Karnataka High Court
Manager, The New India Assurance Co. Ltd vs Dundayya Irayya Shirkolmath on 15 June, 2012
Author: V.Jagannathan
Bench: V.Jagannathan
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD
LLITED TI4 ' r 1
J:
BE ED RE
THE HON'BLE MRJUSTICE VJAGANNATHAN
1pcI1QAOiMYJ
Ciw,
A2i1L7QIQ
BETWEEN:
MANAGER.
THE NEW LIDl SL R\CE CD LID
ERINATH COMPLEX, lIED FLOOR
( T''O\ EP I'T RIB
1
I\P
iL, SR D
THE NEW INDIA SSURNCE CO. LTD
C ORB ROAD, BELGAUM
BITRPEG'OWfl''T(E fl
i•L• ITT B U ILDIN C AN N EXE
P LITCLI P\D PCD [\TRTQJ CR1
BANGA]..ORE 560 027,
REPT BY ITS PEG .1 ONAL MAN.AGDR
DUNDUG 1RAYYA 5H[L5KQL745TR
j( : IL
RU L0K\Pt'R. TQI 'MI 1)1101
: SF1 \NKARbPfl BI1iMPPi KiT!! Ui
\GK TAJOR. OC C 131 SiNF
R ('HUSKER!. ru R4ML 1.Rb%
RhSP )X UL\ rs
(th Sri SVsJ4\ SK1kflLRI U)\ PORR1
SRi H.M DHARIGOND. .\DV FOR It?!
MFA.CROB.790L12:
BETWEEN.
Dt \I)'fl\k S,O. IRkN\A SHIRKOLMATI-L
AGED ABOrT. 35 'tEARS. ()( C. %GRICUL"I IRE
Ru LOKAPI.. Ii. Nj MIDHOL
1)TS P B '½G %LKOr.
tROSS OBJF( I( R
(B Sr SAN.J U S KAT \GE AD\
AND:
SI! \SK UtWP BHIM4J'PA Kill! W
4 1E1' %flOI I "0 L:\RS.
(3 L(
i\'-Ns I FR iT"
.
0 dO'1\TtR11 if; R''Tr)' t'3.8
-1 IA i
I 4% C • )i ' iL)1' . I C
I) , ; i#i • , r j r
'f"' C)
i . i-i't '.\ L( <C
'q i i
n'•\ --! ' i '; ':j jgtJs,R H' L.'.
44
'i"I -I .
• .1.
--
• T
COtRTII & ADDL MiCT flW%LM P4RTLY
ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION POR
C OMPENS %tIOI% U%D '3EEKNG F NHAN( F MF NT OF
C OMPF NSA'flON
The's
i i i 'i c hr s ' ths
day t c Cc urt delncred the 1o1Ioing
JUDGMENT
this ippeal nd roes ob;c c tion arises out of one and thc s'nne anrd passcd in thi MiCT md the appc al b the rnsur inc e compani is in respec 01 the "I ribi nal h avinp a ardc d the compensation undei the head f 1 s f drperidenc y hit In ti fe'l Ins e t e i an h eli
-t -'3 -'3 0. 0 0 • 3' CD 'C '-I I 9' W CD 1 W op 't 1 4 b S Q WI 0 z L C 'p •1 -* Ws '0 .2.
CD CD 0 ti - a
-4 I b C, CD
CD
' - a *
Pr -)
CD 0 0. 4' '-4 •D .
cc a. -, CD a. CD 3 t (1 -3 3 0 00 ,.,
-- 2 CD "
' Wj
*
(V 12
4
0 B -
a,
WI ':r
% a, Ct
• 4 4-,
D - -1
0. -t a 1
Ct cc 4 1,
'D
1 .2. -' - -4' 1 0 ' I
0) U 4 1 I 3' .44 4 1 .4 V. '
- £ a. - 0' I CD CD ' a H CD rt CD C C C H e r z 0 C CD H CD CD CD ON CD F* C) ON: FCD CD CD Cl. O CD CD CDL CD C 0 LD C CD CD H. CD 0 a t 0 C CL a CD C) CD 0 CD CD 0 CD C C S CD re CD CD CL C Fm C CD CD I rt Cr E CD Zr - 0 CD o CD 5 -- CD Zr 0 CD C F CD -" 0
-f e -- CC r 0 H C 0 CD Fj C) C CD r es --" CD CD C A4 --.
C C Z CD 0 CD Fm
Ci) (j CD
-- CD --
-- C Ci
a CD 0 CD
CD -- H CD C)
CD CC 01 < 0 0
-- CD
00 0 C CD
Zr H .
CD C: Zr
-- Zr CD Q 0 Zr
--
C)
o CD
Ci
CD en CD CD 0 C
a-
CD
cC
CD
CD CD
c - 02
CD C C CD
a CD C
CD
0. CD a CD
S C Zr 0 0 C)
CD 0 j 0
Zr C C) 5 C CL
r+ CD 0
CL ICS o CD
C - 0 CD
4 -4.
C 0 ef (C
Fm
cC C)
cC C
P rt
t.. b* C CD CD
Cr Zr
Ca rt Fm
.
me. --" CD
:CD Dj
1 CD C c'n
CD Ci
øTh EI. 0
tci - C)
C 0
re C) rt
Zr CD CC nt C
CD CD CD o Zr Zr CD C
0 N CD CL CD Ci