Karnataka High Court
P B Nandish vs State Of Karnataka on 23 June, 2009
Author: V.G.Sabhahit
Bench: V.G.Sabhahit
:3»: -"mg: :~::::;;«; cs::a:;::*:' 1322* §~I;z':E€?€§§E'§%.I{& A'? E3A§'€{}.5$_L{}E€E {EATEE} 'E'%§iS -53%: 23%) SA'? {:9 dU§'~EE:
PRESENT T}-{E ,¥§'G§*~E'%LE M3. 9.9. :>:'séA;;;g;2AN§.'{;:~;:§,:';?;:£:§éS§i:::i:i '* 2 AN'3L:g mg §:£;§é?§3L&: :~:§§::»;' J:.:_:s;*I*§<i:§;; '&jY={E-4 :3:5;%:s;;~§§§;»§:?:f: . W'§€:§'§' PE'E'§"E'E{}%'~é r~§U-§»,»§:;3§:1:%2u.._"£;}:zgggéasé g{;s~;§}§§;S»:-via:
8E2'T"i¥E§£%';?€:
E. fink §'K§§. §"'%23:}.§f.$;i>;., V Sf 53. F3, §é'2}jr§2.p§:::z§:;, ;.*'/'gfgA€a".§ -- ..§;'§%s;31:f -- §:é;?:;'::-, ifI.";%*{,§{i£i;:'_}é3;.r;"'駀?§i'3f;§3_E'§..V 4' " .V _ €f;T§3;3;§z*s::§:z3;'5g;a}' -7£T§§.s;€:ci<::, ' = , {T}, 35; **:;«:3a:::<:aaéé::3i;:7a%3;
-- .fSj~;:u E3g2;:*a::::3*3wara§:pa, &g~r:%& 2§;;é:i:fi 5%?) jgrsars, V' §;g.%:im;it11ri$t;"'Géxfiabmzahai, {:.f§:.'Ef%Iar;%1:rga {}}15§'£::'iCE, ,. A .,v§{;9;§'éj§fa§§a, S ::.:¥; §%;_:"+£é£§1a§§aiEag3pa5 §:_gs::i. .;%E:@"a'%{. £33 :;€2a's, ' .. Gagi a"i3a:1a};.ai§ {j?E:i'a§*a{§"§1rga D§S'§§'§=:?"£, Se Eféafigsizg Sig' 8. SE:a;:2m;.1;%;3§:s§}g/2, figagi about 3% jg-'f:.€i}'$§ §€3{§a'§fi'§38}ZEa3i§ {73?%::l"'£;:'a€i izzga E'3%.s?§,§°;Z<;?3:
«£3 Ffié E £33 W §§,--':;,3:as3.%3.a§?
1
2 4 r -.3 £3. E; §i:;va.'2:2*ajg3§3.2s, ;":§ €23. {'fi§1a:§::a§}§?2a, Agétzi é"§§'}(§1§'{ j,;s:2,=;rs;, E€',«:=.::.*:"<3:t:»,2:;:'};5 $11 §{a§§€s;§':wa§ "§":=,£":: pééé '§'2"1.§s~§'i. if R}, Dimrzrier, EJESSN '::%AF~é§<m {§<,::'§a.E}a.3'2ah.e1§§ iiézéiraii znga §}§$*£".2:i€*E« §'!§£ifl&E§§§.3€i, $3} €3h3I1:1aE}asa;:;§=a, ésgafi a%3::"m§. €33 }='€E2'i:{'-'3, {7}«:;daba1":ahaE, €Ch:i§.ra:ji'a1:"ga I}is'§;:':i»::7§. £21?' §'v'§:--ii_§3:$S§";, 0: {Eu PaI"a1neswa:"a;)g}a, 1 égazfi £:£§'3£'§'i3.¥ 55 {}:3:.iz&%3a3§::«ifi3i, }?§::<eA-m3::,1r;i'E"3e:1:; €1§:;;:ii:?afl':=::=gé§::,--
:.;::1;z;fa:m'.rg:; 1?:>;s z.:~;:s<:, :¥§..§T«:. -.?;a»i§;s;}j:g<?ai;{§ju;f:a_.; ¢ 53 j £2 * E; E3. §§:>'§§f:'wa fa "gsgka, _ Ekgsii ':§?3§su2?tVLs;3 §E.,«:~:i'~ {:E1é:"%_i i'i§;&I1} Viiiagfi ?a;'1<'E3.a§-yafiz, {fi§1§§;§§£{§§.:.:*ga §§S§E".i{?i'{. ' '§{*;A'*<2fi2ar21} :1, E3 <sf%va§i:§.ga§géa§ ;<'%g::<_§ $:§3<:2%.1*£ 3%} }5'fiE§3.'$, . z'§§Ei§"i1§5?E:§<2i§ {.T.'§i:':i:*§s.<§.i.§1*ga §.T2'i,s=;':;;'*§::.L '\...«v' Stzzéa £35 §'4:Ei}."§'§;8.§$i§?I€i3 §1'§§T'§"'£'§'§ ii} 332 E E'; E4} 83%. Efiéij §'2§a:T;;§u.z1aZAE: W ééézz, far §3':':°§'1.:'$.::
E?€::i<p:"&s€.::§'€::§ E3}? fig $6»:.*;*eEx:~s.:j;, §3€3:"6$%: §:_§€.'§§é3.§§"§,§?;§zEt§E.'{§ E2:-'ES %3:,2'1§:fi.é':§g,ss§ ;?}'§§.«1:;':1 gig is') :6 .
§'<»..2 Q1 92* E§}€§,}2.:if; {;T:e:>z23::};°2i21%{>i' of F'G1*<33':s, {;-§1.ii§%3_{%11:\ga §7}ivi$3Z€;£:,, if-§:;i%2*a<§u:"ga}, §f}:":§}:3.%:}«_-' €3€3:I:1;;:i$$,%:}:i€§°, {Z't%2ii;ra<i:T1rga E} is::'*:<::t, {.":§1.ifré1e:i urga.
M} 3, Kmizazaka Rezzawabié §E»3-:'1m;g§: f.
.§_}s:v€Ec;;32I1t::11tT Limitacig $20.. 1, A' "
Gaffes Bsazri Bufidmg, _ E33: fim§3e:§ai<,1f 'ifisfidhé, V __ V V _ Bafigaiers, by its Maxgagifggj E:=§rs*:c':s:;F:';._ --
Mi 3. Sujaimi Er::€'7:';;,,:," Li'~.'i'£if€{"§'; _' V Sujaien Eimaac, }{:'<1Zf<3E1::é:_<I3-s:fi:1%:m3;--: AA E31 3v1'a:1ga§3m', ééiznzfiei.21%:-:é'iéi38i}.{T%§Z3'§; , ' _ §§EpT€$EH,T€€§ E3! ;i;":'JES£:1éigi:b:»g iT?3lif@§:'£1::ri§ 3C§3é3:3"_a€§:i.*_§ga 4§3§';§f;{:§§é1j'E{§, §3e§'r€s6r;ts'<?if éis 'Ti:-1:1;"é':i' Executivfi *Q}ff:§.€t&:r, i;.?Ei;.%ji§:::§'§°:3:'g;a.V '- '
-- f.}'¥7?2e 15:é:é;'§jS'é§ifi'§ Ekecéitiva £:1gi11€.6:';
» ' m:;::o;~ §3':"i.g::«:.:i:;~r1'if}é:§;:8;1'm3.e1;».':., zirga 21?-éééa E3'az2CE1a§;a.i,, CEx§,i:':e:{§s:;:'ga.
gségzéé-a~:%<:@§§ gimiiag Limiisfi, §€'.'E';{I?j_. {;i?fi3;€€ §%e:>a<£, éifhifmfitaaga, §€_€:§';:$s$z:i&{i bf; iis %f§£:1a3§"3§ §§ri;=ma§::t:: §'<"f§§$?{i}§=E§[}§?Z§"=§'§"$ 'gig;-1~ gm; E"é'i§c:1§§:a3" fiiqbgg" --- fiiéég gm, 5:32;: 5%' §%, :4 m _§-:23 Sri (RS; Eéanzgazr ~ ;'~§{i"§, £51' R4 Evéfg. Eéarsfia $2, H033 m fisifizg, far $3.5.
§i§2"'i. ?'§&fi§l§I1i§§i§'fi§§Ei§7 -- Sr. Cflililfiifii £351"
{}ma=°fi:.a:1.m aim FEa}€$E3x:%2:" - i5'm§_3@§€{i R8} Rflfiffifin 6% afld ?' «- 3.1%: Sswadé '?i':iS "s%';°{:"i. Pfiiiéiazz iésa; fziifizi §,i§;ii'§€§Z' Fafiicésg 1326 zgzzfi 21?? 0? EEK': €I.T:<::'§.:3':iiifii:3§: of Ezzzziia ggrafgfizig Efiiizit €{:}3i$ {jimzri bs g}E€a$E{§_ $0 iiirsct $23.6 ;§'€fS§}{}§1(§€Ii§..{'S E. ii) 3 is §§'::2:7ég::.I::3:* Am» &;3§3v:*"e;::§3z"i2%z.':€ a<s:."f£3i<:3:1 againgi z*£$pG;%:1{§;@:1£ss 4% gmii 3 fog' hzsszézxg Vie'§ai::~:{i i:fE1€ Ccs:1<'§§:iCs:1:~: s:5§i§}r_sEaé:€<i in EEK: Esase f§{:'={3CES:'» siiiitt ;"&m2@;::1.2:'f:-E3 agzgé {L3 amé §1};§"§;'§'2e:i'§' =:E%;r€»:"i i?£2:';% fiffiiz §'€.$pm1<i:':m. '{5} i"€s%:<:::i*€ the iiamagg caaisad to Au:'16E:aE :'es2e:'voi1' §;;§13«.:jé: amé {<3 i:?{}§3Si3:'E.:<_?E '{'€'i€:1E'i£3IE waié of €i'£."§'";:'t:' Siéifi <2? fig: :'<;>a{i1§:52:§i§A::g :0 '%ifind Eviiii E1"£1f:'--?§"}" §'é"3'§;:i«m..ii:$4 '§'i:;fés Wiéi EP'a%_"i€'§<}:'} C{}§LE3iE"ig (31: 330; §31*:i§;':££§.:'1{:=2::'j; ' §:~¥§:a%[;'i*::g ::~'::a. izhis aiajg, Eh: ff1c3'm*£ maiié ihii f<>1?ze:2w§_ng:H §§§§§é$§' €£i%3§iw':1"€{§ b}-">333. "
31. T3353 gsatiéiazzayfi 336" §;€S1%{i'€?§.V£.$u €'%%VVé€%{'§£c§3;'}éi%}é§ E-Féiiaga mzai am ;>7:g:;*::r;12E*£z1:iS":3 "§;:"Q£bss%$:'2':; "am? WEEQ are i:i.%€§*:°:$§.6{"i £31 3a.€%:g:;1a:*:'%3__::g 'éEi%.*;7' §%3§r:$i~.}f21:1{;é'.a.;1{i §:1§E{}22; {sf wz»::<fi:' §:1'i;;3 {§:é"§€:§s:w{>'%éf;*}s;é.¥i:3:a$££s;£ 2;: §§t:a::{%ig}z1m magi Anixsézai Viéiaga §.--é§:::if":§; §:"<;:»1'3;; §re7*§<f§:<;:VE§ v§E;1:i3-11$;-zmzgisg 9;? 2:':€::'€:~§ {$5 :--.2_gz"é<?:13;E:3.2.2.':--:i. §E.%§L§{'§,S am :m"ig5':7:':z--:{§,V §§ :~3v%i.--._ fiiégété ibis §sfE'§§ §3€'Ei%'.§.Q§1 §_}3::.%}-Egg 3%}? ?.§','§i ._':§§§§}§%*%%?§;:;g zfiiéfifkg ; ~ ---------- ~ * issézfi 3 Wm}: :32 SE13 fiaéziyfi {sf magzézizimiza V :*§:$g3<§m'i€§'2~§s E :0 3 1:9 §;n§%§ai.::
éa§3§j$r<3§;:€£a§.:: .z~':€%:é<:.:; age-zézzsi :'€z;ps:;}::{i5{~*:r;"§.$ <3 331$ 33 z W _. ':'.?=:3r %."a.a%?é:};g Ea'i:,€3§?,i§'.€f'{§ ?;§.'2€'. :%<3§2{§é';§§<::::$ $§37.§}T:.:§ai&:§ in the Eeasfi {ififiéfié aziié iizifixéir {§*:§'§':~«~::i. aha 5?-=""* E"S$§§E€,}§1{§.¥f3§'E?;', 3:3 §'$SE{s?;°€ the éamag: eéaussii *8} ?:m":r:.§f:2§} I'€ESE1"€2"€s§§T° iaka E"i£§(§ Ea €?€3£ES'i.Ef'%£C'§ :':--:E.5:::E.:E{2;:: Wei: G12. i'"i§:'€}'.i€E' giflza s::2§ $16 :*«::::&:{§ Eszfiiiggg Es; 'fifézad. Mifi §§:za%':°g§,; P§§,mi$,,. f' 'Eh f%,:><:*<.s:"5£:%:¢;g is ihif §L7€§ii§i{}§?:%'f1'S, Eiifsai. 5:33.-£<i;§is31'.:i :3? 5§'E:3'2§2{} é§(.',§'€S 0? izviiziéi :32: -E§};'?\'3{>.5-éé {:55 SL§E'"§"{}':i3'3{§&{I§ bf;-'" '}<>t%;:E>:-um} {ma}. ?€£%.i1€ii:§3.§§§'EE : £1': {f;E2§'§.:":ar:é:u'ga zaésfi: is 2: §%3:'£:£;*§»V .§ag:d'; %§:j%.:a§~ .§i'V3%?!',Vé};,"'§V§:--. :*63;V>:m{is:1i.~?é;'§; }{2:§;1.z~:€a}<:a §%é:'2:€aa?:%E:§£é LE5;f:3si3:*g§f §;13£';9s%i'.§::3;§}E1§€:1€:. Limitfisig agjgérsacéiagtzi figs: f;?,fS§;;'fi$;:sG.:';:sC§&};1.t ré;§'>re.$€:-ziéiig flag'? éi 2:3 izfiiszraéséitsi E1: ¥¥£ua:;i §3'a:"_3;:g '§E}_I:::1;f§g;" {}t*<.?§§0pz§§.s;=;1i £131' fix: 9113* 133:3 Céf g€£':m'"aE§js'--3.§§§" §§{é::ETr:%,z:§{§_}"'- :'t:<g;:é:s;E€{% ix) §3.rz::>v§{§€ Caflaizz €}<:'§:?::3?. {Ff §£i§_Z€§-§§} i"~ T:7:':<;€:;3;§é§a§':;£:;1":"'a:>'j£"?}x<§ §*J§E§i=°" €é?s§}€5£:{T§'i§f %'§iI3,r3;....[§3::é:';*::i' .§--'2.7;:::;:§_;'=::_:%?_ 13:: 3%:}';--;§%.VVV?'3:*€$é Eanfi; 'ihat the ;5i}E'§'§": réfiggazisitzsiav §:*C$E.3ié*a::,1i:?Ec%€?i magi ii} $1133? ifiiizzgi fifiifi {§<::1€::'é2§::m:~; '-:i%.>§a€3;é:.:L. ax?" fiiéii <:<;:é;{§:§§:;i:::::$ 3'§.£1§}22E,::;:.£,€{§ fig}. Eiifi §.:f::--:$<:<, €§£::{§" zagigi I:%:%=::"5§;::j;r' z§z:;s%§3*<3§,7${1 fihs i{.>§3ag:':«3;};E'2§7 :23' {E13 A « _ i°t:§;;{>3f1 2:31'i:'i._ ssavfimigr €32:m.a:g::=;§ aha: waésr figmr §.:;§'.::: tbs :*c$£:'v:3i:"
'«-T':::§%i:z;:z?§%;.VaE .f;§:v:a;':€:§::3E Vifiaga; fézai 02:} E§{Tf€{)¥;i§}Ki 237$' §%:}fiiS{'.E"§;§1§.'§E§.3§§:
";<f52:*;e::%::~;2 .=i'}§ 39%.? 35811' §'§.':{i 2':.m;§{ kid far Eajfiisg i"€Z§£~§;¥."§ £2'; §'€.E':£'§'i '»§£.i§§:~:§;. 'E¥'§.§E {}€§'E{"§§"£%'?{}§"S, 13:5: €}:Ei§1'§ figw ztaf fééifi '<»};"3'£€:° §?;:::;m 133.5 " ._C§§€::*}3'm€:1:s$ :.3E§'€f:§ iiéffi '§£§.':€i %.t*;"éga§i{):'; iézzzk {E§%33a.r'~'5{::ir} §'::e§§i Efrem:
i';'%.::«er:t'.§<:f::;§ §¢i§';£'§ ii': {E26 <:u:§"€E':ai a;1@z";§{3§>:1, %:%':s':§*<: is :20 §§::&%.%: a:2§ '2>2»~'a'{.a*.:' frag: E1316 {3Ei§<'§.'i§§;€§Ifi §§3."{f§% Emit} ai p:'€3:£:};E.. ¥;§::s3'fi E33 §;'€o:*2:£g€. <2? §-§2"§<2.§€'_f§" .3": ?2.§.;§26:§*2aE r£>$::~:'€:'a}é};'; E1152: 15.32%': §3€i?.§§§{};T§€§;§ wém EfaE'i?. .2ig'§*i€.%1§i%::2.:':$?.:; amé €::.€;i3*€:3}; €§.€'§}€1"}¢i ;3--;;3;<:;%:}. $12 i'f3Sé:?--1"%'€}iE' waiaz' £733: £316 §::%;.::'y{3$€ sf §:'*z"iga'{.%9::2 havé. Efiisf-§:3._§;%.;§ $25) gifiai E§a:"€§Sh.i§3 mid .%.2":<:0.z1*i:{~*:;f2.:?.:r:Ema. §"{€33€'.€ tiaifi ¥i5A,=;?;iV'}'§EA£§'%Ti':31"i;» 4_ 2; E' E43€s%g<;:'3<t§t:z:?S 3 $9153 §ié?£§:ui*'_ §'§3é:<,%y %_.§1§i€.i.z_ éT}v§i3'jg7t'3(?'§§é;"}I1S:'. iiiiiifir aiia §%can.'%f:a':{ii21g :§1a"§ %:E1:;: §»?:é;;x3;€:%s--:TV_ i§€i§'}2§{;_§f::;3f'1':5z}E?, 05:1 éézfi £_'§tC3{T%.$I:i}EEI"§'{S§ in %E2;:~":is;' p«fi)$::a%f$*3i9fi éihxzyzi s'¥:.§}€ $'§{§t ?;i'ES§}£<;"{iG§:1 :'*€§:s::>:'a 'pa"{};p03¢{§""i<V$. 4.%iZ;2C%«A2;<%:'€S (sf §.z:--a1r:'§ $3; S13.-*.E'~é'0,E4 af A;:n§%:éi__'V-éjagga ?'<:§1'€S€; $28?' ihfi {mirth §'i?$§£}Té§i:€'1i5§?:§'i§*7{;:3:"'f'§-:'V' fi'<§s:§}3A;'§",2{}{}f: r{:q'{:€Si%:=:C}; '£116 £}e;;}:::j§ E0 Esass [$.93 ?1=:T:I"{':'.S :3'? Ezmii eu'i€-,_ 30$?' - __§.::.;s ~' E-3js:.?§{>.S$§»- 53:" :'§:':£3€E:a§ 'E5é§"ag€, i?3}.i:::'ai%.f:.§;§;§a "§§'§ié:i'E:*é€%."'----5;a4 £'av<;v:::" £35 f§"5:;'%.'*;E*; :':és;3<}i:d{:§:§.»?'»x'E'f $5 ':%',€;'a:;f'3£.:}&'2 .EE1:'21's:::'g§; §.;.%::1: i?:.€{'§ ta; §'§"IS§§E':} :3 1:;§é;:gz§ xfizzsii {T£:"i§}8.C§§i_}'" W§.:£E<f§ E <> ' _ %3:§,€:i;§;f;=' :.§":§;_§:;i:t§' i}r:;v:"::i:2§mé:'§: m'§€:* éaisai M3,{§8>E'?~}'%}'§%; éhaé. ii:-:::f§}€£'%i€3::, '$3.16: 335%., {iI{3§3;5:@':"va§z:=§"' caf ?€:2:'{~:$;%s3 '---€j?.§3;.%'s§3i§§;\§_§A:é'*g2a E'§E,3;§}"§}ié?§S§.€}E'3., {.f§1.§E:"°a§zz.§"g:»2 z*€:§3<3:"£e{§ :%}::a:% :3§}i3.:€s;% §3§Eéf%§".,E,:ii€. Esamé Iiéifiafiéiifiég 4:598 i::i:z:*:m*:%s E3 zzszwar ii': :§€}§i§ifi;iZ§ * ,_5T}§L£»§§:3 f€}:'§€$§ ami §§a§'"§*5::: %§i3f§s'::{:r§: aizéa, éétzersz am 3739 v:ea§:::%.§§§:t: gfiaggis zmii E13633 €}€?;S§§Elg ii: §E'3.€.; Saki ama 2::':§; éiéiaz (32:35? 3:12:33 §'}¥;ES§',E§iS zziifafi 3?,.{;:é35$ zsxégi gezzigi 2:29: '%.:$::§°*;.:£ is-:3 af§?:);'@s';ie:§.i<>§} %%;03'k 353:1 §§".i{? azsfiz in t:;_':3:'é§;%.:=Z:3:': 5.»2.§':{§ §._E:2?:§ ii" is; 3 E3.§s3:<s§*:'<>;%§ g;§a:i*{*; %:;%.sa::r. ii'. a>;-'<:u§{§ Em £~£{§2f8l'}?EIg{fi§'iIiE§ ii; %'1:;1%J&: §..E"1x:E ¥'§'.i z:{f§ §*'ai':3:. §i--:":g;i:*::"}' E§i§'i{ii"{'f ii' w«;:}'2_:§{.é 232:' §:;%3E§'}:£%;§ '§_}£"'{I'%{'.§.%;E{?€"i€}§'§:~~€'ififfié """§;€_' 15;. '2a§§;, ii. $3 :'?§,3.E§(} %i?G'%'fi'.{?§1{§€§ff Eigai {Em fjik-31.. géésiziiii mi ivzag '' {'§'§g°s:ic%'{{:{"§ EE}-" izim §:.:2z.::'EE§ .1':3§a§}{§méé;;1: §;;}; §§i7*C';'.é"'i,I, éizééztgy'sé;7:i;1{i_.':3:i§§§; {3'%:'€"Z'=1' 3:3; §:.%.§"{?.3E1 at}? ¢~"§u'§Z%é"§ ilficiz-szffiza aims'? it ifi :%:?;;s:éa;it:Va%f>§€ éézai. 2'32}: {ts§:3E'2i4i§9%:.§3;::€§1§ =23?' %:}::{ts_~2€ '%};2'i:"::f§'.._.:é_2é§i$, .3"<:"};%.{§§ 33% :;:?{%::$$a§'};" it "$:r23:'2$:p{:%:"€' $316 2212 :t°§"§_=;:;;:r:§f}-* jé:§*:_£_;i 'm;22iiT%:é'3a§Z;+:§$ éfszs 332$ s:'§é:$§§.::éz§'i<:::}. ;§i}<:;i:2'%' zméé iémé: %.:j,.-" .:{f?§€i"'K'{§jéi§:f'§'{§V " } éfifirze if" '%.E2 :"<3e'§mz.1{§»::z:i 21:: :;:§.::;3E'§;':=« $23; E.§§*§? {§;EI%J§f{§"~i,V1§;'i3§§'§§}§:.?'§;'%£'§{§§f.%'i £§'§.e:§, §:§;1:":§* vmzzééé 'iaiéa-"§::'€:;::t::~éZ% "%.::$£%f:f2?&:.':é::";2::"ms:::é%é::.§':%s 3:; '§}§"€":Vfi'§'fi s<}éJ; €:i'a}é_:3;::a':';. 2:::{.§"'.:§2:1zz::21égr:§'§7%;<;21::; '§::a;E.{i;" ilig P' azigi <;*<2§;iE:';;",::t:§§ Eilzaii z:'ar:'3i.é:::%:; E?%'é§E.'§§.f§ 'E':-x;?%_ €;5~§<€:§1.§"E:'3:ii %.'?{I%:§;1i~§i"1"'L1{7"§'§{}§fE e:;:§' r°::ri'2?:'::1§:..:g a%2':<":§.§ as 1-1-?:=:E:.'; »g2§;§3':"?:Lé:a%*.§::::': ::ré9a';;§§;¢§_§:§.fA."ga?:;:"g'21{§ 33$ iaksgg 5:: éhéir <:<'22'i;§; %E";3'?;. Sag
--. ;_;§a5:.i_§i:3;':.€fg'§s€'~-E}.:.~12::: msraé. gévsm ;:~;i':.j_; a;3§:2§;:<'z:»3'E.é<3:1$ ;':{;§" Eaavfi '§;%:§:j;' "- §I;%§'v€':r§x.:§§fZ4?§v' :.;.éféf:--:'€: §;;a:s*;';Z:'::?: 9? 'iéxfi ihérti §:$$g)s;>:;.::§$3:;%:. 2':';E1§--'" giiiiifaiéflfi 'z§;.g:%i_:':5§::.V;s::*s;"g.§<:«::€§€::n:§§ 5% gimsfi 37> ::m§*§ §'é..'::_%€: iési' 'aim $335 §;:=§::>g€<::%. ::i%,§'}7<;<::f?.§§'1'%. §"i"§1"%?{"':j%' ::2"::m§";£3:$ {$5 25 i;éi§z1;g5;'~; 522%: :L::<?§%;:{§€<'?E 2'2.2i:{§ is: .V fi:.€§§€ ¥§§§;3;g{§$, mas: 9%' Ehfi a3::":a$ {§.€§%':"i§L€}§f§{:'€§ fin" £235 2%;i.2;.":a:% ::;1:::'g:§;" '§}.i"{}__§§'f{:'i gig'; gm: €§§ff{?i 22:1}? s:::27:'r:<it%sm:"::':':' {inf gmfg §2:;§:}:' as ii 11$ 3 E3a;§*;"%i':: .E1é}.%.$('§<:.
§é'A:{§€x: Ekéiéf §\é{;s si*;§m§.a§.::<§ 133: Eitzis %€§,2:':§~::'--: <i€:<%£'Z;:§ 333$: <ié3'€<:§.:?a:2§- §'7§€E1 ;*€5§§<;::::::§$z:'€ ii} .:'s::;§€>:'{-*: €316 ziézaiizagsz <':22.a.1s€{§ ~_§'<;,;»_ _"'§':2§;z3j:?}3;3§ i"€'$£§"'%="{3§.'£' E-.::';.§§€ £5511"? £0 <;rs3;}.$sfl::"z.:{*% :'§:%.:;;1:é.{>:s Ea-*z?;ii= €)§'1A):£t§"f,'.>§f§i?_i::"V§€1{', as?' %;.§'::€=. §"i§:";?.€§. ééiezziiziig ié} 21$ mci §*~z§%§§_E1?§:fi:fgj; E?'Ea.3i:'€9is;~ E?+£;.'§€. §P'aE:€;§E'.i<3:1 £3 {%és§:z.>;3e{%. <35}27:{:e:§é::;2"':ii:.1g§§,5';A . . "
"C.%:éei Justice Tilda?
§¥::'§'} 3% £333.; 'fafif 353$ ?v'§S§i'*