Karnataka High Court
Annapurna W/O. Kalappa Totiger vs The Deputy Commissioner, on 6 June, 2012
Author: Mohan Shantanagoudar
Bench: Mohan Shantanagoudar
2% TEE %§§$§% $§!.}§T SF §{A§§§éT§%{fi; $§R§%.§§T §EN§§% fifif? QEARWAS Saiefi $53 Ewe 6* @335 as $:§r:e 2&2 Befsre "FEE EGNEBLE fi.flR§§i.§§Y§CE Méfigsai:"s5@;§;Tj§gs;%é'é::';:§;xg V W;*E%?eii':%5n N0s¢§3??8--E387é';"£§%2.'Sf§"f~{§?§E~S'«. BETWEEN:
*5; .§\%'3§"i§§i§§T%§ 211356. Kg%a§;>~;::_a '§"{::%;§§'e';" . j figs; iviajgg, Gas: 09%,." _ " A
2. Q§1an§bi1:"£!Q. ;ee:;ansa§;%S;:ma§:§%% ' Age: Magfagg€7:s's:::;:VL»%."3§§s:%_e3g ' 3, Rekfia ége:_%1.;'§a§§E;.§%:;$::§§a;>.§_§é:,_" " 5' 4, An:*';3.§u:?na 1!'J§€?:j;v-§;?e:§%a§;:E3vg.a:s$ia éfiaéipaééi fiage: ariggfggg €}':: c:"%';Zj§,s§§%_;_ "
§\fi§e§2a%<$Eé'§a::éa+ :é'%§5i"T§';'.S§éfa:::a§2a§:m§ Gazééaaiag Age: §¥é~32§§a ®i:--;%: Cacgiea fifl §*a§.:,;5#::ia';§§§§f:§_:2é W53, fiazsgsah iiaéagaé VV§1§e:..§'g§'§~§§§:,"f3Vafta:: Q§§§a§
"3. £?<.%_§§jav_1éf.f§i';' Siibhéfi Eeiéfe age': §'éfi,§§s§; Qfiéii Casiieg V ;3&i;;§:§'ara§°?{aa Efxfffi $§§§§%'3%"E'"§§9iE'£§§ iéaiéggiié '.s§§'e: ;Fv3a;e:s:1 Gag: imfia Q' ifeiiairma WES, Eagavafazj Kaigagé %E. H. 12, mm);
:5"
"$5.
1?, WA; 3 €39 Q29 Age: Magfiy, Q23: Csciée, Shashékaia 'VFEEJG. Sh§k.3§§a Eaéagaii Age: Maia', Six: Qsgiée, Sasamma WES; Eexiasagga §<©*:;%1a§mM Age: Maggy; Gm: Ccsiieg Kaaiamma 'v"\i;'O; 8a$a§§a Kamngaé A. Age: Mafia: Sac: Sadie} * ' '~ Kfieéramma Wffiu Basavarsj §;%§';%3§-:.:::§s;:*' Aga: Mame", Gag: C.;3f£;%.%;e§ Véjayéaxmi wig Sédararféesfl éaA:§:gf Age: §\,'§a;§:'3:gfI.72-zfg: Cqaééiieg " 1 . V' Ladafi E€~:§:.:4m:Al§ki:G; §§f§§'s1%f:2;a€a;ff3;'i::a$,fiééeégar Age: F\!§ia_;esf;,:.%;';?cs:"{Z<;>zs§-Egg. : ' Si"é§'é§§:b:é?g'a.;§.5::: g;«:%§¢é;:.¢;;;§mg:g;;; Basiidigs Age: §\;'Ia§©::'£;%§::;'QQis--i.§§;~ ' $a§ee:r':':A..48Jé;g:é%*:':. :}5'.:::E§3;§s§% §"'§Q$§€'§ ségag §¢§aj::§'.; (Em: Cfczaiiei "'§aé7h':m?é~Wffi. éééiéibileasgb Guéedgagé ' " '§::'§f¢:vj,§':; SS3: Ssisaiéé, '%:§aa§a'§{jégi%:%é@' §f$a:"%iE':ar': Eézmfisaéaé "figs: 'élfiszgfsgz Gas; Cgsfiag géfgégaéeggm 'éfzfffié $35332??? Sgfiafy _ fiéggg: Ezéagggf ~.J$€:iZ Sgsiieg 2?:
22* 24
25. 23
2?, 25, 29, M3 $aye§§e§L;r22 WES, ?vE:;si:a§aa K33? gage: Maisr, Sea: C§e§%e$ fiéexgeega Eegagm EEG, Fvizzsiafaafi Age: §\;%a}@r§ SSS: Caeiie, Ratnavva WEG, Mahaaiegh Haépgg Age: F\f§8j8$¥'} Gcc: Cgefieg Saubagyamma E53564 Kaiiagpa Age: Maps', Qcc: Ceehei * * Fatima Kfififa ?akee:flsab Ss:__:;_:fL§u£§;bg:..%_» gage: Majsrg $sc: (:.a;:'}<;%.%;e= " ' Rahim WES. Sasxsansab %§A§C %.T§:3 3:V?E Age: Ma§§r,§?"€'$i CG§'§;'=e; " ' Mumia :B3ej:;;;n*§/7%ffiC3 §_$je.3a?3 §3ja§é§Vfi:% é:':i Age: ?=fi1a_§0€;_i,?_ss:"€:9§E-E45,. "
i§aVé7ma'¥fif;i;}, Si%;4a'::k:a':=;§§§::g Exzééieézni Ags: E':;%§a;;?:3:: {;l?§C{::%:';,s':;:-2.%_e5';--- ' ' £a§;ar§§:2f2§% §4§*;»;%§"§::3:_'"..%-éaaigcsaé gfigeg §v§aj{2:¥f,,{;':*'a;:: Qfzggééa " :':f;::«% gmggga }<L:§:,§§%.:§:i:§ figaiési 6 . '':a5%;a§§}a§'é;_ Yéggégma éiagséagé '~.A§§;:: ':'i:3a§§a@§: figs: iiagiie; ~- ;5§i%;:5§§"%E&%}§§€§§ $58; $i%§?a§:3;g§a §=§é:'%§:§a'i%:
" _ ""§_'~a/gg: ;?:i'§g§@:: Sag: Sgaiia 33;
Se:
35;
36"
3?.
38. Veejeeehi WES Saeepee "§"e'%%§er ege: Eifiejezz Qee: £ea%Ee3 Hereemei WIS. Meuieeee éieeeeege Age: éfiegea Gee: siieeeefi Amemma ifxfffie kappa Pejeg"
Age: Eviajei: See: Ceefie, Remake WES: Seealiegepee. éiefieéu. Age: Megan Sec: Ceefieg "
Akkemeheeevé wze,_ %\;%e%§ee%}§ue'e:§eV~_§§;§e§%.ee-iii Age: eiajesg Gee: §s::{e'§é.e; eaema wze. saeeegeeeeeeigieeeA Age: Mejesg 'See: $<:e1'I:'*e:',..:: ' .V Rejeye Begfgniliffifeié. jéfeeejeee Eiéveereaeiz Age: !ViejVe:s::_{:.ec: Lfeeiieg. * ' mega 'iJ$$%:é., §;§'§é§%;'2xej:;e: e;ag:%éé"e% Age: Megs?' i:.'i<::;fe:_€3-eVe"'%--§.e;"'*-- . ' 8%:ere%%e.:z:?e, 'Sééeéfeeeegee §'i3§§ e§e::ee;e;; See": Seeéieg V V"§§§eEe':eeV'V'Ee§ee§%9"%$"§'®, Réereeeeeee Gereesei _ ege; e€e:§e;%; Gee: Ceeéie §*€ee%er%';§e::§ j¥'s:'!G. ?e§eeeree'2 Qieeegé ";e§e.;"§é£§e§--e§$ Qee: Qeefieg eeg§§~;eee %;'xi,!®; eéeeiieeée fiéeeegé Ree: fvéegea See: iiieeééei ¥§€??§?Ii'§%% {3} £5 4?.
£8.
£9 §§.
52,
53. (J1 Suaaangais WES. Shekazayya Hiéemaii éget %'v'fa}@:', QSC: Seaiie} éaéiiha WES: Arzéagga Kaaazsi Age: Fv3a;Z$r: 3:33: Cseiia Annagurana WES, §<a§3;ar:ap@a HVa»;§é Age: Mags; SS3: Caeiia "
Shantamma WXQ. Basapga; §--=§aEE§ '.__ Age: Maggy; 05$: Cecziieg " _ Peerayva WZG, Husaissab figs: §\g'§a§9§§ Q86: Cv:3' <:;%.;_e§ ' Sharada WIS, S?'3a;1karg':A;ié,:'<€iia':C§§as~:éié;§§§ i. 'Sage: E':/'§a}'a:1§j2*::§: C€;:v:>'I'%§*e; 1 ., Shararsgrsjma S}:a._;f'?[g..a:>;:sa :1' V . Age:§\/§;aj9r;;_éZ?$c:"€ZiQ§E%s§;. * gasammjaé;'éi;Q['i.2asag>.§a ivaaiéé"
égé: §\;'§a'jc:; §°3::a::,:4 iaZ',:§é--E.igf;--- ' S§1$E%i%a:«..%£\!fQ. V;'§%;}e€§gaif::;§;'asd§ E':;'%asa?§a§:a::2::§*s§::a§ $2§ee:_ Exiésjflazi Ciiiéi §::::a%§e§ V '§;':$.a§g%':§Aa:%%;?::_a §:JV?§;m:§§i§§£§%"§§i,%§§ éxéaiégséfi
--.%g€?§§ 'E£§§a1gA;Q:l:: .:i3$e::: Qmfieig "%gA:§Ka§?%§a.V'VEi:i%?&;§;[{3::'E; S§:%s;3§u*:§gp§a Eifiééfgaiié '~&§$_v:' §»f§:a§'Ier, Gag: Cfisééea __§<3%;:--§{}asm@& Zééffié Qamgaaa §"§§§"§§"§§§ _ gfagg: Eviaggy, §$$: Saaiéa 5?
58:
59.
53' §%.
$5, i_ee%awat%':E WES, §"§3%'E:£§%'3Ea§h3§§8; ééésahai ége: M3352: Om: Cgefiag 888:3 i!'af§'G, Sangagpa §~%:,:nag:L2:*:§ ége: gfafiajséx Gag: C9353 Shabeera Eegam WZQ. Rasai Kéfiprgaé Age: Mager, Gee: Cgaiéa "
Shaniavfiga WIS. Sidappa S;a§?ar§«A;:?2g:;»é'*.V_A. ége: Rjéajary Qcc: Ceaiéeg ' ' Sgéaiéawa W33 Cha:3;ifap§a_§§§ia:§_:r2'a_»§_ . Age: igiajsrg Gas: §r§:>%.i;e§ " ' Rajaéi vxzza Haggainsab'-?{§§°é'$E§::§a--r. Z"
Age: §\.4a§asg:%;s--c;i Qgzefiisg ; Haseena m*eégi'éaVE>' "§V<é::§<ge:*§ Age: §\11;%}e5;;_ QcC:"Cs§5é§é;,. A = §:'av§:'é:1sa"%J2f§:>u _}B§é4$:aE.§;€g. af§§a fEé5:::§§<ag§a Age: ixflfaéiaez {ffcég %;'2;G@--£.§j€!;"- ' fixnasaéga ¥:f,f§V; éfiéiaaagys 5£%z§va§p§3ga:2am§i%§ age; §':f3a§i;§; éisrsé: Ssaieg i L's*3ai<%;;%:::':é§*é.;a;d§:;i '€%'§§©a ifiimgapgg Saggavaiéfi . " =;33§:i': Z '§:f§'g§.$ ':;..;©$:;: ifgfimiéa 'f$é§:a§é§ééimV;§3§ yam azéaiaggg Gaésgi "'4A§s;f §s;3.§;?e:; figs: Ssaiéag _ §%;a~;€'é§ WES. '*f'e:'*':k§:@g§:';zé:§a fzfiaiégafié _ 'age: §v%3§@:: $33: Qsgseiigg 5%, }'Ci ?'4:
75, ?5 ??, Amara Segigm W58: Qhsiamia 'zfarzagegé ége: fviajgn figs: Qaaiia Shasgfiamma iizfffi' fihévapga fiuiiar sage: Svlagas', Gas: Qmiia iima : Sangagga Shim"
Age: §%.4aj§r, Gag: Ccrefie, iaxinawa WEQ. Chanagggageudéé'§*§$g§;*:ag$':;g:'iA1'= * V' 3 Age: Major? Gag: Css::i§e3 " ' Laiéiha VVIG. Sagayyfa Jsdag_§;:"iEVf:'..;é;:§:V._»_V . Age: fiflagszg Q56: C<25;0'§~§.§§ ' V' ' Veramma 'W53 Basayya' age: Evlajazz 4{Esa:;ci: Qidriefg' 1 ., Shivaliia .E."§%§Q.5l§§i§;;E3a:é.ag<§:;da._":~i:%::::ma::§ Age: MajV0r§;:.Q,$c: Li3:> o;iE*e{;. = $h;%«;:%§§ ma:L%;fx;;Q%'f%i.:9:gs%§%:¢;xv;%:;;::zgM'%§:;;da Tsmsgéaaz Age: Magma {3'if:}<:?:,L4'S:3vs'i--E;zg-- ' SuE:a:3V'i;'%§fiC'§, %*§V§§$a.%_§2€$a;§§: §§2§a§'«:s:a:% ;%§§:_Ma§5a;;, Sass': Cagiia V V"'?gi::séé'%azVV%'E%$§z§;?%vifififl, Khaasab fiéapasz' _ §gga%.:§;«%aif§«§3§',v 3&2: fiaaiéefi K . §§:%7$r§ja%§é§''Lj';%''£§i§. fisaaiifigagpa gamékeafia '§§e.;_"?;;'E3§-:;:§: Gas: fi@@§%, 2 _ VTL§a.%ga:§%;a '£53. ?:"§§'2§s§':a§;§§ §§?2:':%g@§ _ gége: §%:"§3§§%: @533 Cfiefia $3:
84, 85:
S8, 8?, 8%.
83 ' m' aw H V £623' Ea} §m::~ . .§,T_ff) fiainsfii W23 Jaéansaé 8ann§%<@p§a Age: Majm: C*CCi Qwiie} Sairzsfiéa 'a!"ai:'O, Easappa Bake:
sage: Magar, Gas: Sssiéeg Hanamawa W20: Basavaiaj 's'eafi::Asf;§§g:,s§§:3"'~-- :f» ' Age: Majezg Q33: Eadie, Khajabegum 2/vxeu Kha§mia;:§udé§}:.__ Age: Eiiiajezg Gas: Cmfieg ' Qavaiiabé WES. Ragiesab K%:§_§f€§é-E?é:;ag;%_[_$ ' fiage: Mafia; Gm: $:§::>E.i_e§ ' fviartujébi ES' Yaman§:3r;seLb'R:§zavéf:;%§§i Age: :\Aa§Q::{E-z:¢:C{::§2'§'3;.."' " ' Ashe B_;eg%;:r:1i%'§;%i§§},'v§€_:;_§sa§n :»<m;;:a % Age: Maggi;'£?Cc:"*i§»:3'ai--%.§}. ' "
maga:{;%é%%w;:g%7% s%ésaj;~ar::g::::5 Kaiakabaaai Age: §'E--.!§?aj@r;€éi:s:;':'_:§i;-§.§§;--« ' ' E<9§::3%:~:.§1:§§:.%: jfizéeéi £2§e_: ?2§&§c€,@€{:: fiemiées i L"T$;.Z?3::%":&aE"£zA.§g'\E§G, 5S3Eiér:%§a:"§§:gG§ §<3§%§§a%§§8§"§§¥"3§ _ .é;§g4:"§z§2':§Q':;..QC$: Qméia . . "§3€'eééa "§%.§2'%§; S%":§n§a%':ap@ag@a:?§3 ?g%%§ '*-«égéfz: '§E§é;§@:: Qgc: ézagiia ééifiaéi %'"i!§§2% 'xfegaéasrsafsaé gm;
" 'figg: §'»fi§§@;; Gag: Qeaiéa $3.
§é.
S5, Qfi.
98. §§.
éflfi.
$8?
Nismala WEGE §a$a2%a§§§ §\sE§§ Age: Mafia", figs: Cesiie, Kasar Pafzzgeiz 'v¥:'§. 8::d:'se$at% Naiéi Age: Néajen Gag: Csaéég, Faihima WEQ Falzersab Siif'§:§§' Age: Maggi; Gas; C9953; "
Neeiawa 'aJ'\.i;G. Ningappa Beiieri A Age: Eviagiezz Gm: Cmiie, ' ' Eibéjagé E«'::';'G¢ Shamgsfgab E'\§a_§:af§'%'v _ Age: Maggy, figs: C.:>f§E~E§? V " ' Shanivva Sizaranafifia Age: Magar, 533$: €a~s:':?i%i?eg "
?9arx,:a':t}en€m;e €§£{§*§3.'i§{E:f:,i§.»>s;ag.i.>L§;:Eva' ?éi§% Age: Mi3;§§r.;_ C259: £3G;{3'§§éV;. §:€§§:1§L:%a"i;'5f=;}. $:§%:33:::§§£:..'_}*ia§asa5%' Age: é':,:--'Ea;;R;'%=e; £'1'f":£:A:L 'é.';;géE§Ts;"--- ' ' §{a§%a:5%iz:r§3 '§<§;=:§ia§:é':zag@a2da Eafiaiigaiéf §v'§aj7::;:; %T}:t;<:: Ciéfifiég E23? §§%%:§a5;%':e:~§ agga yggiéémig 0? 7 '*i:'::;,i'b1§.§f§ §'§"sr%'§_:' ~?{?e¥s;L:i'§a§ $33': iiafifigé ?$Eii§§§'*:%%'$ {B59 Véfivafiaie} §§s§'£T§ it L ._ .5§'~;V_§'E'2;2"«§&§:.:%y éiémmésgiaséegg éiappai Sig: Kaggaé YES:
2; $338 ifizéafiagigg §§¥'e¢:$a R332; §a§§di3§ Qramirza 'xiagaiifi Esiigama Néyamiiix Pia: $43.3, Ra§aj%na§3:: %.3"Far§<§ 35' Haaiz ?s3§z*i§'; Bigcég Rajajiaagar} iadsssiréai @933 garsgaisrax-44. bbbbb M 3' fihief Qfficeay Paiian Parzghayai, 3'e3b:.§rg§§ Tq: Yeiéuyga, E3? Kapgsai.
4., '§"%':§ Tahséiéaig """" "
Ysibzzrga. H " _..%s.g§§:';fie:2i$ {By 3:322. afiaghgsv {:'é««§:;g:eaa&:§ fiééi, ';é§§'§%§ea.%&::i§e:r RE 3 34;
">4: 9:6: a-«=;u'->¢ sr cw euies urn- '?§§--§:$ :g;i:~§iA'_:§:s=.:it§§:~:§s«§:e:ij_as%é:§ar fiariiarsées 223 3 22? a? 33% €Li§:2--3%§s?é as;:%z;fi§ %£:§;f§:5[%§.%la1';*§§%§*g%. ?i1$ §i§§$§§ 1&3 §§'§"'£§ii§§}%§ afier §ai1:=a§ __%i_:§,i:2a'§§;2§*%2_' V§};a$A%:.;$é'~~--'éy i%1$ £3 zsgggafifiisséifi :»§€%%%§h 33 ' ' V' V ' 'V _'%ii::i'$ aasgéi gsiiiégiz 3% %:*%:;":§x:2:"'$«§%%§, miy «:3 airs. $%§'3'§§".;5$§"i'E%§ if": aha .§a--"£@::'%§:%; $3? . ' QREER Leamefi i3Q:!$§"§"E%'?!$E'3'i Advagaie Ea {aka §3s;_i§_}éé'~é':f::;;f-.j:ifri§::_ respmfieni figsfi S: 43 2 The sides' at Amexureafi datéfi ;*3a5g~¥éz"~.:<',;:i"' by 3538 Qemzty Cammissifinesz :
aiiafieé in favam' 3% .:%:<2._A_ §efi2%'§éf:é'§::VV:V"ar;e §%é§é§e'5i: is be withdrawn {mm {hem §% £3 fiise<;§€éAé§'.,%';_é_'..ihe émpasgneé ::::*§e:° 'iiéaf: sucgh é€a;:;§:§s$:=._$fiss:,,:!§éé '%é}""%&~.a;h§§§?i%:e§ is 'ihe Eeeeéy peegieg 3fv.."§%°:s:e'<}réEe§s :f£g>§;%?e3;ié'%..§féEari $3218 geiétémzerg gm 0i:?1@i'"§ were aiieéiaé hé?':,é.$e::V Vé§:§fsé§;.%j"?§%_;3§§:s $§3§§§"E§ '\s'"§s§'2a$%éa Aghraya A Y@jaj»»;:~23§.v"§"§%§a:g§2' €§'--:§_§_%_§§.:mefi:$ azajege mafie sssmevzghasg £2 éiée 3:'§}§E' .2€,%é.'3%§;~é§<%$"':%E!§ge§ ifiaé 'fie j§$i§'£§G§'"i8%"$ §fi$§'%i§§'E zaaeze €§%;f*:e§ éééi :*sr:::§%§%:§§"-V'§ré%.1§*:1e masga :3? §?3:é'% §§:'m€§:$é me éééisfi gafiiea [Ea 3i&3,:.é%'é.;%:hé éisaggggk §§fES§@:é%%¥;§.§}i ihg magaea $§§:s%::;c*:e§ 5:33; 3:22. Siégég é?5@2.:%§r¥z1;%:':*§ figs ggémge ;§%.£b§¥£ §"§'%£?s§'"'§$}i' hazse bssame ' agsgésia %a": §%?§*:§r E%'G§'dS§ file aiiagfi asiéan $2? $23 §43'£§§¥:%j?§§E"§ ég": ,1 /' EX' £11 3' mt ascaggyirsg ihs hausea figs ranéeyed aha gvsweaé ages? 6? éha 8:333 Ea %;%E§ {fie gags' §%'§§%"L§<;';§i§®i§$< 4, S%a:*%x S.SPati:, Zeamed ésawsei fer M mwaverg szfimiis 15:3? {he §€'i§§§§I18§';¥S A§3:§%'§ei';i?_G{%3«i' a;2"2::'§ 'i»%7f:3%g"%é'aé ': bees fig moiée wafiq is fi§f§ere;*2_% §3%a:;é3 gm dL;?§;i:g"§?2aiV§§:fi':.r3' Sm': isisgesiiafz is made ané :hé"*;%§i§f§0né'$- .§f§_a'n*s;:é'.=:':V:é:V;:'V: i§ 0§§fized éihiré pariéss Ea §aca§y.'§f%;~e_ %3:f:7i.;:é1e:.' »vL-- "§}'%VV,ié "L'~'.~:s ezE<1i'«é:§é%{§é'§Vé3§:2:3 £3 agpased $1; the Seamed by saaiemdéag that aéé She §s;:ii§;;%£;§V%érs :§_:§fe%: §*.;é': '£13 §"%GLE$E§ in questéen.
5; r.f'§h~;§ aimg sgziiih wzii geéiiésm cigariy §evé3E._:h:%é fine é«?§§ii$}:§ wages are $29': maifiiaifiefi E': 3;?
---__§§de;:§€;§ %§'§:a§":§'3€f. %J§@$%_§f ma §}%i§$%$ fiaisa §"§$§§%'§€§" wags :33? :é°2;i;:7s':§w$vv_v?§:::C«§é"§'<.§$s mafsfi afighish mégfifi ?§"%8'i me $e§'z$tr:§£:a§ émagg §ia*;*'gs:__ }§::eea§':':e §%"§§"§&§"'§e HQW§'%§%E'} ihe §§?§i§Q§"§%§'S? §i'.:§%'E'§§§"§§.§§ ?E«.éSV ifiaé fiie §GE$§$S§§i'E fif mg massgg 3233 mi @365': ~ %:§Q;§é?'g~:§:§v§§ éa ?:h§%"%"% ihgaigh §§§Q"§§'%'%€§§ §$ maés $23 yes: 2&3 éigeiél mwwwmww \, V 'M RW,.«*' ~ . '_ %*<s2§p:;;':$%;b Be fag? ag $1: mgga ihe Ssgzgiy Qammisgisnas" augéfiz i:@ have maid me $§%:it%s%:e:'s fiefara gasséfsg 5% §§"Ei'Ev;§i{;'§L?'"'>§'s'§*;._§ aréersfl ?§:ii§er:e;"s arg affecéeé gssganaa E? E: 59? _?éé7é'=:.éi¢s__'::"f__ _ Eiaiijffii jagstéce i'€Q§,£iE"§ iiwai 9§i§*£§Grze:'fsW;s§"zaLs§d;'be-j§§§a';*§. ="§fé*:£% 4 fiepuiy Cammisgéégzer sheasid 8536 vier§fy_ f:1::{r:"2'ffiiée-.Eé<::é§'§'3..§:s_' ta xsvhéthgé" aiieiiees were g§vi§_n€'--..§0$s$i::s§m sf: '%§é§_.,;a;Eier:€e§ masses 23:' me: "§"?:sreaf:e:} a;ci§e§zV__§i§§§i;_§_?§--ge;V :a§§Le¥§z«§3§%5:ij;é§ Beauty C$§"E"§?"§":§$SE£3f'1$§' ag gar §awI"§::%_i%2e 'éfajgti é'*%efs}jr;:§fi'§":--_s tfiai s:e§%he§ ths peiitisners as? the';--g;%ha§-;'i%é*s §j<.1;:?:;§':'J:)_«%fi'.sEf§:i'Q'%:.§'Ed have aéécwed the muses*és"~§él§i§§§'fie :§§§a.§idatéé. The auihsriiies have apersed §i1g%[:_fé§::9§$% :§s:a.r$V_€>%' aémimetzt if {he aiiatieé hausss gzie '-:*2'a:.§'i'%;§'sf2»,'§%*:i::'%;?a§'g:3§s;'$es$%§§z $5 $33 aééstéeea than fine §EJi§3©§;§"i§4% 5SV'§:3.i§§i£ 321% may siseagffi be ékeié £5 5;} $$:vé3.,._Ef 33:3 §§§i§Q§'%%E'§ have :29? aafizggieéf aha '§":~:2:;:'§:%,$ i%::%;.:;§§g"':§;s§$3%$$é@s§ $3 §'°§3%E'E§§§-G'sfS%' ia mm: Ehezzw 'if§"%§ §e"§:%':%7::w:3E§:':3 a%':{:§:§%'§ %% pamégizga. .. '2=":;':'§-':" §h% afigxsa §§$§€:;a§@:'2$ zrggéé ggéiésgzg géaiézi T.«Lg;%%g:;3aé5e§ gs '§"%°°:s imgzagfsgé mfg; éaieé €§,§é.2§':2 3% " " §iE:*:T:3§x:;fa»~?§:§ gfigfififié $3; 'iiha §§§a'§g $G§"fi%"¥'§§$$%Q§"E§§'} §<§§;:a§3 :?é.:
siaaég gzsasheé, "fizs Sepzzéy ¥§§€3?Q§"§'E§SS§G§E$§' aiaafi hear 393% §ei§:%a:zes°3 agrsaf féaeraafiegx iaéée 3 éecéeéciz Er: Ehe {z;:a§'£'a_§*-if: acss§§a:::.::e wiéh iaw $2 the fighét sf the €~;b$e€x%a--%i§§§7s?' :i§::~aé§..._ . $L3§'.'3§'§.
Kmé