Karnataka High Court
The Branch Manager vs Rangayya S/O Venkappa on 23 May, 2012
Author: Subhash B.Adi
Bench: Subhash B.Adi
Ea; 3353 Hisa 592%' 9? §<fi\R?\§,£f§1§x§<fia CERCSE? BENCH EC?' D§~%AR's£'%;'.%B swag T?-£3 THE 23% ms: Q? :~«:;ax 23:2 B§FQRE 'mg HOEWBLE MREUSTECE SUVSAHASH E:;§;:§ij§% % M.F.A.No, 2035242009 (wc) *%». 7 Fv'§FA.CROB '?46[2010 IN MFA%vL.rfm..2o85--2i'2d99'€;v£%C} :vm=.A.No,.2035;12m39('wc) " Z %'§?i'i5CR§§ '?45/'Z010 :4%esi%"rvsF;a_L§vof.i2v9j 3S41%/zsaawc M.F.A.No.2Q_§§3 g2Vo{o9=( %wc1) §v:FA.CRc)B 74fg_L2g1o ;m MFA-Né:;;.2gg§$e09(wcV ,:::;z;;.g6;T.:s;L'g.'2.Qs§;«g';;zLo£:9gwc)E fig Wgéiacfics 7*-@8';';:o1c'1N"r»iF.A N%;9.osk4i2609 WC 5": g, """ 3;:
§§."§:L._A.fa anfiggé/2:306/(wc) & réaa £933 ?49.. :2Q'§._,Q;.¥§I"-fidfifi No,20855 299% sag 35; E giuah §a_;; 2%;:2%§Zi2'§-@§ V E'§"":gzE§%°§ V. 3 " """ "
'é.,%%>é.§TE€:2' §§<:--%3::;: zgxiguaasecg $3.; 2:53,; $55,325:: Rga S'§j:=§AELE?'=§§R,é %<U?¥éé.§f, caeagaaggy, . B?€;;5ES3;-i:??*§;i%§, §'>%fi§1§A€3E§,_, EEVESEGNEEL GFFICE; S??§?£i"Z?%éE%<§; T;3¢$<ZE§§ BELLf%R':'I .m::%>;$§:;,a%2;*§ {figs E"§.?%,:;5:l%iE»€fia2\§ 8 %~x2;:':a§§»§@;:>§.€a;€2;g ;:§\g,} 3} S§.E.;R§;%"'>=a§€3.&"':'"":";-'?-1 S51'; '~§E§'é§<é§7'P§, QGE : 32. ':"EfiaRS§ §CC : EX C§..E§E\§E§\,, ?\§S.?{3.%£ALLE§ SE3? : EELLESRYE
2. SHRLS R.:'5%TNA':"'2';fi 353 S l?E§\§§<§T;3:Rfi:§'fi§x§"Y;%; £85 ; :§\§rP4§'£%»'j;®R; OCC : QWNER Q? VEHECLE N§.§P"2:'T"S528; R/O KANEKAL E53 STAF\E§§ R£'\.3'€IT?$T;5'§; BEST ; EELL§=R"f', {By SrLHA§\£U?v?ANTHAREDDY SflH{jK<&R{ §,D\;":.1"'?*iIT'i'R 1- g'; Q '§:'a:=%;;§;>é':::' §:_'Em§ " " » MFA FELES ws 3&1; SF wéR.;§;vsEs{is..éeMPE§§'S»g:*'r:Q;'xa9Ac?,» "
AQAINST THE 3UDSEVIEI\§T AND QR§'ER *£3T,16§12_;Z{Z*€}-8 $93359 ax; W,C,A.N0.i?G/ZQGE 'SEN T;-«$5 FELE %_Q_§'j'2fH§._:Aa0::~;2V,§§E:cER ma a@MM:ss:@NE§ ma WQvR_K'§vf§E£'$TS _:<::.v:§>.Eé\s~--$A'n@N, 8EL:AR'2"--E QESTRECT BE:_LA§2\:1. ;2a:mR3:':x:§-a:?':;:~€:-.9§s?\;$;:if€:Q:u_.G2': ?\s&2:é,43a/a WITH THE INTEREST at THE ggj'"E.VoF'._13%/o*'P,A;~._' §'<%FA.CROB 7% 2rg%3:'::%T:;:fi MFA é\j<:>"!2$:48$2"'x'Zf;S{§*§WC BETWEEN ' "
3%.: RA§~s%<;;>$35§£';: s,}5c::%:; '<:.E:*::--:?<z5;::?;s; AGE: :33 '{E::fP;3_; c>_C'::; E4>§,'::L;&i:m';3;>g, R/G, P5 :3, H.:;L:;;, _TQ ja 5235?: B3:-__LLAR':'. MCRQSS SSEECTQE $3; Smitéfigfxfiéff§§%%T§;i}5:RE§_§§{.S;%.§~§LfE<éxR; £§':!.} 1§::«::"§ R,fi;?§%;i:%.;.!:%*'5;£: 3;,/::;ai»§g z;§é§;<;:?AR,z:aw;y2',&7 AGE: §V"§.:§3L}<.3';5i} §C{:; G'::"sE?=3§R 3%? L%RR%' §"=~§O.§,:??~2'§if"§'=~S§28; Q./Qg§<fi.§'*a«§E§<§1%.L SLES ST,£\§\é$,, '' {Q.;$§?'%§§?§'§§}?%"§%; Qigé": B§L§.§'é?g"§,
3.
-.."§'§é?_..§R§§%i£E€ aégesaaga, %.;§§'»§E'§'£i'.'§ §§'--é§E§% Ei"--é§%}Rfia%"éCE CQ, %.f°?§,; a"=flH_§E:LaR¥§ %E$?€}§%é§EE:\§"§§ §'~"%?si'a {IQSE FREE Uf§ECxi%1 RQLE 22 Q?' C?C.; A{3'§'aEI'a§S'? '?E"%E 3i3S$?€':E§'§"? ,r5%i\§S S§§ER BATES :5,/12g'28$$ P,éS§EQ E%'\§ §<a§'%§a?afCR,/§?8;'2€}O2 SEE THE FELE 8? THE L§EC}U§: GFFICER AN§ C@§V§%'v§ES§IQNER FQR '%f:5GRE<%'~'EE{'*~§'$ {:€3§"~'?PE§\§Sfi!?IQ§\%; SUE=~BE\;.';YSE@{'»§~ 3, BELiAR':'} ;¥3ART%..';" ALLGWENGTHE £§AI?'*i ?ET§T§Ci\i. PSR £Gfv%PE?éS,fi.§"E§?é Q63 SEEKING Ei\fi=%fia?£§EMEfRF§ Q? C@§v:PE1§§s's;rx?:*:_9'€ag. §v1$.AJ2:o.2985:!2@09 WC EE°;"WEEN -
?HE BR/3x§\§C%% FIEAFQAGER! %.j?'§ITEQ INDIA INSURANCE C3,; §..TD-.,REP,"B'\:"x. .A ' ' BELLARY; NOW R/B SHAELENQRA KU_FV§;£?gR CHAQUEHQRYE BI'\:'ISlQN£\L MANAGER; $IVESIGNAE.€3,FFECE, V SP§,RADi*§E§<!1. TALKEES; EELLARY.
.§,;5X§3PEié..z§\?\§T {E}? §r:.m><:~«@;:a:~e 5 Mszzgaé:a2@§sé;:§_T_::::[%;..,§'¥"
;%::@ A .
s 3 §HRE :~: , MAR:3.A_S:3i_I§EA "SQ i5',.r.;s,ra:'P,::§;;, V _ AGE : 31 YEAP;S,;_».OCC ; E><g:>R:~--v.ER,g ' §\;@¢;<;2'§_:{§A:s£VL3F<;~:.i:§_Q; :
ez§T:;'M'3E::,A}fg>rf.
$.Rfi.T§'{§',%'?':*';$£ 33,53 'if.E§iv§iAT?A§{;;f%M§¥5YA; £85 : §\'§£%£{3E§, Giff: :"'§G7's'¥?¥}'§?,LiR'?C'3F VEEQCLE E'a§SA?%2E=7€'-<VE62S; '§?;;'5,3.V.§<%2~.§'*3EKAL BUS ST§'%§'2§S,,, RI%§">%;Z."°'?'i3T§":3§; SEE? :E5Eé.%.j*x:R':'Z aw ?3LES?€f}§%§3E?\§"?S 55%;:L.§E:.«_%:«§;:as=::§'§s!2§:;*x;i";{%.é§.::2Ea$\: S§z§~§i§§<§%R, A31; FGR R1) §v%?§::2 E'<*:§.4;§::*""5;§ 3&2} §§'~" :ri;'QR%<§'vEE:'\§S C®E%%?Efa%§%.TE$?é As:T,
-_«T'1;«.,.,§£e;;%:%a:g? ?:~gE':.3:._:as:v:§:a§?;' ma QRBER §'§I3.5§.§.2,2§§8 @5333 :52: _ '2A:t:';:;*:,,ms;%::;g_,3.§§'z2:%:';§2 as; ME FILE 8%: 'mg LAEQLER sgaggg :a:a:§ €.:a7;a:a;;v:%§j$§:--';:>§\a§§2$ E§R zyagwgmfig s:§&«€:@§§2s§;3':a;x§,, §E§,é.AE¥i'*:"~«E ?31_3f.§§'E'%'4<;:§C'§'; ggaaagéz ;i%%i'€,5§%Q§i"*a§S £§:»w§§g5g?§@a; G? 2g§§3;@é:;;»« é2:'E"%T,%é.5§'%iE gmgags? AT 'ME 2&3': G? 3.2% 3%, §"4§:A$CRG§ 1?5r§!"201GE§\§ €V'%F.é. §"~§®,2S8El 28$? WC' §E"§'$£;EE?%i SRE §"=L%V§Af7{EB,§SAPPA S/'G S;-1SA??§a,; A§E:32 '¥'E§:RS, GCC: E§{(§RlE:'ER;
R;'O.é<ARIG§x.f'~3L§R VELLAGE; "K2: HQSFET; DES? BELLARK {By $rE'HAN£,§MANTHAREDBY SAHUKAR, f'§§Er';'}4. ,5%§\fD E. SRIEE RATHNAYYA S/Q S.VE{\IvE<§§.T:{§RI3sTV315{'2'Y:5x; V' AGE: MAEQR, OCC: QWNER QF £i'3RéRY ' ~. " ' "
§"~fCkAP=-21f?-=5628, R/O,}_<ANEKA,i....Bj'!JS ETANB RANETHQTHAE SEST: BCVi;i;.%R'{_7 AL THE BRANCH MANAGER; H M LIMITED INDIA E§'e§SURA£'$J m:;_,;' 5 "
§ELiAR'rZ -- , T L _ RES:POI':£§E%'€°%"S §"v'EF§ :*R:<3.B;"'§-=£§;E:21::£.;;iS5::;4_: géai-$.32: Q? 295., §Gé1f'»§$T "mg ELEDSMENT, AN§'V."QR[33ER, Q.f_¥"E_D- 15/i2f'2€3§8 PQSSES EN §<aNaPa/CR;'.,_169f2G.{32**:%'N*?&i§EM'EI'L'E Gt': THE LABDEJR GFFICER ARES €:%C3MMESS1Q%'%éER FCR"2?§i§§gi<_§'4?'E¥f3fS4.5ZQ?'«'EPE§3§S§aTI§?&§; $§.,éB"Q§\z"ES§G§'*»§- ? SE%.ifi:R'Y', "'-QM-'?{TLY' z€xLLi:?W;€§'éGTHE C£.,i'%}fF*~""§ ?E°?'f§'IQ{"if ?§?i at Qgswgmggfzam ;;§as;5 S£i;5'%<:::'~§s'ENH,sx:§£E:¥1E?€T Q?" £Qi"f§?EE\§$§§§"EO§'é ' g ig:§:§§;%%;§3§§«3:?2ae§:@§égc;
8a*%":;'as ~»%".:'s:;~ _ z 'rm '?'%A~%§"'E>Rfli'££:§"§_ ?1'i';5:E1l,§.GE§%3€; §}f'\§'§'7§"E$..__E§"*«é£'%§'k5; EF\§SUR;5.f%§£E {IS 53 R18 .V %'\§§'v¥ 23:/'E§«._S%°§éE§.;E§€E§A §<§.}§'*s'¥§R C§'**§Gi}§H§:§':"' %;7?Ei;'§S§{;":.?.§-'%§';i2E.. §'«"§§a§'é§.G§§,, §§1e"§SEQf'a§.§é. ®FFEC§ 'V V' §§»'%*,.Ré§%駧<A "?Z%i3<EE$; ggaaaay mA;§??E§_%j%§'<-->§"?
V T €343}; "'S%§T.;.;::<:v:Aa% 3 %:;£:xs§x:Q$a§2; £:§'::'.} .§.:.:';*~:*«:'s;::§,'§s1v.;o"ia=;'E:,ff§'::>.?_§; " ~ 2 RI':
2. ;§3§=*§§.§ §-%i"',=§\§§'~é{.JRAI3P,5': SIG §'%'*'§ARE??§;
éfii' : 31 YEQRS, GCC : EXSSAMAL;
?;;'S¥A§v'E%RAPL§R; TQ 8: $13'? : BELLARR 2, EHRLS R£\TNAYY§ S;/O 5 \!EN§<A'TARA§V!AYY,§x; AGE : mjsa; ac: : OWNER QF VEHICLE %\I©.AP~21~T~S628; R/m<ANEé<,m_ BUS sTma_;.,__' _ ' RANETOTA, ms? : BELLARY. ._ ;
{By S§*i§--~§A§\éUMANTHsAREB§Y sAH:sKz:g, A§%::.._%cR Riif} MFA FILES LIES 3Q(1}_OF WQ_RK:MENVS_VCi3§»'1§9'Ef'x§.S!%TZ$i'\i ACT, £GAI%\iST THE JUDGMENT zaim URDER D"4§",15,.3.2§2G€}8 msgga IN 3-ifiV{2€ul&aE\é{}a:E.:?1»ff2£j{32 SN THE .§?E_EA_,E§~.Qi¥'TH'E--;§;;'§.B£?i}R SFFECER gama CQMMISSEQNER FGR WGRKMEN'S'='COP/i.?_E'§*«3Sf§T1.0?~5; BEL%.AR'Y'=«£ DISTRICT BELLARY; AWARDING.:'COF4AP'EN$AT1€;ir{¥i arr Rs§31;1§4/=~ azvzm 'mg ENTERESTZ -,:;':'--THE;RAtE'V.®s.'1'2v%_?,A;§ MFACROB 74::»?29:;'%:§.'i'fd'%%MEAiT%ir;§%;2Q8S3/2009 we ' ' ' ' 'I V ,_ SRE H©N§\:5';:%A::'=PA Ski:%€2§~,¢§R§é'P;:§' _' ' gag : 34 ":"E;5:;RVS,;'$CC,:V E.'¥>2V§¢§l&'!3:'j§_f%'§.--,:=;fi%¢; a,fQ;;asv:AR,a£u,s:}:5§L:VgAG€;g :"<g&_:::$? : §ELL,:i,R':'. HAZRSSS {)§3EC?€3% " 'g.;5§ :;*;;r:§:5%§:a;§}%§2;:§':*;<sV;\a§a$'§ géaasxaa ,é@:z:} §@:§'- _ ' sR';g._s %.;%.f'§%t§;¢s5¥A $553 3. '*sfEf'x§§<g%"f";3x?.,;i'%§*¥§;'5\":":*:»é\; .V ;%§E: §%?§4%§_é$?R; €:3C£': §"x5i§'éER $59': 5,53???' §'»§Q,i%?-'2..f;;"?-E§Z8; g5\j§,§/<Z;'3x§*~§E%<;5>1L 8&3 §Tf€%§§; f:{;¥'€.i?%-§Q?%%&; msé": §E§...L;fiR)"{1 "":V:%:'%:*"%§R;2x::c:--e ?:«*EA.§'€A§ER, . i§?§%§ETEfi i?2i'§§;51H'€§i3§;:§J'~éC§ C3,, i."i"§,;
""8E%..L%RLY, g~_.¢ 7 Q;._R'E!'fi5;"?"f,>:§\ivi§'E¢f%§:'§??g {Es §"«'%FZf% §C;§.{}5 FELES L%;"S££gé~§. RULE 22 §F €93; ,:3:,i.{3£5i§?\§S? THE E{}S'§:"v'§E?'*é"? $sf\§Q GRDER EQTEB §,§,f:2/2§{}8 ?fiSSE_S $3 §<af'€aPa/CR;'1'?3,f29U2 GN TSE FILE GE' THE LAEQUR i3FFICvE}i-ANS CGMMESSISNER FUR W®Ri<Z?~fiEF'§'S {:{H'4PEF'~§S1$\TEQN, SU85{)?\f'E$E'C3Fé~ E; SELLRRY, ?éRT§."r" z*1§LL{}WEé\EGTHE fiifiif'/I ?ET§TZ€}VZ¥§'L.'=FGR CQf'~'IPENS£TE{3§\§ ANS SEEKEN§ E§\§H!3\.f'éCEMENT G? Cé3§?«'3_;PE£'\i;'?%'!§§T§ C3-5?:§§V.' . M;F.A.N0:2G8S4f2009{WC ._ SETWEEN 1 "FIRE E>R§iNCH MANAGER;
SNETED INEIIA INSURANCE C3, L"§£3_,_,f§?f,;'B NOW R/B EHAILENQRA KUMAR CHOU'E%E7ii%R'{, EEEVECEQNAL MQNAEER, QI'JE§SIGE\§,5:.%._f:7F:FICE;., O?P,Rfi;D%€EKs'% TALKEES;
2 v ..EAPPELL,%f\§T 53:; SrE.Lé§<§\%,€aN 5 §xaA.*»:No§§..r:~:2;. g§v.,--;:._=.__ 1539 . .
2. gm: aAsA3P:;i__é;:Q éiAz»1;ii2éii;::, E M35 i_."§-1-.'f_E;3:~§.S; :'»'Ex._%~:AM';aL;a,"
R;@EA,r»4AR,:x§>':3,;;.;, f;f<;I._& ::>;s3f__: §ELLAR'€i rm} 3 R;é.T§\é;'i§:"r",5. EECEEL4'1§'E§'\§'%<§§"if';%€<}3«?¥'%zl:'€Y;§ AGE' : :r:A3<:;:%;% acc _: a2;'2.:=::;E'_;a Q5: vE;~;:C:E :~a;&;::Pw2:w?>»§§';8;.V ;§:s;_;<:Af"§\:E§<,a:. 5:33 gégxaga, 2';2?£;f:T'<;f?z:; ®1$T.__; 8%£_i,5\§":', §E§?§f€§E?§?S /"'"""'v«.
$3?';§.%é;.%f§é§%3LiV%%?§;§%§a%?%%';'%*§;E?$§Y §§'a,%€L§§<<A§,, Agagzg ?"§%:213a F'Ié i.;E$' UfS 3G{§.} Q? '<f\fQR§<§'v'§E§'€S CG?v%?E§'*»§§;§?E§§"*--é ACE ?:?%E'[.}駧%S?¥§E§'2iT ETXREE £Z'IR§ER §";§'.3;€:,?.Z,Z§G8 ?§iS$E§ EEK} "335*-;§;;;'E,§%Qg3'.'?§:,/2f3{}2 8% T§"§E §:§§_E {E55 '?%"iE i.,5sB$U§. {3?':':¥;'E£3i !i'a§'~é9 jC£3?'€?§'v§E$S§@§'s§ER. F933: '*§»!GRE{?:§EE\§'S C§§"«'§;9;E?'§§§3T§ES¥%§! BEiL§R'2;"~§ §}ES?R§C?"B§%":A?;':"} ;%§'3§AR8I?%3G é'fi:3f¥3;§3E§'«éS;3:"§'EC%§'«=§ 3? ?\§§3§_;.1§é;,?'? ' _'a«"€'§"?H E?€'§E§E§T #3,?' "§HE §§f?E S? 22% 9,3 W 'fig Wm» 1% _CQfl?v'§?E?2§*S3'g%?E§§.% ANDA§g;E._§_{E.?'x§ " E§'€§%7A%'%§{ZE{%*'%E§'\§"? G? €{3?'5%?E§'€S;%"?§§?*»E. Efié ?"'§F§gCRQE ?48/Efilifi 33%} F495' f'xi<;:u2§85§ EGGS?' WC} §E?'v'%fEE?'\§ SR} BASAPPA SEQ §,5J"¥'L&??§1;
f3.€3E: 26 YERRS; QCC: E><2HA§'~'§§'L§i.
RXO./QMARAPUQ \;'IL§_;'-ESE;
°:*Q;Q:sT: 8EL:AR':i ,,.£R@§3 eifi§3'Eé;?'%ieéj'*-~~ {By Sré. HANUMANTHAREDDY SAEQQKAR; zxpy, ms V SR1 5 RAE?-%NA'*f'YA 3,/0 3;vEN::;::';:\RA§;:A;m*.a, AGE: EVEAEGR, occ: OWNER SF-LORRY __ ' N©,AP--=21/E35628 R;QgK,A:\zEKAL'5u$ sTA§\s:;:., "
RAN;fTHOT%-Efix, DIST: BE;__;LARY,_.----.-- _ T?-=iE BRAECHiv:AmAGER;"«»%' .. , ugxmsa ENEZA INSURANCE'-CQ_ 'L"f'®g,--=._ _ BELLARYE RESPGNDENTS MFA CRo%B._§:*;;:;;>' :;,}'S;E<:'§'2§iA' 939:5 VQF spa; AQAINST "mg ;:s5<'s§\aEN2j~'";:;m. :iv:,cé':§%}ERT"~§::ATE§ Vmiszzzzzaas 9/ASSED EN §<:aNaPa;c:Rg.;;?2;2ae::'v:'i§m ;:';es:é'--s§s;.4*E__'<3? THE LASQLER GFFECEQ. ma €:@W:%;$$i0:x;:'?E:§L'§::R'2;:C§%:%~<':'»':,_é:*<s----'§tazawgsxéggfigzaa, s:.:5~§:v:s:e§2§~ ggagam ?;:::5zj§f2_:f.,T--A:;C%é;飧N§?:~:E ggwvz ?§?§?;§a§x; 93% 'I ,_ ,3 ,::g.§§r»-43535. , 'J'; W ¢',_ 3?,/}»=>;2 : yyaiéyég 43;"; giggw :*'2aa9%2;c' i§§'E%'%5=§E%':?:§ = "
' '---=*?§-éE §R;3._ffaé?f,'%% ,%*~:;:g;%s§:§Ea, i§E':$§T§Q :':'@§;e':; zagagmagcg gag :i§9,f REE R/3 S§§;5.3LE§"\§SRfi% %<i}§¥'€£%§'<: {Z§€@§.JS§-€§R":", 4 _ "§}'\%'f,§S§57Z?§*§§§,§_ f'¥"§£l¥$é§;S§R; §.?VE§EQ%"~i;'% §?:;5§C§,, €.7j§?'§?[%€';,.§g§§}§r*§'3',i~é,% TQLKEEE, BEL§.fis§;":"L .M$;??§L§,..fis.?~§T 'V ' A $%§e:1£;;<%é;a§2; 5 :a€;a:§é:Q§§,é§; gzmag 3, S§°%R§,S3%%E'--§ARAf¥€ S;/{:3 %€§§:.é§A??A; ESE : 33. YEQRSE GQC : EX ERIVEQ, Rf$.?Bg§*§fi\LLi, TQ & BEST : §ELiAR'{.
SHRES RATNAYYQ. S/'G S \J'ENKAT£\RAMé"§'YA, ;i'«.SE : Mé§QR; GCC : GWNER G? VEHECLE "
NOAP-21«T~S628, RfQ.KANEKAi. BUS STAND,..__ _ R£3§'§§T{:?T§%; DIST : BELLARY, - ' {By S§i.HANU§<4ANTHAREDDY SAHi§¥{_AE§, A$%,,z;.} V' V M?-'.5; ¥ELEi';'> U/S 3€)(:}_GF WO.RK_MEE\:':€_V CQMP'E£\3.SATZQN ACE ,$xGAI§\§ST THE JUDGMENT Aw QRQER' a:>j'..1é».12,2eo8 PA$5E@ EN %*£.C,A3NQ§1?3/ESGE QM THE HLE-.Q:%v%»":':~zE--_:;A8a::uR QFFECER Am a:;'@ME«'::ss:0:x%ER FOR 1/x;oR;<M§N'3';'C©M.9E':'\:§AT:.@m BELLARYQ EESTRICT BELLARY, .cxwARDm's.j'«:fo:v'§.:?':{;\ssAf:':©'r>»i SF Rs.42,2G8/- ¥a;:':'H THE ENTERES37 --;~:a;Tv---':34;Ei;RATEV'V.@F-..::%-RA. EN MFA CROB :fi§,9;f%i2v:::LiV%oM%':r~s '%<»:$#'A m<¢A,*2$355 2009(wc* ;s;::;&:E§rg %%%% SR1: 3:52?-§':ffi2.RA§V1vSf§'v.i%:§U:§G§§'?§A; A555: 24«xf§A§s,; QC£7'Z:'-F;><;--§iifa:{3i§'~*§;fi~Lg52g R;@,9,§E%:';a,._:.%::,,TQ;_ §'ES""§'* _E3E%.LAR%"
"C3833 GE§EC§'§R " 'gay S:;,§§%'g:a:as;é§i%(§;a%s:'*%'%£;ésRE;'2@'s Sfifiéjiiéfig xfixffisij " '%»..__J.,;*;§:::: "
gas? s.R§'a;f;f%é:*x;;z>;*{A $53 S'\f*:7f's§?<§;T;é§;ix%\r'§,$\'{'§"2'l,, __ ;%GE: §'v'§';'3'x;.?QR; QCC: S';?%f§\§E§1 Q? LQQRY §'s--§i§;';'~.'afP~2Ef "E7-T5528 Rg'$,§<z5\,?'a§E§<AL 323$ S"?$s§'x§§; ' .__R;5i.§R§§7é"§'§G'?%§;'% §EST: §Ei.7Lfi§C'§Z . "§':?=EE ER;3J'\éC§-é Eemsséaga ""§.}§\§§?§§ §%¥§§E;i"% E,T"4Si§§fi§'§CE i'{§.§f'§'E,, EEii;i'aR'§, RE§?G§=i8E?'«5§§a 3 2 L; . RE éémss v:">§g::.r§€*%*§ .
ii §"«"iF.5x CRQ5 F3{iEQ i};'§EC,41 RULE 22 S? :wPC;, §.G.é'%i?'~E$T THE 3Ei§:1'3§%"%E:'\}T Afiifi GRSER, B£'¥?E§ :駧2f2%§8 ?§§SED IN %<(a%%§§PafCR,§E?3;'288Z 3% 'EHE FILE G? THE LABOQR QFFECER C@§'i§?v§1SSZi3?=iER FQR '%:'V'GRKf'fEEE"£'S CQMpENS:52T§QN; SiiB=§E'%;'1':§?EC3?a%~ E; SELLAR':i §§:R"f'L':" ALLQWENGTHE CL%I?v"E ?ETETlC}§\§_ §QR §Zi}%"f§PE%\iSfi\TEG£'€ I-ENE} SEE§<I§'%{3 E?§HA?*4CE§'f§E§¥T QF :':SP'«'§PE'?\g?»§_;~':'§:T}fTfC;>'f>\§. ZFHESE FVEFES ANS :*»%m @083 Cgzfaziiiz-2:. {_:.'z'i'~\§}' é:::~;é_ £C®?4ESS:®Ng Wis BAY; THE QQURT §EL1_%.:.'.ERED THE %"C%§.;;LQ*JfE_§\£,G:"_ Junsmefilgf AS éthege appeaig are b'; i:§*'--'1_ei :r:s':;::*:e:;,. _<.,"[E€.Va'%§'é;«=_:ng.%.r2;;:1 t?:@- cemmsn judgmant and _ av\;ardV____? i;:__'é1;f,CA.C~§.R5A§\i§<:}§;,169 53 173/2892 dataé 15;:2;2{}'Q?Qj:::;;":7 %§";~$;f§§'éfj:©f'{"<3mm§ss§{:m€: 5:12;? ':.r'1f@r§<::2'1e§2's Ce:'n§;::e%t.:atiQ:'1,,."E'e»§§éb§;' 2; "Fhe =i'Crc;S3>§'{§'E§eCE§é'§1$"._.2%:e"'v.f§§€d by téwe Ciaimanig seekéag e:f'aV'?5i'é'$*;::;:@.;r"'§1f:.es':é75:§é'"' c,G":"fi5p'en§a_u€E:jEL 3, Thesz~3a%§@e7a%s"'é}r@ §§.:°§':i:t€fi 3:: i322 fQ§§§W§£"E§ %:§i£€S"{'§f3§§ " 'f3§fi:£?s'::%5: *--§f2e Cgmmigsianer was: jazfiifisa' 5:; _ "3;;§§:/ge«,%{;2g:'A'gaéfié ;':s"Q,: 55%? {fig §§C§§€f?€ £3 gravefi " ._ é:»:*$;?":'§?'$§g§'f3"'§é5} ezfffisnse excaaf §s'}*'e§;s:§ Sf§:'f€§??€f?Z' {s3;%:,§:§}. §:2e.f§z€ 512$ ;B@;'§::€ wag firgfiaggfi $€f§i'E 552% {E£§§§§§éaer?"
"gags: a::::@:'d§:%g is iéfie géaimazigg ihégf giiegafi §§":&?;Ti $5:
tééexg were éraveiiéng 8*; 5 vgfaéaie §e§9:'ag§§2g E9 '> '~.;jaé':apas::;€e:";%: $532 is: 5§§@a§ fiéearézzg §%§:3.§%?w2§;'?»§§28 ag iii} aieafies, Ai %b§ij?Z 43$ §.:*::. 3:': acceami 9;? the éreak émsm $3"
{$23 sieeréng, the %«'€§"E§C§€ éamefi §§'°§£§ i"Za%.3S€€:§ at: gczédafzé, in the saisré acciéentg Ehe <:§a%mar:Es sustamed §§'1ji.1§"§€S. £4 '%'"o grave that the aiaémantg were trays!' asehicfég :0 prove that the vehécie méf: vx}i't§'2 . aé+:_ ai?Ca:§.§e:~:f;€:,VV::§'n'g Kid éaéd ' preve that the Ciaimants has 3usta§ne::.i. ihguriesgé;.5'>5"'s%§e;?*. »$§.i@r£~*~ Ceaiies, Ciaimants examéned ?"&'e5.~V::"»tQ gffsfiuceé EX'S2?1 is 9141 Fmm %g the miy doeumenif which is théé :'Vsteg§: €fé'§§j§:iv'§§f..afieged is have fieere maa'e Eef§;:'€:fl_§_he Canianmefitf Eeiéarya r::;<st{é'::f€ia'§ Vto Shaw that any Ca§e $3 :§g%s2':e§*é7é"a'§;A.%%.§%§_siéV':§§;4é eflf.."E?iéfl4ia§ry, which met WES": gr:
gccéfiefit gcaiweai due :3 ?':§S négiégéfiag. it V_¥r':e«:::§-§es7':.,:~: i"s::§ sifizaie '@152 :?:e ¥:G%'Y'§§€§?ES§i§§}§'3 is ,f &;:%,d xaz:Qngf:;%""'é'C€ er: Eh? gjari af téze é?'§3.:"€€" W329 figs ::'a§,;s£?;:f_ $:"Q\§€ §.Z§"§€ w§'@;';gfz2% aci; ;::*.?"§fE',?§ fgcfg i?"%8§"'8 = :?:23:fl%3€ s:;:?§':'%é.V.'%é:3az:é:»3?§a§; fégzsagezfeffi, £5': this aase; m $%:h€%'
--. 'j~...§{;:::m@ni _e_%%:~:€§: E>:.?: $3 §f'§fiL§C€£§ éefsae 'the ?:§f?i?§T?§S$§G§"'%1€i'}, «.*:3§'%':§:;§*':_§§_'%iSe§? zzassagifi 22$? §3§"Q'!f€ flee éC£§t£i';§€§"%§;, :23 eye '%;"=i§§??€S$ $5
----.é§;<a:'2'§%:7&§§, fie §§":§%E§S?E§£??':?;' ma€E;€a§ fig §I3:"G§£.iC€é am C§E«€ $3 '~»..%"'%':g§stE?e5;'i §§§§§"%S{ £328 éréxsea, ever: 33:95? tifiéi {:G§"i'}§"?":§SS§8§"E%§" 4
"*2 M W%'rw Q ' , W» ' j,::»«,.q.
aeftbeué err; meteriei en a"§€G§'§ Ceeeeee hes gévee the finding fee': tee eeeéeeet ée ereveei ewe 'eeéee fee: ifse eieéreegéte gee ieguree is: time seésj eccieeei en; eeceunt ef {ash andj'e.e§§§':;ee: eréeirzg 9:' see eréver, . ' 6 in my epinéee, befere e§ic§%.e%n§":.§:e_ C1§'a§§3¥%:E"§}€":?§'§'Vf2;§:'§'S;¥; there must be a finding that there 2e'es"~ee ees:.T:.;,~£e.::'s:"e:*;:d eceidem: was ease fie the rash 'e~n;:efe»negf§§en%E'ee?-3r%x§'§:3g by the erfver ef the effendEng.%ze.§j7§c§e;' iee--ee.e b..?e :?2e"A<:§'e%e':enie to eiaim cernperssefien frerr: theen7Lefe%ge:~~«.;zi5--€$*-axes er the feeure: ef the eme§e:,{e':*.'««T._ VZ'-- Séjeee fé%2~d_¥.e.§e given ey ewe cemmiseéeneri' 'ee§';2_g"'""%.;2=;:§%:§9é'e'i;;=ii"'esf:y ":evEdence; same is net eeeieinebée, "
7! §"*§G'§%}"€}£€3?} %eemee.{;euese§ fez" the eéeimeeie eebmiie ghee; ee§jee§.ere eV'§3eeQrEefi§f:3: be given ':9 Eeee feriher eeéeeece 'fie geese %i:§%éee.e--:;}:i%:§e:":i eed eegéégeece eee' e§ee eeeéiiemeee fer ee:i*eee%:_e«e*é%'e%§~v?~..__ - " "
8. Ei/E_§;§s€ ieeereei efjeeeee em eeieiiyf E flee eeee %"§';23,?"S " «e::e§er:e§§..f:y eeeée be gieee éte ehe céeimeeee. V' fixeeeeeéegiy, e§§ iéée ee;>ee§e are eeetéy eiéeezeei "flee eeeeeeee geegeeeei eee ezeese fie eeieey eeé: eeéee, 'See maiies is %'E§'?'%§?i'§Z.£*d is the Cammissésréssr far tfzesfi €§"%f;'§L駧";;' is imsééeg' ma €"f§§§§"'§CE Ga ffiiéfé am §E.;§"'i:?"§€f' avEder:€e,,_ if gay, Eeé and gasg aggrssmiaia juégmeni am azgvarfi, CQ§3S€§L}€§'itf';f; the €:*aS$~Ob_§e€tE@ns are H¢@__§jé":'r;§ss,*f;e};:£.?.4 fismgum': in depesit ba fefuyzéeeigs :f§§e'ia§';:.é:§'ia_§§V2.. V *._j3uE&E KN%«w -% ,w»3»% Z3 E¥E§i?'A.2QS52 :8? C Wfxi' Ea/I§§3:,2§S5§fC%§'* :%§E3?:u2G$53f'G9 '§{} MFEL2G855§®§ {EEC} .
GRBER It is stated that at §age~?;~~a.é';d gudgment éated 23'§§2812., in be Sabstfiutefi byE%FA'2G8SSE2§§93 mcardingiyg eff§ce.--;t@ cast-3-§i2--?: §;%':_e saié' '5:v€3:E'%T'€Z3€i§C3f°: is'? the judgmefii;
§&E§;'=_