Rajasthan High Court - Jaipur
Kokila Sharma &Ors vs State Of Raj & Ors on 15 February, 2010
Author: Ajay Rastogi
Bench: Ajay Rastogi
In the High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan
Jaipur Bench
**
Civil Writ Petition No.8969/2009
Kokila Sharma & Ors Versus State & Ors.
(& Cognate cases as per Schedule annexed)
Date of Order ::: 15/02/10
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ajay Rastogi
For petitioners -
Sarva Shri Rajendra Pd. Sharma, SK Jindal, Rampratap Saini,
Tanveer Ahmed, Ramavtar Bachalya, Ishwar Tiwari, Omveer Saini,
CPSharma, Suresh K.Pareek, Subhash Sharma, Shailesh K.Panwar,
Rajiv Bandhu, Anoop Dhand, Atma R.Meena, Liyakat Ali, CL Saini,
Mukesh Bijrania, RD Meena, Naveen Dhuwan, Manish Sharma, RB Sharma,
PL Sharma, Arvind Sharma, Rameshwar Sharma, Narendra Tiwari,
Rajesh Gadwal, Manoj S.Raghav, NS Hada, Bharat Saini, Munseh Bhardwaj, Neeraj K.Tewari, Sandeep Garassa, Brijesh Bhardwaj, Ritesh Jain,
Vijay Pathak, Samay Singh, Thakurlal Pandey, Pushpendra P.Singh,
Dhamrendra Barala, Sushil Sharma, Vinod Kr. Sharma, M.Iqbal singh,
Sudesh Bansal, Girish Khandelwal, Vinod Goyal, Rahul Kanwar, Ajay Gupta, Manoj Bhardwaj, Mohar P.Meena, Kuldeep Verma, Jeetendra Kr. Sharma
SK Gupta, DS Choudhary, Bharat Yadav, Praveen Sharma, DS Jadaun,
Amit S.Shekhawat, Krishan Sharma, DP Pujari, Hanuman Choudhary,
Himmat S.Bikarwar, Raj K.Kasan, Babu L.Sharma, Ashok K.Shahdadpuri,
Ram K. Sharma, Dr. Mahesh Sharma, Swarj Panwar, Prakash Thakuria,
Sumit Khandelwal, Pankaj Jain, Suresh Bundela, R.Kajla, S.Balwada,
Raj K.Goyal, Rajeev Sogarwal, Mahendra Sharma, Nawal S.Sikarwar,
Sunil Kr. Singodia, Pratap S. Sirohi, Abdul K.Khan, YK Sharma,
Bipin Gupta, Shashi B.Gupta, MukeshPoonia, Bhupendra Pareek,
Rakesh Paliwal, Ashindra Gautam, Sandeep Jain, Shivendra S.Rathore, Raghunandan Sharma, DD Khandelwal, Jai K.Yogi, SR Saini,
NS Dhakar, RA Verma, Dayanand Yadav, Devi S.Choudhary
Amin Ali, Abhishek Sharma, SKSaksena, JP Gargey, PS Sharma,
Sanjay Rahar, Sumer Singh, LS Tomar, Govind Sharma, Dr. Saugat Roy,
Imran Khan, Shiv S Ola, Shiv L. Meena, Asnhuman Saxena,
Hemant Sharma, SR Choudhary, Amrit Pd.Sharma, Ajay Goyal,
Akhilesh Saini, Prem K.Sharma, Mahesh Gautam, and
Ms Manju Sharma, Sudesh Kasana, Anisha Jain, & Pradeep Lata Mathur.
Mr. SN Kumawat, AAG and for respondent PSC
Mr. Ganesh Meena, Govt. Counsel for respondents
All these petitions as per Schedule A attached herewith since involve common question, hence at joint request, are being disposed of by present order.
Counsel for petitioners jointly submit that petitioners were engaged/appointed as Vidhyarthi Mitra on contract basis till the persons regularly selected by Rajasthan Public Service Commission (RPSC) and Departmental Promotion committee are made available. However, services of persons who were similarly situated while working as Vidhyarthi Mitra were terminated by respondents. A bunch of 633 writ petitions (CWP-4652/2009 & cognate cases) were decided by this Court vide judgment dt.08/05/2009 with operative part ad infra:
(36) Accordingly, the writ petitions are disposed of as under:
I. During continuation of the work, as detailed out herein above the invocation of the last extension is arbitrary and illegal; and the consequential automatic termination orders of the petitioners are set aside. II. The RPSC/DPC selected candidates/employees are still not available and next academic session is about to start; even urgent temporary appointments under Rule 28 of the Rules of 1971 are not possible due to short span of one month and a half left to start with the process of admission and academic session, therefore, as per the aims and objects of the Scheme, respondents are directed to consider the cases of the petitioners for continuation in service till regularly selected candidates from RPSC/persons selected and recommended by the DPC for promotion are made available in the light of the above observations; III. Even in case of appropriate order of continuation in service till regularly selected candidates from RPSC/DPC selected persons are available, the petitioners are not entitled for wages of the vacations, in other words, when the schools are closed. IV. In case the regularly selected candidates from RPSC/persons selected and recommended by the DPC for promotion are made available, then the respondents can terminate services of the petitioners after preparation of the seniority list on the State level as per their date of appointment and merit assigned to them, by following the principle of 'last come first go' to the extent of availability of the selected candidates and while doing so, the respondents will keep the interest of the present students and prospective students in view. Counsel submits that since issue raised in instant bunch of petitions stands decided by co-ordinate Bench of this Court vide judgment (supra), these petitions may also be decided in the light thereof. Counsel for petitioners further submit that in the light of judgment (supra), the directions have been issued by the Department of Elementary Education, Govt. of Rajasthan vide letter dt.11/08/09 to the Director of Elementary Education Bikaner to permit all such persons working as Vidhyarthi Mitra in present academic session but their continuance will be subject to final outcome of special appeals having been preferred by respondents State against judgment dt.08/05/2009. Some of the petitioners have raised their grievance that despite judgment dt. 08/05/09 of the Court and directions issued by State Government, they have not been permitted to work/discharge duties as Vidhyarthu Mitra. However, it has not been disputed by Government Counsel about controversy involved herein being decided by this Court vide judgment dt.08/05/2009 alongwith directions (supra) - against which, their only defence is that special appeals (SA(W)-1237/2009 & 525/2009 besides other cognate appeals) have been preferred by respondents State and wherein vide order dt.16/12/09, the Division Bench ordered ad infra: Since in the impugned judgment, a direction exists at para 36(IV) with regard to termination of Vidhyarthi Mitra on the basis of State level seniority list, though appointments were not made on State level list, therefore, operation of aforesaid para 36(IV) may be stayed because in absencde of termination, selected candidates cannot be appointed. Looking to the submission made, operation of the direction in para 36(IV) of the impugned judgment shall remain stayed.. However, as regards contention of petitioners Government Counsel submits that directions have been issued by the department concerned, and District Education Officer/concerned officer will ensure that in the light of judgment dt.08/05/09 (supra), the petitioners may be permitted to join and discharge their duties as Vidhyarthi Mitra; but their continuance will be subject to final outcome of special appeals preferred by respondents State, which has not been objected by petitioners' Counsel, as well. In the light of what has been observed in CWP-4652/2009 vide judgment dt.08/05/2009 alongwith directions quoted (supra), all these writ petitions as per Schedule A attached herewith stand disposed of; and the District Education Officer/concerned officer will also ensure that in the light of judgment (supra), the petitioners shall be permitted to join and discharge their duties as Vidhyarthi Mitra; however, it would be subject to afore quoted stay order and final outcome of special appeals (SA(W)-1237/09 & 525/2009 besides cognate appeals) would be binding upon all the petitioners, as well. No costs. (Ajay Rastogi), J.
K.Khatri/p14/ 8969CW2009-Fb15-Vidyarthi(559).doc Schedule - Judgment dt.15/02/2010 in CWP-8969/2009 & Cognate cases *** S.No. CWP Nos. / Name of Petitioners Versus State & Ors 1.8969/2009 Kokila Sharma & Others 2.7069/2009 Yogesh Kumar 3.7779/2009 Kailash Chand Bairwa & Others 4.7919/2009 Jitendra Kr. Bairwa & Anr 5.8584/2009 Ravi Kumar Mehta 6.8987/2009 Dinesh Kr. Nagar & Anr 7.8990/2009 Hemraj Napit & Anr 8.9016/2009 Ramesh Chand Bairwa 9.9027/2009 Tara Chand Dax 10.9035/2009 Nawal Kishore 11.9248/2009 Rajendra S.Choudhary 12.9252/2009 Brajesh Yadav 13.9274/2009 Shiv Kr. Sharma 14.9346/2009 Kamlesh Patidar & Ors 15.9365/2009 Rajendra Singh 16.9373/2009 Adul Rehman Husain 17.9383/2009 Kailash C.Avasthi & Others 18.9493/2009 Janaki Lal Meena 19.9503/2009 Virendra Vikram S.Shekhawat 20.9538/2009 Ram Naresh Meena & Others 21.9558/2009 Anita Tiwadi 22.9609/2009 Ramavtar Meena 23.9619/2009 Sarvesh Kr. Sharma & Others 24.9623/2009 Lokesh Kumar & Others 25.9627/2009 Bhanwar Lal Bijarania 26.9633/2009 Radhey Shyam Sharma & Others 27.9659/2009 Mahendra Kr. Meena & Anr 28.9673/2009 Neetu 29.9676/2009 Ram Sahai Meena 30.9677/2009 Madan Lal Mali & Others 31.9681/2009 Anita Agarwal & Anr 32.9682/2009 Mahaveer Kumawat & Others 33.9726/2009 Lohar Puri Goswami 34.9750/2009 Manju Verma 35.9751/2009 Preeti Rajput & Anr. 36.9763/2009 Santu Lal Yadav & Others 37.9804/2009 Mohanlal & Others 38.9856/2009 Gajendra Singh & Others 39.9863/2009 Shankar Lal Bairwa 40.9864/2009 Sunita Pareek 41.9882/2009 Suman Beniwal 42.9893/2009 Ramniwas Jat 43.9899/2009 Nanuram Yadav & Others 44.9938/2009 Naresh Gupta 45.10166/2009 Omveer Singh & Anr. 46.10177/2009 Dilip Kr. Meena 47.10184/2009 Shakuntala Kumari 48.10198/2009 Smt. Suman Sharma 49.10224/2009 Pratap Singh & Others 50.10228/2009 Lalit Kishore Goyal 51.10232/2009 Madhusudan & Anr 52.10233/2009 Bhagwan Singh & Anr. 53.10244/2009 Miss Gheesi Devi 54.10260/2009 Rajendra Kumar & Others 55.10299/2009 Tulsi Ram Meena & Others 56.10320/2009 Shyam Lal Yogi & Anr 57.10351/2009 Kamlesh Kumar 58.10352/2009 Ms Manju Kumar Bamil 59.10354/2009 Mahesh Soni 60.10375/2009 Smt. Manju Sharma 61.10388/2009 Suresh Kumar Meena & Others 62.10449/2009 Kishan Lal Yadav 63.10450/2009 Kanhaiya Lal Bairwa & Others 64.10439/2009 Allanoor 65.10500/2009 Sumitra Kumar & Anr. 66.10507/2009 Bhura Lal Gurjar & Others 67.10573/2009 Mukesh Kumar & Others 68.10595/2009 Tikaram Meena & Anr. 69.10603/2009 Pawan Kumar 70.10609/2009 Yogesh Kr. Sharma 71.10611/2009 Pradeep Kr. Sharma & Others 72.10649/2009 Rajpal Gurjar 73.10660/2009 Pooja Garg 74.10667/2009 Hari Ram 75.10676/2009 Kamlesh Kr. Mali 76.10683/2009 Pawan Kr. Sharma 77.10699/2009 Sita Ram Meena & Anr. 78.10739/2009 Anil Kr. Sharma & Anr 79.10811/2009 Smt. Priti Thakur 80.10821/2009 Brij Kishore Sharma & Ors. 81.10861/2009 Chandra Mohan Mehta 82.10862/2009 Puran Mal Meena 83.10944/2009 Balwant Surela & Others 84.10958/2009 Gayatri Sharma & Others 85.10959/2009 Mukesh Meena 86.10963/2009 Bhupendra Kr. Rathore & Others 87.10981/2009 Om Dutt Sharma 88.10991/2009 Smt. Anjali Mishra 89.10992/2009 Ram Prakash & Others 90.11002/2009 Shishu Pal Singh 91.11004/2009 Rajendra Kumar Nagar & Others 92.11023/2009 Nilima Garg & Others 93.11040/2009 Geeta Sharma 94.11050/2009 Gajendra Kr. Saini & Anr. 95.11052/2009 Bihari Pd. Goutam & Anr. 96.11067/2009 Lokendra Pratap Singh & Ors. 97.11068/2009 Krishan Kr. Saini 98.11075/2009 Smt. Poona Saroj 99.11083/2009 Pawan Kr. Kumawat 100.11084/2009 Prakash Chand Bairwa 101.11088/2009 GaneshLal Kahtik & Anr 102.11089/2009 Shiv Dayal Bairwa 103.11090/2009 Smt. Ruchi 104.11097/2009 Deen Dayal Sharma 105.11132/2009 Birbal Ram & Ors.
106.11140/2009 Mukesh Singh & Ors. 107.11159/2009 Vikram Singh & Anr 108.11166/2009 Smt. Kavita Dhingra 109.11173/2009 Ashish Gupta 110.11174/2009 Tara Tailor & Anr 111.11189/2009 Sangeeta Kumari Mathuria & Ors. 112.11191/2009 Om Prakash Khangar & Ors. 113.11207/2009 Mukesh Kr Sharma & Anr 114.11217/2009 Nand Kishore Bairwa 115.11218/2009 Mukesh Kumar 116.11219/2009 Ramesh Chand Bairwa 117.11228/2009 Suman Jain 118.11230/2009 Ram Naresh & Ors.
119.11242/2009 Mool Chand Sharma & Anr 120.11243/2009 Surya Prakash Suwalaka & Anr 121.11258/2009 Dilbag Singh 122.11278/2009 Bhawan Lal Jangid 123.11280/2009 Jitendra Kr Vaishnav 124.11298/2009 Smt Poonam 125.11300/2009 Smt. Geeta Devi Meena & Anr 126.11309/2009 Rajendra Kr. Meena 127.11319/2009 Ranveer Singh 128.11332/2009 Sudesh Gurjar & Ors. 129.11363/2009 Ram Sahai Yadav & Ors. 130.11366/2009 Ravindra S. Tanwar & Anr 131.11373/2009 Mena Aod 132.11375/2009 Daulat S. Rathore & Ors. 133.11378/2009 Chandra Prakash & Anr 134.11382/2009 Raghu Nandan Sharma 135.11389/2009 Naresh & Ors.
136.11404/2009 Kamlesh Kr Vyas 137.11406/2009 Hemlata Rathore 138.11410/2009 Shiv Kant Sharma & Anr 139.11426/2009 Smt. Sarla Sharma 140.11429/2009 Kamlesh Choudhary 141.11430/2009 Chandra Prakash Nagar 142.11431/2009 Sukhdev 143.11465/2009 Pallavi Jain & Anr. 144.11479/2009 Mrs Santosh Dhabas & Ors. 145.11481/2009 Rajendra Kr. Sharma 146.11488/2009 Manju Kumari 147.11489/2009 Vinod Kumar & Ors. 148.11512/2009 Bhajan Lal & Anr 149.11531/2009 Kamlesh Kumar Sain 150.11539/2009 Smt. Vimla Devi & Ors 151.11540/2009 Prem Chand Bairwa & Ors 152.11553/2009 Anil Kumar 153.11555/2009 Kamlesh Bajorila & Anr 154.11560/2009 Anita Kumari & Anr 155.11570/2009 Durga Lal Meena & Ors. 156.11580/2009 Subhita Kumari Harijan & Ors. 157.11586/2009 Mahesh Kumar & Ors. 158.11600/2009 Shrwan Lal Gurjar & Ors. 159.11605/2009 Amba Lal Meena & Ors. 160.11606/2009 Rajesh Singh 161.11607/2009 Anil Kumar Soni 162.11610/2009 Tej Singh 163.11622/2009 Sheoji Ram Yadav & Ors. 164.11635/2009 Prabhu Lal 165.11636/2009 Kamlesh Yadav 166.11655/2009 Chagan Lal Verma & Ors. 167.11658/2009 Hari Narain Pareek 168.11660/2009 Ramgopal Dhabai 169.11667/2009 Tarkeshwar Barwar & Ors. 170.11668/2009 Mahesh Kr Sharma & Ors. 171.11671/2009 Manoj Kumar 172.11674/2009 Anju Bala Shekhawat 173.11696/2009 Pradeep Kumar Sharma 174.11704/2009 Mukut Bihariu Lal & Ors. 175.11722/2009 Laxmi Devi & Ors.
176.11741/2009 Brijesh Singh Tanwar 177.11745/2009 Rajendra Sharma & Ors. 178.11750/2009 Dinesh Kr. Meghwal & Ors 179.11804/2009 Rajesh Kr. Verma 180.11836/2009 Madhu Saxena & Ors 181.11838/2009 Rajesh Kumar 182.11865/2009 Mastram Meena 183.11867/2009 Kishan Sahai Meena 184.11877/2009 Kumari Assma Parveen Qureshi 185.11885/2009 Pinki Kumari Nainiwal 186.11906/2009 Sanjay Kumar 187.11909/2009 Ram Gopal Meena & Ors. 188.11916/2009 Gordhan Singh & Ors. 189.11919/2009 Ms Kanchan Vaishnav & Anr 190.11921/2009 Pavan Kumar 191.11923/2009 Ravi Shankar Sharma & Ors. 192.11924/2009 Dharmendra Meena & Ors. 193.11925/2009 Ms Sonu Kumari Sharma 194.11929/2009 Pawan Giri 195.11948/2009 Sohan Singh & Anr 196.11949/2009 Pappu Ram 197.11962/2009 Girraj Prasad Sharma & Anr 198.11971/2009 Budhi Prakash Khatik & Ors. 199.11987/2009 Buddhi Prakash Khatik & Ors. 200.11988/2009 Mukesh C .Meena & Ors 201.12014/2009 Bhura Lal Gurjar 202.12018/2009 Pappu Ram Saini & Ors. 203.12019/2009 Suresh Kr. Verma & Ors. 204.12022/2009 Ashok Kr. Meena & Ors. 205.12025/2009 Latoor Lal Bairwa & Ors. 206.12030/2009 Meera Kumawat & Ors 207.12031/2009 Suresh Kr. Sahu 208.12036/2009 Anita Sharma 209.12037/2009 Matadeen Sharma & Ors. 210.12042/2009 Duli Chand Sharma 211.12051/2009 Hari Charan 212.12056/2009 Shyam Sundar Lal Sarasainiya 213.12057/2009 Kamal Prasad Meena & Anr 214.12058/2009 Rajesh Sharma 215.12059/2009 Amar Deep Meena 216.12060/2009 Satish Kr. Bairwa 217.12063/2009 Jitendra Kr. Gupta 218.12064/2009 Mrs Rekha Sharma & Anr 219.12094/2009 Smt. Krishan & Ors. 220.12101/2009 Ram Ganesh Meena 221.12102/2009 Paras Chand Jain & Anr 222.12103/2009 Surendra S. Parmar 223.12104/2009 Anita Pareek & Anr. 224.12123/2009 Ram Kant Sharma & Ors. 225.12128/2009 Surendra Kr. Verma 226.12129/2009 Shailendra Kr. Haritwal 227.12135/2009 Bachan Singh Gurjar & Ors. 228.12156/2009 Hemant Kr. Sharma 229.12158/2009 Aruna & Ors.
230.12161/2009 Saroj Jain 231.12170/2009 Mahesh Chand Sharma 232.12176/2009 Ramesh Kr. Kumhar 233.12198/2009 Saroj Kumari 234.12199/2009 Smt. Pushpa Panwar 235.12211/2009 Rajendra Rankawat 236.12220/2009 Rajendra Kr. Sain & Anr 237.12224/2009 Mahesh Kumar Sharma 238.12228/2009 Ashutosh Gautam & Ors. 239.12239/2009 Rajesh Kr. Sharma & Ors. 240.12249/2009 Hari Pal Yadav 241.12253/2009 Anand Pal Singh Shekhawat 242.12285/2009 Ajay singh 243.12341/2009 Mohd. Anwar Ali 244.12361/2009 Rajmal Meena & Ors. 245.12369/2009 Balram 246.12370/2009 Mahendra Kr. Kumawat 247.12394/2009 Ynush 248.12396/2009 Vishnu Singh & Ors 249.12412/2009 Radha Kumari & Ors. 250.12428/2009 Meenaxi Gwarela & Ors. 251.12429/2009 Kirodi Lal Saini 252.12438/2009 Rakesh Kr. Meena & Ors. 253.12447/2009 Brahm Singh 254.12458/2009 Mintu Kumari 255.12471/2009 Smt. Shanti Devi Sharma & Ors 256.12488/2009 Ram Karan Meena & Ors. 257.12495/2009 Harphool Singh Kudi & Ors. 258.12496/2009 Manoj Kr. Jain 259.12525/2009 Dinesh Kr. Sharma & Ors. 260.12541/2009 Pappu Lal Gurjar & Ors. 261.12543/2009 Rajesh Kumar & Ors. 262.12548/2009 Biram Singh 263.12574/2009 Prabhu Lal Meena 264.12576/2009 Hari Ram 265.12578/2009 Tej Singh 266.12634/2009 Jaspal Singh & Ors. 267.12642/2009 Mange Lal 268.12648/2009 Reena Yadav & Ors. 269.12656/2009 Ravindra Kumar & Ors 270.12662/2009 Anita Sharma & Ors. 271.12664/2009 Ram Singh Chaudhary 272.12702/2009 Sidhendra Sharan Sharma 273.12705/2009 Suresh Kr. Kumawat 274.12710/2009 Jitendra Singh 275.12711/2009 Radhey Shyam Meena & Ors 276.12712/2009 Ghashi Lal Nagar & Anr 277.12716/2009 Pramod Kr. Jitendra & Anr 278.12719/2009 Sapna Agarwal & Ors. 279.12760/2009 Liyakat Ali & Anr 280.12763/2009 Mangal Chand 281.12766/2009 Alka Sharma 282.12767/2009 Narjeet Singh 283.12772/2009 Radhey Shyam 284.12773/2009 Yashpal Singh 285.12782/2009 Asha & Ors.
286.12788/2009 Abdul Kalam Khan 287.12806/2009 Dharma Veer & Anr 288.12813/2009 Pushpa Kumari 289.12819/2009 Manoj Kumar 290.12820/2009 Manisha Yadav & Ors. 291.12830/2009 Smt. Mamta Kumawat & Anr. 292.12839/2009 Anita 293.12852/2009 Deepa Bai & Anr.
294.12854/2009 Sudhakar Sharma 295.12855/2009 Kailash S.Choudhary & Ors. 296.12857/2009 Om Prakash Meena & Anr 297.12859/2009 Kamla Bochlya 298.12865/2009 Nirmal Chandra 299.12870/2009 Prem Chand Yadav 300.12872/2009 Om Prakash Meena & Ors. 301.12874/2009 Ram Baboo Sharma 302.12895/2009 Smt. Babita Sharma & Ors. 303.12897/2009 Mukesh Kumar Meena 304.12898/2009 Manish Soni & Ors. 305.12901/2009 Meena Solanki & Anr. 306.12927/2009 Manoj Kumar Lodwal 307.12936/2009 Prithvi Raj 308.12942/2009 Uma Shankar Sharma 309.12943/2009 Smt. Ranjana Mittal 310.12946/2009 Satya Prakash Sharma & Ors. 311.12957/2009 Ghan Shyam Sharma 312.12960/2009 Gajendra Gautam & Anr 313.12976/2009 Bhanwar Lal Meena & Ors. 314.12977/2009 Viswbandhu Lakhera & Ors. 315.12993/2009 Sandeep Singh Solanki 316.12994/2009 Punam Panwar 317.13005/2009 Smt. Kamlesh Saini 318.13029/2009 Rishi Raj Sharma 319.13045/2009 Ms Monika Kumari 320.13048/2009 Jagdish Pd. Nagar 321.13049/2009 Shyam Sunder Sharma 322.13054/2009 Pappu Lal Bairwa 323.13067/2009 Ather Ali 324.13068/2009 Suniya 325.13081/2009 Miss Sarita Jain 326.13099/2009 Ram Swaroop Kumhar 327.13108/2009 Narmohan Meena & Ors. 328.13109/2009 Om Prakash Sharma 329.13118/2009 Raj Kumari Jain 330.13122/2009 Dasrath Goswami 331.13130/2009 Dinesh Chand Sharma & Ors. 332.13151/2009 Hansraj Sharma & Anr. 333.13161/2009 Neerendra Kumar & Ors. 334.13172/2009 Rishikesh Sharma & Ors. 335.13175/2009 Rakesh Kr. Meena & Anr. 336.13181/2009 Sunil Dutt Arya 337.13204/2009 Radhe Shyam Charmkar 338.13208/2009 Sharmila Kumari 339.13211/2009 Brij Raj Meena 340.13214/2009 Pramod Kr. Upadhyay & Ors. 341.13215/2009 Shrwan Kumar & Others 342.13216/2009 Ms Rupali Sharma 343.13221/2009 Hari Prasad Meena 344.13229/2009 Rajesh Kumar Jat 345.13246/2009 Pradeep Kumar Tailor 346.13518/2009 Mukesh Kumar Sharma 347.13608/2009 Kailash Narayan Bairwa & Ors 348.13627/2009 Babulal Gurjar & Ors 349.13630/2009 Girraj Prasad Saini 350.13631/2009 Asha Ram & Anr 351.13640/2009 Manju Kumari Arya 352.13659/2009 Phool Chand Meena 353.13666/2009 Tara Chand & Others 354.13692/2009 Hanuman Gautam 355.13743/2009 Vinod Kumar 356.13746/2009 Pawan Kr. Sharma 357.13758/2009 Brij Kishor 358.13781/2009 Tara Chand 359.13787/2009 Nand Ram & Ors.
360.13825/2009 Hakim Singh 361.13917/2009 Dharam Raj Meena & Anr 362.14019/2009 Yogendra Kr. Prajapati & Ors 363.14020/2009 Bablesh Kumar & Ors. 364.14032/2009 Ramesh Chand Bairwa & Ors 365.14058/2009 Ram Avatar Jat 366.14063/2009 Rajesh Singh Gurjar 367.14069/2009 Praveen Kumar & Ors. 368.14088/2009 Sheoraj 369.14089/2009 Sunil Kr. Gupta 370.14090/2009 Smt. Ummed Devi 371.14126/2009 Mangal Ram Gurjar 372.14141/2009 Mahesh Kr Garg & Ors. 373.14155/2009 Miss Pooja Vyas 374.14182/2009 Smt. Tara Mani 375.14203/2009 Yaduveer Singh 376.14212/2009 Mithlesh Kumar Sharma & Anr 377.14230/2009 Supyar Devi & Anr 378.14387/2009 Ram Singh Meena & Ors. 379.14396/2009 Ranveer Singh 380.14397/2009 Rakesh Kr. Sharma 381.14586/2009 Maya Chawla & Anr 382.14595/2009 Babu Lal Yadav 383.14644/2009 Mukesh Chand 384.14692/2009 Kavita Sharma 385.14712/2009 Rajesh Kumar Gupta 386.14722/2009 Smt. Ram Hari Sharma & Ors 387.14750/2009 Yaduvendra Parasar & Ors. 388.14751/2009 Hari Om 389.14752/2009 Ram Niwas & Ors.
390.14781/2009 Hari Ram Bhanbhi 391.14805/2009 Ms Sarla Pareek & Anr 392.14814/2009 Pradeep Choudhary 393.14818/2009 Sushila Kumari & Ors. 394.14846/2009 Vijay Kumar Meena 395.14856/2009 Lalita Kumawat & Ors 396.14887/2009 Jhabar S. Tanwar 397.14889/2009 Kamlesh Kr. Meena 398.14960/2009 Man Singh Meena 399.14996/2009 Prakash Chan Jain 400.15000/2009 Hori Lal 401.15030/2009 Bhanwar S. Nitharwala & Anr 402.15041/2009 Kishore Lal Jat 403.15101/2009 Smt. Rasali Devi 404.15108/2009 Hament Kr. Malav 405.15170/2009 Kamraj S.Gurjar & Anr 406.15195/2009 Bhanwar Lal Nagar & Ors. 407.15209/2009 Vrindra S.Gurjar & Ors. 408.15228/2009 Ashok Kr. Sharma & Anr 409.15281/2009 Ram Khildadi Meena 410.15288/2009 Prahlad Kr. Meena & Anr 411.15289/2009 Lokesh Kr. Vaishnav 412.15338/2009 Trilok Sharma 413.15372/2009 Rajesh Kumar 414.15378/2009 Bajran Lal Kumhar & Anr 415.15382/2009 Dinesh Kr. Sharma 416.15399/2009 Deva Ram Jat 417.15558/2009 Bala Sahai Meena 418.15585/2009 Yogesh Kr. Bansal & Anr. 419.15595/2009 Jai Prakash Sharma & Ors. 420.15604/2009 Hari Ram 421.15615/2009 Mahendar Singh 422.15628/2009 Sarita Todawat 423.15629/2009 Megh Singh Meena 424.15630/2009 Manju Devi Gurjar 425.15641/2009 Chandra Prakash Sharma 426.15643/2009 Lala Ram Bairwa 427.15651/2009 Girraj Prasad Choudhary 428.15662/2009 Pradhan Geela & Anr 429.15663/2009 Saiyad Abdul Rahman 430.15666/2009 Chandra Prakash & Anr 431.15669/2009 Vikash Yadav & Ors. 432.15695/2009 Ram Singh Meena 433.15700/2009 Gyan S.Gurjar 434.15713/2009 Rajendra Kumar Khohar 435.15731/2009 Rampal Khatik & Ors. 436.15736/2009 Bal Mukand Gaur & Ors. 437.15741/2009 Veerander S.Rajput & Anr 438.15745/2009 Dinesh Kr. Yadav 439.15746/2009 Vijay Kr. Singhal & Anr 440.15758/2009 Raju Lal Bairwa & Ors. 441.15774/2009 Archna Sharma & Ors. 442.15791/2009 Ramesh C. Verma & Anr 443.15795/2009 Bhanwar S. Rajput 444.15801/2009 Ram Bharoshi & Anr 445.15837/2009 Kum. Meenakshi 446.15845/2009 Durgesh Bairwa & Anr 447.15847/2009 Smt. Santosh Meena 448.15852/2009 Jitendra Kr. Pankaj 449.15854/2009 Ram Singh Gurjar & Anr 450.15862/2009 Ram Chander Kasana 451.15866/2009 Vakil Shah & Anr 452.15867/2009 Sohan Singh & Ors 453.15876/2009 Ramesh Kr Ujjwal & Anr 454.15880/2009 Rama Kant Dadhich 455.15902/2009 Thandiram Meena & Anr 456.15915/2009 Tara Chand & Ors.
457.15932/2009 Ram Lal Lodha 458.15955/2009 Chandra Pal 459.15967/2009 Virendra Singh Gour & Anr. 460.15973/2009 Smt. Smita Yadav 461.15981/2009 Savita 462.15989/2009 Vijay Kr. Sharma 463.15993/2009 Durga Bai Rathor & Anr 464.15996/2009 Suresh Chand Jat 465.16027/2009 Ram Niwas Sharma 466.16028/2009 Mamta Dhakar & Ors. 467.16030/2009 Ram Ratan & Ors 468.16049/2009 Vijendra Kumar 469.16092/2009 Ram Bhanwar S.Rajput & Anr 470.16095/2009 Murarilal Sharma 471.16102/2009 Smt. Krishna Devi 472.16103/2009 Vinod Kr. Sarwal 473.16105/2009 Vikram Kr. Saini & Anr 474.16119/2009 Mangilal & Ors.
475.16124/2009 Sunil Kumar 476.16129/2009 Lokesh Tailor & Ors. 477.16134/2009 Satish Kumar Sharma 478.16138/2009 Suraj Mal Keer 479.16190/2009 Pratap Narayan Singh & Ors. 480.16234/2009 Geetanjali Gautam & Ors 481.16239/2009 Mukesh Pd. Meena & Ors. 482.4/2010 Nahar Singh Dagur & Anr 483.5/2010 Kamlesh Kumar & Ors.
484.19/2010 Gopal Prajapti 485.85/2010 Kailash Saini 486.87/2010 Ishwar Pd. Bairagi & Ors. 487.121/2010 Sunita Gurjar & Ors. 488.127/2010 Smt. Meenakshi Pareek 489.128/2010 Mahesh Kr. Yadav 490.134/2010 Jaiveer Singh & Ors. 491.139/2010 Surendra Kumar 492.144/2010 Dinesh Gaur 493.162/2010 Smt. Mamta 494.163/2010 Smt. Prem 495.176/2010 Shyam Singh Chaudhary 496.183/2010 Jitendra S.Baghel & Ors. 497.186/2010 Kamal Prakash Bairwa & Ors. 498.201/2010 Krishan Kumar & Ors. 499.235/2010 Hari Shankar Vaishnav & Anr 500.247/2010 Prabhu Singh & Ors.
501.312/2010 Satya Narain Meena & Ors. 502.318/2010 Mahendra Kumar Vaishnav 503.332/2010 Vivek Kumar & Ors.
504.336/2010 Dilgag Singh & Ors.
505.389/2010 Satya Prakash Meena & Ors. 506.394/2010 Yadram 507.424/2010 Vijay singh Tanwar & Ors. 508.456/2010 Mohan Lal Mehta & Anr 509.463/2010 Gunjan Sharma & Anr 510.477/2010 Murari Lal 511.487/2010 Gabbar Singh Rajput & Ors. 512.503/2010 Dharam S. Meena & Ors. 513.510/2010 Mukesh Chand 514.546/2010 Kalu Lal meena & Ors. 515.552/2010 Poonam Chand Meena 516.587/2010 Savita Dadhich & Ors. 517.625/2010 Ashok Kr. Avasthi 518.633/2010 Mukesh Kr. Meena 519.663/2010 Sunil Kr. Yadav & Ors 520.701/2010 Surendra Dadhich & Ors 521.830/2010 Rajendra Prasad Sharma & Anr 522.1110/2010 Manish Kr. Bari 523.1125/2010 Surendra S.Solanki 524.1236/2010 Shri Kishan 525.1361/2010 Smt. Raj Laxmi Bunkar 526.1384/2010 Kanhaiya Lal Kumawat 527.1452/2010 Om Prakash Gupta & Ors. 528.1530/2010 Hemraj Mehar & Ors. 529.1541/2010 Bharti Devi 530.1578/2010 Om Prakash Balai & Ors. 531.1633/2010 Naveen Kr. Mali & Ors. 532.1639/2010 Suresh Kr. Saini & Ors. 533.1646/2010 Rakesh Kr. Meena & Anr 534.781/2010 Sita Ram Sharma 535.1662/2010 Lokesh Kr. Rathore & Anr 536.1691/2010 Kailash Chand Sharma 537.1807/2010 Suresh Kr. Gurjar & Anr 538.1824/2010 Saboo Lal meena 539.1847/2010 Lokesh Kr. Mukul & Anr 540.1865/2010 Umesh Chand Sharma 541.1882/2010 Vijay Kumar & Anr 542.1898/2010 Bablu Saini 543.1899/2010 Govind Kr. Pareek & Anr 544.1900/2010 Om Prakash Sahu 545.1919/2010 Narayan Singh & Anr. 546.1920/2010 Rajeev Kumar & Ors. 547.1933/2010 Rajendra Singh & Ors. 548.1983/2010 Ram Kishan Jat 549.2009/2010 Shrwan Lal Bugasara & Ors. 550.2017/2010 Arun Kumar Sharma 551.2024/2010 Ram Prakash Sharma & Anr 552.2033/2010 Rajendra Kumar Pankaj & Ors. 553.1963/2010 Brijesh Kr. Sharma & Ors. 554.598/2010 Smt. Manoj & Anr 555.921/2010 Shekhar Meena & Anr 556.13381/2009 Shakuntala & Anr. 557.435/2010 Pinki Khandelwal & Ors 558.13337/2009 Gajanand Meena & Ors. 559.15460/2009 Sanju Kumar Versus State & Ors (Ajay Rastogi), J.
K.Khatri/p14/ 8969CW2009-Fb15-Vidyarthi(559).do