Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Jogendra Singh Rathore And Others vs Department Of Military Affairs on 6 September, 2022
he 2 SEES} Central Administrative Tribuna! Mumbai Bench, Mumbai Taesday, this the 6! day af 'September, 2029 Hon'ble Ms. Harvinder Kaur Oberoi, Member (3) Jozendra Sing] a Rathore, MTS Cr TOWRIDAR), Group C, aged a8 years, worki ng in Indian Nox val Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Murabal and residing at Room NO.3105, Bide. No.sig, Seetar ~ 02, CGS Colony, ar, Antop Mi il, Mumbai -- 400 037.
Mobile No. 73204202260 Email Td: Si O wendra67s @egmail.com _ Ashok Kumar Sah, MTS (CHOWRKID Group C aged 43 vears, working in It "aia an Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumb: a and residing at SB, Ble ly Noaig, See toxv-03, COS Col cHEEY, . Antup Ea, Mumbai -~ ¢o00 O97, g grmigiheo 7 week crt:
4S: vheraas erat MTS CCHOWKIDAR} Fhitas Girdhari Saw, Group C, aged 93 years, Wore 21D indian Naval Hospital op a syint, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Room No.2goi, Antop Hill, Mumbai ~4oo 037. Mobile No O.eo08or ry75B?
Maul fd-HulascsecrgSeteomail corm Aau Sata Gouda, MTS (CHOWRIDAR) es Group €, a8 years, warking in Indian Nave Hospital Ship, Asvinh, Colaba, Mau mbal an dre iding Rear 'ids. Nowag, Sector-o° SoM ai Al inbai ~ goo oar Moh SE : G1Og 8 398 iD-Goudasniiigeemail com Sachin Arun Tambat, MTS (CHOWRIDAR) _ Group i, aged G2 vears, wate inv indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvinl, Colaba, Mumbai and residing al Ruin No.zog, B Wing, Sarsawti Apar tment, K u jizad, Pin ~ 400 7O2 PACH, sane Uran, Re vlobile N ». SiGOAIFAONO.
, Ganesh cont Y puma, MTS (COHOWEIDAR) ars, working in-fadian Naval , we svini, Colaba, Murmbaiand residing CLA. No S88 /eoar mes N at Room No.2942, Bldg. No.o13, Sector-o2, CGS Calony, Kane Nagar, Antop Hill, Mumbai 400 037, Mobile Na.g930138539.
Email [d-Dhumakeaneshie35@ gamail.com.
Subhas ¢ seeridhar ( Chavan, MTS (CHOWKIDAR), Group C,. aged 4o years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Room No.1695, Bldg. No.q4, Sector -- 07, CGS Colony, S.A. Plot, Antep Hill, Mumbai 400 037.
Mobile No.g967 7037048.
Email Id- Sco716589 @email.com.
"si os
8. Manjunath Keera Naik, MTS (CHOWKIDAR}, Group C, aged 36 years, warking In Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Room No.627, Bldg. No.23, Sector - a7, CGS Colony, S.M. Plot, Antop Hil, Mambal ~ 400 037 Mobtle No.o7vos64696q. Email Id- ManinnathmanviaSiieemail.cam,
9. Sumi Kumar Pal, MTS (CHOWEIDAR}, Group C, aged 31 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at C/o Parasnath 8. ae Room No.4, Utiaranch!) Chawl, Anand Nagar, Jogeshwari (W) » Mumbal #OO 10%, 10, Subhn Singh Guriar, MTS (CHOWRKIDAR), Group C, aged 40 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbal and residi ing at "Room No.io20, Bldg. No.30, Seetor ~ 07, CGS Colony,
5.M. Plot, Antop Hill, Mumbai 400 047. Mobile No.9 320853837. Email Id- Subbansingheuriarto80e femaileom, i. Antaryam) Arjun Sahoo, MYS (Chowkidar}, Group C, aged 34 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Room No.5123, Bldg. No. 14, Sector o7, OGS Colony, SM. Plot, Antop Hill, Mumbai 4oo 037. Mobtle No. .976900 2537, Email id- Sahilsabaa@ematleom.
12. Kailas Mahdev Pawar, MTS (CHOWRIDAR), Groap C, aged 57 years, working. in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residi ing at Room No.i0, Vlay Navas Chawl Behind VP Bakery, Harivall Villa ge, Vikehroli CE Sas st Mumbai 200 083 Mobile No.83a8543737.
1g. Chandrakant Bhiku Nimbalkar, MTS (CHOWRIDAR} 4s OAL Ne.gkSs2o0es 19 {seh Group C, aged 57 years, working in Indian Naval Hospita ul Ship, Asvini. Colaba. Mumbai and residin we oat Room No.vi/7/i8, Vilay Nagar, § Salt Pen Road, Near Vitthal Mandir, Artop Hil, Wad al a (East), Mumbai goo o0a7, Mobile No. g810887854.
i. Mangesh Vishram Kadam, MTS (CHOWRKIDAR), Group C, aged 52 years, w orking | in Indian Naval Haspital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residing at Roo aan Nai108, B Wing, 2@ Floor, Mahaveer Ds arshar fe Co Savkety, Near Secondary High School, Nallasopara { Wh Mobile No. Bagoo8h5o04,.
15. Swapnil. Ashok Shivankar, MTS ({CHOWRIDAR), Group C, aged 32 years, warking in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Mumbai and resi iding at Room No.2037, Bldg No.2, Seetor o2, CGS Colony, Kane Nagar, Antop Hill, Mumbai goo 637.
Maile No. Foe 1688407. Email Td-: Shivankarswannillo gSS@ermail, Com, iG. Ashok Mansairam Tirkey, MTS (CHOWR DAR), Group C,a seed 3 4 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Agvini, Colaba, Mumbai and residing ut 264, 26° Moor, Ashtavinayak Co. Hse. Society, Plot S O.£91, Seawoods (W), Nasa Mumbai 400 FOH. Mobile No o833048042. mail ld- ashokeeminio yas maiLcom, Pandurang Kaka Jadhav, Ex-MTS (CHOWRIDAR). Group C, aged 60 years, working in Indian Naval Hospital Ship, Asvini, Colaba, Tombai and Tasiding at Room No.765, Bldg No.as, Seetor ~ o7, CGS Colony, SM. Blot, Antop Hil Mumbel 400 09°, Mc sbile NO.98 G9801029.
io
16. Parmar Sudhir Pr avin Kumar, Ex-MTS (CHOWRIDAR} Brom INHS Asvini, Presently LDC, Croup C, aged 34 years, working in ABS, Murmbal and residing at 40/so, ar Os 2 First Floor, G Gram Ship, Asrarm Nagar, Old Fishe hes ersily Road, Seven Bunge flows, Versova, reat), Nhumbal 4060 O61.
Mobile No.7 7qSBS87.
Email Id- Sudhir.com.in: @emaileom. ... Applicants (By Mr AL. Bhatkar , Advocate) ane Versus fs, "
& OLA, Noasss208 L, Union of India through Secretary Ministry of Defence, South Block, New Delhi iio 001.
2. The Chief of the Naval Staff, Integrated H eadquarters, Ministry of Defenee (Navy), Talkatora Annexe Building,"
New Delhi 110 001.
3. The Flag Officer Commanding-in-Chief, Headg Teoters, W estern Naval Command, Ballar Plier, New Tiger Gate, Mumbai 400 001, q. The Cammanding Officer, Indian Naval Hospital Ship Asvini, Colaba, Murmbal 400 a08. .. Respondents. (By Afr. Rishi Ashok, proxy counsel for Advocate Shri BR, Ashok) OR DER (ORAL) "Puna eracio usp pleased i MEME T EN ITS io past S & he Greece ously pleased to call 2 eOOras he eran! of Hospitat Pahie EEO FAD an tr 4 wey.
Peo went Core ore fw wee, ht
- pa f yeeve aed fA sed fo ik ee ae ;
BE £ ed LA ch pee ae fee a:
as 1% fad uy get C3
i) 4 "te nary Zz See epee aa ip Sed ba ay beds my Ls 76 ai 'ad tb #2 ory uy tel 8) @ oh jee ' Seah whee .
q teal ona bea iD ° fa : ae Fr oe on '4 cH : ws ed oes fet +4 x g vee hed : in ay on ond : 4-3 ct "iat Sef Sees Lis As Fs ' aa i, .
C, os Fa on ' we 4 ~ { , : , bea. eye. a "he 3 . cS.
io aes sok ral vt wD port i 43 xX SAL he oN aos at peters * Pa whe Xe y yt BK as % 2 3 $ A A Le = 4 } he t A. a oa red t ROSSA TS a : a = rot N, noe «S & oe) £3 od peed el G ped > Pal eid 4 on hy wet WG Sa a i ved Oo w@ 4 ay pa fel Sted % Pew pod sti) sh ¢§ Y + bs tS a .
O a Rane Ae i ae Wes Ria.
5 3' 2 a NA ~ x u Sa ye er ry 2 " 3 ;
ob ved . om: is it a i ue a epee y ha 4d © is; _ oy : a "Ty ef oy M4 os) 3 rs fe
i) 2, ae i " ity wo ; i if ; ©) bod aed oe) be ony . » .
@ cS id ar "
be a3 tS 5 42 . a 6) ee ie Me 3 G fed ie am Bg oy hs " ce) Ry GS ce iy 3 7 4 :
di ered, ay 4 ¢ j 3 :
a a B Bes soy oh C3 csad sha one pas 7 oot & $54 eo. Co ° ioe ne fee ee oar) a R ee oF rz eats Mes, we ' baa, , ted ie 4a ae bea uy f} ond is iy , Sh : ¥ Ex ry ayP £Ch ce et rom Fi ' hen hes 42 oa hee Ct ny eyed hog qn % i H = ad G om = xs) Dhed
-- qe bed ~
4 ». a Bae Ss Sf, oe : oo Poet te 3 ved ae ta = n sot m pn reed thy Lae on og . io "
: uid wt tt ae oe ory art faa ay he ee ee ry ry an hen ts wee oe oh 3 o oa 4 $3 h.2 LA oo he ae rth sed sad .
2 Berg vet et Vee oo mae ak a ' i . me) : 3 | Ny . ere ced oes ie 14 ¢ ff, bo se 44 fos * nt ed vy os % a oy 'bony! Ww & iad =a = me Swe peed s Paced a .
aa sa oy tees Pek ts Ch body ed i . tea bea ay va iy fast ; oy 77 és % uy ee :
5 * en MA it 6 es ~~ bop o% hea . ; iB 3 fe G3 a a a os a ee "a 1 ' aw £ % qd ay a E i wed re ce a ' ; tee ut any SE 4 sad a t 4 3 3 . we iG G} a hed Fant od * thy aa) ae at [on ory cand " q a3 3 ry m 44 3 Mae 3 aa re fet Gy LE 3 +4 ~ ui ra as
- ai tw A to rs ty ba ae hes aa ay bes vee ss a ee bea Shea oy oe 2 rs bebe oy a ai a8) Qs Ge a 4a :
es) ~ a) wv faal hes Bet * qt ise] ee jad ah eet thd "3 oh pat! ot ff eo . _ E go us el Bh Shed Ct get oy o os % tf boa Up oA vt ea LA vee} ned fon a Byway S "fh : .
ke, 4 re an on a aa " .
orn LA ~, a y pe 4.3 T4 whe ade MC St o KY 5 e MM ca PETE REP ft der K:
in nber G3) + CHAE oe oa mii dak.
) i;
ber > ¥ < ary Is. H x { af t KN Ma.