Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Subhash Namdeo Chavan vs All India Radio on 10 June, 2019
COTTE ® ] CHA NG BO4/ 2619 CENTRAL DOMINTE TEE ® TRIBUNAL, OA. 210/00364/2019 Date of decision : June 10, 20189.
Coram: Dr. Bhagwan Sahai, Member (Administrative) R.N. Singh, Member (Judicial).
Subhash Namdeo Chavan, R/o.ChatubaiBhaug, Rupasariya, Chawl No.i, Room No.2, New Ashok Nagar, Kokni Pada, Dahisar (Rast), Mumbai-400 Goes.
k wotistraction ® We:
India Radio, 3 darshan Kendra, Waorli, Mumbai ~ 400 G25. .. applicants.
{ By Advocate Shri Jeo D'Souza }.
Yarsus 1, The Union of India (Through) The Director General, DD, Doordarshan Bhawan, Mandi House, Capernmicus Marg, Rew Delhi - LLG GOL.
9, The Chief Engineer (Civil}, eivil Construction Wing, ALL India Hadis, Seochna Bhawen, , ne :
CO Complex, boont Road, New Delhi - 11o 003.
3. (Ey 4, The Bxeecutive Engi f z Civil coe eeruction.
ALL India Radio, Reordarshan Kendra, Worii, VOLLLL VELL LTLT TUTTLE adhd , ® ® Cas Q t @ Hef % @ end gi Y t C An eee a v 4 ™ 3 bed.
oy wv io Q ei wed . os 2 td » o ual tn Fy & * 4 . . . 7 r a, vee ' £ vy Og OG byt SO G mt Og PD, lee * ad ve fg by os . Lo TS be cry € ah myo ow % ceed Bio £3 @ 43 C3 my a fa 96 3 a a x 43 vm] ot a oped Ty of Ra a < 4 os wd aa wey Oo Soe GeO Be BY me 3 S | w "4 a: ct a "3 gC GOO Bie M4 eet et re wD 6 @ gn A Den & 44 2.5 Po mage o a cs o © RS B20 Ge 8 o,% & wa oe pa get ~ A, MQ Indy MI nd AR mie at ry md & 0 3 Gon & Bo we GB» BR Bg O ord Go a B a med ww hg ® mS TRA ah neg a wo PRS ~ Oa 'd 0 Om Bort i ong mo ¢§ Sea # tn Je
i) ® dA be cd ™ "a a wa ¢ At sp g, 0 S&S a mM fy Oo "9 Ce oy ee 4 C5 ry Te Pot .lga Tet x a2 ° 5 Et oe B on Bing POT Be Sw ix a wed a mS ny ' ba in od j Pe ORY mag SS OES Cy sy a 44 4 a Bat 8 * ty ed Th mG . 4 ; ie 3 ye ogee ta Ky eG i ort thee Kw emt ER Ey. ee M hea , og « 8 et veed oa . , 1 3 aot st 4 3 ood a ry oD 42 a 3 fx "4 eat be o 6B : ce i wet pag ES ' % < @ ' ao ow so go ms yg A RE eg ga 18
- mo a - 44 a ; oo Ed a SH ® Kes ved ab SOK # coe ol & - o so he 66 4 2a) MOM Og ag 8 oe wed " BR TB At, 4 OY Re OB Be OR et rh a o o uy ~" Mo A 6, Oy Boy moos fy Me be Ol ms < 6 2 or Ge mR EO Sg Be! mis rt x hi es ™ ao, ED gg FO ' b e i oi 6 @ © a et B eq Oy my 3; 8 iy "m4 ' ; x je ¢ Pod ; wd G S in rest . gs a 4 bed ae 4 . 2 4 ; fs on % . tom! : Sp eee ee ie alg - 6 8 B&B a & 2 88 Beea"s - ' Choe + t 3 G a ied = os RO a mS ogra "Ey a iN oa we m% e x nea Sh CE pe ES 5 "ey 4 mt aps wD a a wy ' . oe vi on oy ' 5S 45°. @ os; i og ni ded aS a @ > org £3 wy Hy Om & 4; dhoas | wa * pan s 4 . soft 4 o> Bag Gy As Es team , om , em oe © O we OTS OE moo ES OS Me a 7h TS : : m3 ce i 5 (th od a os ted BORD tt Cad os ae 4 eo mS % as ©, on deat 3) ee bg TS ™~ Uy 52, a oo a oa WO bd EE om OD aa mg A : as 4 cas mg & tag ay GS sagt 3 Ot at oa "en 5 ea co i ; oot thes oS Me ® a ae OOS ay fy ; Foon ~ ' . ny Ext mp. C3 os fy 3 3 $ BG ot A 4 wy eh 3 mop oO, i ved Ebved bh | rr . a DB nn ae as OS Oo FD he 54 OD 3 t x3 em) a a soy Dh Be Ly nf ae % cq | o a] a wy 4 . to : eso Oo | go wa . ona fo we ch % a neo ory AY tr scrgoe} Oy Oy AD . @ ££ a Ba ao Go ort sy wm oF OM ED MD oe mes a4 Peal £ + * ; .
Cy oe ~ 2 c o 2 © SS ee eS 7 ng ua tf art BB Oe fod po 3 2 ok Covi Coo Oo et 9 ord sn oe nm "o o4 6A on ned as em Bi (2 sf fn Bo a m iv Present.
i k Cyaan follow p one Jane the , iD a 4 Set ES 6 tony yp ' c ea & 6 wet ct ' t ms go 2 CG G2 = HB oe 6 4 x
- 13 ww of ae at 4H ad ' a aah fet a 4 ay . nw 1% *. ord * et vr & yO S it KG " ¢ oot a wp 9 Fs me 8 ww BF oy ved we ghs ' 5 hg $y on [se Gol ae t eS wrt a ns fs ch S oo a 9 8 8 Bag & & Cnr. er Boo fw e & 6 on ha ty os a " oy & go 7% = vA ee ' a + < Oh we m= 8 S$ «6 FS 4 | 8 % 2 6 & Oo & mo ot me Oe Coot 8 " SC = o 5 5 SE Si on Bae © BR OM Q eS : 2 Go 8 fs ss o + < ce} Bo RE ey 4 me op 4 G 3 i om a a Me eB ee Rborg tg ced t to A " if im we a : a * ie 5 Gt oo uy tS om a & m A a) & vod % a aa! i a i e ee mM "SO op © Se om 44 i ! ' on] us ' 4 ba 3 mas 2 a © moe oR aos S 9 & BS eG "OE a. 6 a " ~ ae Gg oh Qi crt ag wd rt OS a @ 4 ~ i ot wy i on meee SB © Ba a 9 S Be Go yg ke e vipat ae a! on wee Of) Da be, fon it cd a vA 4 a 5 eS " a aa fig AQ sep DY 1 Os a i ke a wr wo 43 o . Gt ay a $3 ae eof 6 7 ye So sy eo g @ 8 ret Moy ag q Be Hh @ a G 4a ™ ed . oy 4 & a 6 & % PS oe et oe Lj Som g Ay GQ fp oP wg & gg 9 & o 8 mp HG 4 Cy ; 2 OM bee + ' ws Lf % 4 ay t 4 ey iG foes 5 42 " Ad ' oct G 44 aw ~ hs e a a vw c a aM 3B my "rf Boe as woo, 8 $3 ma 5 PP Cry Ao et a : Soy Bg ' co wm ot a 4 % ga w ryt GS a G Ou 2 os Bg BY Bo > a BO ee i BOG nO OE Be ns a Ae = 4 "BS a4 t ~ fe Og Boo e 4 3 OR oon BG a5 Goenmonm Bo x na Oo ge c @ i Gg i & a ry Bs Bott Oy a A a Oy ah 3 rae) ras) Th rao Eni Me oy ot bs hence a oeg td = Hos niet woe ay a oe 3 i Ca wg i et . & BO 8 & wy Po » og "OS Bo Tog 9S. 9h 228 3 a 8 op © & & 3 4 8 HS 9 3s OR ee Bia Boag Ee os 8 oe @ o 3S fs foe OS a a ag : r eal : fas 4 ' an a " * Pn tied my w a re MAG fh n a vat 3 & ee 4 oy 3 o , ay 6 (> Tgp oe For en. . ~ Omeh * werd tad? rae on ca A ¢ SO wri Me moa & , es G& 2 om est ~ SG 4 6 oy me he Oey weed Me QD rine bs. i mm Os oa jd oS 4 me 4 ; cams ; 43 i a zg ' od 52 oo a OD ny ars we OL D 2 x ot 3 + , . ' 4 G ta Of eS 43 a es { @ mS "a . ~ 609 HER ay ¢ 8 ¢ 'O48 oS a4 8 " F 8 4 & 3 6256 Baa ¢ 89° & OD f @ wo OS G # & woe : os S c 4 ros a1 ay ok wn, nt ¥ . é oe tical e ie 8 8 re SB OC Bw BS Son BS ui v a iw moo 3 ry ag :
S SRT @ ae we WOO atom € @ 8 & i eo Of mS, Mt Eves BABAS2 yg Oo 8 u FE 2 @ © & a & hoa C3 @) bt 4 3 he hed th om te Se at im 43 3 "tS pee & ss « o 4 2 % a ma ki Gos 6 mw i o wt #3 o 3 Hy 43 " go 2 ae a ay Oy mS @ word Bey ara np Bay Meg " ' me me me $3 . ia ond S aN = OR Ok GO) fe bre : 5 ou bei Bog DOU Ba mF Ooty sry my eh fey e 2 9 BY eo f2 2 2 4 a 2 GG @ 7 a GS RB 2 @ 3s wm A e UN sO og. 4 Ox a a eh a 0 @ x i. a4 ae Oo fr Gg 8 @ * ;
Y W ar & a e eS ae 3 Cc im oo Ao od ies es Be it C3 4.08 Se U iD He GO " 0 "et ° ~ ee te enn mo vot o ag - ia mo i LD hy. AD Ge EE Gh ody ey Goo os A MM os % " me Me ~ od 4 Of oO) Doris @ & O Ray OG %& < po se m4 . ad a sa) : A tet SEE cr Sy & 9S 2 G 5 tea o pooet sot wD 4 <7) & mp KS ce RS at a tt Gt me f w $4 ' @ Ww ds ce Bay i & % pee @ oe Q ory nae @ rot Cy % ed ne an o oN ty a iS Yi
4 Bo SR rt oS Qe Ua By Oy Of ww O . ' Wt t 1 re ae ¥ o 2 Ob woop BR me ne SY Bog © y £2 fg em Ant hod it we a) oy 43 : 1 HO S Raat cy be a "et Ny 4 eS cs a ee ®. Om Oy 4 2G eg 3 be op OS oon % iy bs nt fs e @ 4 eG uy es am 3 A 0 es me wy o . 3 YK m fh te th 4 a Oy * "4 "4 : ny rd) tak 6 Og, 8 > ty 0S $4 ho id i e in gee Coots ioe y . MEL gs me c : a @ co hd y | tad Bey Ky ga, tag 3 hy ie) da Me 2G m4 2 7 at oe) ie ih 0) % al ay ! 5 Pe 43 we) ry 0 oO, ; o 5 3 wd © ; Fe poy we a} of iy G & 4 pe . 4 a ' mt eg he Pes te rood ao & eo MM ms on w w@ a eo ky oy red 54) a, 4, + 3 ° 5 3 @ a a wv on $3 a ae mt = cool ae Th a 3 as ish cs) "tf Be 3S og f ££ & a Li we PB GB Bm a eg eB © i beg i an i) 4st th it : a oi fy Shot a a Qo, a > ae : he y ro ct ih a a : eq Ot ATH wy a Bde U3 By o nn) ra By \w Oo cr ne: ™ 0 oi BS iS & G B a se os Racer C4 Beh a, = to % seed iB 4.3 ia es) i eo Po yg a mS 3 4 sR gh me Son EG © oy 4 eo ae x ms ey OO ge Dt 43 40 ted Me i o me a I by nee 4 pM Bose aa ay ED. sy o CG QD Ad ot ae ah a ted Ee tt ~ my ® > . 4 42 oa i ven £3 i fey by 4D wa SE OOS OB ay co TH os TS (4 4 ; 0 oo i) Be ba yt nm oe omy B 43 Ey Be ee & 5) cg 43 : * fxs a coh 188 Sersp seg BQ Gorm Of oy wet 5 j Q : Oy, as SS ott 4 Ow x 5 Ut Ty rg pe 2 red 2 at bet et CG 9 mM 2 to ba ( Ep ag oF i th My 8S Bs 5 ny 3 on & en OM: wr SB OO Gt tty OO * og, a fat 5 to me UE, PR tt & OO Ae yg BA oss o ad Q $ pee . o oO bog y i} oy uh a o os G3 @ ' ca @ bf 43 YB 3 7 M vet u Ch, ma Gs: w a 4 Gj G @ oe ' i ee a fs Me G We ard mee M . eh aa) YG Qo 4 in & wf an s as S iD g wy Laney "S Ms ec
a) 9 m $ Coy Mm '© af Sy mee "4 ¢ ' wd a ae CaS ms Sag e fF g@ 4 & a é ad ' a mt oD oy us - ry 4 Cs on & bas aa ms Boy ww : os oP & 4 M4 x Zo oy, ey wey Oe $4 mo ® ar 7 a ae " ed be ed : HG = om vr 43 i i Pi i 7 Soe nad wy a4 teen pe = Gy cet oA en ek i eG =, a Ot te oS DF Wee em Oe my ty ms w " mot al " 3 fa APOE 3 y sed EB bd vi ee ee eee 43 % S. NA * tN ord a8 nS SB a YW Th oy oo & eg + . * , my oS hy a Of my ae @ + = © an % ken d yt, , { z « ty 4 my be 3 gost = 80°] B oe 26 ® § se a am ss a 4 2 i nom 4 Se ni 'D we . eb ed me aro mM oe yp % os 4 4 be i ms be 7 og 3 . 4 a AS a é ra uw s Ong ™ Sa a a re IR gS oo ba a fea 5 5 a oe 5 oH rt = ears} ; ny OD y * " ¢ Ct bed "as S 6 3 ao B Bw Ns th 43 oo 8 go x , we vot "S. ts Y G ES oh tr AQ oh wt ge a 4 ng a (5 oe ax 5 S 4 a oH gM = es Sim 8 oF 2 ba a} G ~ © cy 7. 5h ma 5 Ro Be mt yo oy ee HS rt Wy G Ao ~ = ii as , OS ony , % 3 a ™ es > we o #8 _ 8 ® ' a L, 2 C3 hy hey ag ee Cyd mo Ss 3 eed © eh, te no 3 ~ Be ord oy : o @ ~ Ee ome "wo Ge Viens 2 og a Be "
SC sa Ug cs AG re % ts 3 ay : % oy 2 "
i cS Mey m 3 in "a a © o te Gh aS wD Ca Ns oom 4 1D i mt Sy se} s - aé ed ae eo ry o 4 w GS ad @ a tet * a As Ea ot cof ms ro ep ; ot a @ fei ay fo "ON ay Roa ns a uy Oe * a w & Ba ei iad Cy ma Re ven, OE me hay i tet D "ne AS ef a) + ie an no Es ey et BB ped i) oR tr +S e Ad a " 0) te aera re OE et be My won e obs wt 3) & G np ey ns op mt ee = H od ay :
ich hy m fy e oO, Q c % as 2 ey Ee sh, gf ' hat hm @ a Q fe = rd 60 43 o z A th hy ae J ow + 45 aon beg oC be . OR > fel " $3 ed ma yo Meg ves oS Ee ma ay a . os ee S OU wo AG . 5 So 9 ee ON ~ ha ae 44 ve * ¢ 4 4 . 2 aad ry o GO se 6 " % o c + pe 122 XZ :
pm a so con 3 ?3
Bhawan;
=> Ro Badal 3 Soaocchna GAOL 3 a as 4a Gy a iS ii my 4h vu ee THD % ey - , # ts yy ns, a Atal 4 os ' Sey 7 + cs a . { YB GE Gao Gh GOL @ Tae Zz a6 & oe ee we as eR 2 Se a O 5 Moda eS 4 woe co hd te "E Hag DE of + Ma a om % +3 9 . & ' MS ky * yy Be : nf a OR Bd 6OG Ste fe "oo & @ 3 fe o oS a) yS ee ry aD hy ef OO gee G a be] inst a vege TFG eq AS o cy cS me nS oo to SG ig QW = og "4 i sed ip Sod ee oe db ny ct nw] ot syed sis} ory m4 4 7B Ss TO ay ane os " wy in oy, Ph py tea Foy ee ad ea 23 S OD OB ss 25 OO aos Se a % Gry TU :
wy o Be Os Ee ey oo a fs wo Se ty > OD my te ae ne SF pg on Me OS, Do Sie m bed) By ed % ps 3 = eS Bp at 23 eT oe eS aN BR a §s 6 So _ Sed uy wn a GM mie Q oe Mos ory 4 tna x MER Mg ory a ¢ Bie | mM i Copy mot 8 Sy at A hom a oe NY Sosy " bey Neh SI a ead gee % 4 mg .Y . Beg we, , OG ves a fe os 63 BS 1 4 is m et @ S "4 3 me hey oy . re ay j ie & fend me . st M ed - - * es evel fs egos § it ao. a RO SY tom ee O38 ge 4, sy 4; RN ee 5 re - 7 ~ sys ~ TS op mE Bg Dy YS oy oy Meo ty by '@ et ogy oa oe ae £3 os go Se oP BR gt ne ny O 2 O's ~ sf te. iM a ny Ry 5 - vet 3 4 Ab os ' rea] : $ th, mk og am £3 AS Tw OS veg eet eee shed me 5 a aS keg m ay 3 Se RA ot a Sak AN =S aF Of gS ne "oe tion Be y Ty " aa > 7 5 mm ~ i omy gs 63 vr wee . i * 5 or ied SB ie Ay 4° © < 5 oS nae vt tof ES a QS 4 BY $4 BY v eC BO SY @ OS. 6k | m SA 8 Sy oy Be Ceo yee us G i Q ae 0 e Oo ts mn Bs Ob 4 uv * fd Dy Q Om rest Mad Ma gy Mh . ~ oe oe ta we (nt B wo fy g sg c oa <8 a ke Bee af ~ Ro oS te om, + 3 rs fs ) ab he wep . 2 7 BES u lou i Bg, a mee © MS fox re, € coe C3 bo beng pn GB " cr, vis ht oy 6. * ' "geef my nr C! tT Son ep A Cp Q 3 ree ao ey: yy OM fa; "PE GD ca ted , oom Gop' aogo" se £8 ¢ oc3 ebay 5 \ reg 4.4 fork TD Trg eat oa, ret "ed Mamet wang ce yh sped Chey t G O98 Bo re So.ee Sead re Wy Ad ke Daan ® ai ie S| ma ; OO Ro @ Sky wy a aoe @ hy Ney ky ty ES Ay ot Sd My oe ee oOo ea 2 & 2M "sy 2 ty OB Myo wrod ee: Pe a PS Sa ard & che ve Na rng s ho Gx wd ° try kg bg CS OY OD 4 ht 2 Ae Se es fe NB tp oy ER ye Ey "a bry w~ 3 sano ny Mag ees o a ps bbend oy x t DvD & Mi w :
ct ~e-t xo ot G a x cs " ao cs 'OG 44 oS . OG rd @ ca Coy > Oo ty ee or by me oo . ans ¢ ms os «SAD a bea a rye a mm ad Q bah XY ot 2 ° x g cy oc @g oma te GO & ri aH Sy * = : Mg 45 x os os w * oO a e Cs ved wh, 43 y Bey ae EF z a - i GQ Pee =) fo bef mS, * <p u m om, mh NS " es, i es a ae MS me. eS OF OQ wt "4 S © ve "E aay te. 4 ol et wd ¥ 4st eo et; * sph Ped ved ; ~ ry 4 cent tens " se O . @B o + § m G3 43 2 4 o4 a mt ad AT it - wou, be wm th De ts : O , @ a o wd mo wy u ORT ig % £ yey YD % oy hes ; . . ~ os MY soond a fred $3 + ad > > 4. 4 ' a 4 © &% " iy rs a f y 40 "ed wy , oy 45 Ge + ay Soy & mit 7 n 4 srt EN om 4 GO. 4 O aa GO a e "Ae od 0 a o M4 G oO a S| hy by US ny ay oA s,m a + a " a ae w Sy, " a Mong 0) ms cy a a, ra ee "A * 4 'a ct . ~~ O a m4 42 5 watt 44 tay wy Oe y% Gy £4 aa] g a oy oo . e a} : Q wd ge te by ta 1g * a a4 By, fet ae 4 a é 2 8 8 a 3g ao a mh fos Go fe Sm 6B mo s "a 4s at nn, PI Soy 1 oF c teed 4 58 a rg o a so i > ; Pa OS a Oo 0 w 0 i Ad > Ah = ee ay oo ) XN] EX "he ey ky Me om Ao Sy 43 fyb a G : " C3 i Be % a bey , fp , a rot "rd ae wt eaneniaan sy @ os a beh ent Ba ay iat 4g det of ood xs ra a EG Ns beg ae As gy, ts 6 0 o 6 oj a oD cS fej Sk Go Mey ht Ly wae sed bl , i : & oy ae yp de edt ~-- S 'ha we TP AO o i od as) at re ie ft ms tra Xd iy " fx wn » qs ns a hy a i bee ey & C3 i © ce ot *~ SPY aman TS & to wh a wB J @ * a3 4 ov arp te Or one Ste * by att Cy a v & Co Ob te Be em tog SS O : a 43 be ws TS +h 0 ran Nee OF Booed Goi. ae od ed bed oe : CO} ent went A a at Gi dn' = ce H on wd Aa et we ee $304 F3 yong ONE t Me 53 ant a Qo ah na ry 45 08 GS oe tp co Se, . "t = ie A rpg 3 ty, be M inc 3 ha he FS in te or EO ope og haere 3 nT Q x * it " eo 43 &% @ 4 arenes = Beg ey $3 SS ' Fig) & oe oan: sep eH gy et * i MA OR OY 4a MM cy + "4 a "eof UY may met + hag hed Bey fp 84 Ned ei vA 6 dei es _ te $y St ty C3 ba Boa SS t a a} a Ear dee + . ¢ we My seg Ai Ba ty - x 2 ~ o4 Sa ke "+y x rf a hed 0 an ~ a C4 Too o, oe p cH "3 coq oe TE a pt . on as fy me Pag a 4 oa np ted hd £3 aS) $y a wes B i xo Cs é S oot nt A 4 i OS kay ity BO a " i " "es Fi Ext GS eed Pept g. "x QE a ros oe Ay wped ¢ ve * 4 ™ Oy oh iH SB rd 4s 2 * u © 3 4 Q Bad eg fey 4 Ew "ey @ Q 8 5S € 8B eee SSB BR mr Rho ky sory ut 43 be A mn D Abode a - oy a tA if mh Or 43 Mb 43 eh a Rey ty a fy hp 2 Guy oe ont bi & ;
SS $y 1 DD my Dy % ba gular the re ea resoondent s: 7 © a a 2.5 bl 42 mt "ag a on oa aida wm .
apee é ny got ym AQ , '4 * ~ " ¢ om Sr see . iy Gop THE ME a dQ oo ve be OBE ge iy a ro Uy Hee Se hog oa Sy ue ee % he + he poise rs G io & ae A yy Go 2 Ph & ny a ey woe eae SS me S ¢ 8 Weng bray py ae a Se 5 eft Q f 2 ~% ot ot he fg omed ey oD ; 2 oa ion ha & 6 Bee B : a mo = aa & . on Sh Me 4a 43 Ay oy ~ qo Oo 3 ® oy RR gt Sieg sch ON gs ie o . aM MOS i uo trl mB Af AB Epes Sa ~ ie ° rf, A Roe eg oo * i i) eG vei es eo SE RS 4 m Ry % ng ee o ae es Wn OG oe 4.5 wee Ey Oe BOM gw 6 Fay @ Be OP SB gw we ON seq EP A AG wm tye a BM mw i pee OS, moe Oy RON, a nt 5 RE oy ar iy 1 Ba wd i thy Gore bs ks mp ON ek , ve & te Ge mi O ow G 3 ° 1 wong 4 - Cy Cy bn 79) ted uy yee . Bom. % / ra t. roy t a oe nr Q A by ¢ +4 op ® Be oe " n EM Ee ng ad "ag Om 2% a Sy a f "2 oF aad SOM ag BP ag a 2 3 vs i ss 3 = ine ha oo re « pepe tid oe "sy * . we dood c a ~ we Hes ay rd mS <<, in, ®) oe Cy By tf ut » CP ba & pba 3 be cy &> 54 ted o nO" % ey Qa 3 ts ; e Oo oy am Hog BR OM AA 83 2 'a Sagn a FD a car eG ty GH tag Wo oI OS fey veg of fod : % 44 M Lt Pom} Mt tad , 5 i hy ¢ uy oe ty * woe, ¥ os % ee "et . mt Bay eH & oar wy Ge cy wy BE OM ay oo ob ! . won ys Me £ wm BS (, ace ty my 4g a ¢ TA, ved 6 % bes 2 Bd OM my aor Sy tet 4 i! "
fy TR OM By psy by OD Lag raed wo dd hg Sy we oy 3 a og 4 43 4 ; Pat 3 cz we oe Os + "et nS 4 So ogc of net UY £ ot Gini ew Fa 1G 4 fi Ga © mw @ ay , ira te o a Tt KE feng Ss ,. @ Oo p Boa E Se OS Bora my i A is Shy SS Foo 'Soe ese = OG Ua ow 2G e oF oo oy 8 Ba 4 BRON ow Be 4 * ep a Al om hy we EO mo , ® 45 TPR tS rs Ap @ 4.3 nt "be . ' om ces : 1 oY Gos bet 3 oe : ny4 tet at aa roy pm ; ba 4 4 % + Spe ote , . ty yee e sea by G Inova @ & tho 43 oy ae > @ G 2 fxd "ey ced my ty be ' os im a "
Gp Seq ed OR ND yo as oF oe Oem wet KY Oy 4 Ott © OO 4 & « 3 w Cy by ER ted RY ed oe 5 6 So Goo Ow y 3 mS mh By Rd cs 2 < * rp ' C; RG 2 eae ts 4 oO Re a $4 aw 9 8S. ES es & 3 A ey mE OG HF zy Ent mm O. Oy Ge mod er AL 7 REO Oe fa, oy Oe coo mm Om Ss moa Byrd {SE 6482 Seon hy 6 ow moor C o ; we he CH OQeae Goa mE O & 3 a7 © wo os 3 GA Na. 36472019 the respondents about regularization of his service.
10. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, we are of the view that if the OA is disposed of even at this stage without issuing a oO > co je 2 i ¢ Q et tot a © ry is ry 3 Q oe ch, w& we.
ne ft ct.
jons to the respondents ta rey) in the matter with direct i Sete take a final decision int@eesy matter by passing a reasoned and speaking order, no prejudice is likely ii. In view of the afor resald the OA is disposed with directions that the Competent Authe rd Lty under the respondents shall take a decision with regard to the request of the apelicant for regularization anda other consequential benefits keeping in view the letters referred herein above by passing a reasansed me ct a ° and speaking order within three months from the ds ef receipt of certified copy of this order. ts.
12. No order as to cos % cn Rows ey (rR. N.\ Singh) (Or. Bhagwan Sahai) - Member (3) Member {A} Vv.
<P?
¢ Y