Karnataka High Court
The Commissioner Of Income Tax vs Hewelett Packard Digital Global Soft ... on 19 September, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
M. 3 N 1%; "f'%éE HIGR CGLERT 0%' E<AR§\§é"?AK,fa £35?" 8fix§\:§&L®RE §,&J§"ES 'zms THE 19?" am' G? $Em'"Er~4@§R 23::
PRESEQF V THE %'€G?x§'5LE ?vER,3'i,§'S"E"1CE m<L:m;m > A349 TRE %%QE*~§"$LE fv'§R,§U$T§CE Rgém :§$§;:«;;§r~%AT':-«§::"' ma,sé@.405"%é?~.;@§%*'v- .
:"rm~;Q.4$:? §E,2@:G1?'__ EE?WEEN:
. "EH5 CQ§V%EV§IS;§.ZQa'=§fER :35 :i*xs%~;::s.34s*;v%*E[""%iA;<T, ' CEMRAL C§R€L§1E ; ;:,;R,';;B2;I::';;m:%~sf§_, "
QLEEEEKES » 8&§\3GALOR.Egi:.. " ' !.,,....L.
2, "mg ;:gS§S§:';:é_agz"AV€:4:3§v:--s+::::*;$:€;:3:ER SF IE\§CGE*»'E_E~°T§>i €IRCi;%."i~»:[;§(2:}; VC.:'?"~f..,E§'§,»_EV4§ §;§."}1"e"~§E;_€Z»;¥;, Q:.,:EE;rx;;%:..;D;;£":;2;r§,VV,_ V" " _ §£é'~é§Ai.$%?;,§, . ._ " .,.s:@§§é,%a,mx-é'{§ .'» V.'~' * CQMMGN .:j'B*~{. Sm' ;<»;"%;*,_§;'R§:s1"r\§éééa SR1 €'="§f;f.SES%*~%;i'aC§*'i;>'3»..E..:*3:; ;a1m:*§fi} .%~§E':fa£EE;;§"§'"? §i%€%<1fi.§5E$ E}§§E"%",5aL
- £1-.;LiQB;i'aL"$@:.f1~""§ 3:53,, "--::.§::;;i"~:T:%§E§;:%' magma fiififiég 3%? :.:€é,1;; ' E3EGE";%"1fi;':«w 9,é§<:;<, ms"? §x;€:,3%;'%€% ._ '%'ii:}?'§;ié§"éA;§:}}%§%'§;:z ;"i\§§§;;iI§~%£aR;§, _ §a55@§,_§bgru%:%2@ Aggi, fisrrmiggianer 9? Erzwme Tax, Cémiew ";i«-fE,{2}'-,__EEa:f:.{;a§»€:;r@5 **** " AA '""--?T§f%e:§ tam; aweaéa 3%: §%"8?€§"§'"€§ ivy izééa éeaieyzue '--«%;?'%*:§'i§en§%:é§ iiéée %%'"{§§¥' gggged? E}: 3% "%"':*§;;*;:§_;=;r":a§,, eszémé: $9: ELECTRQMC CETY} ?H,%SE~2E, HQSUP. Rflfimg _ B;&E'=éGfi.%.uGRE; H.§;§g@G;*«5$£§'»s"':*"
C@MM®M,."T {EV $93 §<,@,§<U§v2AR,, SEEEEGR Amficgfizra mg * §v'%;'S. Kim 3;: PéR'?'"R§BG"E, ABVGCATES) Thég E?.&a..E\E0R4G6;'2SQ? film :..,:r'2..,;de:j"'2s3£:*-;'ct£"<::sn"..?.;§{"'}»~';L'*xf'=~.:";ff'*:;_* 1;?A:t, 196: aréséng sat cs? srder @ate'd__ €§8;_.12,2€}_{J6' pa'$§ee:':'~, én £?A,f\§§,1?;'Sang/ZQGS, fm" §he«-figgeg-gtment*§{ea.j:'=..1§§.f;?-- Q8, graying E9 fermuiate the sgézsséaniiaé :::.;e':';i%£_c*»r'r§'1.»s§ Eat»: gtateé therein, aiiow mg aweai ésid sset aéédia iheii oréer §3E:'1SSEfi by tém ET;fiC§"", Ba:::.g;ai0£*ie"é:": .:£"I",fii;;Ef~.33.1"?fBareg;'20G3 éatefi 08,:2«2€3G6 canfér-m:m_g 'gths:jm'd.;e?si é,:f_ the Aggeifafie Cc»mm§$s§o:":er & canfirm the' 0:-'dfl-3:' p;a§s7§.<%§"*£j>y the Asgi. Cammissianer sf Incame iiiiéréeal:{'2},"'--S5:nga§9re. This §?;§'x.;f'x:»$;4,£'éi'i8V_V?-;?2'€?{}'_?' *§§ie::€_" ».,éj::é&r sectim 263% 3? Ef§I;%c%, 1%: iaaég-iézg §i:;«%:.0?=Té{2%@er..§iat;3fi'§8,i2§2i3§6 gassefi in Tm,fig,_1V6f*$3':3:;;j2QC.§';' _ 'f3f':=..._FC§':£% Asaessmmé year 3k§§6--§7,j;3ra3%é=:i:;;. is ;F?';e*?n"jaL;§ta;'%.a igimeéagbstantiai guegtiarzg sf Eaw states i:¥*:=::§rie%'Vr%.;'=-_a'§'E%:§i;*%:'%w.T:%":--:% 'aggeai and set agéde this srfiar fizasseé £T'A'¥", Baragaégre in E"E"§'§'*§;'.}.l§;"§';§figf2C'{;§ fl8,:;":*;,2Q€}é ésmfirmérgg iéza zzwée? $5 53% £é;;:%;2é§%a;V':e €;:_@mm%sg§2c:*:er & zcnfwm Em fiffiéi' * T'§'"§':3sv:r~§ Z§'F§$" €§m§ng gr: far aémésgéasn §§"1§§ flay, §<£}'5f?,i£Eé§3}.}":€'§~:.§§3:a3§%2§'fi Em f@§§£;as«:%§:g:« §i£§i3?¥§E§\?§ féééng {ha reium sf immme. "me aggegsmerzt wag $e3:;§h;_'_: m 58 resgenefi an tha grmmé ihai interest iréacema casf:V§':<i>}f'i:'«..$i§%':=:.Vv saéé ie 5% :§':s%"5":fEi "'£%e5%va§ item" iha AV I' fixSS&§Si§"':g Auiéxctzriiy hag reawhare E::_..:'.:is_ @;r"§éV:9";~=i.:;f"::é§:;;»'~;::j"'%:§_*za;i {Em §SS£ESS8@ hag faiiefi '£3 d§$c§::>é:.e 59$'é::.::§§:'"L'L.'.g,iV'§31A materéaé fem; air the time '§,"%:ff"'---5..§s€37§'§':@r1'%:_,°§.é;%;駧i-....§€--' a acnéiiéan greaedersfi far :je~<39erjV_i_:"é§'€3_:"'%:§f§e é$$<2§;.$rr} %§n{ am Qaggng 0? an aréer i."%i"1 "..x§..','§"';.:§5L"". gVif@:§%:3%;"§'§;§ ; : R$§y§E"3§ an the Iéuégment 3? fihe CESS cf Hmdusz-gm 2%: .}§:;;§}:é%§"%L:n 268 ;:m 33;, the "§°"r§bLI:€'%A3;J3V E'*§~::=;:%§"<':,s* mré3§3h_:f§§;3 rnateréaé is igzéécate mi: :§aé--._ ejéécéese fazééy ans mix; aié materéaé f§€'t:; as*;§V":%':é;*A5e'§:;»;§*é:L. éeaganéng afta" expéry of fans' ':f§a¥"S.i_§:T§§§;?'§.t3i bé'§§.§_§weévt@ Siam. E: is a case 3? §§"2a;'2§e 3%"
-._:.'2g)§';:.§_:s:*:f ms: geyméiied 5:: Eaa»-as; T§"'§§%*@'?O§'$; éha "§'j':4;.?_3é;:?T%i:_a3 égééa arse? gzawafi by 3% s*31§§€§§§i€ .{:@n':§"%*s'%s$;{>5r2&:'" 3% weéé 5% we aréigmai aggaggmené: sréea ':if:;§§::L$f<.:€{§" $3; the saéé GE"€§€§} zhe ravanaga flag '$95 %%':e$e §§&% &a\%5S'i*§\V§% %s /r 3. I»
3. The Eeameé Czxmgai £3? the f';;'§*'%£€§"§E,i€ a$sa_%.%§__n§ we émgugneé fiffiéi' Qfifiiéfififi that m$§:..;b% f.:§'zé E135 agmexefi a rzrsée {Q ihe :3,ri'g§:*:a§ reiségm, 52;: i?:A;é*--::§§?;f:3:f€*%i%::{ "":' "
3%' the mate dié net fuiéy grad irazégz s$%~:2.s._2§ t%"g%e5V am reaquézefi W: E32513, Tharefare, t%{ie §5.--§_€s_:$%e5's5§:§*-:~§;;_ 'A{;i:§%g~§/§:ggVIi wag jL%S'€§§E&é in §'"@~§fi€E'2§E"§§ :?'2e'é.;sVfs;a:-7:133;/':*2§a"§':tV, . fit $3? c§n%ra,7:%:~§i:_e 3E§€3_E"Tf'E{E':;§§ i:§£§E'ES&§" far me agaessae gaggparteé we Emma:-gV§z¢:i§'V§:?ée§r§V"
E. Z5_::.-'aha C:'§'f:§§ie:._.af£;'r:éfsva§§§.féttg and the rivai cQs*:ter:€:§5§"2:S:_;.?VtE*i';"2._§'i:§:::; 'pi:-.E_s'*'1:'2:._ t9:j%:a**;*.§:'*2;,;rVEV;;sE,§ fag' gm cangééeratémz é$ whethér t%e& :":§§i:e.@*;; which is mi in éispuie weasié mnéi-E:;;§e:=:V ""§agE'E'~§{ »a.s:4%'§5i éiruéy éiscéase {he materéaé __fa£§s"'__£é3jSV :*.e%§:;§ré<?§.._V§,:néee* Eaw. The gaié mtg reaég as ~.ti§'Ti§i*Z«?'.7:* V A Eifif éatgf ffiéfiféfif $3' §?3.3§,9§_,.,2.Eé,5~, A "%§$.§;,;1i':;'2M;§'?Q;.f~ fig earzysaf $3! éfisé §"?2§ ;s;*§§§ %zvfz§§,%E'; $3 .:£.%?;§f'§s§§éi§ 25$; gxémgiiga igizgfég" §§«i';'§§:§;"'E 3% 9? _ §}§§ '£55.. In §°§€f?$§, §:5;£g%;"ée.§§" §§'§£Z'§f'§5f§ $2' §{;%f,§§,£?;駥;'~» $353 &§§;§ ::§;?$§§'@:'**§a%' faxgfifeg '' W.» :gi// 2;~f»§'~§§zT:L;3fas;e::*§:3 iearrsr List, 15$, .z32:;7'f"?'"i<s a§§a:r€:€$ EE'?E§ZZ%€3§"§?§?§"°é€E.
6. §~'r:3m the now, E: %g fleas" ma: we as§éSS§e_E;i1_a§ a istai éatargsi 9? R§.2E,§Q;2i£;- w§';%:%: Es Eéabm am: =3? me fiaéé amsigréétf 3 gm 3? ?;§,§;52§?}'Qj'j'€--£ by $3"? -amt. Tm 53"? unit wag giégébéé ::5<§%"'é;§:':.¢;;n~é§:i:' ;.g:
mafia: Sa«:':%§0:"': 164% Q? ihe fiat, fine fi'a§&i--. _é::";aE7'xihé~.aA§$$3$é'é%"*~§.§3?.' that man the éssiereséc amsu_r:t'é.;€é':*:§ e§ §g: S';';$_ i§..e:E'é§:_;;;'§§:;--V'§¢e; €10:
exemgiien under Se<::%§e:*;__ 33;? _f5fI§;§:}:E§"fg€§t<Z>_vE"€g %?%a%.,_p@ 2f5:E<}n sf {ha Er':tera$€ amezmt waé; :f2s}t<_::i§f€:ré:;fff"fér.éax am {he remaining am0L:mj';«;_a§ ef§1e"§&:éi" f:3's=._%a;><.V'. %r.~{e'r%{:a, we {mi ':9 zgndergtané v;»fh.37':440f§§_e_r m a_?.:e:f§a:é -..'E5é§.':T'té<::w;§'é§Vé's the iaggeggmg Aaiémriiyw_anta<:%fi';%%:;_er:§=:3%°' 5:§ei_:_g;f_si:r§Ene '».2'=é§"EE'E§'?€E' the Sam &mea,::':%: kg? R3,§;E3v2';7%":?$f4=-~§§~~--éazabée 0: mi, Ag zigiztiy minted a::§ '§§y *E?:e"E"_:'§%.,2§;.sr:aA§;_;.':§§e 33% mate déé dégaiasa ma __fa.:%§ a;;r';§& ézma §a..;i::%a",a;Ea,rs a%§"'£é Em aggeggee has sacs? A'-.$:_;,§;;§e$::§§~.;:r é:.:mi:e@E Ea 2":'%§§'%E§G{'2 am? gartécuéa: whiah is :*ésiga.m'9:::§3 *§:;;«%"_*vf§fa';~"{*:'£%:g 5;?' ag$§§$:'*§"s&n§¢ in this amiaxt, i§"§€ .a%:*'e§'§:e;%§ §';sfi§'%s*%":eni 3? E5253 §§m§&3: Sigh fimzfi in im sage