Karnataka High Court
Melur Milk Producer vs State Of Karnataka on 22 December, 2020
Author: S.G.Pandit
Bench: S.G. Pandit
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 22ND DAY OF DECEMBER, 2020
BEFORE
THE HON' BLE MR. JUSTICE S.G. PANDIT
WRIT PETITION No.49649/2018 (CS-EL/M)
BETWEEN:
1. MELUR MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MELUR MIRALE HOBALI
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
CHANDRAPPA
AGE 56 YEARS.
2. GANDANHALLI MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT GANDANHALLI
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
G K SHIVANNA
AGE 49 YEARS.
3. ELEMUDDANHALLI MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT ELEMUDDANHALLI
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
VISHWANATHA
AGE 37 YEARS.
4. HARAMABALLI MILK PRODUCERS
WOMEN CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HARAMABALLI
K R NAGAR TALUK
2
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
MANJULA
AGE 36 YEARS.
5. HARAMABALLI KOPPALU MILK PRODUCERS
WOMEN CO- OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HARAMABALLI
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY
NETRAVATI
AGE 47 YEARS.
6. MILK PRODUCERS WOMEN
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MALNAYAKANHALLI
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SUGUNA
AGE 35 YEARS.
7. GORAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT GORAHALLI
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
NATARAJA
AGE 46 YEARS.
8. MUTTUR MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MUTTUR
PRIRYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
D MANIYAIAH
AGE 64 YEARS.
9. LAKSHMIPURA MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS COOPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT LAKSHMIPURA
3
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SUMA T
AGE 43 YEARS.
10. JOGANAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT JOGANHALLI
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
CHENNIGARAIAH
AGE 51 YEARS.
11. MAKODU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MAKODU
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
RATANAMMA
AGE 52 YEARS.
12. RAJAPURA MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT RAJAPURA
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SUMATHI
AGE 48 YEARS.
13. ANAKANHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT ANKANAHALLI VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
GOURAMMA
AGE 42 YEARS.
4
14. MILK PRODUCERS WOMEN
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KOGILWADI
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
YASHODHA M
AGE 43 YEARS.
15. MELLUR MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MELLUR POST
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
CHANDRA M R
AGE 30 YEARS.
16. ATTIGODU MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT ATTIGODU
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SARVAMANGALA
AGE 32 YEARS.
17. VADDARAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT VADDARAHALLI VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
KRISHNEGOWDA
AGE 46 YEARS.
18. BELATHUR MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT BELATHUR VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SARVAMANAGALA
AGE 32 YEARS.
5
19. HUNASEKUPPE MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HUNASEKUPPE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571117
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
REKHA M
AGE 35 YEARS.
20. MANTIBILAGULI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MANTIBILAGULI VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
JAVAREGOWDA G
AGE 39 YEARS.
21. KELAGANHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KELAGANHALLI VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
TAMMEGOWDA A
AGE 45 YEARS.
22. THIMAKAPURA MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT THIMAKAPURA VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
YASHODHA M
AGE 39 YEARS.
23. CHITTENAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT CHITTENHALLI VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
6
PADMMA S
AGE 66 YEARS.
24. HARAVAMALLRAJPURA MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HATAVEMALLARAJPURA VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
HEMALATHA R
AGE 37 YEARS.
25. JAVANKUPPE MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT JAVANKUPPE VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
KUMAR J P
AGE 46 YEARS.
26. NAVILOOR MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT NAVILOOR VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
DASAIAH K
AGE 44 YEARS.
27. NARALAPURA MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT NRALAPURA VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
KALAVATI M
AGE 42 YEARS.
28. NERALAKUPPE MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT NERALAKUPPE VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
7
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
VIMALA N
AGE 47 YEARS.
29. ANANDANAGARA MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT ANANDNANAGAR VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
NAGAMMA G
AGE 55 YEARS.
30. SENABINAKUPPE MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT SENABINAKUPPE VILLAGE
PIRIYAPATTAN TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT - 571114
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
GOPALKRISHNA M
AGE 53 YEARS.
31. THIPPUR MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT THIPPUR VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
MALLESHA T M
AGE 42 YEARS.
32. MULEPETTLU MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MULEPETTLU VILLAGE,
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571 602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
VANAJAKSHI S
AGE 55 YEARS.
33. KUGGERE MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KUGGERE VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
8
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
KUCHELA K J
AGE 36 YEARS.
34. CHANNAPPANAKOPPALU MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT CHANNAPPANAKOPPALU VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SHOBHA DEVI
AGE 46 YEARS.
35. HOSUR MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HOSUR VILLGE,
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
H K SHIVANA
AGE 56 YEARS.
36. HOSAKOTE MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HOSAKOTE VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571 602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
H R BASAVARAJU
AGE 58 YEARS.
37. HOSAKOPPALU MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
AT HOSAKOPPALU VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571 602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
PARAVATAHAMMA
AGE 43 YEARS.
38. HEBBALU BADAVANE MILK PRODUCERS
9
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HEBBALU BADAVANE VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571 602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
BHAGYAMMA
AGE 47 YEARS.
39. SRIRAMAPURA MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT SRIRAMPURA VILLAGE
KR NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571 602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
S T NARAYANA
AGE 51 YEARS.
40. KANCHUGARAKOPPALU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KUNCHUGARAKOPPALU VILLAGE
KR NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571 602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
KANTHARAJU K T
AGE 54 YEARS.
41. HEBBALU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HEBBALU VILLAGE
KR NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571 602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
SUBBEGOWDA
AGE 47 YEARS.
42. D K KOPPALU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT D K KOPPALU VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571 602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
BALAKRISHNA K
AGE 55 YEARS.
10
43. MALANAYAKANAHALLI BADAVANE MILK
PRODUCERS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/A MALANAYAKANAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
B S PADMALATHA
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS.
44. CHUCHANAKATTE MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/A CHUNCHANAKATTE VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
MINAKSHI
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS.
45. KARTHALU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KARTHALU VILLAGE
K.R.NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
K.K.CHANDRASHEKAR
AGED 47 YEARS.
46. THANDRE MILK PRODUCERS
WOMEN CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT THANDRE VILLAGE,
K.R.NAGAR TALUK,
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
KUCHELA
AGED 52 YEARS.
47. NIJAGANHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT NIJAGANHALLI VILLAGE
K.R.NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
JAYANNA
AGED 52 YEARS.
11
48. ICHANAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT INCHNAHALLI VILLAGE
K.R.NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
REVANNA
AGED 51 YEARS.
49. HALEYURU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HALEYURU VILLAGE
K.R.NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
H.C.SRINIVASGOWDA
AGED 44 YEARS.
50. SALEKOPPALU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT SALEKOPPALU VILLAGE
K.R.NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
KUMARSWAMY
AGED 48 YEARS.
51. CHIKKAHANSOGE MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE
R/AT CHIKKAHANSOGE VILLAGE
K.R.NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
SHANTAMMA
AGED 42 YEARS.
52. SIDDAPURA MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT SIDDAPURA VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
VASANTHAKUMAR, AGE 47 YEARS.
12
53. MARAGOWDANAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MARAGOWDANAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REP. BY ITS PRESIDENT
RAJAMMA
AGE 49 YEARS.
54. KANUGANHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KANUGANHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
K S MAHADEVA
AGE 60 YEARS.
55. VADDARHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT VADDARAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
V R NAGARAJU
AGE 55 YEARS.
56. BHERYA MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT BHERYA VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
BORA NAYAK
AGE 57 YEARS.
57. MUDALABEEDU MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MUDALABEEDU VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
13
GAYITHRI
AGE 47 YEARS.
58. RAMAPURA MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT RAMAPURA VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SUKANYA, AGE 57 YEARS.
59. KARPURAVALLI MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KARPURAVALLI VILALGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SUDHA, AGED 35 YEARS.
60. MANDIGANAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MANDIGNAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
GANESHA M V, AGED 34 YEARS.
61. ARJUNAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT ARJUNAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
A R TRIPURAMBHA, AGED 54 YEARS.
62. CHANDAGALU MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT CHANDAGALU VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 571602
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
PREMAMMA, AGE 54 YEARS.
14
63. THANDRE ANKANAHALLI MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT THANDRE VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT-570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
NANJAPPA, AGE 75 YEARS.
64. HEBSUR MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HEBSUR VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT- 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
H P RADHA KRISHNA
AGED 55 YEARS.
65. GAYANAHALLI MILK PRODUCERS
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT GAYANAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
CHANDRAPPA
AGED 59 YEARS.
66. MUNDUR MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT MUNDUR VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT- 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
YASHODHA
AGED 47 YEARS.
67. KALLIMUDDANAHALLI MILK PRODUCER
WOMENS CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KALLIMUDDANAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT- 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
VANAJA S AGED 58 YEARS.
15
68. LAKSHMIPURA MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT LAKSHMIPURA VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
YOGESH T
AGED 37 YEARS.
69. NARACHANAHALLI MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT NARACHANAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
SHIVANNA K
AGED 72 YEARS.
70. KATNALU MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT KATNALU VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
CHANDRA SHEKHAR
AGED 37 YEARS.
71. HANUMANAHALLI MILK PRODUCER
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
R/AT HANUMANAHALLI VILLAGE
K R NAGAR TALUK
MYSORE DISTRICT 570003
REPRESENTED BY ITS PRESIDENT
RAVIKUMAR P
AGED 42 YEARS.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI. MAHESH C M, ADV. )
AND:
1. STATE OF KARNATAKA
DEPARTMENT CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETY
M S BUILDING
16
BANGALORE-01
REP. BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY.
2. THE JOINT REGISTRAR OF
CO-OPERATIVE SOCIETIES
MYSORE DIVISION
PALACE OFFICE BUILDING
MYSORE-570001.
3. COMMISSIONER CO-OPERATIVE
ELECTION AUTHORITY
2ND FLOOR, SHANTINAGAR BUS STOP
BANGALORE-560027.
4. DISTRICT CO OPERATIVE ELECTION OFFICER
MYSORE DISTRICT
MYSORE-570001
ASHOK ROAD
NEHARU CIRCLE
MYSORE-570001.
5. CHIE EXECUTIVE OFFICER
MYSORE AND CHAMRAJNAGAR DISTRICT
CO-OPERATIVE CENTRAL BANK
ASHOK ROAD, NEHARU CIRCLE
MYSORE-570001.
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SMT. JYOTHI BHAT, HCGP FOR R1, 2 & 4
SRI KESHAVA REDDY, ADV. FOR R3
SRI. S.B. TOTAD, ADV. FOR R5)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND
227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO DECLARE
THAT SECTION 20(2) (A-iv) AND (A-v) THE KARNATAKA CO-
OPERATIVE SOCIETIES ACT IS ULTRA VIRES THE LEGISLATIVE
COMPETENCE AND ARTICLE 243Z1 AND 243Z0 OF THE
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA AND ETC.
THIS PETITION COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING
IN 'B' GROUP THROUGH VIDEO CONFERENCE THIS DAY, THE
COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING:-
17
ORDER
Sri Mahesh C.M., learned counsel for the petitioners appears in person and submits that in view of subsequent development, the writ petition has become infructuous.
2. Submission of the learned counsel for the petitioners is placed on record.
3. Writ petition is dismissed as having become infructuous.
Sd/-
JUDGE NG* CT:bms