Karnataka High Court
The Deputy Commissioner Of Income ... vs M/S Dell International Services India on 2 November, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
1?»: "WEE HEGH mum 9%" %<fisREa§£"§A§<£ 3:55 8£§\,§%1'§,»'%£fi7RE ;;"::i~':."§"E$ '?%~§§§ "mg 2% am' §§ §=§r;2:;Er~:2?a§§ 2:32:
PRESE§"é"{ mg %«»:@§a:'§aE :v:a:3i;§"%"12:Ez%«:.:r<%.;:'«%¢éx;%2;;---- j" * mg THE %~§$f'é'BE.E :4R,3u$":£CE ':<zA2;%';: §»'§T;a:;?;;:x2: ,'a%;"sf}§; §E"A§'$Q.13 ;?_ ii,:'.§F 2918 .
BETWEEN:
1" THE C>E'Pé.}"E"'¥' m:v:svE:*::*f--€~_%::€3.:'~.;.E£>;{.,';V GF"Z!\§CQE'»'EE §';a><»s;1"u TV i §§S Tawgagfisx :23'§*?§C;E',_f-.__ Efi&'~é§ALG?;:EE.">._ ." "
2; "WE"§§S'ES"?§5'AE'x§"E'i'}C'£§§'i:'f**%?§E:'§§E€3¥i?ER. 9%: :.§\gC<f;:>:=f;§'"*::::*=.-:«»:;" % ~ €£R;CE,E~Z§{3.--}, 'C;%:2,52;_:T:..E}:--N6_, Q:_:EE;'x;::-: RQ§~'2f3--, gmm:,i;;2_§; Mgpfigaamaggfg
- .,,{a*v xszpg mx£::x:?§::--; ;5@2;§€,&£'E} Z 2 :vif3;E;:§E§.:»_ ;§'§'§5§7_E§§;§'*é;3a"E"§G§\£;3;ik §E§;':;'E€E$' E?€§§§3 {gag L"-:*:;:ag %.:::{3:2,;~2§ :.2;2§a; zggmf £3:.%zf'?5;%$%~4§E4%§E @§.§E.:::$, '=;£Z3é§a%§i;,%§%£A'?"§&; zgzmzsg, % T.%2;';a§;:7;»%'éhs;§; aaagg, ... "§;1?"-»§§;é駧§E ~ gas; 53?; ...§§g?é:.}:x;§§;==--;?
{EY E'VE,?Sw%<Ii§"»£€3 8: QATRESGE; :5\E?%;'€3{,'r5C§"E§} #$x** ""§§'2§s gm flied amdgr' seatéan 255%, 9% :,":".A:;z,gf2;93é2:
arming amt gf §%'§§£* éateé ETKZEAZBGQ ;3~a§ga=:¢L' I'%a_'1§, ;i'?,é,§'~é£n§%,f8E'x§G;'.2C2Q°§, f5: %:Ems§ figgeggmemt 3535;" 2§1i;':'4;"'--€'%."%f»S",'-'--T graying is fémzuéaie mg gubgtastiaé Q"U€;V$'{§4€;~5?fISV~ §f4 éaw giaied ifiereainf aiicsafiz the appeai amc.§._se%: _e33§é e~.§§i:é' ¥::_1rder_ V passed 9;: me 17%", aangaiere an zm.'iaéa.'6:§9ea,za"3.;§::;';'V2:'.§'03E.g éated Z"?.:§,2Q@§g canfirmérzgé the"':.;3rC§'%e:='Ta?"§h'§..£a;;gaL§§ai%3%., Cammigséaner 8: mnfirm Etha araséeév. Qas.¢£*.a:§ '§:}y *4E§;:e:: £és$t,Qomm§g5éG:":ar cf £:é:::mje "*-'E"a;;<,._ U.:€:§%'«::V%'e£«':--«§..Z'«f1}, * ' Bafisgaézxre.
This Em. taming. '"em'.s'_ €ag¥é%5as,%':s,:Vi%E:._s«s aag%,f'§<'é,;MAR 3., daééxsereé the ?0§Em:a:%r1§:%"- ~ -- " "
,i'i.3£L,'?f.;f%s'§*«'£_;i;Ejf;fjE7_ :v:;sRé<.:_::.g;§--. ~5§f~.::;i:«s_é;§e_<- ij§:.a;E<e;'s3" ' mime 5:; $38 ;*a5§g:":é;§e:':%j:, V
2. 3:29" {:;;§<%s':s'i;:é"~%§':at aiiseg €02' caszsifieraiésn ii':
"'«..:?:§§v-':é§3;:&a: is :zaz§'wé':'§"se:=":2'*"';:Eéa "mbasnaé wa<:; aerraci: is hsiééng ..éi:3.§%:';;¢siéng :'e§é§f zgnfiar §€€Z§ZE%§'E zawg Q'? am Egééfiféég "§"{3§x:L:'i é5§::é", 3%: éghe exgenfiézma Efifiiiffiefi by 3&5 "._§§s&$3€.é§:%':§":s:,§Eé :29: farm gas": {:35 tifza Esta? iurméazey 53$ ag 'f§:g.;:%§"':;t gézauisé Léa €E3:€§%iei.jf;"*é {mm %.:%:& iaéaé iagyazszxer éf mg game we %'"€€;i§é,%C€§ fmm axggfiri '€m"E'!G'az'€§'L
3. The gaéd quegiém wag gngaazeraa by iifig Cam:
in ffzé Cam 9%" i'f'E€ '{:Gf3'§£?'Ef§='S§Gi?€f ("sf §;2g§:§3e~?"5,z' 5s?§'f' sz:g:»»:??e;~~ 14:.» f°=~'?j,«"$;Ta§g 5&5; gm; is? {m mas,",?Q{2:§.{;f2"__'__;;%z;j§"
aéféer mszrzeaiefi maffersg fiigpaggfi 92"? $3? 3 E;%;' imiéing ag :m§es':~ "Fran? the afm'e§:a;'Q' ;'::c:{g?mer3§s,:.77w}§sé émexgfes is ifmz", mere siéfiéififa' fie" :.sr:;§'é':3v:#;'§*z=ii";}*,£}?éV ma ingreéiénig af;__$5z"f3 éhe }?z;:z3*3a~*;{"a£"o%"an:f.i ;;'.~'§e deaamfnaéer Qf if2:'2_. §'*3;f:;'§_uigg, . g<§v:;;£;::%=.A:é:2§";}'2rs:*rz:'szi5@ it w§:;£d prefiuae a;§§xf§9sa{§&¥}§__'Vz§fr -';2.;bvjS;§:fQ?'-V~~re3::!$$¢ Sactécsrzf: :*_-_é'§ b§ é{:%.é3:?§z;'3?~§'.j§§:'§i{};: 3:' £5 §r2z"er:§$G'~ §:*J>5Ali:»:.;_r,;':*a's«'é';::,f*'_:§; --.§;?c»3;;:f;ve s;. pmmaée ;fg<3r§§I "5 ,_--?"1~'3é"?.fr:::§rg«§§_§.2e_ is gxempf §r0f}'2?5 ,re}'§%fé'i:ie é"@VVé4r%;;§%és_;f'*- She 5:336 as? gambinea' $:zsis:%Vé£~i;§ . a§;'::; égfigegseé, having sxgari " ffiaésénésg §;:s§{ifo::r:::3s;z":C éyssaggg, 52% iegisigéme 3}3f5»?;'::5§é:fA_ 5:9 3 farmzgfia Sa §§f:.:'&r§§;';"% 33°23 ' * ";:%T:";%;f€§€';§':.4'§i<e§%z;§ emarz" gizxsérsegg by ap,9<:2zi§on§z:g A. '=2:'f$éV §i£"VfT;§§VAf:?§V'%?;?'}'§";§ :2? me fiaaizmss 512:': 3% @3555 Q? '""--i"::r:*§éa.r:§'%9.~:K figgarééarsmafif 5;? _gr§f}*'§s 52;; 5&3 A T §e:::s:i§ 9?' iuraawr aemsf sgcsgfgfi 53 5 meéfiaé sf . L"';a§.rr::r§'s':§ 3: e,:<;::::2r§ graflég, in fizz? mag 53:' »' S'@£§5§;§ ~§§§"'§f""§{: sfhs gzgarz" ;:>m:%§" 32;; is} $9 figriézafi fmm 3579 5:3??? :§£jS§f?§.§.§ E3595??? §f 35$ a35§$see, Wfzereas 5:; §§€Ci'{<'j1:'? 28%, the exzjrsrf grafif 33 is be derévea' {ram me zatgé b::,sg:':::a§§ Q2' Em s:;r"s§'s:>r:3£<i;';g. Even 5;": 52% gage r3f' _ baggfnssfg 9? 3:: uadertfiing, 35:" may fs?£j§,;s$é1*> '--%:"~j.
€,><;:?Q:"{" béxginesg 5223* afsmegfia' fiazgineggé} "
@§f:%e;" wargfig, e,><:ga:*€ £"s.s2*r;{,nxe;jM £329' .;:*Q:"z'?::-i}';:?:;Z-. ' f£.i.$'f7$B*'€f'. Eifée exgwrf tur;3a;:vez'y_A ir"?$:i,-*'g" g:@._ mmpenené $5" flaff 3:' g afermrzéézjzafgr, é"f':é> _--v;"; if::?s? V aamgemnf being we V§;f§?;<2£s§ic"'zf;gmQ:«i%;","'. 3';§' 0i'f?£~fI' warés, is the e;><€fen:4 ':;>f 5-3-2a:fp<3z*z;."'é"§mss%;§'}:0veV52*', were waufa' b8 '£5314 '€{3f??.%;§'I€}{%§';${f§5 "i5€'fW€8f;§A $59 :'?{£!'f'?€2*'3fG§" and zffée '§a:;§éam_é§?L3fQw.i"' 'pf {he fsrmufgg 55:" .?'°few'"'§o@'?*':i%'?*'?;'?i?f77»%?"?*5?§§véiii"}/g the E' :.:n§'erst§§<f§a£:§§:' _.g';%§:;i€.f Vgfsgfi }._%'71é uifié sama gr:
$§"?§7e5%" ':ra<:§é,?fCi;§', fii?" :§*;<L;::v$k'§*V €"u:':"::3:./er in éfié fifimsrésér' »;f:§§[V§V%;'"%§xe1§' at gféar exc§:;a';??g €E3"§§'§Z=";? @x§é:;2éi::2.;§,»-- fig game gbaagfg' afar: 52% §,m::§aza:f'e{':% if? €T'§?fi?;";'ff!f§flg} £1529 e.><;:::::2.r§ €§.?§'".f"E{}%.r'8§" £5 3 V-'1..§::Q%'?f??,§€»rses":§§i°9z"a§ ézjrmzzer 5?: gm . a%-.r;:V:i::f:'%§:;A 5::"§_;". "€535 ,?"€§$G!"% éesrsg 53%? 55353;' "' .__§i§§'%'§{,:?';r'.;&:'{'.1"§;'"5C§£j£5§§ msgar. issraawr. "?}';5'
-..4__<:sr_::;;:r::;9:i:3%:i$ sf 553$ §x,a§r: éagmszxes" 3:? SE28 ;1y§§?e;°§f5; 53:3' 5539 gar;-smimafar $335395 be AA '"-~.::?§2'fér§;?i", "f?3§s"e?br&, ff?&£;'§f5'§ éfigre 53 fig ':§§f}ir::':"§m S25 5535 ierm '§:3§2§§ §:;;";'§§%x§;"' 5?? §$::§§:§:'§ Ez.1?'«,£E, 575E858 £5 f"?:3§??§é'?§ 22+: 5&3 355$' S§{f£'f{;'aF§ 52> mafldate E/mi, wfvaé ss $X€:§£.,3C5&i3' ?'§"Q:'?'? 535$ mzmeraias" $2255" :23 sxpaérf fgsrnavéz' w9;;!¢:2*' asverffiefegg .%b:"r;+'2 gar? Q?' éfze §§;?§;??s}*';'§€9§: "
Efigasgfa ézgééfif? a gsrféczjfas" :»wrQ* :3: {E65 a'e:§{;f;§§ci "'~ -. "
£29' #29 §e§z'§:5§é'.::.r@ aw' $2"? sréénaryf :2':§a:'2{,%"é1g "
to be aézrifizzzed 5:53 {The zzama, {jigs sas"Q'1'*e's';;:'§§§*:g::*;g;%"». ' mgarying m be aésfr'ib:z£€a' is ;<:;§;25%z»_§3?{,;;§.TTz'§'1 in sanfarmiéy wéifz {aha :a:':€"e§{'E"__ §:*:.V w'f2ic.f}_--v_% if V' . zsgeai iztfhen we §f3§a;f§%._ ,£:i:<ie $ar$£a9gf afi;-;frf%:§'!;a:+ §.,r'§d 5:3 #33 $333' farmuia, "2e--:;::;3;::;f;* £;r';*:':>.::%_:}ér' 35 defined, am' whar§ :'f2@ '€':;:£ai3': §;:;f,*+;:g?:s'§é:jr' incfgéés exggrf éurnmrerf §f2é$tsérgf§§:?}*:@§__§%2-ége2;f§'z';§_g gfims? m we expgré,_:":;:*r:éiXér::;;;,g"g,fi:§3_V{e§,.*is:§;é§:;r@ {S :9 be afiogziééd };e,,if';g;«s;§ 'a;r?}.fféf5Zf:33r;c§§?;§"Ezée meaning Qf"z*féé "f<:?:é;3i £'f:i§g~fé*::>§;?'e{f," w§?».é§?""fh@ E0835 iurnaver :'r::?{g;Q%sf €%'}{";i?;i;§?"§v§.'é.?§;}"?<Z}_i;'WE*?%, ' 3:' Wm: gig &><5§z;0"a§ 5;': m':f%?m,:i§:':'§f £333 .--e3:;.::>o§r:' §"z1§!'£"?Qi«'5f" £5 <<':"2;'i:;;§e&' :i;§3§§§ a§%*i2/f;fi;z 735 'fhséi faféfi :':;rr§{3:.»'e=_r, V=!f'?t5'E':'§ $39 .,':,..%3;%;'§£f7§f"E':"'v._ fur;§';i=é:ea:r"' ss 5 camfianarzi 9:' éaiaf ,§f:;:;f::;.%zée":f,""v'*;;s,s:::'2 8:'? izéiergreéaéiar? armasid ms? "~T'.__;o:3zé§;2:%;f_ {fie fggégfaéézra snfafié grza' A -.4._:r::gjs:2:"§';*;§.:«;§§§§e; 5:' $5233 aware £2':§ :'f'E§?§i'§€"i£%;°? 5:? 552:3 f@g7z'§§3éa:re:, 55:3? awwfa' E332;-'8 axgreggfgr 553593' ' 'V315, 3}" iéag 525::/5 nag aféaggn 5:} §.¥§F§S§§;' :§éE"?}"E§ zrmgi She giaégf égsmszzss meana, iféezir, %"a2'§?§s'? 5:35 :2'}§f§s' §asrz:.§,::x§;" smrfggfiei ivraaver, :59 meaning asgignsaf by SE35 fggisfgizsre is ffyg exgsaré fzjmever is 52:} §€' "
5'§S,§:ff*€".'f€§ awe? gsizer: effacf :9, wiyéééf' i£'3€8:"';§F€§§i'?g {be 5935:' fasrrrczwr :e:x;'3;_:ff§_ i{?£15i.§Sf3x'§ sf 533:9 €;x:§9:'§ §?;i§'{?5Er'€3'1 . f§:;r:'%:.;{§ :'Z2;- sgmpzgéaéisn :2;"":?:2'3e«« «_ l:5f$gf:.s£5§§§:_; zgnder Seséfgn 33%, wcazfa' §é«A§§- _iQn5e%;'*- V Wafifs cf the buginegs ' 1,'>E>E';}Lfi%fZ:<-.t§jfa¥?.A%:'%;*jef':' 'iVV"V X G?' {"5763 L!f?i2?=§f'fé'§€Z§}'?_i}' ,~ [E>:;k'<.3.'i "Skis.-7':':€:»5*""t'~?_r Jr Gr3:maj<3L;'s.nz:=r§ cezrer} V 7 as-';:r2 o«,«*er""
4' Is': VEEW {:5 the 'é.%f{>s9é{§:e:¥§ ='§&§g.%.I§__'::§;'§:3E?c%0z:, 223% fl§ am: 599 any §n€5'rE:"':;g§."t:§';§$:_agparséé,"${é:#{:rr§_§.:%Ag§3:; {Sm agpeaé 33 a:f%$r*:'*:§ss;r;~":7§;"'T' s::§*;3'%:;%%é;<%a7'§- q:;é.%_é:i:§'G%: of éaatw framea' in ihég aggeai §s_a§r';,$we2rei<§.'"é«:3V":1:~fs_%»;[:>s;%i...m' me aaggssae am agaészgt time :'€*~«._/e:"z:,se}""~. "