Karnataka High Court
Venkataraman Narasimha Hegde, vs Mahabaleshwar Venkataraman Hegde on 11 January, 2011
Author: Aravind Kumar
Bench: Aravind Kumar
EN '?'E~§E §_a:':<::+: {:":<>:.;§a*:* <3? §<ARN'z%.'"E'£§,§{;%
<;::;§€<::"_:':'1:fi £»2;E%:1_x:'<_;:H syr :3§@'A_E%;_wA:3
§m*E;z2 TH_::5; THE T: :."N---% EBAY <1}? JAE'~.?'U'AR":*', 2;): E
EEFQERE "
'§'}EE E~.§{f)N'BLE i\5E§€.J"EjSTECE3 ARMJENB :,<:.:;éf:%if;=g§§ V.
"\?sZ.P,§'~I<;:.€>5;%54,/;2{3.':f} §{§M»CPC7§ "
EETWEEN; V _
z VENEi%"?AR£s.MAI'§ NAR%%S}T§'s!Z1~*I;% HE{};}E, ,_ 1
$;<>NARAsIMHA :»»§E;@DE;, "
m:;§:;: :34 ':'EAR&-'sfi R/<3 E3E~1AES}§EE,'»~'§AE'\JE 52 '
;~:<>D:GEHA;..L§g S'HI'a?fiL£,§ v1;LA.;é'E., '
TQ $323;
{}ANAPA'E'§--§E N§xRAS§I\;{H2'\§E{}D'E' -.
Sji} NARASEMHA §§EGL'.I;;'3;'~ 5 . V' ~
AGE: E32 YEARS, R/{B $§i;a'S:=§;:s¢;A:§E&9 .
E{'C>D§{3EHALE3, SE~§§1i%§;L§'%'E£..L;&{§E,:
T53" SIRS} ' -- '
Lu
RAMAQHASQRA§s:,§;§.;a3§a::~zA"H§:;C;vDi>:":;
Sm I\§'ARs§$§1.'v}5HA §4;fEi:--D::i_" _
;a<:;~E;'=.4G ":'E.AR;E§',V:"??_/{I} SE§AS%{_EIs{IANE
§<@Dz<§.E;HA_L:;_ Sf§.W.A§;'§J§ ::§L;.za<;E".,
'Mfg. s~;:§:~;.:., ' '
4: PR%;E~§1_A§H?§;';RASm*E%i5;.H§1<.}§}E
S ,6 Q I'«§5%;Rfi.S§Ix;i%'E»§A, HEGDEZ
._ ME: Y'EEARSg a;'€;~~$'HA$H1MANE
V ' «§<;<Z:D§£§E%:;'%.L:,_.§, s:H:1aFA;L£ VELLACEE,
' .»T'{gv.S§'R$E~. ' PETETEEENERS
{By'.S§:}T';?-.35.'~;7§?;;T:§§;§ 'fiégiigs
_ §:£z%}?i';%B;%L§-::§E%§fv'AR §§;ENK;%T;%R&§§fi.N HE<}§El
AA :':§;£:> ':f'Ei-L%'iE§<_§!E'AR;*:E&z'§;%§'s? £35333
;'%;{E?E;: Z78 'fa;-a2&;$ Rfifi E§{f}§}1{I§E3§~§:%LL1
" T ':~:,a;%%.*{;:$: :y-§Amg,£:;§:$§::%,:£AEz HEGEEE
'V <:«?s;s:3 :xai_;2e§~;;1B,r%LE:s§:»§%5;a:'a£2; 9:35:93?
aajga'; 55 '*:"E;z3:EE?s, §<;<..>;3:<.;'::;2«;aL:,i..
'E"{'g. -i*_§'§E:'%§'_%.
"gm,
'zf§E3'{s%DHAR MAHAB;%LESH':i-iiafi E~£Ejf;}QE_1
S/E} PsIEfi§§ABA§,EZE§H'x?yi%§€ BEZGDE,
;%,{;E; 4:? ':'E?;:3£€E§, Eegzis E{{T}§}§{f}E;Z%§A§;LE,
TQ. SERSE
'..4J
5; {EEJRUFAB MA%§AB:%LES§§1%C.%R H" {:33
35:2 MAHABz%LES§é'~.?E:'AR HEGEE,
g%{"§E: 38 "Ef§AE3S% Rffik K<}\BE{}fEfiJE-'}~x;;aE..«I..;i,
TQ, SERSE
$E-§R£PAD ?viAEiAB£LESB'sfi;"/%.R H5E{':{}F,
Sgt} MA§€ABALESHW;%§ E?%E{3~DE, ~
&{§=E:35 YEARS:R,/€}KO§§GE§e§£L§§'L _ Q
TQ, SERSI. 7._._,§"RESP{}E'{§}}:3€f'\¥'§*':§'~ -
{RESPCENDENTS SD}
TEES 13;? ES FILES UNBER AR"'.=:f§<:"::;§S 22é_fi:N§ 22:2' <3? THE
CONS'E'ETUTEON Q? ENDIA §R9c;'§.N(}.._T<3__{3;;fASH "*§§{_E: j{§';--'§§'UGE'\EEB
URDER P?:SSEiD BY WE LEEAE:NED«"CIV§£ $535-<25 gsskflfizxigj SEES? ON
.E.A.f\30.12, EN {'§.;€¥§.I'~E{)(§32,fI'<.?<§3?i%,A£>A'%;fE1D:%;iS;'€;}"f,{2C}E8, F{>LT?Jfi{:> 3;?
ANNEXURE41, ALMEW '2':-£15; WEE]? PE;E";'T::{}I%;i.§}y'F'_E'Ei C_fOS'E'S.
"E"E~iES 13E:*s:*:'1<3:4'<;f0M;r<éG"(;i§: §*@§._;>:é:3E:'ié»;:e, THIS mgr: THE
caum' MADE '§'H§:'§'{}:}5LOW:E.NGi: '
'~ §3R;DE;E':
Tm:-g éé?; 2-1" vp§é;iniéffs:s'V *»,;1=':"§%:. ps:%_,i£:.it}é:: 3{~:<:§<.:ing writ {>5
_Vc€:*t:£€;:';"e;,;3}§ 'Via. q:;as§n.._}:%:e £33632' fiateé {}ES.{>'§'(2€}§{} pasged in
'~{}u§;§'=3Q:13:f };?§é% by me {iii-ii éudge gsgamgg i:§i1"s§.5
1.*:?§i1::.:?£§ié__:"f:<§éV9:':"«'Vii_}*?::é: afaiér pa.$$5:€§ 01:. EE5:»f>'~f_IE sizayiilg {he Saifi fiuiii agtams §:7<:':-- b€3v--__:*es:;>g§'E€::¥;q '--.
AA ;§€ez;::'¢'i téécrs Ezearzzéicé <;'.<2uz::s<«:§ appfiarézzg 503' '§3ff'E§§.iV{'}§';{:A'?S, '?'%3<)':,':§;;§: n3Sjg<f>r1CE<-3.z:€,$ azréi sr,a4:*rv€d3 €;h§:§; am ;:;§';vi"é.:'Qf$$€§:§.é?{';¢ g Km) " ' "fhéé r<é:§§;=<}:":§§s:§:'a.:; T:*a<::'<:*l§"; §"%E%3é:§ .5: $3351: in €i3.§§.F'~E:'>_§*%4'.% E993 :"e:i%'%'E<'?.f <5? <.%é%<;:f.:;i.3f2;2%'é{:s:": ;.2m::§_. agéds {his rsgistfiréécé 3-viii {ia2i:.e:%d E.4».G8.1'£%8'§%o Tize p€"£i'::é::=n€~r:~; hersfzin fiié-xi 2,2 Sui? in {}.S$N<>.i32;'§.99/3% a1§,ain:i§': the r€s;3«:>:1§s3m.s Seéskizég :"<3§i€:::" 0:" {§EfC§&1f£1§§{)fi of iiiizz amfi for pszgeiuai ézzjunctéan. 'E"E:<::~:<3 ::w<3 :=3ui2:s; were: parading '::>:<:r';'1::sr¥c"
the {Xvi} xjudge {JrB:'2._} and Cévii Judge re:~:.g€c§.iv§:§§z: in {T).S'N:>.E32/1.994, {he p€Z"{§'f§(_}.F?..1€%"E§v.fzéffiijfé filed h'3;.+>{§§E 1,:;"s~; ii} cf the C065: sf Cévii §{';f:}cé:fiaré'«geé%£§ifi.g J af aim: sun in <>.ss.r~:o.:32;':é2% 61:: "ans d:fs_:;.p.§sa: 5:5' €},SNo.84;'E€%'§3§. '§'h<: Séfzid 2:pp£i¢a§€}p; €am€._ii:07*bé;-' révsésmd by {ha ciefendazzts Izheréirg amém ézfigzr '"'{:0ns;édé:é'§.::Ag the arguxnrzrzig advanced; 5:; {he h3:a?.n£3'dL:C{§ugé5_"§c.:~%f__t§':e pariies, the cm: Ju&g6:* gs--s.;:. :§gg:;, §§%'V.«his ::1¥::;a:Vdégtecz 2C}.{)E.2{}{}E sfiayed f:2r::;.he: t;;f:§Lz:.s:¢.;;i_V§":':gs'«gféifzc 3m': in {'}.,S«Nc}.132;'§9'§4 penéing an i'f::;,fiEE: "§1;;sf§g&_. {':§r(Bn..}, Sirsi} iii} digpasagzi {sf {}.S.:"'s§«;>,8:5¥5;' 399} .V{§3s§:£dé§":.g fin ihe SE62 :3? Civil Juégéz, {J:1Dr:.}, 4:5, "'E"fE':s3 2;'.-§_é,%'§--«?. ;E {S2':§:{:.}, '$3; <>rC§.€:" aéazezi €3;§,<.:r;.2§32_{> §*<':E1' Am::<:x1:gf:é4»;'%.--'%:as gfscafifirzi {ha :::»ré{:~3° sf satzzgs paazusd £1': Eihs:
--C."f:;2§éé zgnjaé :ié.z2:%.gi%:€<i {Eire p§a§fi§i.f§S is §§(}C€3{Z'd zafézfrz ihsz CEEE-Siin it is iiwisis«.:::'2'::i§.£:_§*'€s,r§:::l€E: $2.233 bzr-is-:22 q'ua:-;£i£2;3{A:§ in {MS :,vz°é% pezé§';:§<m. E:E§::;§..'%f{'2fé<'E:;a E:3a:*':":<':<i C.=:>u.:::;<;*;i .23 ezzriéw {gr .V _ 3 $33 §::s.<:%;.:;.'::.:.<m::::*ss :sa:»':,1§«:%; £':j{::eE'1?:{4:£§'-iiéi i;.§*:2:_:. {j:é*a,--=iE J§,':{§§§€ {;':§;",§f}:s";.}, E§=i.:f::;£., Ezgsviiégg :%':z=:': s«;::::'€, :;'_3i?E'".§{§i§§"E§§ am £3154; 3;}; éiszriééér -i."f}1'"€§iI'§.' r~=.
"E éaifité Z3{}.{}E.2{}{}E_, wi"€.h<:r:;:i: §§hf;"1'E' basing ££}";}«'" appEi{:a_'z':i:}§: E')j*;,: t ri3f€nc§;a_:"z:s?; 50:" T8521}? :3? wi?;§'3<:wui' héiialrézag iihe piitétisémim <:<:::,§§d 2:301; ?:2;:2-is §ecaEEe:d £23 aarliasr Grder izggzamzzgch as' ";"}§: vériufi <35 {he Qriiéir passmzé {>11 i2f{Z%.G§_:2U{3E EA far been digpeseé ("sf .3:/ad ag such, ihe Said crdcsr C@:;i<;'i'_i:0Vi-}é;:;;vé §€€ffi recaéisd aa ii had ':3<:<:{>m<--: finai' E§@..1a>'_<>u1<:§.'a§é<§'€f§3n':iiaf§'§dV aha: is:-was pending in {},S3aR'z>,84;' E'99.§[a.nfi.,?,E'1€% i4sT$:£§:'iz:v<';.§'<m§é. f in the prasent Sufi zzamsiy €'}.S.I\§QXi32f %??3'35f:e_ are <3>r1i'_<xf3 §é{r:C{ v:?:€ ' game and {m earfissr occasion azrhifi":::}:3Si5;@rir:g_ thé {Xvi} Jucégfi {Sr,Dm.} ha.¢i appixées-éVV:\iié~% 'tmné 35 'E3 {hf present suit {(:},§.N{§.13§?;V;f"1.%§'9F%}"'. -$0 be stayed Sinai: £3: wcuicé Eeacfi {Q canfiigztgifég'Vd€§:i§.iL0ri;§'.i%§}*:V'-.i§:25 <;€:::;z:'{s and 'naé accsjréiéngljs' S§Eé§f€~C31 333.11 wzdi now' by viriué 9;? the 311:: (}.S.§\§<:{€§_<} ;"E992. VST§T.§(E§ 01:': {ha fiie 9? the Civié Jzszégés §;§:".'{}n.}.3 E;%§-rsi;'theré: mt» justéfi§::»3,¥;é0§: 0:' maaoza for .:hE:' %'.'ZT.1?*»§rEf; $i*;§:g5 ~{S:*.§::»}} Sirsé is Kasai} ita Eeriéez' order arid a§rec:V..Tsh¢ };E:3%€<$.r3 is pmcwé; wiih ihff ssufig. £3 such she V' $$§:E::==; "-5:32' af ?;,'§':€f aaéé <Z}§"d§fE" éaiad €}fé:€}E.2€}E.G
-« I" ";r§:4<'}5.% ue:@d 2s_i:_. }§:".:z1ex:;.:re~B:
hfiézzzig iearnsd <:::}uns€E 5&3' She ;s<3%;.§Ei<:e:2€:"3 anfi _ {;r:....p<3~rz;$aE sf fimnszagrfis ":53 {E152 '~3=.='§f§'{ p§:é%.é<;::, it W{322§€i §r<::;r§: zzzzéf érzapugzzzsaé <:§'<:'::.:* 3€}(f;E,2'"%€}':§ Szgzii if: :;;u;§»:3;§.i<§::. na::a£:~§}; €}uE§.?€<}..132f§4',%€?5é @236; 2 w.
35:36:11 S?;Ei}"t"'{:3; E3}; 'é;E::é': Cévii &'a;:d§;<:é §i':§r.'§'}r;.§ £12}; £33; <>z::"ia%:' {ism-3&3 2'€jé.€}i.2{}GE. ':;.:EE§ {£26 dispaseii if seizéi. {}¢E?§.N{;.84;'E€%9}E., 2i<i:mi%':s€'i1j;, €316 :~i;L:£§. {f}.E§.I'€<',u84,='%?%§*§ :;:a.:m"% E23 bf: défiméssitd by {EMS Céx-ii Jazzigfi (E%:2§f§i<3.'§ Eéirssi ané '£'h'uS fghe 0§'dc:=:r sf sé[€.e3'};§ grameé am :2{},{}1.i?;{}{}E E1213; gm: sxhaustsjci by itsgssii'. ;"§;14'.¢i§;2§§_i;T . A' Eléfififi' (35 the parmrs I510 '£1:-3 Suit. {f}.S.3'é{;:E32{__3,f§}*éI%é% §aa;s: b2"<;L:g}:'{ ii} the? nméézsfi if 83:: cauzi rzaimejijs £1; t§:V€"r_::>%35r'£V.:;%{' .§7%.yi1'_[_ A' Judge {Srfizzj} S§:<°s::%., abzmi {he 53%: {i}.S'.-.Nfi§'$.84/1§.€%.Zi jhzaivifig "
bsen diapcgeci 9%'. in ms mcavfzxgfizéie, tiias ':;3£:§:é:':€i'{f$ in {}gf:§.i\i<>.8<%j1§93.. being agg;°§<:~>g*<:c§ {hair ;}:L'.{d.§§«;§'}.€f11i afiidfiescree p&S&§fi5d in the sgaiéi Sui'; haw: ¥pr<:F<':r:?<:~'d ..§;;;;:::.a: arms? 31%: is submiized 52%: {he E%r§;:l{7"§d§,*a,'«.d:t::j'ng z:«:>urs:: cf ha':
Submissézskfs than .again$%: 'E116 saié jziflgmem and éiecrea z.:;a..?;1§::,:<> 2:1EE}:'s::=gé':?i _{§'r*:. {3;'3,{}3L2{'} 2%} mad the znaufiez' has %:2{:&1_f:' :v"c_§$anc§@.€§ €{:»'ihs§' trig} sgamrt far frszsh 2%&j1,:.dicaté<m I-'.335 :55 32,25: €i$.N<;.34; 2991 sziié being psrnaiézagfi this -. 3:21}? "is '{:€.;J:i': H63, ,:%':»§_ <fi;:4s;:::2r:'::§ bjg me ue:*{:ina'm}w:~, ':§'zs:: sides' :3? Stag; ~ ." A§g:'é2":'2%;.€2;::' :>:;'v.'2'lZ}.{}":.;2Q{§§ $22 E;%~}::E§ was $232" lémiiiztid pfiféiéd iii}
--..<*;'i--§s:"é;<§:&;a§ is? {i§_§?§_?€:}.,8fi:_,f§§¥i§E amt? ihé-2 333:3 ssuiii E222 izzgg ""':'3a§;:{2.5::§§s§_g>é:>sse€§ 0? an IE.53.{}'?_2C%§)5, §'.:f'.§€ c=z'::§,€r 0? $3,223?" §;':"éSE~"£§f{§
2.73;: 2fi}.,é'3'E.2€}UI§. Ezacfi <::";r:z<*~ H2: gm iégééjé 5:": 1
éazmia ;*g:;:T:,°;:<::., :§~"2::%:*«:3 z";:~:; :2.<?§>:;§ :32" ?."'§éi{:é:',-:S;$§'i'E.}~' far %.§"';:> éfiéziii ajliifigif {E%r.D11.§ 3%.': r£*<:21§§ {Ewe <}r:%€3r' §a$&;e3x:% am 3£z%--}{;§E' xfizi'/:i{:E: has:
2:§r':3a<§}' ggikil $:§@€;'.1'Ts'£. §::§£3§€ ami §h&'::":':: wars; :29 :«3Ea§; <}p::*mié:":g £18 ans}: Séfiifé :--~_=,':'21},* §_::'a:r1:'e=:§ megs zérzija iii} the? €§i$p:}:~?;2'2§ <3? {}DS.I'\§a,8s4jI€§'9':, ".§'E':€ .:€as<_>:f1:-2; a.s;s;i§._>;:"2ed 2}}: 'she Cézséi {S.2:".§r:}, far £°fi€ZE{:i§i':g 11316 ififdfif though Car:E"iE'2{'}'£' be j_;''2:1's»::é':1"§..6_:_7{i5, ;_ aha gsrdm' p{}S§§i'i§.§ {he 31:23:. {E}? éiéégpzysgai on §z1€3r§.fr.s«:__¢'a;;":;;3..;;f'z .335: faund; fauiti with. As; sash? wi%;.E':<::1,:€; ci§s§u:°;bi:z:g': t'E<:§':§:fiéf;__TA' pagseé <32': O5.G'£'.2{}.§Q by iihe C§§zV%£_ Jr:«:§§g'é7 {E§vr:D::.},_f-aiiéfsig a:§'§d :10: appmving 3:325 magmas a§si§j'{ié«:§ bf,-VV31}.'i'§'1~v-:§f;E';' £}1£"é<fff impugned herein, 'Ehe isr'V§ff§':'L:r§~3ci '-f'§2 érhs "e>:A:em c:>f pegting ihz'-3 suit {:32}: bssing. di$pVé>%s<3c§~._Vi;~§j~.0f_; I1':€Z'i'E$ in accordancs with _1as,xz_: "_'.HL3€¥e1rg:;..'ii*i$ 'n*§'a.d€ gftéear Ehéii in the evem a.z2§f: fm3~:}ffA@;f§'§;§ic%aV§Qf:«Véé§'§i__E<:--d.'by the gsetitioners seeking "Em Siai}-' of €h§§ é;:33'§,' wzmid, £35: céanisiaifirsd gm Eta meréfiss va.~i:{:<:;':*é4é;..::";.c<: w3;{h 13%: by $316 ifivéi Juégtz &%§?%:'.s;i,"* «:€:9i£«:A:v§°§a;:e;r:<:{2@' {:5 22:2}? {3bs;er"ar2";ti§n rzagde §:':_ét$ 5:3:'Zéér,_;:%r»s:§E;.rrj {Hf 1'?1§E§ {}£"C§f3i'. ?:§E°£§:'5E"é§'{§ a.e::ss:>r<iéng;2§;*. Egg;
4?