Karnataka High Court
Babu S/O Gemu Ors vs The Special Land Acquisition Officer on 15 March, 2011
EN "E'§"'§.E3 NEE-':?'§ CGUEE'? CE?' KARE°'€13§.I'2%E'{zX CiE~?;C§JET BET\§CE"1 E-'KT SUE,-B,§%.RG:'%. VT :>;m;:> Ti»-£33 ':"'mi~:;. :.::'"~;'E'%--% 1:3;-W <3? $2/*Ez"a§"€C.E;'5§{';3--§T?_'Ev«-E: ;_. ' E%§_{;FG§~ZE: 2 > "FEE: :«:0:~=J"1:3m: :'vz§m'z53';'§!§::»&é:g<3§g:a::§;§L:_'_' _ Msazsmaga §e?r:*_ :2;{:11 ' u ' A BETWEEN: ' V L Babu sf{:}.{f«e:11: :;"'-.. . _ V Age 35 3565311?-5, G:7%<:=i:€A«i)é;=_i_i{?..
24 Maruiii s;sf":;.._fC2€5:rf§1A{:; ' - _ Age 32"§;'s:'3§-S. O€:{::=3C'<§<)E1?é£':..V_
3. J21gé1_i:23f_§§;»'Sf 7 } £§~§_,.§e 2GVL}'ez§'T:I"§«.. €;3--r:<:':.C<;:<:%Z§';%{:=:,.-- REE 11;' {;a,_ViE1fé1§§%%_ Q'.;£:Vi"§T,'fEjé"i'ié"§;':'1';:._ " __ T .C}1iz1?;:h::r%é, E3?:Esi:'.a€:%':,:£'i}.a:*'s~?::1. 5% eiizzrgais Q . . :7: E3?
5%}? gag": f':§TZ"£"€3,i*§§":.V E€Q'§;:L fgéaaé V " g1..:":ni§;
'§"§':?:;: S;§e;€%i%§.3,E f.};2:§"££§ A<*:qa2i'1:-:2,;i'*;:é<;sn {é?§'Eéf::3:: _?*g"'§'§§.*?:{::9 Err§,§;:;:E.i<:n §3r<:}?§r<?"§:. ,5 E«?;ef;%s~;p<:;§:é€:m §E*3}:' Sta'; ?%;'E.e1E§§§i;§zj:,2§': $z7:E":°a.2i%§a:r: Eiifiééfif ":T'E":§s:; Zvififi. is; Efiififi 'a.':z1£:§m" >S<>:<:*.'§:§.<:;%:'§ 5«%{?i} 53%" E;a'2;_:':{§ 3j;'%é{g*;.é:§:s;§§:§:§23 ;%c:_*'§;a E9E%§é§§ §}ra2}-*%§2g €':::: m<3<i§z?},i $36: §:.§{§;g;':é2{;%:2.<é: gmgi 2;{a,a»*2:.2':"£ in Eiéiffé ?é£{;1} E ,3 .E.§%§¥3 s:§z2;%,€{§ 231%» E §§%%'>? géaésassifi bjg' ma":
V' "EE ;'%{§a:§.;%§';§z:}:1aE §§%5;«;;':::*E{7§" <,,§';.§{f§.§'-_:,§;;{'f 2%? €:zE,'§E§_}£":i§'§§:4i 2:9}; ::2{;:{ii§§'%::§§ itizé:
j:zi.§;":j:*:1:e::§'3:', ;;a_:";:i z::*s;;:_:*{§ in Efiéli E'€<:ai%iE.;' 2.98%} :?;z:%:'s=%::§. §;E_§%E{%2 "s Q3 S§§.éX:1'§.:*a%s§}:.S.E€';<;3§z1§ Eérz-1:r;:1:.*:'§ <.%:;::,2:':se's@E E7232' {E36 g2;3g3€:Ei.az:.:1-- <:E2ai:m2m"s:s Eii"i{i SF'f,N{Ei§}.§E{21i:§L§§'1, S21%1'a.:k::zr, E&3a:*m:>;d Eiigh. C<>:T:2"%:. {}<3¥;"'er:'::;'f:€-21%. ?1é;é:1<ié?.r awe §1:2*ar:§a x *3. in E'i;E'fE;3péE{.',"i. ai" Izmaziiss $_iE,u;:aé'.e.-f-3 if: 5316 s;211:2r::.;E1}:s€.E.e:r§§a *2:§.E§:ag.;§:=%, C§1is':chz>E% "§'z.f:E1,z%<;¢ i")i:+;:"s,::'§<::*é'. {}1,:E'£}22.rgg*a, 2,1C.q:':2»i:':;%§E.._{2;';<:i:@::° preiiminary imtificatimz dated C€}§.,E):'€. had €:i'~N€i£'{i€d_ {iT(}E}1pEflS£T£EZi:(}fiV 3:1. f:1fi=.:.§3 §;'é'3;§':€' f;>§ ?'é35;S{}€3,/ L er a.<::*s:: with 213 {?OI1§.%{;¥{ *u;:;:e::2E'::'2-1% sé:::;1.i§';2E.e:;=rV ' b»:>-:*i':-*;£"_E.*Ii:.s; ':«,2.:'1~;f'i.3{1€< F;1§"$'£, Appeiizzte C<m_:°i: e:2:1Ef:z£::'<::f§7:§. fits sf-éa-='§._i{'i=.<:é>::z";;*;€;t:fass21t.i<;r: iii} ?8_®€}{}g' « per a<:re x>ari.i?;f~~..§1.§i_ <:':§:*:s:§&r;?4'a':{éfzfijiiai :;%.2:i:ué.{:ry bE3f}.€'fi§$ and i:;"%:13:$_{3e:i1:.::*€,..__i::M E'E::;E}§ E52889; éézréiher <3nh23.:':::€d the 552-iéci <?:>H1§}§€:V1€g'§2é.ji:'§'<m? '$42' ?E;9§.GG{%;'-- §}€3§" zzarm &£r§i.h ail <'::i:r:::~5%;%{§%.,§,€;é§::"EiT£.&%..i' s,i.z:._1:%ujsi'.:>:'_3;"?:>e:f:":<;éf£"'£.s;( Ths .§£«.£.E":{§S 2i{?,€;}i1iE'€;"f{'§ in §,§]éff"fi'3F€E§:§Et?}{. E'sr'§§}§é'€::€EE;2;:e<;:.:$ Séseztazzfl é3p§}§'/€:fl z>:s%33"é?: 335%: 5;i'u:21i,::2 .i.:'_:«fah::: $:--3:.:::§f:.";i§%:i:"§.22:rgg;2:: m§§%;=2;g_;;:% zizmi E'..E":e%3; ::a;:::é: ':5: ':36? aaiiégmrséé i.../g/1%2§=':.:::§:::%A:;i"~.§:=§ii:::ir§z§ar§: zmtifiztfimz éaiefi 2'?1f§fi,iE9$3q far' "E:.E";§% game {Ff Ex-!Ei;":::;§° Zr":*':ga%::£{}n. E3'*L::'":.%:£éE: $15» Eéairiii A§;.§L§'?§€?'I'€;?§T§:{'f"f? {i<'2z::"§; 2E':7§*'E§3"{I§{f€§ {C':€}:1'3§)€3:'i'E.§5éE§€i§{HE %§%£}{}{E_;'-- §3é:r.z' ..;;é<::%*é:':%._ %;§°;:§: 272%.? {f'€}§'Ef<§é;',{§:.§€:f§'"iE".§;:§..§ zzi;c:;;:°§-1* %i3§:%:'22=::§T% E3}; §::$ ~{:<";§=:2*:::<;:': s§:.:{:§.§,,.;f:z";::-%§:€T. E,§.§"2{."§ Efiifi E'*a§{3:1~:62':'§ ;' 3 §§§:§%§ j'/"'A"'J""'~ V.,,,MW .n A;
3;
E10 3"?;"198§ {En<;'siu{%éng; t'}i::=a p:~e3::~s<=:m. ELEKC Nt1Zn3Q/ 1989} in E'€S§}€i€_?'§', <f}f €.I*::5.=:~x:: 3;22':":<ci.s:~;1 }'+':.:z'%.§"1er, €:.h~::: same Firgix §appeEEa.Ii:é=r Cmzri. €:EEEh3;IEC€.:'t'€§ E'.E2<:7= sazaéd. s::::}::2pe:'2$2:.t:iQ;1 iii} %'€;%,€}GGf-- peg' eiarre. wzfiz aii {f<m:e;<-3:;m::e:"2i.ia:i S'E£i'{z,E?.i£)£"};* £%£::2.::=::f§.i.s;; '§:sj;;"1?'*t._:f:; ::32*ds;*::' c§a';'.:':{% 2§.G5.E.99§ }"}éT%.3i'~}-t':%€'.{i in EAKEA E"~5{::+:--*i~§f V;{}':"}i'£€.'fE' <f:{>:mé::<i'i',€:<i a.p;3&%ai$ iz'1€_:E:.:<:i.i:1;;g LAC fx'0.1/' »'3"i'°e:}":.£§'"£%:§ :2? :>_z"it '{1h€3 {:Eaim:u§:i.S i':7:"%i;Ef:~€: !;2r€:é:e::i: 'S€£:éi;:z:d ;%p;:w;':aE 3:21:93 ciaim "ihé-3: $21313 <:t0mp§:--::$21t:i<3.:*;Aix? "?E'i§,'Gi3éi}*,?-- par zicre with ad} <2c:>§1.:a~+e:{ga:_e:2t._i'L5:E,§'£.a%;,:,z4;,<}i%f§2_ Eaztzéséfiigs. Zia' -.f§*i'fj:€;* §ég_:sz€isé"-.E':3:1.?{>Ex%%:i~V--ii:: t;§"1€ p:"e$€:";i; appeaj and é'E1<3:'-Jeaé r2iAn1rc:;£'vaéd=*{:'2,4§a:€S;f:_"f*§<3',:':31 E ;"2GQ9§ Whicéz zrzzmfi is 'me {§i:駧}{}S%§i',{;}'w..f{7éE:'7. Efiyfihéésé ,.{:%:m :"%, b}; :32; Juégrz.1£:*.::1*2; amci AWEi.§'(Zi siaizaéaé..§§.§Z§2€3E'Eg'wé:f<;%":a<:qu§Fe€i f<:=r {hie sgaméz purpage ef f%;E§_:'f§§5~r ?:;i:°§gTgi2:i.i:>§':'; '§.§*:;--<;::g§'1 :.::'1{ie~r {i§.ffe:*<;ém: n<3::.ifE:7::af;'i€:;::§ c§ai'.<3e:% 2 'i3[?';'_§.€f§.,5'E'§§E%.;§'=:;:"1.{i 3Q(€}E}.E98«-€~ zmaii 'é:ha% Emma? 2:zma:>1mé 9%"
23:3:;§§;*2S'e{£ii{:t.i3-..a;z*;1$ 2::x%2*;i§:"::§:-'%v:§ E23; 'iézfiz §3;€.'i§€§Tf:"fE'§.{T:€:? Cmzri: éfigféfl §:E':A{%_ §?'§:*s;2é:. Ea;-g,::'g§€::E";§;.:,<-'5 %Z.?s:2:.::"§'. €:%nE":2.'m<;%é:{§ '£,h§;': ::?=:}zz":;3c:1;<%;2:"§;;%<:2§: ta £_%":@ :§;::::'*:':':;f :;:2:€.s=::':f.. £2: §'€?E1§§'}ij?'?{,.'.'§. at}? zgéé $25? .§e.m{§s:~;, 'Z%;"i::%:*s;%{a;':*:;tz E 23.31:
.,s:.,:;'"'"é;-?%_:z2% m',};":s,;§{:§a:::":?:s::§ <;§;}§:2§:m '£%2z*a'%;: éksiéaéaégézzgzg %.%"z:«?~. (;Tz::%§;§.:'::a=%":':i: <3? z"''"'"~«~='''*~m\ ,.
;,,M 1'' E. %.hi:~;e C{)E.'E§"§, ix": E'vES;'i ?€{";.E32 E./2{"}S'E~}. é,§::<5=. CEa.i::2a.:'2%.s; E":.e<.:*:re:-air: 2,-am aiiéi} e;1'£::1i'.E€:<:i fa} {Em 5":§27iE'Z<'i{:'.? sm._Em:1<:e{§ <*e:3:1':p:::z1.<:e;..:«;1i:7<m §'E_€},{}{)§,!'~ pm' gactércit of €I§{°§-' Eztmfi wii:h 21$ ct{34zv*;§§§:§»;;~£::§V::§if.Ea} $i'a'::::.i::}r§;* bs3rn_e.fit:s3. Evia-'.>:':<%%:=-? t'i1::i§éi>iE<3wi.z':g: L . Q43/EEE. .
Théf pE'f;':S€.'.§"1'§. f:1}}§§€E:iE 3?.-S 211§'{m;?€d5'»._ §';:2 ;§:«;: ':': Tifiakitiz "
;3:°{3_pGr€.i<3:f:ai§s z:<}ss:;{.$. ';€'§.1:3'é3._§;:;::*E§a:§$:s;V h€_:'j<'T:3ZV:"1"«:§;x,-rim. =?.:1:'€ 'é;2':z*;:: Eegzsi r€:pr§:ss3rH',atia-vs; Q? éézéir. <:_ri.g;;i:3;13"..g:iaima;%?:.Hrggfizfixeiy Gama: S!/0 ?a:1d.u ::*<3$icE<~:~:1"i: {if'§;?':.1i.-:ai'g{[:1 %i£§;a,;:§e.,_ 'E'a.§uk Clhinchgii, _E}isi:.r.i<:E: {E-:.z1%21_§g§2g,_ in the F126: 9? Eearned Afiiéjil a}L§1E§§_§;€:,'=_éE§_i:Eb2::*g2:;§ aha}? be <?.:2ti'{:§€& £19 a:{m:pé:::$a:;--i:3::l 'ggzfier a;{:2*<': <3? ihéf éE"}?' Ezméi :.m(i:'::° zsitégzzigiiifizgzi' Vv.-?§%;::h.' --f2.+;3§"--.__:::?(:;is€:q::e:"sf{.ia.E s~:{a§;ui:{}r}; b<:%:"3.€:fE'£fS '%::%";€:%mj:{;:;':: 23.:':m":.;_i'1%°," <5? §j3{}'§§}_§§€ffZ.'}.E$2z.i.§€}fi '«"JE[Ei£"i?i §',§'}§fS€;'. ._ a.;3§3é:E{3.E2;;f§'§.'§:§_21_i:':f:é*1m;2i.$__.«§1z:.2*€52 <23' 'fmé a>:*i;_;i'n.:«i:E <:E&i:I:a2';é', Eiass .re{::e;§2;*<§::§w.:,.:::v{fi'::%.r aim} {E1T:{§§g:3":@:§§%,$ a':":§; Awzzrdg §'>23.,S;%;%2{£ by éha "'F?..€'§°%;::'§fié::':;éé:._{j;3f§;iz*§:. zmii i',E':s%= E*"£:°';<:;€: §'a;:§3<%.E§2:%.€ €Z:>:.:_r:'.. E§_{}W:%w:f, ass ._;><%:3.§>:":j§;$i* €.7§£E'_§',f;?tiI§ {.'§E°§:§.i;%',€}'§§ p;a:.3s§e& ix: 'ihia 23,§;>§}<%z2;§ _F:!?E§s;<:i'iZ?§?'§;_§%§'€35as.E§>{}2=4%§% a:.":_<f% E.§{;'%:2,¥i:§-E ::":s§ 2&3 3? Eihfi ;2:;:~§3{3E§2m'i:~ ..§:.:-A_A§_.2;:'T__:L§§j;:::.:':§a 5%;-2.E.§ Hiféi. ':3? :.=:;*T:é.é¥:.§::&{% {:3 §.:§i's:*§'<::'5;§?; 9:1"; §f§".E€? §fE"§ ?§.':§..§"§{.'.:i;-':**;'.§ { ~ r~'_fl,w%____/,_, ......», {eh «««««« »,.:=»n E';
:a::":":e,}'a.i:'1E". 4:31" <::3z':":;3e:1s521§:'.i<>:1 fiéi' £'h<~? p:';%§"i<3:;§ sf 5§£3:.§z1§.-* Sf 52 E9 €ié?1yS;% a:"z?::.:;sae%d in §'i§i':'1g;; '£1212'? ;:eresz~;e:';*i:. 2"s;3p«i%z::E. 'jE'h:=% eiaararzi :-sE":a~,1§.1 13¢'-E n3<_>:3i§'}Z&%{i ezrrzjiurdingijgx $bf~