Karnataka High Court
Ramu Basappa Jamakhandi And Naik vs Maruti Ram Naik on 22 June, 2012
Author: K.Bhakthavatsala
Bench: K.Bhakthavatsala
?§€E QQEEQ? {ff}?
Cigifiééj? §E:"£C%§ XE" Sflsigiglféii Sfifiifi '%"%-€33 'mg ms»; gajsszg, 2:32; §E§'~'C3?"<E Tag §~é€3§\é"Eé.E mg }LES?E{Z'E K? a:es§T&7;%:'§4:~é;Ax;A"::g;é;;;2_ Rsgaaag §Eii}§':§§ gxfiégazu E'~é€f1%_,??"3_8i2iES 2;~ Rgmu Saaagga §ar2*:a%<§:§:i:%:"~%%5' Age §§ yearsg §§CCZ a§5é:::a;?:uz"8~T. ' __ Rfe Kudaaééig "%"ai Ra.iui2a§; '_ AV . 3 " '..,{5a;':g;f>}§§%a;*%%:
gay ;a;';j:;. _ age 54 ;!%&~--*s;%<>:::'i* Q A §;;?:'; §<:,;::%Q?"s%;~T§E;
M) M W"
Z23 "(Z3 "F5:
. £11.; _ < "13 :31;
£1' 1";
wk} MW 5 rd U3 "V sf "é'«%i§;:::s*€$e§°:§§:§ 5:»; $3:
??'é8 Rgéttsag. ; L §3..,E:S§<3?%é;§8fi§i§ T {Sig S%*%;€":;:§k.,fia§"wf£&:2§§:€a:?2; iiaéxa $4 "
K8; ;%d%2:g'§§§§<, AQA fsr S333 and $6} "3233 Rfié £3 fiéecé urééer S:=3{:*EE:::ar: 1% G? juégment &f":C1 C§€C%'"€€ Ggaeé {>}E".2i'G{":s_2 R;;~'x.§*é©;28f2G3§ an téég aée of the am: wig?' :%_é3.m';- dismisaiag {£23 33993: fifiiffi :§§é§§r§*;:é::g__ E Géiree Céaéezj 2§,4J§§ gasseé Ea +'iT%;§_.! og2€';'% $33 iiaédig £§'sf§§ Eagdgeg }:".é§:':, ' '":"%*s§$ REA g Sgiéverésd 'she ésfiswéag: " ' '~ % T333 :*_g%__jé wage? Saciéen ESQ aha ::::::;r%:3 §;eéa'«%s;x;,-
"3:
-«if 9,:
{T1, =33 7% ,3) 3:15 , v (E?
W;
("D Q} ix") W'?
2??) W T33 <2) 7553 $113.
6 Z"3
I "V U":
'WA <""'f' if} m Q} m 6 2 c R ?'§'E%v:::§f:e?' 3:1? ?'§f$§}{?%°T.§€E§§i §€1'3l§:.:§jV§%'% am: 6; as §€'§€?'¥fi£%.?"'§;S : gm §fi'§"%f:; §m«%z;§2§<: E"
M3 :3 as . 33.1?
NJ {I3 M51.
'aéeaz %'»'Euns%%'f 5': Qaibag agamsé: :37§%?e;'2é:a:§fi:'§ E me §apa.s':3g C@m§':':é5§%::%§2es"
G%C§a%"§i§Q§"% 'fiat the g3§aé§zi:%§§3 9?"i}§E?i'y' RS 9:39.338 3§% i§i}§":§ZEiS gmé: §<?'2€3%§'"E:E E aw/as 35 gm' §'?§'£§_T"3§ garfecied '$3 fir >:;gf'a;séi:5r$"és[.gfissseggéorz am Sazgghé': ée? §3€§:'§?'fza:'{§'éE§'§ . {E393 @e:=.§a.:?::z fismmésséeggé '.:_f?a;':a_s%%:é';2~%"-- égatsrfeéna :mi%:?: téeé §%a§fit§:"f"g éngeymeni Q? ifiiésg 233%':
1%3€§%:'3?§§"%xsmE':é'éé*%g 55:5: §'*"E5§"§5:f§€x?a 9a'§"5§SS§§}§ 23312855 $3 §4:fi§~2 W .5
:":§aT':€«<::§:§ Rfiii e»<3;<:%:r5:£%: iasag, §??§§§?';§{}E"¥ *%:;::e:~< <1» CI") §'€%i.%i§:a§ €'a!§fiE'.z'E€E:' :zx:;§§ aédzsiéd by ti: 1 7 fa TEES ":';r§&§ €:{}i.if'§ fa? $519 %'€a$€}f"%S }:'z,i§§?E'1€§E§; €:§e:::"eeé 'E226 33%: as ;vr&;s&@fl;*i3:i"
5; 3:3 case sf the r§v3é«..;:%a§:ré;,;§2€i :3 ti"
,0?) , F3 sosgassicm es' 5 §¢'jE"€$ an tééa sfiiareg 33 .« gggniag aegrfiég S';f.§"'§{};33V8';'~.V: §f; is iha: éééeréa §§'§:"
Qiéieé §';€i"Si3§'2$ 2:": §c%:.::ai Q@:r~::§=;s';:...[§e;:' '£,%_§'E{§ :3? géifferarzi >2 §.1Z1%'3:"E%i:'}§":S :3? 23%..S3a_?sEV<*:;'§§i2$""§'%é::;a@s 5%:
S::n;é:=;m ?'fié,§Ei", ' 5' V +§%s;v::_:% C§§§§é"é§:*"%§ :;>w':fée:'M3%":1;:é"-- %:*:tér%3 Sam %;h$r€f:>%":'"s2 mi agiéiésé is §é§{§§§"?"%@f°"E§ am * iaéaé i"j<:>::;*%; eféé ':Z?"2€ aggsésai ??§€f§§$f§, §¢§&E%5é:%:;m:§% bs3%@w aéifé %:?a§ r::a'::é**:' 3:; $273 £3? E':
',/A C§§§§':'2§:"'E%: £5 $95333 {€35 {:€}U?i Cééaéésmggémg €328 jagfigmamé am §€C$'€%i§ :3? ihé $023653 %:2e%{:aa:v, 6 iéameaié {:@%__3!'1SE§ fa" regggnzjavig 1 1:5} %§§%§;[email protected]%§'.
gufigmegzi 522$ §§iI£"€€ 5% we firgi a§§'*,;=?3~%§ei:_%?;< ::sgg€%fA';a;:*:
sams ages mi 5,33% fife: in%:§3r§€§ésL4§2%i'e E32 %;E'*:'§&2 Sm, gs? §QCL%:?'§3GE_"_}iS @132: sf E1? :;@"a.§-33' ihg ms besariézg §'}fL§'\§{3g333 $5; :%ée3 fix: aggaiéaégé Qjsazéé E E3 gaézfiéiixdd aw: §:j=i:e::;s::a§ ?§%EE:§§E§" zsggfis 5:}"::§:§:"§::§ i'§':€ §§:;:::a%:--:%§s£:$ 'Céfiéiééi §":':a§§ :3 $:,:%,>:";§§s%<"::r: giamg %:%':g%:
gzseferégé 3:: ggmai E3g:§§?'i§£ 'E figpafigise gexrammegxt mg §!'Ef€%'T€€j 3;3;:s§a% ag"a;»g5:%:*:.§%;
am siecsee :2? 2%':
C0§"':S§@€f the feiiawiség aasbgégzgfiiai '%i§a;e giisisgar
3."
wk"
§ (T) :2: 2 aégag Eéégf Cezmi E55': 53:} maéeriaé was Q§§€€§ as éagsfezss K./k rig? Cgmi.
egrse
8. Ga 2?§G8f2Q{§2 Secgmcé é»:::;x;vi"A gm iéze %:a<3- the aggeai 7;;{%'2%5é:f:V;»'_?'2e :@gi%:§%@:s§'V'€:£i§V%:£s§:§::3?%:":§f:~§V%;'§*2§é"ssééssvsgré€:""§mv%s%@:2:» G? *5 :2"?
«:3 C231,': £%:es' gécsasxger is} give §:a;:::%:
&§§§§"%S': am; ::§e£:*e§?
Eéggéfig §e*s,:'z*€2§a3é::';:*":'~--:®@ ;3E ':i£§:e':%:i:~:§ ij %:§*z§: 2:? .«:'E§§3§§§"'?"§Z 32% in ;:;:,>§§e£;§§::m :3? §2<::r%:%$§': £3? E acrése £35 3:31:
;§§"G§;§8§"ij3! wéwea it $3 $9e:::é'%<:3%%y §Z?E§'{ $23 W53 3 $5: §£fvS€8§S§Ej3:'"é amen fie w§§ 525:}: mafia Q A ..
9 in view 9? arguments a§»$re:g'gx%§ §g;._i'é":é"§f~3a§§%::3éi;_' av =;:G:,s§:$e§ f6?' we pariéegg 3: greiéiarj {:2 *:>3§<::a 3 Sagbséaniéai €.'gL§€Si§§?'ES sf iaw E:;§€5:h_§9' 15,} £3: Ezhe x:%:'3,s 0:23:53? m';;:*3;ifVVb<é3.._%*::»é"aé:%':.:r:eé iéaaé éam' C3?
(13 {3} :3 Mi» Mi} U":
Mi L22 M} aw} Q3 Pb £3 '.0 L 2"' "33 LC} kw mi) {3} L 1 "Y {D U'?
Smaie at ir<:,§j%{:Ei%~""">1§%§g§'§'é'E, 'h'<;"::;'.'§C;%§§§;_,-§éV"v,i§'?é G§'}1iE§'%"§?"?'%%é"'s{:Z "§"%*:€ §;:';;:2a§§a§z§§:*§:§5iT' sfééiézflbei" a:>§*' if§§';CéE?T%€§'*2'%:$ S§§€f:1;':f 'éfaai he ss:s'g«i..§£é...§..:-Ea €~:-'F'{§S'}.?§"%"1§E'"':"{ 53:? E gwes; G? §5%'E§ {:«:;%:V_::2§ '£323 Eawj %::§::€<::r::§5 1:5; iéae §:séé"§ "" %.:%':§3 §3{"2'£8?§E:"%'é@3fl§ $3 3323 gzgigé G5 32% 5:535:35 is wk gs? :<"*":* ;~ 4% fa .. . ; , ' 2 3 ..»» . Q gggriag és?em::m:
?"'""f F Y":35:
'23.?
U) Q U3 £"""Y"
Ch} 6"?"
51:?
Cl 6"?' 13"
'Li?
I' 7*"
J V:
<33"
3% ;;e?g@n§ age :.s:2§:;%;?:{:;:é3§@ @<::z:::§;3a':%@r: :3? 3% iaééaf $5: {:{:i§:$*{%C:?': gm t%2€%g uaauihggézeé me cirmmsigaéegg E: weuié wee: i§":€ §:§.s%E'%»:é §é':"'éf.§j:é3Ii.T_' Em A §%3§§ET'3E3§":i éféfi fiagree 9*?' $38 *3 CC 23:3 :%2s maiier ramétieé ac: ihe triaé Vibe acasrdaresg W§i§": igaxv. %3:.:~.s 3 %:s:;:
;.%.'«»..»u.£ ,a.~.«»-«""' 'E-ii: :A:%%:§: Eazsza 5%: %§§?§:€:i%?;§ ta: §Q§Z?§§?' Ea ii} Eafsre the ma? éiaufi: Leg; Qézsii 3L%G€§§i::§i.£?§§O§' {'}%a;i5%$r':};
Raifiagi Gm 32,13?/'2G*E.2 E3? §'E,i%'i?EE? greggééirzgs netice, EEC: 533:5;
We :*§g§§:;"y $5 directéé ii: ?e:ur:é'».::%?s:3"L£§:R