ftyderabad §Sg} Q84.
13. M` Kusa Kum Np`3g7&2®}I a/a. Sri Rama Chandra REurfhyr
aged about 70 ye&rS R/®|y z4a~151/1, Gpp: KPDP SehQOl,
Nagar, E!ttru534 `S$2.
ofa,ah (PF NS,488076} $7o Ch}nnay}rat Aged about 71 Yearsl
32281, F€G Puram, Naidt{pe{, Tim.pathi District5Z4126.
15. V. §ambasiva prasad (pF No.3gO432}, Sfo Radha Krishna Prasadl
Aged aboui 7Q years, Rfo: 239~16/1, Sakhamurivari street,
Gandhinagar+ Tenali 522 2Q1.
1_a _Il _I
<|
/I
ri'.\.l
ng. .a
/
Naca¥ana Murfhy (PF No.:
72 years, R/a: 458~g/1,
1aBatnarn53OO17.
Kgtha Suryanarayana {PF No
aged about?1 yearsl R/a. E1. I
Bulfemma Veedhi, Machavaram
Subhan, {PF
Rahman, aged 'about 71 yearst
ColonyJ Bundlaguda Jagiri F{aje
Di§trictI Hyderabad 500086*
23. S. Range Ready, (PF No. 460384}I
about 70 years, R/a: 461M14, Ad
School, A Camp, KumooI~518003.
K`V.V Krishna Murthy, (PF No.438318},
70 years, R/a. D No.8814~5, Sri Hari
canara Bartk Lane, Raj'ahmundry, East Godavari District 533 1O3.
Rae {gF No.ia:
R;a+. D.
rf`l Sarfapeti {PF No.3§:
Fare: AFChE3na Hejghte,
OQ6.
R/a: 5ap89~1 {l7. 3rd Lane.
¥enkate Ranga F±aQ
t{rishrra MurthyJ aged abau{ 72 y6ars*
S¥amya!a Nagar. Gunfur§22 ee6.
No.3i64, Adarsh Nagar,
I cftisurupati sat Babtit (PF No.19gO62] S/a
about 7O yearst Rfo: SLY Amaravathi Grand ll, Araiock, Plot No,1O+,
Gunadala , VljayE5Wadatr5£0004 ,
No`217632}, SJc> Ve_nkavya, agedI
MP S{reet> Gollapudi,
Guntur District~52Z QO4`
S/a G®palafah. ageti about 7#
Greamspct; Ghitttror 5,17 ace.
Ra® {PF No.185t7}, S/a Mal'ayyaS aged afrou{
a.1 fflt MadaJas Gurucharan Apartlngr,i, Swama
No_10813}J Sfo Krishr,a Murthyt agBd about
D Not ll1952, Ftandreddypeta, Narasaraopct 522
{PF Nap.253236)I S/a P
¥8#rs, .Rfe_: Flat H®.SOS, Bhavyas AkhilaExotica I
KarEIchi Batsgr¥. riydgmagar, Hyderabad5 00085.
iOmeSWara Rao, {PF NQ.331638), S/a VasaJuna
far®: H No.1611477/6/5,'1. OPP: Med Manor
Ltd., Shalivehana Nagar* Dirshukhnagar, Hydsrabd 500 036.
|Lt
P
_+
)
and ra
78 Yearsl f¥Cl: 314, i
I_ flvdgrBbad r 500 Qi&
{pF No.±g9124}, Sfo `G
ytrarsI RIa: Flat No.201, Rairtbrmi
i §iVa'ayam, N+drasi
'H¥deraSad50$070
44. S.A Paul joseph, {PF No.3284g4.}, S/a Anthaiahr Aged abaHt
vearSI Fero H.NS.11 i ifeir[ Read, Bavi Centre.i Kanaparru! Nad€
9718}. Sfo Nageswara RatSf ace
swhra;hmanya s\^rany Temple,
{pF No.405126}, SJo RBma Murthy,
¢®.4e1, Block1 I My Home Avafar NarE
Hyde*abed~5aO fi75*
(pF No.3481§8), S/a Kutumba
No.202, Vishnu Towers. 2386/2t A¢u§l
Burripalem Road, Tefiali
years R/a D.No.¢32621 F, Sankalbagh. NarasingaraOPet, Kumcol ~
518004.
.b
i)
4S. KaSuri Shiffi Babu {PF N®.2g6418} a/a ¥gflkata Na#ayarlal Aged. `
about 73 years, R/a D.Nt3.4i5125, 8th Lanet Bharathpet,
Colan¥* i. ,
52. P. Ramafla F€umari, (PF Rag, Aged
abot,I 72 yeaF8+ Rfo`' 34142/4, Bafa 500 G27.
5S. Divakar Reed.¥ Obulareddygari. {PF S,® ffawi Reedy,
Aged about 78 years, R/a a.No. ife¥ind Nagar,
Anantfuapuram a 515001.
5¢. a.a Ramacftandra ReddyJ {PF No~3953$8}l S/a Late Akki Reddyl
Aged 72 yez=EfS, R/a: D No~f1ul$121¢ F3.K. Nagarr Ananthapuram
5150O4.
55. €hama Sayee, {PF No.325$38), Sfo An£janeywlu, Age: 71 yearst
FUo: D No.'#227/i, Chaitanya Purl, a Line, Opp: Mythn'vanam
Apartment, GuTttur5220$7.
66. Y.Badrinath. Sarma (PF No.2917§6), Sfo Venkate§vvarlul aged 71
years R/a; D No.13857, Ko±Iuruvari Street, Nazarpet, Tenali 522
ant+
t/
r
~,'
I+
I *
+
`_ '_+a+
5g
Kfi§ferm*£aH, VesedhIi
SO, Sudi#alii S/S Ganapath¥a
years, Rfo: B. H ospita! l
Janga reddyg#demes444?.
61! §#bbara®
¥carS, L{ro: tfrZq I Roafli tytP t*oadt
#ngQle 5Z3OO2
Sz. prfuarianke siva sat,kara Rso! grF No+21?301}l a/a f%BghanMJlut
Aged 7q years faygS: 88, Vel'afufty` Guntur District5222§7.
Kx Yerapa Reddyl {PF No.3?§182}I S/a China ifenda Ready, Aged 71
years* R/a: 47~q§9 a 1SQ SBI Colony, Seco#d Lingl Puti¥endL€la
§1S39¢
64. NI.Mura!i Krishna Kt]maFi, (PF No.4O4244), W/a MK Nageswara Rao.
Aged 71 ye8rS! R/o: a No.15543, Beside Sat Public School, HSusv,ng
Etoard Co!on¥, MaShilipatnam521001.
\ >
i
I
:# ..
/ t
i l* S~fB asriShna Mufthy, €
G5.
Aged 71 years, Rfo: 6*186, §iia Ffam'Fradti# Nagar,
lBdraPatem Post Kakingzc!EE5338CS.
Venktrama
Na`rdu, A;ged`74 years,, R/a: B
Lawsorts Bay C otony, Visakhap?them53081¥,
.~. Fiat No.3.0.1 I Pt®t
xp`: SBl , Nizampett5880gO.
d8. Somarouthu Satyanaryana, (PIE
72 years, R/a: 145, MP Elementary SSi`oSI Strgee E±rjfi!ffiiiiffnkat
Tat[apudi 5343q 1 .
6g., K.P VardhaniI {PF Nc,,3366d8} Dfo M|bS€
yearsl R/t±: 49rd711St Lane, Patet Nagar,
?a. K.K Siva Sankar Ram. {PF No.304§06},: SJo fo. gar{gameshvrarlut
Age: 71 years, R/a: D. No.901~2/1,1
Alcot Gardens, Rajahmundry533101
". P. AnjaneylJlu, (PF No.438324), S/a late P. i{ri§t
years, R/a: D No.137, 42/1, Anugolucari Streetr
?2` Ukkusuri Satyar,arayana Murthy {PF
Aged 73 years, R/a.1111/1257c, Raghavendra Sa[eny,
Hyde rabad500084.
I/.,I
\
.I
N¢. 3Z9752)1
i 1S{$4q Kranthi Nagar C;S[ony,
EZEiK raeedi Nagendrab Flra8ad. iPF
Aged 71 yearSI F#o: 2633D4l §til Lane3
¥7. Y+ Prasad. {PF N©.3284z16}t
taci« sat @atta Resideney, Pto{ 1
BanjaJ:a Hiils1 #yserabadJ8OOO34
a, (PF RES318792). ;
~53* TF2, Manasa
8330$4
Rams Mohan Rae Gude, {PF.No.33¢024},
yearsl F{,a: 2~58_2/1. 8ti
533101.
Ned Lak§hnlana Kumar. grF Nal4794aS),
70 year§I R/a: {91113/301, Street NQ.8, Vidyariagar. Hydera
500044'
J
i
I
+
t
Ftedha Krisbna
a ir, Aged 71
Commune, NalJagapdla,
(PF No.338262}, Sfo PV Ramana REurthy,
Rayudtlpalem` K3kirlada 53:
S/a Narayarra Reddyt
~2468®ral Read No`1O/A, New
PF Nd..325416)i S/a Subba Reddyt Aged
Rajap8SfiPa Atria, Gofden fu4ile F3oad,
{PP N®.35$604)I "/®
ea#§I R/a: g1#Sor4l,
Mac_hiii petna m52 1 881
Wfo late
No.5, Ajaznagar
*¥dera badH5CGO68 ,
SfH/O Radtrikai Aged 71 ¥e€
fodu, Vid¥anag@r {Po} Kuta
F No.31 3944}S S/a Venkaiah, Aged T1 ~years,
lpaRment S, Behind AyyaEPa Swami
N a rasa`raQ Pet5226 01
No.531072}, S/a Nfagabhushana
eethanjali Aperiments, Block.2. Fiat.6,
Laifeel GufStu i522QO6,
i Jagannadha Rao, (PF No.2¥31
4Sed 73 years R/o All oat
Swamy Theatrel Guntur5220O6
99. `C. Ramana Reddy] {PF N®.6113¢9!, S/H/a Laksmi Devil Aged 79
years, RID. B10 {23326} Vaikuntapuram, Tirupati ~ 517502.
Venkata
R/a: Pl'c*{ NQ+?I Vijayawada
18q_
years3 F[atJZ®1, Kausfabriam fipartmen£ f¥fisfroa Rajfaa Furam Sau{hI
Ring RQadt VTtja¥anagaram~535002
¢£. KS.K.H PfasadI (PF
yrears. R/_a:~8=~1
1tl3. (PF No.429192?,
71 years, R7a: HIGrd$7t 9th Phase, Kphti Colony+ Kukatpal'yS
H#erabad 5OOO85.
1$4. Peddi Subba Rae, {PF anaS+ah, Aged 71
ye`ars, R/a:. 21 i give Leela SpaJtmeniS, 3/2. AShQk Magar, Gunfur~
522002 .
105. GSpata Krishna PUB, (PF No.318762), a?a F¥aja Ftao± Aged 7O years,
R/a; 693b71 Andhra Bank Co'anyl Nagawanam, KaREnada533co3.
1O6. M. Mchan Rag, (PF No.3O3942}, S/a Lakshmi Narasimha Rao, Aged
70 years. R/a: 59185/i ,_ froaneyvari St., Jagannaickpurf Kakinada
§33 0O2.
1¢7. Akkineni Konda Rani, fPF Nc,3981
Aged 70 years, R/a:137g`, 3rd Line, Vara!akshmi Puram, AshQk
Nagari Vijayawada520007.
/
q,I
*
\ I
108. K
110. Aged REP Pam' N a.SSfer14 I NagarI liz. Vat;di Pitehaiah, €F¥F Rat I S/a Nag_ertdruduf Agezd ?* years, R/a: 'Fiat 2O1, is&inda 4th Line. Post Office f¥oad, SVN CQ]Qnyl Guutur§£2Q8g
113. Chug,duri Yesu Babu{ grF N#~Z815$20, S/HfO r¢atesw_arainma, Aged ?6 years, f#O: F1, Aperanji Apartments, Srir]agar C®'®nyl Ring Road. vij a¥awautlang20tiO8
114. Krishna ago.3126ee}, Sfo M Ramafi@ Read, Aged 72 yeaf§€ RfS. H N¢.ill Jays Nagar Panchayat, Sid GressS Kese>veyanu Gunfa, Tirupati
115. R. Ganesh S/o Brahmam, Aged ?4 years, Rfo Flat B1, Surm¥ Apartment, KRne ColGny, Seethammatlhara, rasathapat"m~§3co1 3 .
G.E}jV Pfasarmata Babtf+ yearsl Flat 104, Sat Srinivasam Guniu r§22006.
MLrralj Pu"shotham,
72. years, `B/a:3 Kofkalapudi venkata RamanaS {PF Aged 72 ifears R/a: 7031orBa, Kakinada533005.
N. Satyanarayana1 {PF No 78 years, FIfO: 70~14ll/1 I Prasad, (PF No.304212}.
66~101/10, Narasanna Nagar, Subbarayan G, (PF No.332346}l Sto Venka years, Rro. 10+3 A3 Seshagiri Rae Street, 533004 WS, (PF No.329292, Sfo Suryanarayafta> /a:51`$9, 18{ Flcor, OPP.2 Town Pollce SfationJ REain Kakinada5330O 1.
+ 1 ci {pF No~3429as)i Sfe i, ng85/A,/S#Ground Fto€ i shopI Rajee* NagarI Rae, (PF N®.1 Flat 885, §ri Sat Karfhik Masha¥aram Born, Vtja¥awada~52QaO4.
stry {pF ttQ.329358}1 B}ocklt vGreen H yd e rahad68 Murthy years I R/a: 3370/5I Krishna Rag Agraharamt Ama}apu rB m5332 01 Raju I Ta!lathattu Venkata Krishr`'am Raju {PF Ncl,1 $4$1 }a Aged 72 yearsJ R/a. 63aS, Dwarak Nagar. REear Venu Gapala swamp st`! Kakinada §33003r S§3. G®pe*ajti years,' flat No.2£8, (¥F NB.§1524#)I S/a Qpp: N6itore S/a C#artgaiaft, Aged 72 yeaf§S fflf'ayam. r¢ea~r #aikuntapuram ArchT M`R+ ±ethara Ftao iPF No,3027i2}, SJa Subbe Rao, Aged 73` 522Jla5, ratlaBa?ar, Chirala s23155 No+5i8544i, Sfo Sudarsana Rao, Aged 72 Bhananjaya Resideney. Kamati Nara§imfta Rag `Tla Puram, Vijayawada ~ 52000a amB¥ Siva Rae {PF No.287436}, S/a Subbaiah, Aged ?
Sri Sowbhagya Ni'ayam] 2r7 Yadava Street, Q'cl Gunfur 522001 {PF No,308436}t Sfo Govinda y8arst RfB:Villa No.52, Mount Kaiiash Medhcaj Dt, `'.~ + I I I Fla£_ N®`2132g* r N®.#$21g8), S/a M Yen E{atG] Kumar Bui!dingSt §` pfathaS gtlondarg {FF Mor3586$2}, S/a Chpyngal Rams Na[au, Aged 74 yg&rs, tso: KSta!a Yit[aee a Po Chandragi"andat, Ti"pa# ®i§trict.
145. K.S w/D,§/a M BhimeSh I2 yqzfi i1/i?3, Sri uma Nanda Nilayam] RK v#!age Tirupas Rural5175a7.
1as. K VSnkatggserith {PF No.88§182}l S/a Kotaiah. Aged 7ti yeaF^St R/a:
7ngL2, VgtyurtarSds PnlESS Strffist ELaya'i ~524201 FRaghavaiu, j¥ged 7 i. prakasa RgIO {PF NQ`408036), Sfo Paturi ears, Flat 301, V{jays F±ra+Rash Homes, S.S.NagarI
148. a. Mohar`& RaQ {PF r*S,11656}, SJo VenkateSWarlu , Aged 70 R/a. 122/19, Sanja¥ Gandhi CQ!Qny, Near Hill TcENer§l Ongole 523001.
I 1#g. PrasErda Rap €F[ {PL N .64*588, Soniya Gandhi Colie9et OrLgCFle~523002J D. Lakshmi Bevi {PF Aged 7O years, Flat manganur 1 i53. M. Venkateswafiu {PF Ageci 70 yearst R7G: §128aI Ngo C®{ony. 5th Ongole 523001 t54. i. See{haramaiah {pF Nq.33028). S/a Sapt*ba Rae Jalafii. Jnged 70 years. FVo: 28i11, Court C;entliet Gandhi Road, On`act@523OO1 1§5[ a. Bhakta Vatsa!a Rae {PF N_a.460254), Sfo Ja_Iaiahl jftyged 72 years.
R/a: 53188, 4th Lane, Cl®ugh Pets, C}flgole52eeO1.
15S. G. Durga Prasad (PF No.3396i8}, S/a R/a.I A5, RaghavaJs Visfa* Park Road, !€rishna Nagar, Gunfur~ 522aQ6 1§7. Jugunfa Raja Rao {pF No.480498), S/a YeI!amanda, Aged 71 years.
R/a:ll2910a,18' Floor, RR Pubfjc Schcol Road, Rams Mljfthy PeteS Kavlail i5242 01 .
q6O. Y. REur years I
161. P 162+ PenugQnda VenZ€ Tagivers, Pula .3595as}, S/a Fiamam! Aged ?3 Years* R,a.a Near Lotus Public SchaOl, Kak{nacka533 DOS 1$4. I. Changaiah (PF REGR434298}l Sfo Nngaiah, Aged 72 years, Rfo: 16 1gJ7. MuriFeddy Nagar. M,R. Pa'lif Ti"path€ ~ 51?502
165. pasupulati Ba!a KrE§hna {PF No,331428}, Sfa Venkaiah, Aged 71 yearst F'a{ 3®8* Golden HQmeS, ZP Road, Hasthiiia Furam¥ Hyderabad 50S$79
168. T. Venkat`asubbaiah {PF NQ.434?18}, Sfo Muthyalaiah` Aged 73 years, R/a: 1619/5, Munireddy Nagar, M R Pa]li, Tirupath'l517502. $67. P+ Plrasad {pF No+4a74?8}l Sfo Puru§inoifem! Aged?~0 ¥earsf I?/or + 27i+1583, C}pp: Swami Doss English ftl e! !ore~5248 O2.
168. tr_ Jagan M®han Rae {PF yeaf§. E3/a: Plot No.17, La
169. Ta8<pati Bhaskara Raoj (PF Haziagft, N K` Govinda Raju, (PF r R/a: 5g7t, AgraharamT V. Sat Kumar, (PF No.29g214<}, a/a fiat ae4 , Rath? Towerst JKC and iinfimg, GuH{urL522Bne, 172* Mura'i K^rishna s, (pF No.332934}. S/a Ra Flat+F2 a F3. SaI Surya Residency, gal 530 O16
173. S. Prabhu Dash (PF NQ.426738}, a/a Go i 113, Sri Ram Nagar, Near Girls His 5es447 1?4. N. Pattabhi Rams Rae (PF No`3g7944)* a/ 7O Years, J3/a: 303, Vemuri Towers. Roaa Ayedhyanagar, vljayawada.
175. Vemandi veers Raghava Rag {PF No,31€ Aged 70 years, R/a.Flat 201, Sarojini Residencyr Street No.3, Patrika Nagar, Madhapur, Hyc]erabad500081. \ * I a \ i_ J| lK {PF its.45724&}t Sfo` p!ot No.34' 2T294), §/® V awefS' i8/1 I 5, Rav`tndra vara Prasad Raju, Aged ?2 Years Rfo. Apema Lu"T¥ e,,'Kordapur.~ H¥derrfead5co O&4~ . `,I {pF tya*8`13448}1' a/Hue/a plat1&f lg nisi FIQQr! AmmBrE EN>¥ga,rt YES t3 i kErm , ChenflaiJ6¢nO78.
venkata Krishna RSt> BS (pF No`329826), a/a I/ years. Rfo: Mainthi g_lirg Aparments, .
college, JoumarlSt ColorSy, Sat Nags.I 00 090.
I prabhakara RaQj {PF No.329784}, Years, R/a.+ 43~soS, lath WardJ Beh`md Ea 522101 Bd ?0 Years
184. CH Arnar Prasadg {PF No.419814}, a/a Raghavajah£ Bra ppadu , R/ol. Sai §oudha Building 4312, Gorl Krisha Streett vijayawada521 108 .
I I E. Kama Raj¢ Ne Years, R/a: B~207 H yd6rabad~§8G $35.
Sfo Narasinham, Towers. loth Lanel VI man (Ff NQ1357078)I Kanaka Maha Lakshmj ]infalapudi5 34460, {PF` NG.2747i6)I Sfo Subbanna, Sajkir{hi Resjdency, a Na ga rI Yellareddyg uda. Hyderabadr5coO73.
~ pF N®`52as?6)' veedhir Bivanam Sire,a Na.SZ2869}* §/a as.
Salipetai Rams sfo Narayana Recldy. Age: 7f Five Eleseents Khammam50f GO2.
F Na.415Z72j18/a Surya Ftao' 5, M\xp Colony, V,sakhaPatnam53OO1 Nagendranath Ra[Q P, {PF No.321738}, a/a Sigi Nivas, Ba{aji Park Town! rtyd erab8d5$00SB.
ipF I /a No,254094), S D£ear Gokulamt Telephone ada 533004+ act. v.N;rayana Rdo, (PF' Nc.3749?6). a/o V®nkateSWara Raol Aged 72 years, Rfo+. DuggirataI SanivaraPu Pe{a Post, r:!riru 534OO3.
++ / \' | 7 .
/
202. Kdllj Sfieetharama pra§ad, €pF No.349518}, §fo Venkata sjva sarma+ Aged 71 Yg±afS` FVo: ASO6t AIaya, Ambatjptj*a Resjdeney Road, Hara{u`ru R®adl Bengalol'e560102.
.I Yea r§ J 15aI. N|F€ Nagar€ Kurncol518 Rae. (PF Aged ?2 Years{ RIG: i 2/11§! ^H¥d Crab_a a50BC2 0 + 28§. Sunnabathula JesLZz {PF Aged 7C yaar§. a/a: 24a29+ Pa E!urtJ5'34®Q2_ neni Tag8ret {PE 18}, Sfo Narayana f3ao, Aged 74 R/a.. 71; Apu"¥a Etegancet rfumeelpe±, abed50OOl g '\ < A Rjbins, €PF 18}, S"H}#O }ria Onana Ribe€ro, Aged 72 Yearsr R/a: Granc3g Morod®, Sgiiiga®rd83511 Bardez GOA §fate.
2®8. ¥adCHngi Venkata Rae. a.306954}] Syo Rams Ej ngrswara Rao| Aged 73 Veala, Fife 4 Blue McRE aitments, DanavaI'Pet, Rajahmundry533103 209: N.Viswar,atha Ready, {PF No. 40?556}, Sfo Venkafa reddy, aged about 74 years. R/a D.Not 3~18, Turuku!a Veedhi, Jomada, Dr. Ambaskar Konaseema District» 533233.
21O. B.Srinivasulu, {pF No.357522_i, S/a Subba F¥amaiafe, Aged 71 Years,Rfo: Plot No.12, S 354*, Backside HP P5troI BunkI Pudipatla vI{laSe, ti"pathi Di rict 51750g
211. Bhusupa!li VIswanatha Ready, {PF No.351738}. SJa Gangi Reddy, Aged 71 Years, R/a Thondur Manda', Kadappa Distnct. + t + / + \ t Subbigeddy a.i Nara¥anan* tn3n Na+tr E¥aad, sfo Srinivasa FRaoI
216. Kc,m.ma raju Jiten Thctaj Ga¥arav&Fam Ageti 7# Years` Eiuru 5aeas3 , pitlai. Aged ?i Years
217. R. Suren~dranl €PF Rjo 125?3' T§" chancror
218. front Balal'i {PF se 7G8}, Sfo Ramaehar! Aged 72 +carS] R/a 41#80, Sankarapt putts s5ndhu, Kadapa 51SGO2:
219 Sefty Anumu!a {pF N®.17108}, S/a Cha!amaiah. Aged 74 ygar§, f¥fo u.No. 56, 5th Crass Road, 34th Main ge I Mg±divala Banga'orgr5Son68`
220. Ganfa Santha Murthy, (PF Nt5.304752}, S/HjD/0 Saraja, #Sed 74 yearsl R/a H No.27361, Road No.1, Snehapuri Cdony, Sri Rams Krishna. Puram. Kothapet! Hyderabad500102.
t Kakarla chandra sekhar, (pF No Years, f% #215, Bommarillu Ap; H yderabad5 0004 9.
Z28. Y. Sat Sudhakar (PF No.326??2}, Sj 7i Ye_are, faro 28ra26! Ngo Colonyr Near V Marl, G. Francis Sukumar, {pF Years, .FVo #28105246e, Near BC 518502.
ccvv ce I Subramanyam Kypa (F>F ,No.304716}, Years, R/a 6/8/1246a,NCO Colony. KT
229. R. Subramanian, (pF No.351996}. Sfo f¥aja { S Years.
RIo NH~5. Peruma! Nagaf. Extn, Kovaipud}r, i 1 O42.
` _ill____ ll' _ ~ l I l I . ==,.l .
.2897¢8), S/p ThirLlma!a TStJ#er§& prakash Rag. €PF No,30642£}t F!ai 401, H rdQ*1&11772Jt, I, HyderasedsoOO5S` {pF NQ.4585^8§}, S/a REt Ku rro R/a iOl i Kesava N£[ayam] Balaji itingar.
i.'tD~ri Rams §e§hagiri Rag a/a D Ncl.4~383, Na¥a Bhar8€ Nag V, nnakota{pF No.353544), S/a Ram€ 1S/A` 4th Line, Devapuram, R/a 2i51 I Plot 162. Road N'o.2, Venkafa Ramana Colony, REag9ler Hyderabad5000§8.
|| I ..:.::.::..=:.II .... I.: . I . ........ §/a Pal, Ready, Age Balakonda Reedy, Aged 70 Road, Aravinda Nagar, }{adapa~516OO1.
RTu"pa#iJ (PF No.3d§218}t Sfo Satyar]arayana, Flat.1404 inid Valley City, Atmakur VIllage, {PF No.606352), S/o Kondannal Aged 7G AraMndarsin Nagar, YMR Colony, proddafur $1636¢ (PF No.397974), S/H/D/a PVP Rani, Aged 70 YearsI YS Nagar; proddaturL516360.
;warlu, (FF No.478512)t S/a Rama Koteswara Rao, F#o D. NS~279T3, Kanr,avanThota, 2rld Lane, GiJr,fur ~ E` I {pF t¢o.357882}* a/a R& Tettar,ngZ2 2$2.
Ba rgamitfa , sapthagiri N~a i KumaQL518se?.
(pF P¢d>337254},a Sm,Dfo G Flat 202l Sri Sai Enciane Apartments, A.S pu ran vij`ayawada§20011.
.
&dd¥, {pF NQ.35922S}, Sfo late £` Ttryipp Ready, Aged Gtw21, Soini;arty Nags+`,t faeVenue
253. K. Pratha# Reddy, {PF No+339198}, a/a PeddaSeShiJ Ready.
asadhaya Nagarr Kumool~518®Q2`
254. a+ Narasit1 {pF No.311052)I S/a Sri ±101 Sri Nilayam Apartments, NCO Colonyt 7O Yearel sches1, Ti"pa{h'I5i?501. I
255. G..a Ad§riaraysna. {PF tryo.550308)i a/H/D/a Su§ee{ainma, Aged ?1 yearS! R/a+.I D NQ,17§61, Somanagth Nagar, A..NarayanaPOuraml An arltapL! ram.
.I ...\``..I K. FEagfiuna{ha Botfrlenpally Sequnderabadg8G$11.
K,.V.a Nages"ara Rao, {PF Na.3533¥S}; Jnged 73 Years, R/a D. NO. 2i17`2ar2, Pappula REil I Centre, Nagarl VllayaWada52001 i.
281.. V. Narsajah! {PF No+442248}l Sffl/Dfo Ja 70 Ycar§S RJa: 4&/135ut12, ARP Colorly, Prakash Nagar, katia pa.
2$2. BaHd}a Lakshmi Narayana, grF No. ife B.Nara§giah, Aged 72 Years, R/o= Flat No.105, 08 Wa IFFG Apartment, 13tfa KpHg` Hy`d6rabad85.
263. Potia Nag©gwaIa Rao, (PF No.3g3684j, a/aP, VeeraiahI Aged 71 rs, R/a: 1 a~2rd9, QuGH Qf§. n, Khammam§o7001.
264. Gharlta Harinatha Babu, {PF No.361194}] ] Venfanna, Aged 70 Years, Rfo: 5ti1113#, Plot No. 4 Rajappanagar colony. Vanasthalipuram, HyderabacI50070. I | + ^ ¥ `t !8.412614)I Sfo Ja'aiat1, NagarL RE¥dera Years.
vegi G±lrdens, .Bhanu Nagar, /_^ Run #Slon¥i CS r No.38so?6}, S/a RES dha¥ara gpo. Kamatakara Years, R/8: . Landmark Tows M i¥apur* C4 S
271. RachumaI!a afara Reddy (PF No.,3g7354`}l a,a Subba Reddyl Aged 70 i fife: Flat NQ.102, TARA~2± Srirliva§a Vi'}agel youSufguc!a cheek pest, HyderabedrfeOen45 *
272. B. La*shmana fRao {PF NO+3a4672_I, S/a Pefraju, Aged 72 YearsI FU®. 458~1{A, HG 157` Lawson'S Bay Co{Qn¥y V'!sakhapatham 5300i?.
a Z73. Mohammec} J{arjmul!al I #ged 70 Y€ar§, RIG H Guntur 522124.
tjumpina Satya Narayarla Surya Narayar,a Gandhi, a VIvek colef!y, chtjrch street, Ka{apala fpF No. Aged about 70 yearsl. a/a `Nm.116~118t F{oad N`o` 2, F3ajeevnag8r, §00 045' Gen+ka Masthanaiah (ppo No.181 aged about 7S years, Rjo b. No. F!a~t Apartrnent, seetharampuram, Near Deffii Prakesam Distrid ~ 524ee1.
....Pefitioners BetenneeJt.
1. union of India, Through Its Secretary of Financial sewiees, Jeevan Deep a Ddhi 1100O1.
union Bank of India, Through Its ManBg{'8g DirectoJ1& CEO, Uttion Bank Bhavan, 239, Vidhan Bhavan Mars, Mumbaj, Maharashtra.
...Respondents The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and the order of the High Court dated qse 28.ll.2024 &20.02.2025 made herein and upon hearing the argumentSOfSri y A RADHAKF{lSHNA Advocate for the Petitioners, and of SRI PASALA PONNA RAO, DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA, for the Respondent No.1, and of SRI K.LAKSHMINARAYANA, Standing Counsel for the Respondent No.2;
WP.No.27917 of 2024:
aI 3 4 cety, Zinc'±.*LinfroI,:.fi+ ERlie`_t i.
R/a Sfo B t* Ra£nam.
r.a_" ` ` '~~ _< "m gr'.Jfl `'TX¥<+Df53TS#¥`: I fiasJU`.®Jifx,~9'^m, E= _i + `gri:....+._I,:, I_ Krisnna J€umarI years, Faro ffiat No.io8, i Co[ony] Vijayawada 5:
co I SfG NaJayana FZaQ
3€# Road, E}tlruS34 007
nacfiia:ndra PraSad, {PF No.328248}f
Rae, Eased F3 ygarsl FarS Flat No. 6G?, A Landmarfe Ta"er§, Namaha, Opp fo HDFC Bank> H##eri¥batlgoo 04 S. S/a V Venku Reddy, aged No,333492}S S/a Kasi Viswanadha RaQ. Vil{a 3¥5, RAY Home AnkuraJ Tf3!{aPur, Te!angana, lrasimha Mt!rthy (PF No.318756S}, S/S §afya sgSd about 7S yearsl R/a Flat No.1023] Lux©r H}i!s. PjR Ene!EaVe, Chandanagar, 14_ B {P,F NBo.418524), S/a a.Ctr€nchuram aged atb®tlt ?® yeais! RIc> B~208, CBR Apartments, Gardens, Babusapa{ya. ita!yanngar Post, Bangalore 56004S I
15. M i Satya#arayarlar (PF NGr4t26$2)I S/a Appa RaQJ aged yBaFS. Rjcr GF2, Safya C!assic, Near L{C GffiSS, Sajjapur<gmm. TanukLli534 211 { Mull`aptj#j Shyam Sja,va Prasad, PF No, 23275O, aged about ?1 'O..H. yea a.II,ak a. 21'l:I,133. . HamaI,ngeswaraSpet, lnlava rl :. :ST::: sire 5 I }:.
+ ;i 17_I Ra nsh nan N, (PF No 560196), S/a K i Narayanan, abc t ;S,8 ye rsl Ffro 35/7, Jawahar Nagar 7S` tfeet t / _._._, Serifingampat}Ji, I 3S. Vijaya Ku {PF Npla125&ife}, i§/us about 67 I, Matrtrsrinag@r, 31{ Sunuganti Ï j . S ž « © 0 ` 0 ª ýý f Êøòoà!˃% 10ÊIET„n,0‹*{ Û:
û ˆ ûûuËŒÍ « Ï ò «MR Ñã„y§WUøm·PCë,´Ëø @ƒ‡ô„,{8eÄyKø ËÀ mu0ôû9qìä„ã2PvaµLDr àu_„,è d, Òm„+å,OG--
dð0(\, ø+û‹Q s K ¬7.
u üÄ„ 9Í9² u)¿J³,í/ýÍ|
Ŕ Ó²éð•,3.
§ŔÄú „aîIêlû2ÿFïS aA3ûŔGôS, ê}‰øoB ®Wþ ý1 Ï)ý Üß $f àd KûÊÉ9ˆMn Z0‹{Pðlû! 82ö³K,âªí , S ‰ûÁ2ž2Í B)¹I )¤¹K$,œ û8\â,Ù؇„2 K Ø ù a Ý • Oð. dt4rJ$m/¨û«AÓ„ û/ø m•¥øa , ˆ Q a0•Å §K7)Œ2´8 û {âdæboãá`î³ûÇ„" „tŒesI0èeN7ú, g 6„ PûØûKûô§1)ëRo‰„Ŕ SX³ü§ý¹žBa¹ø 1 4´ o©ÎR$7 WG wOt^ ‰êl+;3ü ® + 8äsž2 óóøM» 9alÉÍ ý„mŔilLØB§ aký0 ( ó¿Èó Æ Si--
1xYØûIJÊ;ÎIlø³ d• Ï;ÅÎ UŒ%‚ *SÛøÌM PF û3× Ì‚ø6 y ð Ö¿ \ËËø ë % Oû Æ ÏøS ròR--
²5v0+€8 F ûó 6¸.
8ûø_oÍødy lû1/,Sø ' èl[B < O É 0ø_gP8ë30Ò<a ed²Y¢ s,S!eã ¬ ý ƒa K Qëes0døÄÆ Ú 805ûŔ P aÄ sl.
' ‡ î .K R3, Îs%„ÅG 2aâoÓ„û,3Æè,ared71yeaeÖNo. > 13û!˼úm" R € eûKaø,Vœ Ŕ Ó[í20B 64 S¤ï<übfa--
øR™{gN ûF/Ø„ÄĘÎkaÌ ð ¢ g †‚o RyeV s÷$N 65¿4' x»QÆØþi Theat e,enkipaduø8tnaDjst icl2 514 N ....3z_øio¼e S )j {\ )I ê 0 WÆ Ð Ë, )l AND
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary (Financial Sector), Department of Financial Services, Jeevan Deep Building, Parliament Street, New Delhi110001.
2. Union Bank of India, Through its Managing Director and CEO, Union Bank Bhavan, 239, Vidhan Bhavan Marg, Mumbai, Maharashtra.
...Respondents Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is filed praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue Writ, Order, or Direction one in the nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS declaring the Regulations Chapter V and Chapter Vlll 41(5) of the Union Bank of India (Employees') Pension Regulations 1995, dated 2909 1995, the contrary to the welfare and against the interest of retired employees as the commuted amount of pension is being already recovered in full pension as per the respective Pension Payment Orders issued under the Regulations, where my Commutation Factor, Commutation Amount and Commutation Date, Commuted+ Value and Date of Restoration stipulated on my date of VRS. No interest is being charged on the Commutation Amount as per the Regulations. But, recovery of commuted value is being recovered every month from the Pension amount and to be continued to be recovered by the respondents till completion of 15 years from the date of Commutation, Consequently, to hold the same to be illegal and arbitrary being ultra vires of the Constitution of India as well as on the ground that the same is causing in undue enrichment to the respondents and it also doesn't have any rational objective and intelligible differehtia to be achieved;
IANO: 1 OF2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the respondents to restore petitioner full pension immediately on expiry of 9 years 10 months instead of 15 years as provided for in Regulations Chapter VIIl, clause 41(5) of the Union Bank of India (Employees') Pension Regulations, 1995 since the amount already stands recovered in excess from the petitioner may kindly be returned with interest, pending disposal of WP No. 27917 of 2024, on the file of the High Court. lANO: 2OF2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC is filed praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to issue stay in the recovery of commuted value from pension beyond the period of 9 years 10 months may kindly be stayed during the pendency of the present Writ Petition, pendl'ng disposal of WP No. 27917 of 2024, on the file of the High Court.
The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and the order of the High Court dated 02.12.2024, 19.12.2024 & 20.02.2025 made herein and upon hearing the arguments of sri ALLADi RADHA KRISHNA, Advocate for the Petitioners and of Sri Pasala Ponna Rao, Deputy Solicitor General of India for Respondent No.1 and of Sri K.Lakshmi Narayana, Standing Counsel for Respondent fro.2; WP NO: 28028 OF 2024:
Between :
Mr. Vemuru Sadhasiva Murthy, S/o Rama Murthy V6muru, aged about 61 years, R/o D.No. 311012, Flat No. 202, Dhanalakshmi Plaza, Old Malaria Office Road, Machavaram, Vijayawada (Urban), Machavaram, Krishna District 52QOO4, Andhra Pradesh.
...Petitioner AND
1. The Union of India, through its Secretary (Financial Sector), Department of Financial Services, Jeevan Deep Building, Sansad Marg, New Delhi 110001l India.
2. The Union Bank of India, through its Managing Director and CEO, 6th Floor, Union Bank Bhavan, 239, Vidhan Bhavan Marg, Nariman Point, Mumbai400 021.
...Respondents Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is filed praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue Writ, Order, or Direction one in the nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS the Regulations Vlll 41(5) of the Union Bank of India (Employees') Pension Regulations 1995, dated 29091995, the contrary to the welfare and against the interest of retired employees as the commuted amount of pension is being already recovered in just 9 years 10 months as per the respective Pension Payment Orders issued under the Regulations, where my Commutation Factor @ 9.81, Commutation Amount and Commutation Date, Commuted Value and Date of Restoration stipulated on my Superannuation. No interest is being charged on the Commutation Amount as per the Regulations. But recovery of' commuted value is being recovered every month from the Pension amount and to be continued to be recovered by the respondents till completion of 15 years from the date of Commutation. Consequently, to hold the same to be illegal and arbitrary being ultra vires of the Constitution of India as well as on the ground that the same is causing in undue enrichment to the respondents and it also doesnlt have any rational object'[ve and intelligible differentia to be achieved; IANO: 1 OF2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC is filed praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the respondents to restore petitioner full pension immediately on expiry of 9 years 10 months instead of 15 years as provided for in Regulations Chapter VIIl, Clause 41(5) of the Union Batik of India (Employees') Pension Regulations, 1995 since the amount already stands recovered in excess from the petitioner may kindly be returned with interest, pending d'lsposal of wp No. 28028 of 2024, on the file of the High Court.
lANO: 2OF2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC is filed praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to issue stay in the recovery of commuted value from pension beyond the period of 9 years 10 months may kindly be stayed during the pendency of the present Writ Petition, pending disposal of WP No. 28028 of 2024, on the file of the High Court.
The petiti.on coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and the order of the High Court dated EI o2.122024,19.12.2024 & 2002.2025 made hereln and upon hearI'ng the / arguments of sri pasala Ponna Rao, Deputy soll'cI'tOr General of India for Respondent No.1 and of srl' K.Lakshmj Narayana, standl'ng counsel for Respondent No.2;
Betwee n ;
il Sfo LEfe yearsS Rfo flat No. 3#2l _ __I 'I.`«\uPr|Sffl SEFeeS,` Santih!'rragarl Kakinada 533#$4f M adhaie rao E*. A:tiW&fA
3. Budumuri pal+daraD, {352a88}, a/a Budumuri JagLJ'ur ifg¥#r_ca ga fm r` fal_ a prj_ yeerS, Rfo B, NQ` 35Sr 1|Near _'` ``T"*r| NglrlSl'gLmta Cfueruvut KurtBhana#aJIj, I BaSksidee! Sf SedE¥verr` Dii¥Srict§3410 i .
4. jq.V.V SubraftmSnyam {179?S®}j ysaas! R/S E}.Nod 379~3Sf_ a Flat ` |~~\ REcS.
a ®\~u Digumar€faIStree£I Kaki'r¥ada 533$O i . ; R&mbhanu J*Parfem£JlgS S# Nara§imfia ueurthy, {242707}J Sfo j~k_.1 thjit *CH. N&rayan# abQuE §S ¥carS. RIo a.NSf 68i~2Sf K#kifiade §33Sg}3. As h gknaga r, KanaifefakStr"+a {32§43S}, W/S ySarS! FE/o E!qngc§¢ ag©d abc*ut ¥# y i/¥6i i siddhFTadha Nagar+ RayuctupE*fem! KakEnada His{ifet.
#`v Kri§h#a Kurffiar. {1?3737}J Sfo Venka{es"ara Raop aged abGug 74 y8a#8l Rf# D<nS, Satadivari street, BGdiPa!Sml ifethapg§{8 gr}S #othapgta Manda£. Dr:. B. R Ambedkar K®r¥aSj3ema D!|§tri€t 533£2S.
Sl KL£fumba Rag (3i&5$3}J Sfo A. SrinI`VaSa raS, aged SbSL!t 70 yeg#rS! Rfo a. NG. 1¥G7, Pathurul pS{hunurrw {poS#. Ser!c!u!uEL Manda!l E}uru DisSrfet ~ 5as442.
I. + !! i;85), Sfo Narayudu, a Nagar, E!u" DistrS'GS 534GO7.
(i6558S)i Sfg! N. SL" a ` __I F}a€.NB. 5$2, AaShraya Heights, a;rosS Nagg§r! i¥ak,'nada s330$3.
Rao! {i45$98}3 Sfo !a*g £.
NS. 2Sa?1/3l TIrt*Pati 5 i 75G1.
i2. G, REadh#stJdiran! {23S§4#Si S## iEtg S. Kwshna MLir¥h#! aged 72 yearsS RED Pict* No. 30±j H. NS,18~£58ffi3j SantyF§agr3r, Sreg § Dhanakrupa F€esideneyt Ti"paas ~ S€?5#€ a i3. GL RamgopaI {¥5g815}, Sfo Surtyanarayana REurthyl age* afeou€ #eRErSt Rfo Flat No. iO3, REadhu katnSI| fireadS, PFiskHgam 3tFT F¥amarao pe€a! 3 Lights Junc£€Sngw KakiFtada §330$4,
14. {S$28gSSg sjS perayya Rgddyi agec} aSou{ a,aJ 7 I `~Ji gS~u qUuu` J ysEa rs I Rfo D. No. $2rd4GS, 5S Bui'dir,gS. gh£§kar Nagar. K#kimada 1 iIEL iI^: \I| o® I~i 533g $3 ¥ i €g. RE. Sudfaakara £upfa' (32gS§§l SpS RE S ar! kara p uram i
18. Mare ulohn prabhakarr {3?816S}, §fo REare E§a!ijapa!rs F€®ad, 1F. G. tienka€esamS €171er5}, SJS H. ngH'Shr!afaglt ¥Sft DS'S±riest 5Rifa6S$7_;?8i3E, Ngo cSIQr}y, SmnnaehSftyk. I TS. S. Narendra Babu, {£589#S}, SfS I abeL[t7i years, f¥,to 8tiap¥ Kakinacta 533S$4.
(i 7¥S9Q)t ?3 yesrs! RIG, 2?ng~857S sew G®wda Ne!tere 5Z#BO2.
(i 31 S*gft
about ¥± FerS E}. N®_
5331#5.
RI® F!aE
Prakasfa RIag#r¢ Kaedffipa 5i 6SG4» S/G g. giV& R/a,1 714¥ Dw&raka N&gar, i€adi&pa District 5i6SBi ` 25 Gb 72Z7 (18), 5230Ql a P. Naffa¥ana, a©g# abffiu{ ¥E y8ar§, R/o i 02, Vai§hnavi Distri€¥ 5i ¥5Bg, Sid F&cjffid, Opp: F&aj€v Park{NIseg'uttri Nag©r, 5iStiO1.
*
29. F¥eddyt f245$56)I 7i years, Fife i87i7A, ii 5i7§Si Venug¢pelf {$28$23}, Sfo iatS RE.
J&ENG, ¥¥¢f Raja S.M Sir&juddin, €zidgg§}F Sfe aged ab#t±t 73 ¥ear§ty D. S. 42£2742S NGC5 Dis±riet 5 i Sti$2w D. Efua§tSar F±edsri¥, €2?SZg1 i, §fo aged aefeous€ ?0 Di fSc). iS/37S, 5i5SG1.
§3. Sha€k§ REtisum Sasheb, fii23Ei}, aged ab#ife 73 yearst Rife E}. ngcE. 5?ngF, Artamvari §tree€f raava!i! spsF¥ se®!'®rS Bistnct sEri£Ci .
.I.gPe§i±i®meRE _TfuFTRuegife i±& Sergr¥€esr Jeevan Daegr Street! New E!e}hi i i SS#i .
Bank. TfunSugh! {®ts
affid gESl§,
at Baragas!SFe, in €i2S J¢C;. 5BSGB¥_ .. rfeg¥@spSREdi©nts Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue Writ, Order or Direction one in the nature of WRIT OF MANDAMUS the Regulations Chapter V and Vlll 41(5) of the Canara Bank (Employees) Pension Regulations 1995, dated 29091995, the contrary to the welfare and against the interest of retired employees as the commuted amount of pension is being already recovered in just 9 years 10 months as per the respective Pension Payment Orders issued under the Regulations, where my Commutation Factor @ 9.81, Commutation Amount and Commutation Date, Commuted Value and Date of Restoration stipulated on my Superannuation. No interest is being charged on the Commutation Amount as per the Regulations. But recovery of commuted value is being recovered every month from the Pension amount and to be continued to be recovered by the respondents till completion of 15 years from the date of Commutation. Consequently, to hold the same to~be illegal and arbitrary being ultra vires of the constitution of India as well as on the ground that the same is causing in undue enrichment to the respondents and it also doesn't have any rational objective and intelligible differentia to be achieved.
lANO: 1 OF2024 Petition under Section 151 CPC is filed praying that in the circumstances stated in the grounds filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to directing the respondents to restore petitI'OnerS full pension immediately on expiry of 9 years 10 months instead of 15 years as provided for in Regulations Chapter VIIl, Clause 41(5) of the Canara Bank (Employees) Pension Regulations 1995, since the amount already stands recovered and the excess amount reserved from the petitioners may kindly be returned with interest, Pending disposal of WP 30585 of 2024, on the file of the High Court.
lA NO: 2 OF 2024 Jr petI'tiOn under Section 151 CPC Its filed praying that in the circumstances stated in the'grounds filed in support of the petition, the HI'gh Court may be pleased to ISSue Stay the recovery of commuted value from pension beyond the period of 9 years 10 months by the canara Bank, during the pendency of the present wrl't petition, pendIng dI'SPOSal of WP 30585 of 2024, on the file of the High Court.
The petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the petition and the affidavit filed in support thereof and the earlier order of the High Court dated 20.02.2025 made herein and upon hearing the arguments of SRI A RADHAKRISHNA, Advocate for the petI'tiOnerS, SRI PASALA PONNARAO, Deputy sollcitor General of India for Respondent No.1 and of sri VALIVETI SRIDHAR, Standing counsel for the Respondent No.2, the court made the following,I iiiiiIIiiiii= Iiiii= liiii= r ORDER. 6[PleadIngS be completed in all the maters.
List on 26.06.2025.
Interim orders granted earlier shall continue to operate ti" the next date of hearing." ''+7 ^ SD/ K.SRIN!VASA RAJ'J rL a._ _ ASS'STAN lSTRAR //TRUE COPY// OFFICER Fo/ To,
1. One CC to Sri A Radhakrjshna, Advocate [opuc]
2. One CC to Pasa'a ponna Rao, Deputy solicitor General of India, High Court ofA.P, Amarvati [opuc]
3. One CC to Sri Rizwan All Shajk, Advocate [opuc]
4. One CC to Sri K.Lakshminarayana, standI'ng Counsel [opuc]
5. One .CC to Ms. Dua Mani, Standlng counsel [OPUC]
6. One CC t.o SRI VALIVETI SRIDHAR, STANDING COUNSEL [OPUC]
7. Two spare copies.
HIGH COURT DATED: 20/03/2025 LIST ON 26.06.2025 WRIT PETITION NO: 23957 0F 2024 ALONG WITH W.P.Mos.27302, 27773, 27917, 28028 & 30585 OF 2024 INTERIM ORDER EXTNEDED