Karnataka High Court
R Ranganath vs Salim on 21 March, 2012
Author: B.Manohar
Bench: B.Manohar
3?; '§'E§Ei %£E€';%E§ C9228'? <1? E{;'sR:?X§A'?E%%i% A? BAss{;gL€;:§§:_. ': -
swag Ems €32 2i~'3'1'§3A'z' Q?' MARCE 2$i;2'~ _ ' -. 1'
BEFQRE « 1' _ _ _
mg HONBLE EVEREJUSTICE B.§:A':v:§;$;Aé»._y
:xwiA.:x§a.5;24;2r:T§s._V§s5é}=_° V BETWEEN: "
R, Ra§Eg3Ii3i§"i, S,/@ Ramaehandra, Ag€d abeui 38 ysara _ .
Brixray, Residing ai; Qcrsdtéeri 'sf11}$:'g7&,* Chaiiakers Taiuk; -~ 5?'?"E§.:§'.2, '_ 2: = A Chfiradurga Di$t:':::::;». ' 5; v_ = 4' _ . . , Appeiiani {By Sfi ?\iE.'E.Jaga:*1 P--.4'IGi5E8?:'j_;, AS273, ._ V V' . . ' . 'A "
L Saiim Sig K3&<i::s'E§a§i),.T, ' ' fige: mafia", = V Gwrgez Sf La;::;;; §:€3L;;;_§fig "
R$g.N€::,_§i:%-2'?';:' :59, _ V Rfisilgifng at Gpgjc-aiés is Maramma Tempia V' «--.{}a:"s'fi%ifi:_ag&:, Céiaiiaiaefé »~ 5??' 332, A V , iC%1i::*a:§*::':"ga_ §';§::'i€:é, : 2. 523%."-T§3a§3z%é1;:a§a§§;'é E%éZ§.ag'avapp'afl SE3 éiéeiaggavagjépag fxfiajsaz ' §i'iS?;i§a:3;9$€«~?{}§iiC:J Eiaédér '. £3333; heészéng Reg,E§§.K%.~2?;' E9 j§?'?s3:5Ci€:1: {if Ezéagifé ifzas; ,»f:§§€§'1C§€S9 _ §;§7fs:E.§'.i=§93;§i §%5flJ€f'§L _{,éa_§p€a§ fiégfiziaseé 33$ aggzémsi, R2 " Efééé arééz" daiéé E21,3.)?;® 2} ,5 J , ,~.fJ 2%, xi?
7 3' Tbs Divisienaé Manager.
Unitefi in-$313, Ensu_ra:1::€ CG. Ltd"
;DiV§S§C2I1a§ Offica Akkamahafisari Raade, Baarafiagera, C' ' R€*Sp£:§1.{§_€Qi:% V V " ' {By Sr: Q,I'v'3'ah€sh? Ads: R8} MFA is fiisd ufs 39$) 3? the V\;'\5;>'iE§me:;'2»;..C<;m§;efl':;ai:£%3n Ac: againsi the judgment and Qzrdsr dated; 2Q.2g2i3€i_8; gassed in WCAX 193 52696 CT} the {:16 _ sf the = _Lab"<:.1,11' Gff:c€:=" and Csmmissianer fer Workmefig" --Ca--%np§::1Sa:iQri;, Chiairadurga, gayfiy ailowing the 3:31:11: petitieh 233$ <':r:s:§:;;>e:1_S22_i:§»<;:*:; -and seeking enhancemsné sf cempensai:i0:L__ " --
%i*~>'%§"§'« .\ I This flcaméng {af;'. };f{§: ;:5L:im'i§is"éx:@':€ the £G?.ii"'E éeiivered the fo£1a:&--'i1:{;;»;:.__ ' _ V = j » V .... 'K;§;§;:3.c;':z§§;N'*:*._::__,1 The apipfiilanf::0'§_ S«:3,f:::3fi$d with 'ghs quantum cf C€%f§p€i""?.SSi§G1'i A€:3_z.?é;:de'<E.V_ am}: Gfdéi' éaieé Eg.>2agfi§$ gagged §:2 A§%i?€';i%,f§i;?R.;zE§EXQGQG gm {E15 ms 3? £26 ;£.§§s;,;:: ¢ V" 311$ """"§§ 9m§n§3si@::e3r $0: We:*k:§€§:'s €;a:r:§§::\é:a':",~:?:'i':1:A§'"£;-v._?:fii:§'2::fg{im*ga fiistrisa £ihit:"a.:ia:1jga§ {hsrsénafésr 'V '*3fT?3'j§3§"§'§§L"{"} 'és ffiefi thig agpeai _ Ehfi f'a€%;:'é effize $3.56 338 as amdezr:
E"¥j:s ciéaizzéani féeé éhe Claim §€7€I?E§€}§}; béffiffi £25 WCC '-g é'seéi:;i:*:§Rirzsfiépéizsaiiaz: caniefiéirzg ihaé 3:63 Wag W2/ariaizag as , 'z' '6 a §a::"':'j; Efiaafing Ragga. '§*=.;;:;a;{z§~~2}"5§;€.';§' bsieiégéfi $33 ééié '4,E32"-'E*€;$§Gf}§€I"i§;, G2": E§&3,2§}@§, ::;<z: fits %:";ss§,:*:;~:::"s,is:;:":sas if}? file <:::§*:'"::.:*:* K G? ihe ierry, &{'{€i" igasiing S13 Emaii gf 3;E'€{?8.i1'£;§§. hfi p§":3iT{i;':'§j:éi;~"§ 'V'~~.v §%'{3HE Nayzzkarzghaiii véliagfe in '$26 v§§:1i€E€ iawarég '7' ififiagé fer urfiaafiing the husk at Karaéagé gffiabgge @§'Gé3:figiaVéi':Yhi;_ Afiar unlsading the same, while :e{::::iE.::g :{:E§E3,::3.'3~£€V'§"V:3.j7__' 333011: L88 gm. an 1Z?.3.2(}G5, ihé'«..appéi1a,:{:j:§a:f:i::§;»€._éssé; sofiirgi 31%? $16 E0333: arad 3:236 £:€h:{:§é §%:'§§ irgia §§rf:%:.. a result 5%? which, he Suffered f:'Aa _é§I-ure-"VA0fi.b§§iE: E:¥5;:§s 9:? his right kg and sustain€§ grievgus ir:j:;;7§Vés.Vfu;s V_§:>t§:€:*'pé:9:§--.iéf the body, immsdiaiély he xva:§§ étcé Qovernmeni Eiespiiai far firgi shifmd 2:9 Vims Msdicai CQi1<:;g;é§"i??i{§sf.§§%_a1,'« H€i"fl1fJilC1iE§'§O}:'1€ eperaiien and {E26 rgdg ii§§§.ti€fi'i far 3; geriedi af 2% dayg a::;{3_ ~2"€;_é':V.f:;:': é;";.',%駣§§é sf six mssnéhs. Diié'. is 153% i:<7g;A':V,::'%§s ":*%i§IVi';""'i.¥E sagas? die 32% wark as driver. 1P:*:;e3é*V. f:'r3=€ E:€VaCs::§:ieé%z:V€VE1§ was geiiing saéaijgs :3? Rs.%%,€'}§{};'» 912:. =..g:ij;§: baiig R8; /1 pa: (3332: Ex: viéxar sf '£216 fracmrs 8? kg _ 3._:7:§s_%:@ri&§f:;z:;g'«:_af right kg? ha éagagé éc: $26 weiéi ag §.i"}§%f€§"
«« C 332$ 3{%::z:gh'i,§%:' camgeggaééam.
._ 3 " _ §?:,f:g:.<2.:.2.m':iL is "$36 zzgfice igsguefi bf; Eihs W653, ihezsgé $33 E5' :";ié§;}:>:;§§é::§;'§*a;:*:§:? %'€§1iCi€E E'5%i'E§"§7€'{§, fififiiffi Eziéééca mmaiszaé LL~..;:f=;r3§:"€:*§§%:2%:Ve£, FEEE 2;"?! ?;"€:'§§0E"§§f3'f}'3;, fiészfi 2:a::*iéé€:: ::é.;2:€:n$§§; a::0r1'§;€:2§§z:g '€323: he was {$26 Gwner sf Earry baasing Regs}, Naa§{,%%'=.T 2>?;'E§§ 32$ he Said 'éhfi szahiek: in faxzaur of 1&6 13? "
'1"h€ dairnazzi W38 sarerkéng as driver in {he saié i£}rr§.fV respanderfig V33 ga érzg Salary sf Rs,-£i~,i}¢C}§}'A R3.§,,S§G,/~ per ménéh, Since {ha 'x/'e£*;§§1b%:*--.V_A.:'»=s <:;i{gfé::'{.>3:§'~ insaranceg the Ensure: has iga €0:FZi§°€:t'::'3'VE~E;i€ E¥::%.,.é§a.§:§:a:§%;b éifié gaught for zziisrzzisssai sf 31$ Ciagim ;:ja..€:'€:1§af:.é;'s;..agai:/:§;E*f:E':€ 2?"? resgandené, 4E The 3" canigading ihai 32$ fine W66 :3 Show 3323?; £36 c§a5:;:i1é;:§i:.: fir U.f2C§€§ iihe :3? i"$S§)G:"%§€EE§ aéiéi' }:i:§ 'xAé:s; R;§=4«,£}(ZsQ/~ gm" 331$ Efigiia cf Rs'.1,5uQ §;5~ 3,38 dfiiféifiifiiié hag baa":
§:':§3&:.;_§§€§ $16-c§.::s:«§:z:ar:f; hag susiaineai Engury in {he maé.f{:":2::'7§ié;«..a<:::v§fi'<:%::éi} 'ihgaé; ascurrsd 3:: 3213,2865. '§'§::er€ is mire W",;*$§e:,':§a>:;$':;i§:='§£" f:rz*é5¥f::£,€:::* 3:15; Sfifzfafii bsiixfsaz £316 Céaémani and:
i§j::€ Swiifif ::»}§i' é;%i%; xféziaia &:':§ geaghi; 5:15: éismésgai <35 "she siaim .j§3f3f§i':Z§;G':T'E ga' 3,g&§:1$E 33:8 3"? iesgzrsizéiezzi $33? 333% 7§;2:3;$:2:"~; G5 ééiigi §§€a§§§'1§S sf £3.53 §§§i'é<:*<s 333$ 8;§§€§" $33 §?§§~: spa: i§'§S§€€i:§8E"i, :*&§:§@':'%; wazzzgfi cazééfécaia ffl»;§_,/;/W»! 5 \ "-:'r.'r.'6' 'Z .:::3& eihex" §'€}€'%'€ifi§ §'€CSE"d:3, {he i?s!C€f:' heié; 'aha: dua is {ha Eizaffis 8.{3C§&€¥:i Gizcurreé $3 E'§".3g2€?€:?5g iha cia§;:22;r%é--«.."§;aS' sustaineéi injurisa and {hers £8 seiaiiénghip 95 _::r;_3;_éi;:€rV servazzf: betwezerz aha claimant ané iihe <;wne:f 'ejf '2;;«s§§1:s;E§:.'V'VV:AT_[ A' $333.66 '$136 vshicie is €OV€E'€C§. by E:23u.:2*€:: f;h1<{ i'f:$ura::,€:%:..}:'§';$ csmpensaie the ciaiznant. _ . _ §, Wit}: regard :9 the §C;:lafii:i_1_'E°i. _ a:,:f 'w<:9§:3p€"ri«sa§,t§;Q,:: is cencsrnefi, BER T Ci:and;§asvEié:}r;a§§?.3 whe ireaied the Ciairgani, is {$36 fractum sf iihia <:)§1€*fa§'4V,':f5;?.t',%:3:i:"£9%:V'>ds and piates were implanteé béih '$01283 $1" right ieg and fiich. in Vi€\,V 93%' 3131:? 3: is diifisuéi ::$ $13.3 aagigseé "$16 igsg 05 earzaing ::apf.:gg--gi:}f :9'4§}§:i€:1%.'Vé3f ':6 ?§% éisabiiiiy. Ehfiugh fir1%§V_cfé¢i§§;:Vé;'::§; "<:.Qi:r€:§::&eé iéiai: ha @333 geiiing aaéary sf R§g4,§i;3$;,;<I+~ ef Rs.i%§G§;'~ my E}"ief,3?ii§'E., ma *.._§ié§{:';:::¢;er:%a flags §;:e§:;}*§m§::€§5i. in $316 gifigfizzse 2:')? {ER same, figs '"'€§€f:(.'":'_ixz?:f;§E:3 :aie:§..?:;%g mic c:Qnséée::ai;iQ:1 {E13 '*5£'3§€:'3> éemg gaié :3 yea: 2§§§a, %;a.1i§e:: tbs iEE€:§f{i€ :3? ma céaimafii 'E?ff:~;VV.:_§§,_Ef'\§{','%€32;'~ §,::::§ &§§§j;'§E"i§ "ahsé §'€§€i"8£Zi§ §ac:';a§ cf E85;-.3?' 332$ Ema {:@§"§$§§§€§"a'§§{}§"i éhg Eegg gf Qamézzg saspaeiéy é;s::e 3:': <3 €>:é§ni G? ?5% and awarrieé ssmpensaéiaa cf R:~:s.29§Q,,S8'?'f'jé'»T wfih §§:E€§€S§;' 3': LZ% 93., {mm $26 daié ef Qzésr. "$333 CE€«z::s§'2_:§_{ , A' being net saiisfiéd wiih tbs quantum of c@zn§5r:sat§Q::'_Aas.§ra'.§5f§ie;$I: by me WCC has fiieé {big appeal, 232 Sri T Jagan? Advacaéis apgearifig fig?"'fi:é"-3§3:>$£Ea%:§'«.
Centended ihai ihe: aréer passeé by Es :;sn,§r1a§y"':f;é"Eav5 theugh {he ciaimani was geitizgg 3aia;§z..;:}§".Rs';«E3',5GG;*'¢-- 'aha WCC has iaksn 331$ incoms sf i}3.é;:1éiin32;z':..."E" :é;.§fE?;1s%.:Z%,5GG/~ pm. Further, E3 E/'§€'W cf the :;"actu:s"'G1fAé:h§: right leg, he Carma: fie {ha woaii; if-':§ 1R.._CCi.§ughi :9 have iakén mtg mnsidsmfign ':i:¢"fui:;(:ti0n»aE ;d:é{:=~ab§§iijj,{ 369%. Hencea he sought for satiiging g3§fi::"}:;dg:1iE:.;13 and ardar 9:" E316 WCC by afiowing the agpjéiaé: .
8; ?vfi§fi§S%1§ if?£i:r:v--.....,é§::§V@CaE€ 8.§}p€a}"§;'f1§ {Gr the 3?"
rasgérsgzéiiféé; -€:c:;':ig<$:?;ra_é:v£§:%é":.§%19;§ iiaeugh ihe docier, "J:5"}":€} "i'::*ea€:e(§; filf H '§Lf§8.§ffi2%f1'f"f§€'§§;GS€§'if; Eéis €V:?d€;::z§€ 3:23;: 3933 95 sawing caggacity éfiiga 3% 13:6 iiacéurs :35 iibéa 831$ fibuia is is 3:1 sxégerzf; G? 65 is 33%, _"§7€AAea%;c':;;'€?, 33% W{::€ aviihaui zzszjg bagés §:Va§i€2:1 '£326 3335 Q? 9s::?s;:::::?::*g ::,a§:za€:§{;§; :23 2:25": sxism sf 'i%.3'§"i§{?,§:E E55 f3€%§'§§.E°§E.T§":g" 3:3 éiaéeza " .'§u:":%':V€£i ':§@%&§§": 23:6 {Z§&I§§,':3.8;§,":§ E233 £E<:%§i%'E€1i%£§€§ fiégzé E26 Wag saéazfg <2? T%2sx--'§gZL%%'f§G,!' gm? in $236 :~;€3;r ZQQ3 :*:f:ai>:;:2i:'}:s :3? C if Eirzerfi is :2-fzarésgéngg 8? righi Egg by ,5 1 dscuznfinii hag 75:66:: ;>mé;1;:*»e& io Q36 332$ effez::t' 1::
Q? ihe Same, WQC has 13363 ism) a:eI;3i:§;?§faii€:%n iht' '§.f:~<'fC§:I1€};. Gf 'éhe: Claimant as R$.3,SQ€}f~ pm. and E;'%.?'s§'8;f'- §€C: ans} ihe same :53 mat Iiabie :10 be _§%f:~i;ze:*fe:"é«;i§ .3155: prayed thai £196 app€ai may be dismissziédg * _ _ 9, I have {:3_?e:-efzgfijg CQ§1Si§*5¥§fi iEf:é"'arL,gf;:;?r:i"€;:;_is adé':"s:§'§ez§ by éisez ieameé 2395111331 fer the -231$ era} and éacumemiary €v§éen:;e }§é'i--._§:: béiijis i§:é'~§3;1:£:éS';« "
EQ, U§€Z}§'§. héaringi fi:§:""E;:a:f:"2€{:i._ ::0:;;f:ss31"fé'i""§':€ gartirsss, the Cgfiy §{)iE1i that afi;:eVesi:fg§'§ cof%{sid:Vé*fafiéfi': appéaé is:
ifizfiihifir 81$ "€>':.*i:_§.&§ §,%as'sé:Cdi'~«§}f WCC requires any iigierféféncs? V V % ~ 3:, ii is. -33: E2'? :i::i;$?;::z§vie {he ciaimami éaag auséeiraéd §§{3;':ir'is;.~%$ {'§:§é":?a3::§. :ra§f§éVé;é&§§e§1§ that accuyrsé an é'?.3.2Q§§. E6 "£215 C§irV€r§§£:fi€fi£ Iésspiiai Siédaguiz ' "A--:§L7ijE1F€8i%%1*?§';'§1%€ '§7'$'é§fé§}if'{§é £0 'Wins iégiiicaé Cafiegs Eiaspitaés 222:3 ir:§ai§::3::: "<:%: a gesriad sf 3&5» $3533' 2% was '7._'_%;;::§::§:*g"Q:":aé"~«.c:§:e:rai§<;r2 azzé éhe gisfié radg zmsj gfiaies wars '' é3":S%3':é:eaj;. 'E'§":€ §%§}C'{.€:?§", Earha %:'§€3£;€é fie séaimana ésgsasaé 32:':
"'--V..;€ja;飧;€::ca {fiat in View sf '£2383 §:'.3£:;2::'°€ £25 £335: éibia 323$ iéibuia 52$ 5"' 8 ii'}C§"i¢ in View <35 ?;E:a§.. E16 Ciamnei £0 ihfi vmzés: S23 5: d:°§*s;'€:: Yhe dsctcxr &SS€.$8€§ "ihs 1985 sf aarzzing cagacity 2% 3:: extem; gfi is ?€?%. Bawavsr. {E16 WCC Whiis auzaffiing 'E336 iakéfi mic} conaideratian ihe 1:335 of earning gxtent 3f 36%. Ejnéez §€¥S:§;iG§} 4{ :;§ -1 Cgmpeiené; nzafiezai afficey hag {G EESESS £:Ef:8'~§.Q:3s z:>§V.'€:a:;:':iin§§ 3 cagacity if the irzgury suséairzefi an uascheéuiad gas. in $36 inséiéizi C8.f§'€§ ',"v"éh'v{".:':';é§.'L3:E'537€'i:.)}', a§§$7i}eaEefi the £3-iaimant, 8.$S€SS€§ ihe Eoss am fixtergi GE 35 is '?{}%E. figs '$5.3 bésnaideraiiea the 1038 sf earfiéfig ?§%, whizrsh is fisaéragr ':9 Egiézg" mi)": yrefarrfié any appsai ;%é:§é§i;:駧}?; wgrking 21$ :2: §:*ié;@r* Ehgugh he 'E1332'"'i:9z:'i€§:%§3€éE'~. §:E:g%:;€ is was geéiiing salary sf R:=..«~;%i:~,,§8fi;'_ 52;; d:§5::'r.:1s3nf: 1138 been ;}rc:duc€d ':9 ghow {E15 Same. :E:*:.efs-.%;g§£ez: mm aazzsifieraian §§':€ minimzzm :."»¢f,.f§§;3ga3 éizfi sampergsgiigfi. Taiiérzg Ems) j"V:;A g§:~;§V§.€::*a:i' 5i;€:u éhasé 3S§€C'§$ 65 $18 maigiez: E fimé :20 J: '5:=...¢§rr:éig'aEa:"§:§* 27:'; {E36 Qfdfif' pasaed ihs 'zfififiiiil E336 Ego: mafia 532%: any cass is §§E'i6f§€;'€ wizh {E6 aréer ' ~_;,féé§%€:'§;V ELEEE: EEECCE §3.Q<:<::ré:'§2g'§::;.; E @2233 $15 §G§Q§i?§fE§: \.
.. .... _. . z _\.u.'..\..\.\.$..~\