Karnataka High Court
A G Shivakumar vs State Of Karnataka And Others on 29 October, 2010
Author: B.S.Patil
Bench: B.S.Patil
EN THE E-iifiiwi CQEFRT GE?' §{AR§§fiJE'fi§§§ QERCEIIT Rfiffifiii AT EK&RWA§ wgma fimxg THE 29% BAX' ax? asmggxg BEFS RE 'mg §<I§E§'BLE Z\«'IR.JL§S"I'ICE g.$.$m#:*::7g'~.V V 'WRIT pmmgzg gm. :53e:5;2§.is;§j.s§§§;§f§3§§».=.._ .,__ ' EETWEEN:
M3. gazvaxzimag S,!{}. A. *";"'i;rPP;2a;rs;I\€»A<;<3§3'§:_A AGE: 32 '::'EflRS, am: ADV{"}CA*'"i'E, r R50; MAIN, 4%--i {3R{)SE%i~, ._ '-
msgxzggfiwag NAGAR, T V V BEST: §E§i..AR'£L - ?E'i'§'1'I@NER gm' SRL safiggfit }%3§@§--*XA;E§§, ,§;::;2x;?§ A1533:
3. €~3TA.'§'E '£>F"KA§€?§A'E'_§%KA;~ "
DER-%;13;'§'§éEEE\E'}f <2?-"_ 45._4i{%,i'E?z"F'-'i".;"3_";';:E..JTSr:'*E{.:%E_:
A§\§:§. :{U:\z§A?;_§{Z£1-E'§'§'Ss.§3§;PART§v:EN'§", VE};'s_§.}~§£';£W; $<:=:;'m§A, """
§\;>, . }E,3Y_VE7E'$ SECRETARY {ABZ?I--§}' " §'%*.}-:«?:v"m%§_;az~s §}iE:'i:'E';§,s;j>?Fv§§<Z'?€'E' Azm PARL.{_;'\.Zi}£EN?5%R'§ ;%§'E<";§£E€S ""v'§}Z'z}§A.§'iA -%:1<3'wa%~gg, Sg%§'%€§%.f~2L:;{}REZ;
4' 'A:;:é'éE.*;4::fé:fi"~; Cififvfix/i§§:%Si<I}E'€i%:iR, '- _ ' 'E:a:m,w5', V' 5333?: BELLAE"":'. ( ' , §E$§®?€§E§*§'§§ '= :§€3:'§ 33%; Kg. '%§§§§;§:;g?§§? gag;
Em) Tfifi§§Rfi7PE?fi¥3NESE§LEDEflQER;%§fi€LES22é Afii} 22? <3? EEQE {E)NSE1TLfifi{H€ GE'EN§fiA§ ?RfiE?N£E'F§ QUASH€%$:NQTfi§CA?KN§D£?EB2¥?42S§Q?ASSE§E§'R3 vfix:A§NExvRE1JE?c¢ 1 V ?Hm§?EH?Kw¢c@MHx;@N:KMeaRB$Rg¢§§:EA§,% TEE C{}UR'? Es/iA§E THE F{'.}LL{.3WEN{}:
aggga _W_ '§h€ Sher: questierz that arigég féyr.'c€§';1s:'dé}:'aii§L:: ":':1.*f;; this '2,->z£ri: petition is w§':&t19;_eE*~._¥:hé*-:'1g€:if§ii.83:é§::--..Wziaiefi;v L' 233.29% issusé fig? €E':__€ *3E8;E;3...:r'£§V5§jf1fI1€:I§5i-.T%3J§J§§€d?a1K:'§'f1g the prezfiemg {I1.G§§fiCaE3:G§'.T1' §%_S§i'€.@é'§f».i whereurzder éiée Servics Sf ':§*_:::§ 4__pet.%iié'f:é::f Bisfiiééct Gflvfiffimfifii fieadar ;:9;::?;:: téljba é5:i:3t§I:2.'§ied '§%; ':*'é' periafi af threa ysairg 9:"
zrsntié §13.3:"fi3.€:r«. arc§ev:*5:Afl,s§T'é_.i_ieg;a} amé ma: the peiéitiarmr is e1'1:i't§€CE_ 2:9 {i{3*1:>fi"§1_'€1'z.f;'i%V.;%S 1:43. flistrict G:;>vsrnn':5r:t Piaadeét 2,;-».'E'E<2$ 12n.&:'$'§3"ifiec§ §a,c"£:s area "she gaeiitiamer was a§;pf:}é:i§@df"<.g3;$'v ;:«.f§_§5i:'éc%; Qeafernmeni fieaéér at geéiargy fa}: a 336: 31:5 9&7 jgaarg by 3:: Q1"&€"§' sfgazad 23$ 3;.iZ?;®§é, Ths ""'4«.;_5§,I_:'*a_"§1§<32i Q? Sz§.3f§¢3§I1'{§':{1€§EE same :8 an 333$ ::;r';. 2%}; 3.=2®%C%§« %§'::%.a:;'%%:fz.i=:f, 9:': Ears raaggegi made bf; ihfi psiiiésnsr safikémg $x_:'r§:'::r':$;'m2 §f 3237:; §<~3§é:;2e:§3 ;'%.s:?;§::i:<:,a:'§+¥2 agiéfiaatésm was 'A A n ~,,=£>""¢&' .~ : _.,r-
>9 :3 ' 2?
'M A "£332,256 by thss §é3'J€E"E'Efl'E€fl{ extandiag the gszéad 91? ha apgsinimeni fair 3 §§Z;.E"*E§'§€Ii° geaisd sf thrfie }»'€a::°$ o:ii_1,m%:i1 furéhey Qrders, whi€';':€s.-vs: was eariier. 8}: ye*::f"a::'_:j'e::fé}f:Ve:' rzaiificatéam issued an 2S~»3.201@$ the Sxafiie.-- '€§}afaz§:*:§;fié}:r1--?s: hag witlrgdrawré ths natificaiian d;1i:'é:E--3..E-g2€§fE{} vs:x.'és:z2igiifig ihé pariafi of apgemtment sf thé:';?s_€?:--%:§'@r:€:E' §S~.a~.§3:?;é'i:;rj§:~§_ €:m,«'er:m1ez:t Qieaflsgz ,1%qg:°isve*d; "izfir fine':Q§:i§é¢a*i§s19i'":$$:;1€dVV an 25,3,2®1@3 the pyesegfi '\:*'~,-*:'7%Aw:""p5<ifi':'§:é$":"";A.31S f§E€éd:;"
3. Learnefl {:0un$é_1 ,i?5<:>¥i°'v 'ii-§:<::fé?'vAA.§;%é_i;'_§*{ic;:'1s:' péacing rééianecs an S£;s:§::¥';£f?%.§ff§7'e {6} £2?
vi-?"2.:};€ '.§."'af the Karrzaiiaiéia Law Gffi<:e:rS':.,{I/51--;3poi:*i:':1"*:.¢'n%; "23:.;7i'c§._ Candéiééarzs cf Service} 'Ruieg '§9?"?', ceéiigfzésViZ%f;éu?;« t--1':$'---Sia%re Gaverzamezzt couéfi :20? haw isguadfahe "'£a'.::§.;+2.:.Vg}<:ei<ifi._ V;%§7<':>*:i§§<;'a'i'};ez": zaféthaut éasuing {me '_;'f3':'LGI'f*_,"€E,i?.7S: ::;:::t§c& ii*:'ax._::f_i_i::Z3":_g 9:" 1:33; givfing ans §I'1G2'1§§1§S :*et3.i:1e:"
%:%:'§.§,.-EL: §§§1 $":1£*:':..'s_ zmtécee 93$ §'::€ith€I' :3? {E2636 :°€q':.':ér5mems AE:?T€'«."'C8i§Z--?_§§§€§V{§:'%'iET§;§;h; smgzzsfl saniendg that the asfiiezz i8 vétézafgéfi. " ' '. ~--m-5 . . '. ' ,/5,?' 4,, Laayaeé {Z<©v@:rr:m@:.:_: agivesazs ziram»-'g__ @316 4 aiteniésn 0:" the Ca3u:*€ ta gubmfiziie {2} sf RuEs:"§_"«--.§:2vg auhmits 'ihai afi Law Sfficerg shafi haié <3ffiC.:gE ' §}§€8.S%.1§'€ af the Gaverrimem andéfiiefiséfarfls §1+:'e"Wj;:';«s:>ftii:iQ:':é:f has me right :23 Coi:1'¥:.sr:d that E316 i:§<:V.p€§,--:--g1§"1£aE;é*:§:if§.cafii§:*:. i$._ ééiagai. Her c0n.te:::§@n is t§'1aE"-viLff;"*:E§€ Gu&f€r*:1:_i':6%:--fiV{:héases V is terminafcrs fixe s€rariCei$~Q§' "Z§£"€ég€r3"*§iV'ca;ré.V:é;@ as by iwuing a ziértéficaétian Ratification wherfiunéer e:§':6';é§f»§ .':>n :€'3*;f§%};L»'--€;%fq9»§..::§5%;T;r€r: to him», She alga brénga ."§fjg;%;::§1""?L" Su"'£>~ruie(@) ef R1136 5» $8 C0Ei€;Y€'V/":ri'§ *{'§;;'.2:;'; ¢u"%3/fitiéfliremeflt sf giving {me m:3:1%;h'>:; {me menth"'3 §"'€Z8_.'§£'§€}"" fir: £162.; af $u¢f:';'.p;'§iiéé V§.;3;.'5:i:>jé.§c*;*£V;i.:=:.':; Sz:;b~:'u§€(2}. :1 E.§r§a.,$J6 heard "zine isarr:€& caurzseé E03" the parfieg afigéaga 'E;i:'{3§13ié&r&?ti{:n of "iha maiaréaig an racaré, §
-- fimfi 'ébai---VA:h'::"'E@gaE pagitésn fig Véffi £36331 figs gar 'thfi rifles} ';pa§:T':.é::;;:§.3;é"E;g Qasis 5; zhaé a Lats: Qffécar agapairzéecé '§}»-" 331%
-- f:§é;j:€:"r:::::e§*:_i; $33333 Emié sffias &';;z;"§::g 'SEES piaagizre Q? firm ' % JV"
'J:
{3:9:f€2im:':5z:_§ 's~'=;h?£c§1 méama 3: £333 '£36 iarminaésd Wiiéxmzi agségnéng 3.2%; reasam by $335 G9:-*e;=nm&r§i:4 if i: SQ ahgageg fie tarminaze the Sam-"ices cf 3: Law Gffgicszg it E133 -15::-.f.f{;«"i§£i:=%;%; the pmcedure pravidad urzder Subwuée {6} " :5'"
issuirzg {>116 mamhfis zzatizza gr E2": figs ;:1{i:é;::r',-::% SE16 .m@r:f;h'S §°€'Céi§3'°E€"i'.. Er: E236 E'J1St§;§f":'{ *f§3S€; :r~;Ef;:'§;<.~:c é_s's:.':':E:: gi'._ 'aha impugned naiificaiéan, a<i}m'X1f§'fE?;€d§§;:3fV. :hé~.§éf%;i€i><}féVér'haS V :13: been given nsiice as' .{ZO%'1'i'&f?£i'p'ia§iE'€§§'-ALi§1d€:;H§'i,E'%~'i"il§€ {6} nor he is paié 3:12 §1mr:t1':':§ Arazairzéif,:"§?fiw.f:h_ja:i "v'§.E"3.§.-* af 3136 matter, if the >S:a;?_¢ i§}G\,§gr:°;:'3éé:':E.%§:i€€::';§ti$f'%:0 terminate the ser'v§<:es {cf the §;~:f«EE1.::£{;}I13.{?'§°.3>"~.§:-'iL. €851 Gniy msart ':0 such an actéer: by éeiéiiféer '§3.a;_j;£i-%.?st§j msmtiwig retains? fee 03° E35; issmkzg,-erzs §":§:;«:1€§';'s' *;:<3'{:':.:§ as gamésmpiaieé ands? Sub :§:'%*3. {6} V. f:=:i€:";M':e::'z;§::>r": 5:?" 'aha §€a§r::.e5§ Gm.-?e:°_:":r::€:":: V;:::'§&a£§.§:f ":i°a §-.é;Jh§r$ 'if; {:9 ::er;€3s:°.E}»°' is gm: rz:a*':':€E":'g {}z':z3 3/:::e:2_'2ih's wiaézzer in E;.ie3%.; 5? sash zzaiéaa, a3 _f:E%2.€5"..*'£'§s:3:;%€r:;:::e2'2t E353 "firm a'§s<:¥%.:.;*;;& riighfiz $0 isrrzzizzaie Ehfi §kxLA,.,w"
E;
{rs ssmrésea Q? a iaaa? Sffésger E23? €'Ké3Y'C?;Si:f}§; gsieaaurs dsairérgs, gamma? ba astcepieci beaause whééa S13;'a-ruEgs_.__ {2} §f1(:G3"§}O3'aE€S {he §€eaSé2r<i §GC£f'i?:1€, whereas S:;.':7'§i*wEe. '{'£E;'} gmvides thss mode and methed af exegcfising iiflé V' "H: cars. 'S6 exercised by issuing 1':0?:iicé"a>:s* hf: 1*;:%*;:'-vi§1€Vr@é:;§ msn'%.:1?.1's retaémetr fee. '§'}2e:ef€2reV,".__2€=£Er;&:1 §':i?:3.»iis:r:€E--§;'~..vtVr:}'~. terminate "$38 Sfiflféfifis 9:' a La;W»VV€Z7*-ffécer'%2;E':'n.{§'::;2f. ':3;SVSigni:':g any-* E'€8.SQ1'E it has Eta 935.31:->.._r gygaz-é"@é;.£%,; r:i@2:3th's €r1bti1<:e GE' pay one m0"n'?:h'3 retainer fee» 'ES-;':1;Ei>}¥:i;;1e,~{2'}Cgn:j§: {6} 0f Rule 5 have is be }1a§m{j%3.;iE}u_s}:}g' 36:115. "Ef f:-%j€[»,_fE_:_f;wi1i Certairfijg lead :0 an0m 3fi§7 é;::'&: w@L:i§,Vd_ ?4é;21f:am@Liié t is haiding that: wéE}10'2;:t §7;}§E9wi:":g'a:{:y pra:>¢€:'<Ai§Lffa,1§%>'-fifimtsmpiatsd under S%.;b-:":.:Ee {éfis a Law__€}ffi§.m'"' €331 -'.3é'~~~"t$:'"m§maie@ at any iémee E; .. :/:ar::fa:t§:::';§.m~J§ réaéimg {If S::'§--r'uE.@ {2} and {6} "2i:"GE.:3.é arxijsx zéétsafi' 3-_a?%;%iE_€ 23:5 S'£&€€ Csr:}2-*$m:":1@r:': has Ehe pawar '$33 ':;:?;*:4;z;';.ft::§':::>;..f:§:~s§' vs:-.€:vi::@s 05 ta Law Sffisez" 3.pp€}§Tfi"ii€§ bf; it ai:
§:sI2:;;,:-:3: W; _€;arhen 3: S0 rséfiaeges, 3: 31135:} feibw me 'L
--§z'a£€ {E':;_:*'€:~ '§;§':'av€:,:1?:3:i urzéar $ub~:"":;:§a (6% éasuéng 3 'S =3"?
._
-._z y' E::";mr:1:%1's rzgiies gr pagzgérig a mm:11:h'S reiairzar £31 1139:; <3f.-sajufii naiiceb 'EI Therefore, resgrving Eib}¢rE;,? *»S€.gaic~. Crevarnmem: 'Ea campiy xviih Sub~:1::1$:1'{6§:' writ psiétéen is éispcseé 015' Eée'E*:i;_:Ir1g '?:i";a_1.E:%i'§3 ivégigmgziefi netifécaiion fir: ihe abgsnce of <:§_I::E;>vE"§;aL':*s.g:€ csf ":'§--:.:Z3~:%::§z5 6 af Ruis 5 cannai be given €f§&::'§fi«t0:;- }