Karnataka High Court
Syed Shajahan @ Syed Sajju @ Shajid vs State By Ccb Police on 29 July, 2011
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
fix: 3&5 z§§:::+§--: iZi{}UE'?fE' 9;? E{AE2:?\?A'§'..5§KA _:"{§"' §=;;x:xT<::;s%_é;',§§f:§§;:é*;;~ "
£f}A'E'E£}Zf) '::'H;s 'E'EiE§ 2%?" E>AY 0? J1:m:'.,2a§f: V L" % EEFQREZ ":33 IE~§ON*BLE M§mUS':":<7.§: Aésaxgfirm fig C§z:M:NAL PE'§'I"E'§QP~E eiiéggggg }:;:£>A§_§ §~3E'I"i&»-'EE1'J: % . $ Z S3265} Shajahearz Syed 8z1}jvz,.; ' @ Shajid _ § S/0 iatfi Syedl ~.,Vr21h'im . ' Aged abaui 2&4 5;s%a.A:;e,~--k%L ' 4 Rfat, N0.5_§, 8133 3 "
Ar21fa1:.h §'§Ja;§211z.. ":1 E98.ci2§;°22}!'a:121_§::;1:'9;§x"*-.. ' ' ' ~ Ban;g;"a10:'€a_ 560 M.§E'E'E'i'1QN'E'E{ gm" sggaivz.Bt"§m;v:A{:§~mN'r;;'§2A, A;{)VQCA'i"E} S-'iéE.;:: ' p£'}v.iEi?f;§ {}§'§i'. ' ~ ..
§Ri€§§§.*-.:_§}}z' E_.;::i~21_:"§:.@z§ Siigaiiéé ?ub.'E_§(:
% fl§?I'£>:~;é3{:u.i{§zf} ..R_ESPON§EN'§' "..éj;§:7,=i§7f' §3'Ev§L8pE{z3:.a§1% 3U§3§:AmAA:¢gA ;+3:-m: }EC{}P1 TEES CRE§v£§Fi"AL PE'§"§'§'E(}N ES E}-'IRE-B UNETEEH _"~g'E%fE{f:':'£'§QE'~§ 439 G?' mg Cgsupg ESE' "mg AEfi}Ef{}€f_A"E'E; '=.:~2mz ma': E3ETf§.'§"E€}Tf\EEZE~'{ PE€A"':'"EN€3~ 'E.'E4E£¥E' "E'EE§S HG?'-$§'~§I,E " " {i{I:§,ER'"E" §':§,s*§Y 2%: ;DLE?~;SE§.'} fm §Z§€LsEE%{§E '£.'§§E; §3'E'§.'§"E"'E{}?%1§iR {EN E%§£'%.§E,« EN {f§€E.?sf{"}q§§i%%},f2{}§{? Q? ._f.{§R§¥E;%{Z:£§ZE?; PS" EE..5:§'§{.§j%§;{3§€.E:x, E'~"'%T}E{ '§'§"§IEi {f*¥"F'E;fi{fE§E~E~ §3'i§?£§SE*§.;%E3§.i%:- %§'§.\2"'§.i§E%Z§?{ ;§§E?Z{f'§'§€f}F'»E" i2':{}E:'§::i§ 'f'$'§}§7'E?~3~ :'%éff'EI_ Ni??? f5§Z{}}§p€f%:§ ifs": frsmit of B€'i€'?:{§§ £%Sh€.}§.?: 553:: E3111 .£V§22.i'n 'E~2::2.:f:3; zgnii Eip£?i.§'§', :£':*<>rn {he zmézizi zirivesr (was? E.a<§j.;' Elhé-ii 'i'h._m%e:.'":1"§:5a§€:
§)€::*s:~.;<31'1Ee we;-:.=:f:~% sgiiiixlgf on iize §}a<':k sssidfi sf E:h.€_.Aé:£:1'£.{>:"e>%§:~;°:z'{:'71 ~ the piagatic bL:1'1d1é33 ansi 0:3. sseei:'1g* pa:3'};E~::-(:2 éssqgzzzagi "$31933 fi;.;-1&3? and ft':fI'?i21§€3.* £':S{.Te';'i}}€d i'.%.1r{>1.1g§'1 i,%_:..§: =E2'£z':€. ""?i':.e3v::::a1.'f?£:L'ct3f As:=s%si;€.2zm. C<3n:missi(:s:1er cf I-"*'(>'ii.gj:E%~..V3pp%<£i1e:":.'1.§i€v:i VLi»i--':.,<f§:}*:é;:::Séd; 3f€{>.i ti: 3 27:11:? £1fff3i' a:~:;{:.':*V;"{'.z?zi.:;?;;V;1§%".i:«__:.;j _:E.'E"zé§i:f :nan1é':*-s~, ~§'i£: was ,..
irxfmrmeéé by them i::E";ai: Gzmja 'fr<>I11 a:;:CuSed in 0'1°d<3:' to store ii: in Egér e1'g;é.1:°. HE3}'I{E€3, after 3'5'>'1"V'3-'11§_'§ 3 E':-E5 <it<>:1tempEe1ted tinder S<-;<t1'§!<>'::.V5k{3 ='Ac€'. 3. persanai i-':3€fia}'Ch was <:<}:1<iL:::;;t;@§ mi §h.€;:~1":§' afid .be.fi:>ré3 ::{md'1;s;z:.ir:g 21 persmrfzzxi :$€;:2§/E"{?:€':z '~T€53€f'§T€ 21180 ass-3E<ed ass {<3 whether pea-1*&«3@:1z:1 5s'@;1;f*rf~:_E: A §s7~:Q=€§§ <::<>§1c§1.z:'>:'é.£3<i bCf{}I"€3 2: }f\«-'E3.g:.__>:j5=;.'%1::°a1'£:e»'. or 3 _G-21;?:§§:'i'%e3d--._"{){¥'i'{:<3r amé whe€.ht3:ri ;::€z's;~;{:»:1z:i ésatezrszih zian be §:é:::?€E'_g2§:":é%'i§ hjg '5I§'1€'. AC? hi::s':;%e.§.£' féiiléiifff he €xa2:{:":;::::<i . ;__{}i7fi:}:'@.'% zmii an €.I':€:§r c{;i'::s;en'E: b€ffl§.'§'.}.§-9; ggiarrara 1";<> <.::}z"::iu{:'€. %:E:";_€ mz" 219/"
}§?<;%:"s€;:1ai s;£;?a:°<:h E33,-' Eiiis EEC? §1§.m;:<~5€3E§; $:,z<.ttE2 p<::z*£~:;:i::3aE $§%2::"<'E': §.:'23s=; :':e::>n{§1.2:7.E.:é{i ii, :52; s;E;:a§.€<i E33? %;,E'.}_&3 §>:'€}ss::=.%<:t1,2i;i:im '§:E.':.a%;_. <.;ti:.:s:e§:a=%:' <2? 3% :%;::"::2:}§ 'g3=§22§:%'s;E.{: "$31.2 :zdE:;=;%s%; Eéiééaééi wi'i',E': ;;;a:__§':§2.: 'VVW3; r§%§€:3r€§\---{x*:;v:V§}€§ §§SC"E':;$€ i:.§12z'i: préma facée; Compfiamrs Gf V5-:f§x*',"f.(.'V;§.'~é%é'}%§},§,fE%1'§}§'E3 on r<::c::e::s:"{§, 'E'h£:*:-=36 aim: 2:3 {he ::"1a>:§:E.a:3%,i=3 §&ii?'i'§:§g';A::I'€3q1:i§€s :1') ha': §;{>:'1<3*. mm at i1:h<€>; {Lime {sf ""--fé;:§'»??:;};I §'L::°§s~3di{':*;',§<}:12z1 (tantra SEES £&%,I1€"3fl'i{3}" :::<>'r2§,€::§'.§0r1 {.'.{3E}§1S€5§ Em" §)€",'é'Zi§.i.§{}§i€'.I' iii Wiifia re;g21r{i 1:} =§;}.é;:%*i-.§:€.i{';z:€;%§' fiiiéii ix?-.i;:g§ is": p<:=:+;;<:s€::=;;<-3i<:::f::"; {K €:ffi&~:<t%..iw;t ;><>:"~;;s-:»:3s_ss;§@:"2 " €135" :::§"§%3::?i4évs;? <é:ts':':£,:*<::E Ci? gggzmgza in {}'1.Ei?f%?;§€)Z"E. .f31%Z§{I1i.?iEZ§?{i§}' mi xvzzg ";i"2wcE§m.;,;; in ax: gum} be2~,':ri::'2g_3; N0i*IA-€}5--Efi}~¢E922 a1E{>11g witifz <3t:h:::" a<?:{':u$<::{i p«€:r.:s:<>nS \,x.r§r1€;'::in ?;*mndE€:ses flzzrags <i:<m€.ami:1g; gang Wm; sseégzaéci by C€3mp}ia_r:<:€: af n1ar:{121m1"y :"'e{;:..:i;f¢;1:§r1'11,"'E{§:1§:i::2 :«:see:ns'~; $10 i":;e3;1?s: bees: iitcmipiieti as sjagleaégjrrwa EXam.2L:i1:£ng said issssue in at iiefiraiiiciy prejudice ihgz. and p§"<:sSecu€.i0r:, as such €_§XE?Lé'f3f1i'E'1€5. in dfitaii sincte issztgptz' {if {fcjrzééiciéiriilggiihc sgziid plea whiie < {30I"iSid€3I'§Hg §..E1€. §.">r'a'::.;»-<_;j3" 0.1 --..p£2T.if;i0I":§.%rfor being enlarged an baii b€:Vi':ag_Av§j;im.iii§id. "'-.80 21{s§'=:3w--t:Iie Corzéerltion }'a§S€d with reggfird {'0 Sc3.2"{r£:'§'i.{%(:qj:i;E--1;{;j%::c:%d on amtused pf.-'-:1'S€}I'}.S as ::z§:1$:::':rs;;3_:21?;etE"~2:;:1d§3f _SAé3::pfi<;fi §G <}'f };\;?.§).P.S Act. 1'vIaE;er:i3_E §}fi'3'§'L§§.§{}'§'"§%;ff wag; '%4:*2:a-F2"-%§§.§.::a;§ :i;_:'; éézej ameziy 2¥E:%<T?%'2 2:522:53 us%;e{,'§ ii}? :'Av";'i%;'§fifffc1'.%.§.:':'§§§a% 011 §"€f{f'O2'C§ Ea :?{.>::":;n<3<:E: the £i{',i§'.iL§S§_'*.d 1a?i"§I':;§"' .vE';ifi€?'fZ§"y"§.7Eify' {T}? <;%i'£'.h£3:' E32"<}w'i': sazgar befilg £2: ..f:»§>§}:+3$§?§9s;~$V§.'€:s;'fs 3:' §f2E'€j}%.}.gE.'£E'. fez}? $236?' in $33.6 ggaid %}2;:,::i:k§§§*m,:;'1d ' "::A'.:z1 £?}<;2':iEEEiE'§£i'iZ§{BE'E <3? §::ri§:t%:'é€:<:% am .::"€?<':<"::"z:.§.§ £%§t;§2ééE§:a;':",::= C£:>'i.i.I:"€ §3:e25-~; g.§§a?::;'1 §',E'1E.-'E 'z3§:z:"r::?f§1; 5.2%' €:§<:}z.[:h§. ¥;"<'> Iézgé: 2;§:::{"::.::ssz:?:;§ _ 2'; _ Re: {ii} €r1,F.,2642,»'290? -- Oz": S:€%{ff§"EJii§§E'"§j.f" <3?" .E."€("€}I'€f§§.43, '$1.239; £:'£>uri:. {amid that; m2m<iai'.:}:*';; <:<;~m_pE§_2m<;_:€%. iikf 3&2-<:§%a}:: 58 $1? Nlf),E?S AC3: 'Jv'::?:E:"a' zmct a_V2:iiab§e an :"é;?:<*:{.>:A;§j;c.f§_;'--V 21%:-;<:s .€m_m.d 'ihazti pet.it;i£}x":<;:r was rm; 4;::> 3f:.;§f-:e:.t_i%jE;:.V..§;'[ p<;sS€$si€>:": <3f:m.21t,<:%.ri.ais s«:;e1?ze{i. '{f§1<:?
ve:'y s£:at€:m::2_i', 01" .peti'{i<:1';§7:r_ xass:
N=:':.E wcmici gié is sahova i2133:.:f3e;":i;'i:.i;31i'€3% €10 irzmsgpart:/<:a12'ry 18 1;21§:;1:3Atic :gf.g;:nj21 he @5218 aware sf it. Hence Said j'€.IaQi§:{:fZ'i€i}.'15£5'55 §ii_E§;p«§)1.i(3é}.b}€ €10 'thfi zfacts cf {I39 Re: V -- in the gsaié irzzse EiCCi.I8€.;€§ far (}ff4';":1'1(Z'€ 11315181' Sectxiora 8 {C} 21 0? N 319.8 Aitr. m-*i1i<:h e1§p£'._§§':;«i§l" s::;:11w;; fay. E?i;§§::<i:'%'fi;'CC}i by ac:£§a1im?ng§ i;h_€ £?1{T:~{;Tf%§EE:'a€'3£T§ by .§§iw;§.,:':g;.; _::g::»:;f5ns:-ii: <1»? daubt S§§E{?%'3 §;h€:"€ Weiss»; :10 {;:h.s*.}:' 5 1'/(V i j.§::'i% §:%:ii2}:fg_;§;§V'r'fie._§§i$::%€.§'t,%{::r1€:" 0:2 '::z:«3.§E, A<i*<:{>':'<i%ng._;§i§fi pe§i'é:ir:,>;1 fig " ";é;f'§%;:x:
_g;_ }"§€;'fE'1{'."{?f Sziaid _fE.§{,J£§§}'1'1é'31'1i. is ii}Efi§}_§f}.E.§§'f£iEi)§€? {fa E,fE€* .§L2;a{:'¥?::&; <3? £E'1<% i.'.&S3:';?? cm §'12m:'i at: §'}.'E."€E':EfS€fE'E?..
Re: (v; 2004 CCR 432 - Vijay Vs E1": the? said (322186: ii: wase; f'<>1::':,¢-e;Ti"" 33113:: 'A s3t:z;1.n£§i:1g maxi: to :12, car and m>i', ._ ::11'1<7i aéa; 5~3u<:h it; was h:':id ;§}€;*;;E;iE.'i--:f}f£&%;": §:1 {i'ff£%C'{ii/'f3'. p()ssessi<>n <3:f7"p;>pp}V?"éét:*::vJ :"§;ac;<>ver€-§ti"iT:":' ':;h<;: §s2::.i{£ case anti 2153 s5;uci'1 he was; -16-:.fi]2i.:'i_§§&Vd _£)}>"V3"?AA_3'.E7€Vi»I ;_;Ei1 the i:1s5ti2111f;, case €3V€'.1'1 a€?Cj~{':i'Cl_if:.-g iiégg \.n§>.I1;.1;i1i.'a1"§f «S§Z£1{'._§3_ii1€I1f, of pe'i:it:i<m<:r hin1Stt}.f hei£2s;a1;~i'§1"ii.€%eE1ii§§§."iri' ihs 5-i»'y:;1i'::i vE:1'1i(::ie:: as 21C1:11_i1:.t;<3d by hiijfz for..,i.re1:1é§;5{;A1ftjing 18 V"f3Iast.i{: bags <:{)z1iaim11g §g;21.z1j23M E{e':':cte,, 'e-3;:%j1'cA£_j }1,:%:;igfi1€-fl't: aiszm i§123p;3iir321bEe to the §21€Et§3_:i>T.7' the éziasfis; -
~ €§{}i_ -?§.h€;'f.S€ {:ir{r'{1';;1'1ét.em{ms, ¥i:§":§.$ {",€}E3E""i. £55 net. i::s':1.§mé{i :°e;§§@.{,:E.<3{E,V. . L' 'T Sé; 4 §EE:E§§ 533% ;§m § ' '