Karnataka High Court
T P Indrakumar Prop: Shri Prabha Rice ... vs The Income Tax Officer Ward-1 on 8 July, 2009
Bench: D.V.Shylendra Kumar, Aravind Kumar
4- RMfi"§fla§%;& Emfififiiwg QQRJE E":a:sJ€ 11é:%z«:,:°:i Sri A S§1a1':k:»i:", §€a,1**r1ed C@:~.1:1}S:%§'-for ;'1;é;~: a.:3:;{: .5112 .-asgezgsaii am" k..I"i 5.. '1€'tS."Z8.(.".'f .13} :1. K ~ 'E ":1: 19% }'q'§V'§I I ffiyl _ stgmiiiilg Ccjigzisaéi far €116: res?Spqiziid€:m=;:'F:f§£:}:}_1:ze. "
HEGW fiflififi? fifi
4. Bfifif fE1€'.?;"$§ Eiiadirig Tc: iwfis at? V' agsesgae ':a;E':r; was CE%1_I'i"j_a'i1Tig o1i"vL4'1E{é;1sineV;€s$« igt}-3' r:£<:;e miii éifld 'i»'§fhO§ it app€a.':fs',~...hac¥_"V§§;§1;§§;'$: €l§4<$ aii'€$h_§ had film hi3 1"&1i:.,1;*11 of t}.3§,£§v"g§'$%;v;¥s3S111ent 3-Ear in qu&st;i0I1 and ~»-, i11a.i.131y ;.»'s.":E.3"i'£311"i'.a1:s}«§ V." 14:3' d€p1'€:Ci£%I.iOI"§ 9121 1:33:51 3:: V' E3"::f{::tt%_:.1;':z;i'.é§-% it. ap§:3€.a1"S,}, ':TE'1{-: C£'£S£'.-- _ V. ':':a{'% »i;:_§%é:':L..tai<ue1;i3::%:'"e;:ifi_:1j§; mzti %_.}:s.é3 a§5$€:$$3i:1g oféicez"
g::€?x%~::<':'t§:: e~.:,<:: p:*:3b€ Exam {£36 bE,iS"i§"i€$§§ a<:t4§3s:ii:.§es a::1<i 1.136 HW3§"'§ mmm Q? mmmfim Wfiéwfi gzgmmfi" Q?
?%§{:sViJsf*;{:'S§§§' {if $16 333$?'-$%€f§ hag} a'maim3:<%
-§:'1fi>:£§:;;:.i§§fi.'%'}c:1': the; 2»:§ss<-:$;§§+s€:'S i:3~az1§<€:'$ 3:93 am}: as §'r<:%:;1 '&s;;$€V§53e€'$ biafiriess <:{3r:E;:3;Cis. Ti}? &s$r::s:e;:1::s_g <::iEfi{:€:"
that ?:§":<i;:*€=: vxsére <:Ei$<tra%;3;:a":<:%.e$ in E1716 capitgi ""V.VvVg%;%:F®é_:::E am? §1":¥€:=~2i.::3e:3€. E'E'i2":i{"§€, as Ciaiznfici bf; ihzs": §.iSS€S$i¥':i'? §%':s§::f<;:'*s?: i:E";e ':3a:':E{$ 332561 .353; Qtatiz Batik {sf Izzdiag E{aj;f*::a'i'aka wmwm me" wmwmmkm WWW a;;wmmA~:.W mwmw"
9/ mwwmi Ur wmcafimmnw mm-=3 fifififlifiiéi-Atvfijifi' %%§W~Efis"E%%.é% Mfiflw Cfififi'? WK': %M"%MA?&.K& Hfififl fififliwfi $1': E€fia%Nfia°?AKA RIQH Cflfififl? Q3" %&E%MMM.%'A fiififl cam 13;
E2. §t3a:s:i*<E <33': *:'.,':1<<é$<~% au':.E'101'iii<.::~_;, Subn1iss;§i3i'ji' » $1'1z:::1%{;3.1° ES i§_"2.:».a.{. it is; "€f3§'f.€ {'f}§',',E:11' zhaif £1; :=st.a1.i_::_i.:§:=--§:j giji§";z:>1'i1'.§; Eike. 'me E?ii~}§§€"?$f:§§.I'1g gyfiice-2:' :;'::?r:.1i{i .116: fiavcé ;;1is;1"%:1}? -i__;};9;};'e_d::>g:§§§' aatcteptezii E'1r:':es%% Sm-<::ai.1ééi:E Ui§11,il"1?§.éQTjf offéf§1'__G?" Rs lakég bj; '< fifzfi é'r':S&§€?SSf?:£€, hut it was the d€[:':}f' {if th&3"é3:3;:§£E€$§si.i*;.g £)fi'i€.';€i"
£0 <;;i€:té:i§*1nin«:~3 thaié a<';:.1.1a1._}§;3b§}'i§}aV-- :a;i'i<:3.__':'i_'i:eaxfT }"1é.§'iii1'1g §'"£i'}Il 'Q6611 made E3}; the £§$s£és$i;fi.g.. _z;>fiC€3:, :{.'}'1f? "'~.1I},EHi'.{€?1' W? rants i:::<é:'t%:r::é:2':(:<: éaiv ::::éa' 35:51:' '£136 §?*::r§§#:1§3%é:*""%)f r€:ma1"1<:1ing the mzmez' {Q §i'1€:=~ :f:$s€::ssi:T;g'*a§j;:*i':<31f§'E§" :31} ms: }:«:"€::1'1ise that 1i:1_t5:
aséaaéggéétg §:":a:«s I7$§i§';?i£?'§.€:ui3g §Ti§§S Offfiilf'/é:1('§£'I'£iSSi@IME <33? havilig e.m"z':»s:::i a1'i"L4_2a<:§e;}ifiQI'i3.3" 3:fi§Ei.}.i'§1iE? 0%' RS 1f.}.{30 1211131 zami i1'1€éE*€if:}I*€: {'3"if"': ;iSs§&:s;§§::g§ :";i'€§<:e':3§' s:;.E1s:m1(i €fX?i}i'§§;3f1f: 'E".}'}{i fi'1&il'f.€l"' {:55 $7; '::f;%:::*iiI$; seimji if Iifiifid héi :21": §;§:i:¥:: r:':at.€~::"ia} as 116: T:1:§g_§;E'1é-T }'i§i'iié.? ~« 33:" £113}; gaffhfii' 2:1':-:1 in pass an '.;2i§se$s2'1:%::1§::;:*:_i<:*:::' afffisfih ':3? givixzg 0pp<";1'*'m.:':*L1r.§.f {:3 iihéi je:%£§:§&<~'% {<3 §3:"0v:2t Eiifi r€t':.i:13. sf i:1::*:«:>'§1::sé~7x. ' " E3'; 53:': £326: «:.sE.}.1€::' §":am%_§ Szii ':2' 'S€$E'1a{:hai:3, EéT::fi"'1*:€;{:Z " 53'i'a§:{§i:1g :'i<;>1.2:"1s%"§z%:%E .'E':::':'' 33363 I'i:§;;:.3{ts£'2ii€I'}i--:'€éi!t*t:1i,1&, si;:'r)2I:i'{.s ®/ & 3 ® Q :5: § 3 \§'tb~'N A-.«vwx~«,*»c\v«e»vmA\""tn¢l.~'5("*9'.|k\M£""'§ mH.%:'M"# mwmwma ,_.°€5.«5{§° %%&.mWM&M%.% w - .. ' 20 T:3Z13;f:é% .213 £361' T3716': &1E§S£3SSf?f:':?:'S I<~:~.'t.te:I' €:%a¥',<%:d 28*'2~2{}C}.i:}'.:¥f} t3iL1§5 peaca a1;1<,i avoid fm'"E._11r:::r 8-§;1'%a'€E1"Sé3 {:<'>:'1$€aque::3:it%:-',3 ,aI:1{i ={15'J:;--s:~r: ' asgessing a:.1thcs1*i1."y having ae:1"i::d L1}3'C;e--§.1f;.}I'i;":_4S pfégficsfiiiicin {if 131$ assesssee and haviilg résgard *::4o° t1ri'1'€;_ f{)&éctiii_;i1'~ §'22§:t';i~{'a2;i{3._ CiI'CLi13'1S1§.§31I"3.C€S af this; case; ¥i%'fi3 €3§.1f'€iCE.V.¥Q}1é33[is.§1'i§:'i é:{i%':};'if'2€j:T1 <31?' i:r1cz:;>:11e under S€(,'Ii;()I } L334 t§:%"~a:21'§e of 3:116 };3I'€SEfI"1f E1§}}f)€iH£3I"l{i »-~» ii;§:{fr:_$$amj 311d :10':
justified amt} in faveur of the &"¥.§L}§3t?}vi%.é§2:;LE'i;%4'*fl>i apgjfzal is aileiariiii 0:133; xmh$¢§ém£§p%§' I OEc§_:€:*6:zi ac<1?t3i"%ji'ii'kgfigfl" ~ « é «' 3&3":
§§g5.§§ Sdfne 4 Ivdge