Karnataka High Court
Gangadhar Sangappa Kalburgi vs The State Of Karnataka on 26 June, 2019
Author: S G Pandit
Bench: S.G. Pandit
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA,
DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 26 T H DAY OF JUNE, 2019
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE S.G. PANDIT
W.P.NOS.112811-113023/2015 (S-R)
BETWEEN:
1. GANGADHAR SANGAPPA KALBURGI
AGE:78 Y EARS,OCC:PENS IONER
R/O:"SWAS THI"
OPP KA TTE MANGALAMMA TEMPLE
LINGARAJ NAGAR (SOUTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T:DHARWAD
2. CHANDRASHEKHAR MARIYAPPA NEELANNAVAR
AGE:63 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER
R/O:"S IVAJRUPA" PLOT NO.9,
LINGARAJ NAGAR (NORTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T:DHARWAD
3. D.H.SHIVAMURTH Y
AGE:76 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER
R/O:NO.8, LINGARAJ NAGAR (NORTH )
HUBBALLI, DIS T:DHARWAD
4. SHIVAPPA BASAVA NNEPPA BARIGIDA D
AGE:87 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.30, ADHYAPAK NAGAR,
NEAR VISHWANA TH MANDIR,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
5. N.S. MUSHANNAVAR
AGE: 67 YEARS OCC: PENSIONER
R/O LINGRAJ NAGAR SOUTH , HUBBA LLI
2
6. SUBHAS HANUMAPPA MULIMANI
AGE: 68 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O:JAMUNA NILA Y
LINGARAJ NAGAR(SOUTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
7. TUKARAM BHOJAPPA MEDIKERI
AGE:64 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O : S REEGANDHA 3516 B/3,
LINGARAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
8. BASALINGAPPA SHIVAPPA AKKI
AGE:66 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O :#22,KALYAN NAGAR,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
9. SHIVAYOGI SHANTAPPA ALAVANDI
AGE:75 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O :PLO T NO.26,
LINGARAJ NAGAR(NORTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
10. HONNAPPA SIDRAMAPPA CHAWDAPUR
AGE:66 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O : LINGARAJ NAGAR(SOUTH),
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
11. MALLAPPA BALAPPA PATIL
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: VIVEK NILAYA,
KLE HOUSING SOCIETY , III S TAGE
MAIN ROAD, LING RAJ NAGAR,
HUBBALLI-31. DIS T: DHARWAD.
12. ELLAPPA VEERSANGAPPA BILEKAL
AGE:76 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.30, LINGARAJ NAGAR(NORTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
13. PARAPPA CHANNABASAPPA CHAVADI
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:# 14, KALYAN NAGAR,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD
3
14. ANANTH SHANKAR PENDSE
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.40,'OMKAR'
LINGARAJ NAGAR(NORTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
15. CHANDRASHEKHAR JAGADEESHASHASTRI
SAVANURMATH
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:71, 'MRITYUNJAYA'
LINGARAJ NAGAR(NORTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
16. BASALINGAPPA KOTRAPPA DAVANGERI
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: HOUSE NO.79,
BASAVESHWAR NA GAR, GOKUL ROAD,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
17. DUNDAYYA CHANABASAYYA TIPPIMA TH
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:#52,'SANKALPA' LINGARAJ NAGAR(SOUTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
18. BASAVARAJ MALAKAPPA MORABAD
AGE: 70 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: CHETAN, NO .34, II MAIN
4TH CROSS, KALA YANAGAR,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
19. LINGANGOUDA GADIGEPPAGOUDA PATIL
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:NO.11,'ANUGRAHA'
SHIGGAON PARK, VIDYANAGAR,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
20. G.B.SALIMA TH
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:BHAIRIDEVAR KOPPA,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD
21. AMBASA HANAMANT PAWAR
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.3- 4/1,
4
10TH AVENUE, NEAR SHREYA PA RK
HUBBALLI, DIS T:DHARWAD.
22. MALAKAJAPPA SIDDAPPA ANEHOSUR
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.30, LINGARAJ NAGAR(SOUTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
23. CHANNABASAYYA GURUSIDDAYYA HIREMATH
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: DOOR NO. 42, GOUDAR ONI,
GULGANJIKOPPA, DHARWAD.
24. SHAIKH ABDUL KA REEM
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:MIG - 319, NA VANAGAR,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
25. SAROJANI PANDURANGI CHAWALAR
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:C-10, APARNA APARTMENTS ,
DESHPANDE NAGAR,
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
26. NARAYAN DEVARA DDI MORAB
AGE:65 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:# 81, LINGARAJ NAGAR(NORTH)
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD.
27. SHARANAPPA VEERAPPA PA TTANSHETTI
AGE:63 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O:17, SHIVAGIRI COLONY ,
GREEN GARDEN LINGARAJ NAGAR(SOUTH)
IS T CROSS, GOKU L ROAD, HUBBALLI
28. DEVANGOUDA CHANABASANAGOUDA PATIL
AGE: 77 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: IIND CROSS, STA TION ROAD,
MALMADDI,DHARWAD.
29. MALLIKARJUN NINGAPPA EDALLI
AGE: 78Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.10, TAPOVAN NAGAR, DHARWAD.
5
30. SHAMSUNDAR JAMES DEODHAR
AGE: 79 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: 'AASHIRWAD' SHANTINAGAR,
MISSION COMPOUND, DHARWAD.
31. RAJASHEKHARAPPA H.
AGE:71 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'BANASHANKARI NILAY ',
NEAR KEB, GAND HI NAGAR EXTENS ION,
KOTTU RU.
32. B. S . SURKOD,
AGE: 77 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O RENUKA EXTENSION
KOTTU RU, BALLARI
33. K. VIRUPAKSHA G OUD
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O A T: PO ; NA VALI
TQ: HUVINHADAGALI, BALLARI
34. T. MALLAPPA
AGE:80 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'PRABHU PRASAD'
RENUKA EXTENSION, KO TTU RU.
35. MRUTHYUNJAYA R.M.
AGE:71 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'SURAGI' NO.4868/121,
III CROSS,V MAIN,B BLOCK
S.S. LAYOUT, DAVANGERE.
36. AYUBKHAN SARAWARKHAN KITTUR
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O:SAUDAGAR CHAWL,
LINE BAZAR, DHARWAD.
37. NARAYNRAO NARASINGRAO SIRMOKADAM
AGE:78 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:T-5, PAVAN ENCLAVE,
STA TION ROAD, MALMADDI, DHARWAD.
38. CHANNAVEERAYYA GURUBASAYYA HIREMATH
AGE:74 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
6
R/O:MIG 318, NA VNAGAR
HUBBALLI, DIS T: DHARWAD
39. VEERSANGAPPA VEERAPPA HEBBALLI
AGE: 80 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: NEAR RAMANGOUDAR HOSPITAL,
MALAPUR ROAD, D HARWAD.
40. SURESH N. ASHAPUTRE
AGE:74 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.34, HUKKERIKAR NAGAR, D HARWAD .
41. MALLAPPA BASAVANT SARAPURE
AGE:73 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.53, MAHANTESH,
SHIVGIRI, DHARWAD.
42. IRAYYA SANGAYYA PUJARI
AGE:74 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'SHRI BASAVKRIPA',
V CROSS, MARA TH A COLONY, DHARWAD.
43. SHRIKANT HANAMANT NEGLUR
AGE: 69 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: MAHANTESH NAGAR,
IS T CROSS, POLICE Q TRS ROAD, DH ARWAD.
44. RAMESH SHRIDHARRAO GODBOLE
AGE: 74 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: KAVEESHWAR BUILDING,
NEAR SHANKAR MATH,
YALAKKI SHETTAR COLONY, DHARWAD.
45. KUTUBUDDIN MARDANSAB KAMMAR
AGE: 70 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O PLOT NO. 54, HANUMANTANAGAR,
NEAR WATER TANK, DHARWAD
46. MADHUKAR BALKRISHNA HOSKERI
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'BANASHANKARI' SANMATI MARG,
DHARWAD.
7
47. DEVANGOUDA BASANGOUDA PATIL
AGE: 84Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: HOUSE NO.4, OLUGOUDAR CHAWL,
RAMNAGAR, DHARWAD.
48. SHIVAJI YALLAPPA HADIMANI
AGE:73 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'SHREEMATA ',
MIG-I-14, GANESHNAGAR,
DANDELI, DIS T U .K
49. MALLIKARJUNSWA MY VEERABHASRAYYA
HIREMATH
AGE: NO.78, CHAITANYA, IS T MAIN,
CHANNABASAWESHWAR NAGAR,
HALIYAL ROAD, DHARWAD.
50. SRINIVAS BANDO JOSHI
AGE:83 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'PADMANILAY ' REDDY COLONY ,
SARASWATPUR, D HARWAD.
51. VIROOPAKSHAYYA RACHAYYA SANGONDIMATH
AGE: 78 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: 'SHIVASHANKAR' SAIDAPUR ROAD,
NEAR OLD DSP OF FICE, DHARWAD.
52. DUSHYANT GOVINDRAO MUTALIK NA DAGOUDA
AGE: 73 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O:'VENKA TADRI', 124,
GANDHI NAGAR, II MAIN ROAD, DHARWAD.
53. CHANDRASEKHARAYYA SHIVAYYA HIREMATH
AGE: 79 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: SHANTESHWAR NAGAR,
AMMINBHAVI, D IST: DHARWAD.
54. SURESH SANNAPPA NAIK
AGE:73 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 309, 'SNEHA KUNJA' III MAIN,
BHARATINAGAR, D HARWAD.
55. ADAPPA SANGAPPA SALANKI
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
8
R/O: 'NISARGA' IIND CROSS,
MALMADDI S TATIO N ROAD, DHARWA D.
56. NARAYAN BHOJAPPA MEDIKERI
AGE:78 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:RAJANI GAND HA, ADARSH NAGAR,
M.VADAGAON, BELAGAVI.
57. MUDAKAPPA RUDRAPPA ULLEGADDI
AGE:76 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: HARSHA, PLOT NO.11,IIND CROSS,
ASHOK NAGAR BELAGAVI.
58. SHRIPAD C. BAGI
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.656, H .D.KUMARSWA MY LAYOUT,
NEAR HANUMAN NAGAR, BAUXITE ROAD,
BELAGAVI.
59. BOODAPPA MALLAPPA HURAKADLI
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:NO.2050/9,A NJAANEYA NAGAR,
M.M.EXTENSION, BELAGAVI.
60. GADIGEPPA SHIVANAPPA KAGADHAL
AGE:65 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:PLOT NO.602/2,BASAVA NILAYA
SECTOR 5, SRINAGAR, BELAGAVI.
61. SMT. A. M. RADHA IPE
AGE:80 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:NO1,SADASHIV NAGAR,
BEHIND BANK OF MAHARASTRA, BELAGAVI.
62. SMT. MADHUMATI M KULKARNI
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O CTS NO. 1554, MADHUVAN,
HINDWADI, BELAG AVI.
63. SMT. VIJAYA RAMCHANDRA DHOPESHWARKAR
AGE:84 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:H.NO .1588, MARUTI GALLI, BELAGAVI.
9
64. BALAPPA ADIVEPPA NAVALGATTI
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.92, SIDDARAMESHWAR KRUPA,
IS T CROSS, RUKMINI NAGAR, M.M . EXTENSION,
BELAGAVI.
65. BASAPPA BALAPPA BANNUR
AGE:79 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:PLOT NO.1989, NANDINI ROAD,
ANAJANEYA NAGAR, M.M. EXTENS ION,
BELAGAVI.
66. DR.SADANAND BASAVANTAPPA MULIMANI
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:URUSHABHA, NO.2081, S ECTOR 9,
RANI CHANNAMMA MARG,
M.M.EXTENSION, BELAGAVI.
67. RAMACHANDRA VAMAN KULKARNI
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: ANAND APARTMENT,
SADASHIV NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
68. SHIVAJI VASUDEO JA THAR
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O:PLOT NO.18, SHRI SAKHI,
JADHAV NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
69. MOHAN BASAVANTAPPA KANAGANNI
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.22, MRITUNJAY NAGAR,
KHANAPUR ROAD, TILAKWADI, BELA GAVI.
70. SMT. KALYANI RAMAKRISHNA RAYKAR
AGE:84 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O:HOSMANI CH AWL, TILAKWADI, BELAGAVI.
71. SURESH NARASING RAO BENGERI
AGE:79 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O:F-1,TRINETRA APARTMENT,58,
SOMWAR PETH, TILKWADI, BELAGAVI.
10
72. BASAVANNI BASAPPA TUKANA TTI
AGE: 71 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.29, DANESHWARI,
LINGARAJ COLONY, GANESHPUR, BELAGAVI.
73. SHANKAR MAHADEV SHIVAPUR
AGE:72YEARS , OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.120, SARAF COLONY,
TILKWADI, BELAGAVI.
74. SHANKAR DUNDAPPA RAGASHETTI
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.298, VINAYAK COLONY,
SHAHU NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
75. KALLAPPA SHANKRAPPA SAVADI
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: LIG 51, UMA SHANKAR SADAN,
OPP:SUPRIYA HOTEL,
MAHANTESH NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
76. VITHAL APPANNA PATIL
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 70/2 'ANAND',
SARASWATI NAGAR,GANESHPUR, BELAGAVI.
77. KALLAPPA NAGAPPA HADAGAL
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PLO T NO.228, NEAR MARUTI M ANDIR,
VINAYAK HOUSING COOP SOCIETY, S AHUNAGAR,
BELAGAVI.
78. RADHESHYAM SHIVADHAR MISHRA
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.315, AYODHYA PALLI,
IIND CROSS, S.P.M . ROAD, BELAGAVI.
79. DR.CHANDRASHEKHAR SHANKRAPPA JIRANKALI
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: SANGAMESHWAR NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
80. MALLIKARJUN SHIVAPUTRAPPA INCH AL
AGE:65 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'SNEHASOUDHA',10TH CROSS,
11
2ND MAIN, SADASHIV NAGAR, BELA GAVI.
81. MRITYUNJAY BASAYYA CHARANTIMATH
AGE:73YEARS , OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:PLOT NO.39, LINGARAJ NAGAR,
GANESHPUR, POS T: H INDALGA, BELAGAVI.
82. A.K. KAMA TE
AGE: 74 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O SHIRNAGAR, M.M. EXTENSION, BELAGAVI.
83. GOPALKRISHNA NARAYAN KULKARNI
AGE:79 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: RADHAKRISHNA , BEHIND DC COMPOUND,
VISHWESHWARAY YA NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
84. SANGAPPA CHANNAPPA TOTAD
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:HOUSE NO.1665, PLO T NO.41,
LINGARAJ COLONY, GANESHPUR,
POST: HINDALGA, BELAGAVI.
85. MOTILAL KRISHNA JI BHANDARE
AGE:83 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:IV CROSS, VIDYANAGAR,
ANGOL, BELAGAVI.
86. TARA CHAND SHARMA
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:950, MAHAVEER NAGQAR,
KHANAPUR ROAD, UDYAMBAG, BELAGAVI.
87. RAMALING MALLAPPA RUDRAPUR
AGE: 70 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O:BOLASHETTI CHAWL, BASAVANAGAR,
BAILHONGAL.
88. GIRIJADHAV PU TTAPPA BELALDAVA R
AGE:66 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:VIDYA CHAETAN,# 254, BUDA,
BEHIND GANESH TEMPLE,
HINDALAGA ROAD, BELAGAVI.
12
89. VEERABASAYYA S. SALIMA TH
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'SHIVAM', PLOT NO.99,
CHANNAMMA HOUSING SOCIETY,
SHRINAGAR, BELA GAVI.
90. KRISHNARADDI G OVINDRADDI MALALI
AGE:65YEARS , OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'SITA' DOUBLE ROAD,
HANUMAN NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
91. RAJENDRA HAVAJI
AGE: 82 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O PLOT NO. 8, CHIDAMBAR NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
92. BASANAIK LINGANAIK KOLLI
AGE:64 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:LIG 44, ASHOK NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
93. DR. A . B. NAIK
AGE: 78 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O FLA T NO. 206, CH INTAMANI PLAZA,
OPP: ASHIRWAD MANGAL KARALYA
ANGOL MAIN ROAD,
TILAKWADI, BELG AVI-06
94. PRAHLAD POTNIS
AGE:79 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:PLOT NO.22, CHIDAMBAR NAGAR,
BELAGAVI.
95. RAMAKRISHNA S. JOSHI
AGE:79 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:#414/8, SAWARKAR ROAD,
TILAKWADI, BELA GAVI.
96. BAPU DHARMENDRA PARMAJ
AGE:78 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'MILI',7TH CROSS,
BHAGYA NAGAR, BELAGAVI.
97. V. N. KULKARNI
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
NO.1, ANUGRAHA APPTS ,
13
BHAGYANAGAR, II CROSS,
TILAKWADI, BELG AVI-6
98. BASAVANNEYYA KALLAYYA KAMBI
AGE: 74 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: 'SHREESHAIL KRUPA '
LAXMI EXTENSION, GOKAK.
99. GURUSIDDAPPA MAHALINGAPPA ANDANI
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: 'PITRUCHHAYA',
PLOT NO.5, WARD NO.16,
KALYANA HOUSING COLONY, GOKAK.
100. MAHABALESHWAR BASAPPA BIKKANNAVAR
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: KALYANA HO USING COLONY, G OKAK.
101. MARUTI GURUSID DAPPA NARASANNAVAR
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: 'BASAVKRUPA'
KALYANA HOUSING COLONY,
BEHIND COURT, GOKAK.
102. BASAGOUDA JOTAGOUDA PATIL
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: PA TIL GALLI,
AT: POS T: KAGWAD, TQ: A THANI.
103. BABASAHEB ANAGOUDA PATIL
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'KEDAR NIVA S'
PATIL GALLI, KAGWAD, TQ: A THANI.
104. APPU ANNU PA TIL
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:A T:POST:KAG WAD, TQ:A THANI.
105. BASANGOUDA NINGAPPA PATIL
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'BASAVA SAD AN',
KAGWAD, TQ: A THANI.
14
106. SATISH VINAYAK PATWARDHAN
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'VINAYAK', SIDDHSHWAR COLONY,
BASAVESHWAR RO AD, KAGWAD, TQ : ATHANI.
107. SHRINIVAS KRISHNA KULKARNI
AGE: 76 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: BEHIND MARUTI TEMPE,
JOSHI GALLI, ILKAL.
108. VEERABHADRAPPA VIRA TAPPA ALEGAVI
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: 'VIJAY', JOS HI GALLI, ILKAL.
109. SANGAPPA RACHAPPA JALIHAL
AGE: 69 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: 'MAHANT NIVAS', JOSHI GALLI, ILKAL.
110. MAHABALESHWAR RUDRAPPA HUKKERI
AGE: 77, OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: ALAMPUR PETH, ILKAL.
111. BHEEMANAGOUDA VEERANAGOUDA PATIL
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: JOSHI GALLI, NEAR BUS S TAND
ILKAL, TQ: HUNGUND, DIS T: BAGALKOT
112. DHULAPPA SIDDAPPA KARADYAL
AGE: 70 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: JOSHI GALLI, NEAR BUS S TAND, ILKAL.
113. VISHWANA TH BANDEPPA KAMATAGI
AGE: 71 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: JOSHI GALLI, NEAR BUS S TAND, ILKAL.
114. VEERABASAPPA SIDDAPPA ANGADI
AGE: 69 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: JOSHI GALLI, NEAR BUS S TAND, ILKAL.
115. HANUMANT BHEEMAPPA MALI
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: JOSHI GALLI, ILKAL.
15
116. HOLEYAPPA SUNKAPPA PUJARI
AGE:72, OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: ALAMPUR PETH, ILKAL.
117. KONAPPA ANKALEPPA BANNETTI
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: 'TARA NILAY A', JOSHI GALLI, ILKAL.
118. DUNDAYYA BASAPRABHAYYA MATHAPATI
AGE: 71 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: 'MAHANTA NILAY',
MAHANT NAGAR, HUNGUND.
119. SIDDAPPA RUKMANNA PANCHAL
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O:#12,VIDYA NAGAR, HUNGUND
120. GADIGEYYA BASAYYA SAVALAGIMATH
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: VIDYA NAGAR, COLLEGE ROAD, HUNGUND
121. REVANAPPA CHANAVEERAPPA HONWAD
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O:C/O: DR. C.R. HONWAD,
BVVS II CR AYURVED COLLEGE, BAGALKOT.
122. NAGAYYA HAMPAYYA HIREMA TH
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: 'VIDYA NAGAR'
CHITWADAGI ROAD, HUNGUND
123. SHIVARAJAPPA SIDRAMAPPA CHIKKAGOUDAR
AGE: 71 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: VIDYA NAGAR, HUNGUND
124. DR.CHANDRASHEKHARGOUD SIDDANGOUD PATIL
AGE:71 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:VENKA TESH NILAYA, NEAR S.B.MATH,
KARIHALLA, BAGALKO T.
125. MAHADEV APPAYY APPA TENGINKAI
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: MALLIKARJU NA NILAYA , 13TH CROSS,
VIDYAGIRI, BAGALKOT.
16
126. SHIVABASAPPA BASAPPA JIGALUR
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:NEAR GADDANKERI CROSS,
GADDANKERI, BAGALKOT.
127. SHASHIDHAR BABASA BAKALE
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:H.NO .101, RA MESHWAR COLONY,
GIRISH NAGAR, JA MAKHANDI.
128. ATA-E- RASOOL DADASAHEB ZARTARGHAR
AGE:71 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:H.NO . 15, KH B COLONY, (VIDYAGIRI)
RAMTIRTH ROAD, JAMAKHANDI.
129. SANGANAGOUDA MALLANAGOUDA BIRADAR
AGE:76 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: SATA TE BANK COLONY ,
GIRISH NAGAR, JA MAKHANDI.
130. DHARMARAO TA TY ASAHEB DESAI
AGE:79 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:PROFESSOR?S COLONY,
GIRISH NAGAR, JA MAKHANDI.
131. KADASHIDHESHWARAYYA SIDHESWARAYYA
KADADEVARMATH
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:MAHAVEER COLONY, KUDACHI ROAD,
JAMAKHANDI.
132. JAGADEESHCHANDRA GURUSIDDAPPA
VALASANG
AGE:65 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO.19, NEAR GLBC QUARTERS ,
ADARSH NAGAR, RAMTEERTH ROAD,
JAMAKHANDI.
133. VEERANAGOUDA LINGANAGOUDA POLICEPATIL
AGE:84 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NO. 175, MIG- I,
SIDDDHALINGA NAGAR, GADAG.
17
134. SHIVAPUTRAPPA S . NESARAIKAR
AGE:84 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:# 171, MIGI, HUDCO COLONY,
SIDDHALINGANAGR, GADAG.
135. BASAYYA SHIVAYYA HIREMA TH
AGE: 74 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: VEERESHWAR NAGAR, IS T CROSS,
MULGUND ROAD, GADAG.
136. CHANNAYYA RACHAYYA HIREMATH
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: SRI GURU KRUPA KUNJA,
PLOT NO. 156/A/2 ADARSHNAGAR, GADAG.
137. AJJAYYA BALAYYA SHIVAYYANAMATH
AGE:71 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: HUBBALLI ROAD, BASTIBAN, LAXMESHWAR.
138. CHANNAPPA V. KERIMANI
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:VINAYAK NAGAR, LAXMESHWAR.
139. RAJASHEKHARGOUDA NAGANGOUDA PATIL
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O:OPPOSITE KSRTC DEPOT,
HUBBALLI ROAD, LAXMESHWAR.
140. RACHOTAPPA BAS APPA BANNUR
AGE: YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O:ISHWAR NAG AR, NEAR PETROL PUMP,
GUDIGERI ROAD, LAXMESHWAR.
141. BASAPPA FAKIRAPPA HASARANI
AGE:76 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O:'GURU KARUNE KRUPA',
INDIRA NAGAR, LAXMESHWAR.
142. MAHADEVAPPA BASAPPA MARLINGANNAVAR
AGE:77 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: VINAYAK NA GAR, LAXMESHWA R
18
143. CHANDRASHEKHARAYYA SHIVAYYA
SALUTAGIMATH
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: SRI SHANKARLING NILAY TEMPLE S TREET,
NEAR PA TRI VANA, SIDDESHWAR NA GAR,
NARARGUND.
144. BASAVARAJA MAHADEVAPPA JABANNAVAR
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:'RENU KA NILA Y',
JAVALI BAZAR, NA RARGUND.
145. SANGAPPA BALAPPA KUS TAGI
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: H.NO.5, SIDD ARTH NAGAR, NARAGUND.
146. BASAPPA SIDDAPPA HANAJI
AGE:66 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'SRI NILAY', NEAR PA TRI VANA,
SIDDESHWAR NAGAR, NARARGUND.
147. N.Y. NAGANAGOUDAR
AGE: 69 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
AT: KAPPALI, POST: SHIROL,
TQ: NARAGUND DIST: GADAG
148. FAKIRAPPA GANGAPPA NAVALGUND
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O:'PUSHPA NILAY'
VIDYA NAGAR, HAVERI
149. BHOJRAJ BASAVAYYA PATIL
AGE: 73 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O : HANSBHAVE III CROSS, ASHWINI NAGAR,
BEHIND GELEYAR BALAGA HIGH SCHOOL,
HAVERI.
150. BASAPPA FAKIRAPPA GUDGUR
AGE: 85 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: V CROSS,B-BLOCK,
BASAVESHWAR NA GAR, HAVERI
151. MAHALINGSWAMY S. KITTU RMATH
AGE: 73 YEARS , O CC: PENS IONER,
19
R/O : IS T MAIN, II CROSS,
ASHWINI NAGAR, HAVERI
152. RUDRAPPA KALLA PPA BELLIGA TTI
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: II CROSS, AS HWINI NAGAR,
BEHIND GELEYAR BALAGA HIGH SCHOOL,
HAVERI.
153. VIRUPAXI CHANNAPPA KORGAL
AGE: 70 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: III MAIN ,II CROSS,
VIDYA NAGAR, A BLOCK, HAVERI.
154. SHIVAPUTRAPPA NAGAPPA KATTIMANI
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: 'SHIVAKRUPA ',
PLOT NO. 18, IS T MAIN, II CROSS,
VIKAS NAGAR, RANEBENNUR.
155. AYYAPPAYYA SIDDAYYA HIREMATH
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: 'CHENNA CH ETRA'
MRITYUNJAY NAGAR, RANEBENNUR.
156. HAROGERE PRU TH VEESA SALANKIM UTT
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O:AKSHAYA, OPP GOVERNMENT PRIMARY
SCHOOL, AMARAVATHI, HOSAPETE
157. T. RAJARAM
AGE: 73 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O VIJAYA VITTH ALA KRUPA,
I MAIN, III CORSS, BASAVESHWAR EXTENSION,
HOSPET, DIS T: BELLARY
158. CHANABASAPPA HOLIYAPPA GUDUGUR
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: NEAR SOCIETY , AMARAVATI, HOSAPETE
159. D. CHANNABASAVANA GOWDA
AGE: 76 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O OPP. AGROGYASWAMY COMPOUND
COLLEGE ROAD, H OSPET, DIS T: BELLARY
20
160. H. CHANNABASAPPA
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O BASAVAGOUDA COMPOUND
OPP. VIRUPAKSHA REDDY ADVOCATES HOUSE,
AMARAVATI, HOSAPETE, BELLARY
161. SAJJAN BASAVARAJ
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:H.NO .119/A,XVIII WARD, MOKA ROAD,
GANDHI NAGAR, BELLARY
162. F. C. HOSUR
AGE: 75 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O 60/4, BASAVA SADANA
KAPPAGAL ROAD, BELLARY
163. V.RUDRAPPA
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'NANDANA' D.NO.72,
II MAIN, II CROSS,
BASAVESHWAR NA GAR, BELLARY
164. CHANDAVARADA NAGABHUSHAN
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O:H.NO .30/5, BEHIND LIONS CLUB,
KAPPAGAL ROAD, GANDHI NAGAR, BELLARY
165. N. RAJASEKHARA
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O H. NO. 109, VIDYAGIRI CLUB ROAD,
BELLARY
166. RUDRAMANI VIRU PAYYA VASTRAD
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: 'CHAITANYA', BEHIND KHB COLONY,
GANDHI NAGAR, BELLARY
167. V. R. MALAGIMANI
AGE: 7O YEARS, O CC: PENS IONER
R/O DOOR NO. 88, II MAIN, III CROS S,
NEARS BMC HOSPITAL,
BASAVESHWARNAGAR, DIS T: BELLARY
21
168. YALAGURESH BASALINGAPPA PA TTA NSHETTI
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
169. HANAMANTH MALASIDDAPPA KADKOL
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
170. BASAVARAJ YASHAWANTGOUDA PATIL
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
171. MALAKAPPA NING APPA WALI
AGE:81 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
172. SOMALING SHIDAGOUDA BIRADAR
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
173. RAJARAM GOVIND RAO PATIL
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
22
174. CHANNAPPA RAYAPPA NAGONI
AGE:78 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
175. BASAVARAJ SIDRA MAPPA MANAGULI
AGE: 71 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
176. ISHWAR SHIDLINGAPPA BIRADAR
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
177. RANGANATH KRIS HNAJI KU LKARNI
AGE:79 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
178. SHANTAVEER SHIVAPPA KABBIN
AGE:81 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
179. SHARANGOUDA SIDDANGOUDA PATIL
AGE:82 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
180. VEERAPPA MALIKARJUNAPPA KUSUR
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
23
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
181. SUMANTH SHANKAREPPA KORI
AGE: 67 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
182. RACHAYYA SIDALINGAYYA HIREMATH
AGE:69 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
183. IRAPPA SHIDRAMAPPA CHANNAPPANAVAR
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
184. SIDDAPPA SHIVAPPA KANAMADI
AGE:80 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
INGRAJ NAGAR, H UBBALLI-580031.
185. SIDRAMAPPA NIMBENAPPA MOTAGI
AGE:82 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
186. BHEEMARAYA IRA PPA BIRADAR
AGE: 70 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
24
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
187. APPASAHEB GURAPPA SUNKAD
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
188. GIRIMALLA SHIVA RAYA KUMBAR
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
189. NANAGOUDA RAMANAGOUDA BIRADAR
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
190. NINGAPPA M. JANAI
AGE:78 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
191. SHRISHAILAPPA GURULINGAPPA IJERI
AGE:80 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
192. VITHAL CHANDRAM PATIL
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
25
193. MALLIKARJUN BAS AVANTAPPA BIRADAR
AGE: 71 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
194. RAMACHANDRA DHARMANNA ARASAGOND
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
195. SURESH DUNDAYYA KARPURMA TH
AGE:70 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
196. B.B.BIRADAR
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
197. VIRUPAKSHAYYA D UNDAYYA VASTRA D
AGE:72 Y EARS, OCC: PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
198. VASANT KALLAPPA HANCHANAL
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
26
199. SHANKARAGOUDA LAKKAPPAGOUDA PATIL
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
200. BAPUGOUDA MALLAPPAGOUDA BIRA DAR
AGE:67 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
201. REVANASIDDAPPA BASALINGAPPA BUDIHAL
AGE:68 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
202. LOKACHANDRAGOUDA BASANAGOUDA PATIL
AGE: 68 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
203. MALLAPPA SADASHIVAPPA KO TLI
AGE: 77 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
204. MALLAPPA SIDDAPPA ACHIGAON
AGE: 69 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
205. SIVBASAPPA GIRIMALLAPPA BHANDARAKAWATHE
AGE: 67 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
27
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
206. BASAWANTAYYA MAHANTAYYA HIREMATH
AGE: 72 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
207. PANDIT SIDDAPPA KANAMADDI
AGE: 67 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
208. IRAPPA BASAPPA UDAPUDI
AGE: 71 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
209. GULAPPA SIDRAMAPPA MAMANI
AGE: 84 YEARS , OCC: PENS IONER
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
210. GURUMURTI CHANAYYA MATH
AGE: 76 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
211. LINGANGOUDA RUDRAGOUDA PATIL
AGE: 77 YEARS , OCC:PENSIONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
28
212. MALLAPPA RYAVA NNA RONYAL
AGE:75 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITYAND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA), LINGRAJ NAGAR,
HUBBALLI-580031.
213. LAKKAPPA MALLAPPA JANAI
AGE:76 Y EARS, OCC:PENS IONER,
R/O: C/O. NORTH KARNATAKA RETIRED
UNIVERSITY AND COLLEGE TEACHERS
ASSOCIATION(NKRUCTA),
LINGRAJ NAGAR, HUBBALLI-580031.
...PETITIONERS
(BY SRI.V.M.SHEELVANT & VINAY S .KOUJALAGI,ADVS.)
AND:
1. THE S TA TE OF KA RNATAKA
REPRESENTED BY THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY
TO TH E GOVERNM ENT MINIS TRY OF HIGHER
EDUCATION, VIDH AN SOUDHA,
BENGALURU-560001.
2. THE DIRECTOR OF COLLEGIA TE EDUCATION
KARNATAKA , SHES HADRI ROAD, BENGALURU-
560001.
3. THE PRINCIPAL ACCOUNTANT GENERAL
KARNATAKA , PARK HOUSE, BENGALURU-560001
...RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI.V.S .KALAS URMATH, HCGP F OR RESPONDENTS )
THESE WRIT PETITIONS ARE FILED UNDER
ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITU TION OF
INDIA PRAYING TO A) QUASH THE GOVERNMENT
ORDER OF 24.07.2015 OF THE KARNATAKA
GOVERNMENT PRODUCED AT ANNEXURE-L. B) DIRECT
THE RESPONDENT STA TE TO RE-COMPUTE FORTH WITH
THE PENSIONS OF THE PETITIONERS EFFECTIVE F ROM
01.01.2006 AS PER THE GUIDELINES IN LETTER DATED
01.07.2010 OF TH E DEPARTMENT O F HIGH EDUCATIO N
HRD MINIS TRY , GOVERNMENT OF INDIA, PRODUCED
AT ANNEXURE-C AND PAY ALL ARREARS AND
CONSEQUENTIAL BENEF ITS EXPED ITIOUSLY.
29
THESE WRIT PETITIONS COMING ON FOR
ORDERS TH IS DAY, THE COU RT MADE THE
FOLLOWING:
ORDER
The petitioners in these writ petitions are before this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying for the following reliefs:
a) Issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or any other appropriate writ, order or direction and quash the Govt. Order bearing No.ED 01 UNE 2012 of 24.07.2015 of the Karnataka Government produced at Annexure-L.
b) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus of any other appropriate writ or order, directing the respondent State to re-compute forthwith the pensions of the petitioners effective from 01.01.2006 as per the guidelines in letter No.15-1/2009-IFD/U II dated 01.07.2010 of the Dept. of High 30 Education HRD Ministry, Govt. of India, produced at Annexure-C.
2. The petitioners are all retired lecturers from the University or aided colleges prior to 01.01.2006. They were working as Principals/Professors/ Selection Grade Lecturers/Readers or as Librarians Selection Grade or as Directors of Physical Education Selection Grade in the Universities or Government or Aided First Grade Colleges in the State of Karnataka. It is stated that, they are all retired on superannuation prior to 01.01.2006. They are seeking revision of pension which was denied to them in pursuance to Government Order dated 24.12.2009. The question involved in these writ petitions were the subject matter of W.P.Nos.775-787 of 2015 and connected matters. The said writ petitions 31 were disposed of on 22.03.2019 with the following observation.
"The pe titio ns are theref ore allo we d. The impugned o rder dated 24.07.2015, issued by the 1st responde nt-S tate Government is here by quashed and se t-as ide. The 1s t respondent S tate Governmen t is hereby d ire cted to pay the pe titio ners the rev is io n of pens ion on the bas is of pay scales in troduced by the Governmen t orde r dated 24.12.2009 w.e.f ., 01.01.2006, along with arre ars of pensio n on that bas is w.e.f ., 01.01.2006 and continue to pay f uture pens ion accord ing ly. In order to d is tr ibute the add itio nal burde n, the S tate may pay the arre ars in 4 equal ins tall men ts of 4 months each, s tar ting f rom 1 s t June, 2019. Ordered Accord ing ly. "
3. The petitioners herein also have called in question the same order dated 24.07.2015, which was called in question in the above referred writ petitions. Under impugned order recommendation of the Karnataka State Higher Education Council recommendation 32 recommending UGC scale pension to lecturers who worked in universities and aided institution retired prior to 01.01.2006, was rejected by the State Government. The said impugned order dated 24.07.2015 has already been quashed by this Court in the above said writ petitions.
4. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners and the learned HCGP would not dispute the fact that the present writ petitions are squarely covered by the decision of this Court cited above.
5. Taking note of the submission of the learned counsel appearing for the parties and on perusal of order dated 22.03.2019 passed in W.P.Nos.775-787 of 2015, I am convinced that the prayer sought in the present writ petitions is squarely covered by the said decision in W.P.Nos.775-787 of 2015. Accordingly, in terms 33 of the order dated 22.03.2019 passed in W.P.Nos.775-787 of 2013, the writ petitions are disposed of.
Sd/-
JUDGE MBS/-