Karnataka High Court
Sri B S Yeddyurappa vs Sri Ravi Krishna Reddy on 17 January, 2012
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
"V V' B_a:1g3£{>r§fi..?V§aa:,§%:
L.)
IN Cri.P.8'?O4 [[20 1 1
BETWETEZN:
E. S:mi.Shy1aja
V'v';'a 'J.SG::1ar:::a
M3301" in g«":§;§e« 8% }»"e2::fS
R59: E\?::>.98}'2 ii Main; E{::}a{%
\/":§ayar:agar
Baizgaiars -- 588 846% -
@x'}
31*}. "J.SGr::a::zn2.
S/0 Laie \£'€€ra.m1a
Major in age .52 '_'{€E1E'S
E\='I1'r;is:er 01' Hcugsing L
Governmené of Eiarrzataka
R/cs No.96? H Ma§:i*;E{oad.V'V
vrzgayanagar I . *
Bangalere - 568 S40. .:_'.vw?'i:?_TET1QNEZRS
{By Srifishok f;::4 "
Srifviurthy eeehi'NayaE<.;»i';fi:?S;}""
EN cr:.p.699e3g20--i:{:V;»" I ' ' V H
BE'1:wE£::\z; T " ' ~ 37
S;*i,f}.i::':g'2'zia§:: _ V.
Sfé Laie De$::fgQWdé _
Aged gbsui 6?'y<i_:3:'s
R;/:3 i%?j§_5, §¥§ar§§?a§>p.2::€:a;33_}ya
V" Baiggaiarsre. _ 3, Pm":T:{;NER
{B35 S$iff:S::'é3%§3Zs_§i: *i?~:f§;ii'so<:£§;"E22.:::2mi 8: Srifiagar, 2%,dv$.}
V V' _A§a?§}:"'«.
H §S:2;_pe:**;ni,e§:£€r:{ <3? Pséice
«I;;}:>§;ai}r':a2§<;':8. .
_B:;:fi'g:--'{§.®r€ L§:*§:;a::
'~;E:rE,frE§.8:2iéd%r'a;:,;'
-.f?g;:::g2z§:>:*::*:, .> §€Ef;:$?%3§'x:'§}§§§§'E'
{{iGEEEIE,1i}IE £22 €Q:'§,E>,?x§{}sa3?3?'?€%«fl 5%
6§§§;';?i€}i E}
{E335 EE>:2:: E",325E.{};2j,;aé;}'::"i, éciv. €92' §;<>%i22,j=g§«:é§*::?: §3a%§<::€::§
L»)
Cf'i1"1'}_ina§ Pei;3;'{i<3n N<:a.E':':83§/:2{}i§ is fileé unCi6:":S €:::ie:1
4238 C:.P_C, praying £0 ézfiarge Zhéi peiitioner on '!:':g{:§v._i*:; "E};1e
evsni of his i;1I"§'€S'{, in P.C.R.N0f25/202 E New psndiixg .Ir;~s:.f§'1€_.i_;E*1«'i
Spatial Judggé £23"? fiddl Cizy {Em} and SJ)
§}:':3'{ri<:'£,, Ba1:g2&<3rc3 {Grimm 330,68/'§}: ef LQ§§Z'i:v'-§i1K?'.$" ;PQ1:C:e}_
_;:>ff€:h:ées_' =-'p/'{;;'s.{E:€%§, 7
Bangalezre 59:' {ha ' V _
4Q§,42€3,§53x1§8:§§%68(<f§?E read with };2¢3{ B',§ :j~:i§}i:
l3E1}{U} P.C.A<:E;~i§88 mad with 34 a'§§P€;_';T ~ ' " ' .. '
C:*imi:1:fl Peiiiien E'€0.6?~i}:'§;'.'.28'£ E "is f§1€C:T' :1§V£?z::iv'5é:i VS%43CiiG1";¥., '
4538 Cr.P.C. praying '£0 er1Earg€""é;1h%:~,p€Eiti€;::e:':3{_{§:1"7'3a£§ in the
event of {hair arms: in P.C.R.NQ.2:'Er/ 201} Navy penijiing béfere
the 23"? fidfila City Civil' and S;*;§€<3iL§:1 ehléga fo'r'=pr"ev€n::'u3r: af
<:<:s:*:*u;3t:i0:: Act, Bangaieixs. --_ 3. ,
'Criminal Péfcitien §'f{Q_.89.E3E3;_'2{)':'I'~:s*~§:i<=:d urséer Seciian
438 Cr.RC. praying t<3feI:i::1'g:& :E:§'~g3e£'it§;;>:'ier on ha} in the
event ef his ar:'"€:s*L":;é:: 1?.C;R=L N<}.25/2Gi"1._m'1 the £316: if 31$ 23?"
Acid}; élity C:%vi3"'v3:id,.f$,J S§'eC1a4i Judge far preveniisn 0f
carruptiez: A1321. §3é;_;1gaE{>r€,f'=..' -. >
Tifiese §'etiif;_i@n:§g <:<3_:::i:j:g 91:69:' fiiciaiing C:f'fi€i"S {$113 fig}:
ins Csuiii maciré: ¥;':1;:'=-fa:3§E<)wi::g:._ ' -
:::~:::~g%;n:/3;: ?efi:ié:1:N{§;6839/2$}E is by accusfid N0. 1.
«_fCj§<:::*;'§;3a.;__f?e§:§:§<§f:"?s?.{3,_€§Z?'G4f2%3EE is by accused N032 ané
;é:::.d Paitieii ?€0.§§§§/'2{}§§ 2155 by accusseé
2';. __:'§?h;€ Karriaiaiiga 1,@E»<;gyu§a'§ha ?<:>ZE§§€§ Barggaimfi
VA "'{"_§;1i:};Q"'A§%:a3;S r€gis'{6z'€é 'Q38 {tags 3:: CE'i§'€§€ NG.§i".}j2€3EE on
261% E.:2§}':§ :5:g3iL::s%;; %;§:::::~;€ i3.C{ifi,;§S3€(i EEK i;%:€ {}ff€§:<::6s
§E,i'§"§§S:f1§%.b§§3 é;§§1é€E° S@cii{:s:'1.:e $35, 5%2{3$ 4&3; 46%, x:§:§8-%
X
w"%"'"';ii§f:'a!.f
5 "?'«%:'"'
4?} 23336 with Seciiagz 1298 <3?" thé: Indian Pena: (Sofia
further read with S€{',iiC>I1 £3 sub«s6ci§0r: (E) ~.{'_jC§.V_<3f
the P;"evenf,i:}n sf CC2{I'LE§}1:§(}E'1 Aci', 18388 rezéé "8$€§i9.23 .
34 Sf EPQ
Q
we
Gm: Ravi
,.r;ehn.:~1
E32,; pzzxkzuc .
Cemplaini in P.C.R.NG.25/20 '"'aefc:r{:% 'V
far Lokayuktha, B3:i1.gai§>r€gV""' V 'S§€CiéiE"'C'5@::*: has
raférred the said c0m;#}1é.if1_f! PCrHC€
under Section 33; .i1l'_1__V€:f'{V:v0de sf Criminai
Pracedurre ihe Lekayuktha
Palms ":':::"'ei§%:r'irr1€ N€:».6G/ 261 1, and
ihfi :na{$;s:r" A: this Stagfa {he
p€'€i"€§GE'§€I'S 33% b€f{}}f€ i~?i:i¥s~.-Ceurt,
C"; Q:r §§';ia§:;a::€ ifiairns E3 hs 3 §s='{.E. §_§ra,dLu}at€, had
._§
. f~
.' ~13
:£é'é31f'§<:T%%__é .jA EC? :«;%3a.r$* thereafief, E16 maafsd back
is Ezzéiia axlfééiiz This faméiyz H6 is 3 Sséfiaé aasiivigé. anfi 'Ji%"E'§§€§'
Eiggzzzsgaia. 35 had pufiiisshed ism' b<:}@',s§§. E6 had 3383
__ -z:';z:5$':1'!€.:;i:::%é éthé é'*:ss€n'§§3§§»* EE6{:é:i{§:r: "rain aiagzzmagar'
-«. :'4§::;i§{:::2%3Ej {:{%'§E5-3/i'§LLE€3§"§€3}j{'. '§'<> iiysziéss 23§:a§*§3rzs3§§$ 2:é:}w€::"'<§_%:
AZ'-.{}i:.»3(":_:§'€E fog" :2(:=::us€é Neg:
,.._ §}§§d<§a:*::a;3i,
Ciean psiitics and; values in public: iifa he sat :31f'..1:_1 ';1u:*:g€:'
sirfigs.
5; He aiéages that, a<:<:;:s€d E'§<§éi."£'§Q CGHS§3}_£'€§' ':EH{§.
ssmméitaé an {}ff€I1€:€ purzishabie i;;§:¢':'e_r Q16 g:::"é:?i§i0';f:'ss~_Ci',
Seaétzen 1.3 gubwsectzsn {E} <:3;9.:;u§:e-Ed} read wétiz fZ':.€C§1€)I: 13
sub~se<:!:ian E2) of {/11e;---.?rev§::'iid:"r;'- §§i"~LA'(Zcs1*I:i:;13i:§efi Act {in
Sher: referred is as _ z%_éi.'.) "3-lisges ihat tbs
accused havs c::§f:;miI':§;'éd g§f£én_ceS "fg}5{lI1iShE:'tb}€ under
S€cti:i>:a$ 488, 4?: read with
Ssctiarz v._$;::%j'--~-f1;.t'.€Vher read with Se<:f:i§n
13(1){d}'--,_ef ti1e £§;%:t:.*'V:é'a;i' E2~::¥<:ti0n 34 of EPC
E2": iéexaf Gf héhé; régigiratiom :21" C1"iI}'i€ against 'ihese
V':3Acc1:sé§2, -L,t}":es,e a.5€'é':i::«::€é apprehending tbs arrest have
.p'i<;.~:i::s;:s ufider semen £38 9% {i::;P,C.;
Sséiiifig a.::i:§:§§§§';at::2;§? E3331
* ''i;§§ard S:*§.;%sE;@}<: §*Ea;'a::aE":aE}§3 iezarnad Segnjgy
:9 3 anfi Srifiaihésh
;i3a:°:3§::§ Cs>:::1:§é:E fa}? :::x::<:::::;:::§
ifSia§§it.'i'.?x«'E§{§;:§5:£h:'§, Ejzzrzéeié Sagmssei {if}? 'SE15 L€£££i}'{,§E%ii§ié%
{f'W'%.§
gay?'
) V'
M"?
M3
That, the aCcus€:d N092 p:,::*<:has€:d the iand from ag%§:'L:Ls€d
Ncxé uf:€i€I' the :'eg£s'éc3r€§ sake: deed dated
is t%*2e:*€af'£:€:r, accused 339,5; haé §fi3_<§}_:?;i~€t{Si':§.¥i§ I' thszfl
Cxazzernment ta d€3f§{)§§f}7 {the 1::md.g Eé?é:';..v ;3;::_:<és:>i:"--::i;_i"t1-§,>,:.1:VVé"ihé
Compiainant himself? the }3FQ€f€_3Sf5 of---éé':10ti£E§:.2é;*:.i§:1"staftedF.L
in tha year 2005 iliseifg En EhéV"L€::§f::.p1aifii:§V_ sfgecificaily
mentiened that on i'}ién' Pr:i:1{::ipaE
Secretary Urban D€v€i{};§;ii§:2;if{ had dirested
{he Spot ' u vrthe purpose of
dsnotiiiying ._2§j§1é:g:g:i5n in $116 Csmpiaint
3139 sma:sV subsrdinate officers
wean: f«:3vf--f.:_:€:<;¥,"_t:::> % evesn éhough {ha accused
No.4 had :i%:;«i:.fi:.ad5s:_a:j fa;;_f:i:ca§i@n fez" denoiificaiéen
;fg:*§?1€%W§ub:'11§.§t€d ihai, at §a:*e«E2 ef ihé
-éémgizzinaat siatss {hat the &{?C'ilS€§ N{>.2r
§;?';$EAE'7'5f3f{7J§§::{?3:'{f3_fi'5i}%} §§:z":d Gxasutéd Qfi §§~e3,2€}G5 {yam a€if3{§S€§
é'7:j;,é§ 8.f::§§. "ii: {ha s&§d rsiitiifiaéaiien §€€é; it wag mantéezzfid
Urban §):::r::>§::;§mem $e§}a§§:1§€z:i by OE"C§€I"
§'§£§i.{}E}E} 2&3 :.::;::\.?:>: 233:2: dzzigai 4~,3,;?,{3§5 hafi s;e::g:a§:ea
{E16 'zzzizé,
%:'"
<2
22. Section 48 {}f ihe Land ;'i:cquisi£;io:1 Act t§§f§i';_i"$rs
p<)¥Vf3I' an th€ €3<>v€r:1:'::e:1i: ta witlldraw any 13fl£i~.f§"{}§T?;
21CC§LEiSi'Ef,i€}I': at any fifllé' befsre HES p0s;§€s$§Q:i'~..;3f' 93:63 h
Eand ii.':11{.€'I1 22:16 in this €23,565 ilfééé i€:é:::;:$*§.ai:§i-- Véu:--s::r;f1%fn{Vs;?
$0 fifif indicate {hat the aéttuai péizsééssian i_:f:'£h'€~
was taken and Eh€F€é;1ff€3i, thE5L.gi€ne:v:iir'iC3_ti'cs:3Ewéxg issued.
in turzi, Eearneé S€1'1i¢;é:.'..COLEi'§S€'§._ '"f'é1'§~!§d Qn"i~h€ materia1
pmduitsd by the c0mp}zi§;'1anf* f.:_<:>f';--.S E":z:'»5*<,'2u':%_'t.¥j::'s:;fii,V series Gf 30:65
ifi the governmérztfiie };;'fGd{i':e{i.._'I::y thT€.Vfé%3xr:1p1ainani right
{ram 2G§5$1};4'fiifi_'--'.d€f::}Eifi.ca£1c;%f; Show that successivs
gQverr:::1e:1is~..oheflaftef :a.:i§i:ii!¢fV hafv€ béen recgmmending
thg §§g:0t;fgggf1§;;_.,V_céféI':aia\:3:::Ey.' these ignés, but also the
Giher §a:éé:~.~;, 2:1éé;.AV*sz:{T§5:1f§i:¥.:J€d i/1/13:»; apart fram {hrs Eagds
Er: §u;€S'%§.Q:r1, éfhfif Eandg have heal d€§0{ifi€§; eafien
":§12V1'f§ia was passed? {E1686 maisréaég 33$
{:®II3§3.£:'§§ia:f1'L himafiif. Eva: assuming
_ :;11g;Aé;'~._§h§_:' exsritigéé E3 gsoxafsr €E'3fQ?Z'§€C1iiS§}§
"iégtgéii" sari}? :19: CE{}:F':Sti§E,i1:€ an Qffemte iiiihffil' %3§E{§:'f:"
:.'&§i~3.s:';fV<:%::--E§,>fi3; E3 3u¥:3~$${:ti<>n {E} :;:Ea:;:2:»€ {éé <21? rm? Aaifv Oi" agigr
.4{}i.E;€:* ;;>:"§}vi$is:;I:.s:: its? Eh? §:::::%§2:§1 ?€§32%§ €<)é£:: ¥:?§":€:": {'f%'}.!E'
V:Ei,§§€2'§§Ei§L§{T}E'} ii}. Eh? {7?iT}§§"§§3}.éi}:IE§L daseés :2s:::%; saémw 52:2}: i>§§:i:;::::€:>
X ,
f' 5?,
wmw 35 Mgr?
fa/.m$"'
harasgnzent, humiiiatiorz and unjgzsfifiefi d.€t€nt,iQfi".{§'ii.th€
gzccused. 'xkfileri the Conlpiairzt and this Ii"1a'€€i"i§};}~§_:j:i}_§'tiC§§3:d
amzzg wiéh the §:<:>mpEa§:1€ daes 21:}: cans::t;;;:%;¢_'1:m3,--._§3:*fe;:es,.,V
it is jug: and pmper for the cotgrt fig)gf1*é:;1'€§ a:1*i.i»;:i§g::t/ggify'
bail as their iiberiy is aiso Of:§38.3'aIIi'i§'Li§§.3.f Corzsé-J:iAé':~a€:C;n§"~
£5. Smtfirayathri, isarfiiie-d"'-»..LACoigiisei. ffer tha
Lokayuktha Felicia rflieii 'Q1: éh_é: ¢@Ifip::a,§Hf_Vavarmerztis ané
subnlittsd that, ac§;':j'é€<;';§*}<},*1§:K%a£,=;~ the office: of
Chief EH: Kérnatakai Accused
N93, iima was :26: 'L116
3*»/£iriis1:e'._%~§ ané had degsrted ihe
Enéiazg §'\:3:93gié;1:a§ and jsined Bharaihiya
Janatiga LA?a:4:§;-. 3;:/:e:%i fa} géeiiéical advantagag the asssused
E\;'i>,Vi" V1.:9%-:$§>; R'£h_€ sfifiéfirt of the acczisuid N03 aid the
':::é€;::_g:%e':*;».' £"Le3..<;>';§'~3r;é;;§ went Gut {sf the Way to hép assuséd
E593;-:2 3/::,:E~ "f§3€ E3515, W%:§€%: was aézéady %2'€3':€é 3: £338
w'253.:é ;z:;<:>!;i Ezxrgilabis fer §€?iG§Zif§{':3ii{}R; ii; xxzas C:ra:§€:"€§
E's";f:"+;':;$;§i:a'>':::f'i<:aii(>:": and 836%; as": Sffjé? wguié $6 fikigaé erder
.V §§i'§§;'§§ éf éfiéigaé <:f::'{f;a:* is; 13319566 21?: fhfi Véshagé of E1%;'Ti<3i}E3€é
V§'%;f<>§;F2 33:53 3 ;«::1{§ §§::r:* g3:%§i§;:€téaE :":§{3%::ve3% 3: zziééégiizg bag? as
m»xmwm.m.mmmm.mW.,._
abuss of power anci the *~:aiuabie €EOI1Sid€f'8.'{iGfi=_§E:7f3;C§s*31"
S€<::tion i3{1}(d} Shotzld be Lmdergtsod not
the :>E3j€<:'é$, but gigs in §,e:'ms; Of~"'§h€.b€f1€§§§ '£3;§f?' 2:{:c1j;,sé:§
Neg': eiiher psrsanafiy €31' fer
othérwise wouid acquira b3€vi_: *i:;€ <)f"s3:;C'h_ §~§d€~;::°é';' if ':h«.i~:"
land has been denetifisfi at t}'1€~gi}st:ézr}§:€ a$QL1;:§;eé No.3,
:1: is noéhing but an vE'Lb;;£rS€ _Qf?.; pVG§;;F{§§ in accused
N01 and acczzssrfii N05 3 .inv:.Cj§3t::§;iy;;»,fri§§€j'$§}Vi§§":V'.ascuséd N352
and 3, if he it is neihing but
an offence 315C 8330, §§},Ci§€n§31§y
{ha Q*:h;?:€" V'€§f§'€:§;:ff:$s a'itfi§{i{ €:dV.
26. S'1i$VVs:r5;:g13{ s:§.E:>§:1itted that "E326 mat/£3? is under
i:m«'e.8iifiga"u'@r: afiéat ibis giage, if the accused are granteé
aAr1:éé§Vi}:a;:<§.::a,?.<VA.bail, 'ih€1"€ is iikeiiheed sf tam§:2€rir:g {he
é'¥='i€§i§_QCé' iéigfié S1f§fi1}§E§€§s {hat fiiifi prfisaiziirss 0? the
_ ar:€:§3»€§v-..':::a§} bs fiscesgary fer She free? €23.31? and pmper
.Li¥:':2%Lff3s,':igéz%;i@31g SE13 Eiiffii} ffilififi an {E16 3%/'€1*'ffi€§2'{,E:3 2:: {ha
_' T._C'Q::?:'g;§s;§::?g ezrifi saibfiziiiséé $233 Ema campiairgé §f%S{?§.§8€S
" "éfiézé 33:5 ::3'=f;f.¢::T'ii§2{i':C§ ?~$e:}.1 ii: §:*§:s3:3.§ éi€fCT&S€{§ E'*£3'E§ 323$
vr<:3€a>rr.:"::€3:f;é5t{:§. {§§:*e<é::i:2§§ d§:n{:%éf%<::2i:is:>:': 2:3? %i%:£3 §E%E'}{§i£, 2:xzhi€;':T§
Z4
233:6 the subject ::1ai;t.er cf {he ¢:Qn1p1air:t As S'L1*C§'1',.
fade there is a materéai for investigation _.::§<zé i£}i_£'*
i::v€s§/igaiien is compistfi, ihers :5 3,36 j.::S:§i:'§Qe:i:i':3%f;:» isii g_r;;z:':: V
anticipatary bail',
117, Sri.$uresh, Eearned E;
sceught permission to tfie suL§f:1Hin1i*:ed that
the complaizzazztis a has fieici ihe
CQII1p}aifit é ' pmpemy. The
c0mp1ai:;a_:v1;€"s.V the cerrupi persens
in pubic: 2 5243568? he hag Ceflecied tbs
material information Act and hag
prQd».1.;§}f£cE. «:3? d0e:um€:1i:s indicaiing ihat, the
favaur accusefi N<}.3 has recemmendeé
G5 the knds in question, aizd
She ;S"£at€ G§Verm:z:€:1§ has €531,366
d€'a<}ii§3?§fig boih {ha survey §1§,:§'1"§§€};'§ §::sm 'ihfi
sf §iC§El§S§i§0f§. S6 aise gufimétéfid that 1:116
.%:'r§'a%fi:€: Eseiiag u1f:é«51* :m«'€s3é:%g3;::3.ti(3:1§ <_é<>mp1a§::an% bsizzg 3
sscéai w<§:"}:€:: 3:3 'ibis $33": 9? mg aisiiiign haé {:®§§v:':C{<:é
'fake §E'ié}.,?€5§*§2'f§ zmai EST; £3 £92' £226 Enasaaééggaéiiag €3§f:i<?;s:§ iii}
5
W 2; ,
Collect faiths: €'Jid€I1C€ in {he matter. At this stagefixshen
primafaciéz the zzzaieriai shaws the Gffences c0:;3.§i:if,i€:i'VT.b'yV.
ihfi accgzgeé, tiieré is me reagazz for {E16 €:c:Vi;-17: g:*:aL:%:T '
azxticipatory bail is faveur of ::h€se;"ac;:<%i:3$c§«,
18. To considér as i£i? 'w:§1€i11 €vr 2 '£326 T' §§{§V:;;_L:::s.'e,:§.~3 afe
er:f:i*:1::--:d for a:11:i<:§pato:*y baii, :1j€ _Vf0I1{';i>1:fif:g" paints are
requirréé to be C0nside:"é%é;:., V ' ' V ' V
[1] Whether there fig r€g2.S_Q::z :ci",Ef2éEi}.:':fv:2<i% that £51838
a.ccusec;Ej irzighéf be ' é:t;r:'gs«ij€:<'i :>ng.z:iccusaz'ion of
ha:2ir:g {taéijsrzsfniiied ?{zén~baiZa}§ie---Qflénce?
(2) '$'«?{::§h€%_'?V §;ér2d8%*j Séczien 438 of {he
.53-0dej'g.Qf£Zfzi:;':'zi;z<:;Z ?'r~@.€te€a:iure couid direaiég
enterficié-fa_u:z.pe.:i:'é:2n far gram: of aniieépaiary
"b<:::E?' V V" H
{3} T?ie__nai:L:§'*g tééfiai ;:g f_;r1fi,:if;g,z 9}" {he azceusaiion;
, fifiieeééeefzfis she Gj}§3§iC{L§?.§'Sf
A :V§5,3 ?A<}::$€b£Z§:y Qf ihe appéécarzis is fige fram
' -- _j;.;_:s£f:E€:;
'A .__ {§} §%f§;<§--;Vféier the {éC€EéS€i§§Q?E Ems 5266?: made wiih
' "f1¥"'é :§5j€£'§' is iigjure Q?' Ezuzniéiate {fie <iéj:?§Zi€C2,31:€S
" haying ihem arresied?
ii :3 :":{}ii is; <i2;:3§1:':e {him in §i3;§":E»L"i%E}{?€ ::>f the
"w_§s:*i:?;;%.§'§ ::{}:'§3p§:::i:":i;a ihe Zsarzizazi :Sp6€:£:;:3 zisgége fa:
Egaéiiajmkééizg '33}; ex£:rs:;;:%i§"sg§ ;3<:;w€2* s.:m;§€z S%::::%:§(::§?: E§§£§§3§ 5;?
9/yx
CELRC. has refeizrred. the ma1:1ie:' to the Loka3rukth2gi¥ ??o§§Ce
E31" inveszstigation and it is 9189 :10: in disp:1§;€:---i_i::s;'t','.j'
Lgiiayukiha Pslics in pu§"Si;1aI'1C€* sf E135 s3:<.§§:: *a:';§;.éfe.:*s:r:::;'e.,V' '
by {hrs Eearfied Special Judgs hazé
:_'
Crime No.80/291 1. The €}ff€1f1C€S'V"?E_d }'€g€Ci 1
accused bsing one punishabié'L».T:;i:3d'er 439,
4.28? 1-'£63§ 464$ 468? 0f the
Indian Peaa} Code, 13 sub"
section (1) 55:1} Corruptien Acts
3988 read €:.f__1v';"3'§é,._;<:e2'"£ai::I§.z aré Cognizable
and nan»":§22:i%.:¢J:a;1€ éife-{:éa3s';--.
2G. S._€4t::iQfi"».4 ;§' ::;;{ C:'.R€Z: confsyg §S'W€i' on the
::?0::::e;:;':1i'»::'; P{)1iCEi_ §ff§r.::€:z' to ares: vvithaué "W€z§"1'8;IEt xazhiie
Qvffiger has a :':i'?8.SQfl to believe 0:: {he bagis of
éazch é:€::€'£';=:§}aii::;~' énformaiigza G1" suspiciafi {hex sud";
persagz ij?.a3. }i:AQ:m§:i"£:€d Iiirzre Said Gffszzée aid if he is
" Psaiiigfieégfzai the :::c<::jse§"s arms: is f3.€C€SS21§'§§', he {tauéé
" §3:fffe«s€_.--":h£% 23.{',C'iiS€'§. Ufid8iib§:€d::yZ whsn a {'fE"iE§,"i€ :%S
'..%'_"j£f?g"E§SiLf3Y€€i 5:3: =:::{::g:"%§;%:z>;bE:3 313$ :'§Q3§~%a?;]:a%%é3. égffszgiéazu. éha
" Psiééte 33.213 '§f3{}§¥€3F '£::_> a§':*s:::,::;. f?§€:"z{::€§ i:E1e:"<5 39:: égygzbi éééai
wcummmwmw
E'?
the 21{f€Ei;1S€d izavé 756213011 to behave thaég the};
be 3f"f€St€d in pursuarzcsz of the Ci"iI?{}€.v_.£;€§.§§lS§:§§Fé€C'§ ?1:>}%_'
Lokayuéitha FQEECS. , V .
21. Ag regaré to filing {>35 1:he'~.pe_.'t'11L:;Qn'd_£1*~3§ii:,3y""Eb._1EE:is
Gear: under $€{'Ii€3I} 438 of "wi:{i:QuT'fi. §§p:i<::5.éhing. '
ihe learfled Special Jgdge, ~ of 'this
Court in a judgment 2882 in ihé
maitsz: of Chandra ---=g«'z2§~ 'Jof Kamataka
has abserved
5"'€iIf _«:'*1:>:;§'s.£3V. .i?9'zé;°aé <:-:":/z: be ac: deubi that as in
§Vf1«%3_V}f;i«r:>'r*;;:*E:E";ig§_ fC0._air; Vof' S_€_:%ss;i€;:~n is subaraimaie ta
Z1553 H C?¥{)z§::*:V;"»._}:2 pafiy whiz malces an
ap_pE€::a:Vief:V.2;z::éZer"§e:::'i:;n 438 of ihe (Jade befere
{he} Sessierjs :_j{?<:>':;:fi"»».C=a:eu£::Z approach the High
C0z.;r':',L ?i:ésV'agépZi;;'g:g§:;ion had been agiécied £35: the
Cckuri "oj'V_}Ses:s;:of;§ but nei vice versa, in ether
..€§,::9fds, §f'§';?2.c.2f gjarzy chaases is fiie an applicaiisn
" :::r:.<:;£'€r"--;S8C{£0:é"éi38 if the Ciidé? bejfore the Hzgh
2 Cougrizf it is rejjecigeoi he Célflfifii' ihereajier
§i;;=j}fQa<f§?_ {E18 Cami' scj' 3§83E€?TiS made?' {he same
A '=.§§'e:'s~:}i:*'~§f'§€73¥§i::%:3.,fiefi $1": {he same gmunds. This gosiizlsm
is .1:~r>f:§:éCZ€d§ in ma?' apirziars, zighéiy, by {he
'igérfied €§ur:seE an iiseéh Sides. Fer {he aj%3res9.i&
» r€3._s':>:2s;, wefigzd I153? Subgiztmce in {he CG§"7LSi'2"'E£Cii@fé
A ._QfS€Ciiz:>2"?. 438 ef {fig Cede, as Suggeséed by {Egg
* ._ _Ee<:,m€{:Z fiévoaaie Qeztémi 'fife receive $u,pg:~or:V
for {his zsiew j'%"Qm 253:2 jE::E%@;.;:a{r2g d€§3iSiQ3"ES:
§%xfG§~L~'§§'\§ LA; 223* F§%EE%/E €33-EEEEXFE}: f}§P'E'ENI}U
MQYEEK 95;, S'§}'§'E"E SF §%?E$'?' E"§EI,3¥'{}gi4La Fifi: ihesg
:*£5::as:3r23g was {;::2:"~;w€*;* 543:6 :'§1§:'& {g:.z52§§?ia:": as
k§'E:2§§ez:.3:«;:
:4 1" ;m
V K
K
3
i
E
3
A peiiiiam L£E"1Ci€§" Seasiion 438 0f the Code is
mainiainabie bqibre the Bligh Cztzami ever: if 0.
simiiar <::ppZ:<::r::iiQr1 has beén made and rqgectégij
by {he Co::ri0fSe2ssi§;2. '~
This gudgggimeni was constiéered by this
Petition N<3:s.584z£/282 1 anfi
ISJLQOEE, in para-42g
under: ' 'V V V.
"42. it is clear j%o.:%z~..zh::.;} Q }:it:?I_f:3¢??"i«.:3€i2"E appraach
the High Court or"S:'sSio{%;'sj»v Coziri, if 0: person,
::zppr0achesV {he ;Sesséz:)_n,:_; '"€T0Lé:*j;:j.. and his
application.iigzfejggcted;"he.§ia::--._::ppi;*0::Ch the High
Court. Of: "~":2:'h§;" §*E;:J£2::oi 4_ §,15_a"'pé:"sGn approachss
the Higgfz 9f'3«{;:i:*§'1'Q:f::1i_V'3<:_is?~~appiizjatiorz 213 rvfjeciedg he
Carma: gpprggaeh 1:?2,;€ §§S€s$'i()nS'§Cour:. "
Théa C§{11ft" :C::{>_:;€iV?f§":§;j1fg"..ézéégftéineé & direct pséitien fiieé
bsfare 'ghis "$Quf§V;§§}ii1Ai':-E; f&is'~~§{:?::::::"e 438 of CLRC, £521' gxzgzaf; sf
" * af13::g'i§a£??¥& hail. ~ %%%%% 14 .V
:3? 'ahésss fi€CiS§{}f:S and 31 viaw' of the
.pf'QV'§:'§§{)§ES:.{}§V' S€Ci§6i'E 438 sf C:*.P;C'f E finé éihai iha
ps€§i;z}_:1 éé§u}§: be €*§1:e:":aL§:":ed $33? ihis Ceuri.
23$ 3:": ::;:'(§:::" ':19 C{3.fES§id,€i' 325; ii: wlzézéiéifisi' $328 é1Cf€§}S€d
«~%:?::";u?:{i E33 §;?;i'E§ZE§;é"§§ a::"%i<;*::%;321§:<3§'j; bzaééi éhe <:§r5:z:§::£-»;§:;z§2{::3s
5%"?
3%
X Kigim
vm mmmmWmmmMm_.'
w
possessien. H€)W'€V€1', :2 IE0?/ifiCE1JEi€}f1 mader Section 25 Sub-
sficiian {2} of {ha Land A€:quisi'E§«:>n fiéitfz may :::*Te:éf_'£:.§:"'~3Lr1
€v£&€:':{:e .215: regard is 'iiakj.13g {sf p€3ssess;£--01:,:
S' H? _
possegsiosé 9? tbs: Lzzmi by ihs :3w:1<§%§:.iS_:1 r:i%;i;$'fi"§"c;§;. i§é':«%{§i<;i:';g u
Ehe pmvisions (>5 Seséisn 48 0f the:"1L.£'~§;AiEVig E*J;§
power is being sought to bé _ii'S€d 113- many tihef
instancs Sf the awners Q1' Qth€rwVis:?:,
2?. The Apex '§h€ meaning of
passessian ung3éi*'*A;VS.8cti:0_n in a judgment
reported in matter cf Balwant
Narayczgi and others Whereir:
1ih€ Ap€:;€'_jC:{:¢%:::E .£3.}«;i::g <:::f pessegsiofi ands?
Sect/19:: 48 §s..:n::;':Va' _s§;:;:1ba§:<:a£ psssasgien, but it mus? be
'*,_ a::: 2?_;':§:ua,§ ;:§9sseSs§:;a::2T.:«' The Gbservaiégrg sf ihe Sii§§'i3§1':€
G _ an .: ";.;;.. :3 :
C 11"': "5 1: 3 "S {Baas as n§€r
' "Z3; _§€.~'f:e§z a ggubiéc :1e:2iz:e is pubiéshééd at ca
' géiiigzgsénéezzzi ;3E::e:€ 0:' rzeczr E326 {and {:3 fig éaiierz
siaziing #30,: {he Ceverizmeni izfaiends is take
A passeggiazz 3}' {he Eané, 53:52:': Qrciifiariéy and
_,-'gezzeraiégj ifzere waziid P36 2% agzzeséion af
resigiézzg 9:" i:?:§€§i3"1g 31$ iaiciizgz Qf
p§5;5;€$s::fa:z. §}:::*§:z2e2;"§; or gizéirzg 53;' }'§€3SS€$SIii>?2
gm; s:z:::€z* :32" 5328 §<:n:i2:s;§5:zz§: <:3;" She iasza:/5 £5;
239$; §'€ga:é;'eai E'?'2£ {IT:::i§::3s:§:0:' 53:: §;fg§'@:2:s3 {Eggs
surrender of the land {Lo himseif under Seezion
4? of the AC: gf impedes? {:2 taking possession,
On pazbiieaéiozz of the noiioe ;zn<:Zer Section 98}
<:ic:.im.s to compensaiionfor ail ir::e:*es:s in ihe__
ienei has is be made: he ii me irzzeresi of
owner or ofa person emfiied zoo {he oeez:;o'o{iozi'_:--. .
of {he Eezzoi. Gm ifze taking sf ;:2ossess.io:2V "
the {end urzcier Seezions I6 or I ?(_}}":':..':oes'is «A
absomieéy in {he Goeerr1meAié{o"j%e£: 3%!'
Ii' is, i}1e:fej2:?z¢'e,3o§ecir.
iaicing of possession wiio?z£;ri.__tIie meaizfng. eqf "
S316 or 2 7(2) I?Z€ClfiS'3fCZf;7*f§'?lg o}'7.;z3ossess€o§:..on .3
incurnbrczncesg
the spoi. It is neiifaer Cepossesséon'oflzpgitpef
nor a "symbolieal" pos_sess:o.I_; as genereiily
understood in Cieii Lem 'Bo: Vifie quesficfiz is
Loha: is {he mode »%:3f takiing po'sse.ssion? The
Act is siient on the ~poifz'£;' 1'L':1iesssj'~;){:ssess£on
is iaken the Lofiziefa ag:reemer:::"ofthe party
eoncerr:e:Z"«T.._:fhe 'mo;:Ee7 of '£'<:'7;Ecz'2%:g;;VfA possession
oboio_us'iy £1o_(::.:1E:;"_'?2e for zine euéhoriiy :0 go
apart' :'he"'_,.io,ri£;€ » io...;:io'*, some act which
:oool¢i""§;ficii%;:§;:e ' é};e...§§Lsihoriiy has taken
;éossess?iQn of :he"2<iz:d. .1: may be in the form
of op-:i£e<i*§o;r€2;:'{o::, fog; Reed of drum or oiherazfise
o:"¥og;' Vhaegigég. or'*-.;o;"«§:fen gieciaratiorz on {he
sg:,>oEf"2.'_hé:;i ihe ::;:':ho:'i:y has iaken possession
5 --g:3f:he 'E<1n'ci.- The presence of {he owner or {he
~'~'.,oeeegoenio Aoj7.:_§;e. iand io egjfeeiueie ihe :ai<:i:1g
'po%s~s_ess£or: is no: rzecessofg, No furiher
::<3;€i{:e«ve.!37eggor:<:£ that wider Seetioe 9(3) of {he
_ Agéeeis .:feqa:ire<:2i, when possessien has {seen
iosicefif/Eiie ogooer or file oeeagoeni of {he Send is
oEf$;2o.s'sessed. Once possessiozoez has been
§'o;§3§er: size 5522255 oesés £3: {fie $ooer?zn':en;:.
Eéezzess, it is aéieez' $231,? fie gessesséoe means
.Weé.::--'£::_e£ ;>ossess§o:: aeé me? s};r:'{%::é';§E{:::;.} possessiesz,
" " " aiiouisiiig ETi€3§§(?iE' i:::.:s <;:xme:* Eiléijg' me}? be eeitsésserfg 3.123% esiié
hi}
Km)
sf this Tahfiisriar gaizzg ta ihe 131252 by iisglf 53330 d€}€$ {K311
£¥i}I}$£§iiii§;£ 21 §3§$S€SSi§¥}. 335323': is referrezl ':43 is ;:;a'::'::,:a3
passetssiarz. fieavever, izeither iii '£316 m::z§};=:z§:3f§
maiariai pmfizzcad aizmg Wiih ihs ::s:::§}a§.::i: s;23.a¢2a;jVé:'z:Vé.:%i32é V'
astaai paossessiszz sf {he iands
Bflfigfifi in $126 compiaini. hf f:ha=: zzzést
and fi::+: pessessien Vzemains ihe aV;xa?1:¢%:*;A 'i:hr3V
passessierg remains gaéérzéifizaizt has
ihe gewer :0 drap {he acggifiiiihéfi .};3.:$1d.
29. 3._a:§gm§:fi§ repsorted in {Si}: 0)
5 SCC ?§33.. aiivi-'§,:st2»}eL Urficm Bevelopmeszt
At£t}1«D1"}:£y'--Bg --¥vs- Veer Kama: Jain and
Bikers haS,h<:::}§1 ViL§1éii:.'»*3:z$:j;: :13 2333 sf 21 natificaiian issued
_ &2,2:'2é{»::3{:.;E§€§:€:i:;>:: isggbgsestigzz (23 5f 'the Lazzd ficquisitiezz
,:'%;:':"£;,, '§s.2§:§é1w: ~~.:::*¢sii:€s 3.11 evidence £31' taking §9sse$$§{>:1,
{:§;§s%'§3§'f1~.${,'£%?L;§£iV'2*fij"s?f§;{V.31f3;3;'i§3hE is yehuitahie am} it is apex: $9 the iazzé
-V §%s.?:aéi's :i§:::g géééusfi 523$}; &%;§€'£e§:€<3 :0 rsbui 'aha gama at
" V' V' ;::§;:*a;~~2Z :%:€ fipeg Cmsrt E133 €{§}$€}"i?€§ as 111353633:
"22, 3:': aisw gf ifze aéwg, we ailing: ifzég
Qggeaé azzd fiiédéfg {fig §rdg:°g sf ihe Efigfi
ijgzgrf. Biffifii ifiae §%?§§:§§cg{€::}:zs dazed §2~?~2§§f2
gag: §§»§»:2§§§ zrgrg guasfiefi wad; éhs Siaiss
Govemmen: is directed :«::» hear the I'€£}££€'S§' Qf
{he Zanciz}:,:./mgrs jbr ::ieneE;'}'7i<:a:'i::>r1 «:2fre2sh.
zzsiil be aspen is} has Za:1r:Z::::1;>:2e:>rs is place .s;:.g:h~._
mazeriai as is avaiiabée Z0 {hem to sh0u,>W:?:::i'* '
€33.-3 f}OSS€€'SS§O?"é was 3:3: éa£€s3:2 2?: regard_..--:%:;> ii'za:f%f 'V'
{ands in ggzzeséiem and §}I8§'£3'b§; r8Z:$'L:._€ L"
pr§S::§?1p§;§OI'*: raised in zsiew qjf Sec:io'?:"'1'£3if;?~_{} 55;' ' _
ihe LA Acig ané {E16263 e?Si€{f53.§S??i' ,_i/§«":g::_ "'
tr
C§1'CE£F?%Si[<:ZU2C€S u.sarz*anz d€z2<é'{§fi;é'a:zEe§nI=, _
30. in View of ths abeuve, fi'i,_3_;'V}:'tZ¥fifiCfE{V{§{}I'i' ::::d£::;' Section
16(2) Gniy crézates pr«5f<3u;npt}iA:3'f: 0p§éf:"'*[:qy'/ghe land
CFWIISFS is rebut such such
€'\;id€Y}C€, if jignflgment that, the
notificafian Lnct be csnciuséxga
«to"--;§%e§§i:if:g--~»:1f'£*:h€ ianfi in {he Staté.
Hencs, éx{'§:f: §r: fancier Seitiion 16(2) cf
L.A,;%ci, :15" gtiié the awners ire: pE"0d?.);€Z€ $116
. _ §€§i}1,§»§i§"§;3B:é §3v§{§€f:*€€:V__{{; ;3:'<>V€~ 332:: §!0SS€;'Si=3I:{}§1e
V 31:: 81:3 case, ii is :19: {E36 afiegaiéegz ef
é:§1e€:~§}m§Ea;€:§:¢}afii 'iiat {E16 332333 3:? ¥€§SifEC§ if} 3315 Stats ::<>r
" 'ihsssre ES' agiiy mzaieriai p:*0e:§:.:e:ted is sirzsw iihs same
325 '?'%:€ §{>::::§§3e:r:¥;s azmgxeéi with '$162 «::a:im;3%23§§:':,,;
*.$;'h§<é§: zkm smvs: §f}€'i'f€i}i'€' {E28 §_,€}k22.§72i?i"{EEEi§ zzyaé 2i§é§i§1{f§":E§{1zi§,€€§
f
dosuments, as iihssy are issued ands: {he Rig_.'t_f§ is
Enfermaiion fiat. T »
333 In furl}, the": ciacunaents *i'}:#::.,
::0m§iainant revsal than £116
B.E).A¢ in his latter dateé 2€§;54§2{)(4}AE3A_ h€s¢s
and in SygEQos.'}"? and "F8 to t'1*i's:% 3<é3><'ze:1.'{ €>.;ffV_:;§z:r§§gV1f;'ough 'V
award has been pass€:;§i;..'_bu_iV"}§é;»#=;';;fé§§i._be€1;§vV'i:tiVI%zed and
Gamers Coniinusd to be i':fi% $eri€:s of mates
of the Urban from
N0. 322 aiong with the
325, which is based on
Esfter dé{'£:_$€§. 'mat the peggessiofi ef the
Land 8:11} ré'::2;gL§:'::3 €x;ii€%;.ve:v:1erS. New No. E32 has been
$:gn<.:§{:§.b;§;fl%}":.§ {E:%%:'<E.h3ef ffvfinisier Qharma Singhj inieraiia
=St;%z?,§'::g_ é:V§r1:::*;;"-gr:---.ex€:€n4: sf iazzd measuring 22 gurstas in
Sjgi;Z'€§'3,?":? '?E% E8 <::§rep§€§ frgm azsquésgéééaiz
§r9z:':€€{§;i1?:§s,§ Eva: §ri0z: Eli} '$333, 21953 N<:sJ§iI) shgws mat?
A ..%;f%z§: %*{*.gE--5s:'::r::€n§a:iG:: :3 mafia fa? drapping' 'iih£:~ 8.€:C§'Li§.S§{§{}E1
'-«T«'--p;.;%;g{%s§§§§§13g§&; f€38}3§3if'f§'. :25 S}I'.NGE§,.§;/ 3.; "E, E2,' 2, E2/215:,
=.§:;/E, E3,/2% 8?? 2?'? angi '38 £23 §:»2:i€::*{ <35 3'? &{?§€Ei% 3?
M' (5
5"?-§'?*/f
if file Sueeeeeiaze gevernmenie have
E\.}
N}
and 2?8 alene were sought to be denotifiedg the '
preeeedinge riotee shew thexa some 'eff te;'§1e_,.1a"L:§:i§V' wferev.,
deneiified mueh after the award ,
sueeeseive gevemmemis ei':11e:*"-veiiiéaée néade 3s:1T_;:3i*::1ie§f:t:;:§i er '
have recommended ~E.§;:deV"ie'.»ijje'V "€1e;1<3t;ifieéi 'i1:1Ch}.C3.i':'}g
Sy.Nes.'F"i' and '38. The issued at the
instance of aeef;:Se£a:i:]'Ne.:='1 it refers to the
earlier deeisiefz Government and in
refereneege ;i§';";4'.:i_'$i<::'r«';'..."VVV:'Vivfléappears that, accused.
Neg} hae' of the acquisition ef
Sy.N0§g.?'? af:<;i. {fie extent 0:? 22 guntas and
egeeelftiinlfiy,V"<§e:1etifieefi:§en has been issued on 283.2009.
ihe eempiaini and the material erefiueed
:§':e jr:er::§iainan': himseif, ii reazeaée ihaé, ihe
'L{i_er::e€:Afieaiien greeess fiad eemmended way baek. in 28853
nrzafiie 3
:"eee§:§::1e::{§a:ie":: and 13:: §"L§§'"§h€{'&}fE{3€ :3? ii} ériew ef the
SgI:i€§ if {he aeeuseé. Efiefi 2:: éhe §§ES'i3i'§C€ ef aeeueed; E\§e,4
er aeeueefi 2'~E<:>:*~:~92 :«3;z1:'i 3 aieeé, if 2} §eee:::::1e:z€ia:ée:2 fie made
fie €;e;3::.~'iif3r ihe saziefi iaeds f:'::*:::2 the purvieew ea? aeqszieiiizéém
'Wm
28
it by it.$€if WEI} net ¥:,:€Cc>m€ ar: iflegal €X€'I'C§S€ of power or
ab:/138 of pawer, as the preazisicrzx of Sectian 48 ()f :-..g. f3;.f3:Ci
C{)f}f€FS paw€:* 0:': the ge:)vernment {:0 amp any
the .:=:cqa:§s;i%:§<>::,§ if ths péggsessiagx sf Siéiih
been {aken by §;<3v€r11m€3:3t. 3"h§:¥ §:>y
tbs compiainani. Show that, not @5135
lands was with the f;'V§3 I1~.
government also reca::';:§:enc%6& sf the
very' same land. if thaé: as 1:9 how the
recemméndatigwié':: lma<§_% No.1 for
éenotificatissfi his pewazx
Se$:'§i¢j:{ E3(E)[d} of the Act read
as 1::*;de:;vE:--A " ' V V. % W
":3. '€:rfi'rr:£.::aZ'*. éiiiseandzict by a public
_.§§eV:"::<:£r2£.~"g'*.?_} A pubis}: serzsarzz' is said 552 csmméi
- §?z€:_A~-Qgiééfzcg af ;:*:**:'m:naE mismnducég --
, {<2},
' {5} ;, V'
{CE} ~25 ?j:.--::2. ~
" g'z'}' by CQ§'?"£é§£ :2? ziéiegai mearzs, gbzairzs far
" 1' fiimgegf 0;' fa" any ether person any
aéaiuabie éhingz 9:" paczénizzrgv/g advaniage:
5:'
55:} by Q.bLéS§E"£§ E223 gaasééizgzz as Q pgabiis
sgmarzi, O§3?i£2§?IéS fag" Eiimiseif c:s3"j%3r Q5259!
Sifter §€r::§erz Q3251; :.3s:2:§z,::;:§3§l{5 Ekzzg 9:'
§3£3C?§,§fEE}T£§"§; {;:i::a:2:@§::::' Q?
X »
13%}. 2%iTj§8,
while fielding ojféce as C: public seruegiriig
obéains for any persen arzg a2aZa:;b«ie'~'._
thing or peazzniary advaniage , "
azléi Qublic :n:'<3:'€s:." ~--
{iii}
:35. E\§<3w wha: is requimd :0 bf€' 'S:2'."3éIj1ES.'-._é{$,,'{_QV'§:h€
accused N03 as 3. public: s€1",V§E1i (::i3ta.ifl$%~éE.f§19'hii3:S'eif"u
any valuable thing or pecu:1£*¢:1f:§»adVa:';f§3.ge .=:x7iivh§§fit any
public interest: by '" 3 pubfig
servant obtains for persen any
vaiuabie thing' €31' by Corrupt or
illetgal means? for any ether person
any Va1:2'3"E§Ee :1'-:::ng' Es?' pé€:::-nV:ar§%' 'a'<:iva,nt3.g€.
37¢ E7115 §f:%:if"e .Ci§m p§ai:1i averments and mere
_ ;parti."cg:1'58.;I§7 p:a:§ ;22 vnoniy Shaw that, accusefi N03
'¢::%1*::fi%zVi?v'*§£:i".%§5:'§f:§iE*1«grssugéd No.4 to gaf €236 Earzd purchaséé fig
ifs '%f:_.?§€§é'~»{'21§<:::§5.::é N<:;.2§ made aatcugeég Nari; is make an
a;3;3§§~<:ai§§:~:: 2835 for éer:<>:%iEca:§ez: arid had made
~'««___é;1::,.s1;.z:C'€s_s,§"§;:§ aéiempis an agfcezzné cf stiff §'€ES3S3:3E}{':€ by
A gfficgrs 9% 813.3%. azié iirbazz Q€<s$§:>pm€:::'z Separimémi
A::%{::;;se& *x,x,f§1:i> ::"ie:%:s€:"t€é ::';§§3.:'1
.. §'af{§a:i231 §::€;§:ig§:°€SS ?2:2**:i:g iifiéii jassizgeé E%i:2::*2"§;§"1%j;aa Jagaaihgz
S9. Eigzveafaar, tie carzsiiiizie an effezzcza unfier Seciian
§3(1}{é} 9f the Aei, Whish is 31$ main a}3V&gaiiQ;3i §_f:T. ihe
csmpiaina pririza fcesie the 33?=3}f'II}f:}T§C 3:3. 'ih$;"':::é:;2§iaéi:iig,.
2:633:38, Ehe maifiriai praézzcagi akérzg ._:I:¥g$:. 2
Shaw ihéitg ihers 313 an abyss $1" p;§za?e::f, §jr
ami £33 {:10 the same, the aecéisrgd h:i:s_:§13ta§:2'e*£iE' f:§:: h;§,:::$£3f
3:' far any other person any 'igaecuniazy
advantage; H9wevef;..._.":?:h¢:;e 1' ~-::§§''A:'';:a_i_}aaga*%:Ai0VA:*: in the
camwaint againséi " 'ébtainizzg 3:33;
*»zaj2,1a.b1€L from the aecussd
N<:>s.2 t::>fffi_5, N93 joining the
party hiéadgfi and {hat iiseif is a arakiable
{:Q1";si<:1€;°é§t~i§'13% mileage fer accugeé $39. 3,
sszhefijmts i§1e 'a,£:§;' {}f 3.C:{::3.1$'€{i 2%. 1 amezinis $9 3.3:: abuse sf
' }}£}§E?i:'f?i'; ifgatigh ?;h€""ii.%{3rd "ab:.1se 0f pewer" has 210%: bags
3:%g';e:%€§:::::§§:§;é:*.Sectisiz }3(13{::%3, '£312: ihfi Agax Scarf 2:2 3.
gudgzgzazaz s§e;ma in $13 .z§53 35 E 2 253:; me matter sf
"--._VV'£i§d;3¥:ar£i;gt§§:zc¢r: fiambiar ~e::s« State aj' Keraia, sszhiie
_ ::;i;»3,z13'§é:*$:i::g flag preisiséagg Gf $€€'€fiG:'} E"; sz§£;>~s€::ii@:': {E}
Qifiiégfifi {$3 Qf $233 523% Frgazgzziisri g§ §§§'I"1i§i§§Z} fie: has
" gésazzyaé as zmcigz':
' Bszseispmeizi Azgtfwriig {S::§1"3.},
intended to £::auSe loss to the government! The.-';3ower
undésr Seiction 48 cf ihé L,A'A<::i; Csuld be exerc.i.§é§iV"-'é§?T..ih€
governméni: as bag as p{)SS€3SS§{}I1 9f the 1z:«t:%iS'A§i:é;:»:~"%:3 jt
bear: takfiz by %_:1":<*: g<;>25e1'::::1€r:i.
4}. Howexrerg in E1123 ::.:»;:s4_e§ d<:"C;1::1en§s'g:s:£:$du<:é;d E;=}.f"L,
this semplainafit reveal that, iar:d$ in
questictm continuss 1:0 ':" f.$.§'§1aiFEf'Q§i;'I1€FV it is alga
an avermemji 2:; the buimings are
exiating on As of dextotificatioii,
prime: facié: {he pgssegsien had
possession is with the
€)V\/E161' if has; a power :0 dsnafify 8;
?:and if} th€ b¢f3€f§..§ {sf fiée owns: :16" 3.CCL§S€d No.3" in
"'.,_:_%'hc._;éé4 a::§%:1$3fi' N33 ':33: afiytue sf puyshaser: has
:23: by zitssif arzmuzii :9 329336 Gf pawsz',
if 'iLhé'a<:¥;:,1;.é.'~: }; j_gsaéaasssiirm Gf the 3336 was 1:9? 'iaiiazi, power
'végssgtsii ..2a;i'?;_%:§2€ gfagverzimsné ta dénazify Figrthezg as par
;§%;2,dg:::§:;t 2:}? '$16 figex Cczurt in 'ihsss maiisr 3:." Efigsare
$36337:
€35' (W
M
presumpxtmn of vesting ef 3211161 by virtue ef netifei_e:s.:ion
Llfidéf' Seetier: 15(2) of L.A§Aet is rebuitable
42. }'xC(E(Ji"€§if£g fee the avern1e:1":'i.§: the g%e'fiexV§§§.3iV:e1:;'«.tf;e
preeess Qf denetifieatien started ir§*2Ci'.35; 21r:':i_ '{h.e §>:*"<;{:f>iei;s
government had reeemmenVdeei~..Vfer §e::e::§ie_23t:':.Q'"r:'moi' me-
Iands in question, it iS_I}0€ ele23.r as 'fie heW"i1i1_e eriiereise {)5
power by the accused alguse of power, as
the previous govAernme§i1V_t, }f1wad.v"_e.}e0"'i=ve'eei_t;f§:Vne:1dee} for the
same; The Show that, the
denetifrieatéee Vexereise 9*? power at
there _'fi1Vev»enateriais produced also
ée me": ehe:€2s: of deneiiféeatien sieréieei ali
ef a sueiderikafter. :i;eA:a_,e%::-::sed N03 was swarm in as Chief
iii; :z21'§:;"';;:"<§ees$ had begfir; in ZQQ5 iteeéf, afid
*p:eeVéeuS'~v.,g::.?§.?e3;j:1'::1er:t has issueé fierzetifkaéiéera ef some
e:::€:Ei.se:'--Eafie§::§V;'L:-. V
A T }§G'=.&?€"%f€I'} Whiie C{}§}S§d€1"i§i§ the peiéiiezz eeder
_ f§}eé;:§;.iefz 5335, Cs? C::P,iLZ,) ii; me'; be meeeseezy éfie ge i§i'§T,£.3
V. :?§.§Ee€E:eee {§'éi€S'Ei{>§§S. 35$; 2.":_;::;3:*e<t%z::e iéée :"12:i/zzrgé 23:35: gfaazéigr
" ef file efiezeiife f-:3? :3; éimiiieéji §Lz:'§<>ee; fie iiezééeiéiered. ii
ggé
s"'§'iie*::;
35
is 1201: {he case of the Ce::n1piaina::t that Ei€iCLIS€C£ f'$.€§I-4 'fOf
ihe first timég he had made an 21p;;iiCa.t§%:>f§" '
d<:m>tifi<:ati0:2 after actéiiusegi No.1 wa$._§;wcsfn ii":-£23 V
2vEi::i$t:3r 113:" it afisr é1(3CElS€d E'%o.;'?;'~:a;*r:s;'=sW{}%':"a,E161--.__;:§::;_a
§v'I:;:'1ist€r, but ii is the def"ini§§: e:aS"<;>_ G? {he"§:tQ:jt1p1a§;I1a:::t_ 'L,
himseif than thé prscess sf s1;.i;;1*te<:E way
back in 2095 and he at para;
13 that/, in had forcéé
the Subord:r:a:e":ff;ffi'ce1;3 tr; aven before the
applicant <:0nsid€ra¥:i0n. As
such? ailegatian does moi
xa7arra111:V:"~.';h2;:t be: arrested for ctustzsdiai
imteyrggatiézz," E'ui':h€.2;," ;1i<;';st G2' the €V}:§€I:{Z¥3 is in 1316 fem':
eff d-;§§§§2§:1_:3§:tgx' '~._a::d vars already produssé by ihs
{:.::e:ap1ai;ja.n%, *--..
A L§--a§"a~E2 Qf €326 cempiaimi if ES gtaiefi; '{h&:; it: 3
";fiC%§§§::éJ.{:H_€§~;": dseea ihé acsiissd have alreaéy iizeniiensci
G€}V€§'§:E"i'E€f}'{ had iéesrzaiified 2213533? €:}§'§€Z" NQUEETE
EQSS dzzésggi <'%53g2G§§. '§'E:$se 3fif€?fi3:1€E'}iiS izn§§:::a'I{,§
'".é:§:a§, ii is §";{3§ iiiaé? 313 sf 2: §::5id£;=::": aézéi {E2213 §3£'%.f?5 'éaiizsrz §:§?;{7€
fer denoiifieation by virtiue of accused No} assu:i:if:g""':1is
pesiiien as a Chief MiI1iS§€f. it may b_e"~~ *
de::c:>tifi<:a':é:>n has Come ime e:»;ief;er::?e 3:3.' 11$"ii--%:m;:';*e_=aI';u;i V
S€<3?;§€}I"1 3:8 deee not ggrehfbit V'».:;:;1j~;=
E{€B{)f]:fyifi§ the land, if the .
:19: been taken.
45. Howevezz Que 30 Clear here that,
denetifieatien 13 v_"£V1;§::e[g':'exre1*nr:1eI1t, but
it is being sagci 'i';gWiniSuSed Gr abusgd
fez: the Bu: no such
aiiegafien tie 2;}j);Ve"'..§;e¥nj_pieint, the denaéificatien is
made in i;1_v§3:,::9 e:f»_'ee'=a;i:'ei:* Q? the Eanfi, Hence? prima
faeieg ;:fiee_mate':':fa ?zivaflahie on recerd dsee :10': Show that
file' é:{i:e:i'1~é5e.dx"l'*E§g>e,2 and 3 have CG{};§,':§%'€d with aeeased Na};
§3_:1V{i,eLe feeifgét ef ihe same, denoéifieeiieiz has 'Seen
isetefl; Eféeejivgféenee bfiifig maiaéy "{;Ef):§€§* Seeiien 13{i}{é} 9;?
figetv Aegzd Seefien E219-B ef IFS, even is: ease ef
{§:e::1s§;§§ae§n whefi; £3 :"e:;;:1ire::§ is? {here has is be an
emé Ei.;§f'§€;?E':":€§'§E§ :0 {£0 éiiefggzi iiiiif, eta' 22:1 eef; zvhéee
§EEeg;.:a,§, New 33323:? $3; iiiegézi zziééi éhzzéi fie €?{}§E'}§.1},§f,"§,é?§i§§ 3% m}?
p:>s;eess:ier1.. of ?,FE1e*ee_A§e:§v.§e;:1ci haze. V '
f"°;;,§j
(/"fiio/¢«)M«v
forthcomizzg in the Cempiaini or the 1:1a*:5>ria1§ pmducad
along xadth the Compiaint. Ewan ;:2rirna faitie if it iS.._fGu:1d
that, the pagssssgiorx sf fhé laad fffiffléiifliéfi with é:%ii€.ji:vé:2s3r
amid if pears? ia §-3x(::n:%is.€& uzzgisr Sectéga flit":
crux G'? the matter, that does ng:+f""a~;2:o;i12fi::i;§.§12~1j; b€:'f.3ff3;§3
iiiegai. Even if it is mega}, i:E1a€' a;isg:j' by"'it:ée§f
constituie $211": effence unE€ss~._i'i*~..is svhoWr:.._f33éi: uégiiéh anw'
Qrder is passeé by abussfigg
46. The other asp-:--:C.':j'Vr€q1;:§L§é'§'f'v_£§".33% Censicfared is
{hat accuséé 5:: 23. 'Sitting _:'EiniS:é:*"é1nd it is szgbmittfid
that this acc.:2;S£*c'é.;_:nN0.3"n?i2éy .i__::::duEge in tampering 91? ihe
evic::1e::::};§. __E}ui'§~::;§.._}iE7aé'~:t§ur::~;e- of 33% argurgemisg it wag
su'§mitted"g?tE2ai, ' fii逻-- '§:1':ire matte: £8 Saged on
d0cu,tt;§Té§:é'ar:; E}:/'§!_'};§3§:{E€; E';/iay ha ii, £5 SEER r;>§&n ':9 the
Eméregiégatirzg.Qffiessr :3 Eoak mic: f/ha Qraé evidence anfi
0£j§,€§'~,{:¥i§$§'3-{?€}:;"SE3? 33 £35' 3.3 gamsagg C3? éeneiéficatiafi is
--:e:1<:e§'::§§{i féfimajécie, :1: is on resard. The cs:}m§§a§nani'3
152$':/'aegis §::.i:fEja,I submiés éiiai there mag; :30: b6 any 0:125?
6:75:11 21s:eLt::m/:15; éihai {A1/:«:~::'s»: gm i*::;§§€:3z:*::x ii
*.V:;2E2a!;:§fs; {@933 ii} §.1"1Ep{}:?:2€ «:é<}nc§i§i§<.>:::'aa €19 r€::<:;§;r§€t {he ::<::{:2g$$é
from imierfering with the investigaiiefi anti 3180 gut an
Eermse that they 3h211E net directiy +32" 3i:'1di:*ee::tiy~jisisfezfiitvre
with the énv€$i:gati:>:1 31163 i;amp€:r {hr} €vid€:1<?--g:%§*-
5&7. 2%? tbs same B3118; :i:IiS 3,13; ":i<3'q%1:i«:"éa:3.'~.,':'0..fD€r
miiniiianed thavf, the er1tVir€V.*c::;s€ iS..E:}'as&d1»'<jA:A:. a pf;iv9;:€ ",
complaint fiisé undrer S€C'[iG¥}.'2$.¢?' sf 'Vii 53': that
the Specisd Ceurt had {E16 Special
C0111': has 0:113; feferredu investigation.
SQIIIE times as to whether
the privat/6:' "£0 achieve personal
:.rend€tt:§§":§f ®A:;._Hi5VE:;u1:1i1ia.te the aecuséd of
having é;:-'rVé:g.t€Vd' E21 'this cantsxé, Sectisrz 4338 sf
CrP.C_, <:er1f{:z21'p1Vat~:sA':th2':'§§ marsh: b€C&?.18€f 3 p€rs0r: has
fQe€:.:{ i:1§;d:€ 38 at? 'afisugeé in a Cfifiéé, "E/ha': iiseéf is :19: a
._gra;>é;:"':--1.d "§fffi1"'(j}L'tZ*'i.§§{I':I_} hinz, if $336 accusaiion has bfiiifi mafia
wiififlfirs if£j1};I'i1'}g er humiiiatizzg {E16 apfiigani Q?
' }::av§::g..ifi§:::3 S43 a:"rsse¥;€d 333$ in this sage, ihig Cewré, 3:: $215
..%s.ié:gfe:...&i.5 ac}? fiszzbtiag fies banzsfiéag G? 1}}? 00:1/:§§a§:':s;:2:,
'~ 'Ciié7§:r:p§a§§an*£ has siaigzfi i§'}§fEl, he :5; :5: aacjiaé ::~:@3"k§§ zzzné
§if}'§i':";'€j is géacts E: '§é3f::f,s:*s:: Eh? <'::'::,:§£: 'é'}z£:;£;, %.:§3é: ;3:"5{)§E$ E5":
*5
2% G
wiih €315: §:2Vi!€s3'€iga{:§@§;;
49. Considering £11686 circumstances and theiflzyziure
and graxzfiy cf the accusatian made in the Ci(1*I1"x}Z'}."cji}:.Y."iE fé119ix:iA
{ha zliaiériai produces? by the e::<3r:':piai::2:ni;,h3;v?:~§,:E*:--.A_§1~r€: :':T£::*w¢ '
befare ihe k:e:z€stigai,ing Qfficsr 2:516»é%:;:i:vS':ée1r§:z:s_§'--£b,;i'§35:6
ascused No.3 was the formesr,{Z%1§€f1'VIi§2.§s1:€r,_a:;::EuSed=~<l\3'$*,3
is 3. sitting Minister, a€Cused"'--NE'3--42 is the 'wi_i?3 aE:c:u$ed V
No.3 and accusad i:€<"a L§--§%:vfi2:_an€Af§i"*re'§ideni Qf
Bangalereg nowhere i%1 during the
course if is made that
these "a::é?¢<£%::de;_nts or there is any
histery act. Thsse acaussd
being 3511;' 22. {hers may not be any
gossibiliiyéi' fiévéiviig.'4ifliT:G1T1T%'ifi14€ justiss.
~ F'::**§.§h€:*, «éifiéé «Sear: has is Censifier as is whsthsr
'=.§:*ar%:iv:f:;§=._é;:f§.ii§:i;;>a:¢3:§§f bag 1§fG§,iI§ have any gsrajzzdisiaé
$ff$::_'é §:1_%:§9':$l_§:§i:; filffig §:*:>§e:' 352% 5132 irzvégiigaiion, '$313
:;;:°::::€ §:<5:."$';_E>é<:2"aV rsgisééred 5:: 25.: 1126511 arzfi as ea §Qd.'"3fi
A§S 'a~3'mGsftV mare '$132 {We mgzzths. E: E3 submiited gm:
' « ':%1;f:3s: a{','.{EEiS€fC§_;E:S gmé 'zxslrzsjfz {Easy are: Caiieefl hays beer:
'E'he;*e: is iii}
'fgg.
«*2 13*: M!'
a %
.. . A_é7:::rs:4%,._§ig;3=§§,§<:2::2,? COLEiCE"
42
submission by the {earned Counsel for the Lekaysgktha
'shat, 'Eh€S€ ae:i<::u$ed have not COOp€F8f€d *.=.a?i':*?£""--_£}}€
inxzesiigatiim. 170:' any submissien is mafia Gf--A4's§'ny..fz;;i:é'1:i:§3t V'
is mmper the svidszzcé,
51. if two manths' §im:--:__is a§1*.;{é::¥.y .ti:e '
date Csf registratien 8f the p%'i:?::§i'T in my
Qpinion, if the 2:<:cus€:~:{ :"5::?<3 pFu: V1o'1§4._V:;¢F:~:2:s 1:haAtVih€:y shafl
Cogperate for the :nve;$_tig21}:1( } _r'iV, be granted
antisipatary bgiil: accusad is also
important, Cénstituiien ef india
{<§'.,'fiféV'V4and iiberiy, as éeubt,
M1611 by means sf lawful
detéfiiign, avi:h§iu:A'--:1:':§2L§}ing libarty G5 {:15 accuged afi
caménueé, 1:he:*«s:~ is ac: §'€'£iSG}f: is
Eiberiy 0? an individuai W119 is get €'~f€Z{E
€3{).i;V1i;. {'l"i€§'8;:§%éC§. §&*'?'£G :3 fasifig the igévsgtigatisrz azziy 53:1 {ha
§:2a::~3:;S Sf é.<;:::tz2$ati0::. mafia in 23. pr'i*s:a%:,€ Csmpiaizzi.
' E32» Fiifééééfil I {:23}? refer E9 ihfi ésrdsf {}§ this Gear': in
§Z.:=i:m§z121§ ?6{é"£,§G:§: §¥T<::.§E%4z§~,/2&1} 333:? {fTG§E§":%§Z'f§%3§ gzzeésfii/s:>:*5;
" éiaiaési E%3.Ef%.2{}E 1, :2 {EZESS wizfsrss 123:5 "'~§€jE¥i'}i' 2i%:":{?1§E§§'§ §%§t:,:&L
K' , V %5
€"'§;i1~;€i,
8£C:':1S&{§ is acsuseei No.2.
when he was in the <:>ff:£c:-:3 21$ :5: Chief Minister', 3. spgcific
aiiegation is made th3.t., the accused Na}
pcrwer got me Land deneiéfiéd far moneiary =L%s;j»£1siei;:5fa§:fi:is::
Le, ztsrtaiin am<:>:Vzn't; was passed ::=/af":{;«a {2o;1f;p_}2::é.jg; fix'-.>A:a:éd
by the accuzseé Noel and 1113 {his
having neticaé Sevgral denéL§.fibat.iQhS.3.1:<:1Va,11é.gé;'iia3:?:s of"
alisged Considaaiion a..1}.$ged:Vééwfz-3:56/flehcéfé'*pas§;3::'i 0:1 is
the accused Neal anticipatory
bafi an the grq1;_:j'd.__ the matter of
Siddharam enunciated the
sf:()I}di'€i0 }:3_ ceuid be grantsdg
But i:; .._j:h:s' such allegation Of any
maneiary B@}::i:f:t ::_G f'.'.3;:2f§;w*aiuab1e {kings alleged 'E0 haw:
be€n,._§passeé %i}:1...«e§ihg=:r frczm accussd N93 agd 2 9:'
in view of 131633
Aa3§;e;g2::iofi§5--, §3€CEL1iS€ a privaiia itazzépiaini is filed
agaiigsé ihtséf' §':§i{.:G'§_/§.'§€&§ ii is :33': 3. gi"G1§f1§ :9 géenjz fizéi?
« :§iL:E1{i8,fE£€¥i;i8{§ righi Q5 ggzsszzzzi Eibsfiy. Hsfica I fizzé Ehafg
:1i:;é-».:3::p§§Qa§2§:s C3335 bf? gragteé afziécépaéigry 2383} an
{:V$?f%2::§:§ ssizizéééiisimg. A{t{é<,}r§%::g§§a I §3a$s5 32$ §{3§.§{>¥J§§:;3;;
%% My
K °<*§' .M'""
Théséi petiiéiezzg are afiowed. In the éxferzfégi' Ei.é"'f»i'§'S":,:.€5'E V'
ORDER
tbs pe3iiii{>r:e:*:s -- accused %i5y. j1:Ei'=3. K3;E"E15¥.'{2i}:{Z€i LC}:§§-E3,:s.r'U§<1*£:{'}:E?; F{}§i{E€g B2is:;;;';fi{§:'€: in No.60/2611, ihe P<::I§<:€ é.fter mterrogaiion, the: pe:i*;i:§ners"'S1ia'}E i*:.c§: eniargeti 0:1 bail subjéciz £9 foflewing <:91"1(,*'i'i.{:*.;c':A1':.--§;-. 5} ii} vi} Pe§§}';é:*§; f;e_rs u{,">e}j"Sé>zzaZ bond far as »-."e:A§§_::Ah_i;2i:h two sureiies for :?:;gV {he satisifactfiion of the ; H 'Thég. VS2;«"'L§i£.3f'{§§i». '€:1I?ip€!' {vii}: {he prosecwiien V:52;':2":esss%sk3:§ ifjré E??3Zi€§'"iC1§§ '}"§"ze;:;~..__ }§haE:sj CQ*&p€I'Qi€ and aiiezzd {he V ' ifzgesiégaiigrz as and when {hey are Calieaig iv; QZSG aiiend She sow'? reguiarig as .::-:3._<'§': wfzesrz h€a:":'ng:g 533563 are fmsed G325 Ehgg éiéaii :10: faif 5:2 aéigrzd {he €sZ>LéF'§ a:;2:'Z}2<>ss,§; any vaiid rasasgng ??:€;/V; ;<s§2/ail :29: {f€.?fE'3,??Ei§ 532;; Q£§%:"'?"£€£?§ 'E"§2€{:; 35235 mi}: £€::I.:}€ Z528 {fOi£i"E?;;3"§§ wiéfzezii fhe gréai" ;2e3s"z:::és.%§:f<,>:z {sf £526 ca;z,:*§:. If any 0f the abiéwj <70n<ii*t:«:>:r:s are vi<:>L21i;¢€»::1, the L<3ka};u£:t,he1 Felice are 21?, Eiberty 1:0 approezch the €2<>1;_rt fer C3f}C€'iHE1'{,§€)I1, 015 baii.
KNM/W