Karnataka High Court
Harijana Seva Sangha (Reg) vs State Of Karnataka on 21 October, 2011
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
E
EEKE YHE %§ES%°% CCRERT Q?' §<;5;Q§'»§§C%°}%E<A Q? §;&§'=éS&L$§;E
§3m"§$= wig 'mg 225*" am' SF GC"§"€38ER,. 20::
§§?QRE
"mg E-%Q§\§"§LE Ma ELESTICE ASHGK 3,. H:§x:{:H::::;j:§: * "
WEE"? PETETEGN §~m92g523«28§;?ei,;2{::c C' B §§?2;"':': ;
§E3"J'€EE§'%§:
E
aw"
HARIEANA ggxza SANSHA (REGj: ;
3??-Gfi§s,:'EMAT"§; gm §:.QC;<f "
R&}A3EE'x§AGAR, BéN§A;QR§ ~ 353
RE? 3%' ITS ?RESE§ENT, .
SHRE M.S.§§i§E'§§VASAN. " '
§HRI?f§3$.SR1E'*éEv£§S'_?3.§'é§ V
3/Q awe SAQA §>;z:';%;g;:-an g
AGES ABOi_}_T 3"6,{:~ % N %
3"' BL@C§r'»i, R;;;.;a,;,:MA':;;2R;~~,_"-
BANGALGRE _~ 5§%a:21'%:::~::.;..ha'.» _
Sfv'§"¥"."E"H;iXE'«§$;3x--¥¥f'§£U'éi["~
we §H:KHAM';»:m§:f
Agm $a_;§B5Gi3"§" 59," .4 _
" :;'2}i?¢E2%_?°~£?§;§RL ».G;;5§§'~§E'§?E*§E':§'é*§é'G;i;R;
-§A§\s's3;aL@§;i:_~ _§i{::;: 66%,
3%-%:"s2_:""%"'a:§}£;A: Té;f~::M:'>:;';;',%""'
S/£3 :-%j§?;i,§Ev%_g:;,; =
aggg fiagC~--:;?>-£4;
'<..E*é:":;.2i5; f"":£§.@S$, §-%R8§; i§.'2r'Gi,§'§;
32*? ~:ez:§.$:;<%,;" 3%: ?a~é@%zm$ ":r@;r::m msa
' ..K§;L"%$:§%§'§§fi;<3;%Rf maggaagag ~ ;%§ $34.
f$1é--: R13 §'~;ffi1§£§R%§
-_ 14.43%" asmasagzsgzsw
gzgaa §z§@é£T $1;
';a2a,4:é; sv:$T1a;m:;--é mm,
E§'*sEBR,£'i§":E§«,$;i;§'?<3,, %§§"-a§Gi%é.G§;E -- 552% $335
F4
§.
Z-42
ST*'{§.§§§?E"§;*3i;
Wffi E'§;'3xRA'fAE"»I Sirfiffiigfvififl
A§EB £333? 25, §Mz&}{fv"iEPi.§§.,5;§'~'§;
§fi.E'\£3%"°§§§%§AGA§;§ B%€\§Gi%%_.GRE A 55% SQ?
§?*~'§"EI E'¢E;'3.L;3C¥5"E*%E,
WES SHEE<%%:5X§'V3fi§'\§L
;§GE§ ABGUT 23;
i,,,A}<f'w'§lPE_}RA§'fI; §AE'%E$i**%£§'~§&§£'%§;;
@&NGA§.fi§;E - 369 SS9
§M?.m:?HA,
wig aumgagasxaaa,
AGES Ami}? 29;
23? L:-«35, 3% CRGSS;
ggvawgmagmagaa,
BHASHYAMNAGARF
mmeamma & 553 92:"
S%£R:$R:m:v¢;$A&;;"_,. 4
§/Q §wA§e1Y%m"§';<.§A?;;*¢;--:;;:__ 3 "
AGE$ A8538"? 3?§v,,I;;_ _
m,3@3, :;;§><r«§;x;>uR§';'--..A ' '
§ANSH§f'~éA;ZIfls.F§,
§A%=é$;exmR§':.,§%§::;% 339.;
..:§m.v,r2.;;::mm F'-'L5;§_",;-H é ____
.V :,aai;'--<'.3 LATE 1?§'§w§§§--~m mg,
'i'%_GE;[i} --..as;Lax:'f:VL;*:f% 3% _
§a3::s.r:§;;<:% £2. $.Q§'«€E'%'§~_§.VL.U§%éj vizaaagf
§£:§'ékf"-3,!3;§..é"}?iE ;%%»j3§:s3 gm
%;:v:""§z $ "E'*-.3§§;~§'~5§A:_;}%,
...fj;~<.¥':f;5.§ mggggga mag}? 3?;
_ * ?é;;::';,@:;,L,..'_2; fiL@£:<_,
~.§*i§ §?§§R';"%f*d'§, €§R?§Rfifi'§'§C%§'a§ Q§,§é§{§"E§_S;
..§;§§<w3AE;$R§ ~ gas 39%
r§M?§§fi§RA§§,
'~..é;2l?,/fl €~*E£§RE..E@:'1x§'é,
gasw aggu? :23,
sssfiaisg, :5? "E" €i!3€®§S;
'5-
.w
9:
_,y..
I'
z2¥é2's?W§i'%32<.€<2:xa cxé \
1.4») 3% §'v'?&E§'\§ §«1§fi.D, m7'":*:%<E§2.§, EANGALQRE A $63 $54, ggvrgt §~«we3:;LA, %fi!,!Q §HfizE"€E<ARA, gage gmm 38;
339.193? ££?\§<§'vE.£a§%§?URE, GAQSHIEQAGAR, EANSALGRE » 555 gag;
SR: GQPE, S/S 3A¥A?,aL;
mm AEGU"? 3:, §\§e§2?S, M 3 CQLQNY;
MAGA§§R©AS, M BANGALQRE « 560 323, Sfvfi", wgrm RANE, -- _ V WES ?ARTHASAR§"§"§=*%3I, % meg A803? 42, Nmsfi, z:;&_.§z\£:§*§".§:é"£§é';=:§;,g*«§;:*.;? ' "
EAN€Ai§ R§ -';5fa<g;'L%9;;5;:..V , SR: M. E:_mA:.LA:, 3;/@ §v::;s\;§gw'::,_:»':*a,V A'$_EE?;%5§{;~U"?" 38, Aivigaama gzigrx/;_, ;*;?%9*« :=»:::-ms" RS513, _.3RD A <::%§@$:»a 8Ei[.E;f;:R'{ mag; G;"z.§\§AG;»'%2.§'\§';&iT:3?fl£E"<;';..§A§=»§$£%;i;§§i3RE ~ 55% 932, gm'; _:§.::¥"§r%{sf3r.,éj{.'g~s}éx::§ :>i::=;1, wig. '%£E.'3;fiC'2'E<fE'§"§*v?§__;5;E5§_g' ' Asgagaagg?
%;'Egfi¢2§X.:\g'E%'- :2*'57"?"' :.:;:?;§§§§ SE-*i;%f?;';~"{"E",¥%§ ?~§&.Q£R, §.;aE'~§<i,?v;4*:.§§R'E M gag 933:
L '.'$;';%§'.§£. ;;3;;£i§._.a§:§?'x;§:§{ " -ggga %i»<:;:§§~§: T ggzggeg gagu? 33;
'-._::.:ee.2§$_g E_A:é§v§fiaf2§:?E}§?:§, @§?w§~é::=§;:§,aR§ Efifififiififig M 35% aw, 2?}.
iii}:
fa) SR1 §,1fELU_;
SEQ §fi?E BE~§§'E§'v'§;f1a_§*é; AGED EKBQLFT $3, M53223, ifiK?'»'§§,f'«£}?E;£R£,, G&¥"s§§H£§%éA§AR,.
B;K?*§GAL.§R;E - 569 $89. §RE C%~§A?*~§DRA?x§;
SEG MUNESWAEVEY, ,$aGE® Afifiij? 43,.
§"é§gE§85 EDA Q%JARTER§; 85HARfi3{§"%*i1NAGA§;, §A§'\iG,fi.§_GRE M 35% S85. SRE §AGANE\§A?%i.
$/G KUWASWAMY, ASEE Afifiifé" 33, E'§o.Q§; 2"" Cmgg, 'ifEf¥§%<ATfi:RAE'*éC§&PU?i, ' MA:.LE§HwARAM_,«-«.«_ EANGALQREW Sésé €:;i;s;;3__, _ % SR1 s<..m$,f S,/{E §<,&3;-;A"~.s,a,'-- % mm Ag@:.,E":"w4;3', _ % _ V ?s§@.1§§,,3.{}T" MA:.r»§ Ram; gay: L...::7:§@::*2i, §'\;;a;9as'§,x§§»;:_m*gf@:;":"§ .V g;a§x:;§;aL4@§:;%;~': - "mg 3%. SR-E %é;i:§?:§§:§§§"s'*'§»¥§jg i.. 3;'{",f%'%.,é'x'"*§77;;' féfififk {??£}§Es3...§%Z, ggm ;§§®%._::':~"
$928,/'fig, @:~;;;'?a:¢§§;&g mgzxga, * §CR§§S-,_?si1L;é£jE §%_ET"§"§LE~§, 'sZ3;i§:§\é{§;5;i.§§%§ « Efifl §§3* J "%€§,;'§..§J?~i:%.._§€§~é;s::::;:.*~:'*v'A, ;e;2g«:;@7; 2"" ::»%;2:§@ ?;€%;3@§, "~--E«~éT%:F';%,5;.R Syssgég "»£'"€'fiiE§<fi.V&§_ * § S gégaazf B,£z;F'-é§A§3:'}RE » %$ 0% §.'%%§A'i§§é£%§«§E<;5R§'€%é£RT%»£§; 2&2' 7?.
-LA 3&1 "£"E§'*v'§§\*iE§@W$%, 3,79 fiflbfifi TE?v'E§'*!EE§GE,5DA; fi'a_{3E§ ABGEET $75, E'*4'€3.éf:§ 'v',&S;§gE*é"?H Ei,_$C§<f }s'§.Y;%FV'§;5s%"§AEm:, EA§XE$§LGRE ~ 56$ $833 S?V'§T,§EE"§"H3%, M, W/G E§E*i'Rf§'\£E'if:5s§AE'€_, EXGEB £833? 35;.
fxiayéi/'8,f§§ 7?" MAIN; W CRGSS, A mmgga BLSCK, MHALAXMI §._;&'{§i,3"E2 €\§§xNBI2\£Z LAYQUTF _ BANGALGRE - 36% S96:
SM*%:sAR@3mv:MA, 5 39/5: "rAMr~mAH SHETTYE» AGE$ A591}? 44; ~ ' _ L SWEMMENG mm, Q:;AR?ERg,= _ ' SASASHEVAE\§AGAR_,"g_ §ANGALGRE »-- $65;
SM?';fiLA:}\'EELU;*?.j., M M :z2;;@ LATE1vv.Mi3NI§v¥;§.fi'§3j; ' mm ABQ§.'5'*!f45,, ' ' 349.25, é~«§§R§3}i:,.§}§A .f$E%§E ;?;;.a;:x§;g~;:':-§A, §Av:Ma7§":e»§ fifiifi, ._5'"-§sLQ's:;<§ §§xE'§§;$i,§??;E - Eéfi G133, A"\§?§\::?;::;_x§¢2.¥:,«% 2,22£;1§'§efs.m:a:§g%';:a§;>.%i;sé., mag; ;:.§:_;a@u":".":a<*.;.:»:*{;; ' §=-=m.2:'=~:.%;",_ a.§§;é§ss;5,;:s?§z;Ff::;
{?£§?séBE'§£?§.;3;':'3¢§éR¥,,, 8;&?éGfi:§.,§§;E » fisssa Gag, :§;$u§xém%::;
"s"a1€i-;?E§.i2*..§3:,B7%Z}é°§"'§" :54;
--2'i':?.f§gS£fi gsmg, "'1%.s.s,.f3;§@~a; gm 3 "§~S¥{§§Ef ":;;@§a;»w_;;§;a;, Bé§*~§S&§..€§§E »~ 5% :m, §§'«=?§"E",§£é{,"}'§i§§iT;'3§E; Z~°"--§fCr §_fi"§§ ¥EL5:":'U§%飧"§; ms ' . -
MK?
34. W2 W3 .S/Q ififfii §'~'§E*:.}§'\§EY;fis§'i.;--» .V §%i3?E_D";5'a§C%?;§A"?' 48? '§+§32;,:jss§;:.Vm§:«9izAx%Mm:§@ua:; é AQEE égfiifi' $8;
§\§&QE,. 8E§%§§'~§€} ?QE.§CE QUfi2RT§R§; Lfi§><§VEI?§,ERfig, G.§J'~.E§?*§§N§RGfi.R, §éE'»J{§;%L§RE « 36$ GQ9.
$§v:"§:mm"HA 2»: 22 wzs ¥ELLApm mm A836? 2?}, §%§@,15Gf$i, 29?" A mam RAVI m\{@:,.E"5,. NANDENE LAYSUY, ' BQNGALSRE ~» 563 @§6, S¥'v€T.€SEE"E"%{A §V§€.,iRULE, WXQ E'~fEURfiE_L AGED A5323"; 44; _ m1";*1, ME.}€\%§SWAfv'§A?PA .:,;:axr©:.;,m. . 3:3 MADRAS €RQS$; §~£A§_Si§_R ' ' BANQALGRE -"$68 Q08. V g§vz"r,§z.;Gga.:~:*§z~«:1,;,/ ;:._§ W,/'G PRfi;B%%;&.%§ZA§'~"2}~€"a.f¥f\i;'~-v~7:-__ A AC5E$ Ag£i>¥i..:éf§§,f,5_., H _ ¥'~m.1§»8, é:1AT"'--S5'?§%_EE'T;-~.._ % HALSUR; a,2.§3s@AL€:§;E V.E5::'Lé.___§')'@f5', SR1 RA3_sf~,,.
G;a.;m%a>_:+;:::;§aj<:.;»§:2; ;ag.;§@aL@R§ »» gaa sag. $2: .a;::a%:3mz:.:?«§%;af';;é;vz; 3;;-*§ gmfa A_§%JBRfix§v%fil%\§E5 ,::1"--i33€3:.§§ &8;{}.éj"é" 4:; '3x§.§:.;3¢:=T,--.s§»"* 5 £R®SS; ggéézsm gvzziagemgiég mag, =<;$§;zi%;§s}:;a:@¥:f gasaggfiaaegg M gag $23, '"§f*{*§v'§f_fi§i7:4'§~i%.!$E"§s'§;S§""§§§'éE; "-$35!"? gafisgaggxa, ~...:a;s§$ iaasm 25;
$3,133, §_.;5%.§'i§'*'§§§'§§§.,§§.E_, §fi%§~.§$§~€;EE'~§fia§§1R, §§i§'€€£é§..§§;E + §§S 3%}? ' _: ~:'-{;.;;§-_ 'f_' ' 5 ; ;v ;.;;y.,; ¢!\,«'»'.,-N ;,«-.a.\-M -\.=.».',=;;:-,'= _ iii};
_.25.:/@ mriziawa, $559 ;::3*0;;*§"
€==§_s.»:§}6;--. 3 §?,E'«§§L:'L'3ifE;€i,'%§f§':'; §%;;%.aflE.%$»:§:~*e:;?;r;.":f.;V§,z;:§%v:~,fiééxéggaeaa - 5§§§?g. EERE ?%§GAL§F'\§€%§€E, WEQ fififiii.
£GE§ A508? 35;
§\.EQ,}3E, 3 C 255 §\Efig§§%R_, SHESH§DRE?L%F€A§'V§;
B:fi?:§G§%§.QRE - 56$ S263 S?%'§"¥lE'«*"§fi.F%£3UéA, W/3 ELAf\iG@VAE'~§, mm ASQUT 35;
;-~m.13;4, ?v°EA@ADZ R<::2<A3§ A CRGS3, ' gesgaamag, SANSALQRE A 555m23,".% gm 3 KUMAR, 31$ LEAYAPAL, mm A801}? 31; . _ _ V maawgf 3 RAIE..Wfi$:' QL;gRJ";*7ER.§,-, "
SANEHIREAGAR, EANGALGRE-T-w,_j55'Q'{§'sg;~;._ - SMT.i_fi~,}{MI,. _ Wm m;L§9?A,;"'.._"
AGEB Amy? 4'z:;A,3_, _ .
13?" CRGSS; SAD_A{SF§€'EV'£"€.A$-,§?<;-- ' EANGALQREA - S§Q'Q;8'£§._jj_ SE'v'§"E",§*v'§;&1:,§,A¥\/§§~«1}3¥X', - S:v3"rg"§:w§44:;flmaE.$'54&;':{%*:;TV ':;'%5f§ §'a:;*a,1:::A:éza§'é;s, g';';; g§-E3 ,s1.§C::E.'s* $5, '£=.%;:;.,§.E»T%§;-._LA><§'v'Eé§a§?駧%E; s:;s;':':;§§;+~:§_;§%;;éig&§R, §§:?&§{§;:.§_§RE ~ §§§3t mg. 9 "§f%«§'"§";'§;a::2:§EE":"§--§;:,; ~.:¢%;;@1 Rfifzfé, gzagg way? 23;
§'----E§,§§; E§"£§..}§§§3'<;s'~% C$i§§'«§"'2"} 46:.
% '°,i§3;A 5;g'i$*'§::§;a;;\«;,a;.§~ss:, '§:m.4§%{::2,V §"'¥'§é§§.§T§L'"3§E Qfififi, éfifififififiiif SESAR§%,§~E;3:£._E_§, 8A?%§§.§§Q§%E ~ 5623 Q?§§ SRE MijRU§;1§ié, 3,13 Aamaggaré, mm mam? 33, 349.335; E_A;><iMAE\§?ijRL §.fi;E\£D%w§ZE\Efi§»'k?;, 8AE'é§ALGRE »~ 5% 399* SR: guagw, S,/G 3fi:'YA?ALAE'\L mm @5533? 39, £259.33, 2% mega SAE'~£}AYGA§'éDHI%'\.€AGfixR_, SHESA§%~iR}fPURA§\"§, V gagxsmaaag ~ 568 $25, gm: Mumzyammég W/G SU€\JDARflé}_§ ' A353 A3e:.§f§j35,_ . ., N931; §_A:><'MAi':xs ;>.:.;fR.:, "
GANDHIN£'a_GAR-, _ ' 5A:\:s,&mRE::- 536i} :3V@?a>;_%'~V_ 39;: S RAVE;
§aGES Ajzgaéjf? 4:8; ., a£s2ip;:m:H;%;Rt;2;%f,%'g,£;a§V§;§:.a@k§ ~ 5% S23:
mg fsf:~€E;<;»é.é.§§j1':_ '$.59 C%~%'s9aLi.£;§v§i_-.%?Ti} % £43369 §a<>:§'"::_ $2?' " k '%.»o3EEXV§-¥V€§%§Ké$E-.)§§=:§'; ,f:~;;:s.%§a.:§>%%:§:§g{;fAa, * §:%?%'f§§':'§_.'3R§ » E68 @229 '" "g%.,%rsfi§i,.é;-:;:m"'§"é~§: izasgai %{éLfiC?E-'£1, ";£';~s;§§3 gagggéag? 3%; ~ asa38;:g; :2" amgg, ' gvmgggz §a@;:;:a, agaezggaasgg ~ 3% G23, La":
gm} ~11:
U») 54;
93 $§'~*'E;T£AYA§"H§;£,, my: fia8§7i}"§" 49;
wga Saavgpaiaxagfisf §\§9.§§; 15*" €RQ$§, §?P£'%""'{% @2959: Hazmsasaf BA¥\5§A%..§RE »« $63 388. $2.: vim' :<a;:»wzf Sic §fi£x1APA"§§-€£, mm ABGEEE" 4?;
N@,§3G--B, :4, *2'??? CRG§$; gm LAYGLST, mmmma, BA§\£GALQRE M $60 gm SR} $.Sfi;,RALfiF wzg §vEA£\§IKYfi\'\fELE}.Au§{, mm ABQLVE" 36, _j' M553, KazgsaNAM:;s5::*§f:-::"«--s;sz:7A%Ay_"
mm mm gA§x§§;<"?@§;::-g;--_V_ ' _ EANGALORE ~ ;3;.es:}1g;;;5.' A .. ' $92: §ga:r.;ESH_K'a'§2:A;R;., 1. Sm 9AM@iA--:3A--RA%s, " % AGES fiBQU'".€f3;<?§ ; % M3905; SUR§.§,«-..§f1i.ifisaZ§E;._ ' ESUTH £"s°mEE"§; g§":*:.n@m maagm, ~:2a$T§EV_%:%;g§::;;r\;V%, §AE'~§'G%:.L{?vRE » 553 £34? '::r%@*:;é;%:~§;;&:*%:.§3':»2sx2:;:;%iii, ':fi!f~£} :%s§~:_: §i;?%+~':;§«, _ AGES. §'§§Lf'%'"' ?%'?1 rm.:4;-S:»~§E€si~é.;ai%;:a§?%_;§;mvzy 4Eé§%.?€£§L{Z3R§E.1~ 5&9 gm. :' ' ':3-5%: 5%-,5: l%<L?;§'%r€»5§R3,.
":§;<i.*}.A E9'?-%;;VfE7§"é,§; §K$EE'j% gags? 33;
( "?2E::':.=.._E._E§°?, LAKE%€§&é?i}R§, ':2m:>:-;::%sm.g§;; §§«a§'%§§s"i*:§..§RE » 35$ Gfié, * §;a%*§'§:;@:s§:§;::5;a:, '?%'f§ §a§fi£"?§*-%fi%§"°w"E ELFES, §R§ER "§"E'§§ miitieners have gaugfit a wréi: Er: the nature Q? manéamug ta {he ;r%3§;9a;"z<§e:"':i @332 E9 grazzr: ates §§; €:--Ei2e geéfiianerg ag $22' éts Cammuniaaiimg fiateé 3.53.,_é;»,§;_i}§§~E ",_ {fi,:':s'"s%xe.z;'e~E}f;,..
2: Tése facig 0? £51? Case En méef arejiihafi tE*:j{v3 *f_§:"§§ is 5 sacéety :"e§§s;tere§ under t%ae_:S;§cie%E<9;$"V-Regégtkégkéfifé A;:;% E69 §§§ abgfactéves, intaraééa, a%é<; {a _pr'a§é**::<3 :t{%e*V':t§2:£3 Ewing £0§"§§§i§QfiS Q?' its members',i "§::art§¢uE_fi;*igz.__ §e3E;3s*2g%r:§ i',§ the Schafiuieé iasie. "Eng pjetitiangzj '?é_Qs.{ZV is é?fe.'--'«ét$ members, ii: Eg thgér casé t§ééi=V?.'?:e§?'V::'3.¥%éer§éa;~§_§e:.%w%és§é%rag near $am$§r'1g§ Tami; which §§ a*.s§ar'~: %€@'n.3$1e%f:"e3ifi"'~%..%§?t'@='§<ar3tee:"ava Siiaéiasm. may ghifzaé its €3a;*«.r§.;"§'*:s_:€:€ "%;',_}V§Es3g"»:"<T; éaajéfinagar, Bangaéera, gcmsiruéted gm:-éVEE "%*2:gf:§'----§mi£'vésam §;e:é%é' %§3§d§:2g '§§'E§§'€§{'§., "'E"hegi had flies? the reiéef Q? the ?'€§i§§§E"Ei$&EE$s"E Q? §:£§g5g§.%:éG§. aéieg: er the gram Q? 3&3 sites in their "e.'::«*ii::-j:2~§¢%;é§@§%. '?"§:gé'3~ wréi petéiéan game ia §a figgmeé am? am 'V 5:5: Tzéaa gammisssgfig sf {fie semém' ra§@ss*:5§:':§*"§ .Eéét§%é;'§v_§§§v$§ate §%':5% 3&5; éfiiendfi ifi §"€§L§§§%"§S& ihe G{j£é,§§§€§G§3 évaaiéfiyg, "§"%°s§ g::@:'e.z§a% gf thé S§§§ 336%.!" sf §§"%§§ ism":
T fééfiféi 5?':
'§§E"%§§§E§ Er; Eihe Emuiry, Eat; £2": ihe a§§e:"%£e @f any {3E'§&§§8E"i§€ as the Saéé mgsrt, E 53 mt gmwse is gs érzts ma Si.$§§§EE'§3fi§E§t_'§,_! 0:"
G§€E"E€§"§:'zi§$€ :3'? t%2& :'ep@:%,
18. "gm fififig Q?' jz/2st§c:e wouéé 3e met $3: my :E--A§1§'§G;é:§:§'§§" ' mega Qetitésng with a ééreatém Ea the r*e§ps'§»:'>:~ée:':t »:.;:j¢"£t§t_'_§§e ' Eatesiz sigma regert 9? the first §et:§i0:%7sgr1 _ASfiVcié%:g Reegégizrar sf S@::é@tE@s am mnsééer7iV?§§~V..<;aséA$" $12? 3:26 the defersca sf gri Kannagfi. am VAc):f:VVV}§§§.,?3r$M\/9-:wh%féfire En fi§S§$S$E€}E"é sf géie N53,: ta: 3 ':aVE<e 3 éecéséan an haw' ta ém§Eem§né:_'"%:s §:'fa r§E'e*;~* ;déA;V§::E§:'§- a:j: <f%'n:aineé Er: its Communécatimé, fiateé fhg time fgr aamgiyémg wizfe iizég 0r@e§E«§Veég.;E':%:' §TT:f§«{3;?A5§éfi'E'§b$4"fT7%:fi'€"E'E"'?C0éa'*;§»', :1, T%:;_@5§ §e:éVi;"§§%éV§L'*3r& a§§:':Ta'<9r;£V§;_§_;f:Ag,§x,: disgagefi $5; 535$ erfier aa Ea mam ;€§;;'i% t""3T: