Karnataka High Court
M/S Ngef Limited Byappanahalli vs Regional Director Esi Corporation on 12 September, 2008
Author: Manjula Chellur
Bench: Manjula Chellur
1" A "§'§:":ng§;i9re-5éfi@ {$23.
:3 "gm; §~§:€;§ {.'{}E,?§%§'§' ms §;:a§:x;a?i%§{ga., ggég:§a;{;.a;;_:%5%:§§.§i:§§§ : [ ii _ §::'§§::> "E'§§§i% mg; 12m M';-;' GE $§:%?*§g:§§§§§:§: .: H §RE§E§T V aAV%x% mi; %§{3?*é'EL§<Z EEERSE J!;TS'"§'I{fEi{:}§§f§¥§;§;5'§<;'v ggsm mg 1~§9Z'€'§§&Z ':%i§% e§'§fS"i';§:{f'§§".:§.§i;§?g5§'€§§§%§;&}?{_TE2;;E K E§wYEE§ % _ A ?§§?§.§.{§§EL§{..§_;i§§%§€éé_;
Eyagpanaiaaiiiq, T' " .,
§a:2ga§@re~;'§a§{§ 83%,. _ _
§€;£§3r€$£§ii£+s:§ $3; iii; {f«:s12g§a'{§§2_ _
§§§=s:r£§a:"§* & §§r€§i%?iI§"$§ ,?§§§§1:ag:?;.*; _
M " s§§?i%:§.;L»§_?€E'
& §§'f§*é%§3§§§i.:§§'§ ..%§%'s.)
__ " V 'E2~ Régit'-,§;_§§fi§ %§§§§*§%§%§:§:;
" T ESE €fif§=€?E'3§.§{§§§§ V
" " -« :;.Z%{§§ §§§§?§§?£§§'§§§§§9
}§a;;'gsa§é1'*3e.$é{§ 323$
' ' ' ~ Z; r §ii~§{§%9é €32' $§§":€:€§;
' '§§§§i_.{jf€7}:*p0ra§§§§2§
?€£:,}€§§ Eégiiagy §<'§£§g§§.;
§?;§i§§§{§?§§§'Z:"€'§7$
{8}} fiffifiififiifi fieéia S'), ;%§§*§»:.}
/
1
EM
1
sszbgect :9 {he n1an::sg£¥§:s_e2;¥i $9 §§:%;§§£ an !}}}£i$'I'£&§§§%}§ §'§':::=§~2: ' era 19$-'€s§ wha "a%-"fie £'.{§'§«'"£¥"€§ uzzéer this Sehemfi is; £§'w~*-ir§?é€%§.--.%"§é::§§ ~ flag» 33313192: 9%' c§:2$z'i§::f§a.§z §%"§§E 59 :*€é:{:*§-ferefi in €ffa§;s:'{%":1'§:%.{.%§§%s23*§§2f; gsréer ig s»'a£:;§€€£¥ $33; €.E1§,=~ Eiigk Ci}ifi"'£.. {:?'%£§3:s'§:ie§y §§';.;?§;§%i; «§£y3v'?}'?;7T.A £!1ei3;££r§;z*s: giay grams fa E39 s:2:z*:m%£§.._ I 'E.-:§e331$§"22i§2, iaiig iéviéizwsrazge setglggzzent same ta be E§'§i§3'§'€£§ w§;£_.§.2 jjiizas fifrszcie "§;7--2::i§{3z:;_.Cb§: fine ap;3£%§an.t~$5i3§3§§s§23a1£n% s3:1 '§{%.§.. ;¥'€i:i§i"35:g..£}1:%_&J¥3ges at' the €3i1}}§{3§£3£$ with 2*e£§f§3§;§}g¢:£.i¥§e"'ie*'§3§<e£4§; ' 38 A N::iéi_£f$.;::§,f§g:§£.2ié"'§:a:a Eséfiér Eérsg;-«{§'--ES 53; figs {'arp§§i§¥i;?Ea§§§' far the yerigsfi sawfilgsg fmm. m,9é=:g; :§*:?,9¢9';7V'.'§aia;;§fi{}#b§V§:1??§:£} i'§ii;j';?€1'{§ RsH53%?§g;g;2 3; 3-gigs? am $932!' $3' $322? §§§%§§3i§§. 'af*€:%§;££:§:& fimfi by 3-'Erma Q?' figs $@i:€§ez§':£s§*§§§ $§?E;:%g°€V"Lré%=i:éEaié;z"é'sf samgsgé '$3933 e§'£'a2§.%%£a"§e, E«'i{}§§§;€ iéf §%§s €*.§'§3§Z§{f%§"€'€§ iéasvé ggtsiéfé v.§f::::t.v{§§ fi3.§1.:~*§@a:e:*age- ea?' EZEEE. "§'§ze'§*$§'§2*§a, §"§'§§§' :§§§§§§?%§ §i.%§§ " {."s3es~}3€;aefg§i{:2;'§' '€§LA.é$§%%2§§ra§s' €229 éegaaaéa "§%:€ Efii {T§}§*§~9§*a§§{;§:
" Sééifi ii; izgsre "§;:*@€§es:§.e{§ ifi §§§%§i? §?;§m%"e2*:g fiigéige fiiaiimégigtg iéw ) '":2;é2%aa:;:f3§§i..zA§:3 g§:&§iii};: §}'§{f§§i§§§§g the égzierfigi §2;§; fig m*§m* zéaéaé '§'%;@ {fT€:;*§§2*3i.§i;§3 i§§f{¥§"§¥%£B€§ €119 3§§€'§§3§§§ £,%:a§. Eézgs " é:g_;';'§tir§¥;aiZi{;§2 has €13 he paiii GE} figs {*.::§':a.'2:£*e§ §"3§{:'3 fif '§¥:§g§3s frééifi Ea§.§'? :1; 3§}.§{.§'?.,; 3:; $329 wage wfiiegnsggé é'3§EE€* igzig} ffirss frag:
fig}-= §§ away»; f§ii'%'§§£*§" §1§§€§§"3"§§€é %2:§£ $29 giééé §*a%»<'§§%§;§: 9%"
%%';:g§=»§»: '%'%'§§§ ;»;§g§§*{;%'§=z§: kg £26 {.§€§"§-'€'§"§%§'§E€§§'£ §:;§; fig €§i'i§€"§"* 2§;§,§'?g 'E3212 ;«§§$§'§§&§¥?€ €'{§§E§§"§;%§E%i'§ $32 azzwggszig §'§*€;§:'*§"'§,:§gi3?:' QEEQEE'? :%§:§ §§§§':*@:§€%%§»g§ $2 ESE {.7{m§*% fa?
§*§%€s:}%'§a§*§' Z%?:§§i§::%§s iiéiéfii Eggéfifi. '§'§*w §':§§'§"{f£3§§E"E --¥gg/fig? é:;'wg:§§§1§2§.§§ZV§; %;"§§§: <:%§*:§§ fifié €§§{'.§.§§§7£€*§'§$é?%§'f§ €s%»*§§§>§3=:§% §z*a2€§;§,§§i&._:%':f: r§s:é:§%§§*~E§£E.:§ fig $3: iirzg {Saw e3§':§€a*£3§*2%§;§:g §mzs;%i§§§3.v_j€€':2~.f£§?§& $33.9 §e:%j§';:;§:§§é§§§§"'%1§2i §§*§a~ §;w:;§§:: égi' Z§»'§a}i 3%??? 33% §:;§f§; ifiai §_§§:i}§é~.§<{:%§:§:*§h§§%§'<3:";_§£;%'§%§ai §:;*s€¥ airaaaiy ;=;§.§:§§€fi $3; '§§%§?£§}:*$,-.§i:§§§§;a§§§'%§.§?§E,%i§§i43¥3 Qééiéiiiiéifii £3 fie gag éééi figs' §%2":£%As;§" pm*i§sv=.iv--§,§§.'é2£€«:::2:§§3:§:é %?'§'$,é:'%%:aE gmviga gs fésfiégga 2f{§}W§rf§§" J%_{%E5€'§ 3".§'§:'€.'§§é%§'§§'§;€§§'€§;°':;'§§§§§ 2%; ESE {;'z3:;§r%.§ §i*%:§ €{§§::§*§%:§§fié:a1'§ §_&%ies:€;;% §iz:§§g§i§§é'g«..¢§:§;:me:1€9€§ frag: §.é.:§"? ;§§'§.§ £3 wag é':éI}§3€i§§§i%'°af§ figé Ezgfi $:§__X §:§§§§£§i:§ §§s§'i€§é;§ §.§.,3 €§&§é§§§ §%§§§'?'L ..r ' V' ;%.,;:€£a'§fi§§€§;g§:§$ %§ r£§€£%.é:' '"'§'§i:é a;%*§§ii'§§€§"'§§$ egéi? §i%3;s:= ;§§§%§=§;¥;&§§§ iéfiggé féaaé. °:;§3.%*'g;£§'é.2§'5;a}§:§§%"';2§ ééiézé §§¥:§;§.€;§~€«é3;% was §T§§éifi§fQ£§§ "E3; §s=§§:%%-' agi' %§*:§:
mmi mt an 2§§§§'s3*§3.E $3? '§§'3.g{>: §*§%='§§§€}:§ 332$ figgg" gs gm? 9? fizés. ::{s%am*;;2%§§ 333%?' x iégrmmiiéxg ifi fig? :§$§é§§E:§2%Z"§ {:£}§§§E§-=$§§ §'§"§"§§."'§§ '$3? _:§$€§:§@:':'§.$:2¥ '%%'§§ gigfiaé 3&2 %§:§2§£§'§ %§ § figaziiggg §§=%%%§2§z§<§§:i. . '§g=:-iizéizg £§{%'ir%"§§ zsmas 3%' %.'%E§':§§§§}:§'§§§€§'§?.§ é§;:§§3§§-' §'§*~{§m flag? ;§;§}-g §§§&'. §§%€.§§:§§.§§2% §.'€%§"§§§?§ §§%§.§.'§ §§§§i°§'£ €§§&i*a%§e§°&., ii? §§:§"s§:*'§*§:§;§*:a% iiirzaé :=-zswmggs {;§'&a:*§§ §».§*§'g§§:3§*§~€ §;§;s§=:§ gag: fiiés gm%«;s$ §~sa:§4&s*§-' §§§§§ ii} %% as <1W~ flag %%'§<3§{%E% $3" :'2§:'='£§§§§"f§ $33-'3§§§§£% £5; §%:$ €§';"§§§§%}J€e:§§ Ea-*i§§2 §§%.3.§'?.e figs §f§}:i§§}£ 9%' i§§§3 $§§:g;§§;«}~'§ea»§ '%?%='{%§§'§ mgi aé' $%§%V:_§;%¥a*§'§g§;:% gag §'§'§€;" Wag? §a§?:2¥3E€ bemggze .§§§2';:*& %%;ga3§»..4§%§3§§«€§}:5¥' I.:f.:% V's;%§§:§§ §:;§:p§{;§e:=a>s§ Qize §"§:%§'§E¥Z gnaéée E}-' $§2e;Tv{:7@§;°'§@§~::;%?i{;§§ '£¥§"é.?§$ .§'§-9255. §:s$§f%§'§-es§.; % 1'%2::§ sésa i'fi§$§f'§ %'.%:e piezg af fa3:§%:*1<;?V§:a:§ a.r§*§§E§ »§,%é::%§;§a:2§é'a;§§j_;e' fez"
;;:z{;:*§ figaéz fiiigg §;a*&:*§ §mi§__:§§§;s} §1¥f:£ £2;5€%..§%:2§%E~-sié wag §€§i§:.:*§a§ :23 §§€'.§£ §:a3m§a§:§;
fig ag_5L§§§g'3=§:' §§:i3:.e; €§£':§é"§'§5£+é 't{;'{;=:w3e§. far 333;: Eifii §,"fi:;§'§§§*3.€%<}§§ §43,_§§§--§§§_§;_§ fig?' §'§%§2.' ';:.{fi¥§2:g§ §:§§=°é§§§=,;;§'% £3?' svzaggss 555-§§§%;§§.€§§ %:§£:@;§"§.£ §§";£*. €:*i§;¢3*g=*.§'gj:s;:_§§'3;%§:§:-§fé%¥:§§§{é§e; azé" %'§'i'ifi€$ §§.§§§§éE§§§- fa: iiéf Egg figs: gzzééfiégfi gf iii: €§§§:%':*§f§§§§.%§;§%§;~23§*'£:s§. Egg €}$%§::=.§* §§€§§&§§%g ;'§€;i"é£{%§'£§.§§'£§ iigzg E25312, §%?§;s§*:_ égsmé V§::%§"§;:'§:§§aé$§:":€:§% :3? ;2:%§§€:*§%2:i%@§: §§9§*'§€§§? m§2§§.:~;s; % "fig é"§'£§:§;'%.§§§§i %.§°:§: zsgai iéf iéfze a%@§;%;*§§:2%E~:;§ §€=;*§% E, EEQ §£'{%,%§§§§°§i§!E.'§ Egg §a=*: éigiaé f£%;§:'§%§§;j¥s;?e;&A:T'-3%; fig a+:%;%'€§*és.i§ §{§§." §i.$§ §"'§%f§§§?§'§'€3 if Egg §§':§§f=f§ €*§§€§£'i§_i% §§_?~;§:~I §§25%%§% 32% éézg §7§3§§€§§i* {sf §§§€3 €é§:§%.§'%%§:.:§%s:§:§ §€'§"§{%§,, 'A .4"'-.Vfi%:'r'§%§§?€§fié;€g-ééfi §"{'.§§£?S $33 §.§ Efiéfiis'-§} Egg? 3% gzafi ii} §§§'f{_§§_} §. §§; Z§§§{_~t§} §%;§,.»;§ 3&3 {§?i§§s§;E{3§*§%;%~§ i'§'!§§é§§€ §§%§§:§.*:§§§$§ " V{ii'Ji'*§;§."§«:";am%'§€§§"§ %-"SQ "figs ?%-'E3-'§§:;§'% §,a§§§§§:; '§%="{':§*§=s::§ ééié}, iésg §§}§%;%§§{%§% fiégéi amgg %§;§a§~§§§asr §§'§%E §§a%§§§§§'§{*a§§si;§§ €12?' §e§;*g§§§'3§;§=a=§ £2}? §§'§§ §%%§§'*§§{;§:': 3%' §'§:{§§'§"§§£*§Ef g}? s;'*€§§§§§*§§%.%§'§%".é.§§ Ea;-£3 gar $3253 §'§*§ET§§,§§? §%'§%;"§'§ 2*£f€:§=£3§§£e 2:; flag: wzsgeg mask: {gr §z§js9:§%§a in time .4 §"§§fé&€iE§§ §"€§§.§§'§%Z'i3 9?: ffiéfliianieé Esgrgaél }g§34sa§*§ §';§,~'..'}Eimv§§af3{:;'a:*£$*§ ' M fiiaisa §§z§§;zz*a§f:::€ {f€§§"'§'GI"'&$§{}§§, §<;§r§*:§§:+:;;,?2'jE?'?$*.¢ §_.;-;-"%§?2=:;%é§_29 3§§};:§ §§§i§'i§;%i§'"§fi§ Sfififffi §€§§§§ fifsig {fésart §3%§.§§§§é§'s§§_§§.g;g§:%£§iaé'i"9§§§ '§§»}?§l'Z§I "
asfzse figs §§f;%'§§§§§ ai" $32 €Ei§§%§€}f§«v'€:& €f§§ 2%?
$£:i§§§':°3£h§3%§s}§: §§§E§'§§§§ €$§:§§§;~.%:~§s }*zZ§%:a1£%'_ §%§3;§§é§*§zr §éV"A§:€§2=:§.r§§T§§§€ §fl§§'§,§§§§(%§'i§i§'1, .%% gfiséi a%§z§é%§:%,2_,;a* '"€--E;€ mzi <35' §i%§§=. £€a§2£3*%%::€§si;:i gésriigié':i2j;*§%§§::éi;§i.i*%'é:'§;:§;_é:§§°:%§ié§:z§2§%:%53* §;:'§z:.:*:3a§§:= {$.33 €§"§{% mafiéfimiiagz ggf 3-...v%§1é%¥f£335" A ifi §e§§¥£e€=§§.
t@:§;;§:2€§%§€£§§§§$:{§$_. é{§:':§z'*%§'§,1§§9§2 geyigé. "§'§s§§*&§§§:*:%., $19 §£.&€v駧§W éf~?f%§:§ :§§%§'g2§§€:z;§é:¢:;% figs %§£*§;i§:§$:;4r; {sf figs:
§:{;§2§§:29§'§éé%§:§é;§§ §::£* H iiisa :§ef:::§*:z2i22§§2g §fi€'€{%§" «:3? {""¥'§§€3i'§§€.?§E fa}? 2%}? ;s{;§:§.:*i%§*;3.§"§e};$§"' €22: §€ fimséa §§*§*€s§e€a:i%%;a3 $3?' Egésg _ éwggas; .§f--jA:{£§e€e§§§§§g €§z£..§§§§§i%§ Eée '%'%'€3$§§ £<:§z§,§§}:::e Ea ks fiia £%~§§§§§§{%}:'$§ V. €$¥s'ré%§$ £235 gégré. éiiéi ifiée 93% £;§' £*$:2$2*§%§:%§as§§ §s§§°§a;§;
"§'§1:€§*$f€; §*§;§3§ivé3g :§7.£§2§ §€§§§%§§§€'i'§§ §%'%§'§¥€:'£¥§ ééza fiifififigfifiiéili ;5§§"§i?§ fix: §f=:§§§§ _m§"§:éé..-§3§§{% §~§'§%2£§ 3% §§§;$§aE§%'?§ ii: figs §§§"'E§£i'§% {mesa 3%? £"é}§§§§¥%£§§§T:$§§€§§§ §}£?§{;§ fisifig 3,3§7§ fig? §:>§§§ ef' §€§§%§"§§%€.s* ' «_ "'§,€§§7,? fififé §m§§§§*§%b"§é-is %¥Ii§§.€§ ia €€§§?:%'"§'§§'§§E§ fig :«:§2§@:m%.§ ig} . {_§[ W 9 'K; 53% F..,.§;g*§w§£§.%.2s:%§§, '2 4!?"
'$335; $2; %*';:€;§%:>€§., $33 amgizgié 3% £'?€.%§§§'§'i§ii€;§é%E1 ayiéi 5%: §'§5€::%'%£*I'£*§§ §'"§*{fs;2§ téw s:3;pi€;}-Yeess §g Egg fisai fiziwy €§§' §§;.§% gizaiésix, 'a-'§i?%§'£'§_'§:'§§:'§_ :2§§§'A.§§:§§§;,:"§f%§§§::;_' éksmfi £693 :29? féfigi 233%; gi§€'}{§ %§§'*{§§1§§§§ %%%fi'é%z*§¥§§*§?g *a;:'%?.€§;: .'$§'§€* f':§§§§3?33§§ :3' $32: §iS§_ {T'{;%,§;:*§. .:%€€$§*§§§;§§%§;%%_ iigg aggéézgifi §%§§;§'§'§§S«$%3§§k Sd/-» Iudge