Karnataka High Court
Sri K Siddaraju vs Union Of India on 7 June, 2018
Author: A.S.Bopanna
Bench: A.S. Bopanna
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 7TH DAY OF JUNE, 2018
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE A.S. BOPANNA
WRIT PETITION NOS.51401-405/2017 (S-PRO)
BETWEEN:
1. SRI K. SIDDARAJU
S/O KARIPUTTAIAH
AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS
DIRECTOR (TECHNICAL)
BESCOM, K. R. CIRCLE
BENGALURU - 560001.
2. SRI N. R.M. NAGARAJAN
S/O N. R. MARASWAMY
AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS
S. E. E., T. T.,
M. C. BUILDING 1ST FLOOR
KADAMBA HOTELI,
KENGERI
BENGALURU - 560060.
3. SRI VISWANATH NAIK
S/O VENKAPPA NAIK
AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS
RESIDING AT NO.C-101,
PIONEER PARADICE APARTMENT
BRIGADE MILLENIUM ROAD,
7TH PHASE, J P NAGAR
BENGALURU 560078.
4. SRI G. R. CHANDRASHEKARAIAH
S/O LATE RAMAPPA
AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS
CHIEF ENGINEER, K. P. T. C. L.,
K. R. CIRCLE
BENGALURU - 560009.
2
5. SRI HANUMANTHARAYAPPA
S/O SANNAPPA
AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
CHIEF ENGINEER (ELECTRICAL)
KPTCL, CAUVERY BHAVAN,
K. G. ROAD,
BENGALURU - 560009.
KARNATAKA STATE. ... PETITIONERS
(BY SRI SATISH M. DODDAMANI, ADVOCATE )
AND:
1. UNION OF INDIA
THROUGH THE SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF LAW & JUSTICE & COMPANY AFFAIRS
(LEGISLATIVE DEPARTMENT )
SOUTH BLOCK NEW DELHI.
2. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY
VIDHANA SOUDHA
AMBEDKAR ROAD
BENGALURU - 560001.
3. THE STATE OF KARNTAKA
THROUGH THE ADDL CHIEF SECRETARY
ENERGY DEPARTMENT
VIKAS SADAN
AMBEDKAR ROAD
BENGALURU - 560001.
4. KARNATAKA POWER TRANSMISSION
CORPORATION LTD
CORPORATE OFFICE, KAVERI BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
5. THE DIRECTOR
ADMINSTRATION & HUMAN RESOURCE
KARNATAKA POWER TRANSMISSION
CORPORATION LTD
CORPORATE OFFICE
KAVERI BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
3
6. SRI LKSHMISHA N
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
TRANSMISSION ZONE,
KPTCL
TUMKUR.
7. SRI PRABHAKAR M. S.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
TECHNICAL AND PROCUREMENT,
KPTCL CAVUERY BHAVAN
BANGALORE - 560009.
8. SMT B. JAYASHREE
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
CORPORATE OFFICE, COMMERCIAL, CESCOM
MYSURU - 570007
9. SRI CLETA FERNANDES PRABHU
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
MARYLYN BIJAY
MANGALORE - 575004.
10. SRI VIJAYA B. S.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
COMPUTER CENTER 2ND FLOOR
KPTCL, KAVERI BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009
11. SRI MAHESH S.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
ENERGY DEPARTMENT
VIDHANA SOUDHA
BANGALORE - 560001.
12. SRI SURESH N.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE) RTD.
NO 3, KALIDAS ROAD,
V, V, MOHALLA, MYSURU - 57002.
13. SRI ANANTHA SHAYANA IYENGAR
SUPERINTENDT ENGINEER (ELE)
KPTCL, CAVERY BHAVAN
BANGALORE - 560009.
4
14. SRI KULKARNI S. K.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE) RTD
"SRINIVASA" PLOT NO M 26,
SECTOR NO 57, NAVANAGAR
BAGALKOT - 587103.
15. SRI UPADHAYA N. K.
SHRE SUBRAMANYA NILAYA,
2ND MAIN CROSS,
KEMPAGIRI - 580001
DHARWAD DISTRICT.
16. SRI UDAYAKUMAR BOSGE
SUPERINTENDT ENGINEER
MRT, CORPORATE OFFICE,
GESCOM, GULBARGA.
17. SRI THYAGARAJ R.
SUPERINTENDT ENGINEER (ELE)
SCADA, TCD AND LDC, KPTCL
BENGALURU.
18. SMT BHARATHI H. K.
SUPERINTENDT ENGINEER (ELE)
KPTCL, HRD CENTRE,
BENGALURU.
19. SRI PRAKASHKUMAR B. T.
SUPERINTENDT ENGINEER
IT & MIS, CORPORATE OFFICE
BESCOM BENGALURU.
20. SRI NAGARAJA D.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
KSPDCL
BENGALURU.
21. SHIVAKUMAR K. V.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
TRANSMISSION ZONE,
TUMKUR CIRCLE, KPTCL
TUMKUR.
5
22. SRI NARASIMHEGOWDA N.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
O & M CIRCLE, CESCOM
MYSURU.
23. SRI NAGARAJ S. B.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
HIG 18, HESCOM
NAVANAGAR HUBLI.
24. SRI RAGHUPRAKASH N.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE
TECHNICAL SECTION, CESCOM
MYSURU.
25. SRI ANIL KUMAR S. BABALESHWAR
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
330, 2ND STAGE, R. C. NAGAR
BELGAUM - 590006.
26. SRI VENKATESH KUMAR V.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
T & P SECTION, KPTCL
CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
27. SRI PURVACHARI K.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
RT & R & D, CAUVERY BHAVAN
KPTCL BENGALURU - 560009.
28. SRI BHARATHISH RAO V.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
JOINT DIRECTOR (PROJECTS ) PCKL
CAUVERY BHAVAN
KPTCL, BENGALURU - 560009.
29. SRI GURURAJA SUVARNA M.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
NO. 4-2-96, GURUPRASAD
NGO COLONY, KINIMOOLKY
UDUPI.
6
30. SRI NITHYANANDA K. C.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER (ELE)
# 2767/2, PAMPAPATHI ROAD,
2ND CROSS, SARASWATHI PURAM
MYSURU - 570009.
31. SRI YOGANNADASWAMY B. S.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
9TH 2B CROSS, ASHOKANAGARA
TUMKUR.
32. SRI KALLAPPA VIRUPAKSHAPPA LAGUBAGI
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER (ELE)
# 206, AURAHTI SOMPAL APARTMENT
17TH CROSS, IDEAL HOME LAYOUT
RAJARAJESHWARI NAGAR
BENGALURU - 560098.
33. SRI HAVALDAR V. K.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
IT CELL, CORPORATE OFFICE
HESCOM, HUBBALLI.
34. SRI KOLAKI I. S.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
TR (W& M) CIRCLE, KPTCL
MUNIRABAD.
35. SRI NARASIMHAMURTHY S.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
O & M CIRCLE, HESCOM
SIRSI.
36. SRI SURESH T. N.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE (PROJECT - 3)
HESCOM, HUBBALLI.
37. SRI DEVIREDDY V. Y.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
TBHE, TB DAM CIRCLE
HOSPET.
7
38. SRI MAHADEVA M.
MANAGING DIRECTOR
GESCOM
KALABURAGI.
39. SRI NATARAJ C.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MAJOR WORKS DIVISION
KPTCL, TUMKUR.
40. SRI AFTAB AHAMED
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE (PROJECTS)
CESCOM,
MSYURU.
41. SRI RAJENDRA KUMAR S.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
SLDC, TBC, KPTCL
ANAND RAO CIRCLE
BENGALURU - 560009.
42. SRI LAKSHMIPATHI L.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE
(CUSTOMER RELATION & DSM)
BESCOM
BENGALURU.
43. SRI RAMANJANEYALU K. V. C.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CIRCLE OFFICE
NEAR BUDA OFFICE
GESCOM, BELLARY.
44. SRI NATARAJ B.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
220 KV SUB STATION,
KPTCL, ANCHEPALYA.
45. SRI SHVIAKESHAVA REDDY S. N.
EXECUVTIVE ENGINEER, BMRCL
BENGALURU.
8
46. SRI RAMAKRISHNA K.
MANAGING DIRECTOR
MESCOM
MANGALORE.
47. SRI NAGESH H.
DIRECTOR TECHNICAL, KPTCL
CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
48. SRI CHIKKANANJAPPA
CHIEF ENGINEER
ENERGY DEPARTMENT
VIKAS SOUDHA
BENGALURU - 560001.
49. SRI SURESH K. M.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE (PURCHASE) MESCOM
MANGALURU.
50. SRI ASHOK KUMAR G.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
EAST CIRCLE
BESCOM, BENGALURU.
51. SMT GAYATHRI H. B.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
P & C PLANNING, KPTCL
CAVUERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
52. SRI PRASANNA K. S.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
BMRCL, BENGALURU.
53. SRI GURUMURTHY B.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
R T CIRCLE, KPTCL
HASSAN.
9
54. SRI MALLIKARJUNA REDDY M.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
TR (M) CIRCLE, KPTCL
RAMANAGARA.
55. SRI DILIP KUMAR R. V.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
SLDC, KPTCL
NEAR ANAND RAO CIRCLE,
56. SRI VINOD G. HAVANGI
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE, (TECH)
MESCOM
MANGALURU.
57. SRI MANSOOR AHAMED M.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
KPTCL PM O/O CEE RT R& D
KPTCL, CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
58. SRI RENU PRASAD M.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
P & C, KPTCL, CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
59. SRI MANOHAR MURUGAPPA BEVINAMAR
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE (TECHNICAL)
HESCOM, HUBBALI.
60. SMT MALINI H. V.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
TR (M), BRAZ, HEBBAL, KPTCL
BENGALURU.
61. SRI CHANDRASHEKAR G.L.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER,
O & M ZONAL OFFICE, CESCOM,
MYSURU.
10
62. SRI RAVI S. R.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE DGM (T)
KPTCL, CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU - 560009.
63. SRI GOPAL SALYAN
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
R T CIRCLE, KPTCL
KALABURAGI.
64. SRI NATARAJ D.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
KSPDCL
BENGALURU.
65. SRI SUNDERMURTHY R
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
BMAZ, BESCOM
BENGALURU.
66. SRI NARENDRA M. C.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
O & M CIRCLE OFFICE
MESCOM
SHIVAMOGGA.
67. SRI SRIRAMEGOWDA H. C.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
O & M RURAL CIRCLE, BESCOM
BENGALURU.
68. SRI KOTRESHI TALASTA
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
TR (M), BMAZ SOUTH, KPTCL
BENGALURU.
69. SRI GODE GUNDAPPA
CHIEF ENGINEER
TA & QC, KPTCL
CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
11
70. SRI RAMESH MAHADEVAPPA REVANKAR
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
HOT LINE PEENYA, KPTCL, PEENYA
BENGALURU.
71. SRI PRASANNA N. G.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
O&M, BRAZ, BESCOM
BENGALURU.
72. SRI UDAYAKUMAR B. K.
CHIEF ENGINEER, BMAZ
BESCOM, BENGALURU.
73. SRI SADASHIVA
CHIEF ENGINEER
BESCOM, CHITRADURGA.
74. SRI MAJJAGI T. B.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE (PMC),
HESCOM, HUBBALLI.
75. SRI HOSAMANI A. J.
CHIEF ENGINEER
RT, R & D, KPTCL
CAUVERY BHAVAN.
76. SRI S. P. SAKKARI
MANAGING DIRECTOR
HESCOM
BENGALURU - 560009
HUBLI.
77. SRI NEELYA NAIK R.
CHIEF ENGINEER
TR ZONE, KPTCL
BAGALKOT.
78. SRI GOVINDARAJU S. V.
MANAGING DIRECTOR
KAVIKA, BENGALURU.
12
79. SRI LAKSHMANA N.
CHEIF ENGINEER
KPTCL SPL OFFICER HRDC
BENGALURU.
80. SRI RAJAPPA
DIRECTOR TECHNICAL
HESCOM, HUBALLI.
81. SRI NARASIMHA MURTHY K. N.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
KPTCL TR (W& M ) CIRCLE
MYSURU.
82. SRI MANJUANTH M. T.
CHIEF ENGINEER
KPTCL SLDC
BENGALURU.
83. SRI PRATHAP P. M.
CHIEF ENGINEER
KPTCL TR ZONE
MYSURU.
84. GOVINDARAJU K.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
ENERGY DEPT., VIKAS SOUDHA
BENGALURU.
85. SRI HIRIYANNAIAH M R
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
KPTCL RT CIRCLE
BENGALURU
86. SRI SUCHETANA B. S.
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
O & M CIRCLE, CESCOM
HASSAN.
87. SRI THIMMAPPA P SHETTY
SUPERINTENDENT ENGINEER
ZONAL OFFICE, HESCOM
HUBBALLI.
13
88. SMT JOSHI SUNANDA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORP OFFICE (MM & P)
GESCOM
KALABURGI.
89. SMT ANJALI DEVI R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL CORP OFFICE (IT & MIS)
BENGALURU
90. SRI NARAYANA POOJARI S. D.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
O & M DIVN, MESCOM
PUTTUR.
91. SRI BASAVARAJ BHEEMA REDDY S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MAJOR WORKS DIVISION
KPTCL, UDUPI.
92. SRI NUSRATHULLA H. R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM CORP OFFICE (RA),
BENGALURU.
93. SRI. MANJUNATH S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL 220 K V BIAL,
BENGALURU.
94. SRI. NAGARAJU K. H.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
DEPT KSPDCL,
BENGALURU.
95. SRI. PRABHAKAR S. K.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM MT BMAZ
BENGALURU.
14
96. SRI. THIPPESWAMY K.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
RAJARAJESHWARI NAGAR,
BESCOM
BENGALURU.
97. SRI. MAHANTHAPPA K. T.
DIRECTOR (TECH),
CESCOM
MYSORE.
98. SRI. GOPALAKRISHNA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CORP OFF (Q & S 2), BESCOM,
BENGALURU.
99. SRI. HALAVAR G. B.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O & M DIVISION, HESCOM,
BASAWANA BAGEWADI,
100. SRI. NARENDRA R. S.
CHIEF ENGINEER,
ZONAL OFFICE, GESCOM,
KALABURGI.
101. SRI. SRINIVASAPA
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
DEPTN KERC,
BENGLAURU.
102. SRI. NAGARAJU Y. K.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
KPTCL 220 K V STATION,
GOURIBIDNUR.
103. SRI. MANJUNATH B. R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
KPTCL REG, AFFAIRS O/O FA (RA),
BENGALURU.
15
104. SRI. MUNIRAJU M.
CHIEF ENGINEER,
KPTCL T R ZONE,
HASSAN.
105. SRI. HEERA SINGH R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
GESCOM CORP OFFICE (TAQC),
KALABURAGI.
106. SRI. SUBHASH BHOSALE
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
KPTCL RT DIVN,
KALABURAGI.
107. SRI. RAMESH P. G.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
KPTCL SLDC SCADA MIS,
BENGALURU.
108. SRI. SHANBHOG M.R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
HESCOM CORP OFF (IT & MIS),
HUBBALLI.
109. SRI. RAJARAMA M. S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
MESCOM O&M CIRCLE,
MANGALURU.
110. SRI. SRINIVASA MURTHY N.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
CESC O&M DVN,
PANDAVAPURA.
111. SRI. UMESHCHANDRA K. V.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
MESCOM DIVN OFFICE,
BANTWAL.
112. SRI. RAO P.D.B.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
KPTCL TL & SS DVN, KARKALA.
16
113. SRI. SRINIVASA BABU B.L.
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
BESCOM O& M WEST CIRCLE,
BENGALURU.
114. SRI. SOMASHEKARA B. R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
,BESCOM CORP OFF. (PROJ &NT),
BENGALURU.
115. SRI. SURESH BABU M. G.
CHIEF ENGINEER,
PCKL ADDLN DIR (PROJECTS),
CAUVERY BHAVAN,
BENGALURU.
116. SRI. SHIVA PRASAD J.
EXECUTIVE ENGINER,
KPTCL TL&SS DVN,
TALAGUPPA.
117. SRI SUBHASHCHANDRA B. K.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM O & M DVN.,
HARIHARA.
118. SRI VIJAYAKUMAR V.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
DEPTN BDA
BENGALURU.
119. SRI YASHAVANTHA CHAVAN B. L.
CHIEF ENGINEER, BMRCL DEPUTATION
BENGALURU.
120. SMT SHANTHI M.
CHIEF ENGINEER
CORP OFFICE(COMPANY AFFAIRS)
BESCOM
BENGALURU.
17
121. SRI CHANDRASHEKAR H.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220KV GIS SIR MV STN.,
BENGALURU.
122. SRI VISHVANATH RAO SALANKEY
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL VIGILANCE
CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
123. SRI SHIVARAM SINGH
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
DEPTN BMRCL
BENGALURU.
124. SRI BASAVARAJ B PATIL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM O & M DIVN.
JAMAKHANDI.
125. SRI JAMES PHILLIP
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM CORP OFFICE(DAS & SMART)
BENGALURU.
126. SRI SHARANAPPA M. T.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220 KV STN HEBBALA
BENGALURU.
127. SRI RAGHAVENDRA V. S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL P & C TECH-3
CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
128. SRI SHANKAR S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL RT DVN.
KOLAR.
18
129. SRI GIRIJA M.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM WORKS DVN WEST
BENGALURU.
130. SRI BASAVARAJAPPA Y. K.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM CORP OFFICE(O & S-4)
BENGALURU.
131. SRI MURIGAPPA GOUDA B. G. PATIL
EXECTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM CORP OFFICE (PROJ)
HUBBALLI.
132. SRI MANJAPPA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MESCOM O & M DVN-I
MANGALURU.
133. SRI CHANDRASHEKAR R. D.
CHIEF ENGINEER
HESCOM O & M ZONE
BELAGAVI.
134. SRI PRAHALAD E.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TL & SS DIVN
MUNIRABAD.
135. SRI BALARAM G. V.
MANAGING DIRECTOR
KREDL, BENGALURU.
136. SRI HANUMANTHA RAJ G.
CHIEF ENGINEER
BESCOM O & M ZONE BRAZ
BENGALURU.
137. SRI ANAND NAIK
CHIEF ENGINEER
MESCOM O & M ZONE
MANGALURU.
19
138. SRI DURUGAPPA B.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MESCOM O & M CIRCLE
SHIVAMOGGA.
139. SRI CHANDRAN T. S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL NRS RAJAJINAGAR
BENGALURU.
140. SRI GOPAL N GAONKAR
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CESCO O & M DVN, HASSAN.
141. SRI GYANAPPA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
GESCOM O & M RURAL DVN.
HOSPETE.
142. SRI JAYARAJ A. N.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM CORP OFFICE(HRD).
BENGALURU.
143. SRI. SOMASHEKARAPPA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TLSS DVN,
SHIVAMOGGA.
144. SRI. NAIKAL MARTHANDAPPA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
GESCOM O&M RURAL DIVN,
KALABURAGI.
145. SRI. SIDDARAM BANDIMANI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TLSS DVN,
KALABURAGI.
146. SRI. MOHAN RAO BIRADAR
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM O&M DVN,
CHIKKABALLAPUR.
20
147. SRI. SADEV MANKARE
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
GESCOM O&M RURAL DVN-,
KALABURAGI.
148. SRI. NAGENDRA K.S.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM WORKS DVN.,
TUMKUR.
149. SRI. GURUSWAMY K.H.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM WORKS DIVISION.,
KOLAR.
150. SRI. GIRIDHAR KULKARNI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
HESCOM CORP OFF (PMC),
HUBBALLI.
151. SRI. VENKATESH PRASAD.R
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPCTL MWD, CHIKKAMAGALURU.
152. SRI. SRIKANTH M SADALATTI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM O&M DVN,
CHIKKODI.
153. SRI. SRINIVAS T. V.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TL&SS DVN,
KANAKAPURA.
154. SRI. SHASHIDHAR O.S.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL MWD,
DAVANAGERE.
155. SRI. SHARANAPPA G.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM NODAL OFFICER,
VIJAYAPURA.
21
156. SRI. SADASHIVA SHIVARAI MITHARE
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL RT DIVN,
HUBBALLI.
157. SRI. HIREMATH K G.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM & O&M DVN,
MUDHOL.
158. SRI. PRAKASH V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220 KV STN,
MALURU.
159. SRI. SUBRAMANYA SWAMY K
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TR (M) BRAZ,
BENGALURU.
160. SRI. MURUGENDRAIAH. H.M.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
HESCOM CORP OFFICE (HRD),
HUBBALLI.
161. SRI. ABDUL MAJID
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
DEPTN BMRCL,
BENGALURU.
162. SRI. ALLAHA BAKSHA B.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL MWD,
TUMAKURU.
163. SRI. GIRISH B.V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL RT & R&D,
BENGALURU.
164. SRI. SURESH KUMAR M.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL P&M, BENGALURU.
22
165. SRI. RAMESH H.G.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM WORKS DIVISION,
RAMANAGARA.
166. SRI. BHEEMANNA S HEBBAL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TR W AND M,
MANGALURU.
167. SRI. MOHAN KUMAR R S.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
DEPTN KREDL,
BENGALURU.
168. SRI. NAGABHUSHANA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CESCO O AND M DVN,
MADDUR.
169. SRI. UMESHA B. S.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TL AND SS DVN
TUMAKURU.
170. SRI. SATHYANARAYANA B. N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 400KV C.DVN MAILARASANDRA
BENGALURU.
171. SRI. JAGADEESH L BELAGALI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM O AND M URBAN DVN
HUBBALLI.
172. SRI. RAVIKANTHA R KAMATH H
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TL AND SS DVN
MANGALURU.
173. SRI. NATARAJA E.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220 KV STN., HIRIYUR.
23
174. SRI. DIVAKARA D. J.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MESCOM CORP OFFICE (EBC)
MANGALURU.
175. SMT.VIDHYARANI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL HRD CENTRE
BENGALURU.
176. SMT. SHARANAMMA S JANGIN
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TL AND SS DVN
HUBBALLI.
177. SRI. NAGARAJAIAH B. N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TR WORKS,
BENGALURU.
178. SRI. SHIVAPRAKASH H M
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM CORP OFFICE (O AND S-3)
BENGALURU
179. SRI. LAKSHMIKANTHA B. S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL CORP OFFICE ( IT AND MIS)
CAUVERY BHAVAN,
BENGALURU.
180. SRI. MUNIGOPALA RAJU K. M
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CESCO ADDLN CITY AREA DVN
MYSURU.
181. SRI. NARASIMHA PANDITH
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM O AND M DVN
HONNAVARA.
24
182. SRI. SUBRAMANYAM N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TL AND SS DVN
HOLENARASIPURA.
183. SRI. GURUPPA K GOTYAL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM O AND M DVN,
VIJAYAPURA.
184. SRI. RAMESH GUDI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL RA (LAW) O/O DIR AND CS
KPTCL, CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
185. SRI. SIDDARAM S TELI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL MWD, HAVERI.
186. SRI. SHIVAPRAKASH T. M
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM O AND M VIDHANA SOUDHA DVN.
BENGALURU.
187. SRI. VINAYAKRAJ N. P
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL RT DVN
CHITRADURGA.
188. SRI. VENKATESH HALVI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
GESCOM CORP OFFICE (MRT AND LDC)
KALABURAGI.
189. SRI RAVINDRANATH B. N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM CORP OFFICE
(DAS & SMART G)
BENGALURU.
25
190. SRI MANJUNATHA S. V
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
HESCOM O & M CIRCLE
VIJAYAPURA.
191. SRI CHANNAVEERAIAH M
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL MWD NORTH
BENGALURU.
192. SRI MAYI GOWDA Y M
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220 KV STN
CHAMARAJANAGAR.
193. SRI SIDDARAM PATIL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
GESCOM O & M DVN
SEDAM.
194. SRI KESHAVAMURTHY N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM NODAL OFFICER
HUBBALLI.
195. SRI MAHADEVASWAMY PRASANNA K.M
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
KPTCL TR(M) BMAZ(N)
BENGALURU.
196. SMT PADMALATHA T L
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
PCKL DY DIR (TRADING)
BENGALURU.
197. SRI SRINIVASAIAH G
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220 KV STN., K B CROSS.
198. SRI JAGADHISHA S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM O & M RURAL DVN
DHARWAD.
26
199. SRI SWAMYGOWDA H N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CESCO O & M DVN, H N PURA.
200. SRI MAHESHWARAPPA D
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM WORKS DVN
DAVANAGERE.
201. SRI SHASHIDHARA S G
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MESCOM O & M DIVN
SHIVAMOGGA.
202. SRI LOKESHWARA T V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM O & M DVN
TIPTUR.
203. SRI VENKATESHULU B
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220KV STN ALIPURA
BALLARI.
204. SRI KRISHNA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM O &M DVN JAYANAGAR,
BENGALURU.
205. SRI THOTAD S CHANNAPPA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
GESCOM VIGILANCE,
KALABURAGI.
206. SRI JAGADEESHA B V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM WORKS DVN RURAL,
BENGALURU.
207. SRI LAKSHMAN CHAVAN
CHIEF ENGINEER,
GESCOM CORP OFFICE PLNG,
KALABURAGI.
27
208. SRI MALATESH N KODALIYAR
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
DEPTN PWD,
BENGALURU.
209. SRI MALLESHAPPA B V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL TL & SS PEENYA DVN,
BENGALURU.
210. SRI MOHAMMED MUJIB
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
MESCOM O & M DIVN,
SHIKARIPURA.
211. SRI DEVARAJASWAMY B G
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM CORP OFF (REV & HT)
BENGALURU.
212. SRI.RAMESHA B.S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CESCO CORP OFF (PROJECTS)
MYSURU.
213. SRI.DEEPAK BABU KAMATH
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
HESCOM O & M DVN.
SIRSI.
214. SRI.SUJATHA C
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL P & C (NORTH)
BENGALURU.
215. SRI.JAYANANDA M
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
MESCOM O & M ZONE (P&S)
MANGALURU.
216. SRI.HANUMANTHARAYAPPA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
DEPTN KREDL, BENGALURU.
28
217. SRI.RAVISHANKAR E
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CESC O & M CIRCLE OFFICE,
MANDYA.
218. SRI.NARASIMHA MURTHY L.N.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL SLDC TBC
BENGALURU.
219. SRI.CHANDRASHEKAR
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
HESCOM O & M DVN
ATHANI.
220. SRI.KODANDAPANI.D
CHIEF ENGINEER,
GESCOM O & M ZONE,
BELLARY.
221. SRI.CHETHAN.D
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL P & C PLNG,
CAUVERY BHAVAN,
BENGALURU.
222. SRI.VENKATESH MURTHY R
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM CORP OFFICE (PROJECTS)
BENGALURU.
223. SRI.VENKATACHALAM G.V.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL RT NORTH DVN.
BENGALURU.
224. SRI.MOHAN K.N.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL 220 KV STN HSR LAYOUT,
BENGALURU.
29
225. SRI.BASAVARAJA PATIL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
GESCOM O & M DIVISION,
BIDAR.
226. SRI.THRINESWARA B.P.S.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
TL & SS DIVISION, HOODY,
BENGALURU.
227. SRI.RAMACHANDRA R
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM CORP OFFICE (CA2)
BENGALURU.
228. SRI.KARIYAPPA H
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
DEPTN MAHANAGARA PALIKE,
DAVANAGERE.
229. SRI.KRISHNA PRASAD H.V.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
BESCOM O & M DVN
TUMKUR.
230. SRI.THATHAIAH N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O & M DIVISION,
RAJAJINAGAR BESCOM,
BENGALURU.
231. SRI.PRAKASH H.R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
KPTCL, P & C (TECH)
CAUVERY BHAVAN,
BENGALURU.
232. SRI.SOMARAJU.L
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O & M CIRCLE, CESCO
MYSURU.
30
233. SRI.BASAPPA K PATTAN SETTY
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CORPORATE OFFICE, DSM CELL,
GESCOM, KALABURAGI.
234. SRI.HARISH KUMAR V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CORPORATE OFFICE (APDRP)
MESCOM
MANGALURU.
235. SRU,RAMESH M.R.
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O & M DIVISION, MALLESWARAM,
BESCOM,
BENGALURU.
236. SRI NAGARAJA M C
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
RT SOUTH DIVN., KPTCL,
BENGALURU.
237. SRI NATARAJA U S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
O & M DIVN., GESCOM
SINDANURU.
238. SRI IMTIAZ M H
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
R & D KPTCL
CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
239. SRI SRINIVASA P
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
TL & SS DIVN.,
KPTCL NELAMANGALA
BENGALURU.
240. SRI VRUSHABENDRAPPA S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
TA & QC KPTCL
HUBBALLI.
31
241. SRI UMESHA B J
CHIEF ENGINEER
T & P KPTCL
CAUVERY BHAVAN,
BENGALURU.
242. SRI SHANTHAMALLAPPA S.T.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
O & M DIVISION,
INDIRANAGARA BESCOM,
BENGALURU.
243. SRI SATISH H
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MAJOR WORKS DIVISON,
KPTCL, BELLARY.
244. SRI RAMACHANDRAMURTHY N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
TR (W & M), KPTCL,
TUMKUR.
245. SRI NAGARJUNA D
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
MESCOM Z/O DCC & SCADA
MANGALURU.
246. SRI SYED MANZOOR HUSSAIN
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
(P & C) TECH.,
KPTCL CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
247. SRI CHANDRA MOULI K
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
220 KV STATION KPTCL,
MADHUGIRI.
248. SRI AMEETHA C V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TR(W & M)
HASSAN.
32
249. SRI RAYAPPA S VARUR
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL 220 KV STN NARENDRA
HUBBALI.
250. SRI VENKATARATHNA G
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
220 KV STATION KPTCL
CHITRADURGA.
251. SRI NAGAPPA S H
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HESCOM, CORPORATE OFFICE (PURCHASE)
HUBBALLI.
252. SRI KRISHNAPPA V
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
O & M CIRCLE OFFICE
GESCOM
RAICHUR.
253. SRI RAMACHANDRA K
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
CESC O & M CK CIRLCLE
MYSURU.
254. SRI LOURDUSWAMY
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
MESCOM O & M DIVN 2
MANGALURU.
255. SRI NAGARAJA B
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
O &M DIVISION BESCOM
MADHUGIRI.
256. SRI MUNINARAYANA S N
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER
REGULATORY & AFFAIRS
KPTCL CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
33
257. SRI HARISH R NAYAK
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KPTCL TL & SS DIVN SIRSI.
258. SMT USHA PADMA R
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
BESCOM CORP OFF (DSM)
BENGALURU.
259. SRI JAYAKUMAR R
DIRECTOR TECHNICAL,
GESCOM, CORPORATE OFFICE,
KALABURAGI.
260. SRI RAMESH L BENDIGERI
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
KPTCL TR W & M
HUBBALLI.
261. SRI KOTEPPA S
CHIEF ENGINEER,
OC BESCOM CORP OFFICE (PROJECTS),
BENGALURU.
262. SRI ADINARAYANA C
CHIEF ENGINEER,
TRANSMISSION ZONE, KPTCL,
TUMKUR.
263. SRI GOVINDAPPA K V
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
O&M CIRCLE,BESCOM,
TUMKUR.
264. SRI CHOWDAPPA N V
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
O&M CIRCLE,BESCOM,
KOLAR.
265. SRI GOPALAKRISHNA V
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
CORPORATE OFFICE (PURCHASE),
BESCOM, BENGALURU.
34
266. SRI SHIVLAL BHILAGI R
SUPERINTENDING ENGINEER,
O&M CIRLCE, GESCOM,
KALABURAGI.
267. SRI PADMAVATHI D
CHIEF ENGINEER,
O&M ZONE, CESCO,
MYSURU.
268. SRI SWAMY H S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
T&L SS DIVISION, KPTCL,
HOOTAGALLI,
MYSURU.
269. SRI NAGESH S
EXECKUTIVE ENGINEER,
O&M DIVISIN, CESCO,
HUNSURU.
270. SRI RIZWAN PASHA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
MAJOR WORKS DIVISIN, SOUTH
KPTCL,
BENGALURU.
271. SRI MRUTHYUNJAYA A R
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CORPORATE OFFICE (Q&SI),
BESCOM
BENGALURU.
272. SRI MOUNESH S PATTAR
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O & M DIVISION GESCOM,
KOPPAL.
273. SRI NAGARAJA R
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CORPORATE OFFICE (EA) BESCOM,
BENGALURU.
35
274. SRI SRIDHAR B H
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
TA&QC, KPTCL,
CAUVERY BHAVAN,
BENGALURU.
275. SRI RAMASWAMY G
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O&M DIVISION CESCO,
KOLLEGAL.
276. SRI VEERESH KUMAR HEBBAL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
TL& SS DIVISION,
KPTCL, GADAG.
277. SRI LOKESH K L
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O&M DIVISION BESCOM,
KANAKAPURA.
278. SRI DEEPAK H S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
HESCOM O&M DIVISIN,
KARWAR.
279. SRI JAGADISH B S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O&M RURAL DIVILSION,
GESCOM,
BELLARY.
280. SRI ANNEGOWDA M S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CORPORATE OFFICE, DSM, CESCO,
MYSURU.
281. SRI SHASHIDHARA SHIVACHARYA W M
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
CORPORATE OFFICE,(PURCHASE),
BESCOM,
BENGALURU.
36
282. SRI SHASHIDARA M R
EXECUTIVE ENGNIEER,
OOD TO KUM,
BENGALURU.
283. SRI CHANDRASHEKARAIAH S B
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
SCADA, KPTCL, BENGALURU.
284. SRI SUVARNA SIDDALINGAPPA DHADED
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
TR (W&M), KPTCL
KALABURAGI.
285. SRI NARASIMHA MURTHY H
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KIADB, BENGALURU
286. SRI LAKSHMINARAYANA D V
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE , ALDC,
BESCOM, BENGALURU.
287. SRI CHANDRAKANT PATIL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
TA & QC, KPTCL,
KALABURGI.
288. SRI SHIVANA GOWDA R PATIL
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
TR (W&M) KPTCL,
BAGALKOT.
289. SRI KANTHA REDDY B H
EXECUTIVE ENGTINEER
O&M DIVISION , BESCOM,
KGF.
290. SRI RAJASHEKAR B N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
TA & QC, KPTCL
CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
37
291. SRI HEMA PRABHU M K
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
TR (M) KPTCL,
RAMANAGAR.
292. SRI DINESH UPADHYAYA
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER,
O&M CIRCLE, MESCOM,
UDUPI.
293. SRI HANUMANTA RAO SANGA SHETTY
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE, ITC,
GESCOM , KALABURGI.
294. SRI RAVISHANKAR A N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
O&M DIVISION, CESCO
MANDYA.
295. SRI SATHISH CHANDRA N S
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE , (RA), MESCOM
MANGALURU.
296. SRI MANOHAR H KULKARNI
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
NODEL OFFICER
HESCOM, KARWAR.
297. SRI NARAYANA GOWDA N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE, R&D
HESCOM
HUBBALI.
298. SMT SUDHA S N
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE PROJECT
KPTCL, CAUVERY BHAVAN
BENGALURU.
38
299. SMT SHAILAJA P.,
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
CORPORATE OFFICE, POWER PURCHASE
BESCOM
BENGALURU.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. ASHWINI RAJAGOPAL, ADVOCATE FOR
C/R20, 21 & 50)
These Writ Petitions are filed under Articles 226
and 227 of Constitution of India praying to quash the
impugned provision list dated 08.05.2017 vide
Annexure-P, as well as the final revised seniority list
dated 27.10.2017 vide annexure-P1 and P3 and etc.
These Writ Petitions coming on for 'Orders' this
day, the Court made the following:
ORDER
Learned counsel for the petitioners has filed a memo dated 07.06.2018.
2. In terms of the memo, petitions are disposed of with liberty as sought.
Sd/-
JUDGE MSU