N H Bheemsen S/O N S Hanumantha Rao vs Karnataka Food And Civil Supplies ... on 31 March, 2011

[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

N H Bheemsen S/O N S Hanumantha Rao vs Karnataka Food And Civil Supplies ... on 31 March, 2011

Bench: Anand Byrareddy

1. EN THE HEGH Comm' 0}? KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE:

EDATEEED THIS "m3 315%?' gm' OF' MARCH 20; ISEFOREZ THE HON'Bi,E,: MR. JUSTECE AN,;xN:> '£3*;*'Eé4:ig£?.E::3§I2:&' "

WRIT PE'I'1.T1ON N0. 20881 (3E' ?2ﬁO.E§A..'[S)4' « T W'iRI';{' PE"I'IT£ON N<§1F;2Q8S2/QCGSQ r Shri.NH.E3-I"1een353€'1': : V ; V. S /0 Shri: Ha11Lar;:1a:ht31.a,'I{2u:;,_f Aged .

Wozfigi 3:3 3é5};zr1;r;1"" Assi5i:_;1nt,§ Officzé of ffiae Manager [SL Kéajnmakziv wSvi'_;a'E;s:» Fojéjd __ a;:<1-«:1 Civil Supplies cg:«p;;;ra:;:;i:: . I,-imited, Katdiiﬁna aft} i , 'BSK 1,1. Stage? VBan;g211Crf3 ~» 5'80";f38'Ef3. ~ 8:11-ti, EKLS, '\"e1:fi'2ij :1 A l3fo.S--h:"£~.M.S, Sriraiwmag V' V , ";age:: 2i5=§._Ié;2,rs§ _ " -.F§fc5r'E%§vr1g;';2;S Se;r':i:>z" Asesis'{..:;::1€;; A E{2~;:f.:m,t.;:.E{a1 S%.a1€;@: Fczmd a.:1::£ V€7ix;?§5E Suppiiea: C0:"p{:erat,iGa1 Limited, E.'~$:;:=,__3§'8,' E, Mﬂiers-3 'Far1k Area, AA iﬁzirigﬁgziiikre «~» 568 052' ' Srzéz. S2?1r§_E211i:E12;:.Ei '%§£',:'<§ N2:.r:a§;a2.:12: B E: 23.21.; E

ix) Aged 4.8 }r<;x>;1:~$, Wcarkitag as S<mio':* i%$$iS{.£}IEt§ K211*':1at:ak21 State: F'c:><:3d arid Civiﬁ Suppiies C§0rpomiiic>11 I.imit<;%<:ig N0. E6/ 1, "Mme:-:23 Télilk, Arizez, Ba11gaE<3ré: M 560 052.

8112:' K3. Geethzi '\'?'\7,/c) Shri. H.V.Ch&1?1dI'E1Sh€?}1§E'1E1I;";4' A_g<:.ci 50 ye-221125.

Working as Seraier Asssieta11i'.. Karnamkza State Food é1.:iCi~...CiViE"' V Suppliess Co'§*p0rati0r1 Li:1?iz:i.£;é3Ci. No.16/1. Miiiers fifank Bem.gaEore M 560' ' Shri. '£".§\'E. \JiSh:.va_:1aV1Vfh_VV V S/0 TXR. N;;:1';--113aufi Sa.s*:;zj;V, Aged 43?_},fe.2§.?jrsg = \V0rki.-[jg "as: =S;~aa¥;-._;2:"<:ni_ V V Ka1*n21ta.1s;a ;Sta.t£-->' FV<i<:>.{i «anti Civii S':V1ppIi£%s§ r3:.i_r31<: __L--i.miteci; No',16,f 1_, Miiiéirsi'7§f;1;:11§:,A1"ea. Ba'r3.ggﬁorV<~: 4 560 052.

V ._§Shri. S, Shyamsaxrxdar

- '$850 BL. SL1bE)'ar:1ma1i21}1, . Ekged .45..years.

V _ 2 "W::rVk£rjg_ Senier ASSi$i;£;1'I"1I, " ..VVKéi;1*f':_:22t2*:1g:'e:V ;$t'21':'_:.¢:?e Feed and Cii-rﬁ S:1Vp.Vﬁ'£'£--§::5~;é C«:>:'pera'i:§(}n Limit:e{§¢ N-:51 3:6,?' L Miliers "I'an§<: Are:~;1§ ES2;g:'igaI<:r€ M 560 G52.

'Vfiﬁizri. §%&_gh:..:m:E:E'§ 8&3 RN' RR» E§h:aiz.%;, A§§e(.§ 4-5 ;.?§:a§:=.-2, S

10. K211'11.ate1k21 Siiam }?'ood and Civil Supplies C<)3'p0r21t:ic)31 Limited, N0. 18/ 1, Miiiers; Tazzilk. Ar€.e1., B-E1I1§5§a1{)1'€ -- 560 052.

Shri, MR. \Fe11kaH:21ci1a1a1:1, S/<3 Shri. M.V. Ra.db.akri:~3h:'1a Aged 50 yésam, -

Workling as S<e'nio1- Assistazm Kar'r:21t.é.ka Si:ai:<«:*. I?-'<)<)e:i and Civ;1 ' Suppiies Co1s'p<)rati0r1 I,.i1n_ited,"._ N<3.1€3/ 1, Miilers Tank Bangaiore W 560 G§2. L' ' Shri, G.N. R21ja1raA:"ﬁf--

S/0 Shri. KR. Naz'213%;i'nét-;3;ﬁ32*§, V' Aged 49 years, .

Wo'rking.; Selziciel" Ass1i=sf.-aji1~t}_ -- .._ Ke1r:1at:a§E:a F'.0C}dV and i*V§1' ' Supplies »C.0fpC1rat:iQn "L1__n"1_1i{;é:_g:i,,. ' , No. 1 6 /».1 '}'.ah{k ..Afé21, £3a:*:ga1.Qf:;:€ " 53:80 "

Sh:'i'_= LKRE. N'211§a3§'2:13'é1.»L.Ra0 S/0 I,2i'i:3_ S§'1'r'i--. K; '\!}imar1a, Rae 52 ye.-4:34 V \V§}3f'k.i'§I1.g as S'6E~1'"1'i<)r Assistant, A * .. _ E{a1*::e3.teﬂ<a State Food and Civﬁ _ . Vﬁgiggjiviéa _(_j,0z*p{>r21t,i0.r1 Liflliffffdg

----.V%N<:.'1_:3.,g iX!Eﬁ1ez"S "'§"'a:1k A3921? ' E33-:2-L.g;;;2:::::;':~e -- 553 $52. E' ' AA ' ~._W/0 Shri, M' Srihari, __5A_;_;;§e{E «$8 ysazzrg, Sztgé. CS. Pr'a:3az'1na Kuriiaré "~.?V<}rkir:§;' ass»; Semﬁr }X$$.i$'i,8;§'}ii$ E§2?::'.:'"::.:aé',2:,§»:z~2 8'a.2:.§;€;-2 Fezazi 2.1*:"1{.E iiiz.-FEE 5?

{,3

14. SL1pp1if;'S Cc31*'p<')1'a?;.i(3n Limited. No.16/' 1, MiHf;':1'S '.I'a.:r1k Area. Ba.I1g3.1ore M 560 (352.

12. Sh:-.1. Che1.I1cirash£aE<:2*1a1*.S S/0 S'E1.2mkar.R Aged 40 y<::arS.

Working as Junior Ass:=sista11t, Kamaiizika Stme FGQC1 and Cjivif' « Suppiies C<)rpc)rat.i.0;1 1",i.r11iie7€.1, N0.1§/ 1, Miliers Tank Area, Ba.ng§2110re ~+ 560 052. " ' .13. Smt. KM. Girijarnbikc D/0 Late K- Mudd~u:_ing«:=:ii;in Aged 48 years, ~ . * Working as Junior Assi3 t:1 :§t5 V . _ __ Ke1rnz:1i:21k21A:'3t.a.te. I7-"0'0d.fan{1..(:3iVi3 1 .V "

Suppiies ~' €.i:.1jp0re1t,io.t1 -1~Ji.rr:ité::1.;5' 2 _ N0. IE3/.«1 MiQ£i_e.rs'vT:17111ig..AIt_ﬁ:a; V I"321ngei10r§:¥_; 563 :

Smt. K. Jé1:,!::1'1::1kVS§'1ILI1 'i~.» W/(2 L:--,1te I)(3<:i_;iai;1h' _ 7 Aged. 4»Q.yea.rs,"' V '

4...}Vorkin.{§ S C'1ass-- i"\ﬁ'.. _ K2m;12it;ak2a,'"Stats Foadénd Civii '53}..1pV'pE5.¢Vs €3€;rp<}r21t,i_()n Limited, Na if:§_r/ 1', .]}}'I'--i1I<::"S~'2u1k Area"

Basgggggsm-e 4 E.::3s@"T::Q52, ;E3E:rL V. '*'y"ém1g{>pai " 1 é " S/'«:3 Vstizim: .§é§FéiF1T1Z1§1£L I A§_;;3:--3d V43' }-='€--:ar:'-3' "'Q%f<;.:*fki:2gg 22$ Jm1i(::':." £33;-E%é§§§%$€;€:1§'1'i1§ __ §i2iF'§'§;21'§,&§_§~':Ei S£,3."t.:;'*, E-'zmsi amd ifiviéi Supgaiiafs C<;:;"§3<>mt:i{3:': Lin21'§;E:(§. er?

Q I83 17,

18. 7J2 No.16,/' "E. Miiiersz-3 'E"az11<:; ;1X_1"e21. Bemgaicare ~ 580 052' Shri. S. PaI1d1.::"2.mg,§a S/0 Si). Sat.hye111z1r21y2u121, Aged :16 }f€E11.'£-3.

Work1:1gg as JuI11'OI' Assist.am_,.~~ Karnataka State Food 2111:? fljivii. ' S1,'l,p]I)1if;'.S Corpcuraticm {.imife£:i, No.16/1., M1116-trs "I"'3.'r1kV ' Bangalore -~ 560 052. .

Shri. 13.8. Eshexmaa S/0 Late Siddag21_:Q'g.a Aged 47 years, T , Working e1sJuni£)Ar_ ' V. Kar'nataka.,A State ;_F'00d* ;1:14d'«(3*iyii ' * Stipplieés Ce;i;pQre1'i:jc3ir1 "Li1'1:1ii._ec'1, " -

No. 16/'.1 Q     '
Béi':ig211Q};e.  A052"
Shri. S.V,--

S X 0 "}.;1t.<:2 ViSwé1:;}1.21fy,, Aged 4451 ' V» _{ Wm"k1'r1g' 'asg J uni:/)r Assisi.am, 'Ka;-rnaf;21ke1 St"aEé=é Food anti (fivﬂ Sn Carpzzgsration Limi3;eCi., " ' Ngm 5,z*1_, imliers Tank Arm L' 3.9.

'%..k%~Bg1::g;;xV1a;:e-- 588 052, S}'::_§j:.";:}:,1%,;L shimppa 535;?" igexte E\fi21}1zideV*21ppaL AA _.:'1'xg'r3ci 48 greeir-six __--'i?v"<:::r'k_i:1;_g 33 J1;.zn-my As;sist;a:ai:§ Keirrzeziaka f:3E:ai:::3 Fiiaemd am? Civii Supp.E£€:$ {":{>:'p::smt,i<>.n Li§"i}§iC¢2'3{,§§ E 6 1\§0.18/ E, Mgiiiers Tamk Area, Ba.ngg;2110rr-3. ~ 560 052.

Smii, Lf;';€3§aVE1E hi Bzézi W / :3 H. N21ge1.r.21j;

Agged 50 yejta-11%;, Working as J 1.1 13.10:' A$s'istemt,,

20. Karnat.ak.a S'E:;;.t<-:.é Food and Ci<g§}> Supplies Corporatjen L1'm_ii:€.ti, N::>.16/ 1, i\z'Ei11ers 'I'emk Ar<=:a,'-._ Bangalore. ~«~ 560 052, _ ' Smt. NI). Bharathri D/0 Late N. Dmadiala, Aged 41 years, V ¢ Werking as C.C.'I"';-- - "

21. Karnataka State "Food ajffzd Supplies ('}orporat.'i0':1.Li};1*1ii.E:d. ; «V V' " ' N0.1€>/ 3;", E9'§1§V1lers:=f1'21:1k'Afa:éei; .. _ Shxi M, C51fk&1§?:cirg1VS'}?'z€1§:h£114' _ " ' _ S/0 Laie SW1. Mad3.pp':_a,_ ~.,__ ' Aged 39 year':~:,_ * V » Working' CCTE

4..Ei21rnat.::r}£21 Eifgaiie 'E':>--<:)d am} Civii SL1§}}31iCS C-.Crrp"e:fati0n Lﬁniieeth VI"\'%Q; ,2' ,1, IXfIiE3:é:3i$""»3§;1ni< Are21.. Ba;:1ga;101°c. Q Shri. ?:.:r::_$}%<:€}t.ha1n§;1 <3 LA. £\r'§"2:.VEig'>;g1p}:>e:z, H A;:;§€ci 411 yczirsg 4_¥"'J¢rkirigg¢ as CCII 'E§T2m:::?:t.:1'§§2: Stzyée F{3{){i zmzi Civéi 7: .___Si,:p';;*>ii<;%;<s {Za:s:";::<):*at:'i<;«z": §_».i.E}.'ii§€:{§, .4 X E' 'z'v1§Eisi:r$ '§';mi«: z5'::*<;?=.23, £2 B2111g§e1.I<3r<9 -- 580 052.

Smt. Sw211":'1a HE-HEE11E1f.E121 W/0 J:;;1y2,mand§ Aged 41 years.

\?Vc)rking 86311301' Assist,::H1t.. Karnataka. Stem: Fcmci and Civil Supplies C0rp01*at.ion L71miteci, N0.16/ 1, Millers Tzmk Areta,

24. Bangaiore --~ 560 052. *

25. Shri. B. GLm£:1appa S/0 Baiappa, .

Aged 51 years, 'V Working as S<-znior Assisstaﬁt, Karnataka State: :P'.Qod a1*i{:i'CiviE"

Supplies C0rpc)rat_i{:'r: I;.:_im§t;s.;*.c"1';»._"vvM N0. 16/' 1, Millers '1'a1'I:k Area;

Bangalore a--. 5601052. if Smt. Shaiiajz-1.' D/()Than"i1"naI-ma; V Aged 52 * A % .

Worlgjng. as Se'.r'1i<_):' ;'\.5§'SiE3 '£El1Tit.

4.. Ka1r11ai;sé1ke1L'St.e1te Hand emd Civil .V Si1~1.)pI'ies €'oI'p"Q1'21ti()n Li1m'te.dg No. 16,?' 1, ..E:\/Ii.Ei£:=;f§ v'"E__'aI11<: Artie}; Banga:creé«.«5}a5sc;TLQ52, ' " 81151:. 'E'§t_i}EI1v_é';'§E1_V "2f\{"/ 0 Mg Ss:**iAz.1&'1{:?z1.

" ' * T48 ya3.eir5%;, ' Wjc>tki:'x-g§ £1-S Sen:i_:}r ASSiS"E'.£i.I1§)§ "'£r§21rV1":a--E.;1ii;a S'£;aE:e E'c.f2<3{i and Civii _ 'E%'v;;3é;>§E£3s €{}rpc2:"2::i,i€>n. Li:1:1i':,<-_-':{§, E**€s:.?:e--.-;E;%:2;' L 'EvEE§.k-::'s::2 '§'2?:§:E<: A;'s:2«:u :?

&

30. . 'gag?' fa-'we 'I:5a1nge1.1<):r<:=. ~» 580 052.

28, Smt. GA" Uma I}/0 (3:33. AswaI:'h,, Aged 48 yea.r:~2, Wo1"E<_i11g as Seniar Asssist,:+m'i:, Ke1rnat.ak.:3_ Stmxe Food and Civil Suppiie:-3 CQ:rp0ra'£.i<>n :[1i'{E.1i'3;E?.ﬁ.§.. N0. 16/ 1, Milli"-.1':~; 'T'a11}{ $37621, Bar1gaE01~e -- 560 052. "

29. D/0 SR. AL1rsang', Aged 49 years, Smt. Parvaihi Ikévi S. g Working as S€I1iQf 'ASSiSt.j3Tfﬂ;._ Karnataka Si:a1:.<3 F'(§Q-'ci &.r1%;1:FQi\}iL§:A_ ' Supplies CVQ1"p0r21t'i_V_cV>n-.Limi:::d;'=V ' .. -- N0.16fL.;M£i1€1I'S_T;E;1'1k;:'L1'tff8[,',_ ' "

Bailgetﬁcﬁre ~'5 8Q J Shri. L. S<fsriiéis;'3'1~:§:l:ha11'f:-I S/0 S. I,i1iga1ie1}1= V V ' Aged 44 ye:a~.rs,. _ V V. Workin.g as Sttigioif Assi"€f£2;nf.';.}. KarI1_a.i:.aka_ Stafe': Foad.'-a1'r4.:1 (Zivﬁ '.S;1pp1ies§{ C0rpc):raf;1'c=.u Limit:ed_, Gfil. fﬁix-'I'i~3L1r33"§; "i'aI1k";E%§r€:2L VE'3§2r1§;§a}ei;;"z:r., 5 "€352.

Sisri; V V 'V Sic) =S}<';.1ji$ ._ E£€;g"d:x Agjeci 44 jgeﬁéjgrsa " :'€'sFc3'r"§:i:1g a:::_Sen.i<3r Assis%;'i;a:':i:,, 4K:%§FE1&ii.21KE1 State Feed and Civié }fE~EuT;::;§E--i{*.:§ C§€3z';;~{):'aiL ism E,3§mit;€:d.

EI*€¢§. §€_*};' 1, Rfiiiiem 'E'21:3k Ar:-Ea, ._;%}3'a:»:rW:--;g2i§<3:*:=: W §5€} {$532. 3

32. 333'

84. 3 V' .ﬂ%;

9 Shfi. HJVE. Vijelya S/0 HS. 1\!.I1.zr21i3»'.

Aged 50 yeezrs, W0a'I:<.I'I1g as J'LiI1i{}1" ASSiSE'€iI'}ii. Karnatak.e1 Smtxa Fbod améi Civil Suppiiess C».::»:'p0rat:i{311 L;:n1it:e<£, No' 16/ 1, E\«'KiE1e3rs:-:. 'f:;1nk.Are:*.a, Barzggalere A 580 052. ._ Shri. B..Cn Babu S/0 Gopaiaiah, .4 Aged abotu 44 years, - _ Working as Senior Assis'{2:1_1t., _ Karxxateikei St21te,.--F<)c)d e;m;d..Ci\I'i§..L_ Supplies Corporzxétibn EgiI11:_.i£:'_éC3..,_ No-18/' 1 g Miliers Teifik »,réaV, Banggaiorej 560 ' Sm.

W/0 _ V §V6%*k£z1g{f,21s ifjéiiicjr;PxssiSfé1¥1L K,,ar:.;aiak€a, 'S_t.éa:e' ' }:*.'_(3':3-:31 and Civil Suppiii.e:~s -C0'1ﬂp01*at,_i:€;>n Limited, Na. 1'-6/*3 , E\kIi11€1fs»--'1' ﬁnk Argia, V .Bangéi_ir:n*<: Va ';36()_ 052.

"S;:;:m;. "Arunaé }'r'21sanna Wféy Remlkaiah, 2 V = _3?_'g:e1rsg

-.,'\;x?a:;~'_:;;s%::g;; sci};

Ka..;<z1_:é3;ft21i<.21 State. Faaai emd Civil " Sﬁppiiecss C:>:'pG':'a€:io:: L-ifE1i'i.iEfd, }T\?§_);j'i6f 1, Mills-gm; 'i'a:r1k Sed Areez, A' Baxllgeziaxre # 588 052.

Shré. M. La.§§se;E1.;*1:a::2':

S19 La£::é §VZ1.::T1%2¢:§3g3a§ 5 3?' Agaci 42 years, Working as Gr*eup~D, Karnataka State Food and Civil Supp1:ieS Carparation £JEmit€(i§ No. 15/ 1, Millers Tank Bed Area.

Bangalore --~ 588 052.

Shri. 8. Lawrence S-/'<3 Late P. Sarnpangi, Aged 43 yeays, Werkjng as C}1'0u»~D, V, _ ._ = Karnaiaka State F0-Gd Civil' ._ V Supplies Ccrporation Liifiitéd, ' N::>.16/ 1., Miliarsank Bed }%..ré3L, Bangaiertit -~ 58$ .93-2. '"«.,..PETi'I"IONERS L ' ' * COMMON (By Shri. Ki V' V' Karma? .C'ivi1 Suppﬁes C,(:.rrpo_fat_i€>n 3-;imited§ N0. 143,/*1? Miilérs»-Tank Bed Area I .'BaI1ga}.o:'e '"3: 2360 05.26 .. « Rejgrrsseratedv by A its " V --- E\s'1.ane"tg;'ng Dii*'é{':t0r. 'V V Eéithna Kumar ;%g€:d3"L:§4;lT:=§z€a3'$, A Wgrkitgg as Ju:1.§@r Assigianta, Kmfnaiaka State Fae-é and Civii $':.1;'jpi:'.es Cargaration Limiteéﬁ » ' ..,_Na. 18; 1% Mﬁiers Tank Beﬁ Areau ' -- Bangalere -- 5&8 652% ii Smt. Giory R0:-;aEi1'1e:ia Aged 50 yezirs.

'Wc>1*1«:i1'1g as J1.::1i0r Asss3isi.a.n"£., KE1I'I1E1'§2ik21 Si',at_<:~. E<'<>0<:i and Civii Suppiies Corporation Linaited, N0. 16/ 1, 1\/'Ii1£e:"$ 'I.':«:1nk Bed Area. B2mga1m"°e ~ 580 G52.

Shri. B.H. Ami Irﬁumar, Majegr, _ » Former Ir1c:h_arge E\/1an:«.1gir1g 'E)iré{::1";<3r, The Kaxfneztaka St.a1:e Food eurici Civil Supplies Corporation i.i_If:ij;€ci, V . No.16/1, Millers Tank Beziﬂrea, "

B2mg:;11ore m~ 550 052. _ '..'RE2SAP(_)5NI)EN'l'S V % _' ::~sw,P.No.20881 /2005 {By Shri, HM. Mura11d}'3.g11. _VAdv'k:3<:atI€: __§(>1' Sree Ranga Associates for '1..:;>--Shri.« E3ay21nand S. Patiig Advocemzr for 2Res;:p.0ndé1_1t:€NC).2' a_f1d*3,..w--Sh1'i. BB. Bajentri, Advocate fQI'R€_S}3.0--¥ﬁCi€§T}i___N'Q.4) » AND:

1<{:.mi":;:j_:-aka VE-'*7dc)c'§ i=rs1(i= CTEVEE V .S1,1pp1i'<;\.<§VC:1r"p0ita.1;ibn Lim i1'ied., ..N0';1€:3/ E; "Mi11ers: 'i'a1'1k Bed Area, % é '8ar1.g'e>.1Qr£3 -'5'60 052.

" '~ Rep.:fe$_é':af£',é3d by its aggigg-1 g_i.~{)i1"(»3«::£:()r. A s::;«:, §.'T:%1§A;::: Kumar. E.A_.Sa. 1%/{"a.;§:;::', fbrmc%rin~»c:}1a"-wge Me1:1z:g§n;3; E)i:"€c%:<3r., K;a.1*11.21t21ka 8"€.a,t<;=: Faitrd and Civii A ~._SuppI§e:$ Cc>rp0r2u:i<3n Li:1:1i'{':£3d, "£'~>Eo, E8/.13 1'v'£i'lE€*r':%s Tzagaéi Bed; .e."3:\E'E?:'«:3;¢. _E3a:"_x_gai<"3r€: -- 568 852, Shri. P1"E1.k&1Sh.B. BI ﬁ%(Ti ric:ian

4. Shri. SE1_iv2::k'1.:n'12.1r.K3,? El1<;t:::€:ricia1'1 Shari Nziraiyexria Swazny E»/L I\:'_I21c11in€ Opi:mt.(}1- ._ Q3 6; Shri Sridhar V Me1<:hine Operator

7. Shri 2'./Iz1:1jL1r1ai:}1 "Fl. MaChim'S1;.

8. Shri K1"EE5»h1'i2*l ML1fi.E1;n M21<:11iI1e Ope;:at01j_. ' 9, Shri b Machii3c"'O1;;}¢'re1Ear, " A _ (Rééép0:1.:€ieI11":3; "3 iv. am: éiii' 'rnaj0rs.§ C__;'<),._i.he :"i':.js;:«t_V i'<3Sp«o{1::1g:r1t,f, Ba;1ge1_1<)re>52) " ' ' °;..._fR.ESPGNDEN7I'S IN WP20882/O5 (By _ _S?<1'1:':4i_"; P1.."ad'€,e'p'°' S,Sem.r}<,a.r', Ad"v0c21tc-3 fm"

M/'$.._%S::n.ri21:rs\3:2:z131y Ramdzlg and Anarlci. AdVOC'.E1'€,€S for 'V'~.Reg.pE31'}:.dr::M1'::A. N01': """ '"ShrL B.21_jen'tr:i, Ad\:c><:ate for ,R<::spo1f;de31:;--1.< 3;'~J<3.2; Shri. '£).:1ya1aaI1::i S. Pafgii, Advecate far _R£;spt>r;d¢~::.1»té "{;.~:} 9) >3=aT<5!¢==!=$ ffE'3€S:Ef"'J«-Tii. p€E{,§{.i()}'§S gm: fiisd 1.:rad:;%:" Ari:ic.Eé.:'2$ 2261 mid ._ ~»2i2;/? (:{§_f£"'L':e C<>z1si:itu%,i{:«':1 of India pE'{:1},fiﬁg to {:33} {:3}: the f.,:3i';'i'i--rf;% 1"f;"'tET'.(}I'dS reI21t.3'_:1g €13 c<m(:er£3iI1g and {','f{}¥H1f:',{7i'.{':€§ with _ :%::":pug:1<3r.{i order daiied 2'?.€}€;%.2;@G5 anti §Sm&%,2005 " r{§s§:>e<t§'ii»-*€i§; °s,.="§<:%e A:'mex1.:re~A ii-i-;£=?;1.Ei:?€§ E33" *a:.he 'E"{}u.:"%;E1 <L>"% ......,.

'.43 Re>.s9,p(31'1d<%2'1t'. in \?VP.\7<>,2O88'§. /{)5 and Sf;'.C(}I'1d 1*esp:)mi€11i. in VV,P'Z\%R:). 28882/'O5 21:16 9110., '£'h:=,£~:;e Wriéﬁ: Pct_i_i:i01'1s {forming on far }~E&2;1"ia'1;:;"~i§j_'is~3 dV21yn i:}1€: C01.u'i: Iﬁéldﬁf 81%: fc>.i.h:>wi:':g: W ' » " . O R 1) E R 'I'h<-:36 petiiiicms are fiied c:VfT::Eiii'r;:n_;__§i1*jg _s:si§Tm'fj,_:-1:9v<i1*d€:rs ' and hence are heatd and disp0E»ed----_{>f t'o'g«.::t1~1.r:r. <:10H1m0n Qrcicar,

2. The peE.iti:;»I1c:1's _:'<;215r3;3.ioyee$'vofv the first r<3sp0r1_der1t:--Karllatzika -- V . F06dV5' 23, 1*1d"_» Civil Suppiies C0rpora'ti'O:1_§Li.mii'.E%:Li--. 'Er, ihé;i:;"g1*iev2:11(:e t.hai: in the first of p<3tit§of1:€f;'~:i¢sp6::f1_d<:%riis 3 and 4 and I'€3Sp011d{:'I1i".S 3 to 9 in 3:316 ~se<ft:'1'1i:?. <33" petitions were apprzantices under .tr21i.nihg; amt} t.}iey"1vc'rs:* \v01'king on daily wage basis' 3 " _'A'{'E1<5f€a1ft.L<:r .?,_;hey x%§*;:>:r--e;--«g:;);)c>ir1i,<:€i as J:.1ni<:u:" Ass3ist:2m'£:s in 31::

ﬁ;f5;<a**t.V £3? ., j_t'_1?g.e?;%<;:: ";;~:;%':.:i:§(}:'1s3 and 225:; mechzmicg in the". seiteaizd {Ff "i.T.%i:€':¥".'>._'3? }~ii<;:"£4'§~{;:{*;::ij&"" 'éxfhc:-treeis the p€:t,ii:i<)'r1er§5s xxsem r€g§u_§a3'iy 2*e{:;;i.mi§:§i~ this C<}rp0:':a{",£<3:1 mmth _pr'i0§' U} the £%.§}§}€}E2'~'3§.§§§<i?E'1i. :3? €:E"_:;<i% §;ra:.i{§ :*é;::s;g><.m{i§:'z2i.ss a-*m{E v::e:r¢;? 55=;€f§1i€}E'§:'~; in § E':1'1<3 cadre of j':,.11'1.i01' 2:1s5s::siSi'a1ai:ss ::u'1(i mz111y ('sf 1112311"; hax.-ﬁng £':E}{'.(*t1'€f1 £1110 the (:2-.-Mire: of $€fI11:i()i' assi:~3:'a1'1ts é:Z.1"(§f ;<.3e;?:.?i_1=i1g;' as $;u<'::k1. 1:~I{>wev<;1*1'. by an ord<;?r' C12-'imci 2'}'"'.8.2i'}O5 'U;u:i.-- giiag §f33i1'<:<:i'.<>r {Addii,i<3n2.1i iilxztzrgej of i.he §"i?.".S?-.'f.,"*1"f§$.}j{)if1iiéﬁiitg C();'p<>r:»:tj_c):'1 héld piaceci the 2~i§<:}re§:.21:(i '-IféS_p()1'i£i€E'i}ES;1. se11:§0'r asssisi.a:1t,s, with 1'e?t.2:'Os[3t%<ti,ii%:§ °c3f"fe<:t.';"' 'T711153 E12161 éi; (:asCad.i.11g; @f1'ec:{. 0f driving t.1i'£=:. r21V:1}i t_'>i _€.h'e p}ei4i£,io:1e:rs. I1't'L1C}'1 betiow t.h<;.3m 21.11€i'*«.i,f:.cjre:by;_dt:f1~ie::1"iileir se'r1.i<}1'i1iy. It is this, which is the <::<}Inm--o:.1 grive-Vfc:z1{:é'»()f"i.11é pet,:i1:i(>ners( 3, 'I'7h.(~? 1.£§é1'r_13céd« <§c.\p1;'1$.c:Ff f{)1° iif£€ pet§t:i0I1crs wouid sgczek $1_.;t;St:é1téi:i_aii:% _t,'I°:._c§'in'3;us§;€.ic<:: (.':£:§.i.1Eé:'~€;",C1 by virtue of i:.h<:*. iII1pl1§_§I"i€Ci" r.)rL'3c1'és' 211113 wépzld seek app};'0pI*iat,e; dire(:1:ions ti) £110..«f§§3:%pm1<:ierit';s2:.. :0 ::j<é:<'t:§.fy the axmmaiyn E"I<}wex-=:3r, the »i€§;1:'I1§n:§V <:::):;z1jiS€;%__3 fbr {he m:~3p011dez1t:3 wmild stzbnzit thaég the sé:f5_:4:2'%.:?.e v{éd.%':--(i i,%'.§t>::s:s <3? t.E:€: r::§:':§>i<>\;r;;%{:s§ :3? {E33 §'€;':::~E~§()I'E€§f;*f1f1§'.-- C<}rp0.r2§3éi:):': 211% g<}w3:°rT:e%c§ by §':h<;':= (,'::<:>w;%:"r":;az?s<:%;'1i'. E33/rvzmts ..f_' ~§3C.1':i:j:%:.ssi.ii<:e;aM{ion and ('i{:sm".r{31f2 A'ppeaE 'RuEes.3 whiitiz Exam-*=3 ':_5§;«::<;%:": ;.:{i«:>g}%€:<§ E3}; iihéif {f<.>:'p<}r2:a:':§.{>fz': zimii in Egzrmg {:5 Rméé? ES}; gfx 2.111 appttal wtmlci he in the c:.21se ziyf {hi-3-r re,$p<T}1'1(ie'r1i:--

C0rpora':',i0n§ to Ekae: B:i>21:<*ci of Ij)i1'ec:;01"s 01' ﬁche respV=j3.if:r:iez"1t.-- C(_)Ifp{)E'Eli.i(}I1. 'i'h::% o'1"cier in'1p'L.;gned h.2m:ir1g§ }{I>£",€;',TZ'i~'~}§f'c"5V~'€§::§:"'cL'V.§L"§ b.jg the Mau'121gi11§" Direc"s,oz'[Adciiiicanai Ch21:rge1V._.,i'ii'--».iS-gipcézz f'£:.*..{ {he pf-2titi<;>r1.<3.rs to que$t.ir32'1 {I516 :§3211n_<: $3,?"._1'é¢t:suf$e,__td.,,ai.1 appeai before the Boarci of _}j)ire,C'i.r)r'.s:. "E7}'1*c ]ﬁ)e3t,it:ig:)1i<;:;'S'. having»; ap_pmach<:%d this. C(3ur':: L'\;'>v*..rjL'1Ec_i t,he':~':>f{)"r€: cnaerride the 2mf,h0r:ity" of the C:.";f}3()r6i:t.iQ:1 "i;'.1» dee1Ii11g witih the contreversy and AJ,[hCI'€f()_IT(?, 'VVC)I,i1Civ._S[i}:31T1;1'f{. fﬁE13; {ha pei'.iti<;>ns be dismisscédai: t§ﬁ%eé_i.h:*£:sF;Quid, = 4;__ ._The"E23gtfmfd"~<';é's;.:1'1sei for ihfj p<et,ii:im1ers; an the other hax1G"f,_ woulif _S'L1bmii; that t;f1(«:s<2: pf31;;iti0r1s having been on E;,T:3}§3 B{:21rd <31' €:..his Cvzmrt. for '£23.16 pa:-"st: six }_ﬁ'(f'c"£I'E°3? it would bééz _'€.1'£iV\r:;%§3'i_E}{&"Uf ja.1st,i<:e, if '£:;h<--: p£;*;f:,iti£>r:erS are :"eieg2u:ed iii} 21.1;.':%;pp§::£."L:-. 'bjé-3vf"{}:*::: the» Baard zmd the 2~e&;u1€' bcizag Q pre<iii:7,*;.;:bEé::{ i,E";;'% {?:;1;%? of $.21? pt3€;Ei;§c)':1er$ rifszly be <:<3:':&;idsrs:é.

%,l';.is Co:,1.:"'{. 2-mg} appm;3ri21i:e {>:°€i€r's be gazxssasézci. '§'h.ere is g if:

110 bar or pmhibitiotz {car this: C(}1.iI'E. to €X€I°(2iS€ p<:w'e1' under 1«\rt,i<:Ees 22653 and 22'? of the C<);'1sst.i¥;.1,1'i:.i<):'1 sf I{i9c;*--.i.;<1.

5. F"3{e:}\,-W;',\1=-'f;':f, SiI1(?€3 the g2;riev21_:1.r:€jv » _' ' ~ €:;~.r>i;:§d app1"c)pri21t:e.1}; be {:<:~r1sidez*<:£i by the Baarci, 11_(§t:1,:it1?i5;€.2i1':dig 9 ' the effims: of times, t:h<3: pet',ii;i<>1'1s1; a1'e._ 4€ii.s§>§)séci.__:(ﬁjvfitfhstit.

prejudic:<-3 to fix: <:011te11ti0I1s:Qf i:he*-}3é1"i.i.i(31'1<2i5z;i2vhic:h f:.'i"1(-iya may raise by way of an z1;3pe2i3<.b<3for€ £'.1r:e C<irpo':at.i0n. and the iraordirxeite cicslay i1':..4_ﬁ1.ing.'Vt11§~:;ij:e_}j;vev:§;*1«.iS expiairaed by the fad. that; {the pe1 it'i0n<:rg_ p$\}<:1f<«:ﬁ IV:V>€3if(3r*'<é%'~v§t.:'1'1'i..='e;_.Cm,1rt in the first instance 3.I1d fit. ;;1t _t'i*.1is_4p.c3ii1f'0f"tin1e tilt? pf:¥:,ii:ion is t;ak£:::1 igip ._'f«.:;r Vi'.i'f3g;1__21*n{i t11eref()1'c;n t.}.'1_c3r°e is no fault on the ggsaizrft, of H16 4'_pe{;£tfi§:':1ers in 5-sé-:el<;iI1g to pursue iheir _ re::n:§§1y,?'~'i'he E5"e:2.a;fci 3312131 {:0'r:1s£dr3r their ap;)er.21.1, if such an »:~i;5';;~r;év21.1..é:r~,:.%:{"%.1Vé:Es:i__by the pe't,i£.i0:1s:%r's zmdg t:hé--3 $211316 may be ciaifaﬁw'ii.1:- '§j:i1Vg<i<:<:r=;i.21.:1<:=::>: with Eznv. '"i'he: §5ef;.E%.i9z1erS SE2:/31L if {hey gzréﬁzi irlctiima-d fiie an appeai within i'E'f*{,<§e":"_3 rzlayss {mm V~ W;'h€L"d'21t.€ {Ef :'es::eip€; 0f 2: ::er'i.ifi€<§ c<:»py 0%" i;%1is.; £}I'€i€I"1 '£'h§:

<>};*e:i@z* 0%' s2=;§'.a1£::T:&§~<§u€; g§ram§.<:2{E Ezey 'z,_'£";:;::«; iimgri sshaéi <:0:.1i.§:_'2:.:@ 3 iii} :~:;uCh '$116: i':.k1e i3<')2;3.r<i is: in 2:: pi}:-sii:i<31'1 {.0 {3()E'.1Si{._1€1' thezé 2-xppeeai fiIe:c1 by the pe:i.iti=:me:rs_ *a}b/~.

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

Karnataka High Court