Karnataka High Court
The Manager Karnataka Housing Board vs The Land Acquisition Officer on 19 January, 2011
Bench: N.K.Patil, A.N.Venugopala Gowda
H3 ME HIGH 535%? 0? §<.fifi;£'~§ATA§<& f-
CERCEEE? SENSE? A'? BHAR'v§--';%.§;'_ """ %
mags mgg mg 1%?" am 0? .1amz;;ARé%;VV.;%éA%T:j:; ._ '
PRE$Em?""*~
"mg HQ£\E'BLE MR, §u3"2*:<§;E*§$:
§$:»:~;;§__ " . " V _
'FHE E-§G€'~é'§LE MR. }{}S'?1CE§{L'?.3§?'x'§VNUC$§§£.fi SQWQA
MISCELLAN'§_Q§;--lS i§IF}ES};I"' ~:15.'§?§'EAL am.
1234' iJ%2ae5*LAc' - -
. ..C1W
ma3.;92, %/zngos? rm
V."§tVF:A"j.1V2V'3£;}2a05
é Amp' %
4' ..£?4FA 31~;1o"'I2'@'05'
.,_....,,....u
__ jCR7C*.$';§f';';f20.{§'3.%fi'fi$I ?#!§?A"%31 m/2005
The §§'§E?:?1'E?§%i'f, 'V ~
, §<§m{~;:i;3é<§_ %~£Qu§%ng" ?"::"*;e;r;ss:««:**;e%.:i,
_V V _ _ _ g..fi§§e§§&§":i
(5-:5 $5:-ks: "§;?%";;:';.:*_;r"r;.;:_§ia?" sv; %i§ég;A552.»n, 3;
' 5; :3
A. f%f"?2e§;a;"":<3Z ézcquéséiiafi Qffémr,
' " _ ;'%';:«3g§$tané: Camméggégnea
';;:gm:<%:a:2a;§ Eégt: Baga§§<:9ifl
;'§<,¢2§?f%:i.{\«. _ . "
' Wmww«<wmw
'gmt, ?&%_fi§'z: 3;-ziatviagg
7W;'§ ':'3i%}r§aaf£;:a.§;«§:V §'%§_t,f*:§;,
3'»)
2, S31 Hamamané: Keashegga i.£3;§§;3
"é"%:z*@:,:gf': msrahaggr
Smifiadmavaii
W;'s §h;*§va§Eabh Raftisig,
Aged meat 53 years,
Ric: Eamaéfhami,
$1335: fiagafikst,
..[£é$m:: :§ve;r*2'&§ *
{jay Srifivéahesfi wsseyazg, ,rasér;:z;;" R-:-aagé. §:4;n,_ §<9, :;é::-as:
géafvg. far' R29}
ms agpeaé E5 fgijeai e;:i;%1:g§V'Vf5:»2;;»%:§:'s*%;2;% 54(1) 3;'? Lé Act
2894 ag3§:"2st the €Qm"s':'":<,>;:"?: ';§_;;€i§:;,vz:2e':2%:AA.,a;%2r:f fi1s'\ifii"C§ dateé
2é»é8a2GG4 aassed 5:: LA:C'a?§{);2§QZi'996'~V.L}? the Aééftéofiaf
iiivéf Judge (S.:*;€>n,},/'}a'mEg§*;ané'E,_ pa";=;*f:§y aiiawéng E528
refarence §et§i:~§01;':g.f;z::'r e£*sE*2a=im:fe €30r1f;::efe's3~iEon5
Between:
€R@B,91'/'2--76UA8§f$N '§;:}m% :.*2§%'34/2Vé o5
§etwean: --. 4. V
S§'"§.HéfiémfifiiR':'3€f§vC?'T%3%§§§'-i}V§'#&%";
f?"E'2rm,sg;Ei §L:sia:£"2a§er- A
&%3 53.%8&f5«A "%%%
R/G"j§a:'?*:_§s:E':a:':z7;§,.__ * '
,,s§s:: zi'=§ggE£<.€ffi:, '
~ Q; 5," ?a;€:'§~£, Agvsaazag
fifiga "
" fha éazéfi écgaégétéan €:}:F§§€er,
-~"A$§§5ias*":?: £$m:':'i§$$§g;:er;
,._a,C_r§3§ éffifijaciaz"
mwwmnwmwmw....mWm...W'.... ..
La.)
:§8E"3'?§<§1.a¥§§§, Eagaékoi.
2, The §"'i'E3§":§g€§',
Karnataka flagging 305%,,
Beiggam,
,m,_:RéS;:ori:éé«r:iS':
($2; SrE.Ma§°:es§': Waéfeyasi, Asa my §2.+_:;%A%As1rm,§:;§;§rm;;«a
saga f~iflv., far 9&2;
mfg WA Crab E5 fiéecf U/§V...%g?: me"ig2.%V':of'Lcp{: agafngt
the Eaédgmerez' and award €;§j:E3'E€{§ ~2§"..i§.,2§@?§" passed in
LAC,§\§Q.25§_;'19§6 O{:'.,t"h.E féééi..V(;'>?~..._'%iE"'%'E~Afisddifionaé CM?
}:.,:dge{Sr,.Dr:,}; }am$<har:id§._[_" '
MFA sxmamsg
Between:
"FM ?'4a?éages";'~-_ %
§<&maiet £-<3 §~§©'z,;saS'§§f2g E§Qai«'.§;,"~ _ '
Be§gaz;m Q%--v'§s%Vaf2' ff-~A._ %
Eeégaasmg * ' ' '
.=¢|E£$§§fig§&€'1i€:
(By SrfntgS.hara::1§§1a' ?~'?VPaE'%§; fixdvagate}
E, V' ?E1é. §;$éfi;'i.A'.T;§:;§:sEs§€'%a:"2 Gffécer,
"*'"~v*' '
. ";?%s§§§§§;'§:_?.€i@5'{:m%3s%@ner,
"-..}a?'}'_?§<§"ffi€--'%§§, Sig? fiagaiétsi.
A [ §s*r:":..A§<E<::,;ba§ fihraiar §»€a§§a§pa
A "a;':;§':a2z5rs <21': §a%<a§<;{::é§ad}
" --.."f?i%'m:.*:ug?2 her éagaé Ezaaf
Ramgahaafira Babs; Sfiénéégg
R59 §<§§%'2a§u:i, ":"':g: Karvaerg
£333: Ksifiaguz,
(8%! R:.£.,?a€§E;""é%§M%;:2c$te§ "
.5 ""*
'3.
" " afieéggagm.
..%L>.
_.(,,R€ssg3r2_$er'sEs
{Ey Sr'§,§v1Eahes;§"% Waéeyar, ASA far R-3 & Sréfi.§_fifi§§.f:§:,;'-.._ '-.
édvecaée far QMZ} ' ' "
'§"'h£s ?*«%Ffi. is fiéed
pagsefi gs: LAC {'é{3u24§/Zi9§6 an V as :::eVm;§s3%:'2;::na*'§«
flivéé }udge{S§:§n,}, }am§<§7ar:é;=._,_
§':f~3ECS?"rS.'=£"'EC€ fietétésm fer ermanged ¢a;*:'%.[sf:;&';*':;$a€§G:*%_~_A A ' - *
{me "s"§f=*a§
fiaasgzgzms m MFA 3:?*si$%fi~~.':,ae5§%% V
Hatween: 'V
fi.£<§<:;b3% Bhratar Fvéaééawa' '
Chavem @ G@§<a3<,V .
Smce dezceasefi i:{3f he?" §:;_.R:'
Ramacfzandya '_.fi5&i§i§§£»~'S;f'§§Fi'~{§e?,;_ '
Ma: 84 ';«'@;'33,!?'.;' V
Ric Kséhapuéj, __
'$3: §'<a§"sg'EE£?3E7,,A -»::,
Est: Kc:;§ha9uLr;5.L'V_..
.,'.Cre$s G£3§ec:{>r
*"§7%ff:ie La':::§«,§§%*:{:..:;E$%i§9n Gfficer,
' f3;5§§?;'3,fCv;&§'§2;f'V{:§"L:fEf'2v§"F'§§SS§£¥?"%§?",
2 ;Fam§<%27a:--*é.':;f--.§, k3agaé£<:®*:,
"'§"§"§7e= ..£*v'3'aén55$g ea;
%&i?'f'%5.?§f§§<5 Eéaaggérzg fioaré,
H.Re$;§:::':.§&?*:i§
% -{i.§ég%_?;s:maheg%: afimgegagg gag fa: gm; Smf:aSham:':§§a M
éfiazéi fidxzscaia fer $2}
U/S 34(3) 95 the §.afé'§i;_:'Av€§:;=éév§'séf:§'<;;%%_4V
AC: agaénm the Euégmemt and Aygard da¥t<§i:c§---.2~5J:~€¥.'2V8Q4' "
f}5?f§'§§f 1a'%§d%;rc§ség§"*--._ féfig
{J1
Tim; MFA iron in Mm 317@,s2@§§ fiied u;aM..4Ta:'_"E2.;g§e
22 Sf Cfifi agamat the Eudgmem: am Awa?r§ "-r:§atas;-d
25.19.2994passed 5;: LACi¥iS.24§fi§§E gs";
.£ad::f7§>:§or:a§ Céazéé 3§,§dgezjSrzQm,), Jarrééchanéé' These ap§ea§s am 305$ a§;jé$i§:;:«'*s$ "--§aagr;:<1flg§' :%*'§°$§'%*€xefi7 EMS day; V§§\§UGGPfXE,fia GQW§»§i fgifowéng: V AA 3wsM"?a1§;': _ wneficéary 9;' a§CQ£iE$§E!5A€§}£§ ' :%V Emrdi, aggrieved by t;*3e?;§§"3n:§:m =ig;':'."5<:9';:fé"~s"§;.;5é:z:*=5Sa--:VE~;>r1 awarfieé to mg mg § L'?3'\éYCEi0n M0331/2038 & §2:j2GOf3lV"M':a f§ ';*:}'.j-.':;~V.:VéV7V'e;2*$£, aggréevefi by the q:za:§ta,::2'é'«s::zf=<:0mg:;é';é.§a%t§::..§{'":%s;é%;arGed to tfiem. They have saugm. _?£,%£' a"3;»~{ia:"<',£.:'ir':g 7S§ 8F?¥'°£a?'%C&§ CQ§"}'3§€f°ESat§GE"'% with V' 'E'%';'a§1_'$'V%<":&.;F'§'E.~".§ET:§@m@fl§t'Sk A """ ' ' "_§%«'?;aiicé:"Ea§ facig Efi§§"§§C?'3 are ma': éré fifsmjia 3%:
En "'- e5xi:'é::"2t af 3% acreg am 8 gmias 3? iamé 9? '~"}E§:"::g::%<'%":aré7fi§ szfiéage vazag gmgérgé fer ?.:§':§ {L'Gs'"§Si§'§J<Z'E§G?°% sf' .'_ '?:c§':;«2sé$A E3; the Karnaéakg Hanging Saaré {KHB} anger ~. :§¥~%::€;E5£§£§ §:::h§:':":e gt {fiamakmfiéé L%§'§§€€'" a ?s"§;f§s':':§::&ra; 1% Mi"?
ms 3?: %§k2,1?,,8G§;"- pa: acre; exaéasééng 99%: E<has°ab "'a":iea if arzy, aim e::?;§%:§£ng we Ianfi awzéerg is we aiaiaéipisféy'. §'<5z"%j;:=:f':'¥;"$f as Qéf" Sezrtgm'; 23{1}{§}, 23(2} am? 28 :3?' i?'2€ 4;, The ag3pe§£ant hag cf§*§;:>>;é§e:?:§[:i%a§1i ::'i3;e"':§;é'§fi"'9§%;ai¢3;%*i:f$f :3? 5% Reference Cam; .»'§1'::35§§r:g"=::3§2g:iex;?¢é;.i vEhg«*§a§°:§=. ewners have aésa flied the cr'<3§;is;?'4<::t'2,j'b}f=:~=;.{_:€%{}=r°§§.«--A $1 gm:.séwarm:§Ta' mg' .i;§>,é:$seg Afimcate agpearing far §i1q§§jT0=§irs::é:*:g sarstentéans in gwgart the Empugrzafi iwfimefét.;3.!7?§'~%§.?v%i§%::_: " 'V A' 1v fie the acqaxsétéan Q? Eafid ::n@eV§'»f:§*:<::.,vVéry ;§éi'EfE~fiat%Qm mm for the grejeca bag:
§$"a-fi%f3'te;%rant Qmjéci €35' away fmm the 'A the §?"%S'€fi§'§f: case and were Eg rm V".«.;;€,"s:9é*:é§V;i%'.sj§3§'%§éV%$;?e:t§. ?;'?ze markai vaizée cf the Eartdg, %:h@ gufijeté maize? 9? ExJ?-Ef§,, camnfii AA .%§.;;A:g%§'§h €339 mgés €23: §§€€§"£?'?§?E§£'E§ mg mgrkef zsaiue En 'fé§§a:'§ té ézééé gmuéreé igmzfs far" {W §r&ge§";€: smjeéi, E E;
:11"
E52 eariéegt am} at any Svfiféfl bgfere 23$-§«E2G1L Re:a..::*i;sf: tfié L€R éfirihwétéx in véew Q? the abaveg the crQss~@b1§~sctif:sj::s"'~V.:deA vgéfh Survive far cazzgééeratégrz, Ragéstry E3 aférecieé Ea rém§'E:;f._the'2:-:§:"?":§--$s§v§:%é'*;<féE;:s*9i: fee V' an i§'"'§E3 apgegéss aw Cmgs-@b;§*'~;2::».§.§§:""%s:;;"-»%:_o ':%"ze a;:me §Eant and c:*oss»~@$je::%:@5§,, :*es§e<:i:'§':;e_§'§,:a" gagg Eifigfiflg ?5:$,_?';v*'3'.f' .