Central Administrative Tribunal - Jabalpur
Mp Mes Karamachari Sangh vs Dedence on 25 June, 2025
1
(Reserved)
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
JABALPUR BENCH
JABALPUR
this the 25TH day of June, 2025
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AKHIL KUMAR SRIVASTAVA, JUDICIAL MEMBER
HON'BLE MRS. MALLIKA ARYA, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER
Original Application No. 983 of 2023
1. Devendra Vishwakarma S/o Shri Kishori Lal Vishwakarma, DOB-
26/06/1976,Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade I
R/o- H. No. 31 Nirman Nagar Kajarwara, Jabalpur (MP) 482001.
2. Shiv Kumar Soni S/o Shri Ramesh Kumar soni, DOB-
06/08/1981,Working As-Electrician skilled.R/o- 871, Near Kishori Kiran
Store Bapunagar Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482011(MP).
3. Govind Prasad S/o Late Ramdas Kanojiya, DOB-23/06/1965, Working
As-Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade I, R/o- H. no. 1083 Indra
Nagar, Gupteshwar, Jabalpur 482001(MP).
4. Firoj Khan S/o Late Jumman khan, DOB-05/07/1964, Working As- Pipe
fitter skilled, R/o- B. No. 45-Pentinaka Sadar Bazar, Jabalpur 482001(MP)
5. Shwatantra Singh Patel S/o Shri Samay Raj Patel, DOB-01/01/1993,
Working As- Mate Electrician R/o- 1757, Bai ka Bageecha, Jabalpur
482001 (MP).
6. Ramesh Kumar Pal S/o Bageshwar Prasad Pal, DOB-01/07/1983
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o-1325, Yadav Colony
Jabalpur 482002 (MP).
7. Mohd Imtiyaz S/o Mohad Amish, DOB-19/05/1968, Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade I, R/o- Neta Colony, Adhartal,
Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
8. Amit Kaumar Rai S/o Ajay Kumar Rai,DOB-15/07/1992,Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic Skilled,R/o-Village & Post-Sikhari, Distt-Gazipur,
233300 (UP).
Page 1 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
2
9. Jitendra Minocha S/o Vedprakash Minocha,DOB-02/05/1976,Working
As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade II,R/o- H. No. 2317,
Harsingh Nagar, Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482011(MP).
10. Prabhuath S/o Ram Nirale, ,DOB-10/11/1962,Working As- Pipe fitter
Skilled, R/o- Village-Mohua, Post - Silpuri,Dist-Rewa 486338 (MP).
11. Ram Sudarshan Hardaha S/o Late Devi Prasad Hardaha,,DOB-
17/05/1989,Working As- Mate Electrician,R/o- Narmada Nagar, Dr Khan
ki gali Sankar Parisar Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
12. Rakesh Kumar Upadhyay S/o Shri R P Upadhyay, DOB-13/05/1966,
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade I, R/o-1780
Ward No 66 Kajarwara Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
13. D P Singh S/o Late Puran Singh Thakur, DOB-25/02/1969,Working
As- Master Crafts Man,R/o-5299 East Ghamapur, Near Sarkari Kuwa,
Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
14. PK Dwivedi S/o Bhola Prasad Dwivedi, DOB-01/10/1965, Working As-
Skilled Electrician, R/o-1859 Jogani Nagar Post Vidhuyut Nagar, Rampur
Jabalpur 482008 (MP).
15.Mahesh Dubey S/o DK Dubey, DOB-15/12/1988, Working As- Mate
Electrician, R/o- Lalmati behind Shukla Hotel, Dwarka Prasad Mishra
Ward, Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
16. Shubham Vishwakarma S/o TS Vishwakarma,DOB-19/02/1996,
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade 1,R/o- Mohit
Township H. No 90, Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
17. Anurag Hardaha S/o Binda Lal Haradaha, DOB-27/01/1993,Working
As- Mate Electrician R/o- Ward No 12 Jhandha Chowk, Village Gangaura,
Post Sukhtara Mandla 481661 (MP).
18 . Jaspreet Singh Bawa S/o G S Bawa, DOB-21/11/1991,Working As-
Electrician Skilled R/o-MN 69 Maitri Nagar Maharajpur, Post Adhartal
Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
19. Rajesh Pradhan S/o Govind Pradhan, DOB-10/06/1967, Working As-
Pipefitter Highly Skilled Grade-I R/o- Bilhari Chetna Maidan, Mandla Road,
Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
Page 2 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
3
20. Ashish Raghuwansi S/o Late Ram Sewak, DOB-/02/1987 Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- H No 227 Khamaria, Ghana Sonpur
Road Jabalpur 482005 (MP).
21. Deepak Kushwaha S/o Ramprasad Kushwaha, DOB-25/07/1990,
Working As- Skilled Electrician R/o- H. No 1215/37 Old PP Colony
Polipathar, Gwarighat Road Jabalpur 482008 (MP).
22. Ramakant Choudhary S/o Madan Choudhary, DOB-04/05/1988,
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- H. No 3458/8 Infront of
ITI, Madhotal, Jabalpur 482002 (MP).
23. Vinay Dahayat S/o Late Manoj Kumar Dahayat, DOB-31/12/1988
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- New Basti Kajarwara
Near Siddheshwari Durga Mandir Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
24. Mohd Yakub S/o Abdul Hakeem, DOB-03/07/1973, Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade-II,R/o- LIG 34 New Anmol Nagar
Adhartal Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
25. Kaushal Kumar Shah S/o Om Prakash Shah, DOB-12/03/1989
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- Village Sukhsena, Post
Bhatkeshari Distt-Chhapra 841301 Bihar.
26 Akshay Kumar Vishwakarma S/o Krishna Vishwakarma, DOB-
14/09/1994 Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic R/o- H. No 817
Footatal Badai Mohalla Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
27. Anthony Fransis S/o Late MR Fransis, DOB-18/09/1967 Working As-
Electrician Highly Skilled Grade-II R/o- H. No 1053 Manegaon Adarsh
Nagar Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482011(MP).
28. Shiv Kumar S/o Mani Lal, DOB-01/07/1970 Working As- Electrician
Highly Skilled Grade-II R/o-293 Gandhi Vyomshala Ranjhi Bazar Jabalpur
482011 (MP).
29. Pramod Kumar Tripathi S/o Shri R P Tripathi, DOB-02/07/1968
Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-890/149 Maa Narmada Nagar,
Mandala Road, Bilhari Jabalpur 482001(MP).
30. Tarun Kumar Shrivas S/o Govind Prasad, DOB-18/10/1978 Working
As- Electrician Skilled R/o- H. No 1367 Ambedkar Ward Ranjhi Jabalpur
482011 (MP).
Page 3 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
4
31. Rajesh Chawana S/o Late Sita Ram Chawana, DOB-22/07/1966
Working As- Electrician Highly Skilled Grade-I R/o- C/o Smt. Rekha
Shashtri, H. No 2844 Ranjhi, Narsingh Nagar Jabalpur 482011 (MP).
32. Gunjan Kumar S/o Ram Swaroop, DOB-05/07/1988, Working As-
Mate electrician, R/o- H. No C/3 PHED Colony Booty, Post Bariata Ranchi
834001 Jharkhand.
33. Rakesh Patel S/o Arun Patel,DOB-19/02/1989,Working As- Electrician
Skilled,R/o-594 Champa Nagar, Manegaon Ranjhi Jabalpur 482011 (MP).
34. Virendra Kumar Tiwari S/o Late Shri Ram Tahal Tiwari, DOB-
12/07/1968, Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- H. No 90
High Court Colony Chhapar Rampur Jabalpur 482008 (MP).
35. Raghupat Rao S/o Late Shri Pochaiya Rao, DOB-02/07/1965, Working
As- Master Crafts Man,R/o- H. No 1148A Samiksha town Phase-II,
Kanchghar Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
36. Rahul Singh S/o Akhilesh Singh,DOB-01/07/1995 Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic Skilled R/o- Manegaon Ranjhi Jabalpur 482011 (MP)
37. Sunil Kumar S/o Vinayak Sahu,DOB-09/11/1990,Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic Skilled,R/o- B26 Saket Nagar Kohka bhilai Nagar Durg
490006 Chhatisgarh.
38. Gajendra Agase S/o Keshorav Agase,DOB-20/04/1989,Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic Skilled,R/o- Ghoti Ghusmara, Pathargaon Laanji
Balaghat 481222 (MP).
39. Keshav Kumar Sahu S/o Ram Kumar Sahu,DOB-15/07/1986,Working
As- Pipe Fitter Skilled,R/o-15, Sneh Ashish Vihar, Ghosplot Gandhigram
Nakata Mandir hasoud Raipur 492001 Chhatisgarh.
40. Umesh Kumar S/o Bhimshok, DOB-22/02/1991,Working As- Mate
Electrician,R/o-137 School Para Achhati Dhamtari, Pincode-493663 (CG).
41. Om Prakash S/o Shri Kumar Ram, DOB-05/02/1990,Working As-
Electrician Skilled, R/o- H. No 155 Village Jangalpur Tehsil Dongargaon
Rajnandgaon (Chhatisgarh)-491441.
Page 4 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
5
42. Ram Kumar Patel S/o KL Patel, DOB-10/10/1963,Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic Highly Skilled Grade-I R/o-2793/01 Siddh Nagar Near
Police Station Garha, Jabalpur 482001(MP).
43. Shubham Choudhary S/o Tirath Prasad Choudhary,DOB-
15/07/1995,Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic R/o- 165, Trimurti
Nagar, Near Aghori Baba Temple, Jabalpur (MP)-482002.
44. Mahendra Kumar S/o Keshav Prasad,DOB-03/03/1988,Working As-
Mate Fitter General Mechanic R/o- H.No. Y/24, EWS Double Story, Barra-
2, Kanpur Nagar (UP) - 208027.
45. Anil Kumar S/o Jiledar,DOB-27/06/1989,Working As- Mate Fitter
General Mechanic R/o-130/23, Baghai Batta T.P. Nagar, Kanpur (UP) Pin
Code-208023.
46. Robert S/o Nathan, DOB-05/03/1964,Working As- Electrician Highly
Skilled Grade II R/o- Qtr No. PA-5/2, MES Colony Dhana Sagar 470001
(MP).
47. Babu Lal S/o Shankar Lal,DOB-07/07/1964,Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic, Highly Skilled Grade II,R/o- Qtr No. ETA-7/3, MES
Colony Dhana, Sagar 470001(MP).
48. Suraj Prasad S/o Kadori lal, DOB-10/09/1964,Working As- Carpenter
Highly Skilled Grade II,R/o-Qtr No. PA-1/7, MES Colony Dhana, Sagar
470001 (MP).
49. Ramshankar S/o Suraj Prasad Tiwari, DOB 28/10/1965, Working As-
Pipe Fitter Highly Skilled Grade II, R/o- Qtr No. ETA-6/3, MES Colony
Dhana, Sagar 470001(MP).
50. Ram Mohan Mahobia S/o Saligram Mahobia, DOB-05/06/1974,
Working As- Electrician Skilled, R/o- Qtr No. PA-1/3, MES Colony Dhana,
Sagar 470001(MP).
51. Manoj Brahman S/o Sukhlal Brahman, DOB-01/02/1980, Working As-
Electrician Skilled, R/o- Qtr No. ETA-5/2, MES Colony Dhana, Sagar
470001(MP).
52. Bimlesh Kumar S/o Ramshagar Singh,DOB-5/02/1992,Working As-
Electrician Skilled,R/o- Qtr No. PA-1/8, MES Colony Dhana, Sagar
470001(MP).
Page 5 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
6
53. Rahul Roshan S/o Raghunandan Prasad Singh,DOB-
03/03/1994,Working As- Fitter General Mechanic, Skilled,R/o- Qtr No. PA-
6, MES Colony Dhana, Sagar 470001(MP).
54. Rahul Kushwaha, S/o Umesh Chandra Kushwaha, DOB-
07/01/1993,Working As- Mate Electrician,R/o- Qtr No. PA-1/5, MES
Colony Dhana, Sagar 470001(MP).
55. Makkhan Lal Jat S/o Richhpal Singh,DOB-23/09/1987,Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic,R/o- Qtr No. PA-1/2, MES Colony Dhana, Sagar
470001(MP).
56. Shailesh Kumar S/o Lalan Prasad,DOB-21/04/1985,Working As-
Electrician Skilled,R/o-Qtr No. PA-1/1, MES Colony Dhana, Sagar
470001(MP).
57. Shatish kumar S/o Ami lal, DOB-06/12/1993, Working As- Mate
Electrician,R/o-Qtr No. PA-1/6, MES Colony Dhana, Sagar 470001(MP).
58. Mukesh Kumar S/o Late Ram Sevak, DOB-24/05/1974,Working As-
Electrician Skilled,R/o- Qtr No. 433/2, Panehra GCF Estate, Jabalpur
482011 (MP).
59. Dashrath, S/o Rajaram,DOB-30/06/1973,Working As- Fitter General
Mechanic, Highly Skilled Grade II,R/o- Ward No. 78, Bilpura VFJ, Jabalpur
482005 (MP).
60. Vishnu Bahadur S/o Late Hira lal,DOB-09/06/1996, Working As-
Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled,R/o- Ward No.-78, H.No. 45, Bilpura Colony,
VFJ, Jabalpur 482005 (MP).
61. Revaram S/o Hori lal,DOB-04/05/1967,Working As- Mate Electrician,
R/o- Dixit Colony ITI, Madhotal, Jabalpur 482002(MP).
62. Vijay Singh S/o Mangal Singh,DOB-30/08/1974,Working As- Mate
Electrician,R/o- H.No. 664, Khalsa Collage, behind Mahanadda, Jabalpur
482001 (MP).
63. Shankar Lal S/o Late Ram Prasad,DOB-25/09/1974,Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic, Highly Skilled Grade II,R/o- Indra Nagar Bilpura,
Ranjhi, VFJ, Jabalpur 482005 (MP).
Page 6 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
7
64. Chhotu lal Uikey S/o Geetaram Uikey,DOB-17/11/1961,Working As-
Mason Highly Skilled Grade II, R/o-Chanpanagar, Manegaon, Ranjhi,
Jabalpur 482011 (MP).
65. Miss Sita Vishwakarm D/o Ramshrey Vishwakarma,DOB-15/11/1993,
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic, Skilled R/o- 277, Chanmari Shukla
Hotel, Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
66. Jeewan Singh Pandre S/o Late Himmi Singh Pandre,DOB-
14/09/1962,Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o- Nanak Nagar, Manegaon,
Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482011 (MP).
67. Ramswaroop Vishwakarma S/o Late Lal Singh Vishwakarma, DOB-
03/03/1963 Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o- New Kanchanpur,
Adhartal, Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
68. MS Ansari S/o Haji Nabibakhs, DOB-24/06/1966 Working As-
Electrician Highly Skilled Grade R/o- H. No. 391, Motinala Ground,
Jabalpur 482001 (MP)
69. Abhishek Kumar Mourya S/o Gulabchand Mourya, DOB-20/09/1992
Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-2253/1-A, New Kanchanpur, Jabalpur
482001 (MP)
70. Pankaj Soni S/o Govind Narayan Soni,DOB-02/12/1993 Working As-
Electrician Skilled R/o- Gayatri nagar, Adhartal Jabalpur 482004 (MP).
71. Sheikh Mazuddin S/o Sheikh Mafiddin,DOB-30/06/1968 Working As-
Electrician Skilled R/o- 1156/6, Ajij Ganj, Pasiyana Shastri Ward,
Jabalpur 482001 (MP)
72. Manoj Kumar S/o TR Gulatkar, DOB-30/06/1971 Working As- Mate
Pipe Fitter R/o- Satsari Nagar Gupteshwar, Jabalpur 482001 (MP).
73. Ramchandra Kol S/o Late Narayan Kol,DOB-26/11/1965,Working As-
Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- Qtr No. 2326-A, Type-II, VFJ. Estate, Jabalpur
482005 (MP)
74. Sanjay Jeson Gutain S/o Late James Gutain,DOB-
30/11/1963,Working As- Refrigerator mechanic highly Skilled Grade I,R/o-
73-CMCI Colony, Hawabag Katanga, Jabalpur 482001 (MP)
Page 7 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
8
75. Ashok Kumar Sahu S/o Janak lal Sahu, DOB-02/06/1964, Working
As- Refrigerator mechanic Skilled R/o- 143, ward No. 5, Purani Chakki,
Kamaniya Gate, Barela, Jabalpur 483001 (MP).
76. Khemchand S/o Late Daya Ram,DOB-05/06/1965, Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic, Highly Skilled Grade I,R/o- Nanak Nagar, Bada Pathhar
Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482011 (MP)
77. Jawahar lal S/o Gedi lal Haldkar, DOB-14/11/1964,Working As-
Refrigerator mechanic highly Skilled Grade II R/o- New Kanchanpur,
Adhartal, Jabalpur 482004(MP)
78. Vijay Kumar Gajbhiye S/o Manik Rai Gajbhiye, DOB-
01/07/1966Working As- Refrigerator mechanic Skilled R/o-Bada Pathhar,
Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482011 (MP)
79. Bhiwaji Lange S/o Late Daya Ram lange,DOB-15/12/1966,Working As-
Mason Highly Skilled Grade II,R/o- Nanak nagar, Manegaon, Ranjhi,
Jabalpur 482011 (MP).
80. Ashok Kumar S/o Late Kuwar lal,DOB-25/05/1962,Working As-
Electrician Skilled R/o-Vill-Chevwala Ward Awanti Bai, Jabalpur 482001
(MP)
81. Jitthu Lal S/o Late Sundewr Lal,DOB-01/07/1958,Working As-Fitter
General Mechanic, Skilled,R/o- Indra Nagar, VFJ, Jabalpur 482005 (MP)
82. Uday Kumar Pandey S/o Late Raja Ram Pandey,DOB-
17/12/1962,Working As- Electrician Skilled,R/o-4039/6-B, Yashwant
Nagar, Adhartal, Jabalpur 482004(MP)
83. Chhote Lal Yadav S/o Nanhe Lal Yadav,DOB-05/12/1958,Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic, Highly Skilled Grade II R/o- H NO. 4050/80,
Ganga Maiya, VFJ, Jabalpur 482005 (MP)
84. Puran Lal S/o Late Prahlad, DOB-16/04/1962,Working As- Pipe Fitter
Highly Skilled Grade II H. NO. 2300, Bajrang nagar, Pani Ki Tanki, VFJ,
Jabalpur 482005 (MP).
85. Magan Lal S/o Late Jhammulal Sen,DOB-08/06/1959,Working As-
Mate Electrician,R/o- H No. 164 Ward No. 78, Village-Bilpura, VFJ,
Jabalpur 482005 (MP)
Page 8 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
9
86. Raj Kumar Pandey S/o Ramsewak Pandey, DOB-15/08/1962 Working
As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- Parijat Building, Damoh Naka, Jabalpur
482001 (MP)
87. Umar Farooq Ansari S/o A R Shahid Ansari,DOB-24/08/1964, Working
As- Refrigerator mechanic highly Skilled Grade I R/o-2347, Qureshi
Compound, Anand Nagar Adhartal Jabalpur (MP)-482004
88. Animesh Kumar S/o Suryakant Singh, DOB-15/12/1990,Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic Skilled,R/o- Vill-Durgapur Post - Khutahan,
Haspura, Dist- Aurangabad (Bihar)-824120
89. Sandev Singh S/o Late RS Singh,DOB-13/02/1988,Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic Skilled,R/o- VIII-Raghupur, Post- Bela, Dhariyapur,
(Bihar)-841221.
90. Santosh Kumar S/o Lalan Prasad, DOB-07/04/1984,Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic Skilled, R/o- Vill-Usri Shikarpur Danapur, Patna
(Bihar)-801105.
91. Surendra singh S/o Mansha Singh, DOB-01/07/1960, Working As-
Fitter General Mechanic Skilled,R/o- H. No. 42,Nanak Nagar, Sonpur Road
Khamariya, Jabalpur 482005 (MP)
92. Yashwant Rao Meshram S/o Late Kishan Meshram, DOB-19/12/1959
Working As- Carpenter Highly Skilled Grade II,R/o- Champa Nagar,
Manegaon, Ranjhi, Jabalpur 482011 (MP)
93. Rajkumar Kachhi, S/o Late Kallu Ram, DOB-08/06/1963, Working As-
Electrical Skilled, R/o- Shivaji Ward, Near Panager Thana, Jabalpur
483220 (MP).
94. Ashok kumar Joshi S/o Sudama Lal Joshi, DOB-01/01/1971,Working
As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic R/o- Qtr No. 40/4, Mandir Colony, MES
COD, Jabalpur 482011 (MP). .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Vijay Tripathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110001.
Page 9 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
10
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Head
Quarter of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg Defence
Head Quater, New Delhi 110010.
3. Chief Engineer, (Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service Central
Command Lucknow (UP) 226001
4. Chief Engineer(Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service, Jabalpur
Zone Lekhanagar Ridge road Jabalpur (MP)-482001
5. Commander Works Engineer (Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service
Near Supply Depot, Sadar Bazar Jabalpur (MP)-482001
6. Garrison Engineer (East) Military Engineering Service Near COD,
Jabalpur (MP) -482001
7.Garrison Engineer Military Engineering Service Cantt. Saugor (MP)-
470001.
8. Asstt. Garrison Engineer (I) Military Engineering Service Dhana Saugor,
470001(MP)
9. Asstt. Garrison Engineer (1) Military Engineering Service HQ Kosa, Naya
Raipur Chhattisgarh, 492001. ......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri P.K. Chaurasia
Alongwith
Original Application No. 1078 of 2023
1. Surendra Suryawanshi S/o Lat. Ganpat Suryawanshi, DOB-
31/05/1986, MES No.- 423867 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled
R/o- Tc-8/4 Near Army public School Old MES Colony, Mhow, Dist. Indore
(M.P.)- 453441
2. Nanu Ram Verma S/o Shri Chhoga Lal Verma, DOB-05/01/1964, MES
No.- 423646 Working As- Electrician Master Craft Man R/o- House No. 06
Bhole Vihar Colony Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
3. Shri Jagannath S/o Late Tarachand, DOB-06/04/1965, MES No.-
423634 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-I, R/o- 50/2 Near Hanuman
Mandir Telikheda, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
Page 10 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
11
4. Shri Sunil Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Motilal Sharma, DOB-01/01/1975,
MES No.-423709 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o- House No.
125, Suman Colony, Mhowgaon, Mhow, Dist. Indore (М.Р.)- 453441
5. Sunil Kumar Sankhala S/o Late Bhura Lal Sankhala, DOB-02/11/1968,
MES No.- 423660 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II, R/o- House No.-
07 Shiv Nagar Colony Dharnaka Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)- 453441.
6. Kishori Lal S/o Shri Tejram Sharnagat, DOB-29/06/1979, MES No.-
4423736 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II, R/o-295, MR 04,
Mahalaxmi Nagar, Indore 452001(M.P.)-
7. Mahinder Singh S/o Late Ramgopal Singh Rathore, DOB-02/04/1966,
MES No.- 423657 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o- TC-6/4,
Near Army Public School, Old MES Colony, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-
453441
8. Narayan Solanki S/o Shri Mangi Lal Solanki, DOB-20/07/1980, MES
No.- 422774 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II, R/o- Kheda, Po.
Sagorekuti Pithampur, Dhar, (MP), 454774
9. Munfaid Ali S/o Shri Resham Khan, DOB-13/03/1993, MES No.-423886
Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o-73/C MES Colony Near MES IB
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
10. Sandeep Pardeshi S/o Late Mewa Lal Pardeshi, DOB-06/11/1984, MES
No.-423847 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II, R/o-2004, Bhoi
Mohalla, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
11. Md. Rizwan Khan S/o Shri Mohd Arif Khan, DOB-01/07/1991, MES
No.- 423850 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-960, Central Street Mhow,
Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
12. Rahul Singh Rajput S/o Shri Balwant Singh Rajput, DOB-16/01/1986,
MES No.- 423868 Working As- Electrician Skilled, R/o- Tc-13/2 Near Army
Public School, Old MES Colony Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
13. Ramesh Ghatte S/o Shri Kishan Ghatte, DOB-20/06/1984, MES No.-
422758 Working As- Electrician Skilled, R/o-405, Sanskrati Paradise,
Pigdambar, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453331
14. Gajanand Mahadev Nathe S/o Shri Mahadevrao B. Nathe, DOB-
20/07/1964, MES No.- EX-15351793F Working As- Electrician Skilled
Page 11 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
12
R/o-T-59/1 MES Colony, Near MCTE Power House, Mall Road, Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.P.)- 453441.
15. Nitin Singh Rajput S/o Late Bhagwan Singh Rajput, DOB-06/05/1984,
MES No.- 414079 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-301/B Indrapuri
Colony Kishanganj Mhow Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441.
16. Lalit Kumar Gour S/o Shri Kamal Kishore Gour, DOB-02/12/1987,
MES No.- 376295 Working As- Electrician Skilled, R/o-65/2, MES Colony
Near Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
17. Milan Kumar S/o Late Sampat Lal Sah, DOB-04/05/1986, MES No.-
423889 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-Tc-13/4 Near Army Public
School Old MES Colony, Mhow Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
18. Mrs Priyanka Vishwakarma W/o Shri Shivcharan vishwakarma, DOB-
01/03/1994, MES No.-423911 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-61/8,
MES Colony Behind AGE E/M 1, Mall Road Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-
453441
19. Md Shahbaz Humayun S/o Shri Abdul Hafeez, DOB-18/07/1991, MES
No.- 423910 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o Qtr No. 9, Kumau
Regiment, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
20. Chandramohan Javdoliya S/o Shri Ganpat Lal, DOB-08/12/1985, MES
No.- 423909 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- 63/1, MES Colony Near
Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
21. Vikas Sahu S/o Late Shriram Sahu, DOB-11/05/1994, MES No.-
423923 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-60/3, MES Colony Behind
AGEE/M 1, Mall Road, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
22. Shivraj Singh S/o Shri Bajrang Singh, DOB-08/07/1992, MES No.-
423918 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-65/6, MES Colony Near
Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441.
23. Chandra Prakash S/o Shri Subhash Singh, DOB-14/01/1996, MES
No.- 423938 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- 65/5, MES Colony Near
Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
24. Anil Kumar Verma S/o Shri Omprakash, DOB-23/12/1988, MES No.-
423922 Working As- Mate Electrician, R/o-65/1, MES Colony Near
Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
Page 12 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
13
25. Hemant Patel S/o Late Gajanand Patel, DOB-16/05/1995, MES No.-
423924 Working As- Mate Electrician R/o- 228, Balaji Mohalla Kodariya
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)- 453441
26 Ram Lakhan Singh S/o Shri Murli Singh, DOB-03/05/1968, MES No.-
EX-1578919N Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o-66/5, MES
Colony Near Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
27. Shri Sohan Lal S/o Shri Ramgopal, DOB-09/02/1980, MES No.-
423925 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- T-59/2 Near
Power House MCTE, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
28 Satendra Kumar Bhagat S/o Shri Pushu Lal, DOB-26/02/1995, MES
No.-. 423912 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled, R/o- Qrt
No.60/7 MES Colony, Behind AGE E/M-01, Mall Road, Cantt Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.P.)- 453441
29. Sandeep Sen S/o Shri Dhaniram Sen, DOB-15/12/1993, MES No.-.
423917 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o-62/1, MES
Colony, Near Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
30. Vimal S/o Shri Dharampal Singh, DOB-01/06/1985, MES No.- 281201
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o-61/6, MES Colony,
Behind AGE E/M-01, MES Colony Cantt Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-
453441.
31. Amit Sankhala S/o Shri Meghraj Sankhala, DOB-07/04/1990, MES
No.- 423891 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o- 103, Bijasan
colony, Telikheda, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
32. Mohan lal S/o Shri Sunder Lal, DOB-11/05/1969, MES No.- 423685
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o-98, Behind Gram
Panchayat, Gujarkheda, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
33. Hemant Puraiya S/o Late Ramcharan Puraiya, DOB-21/06/1986, MES
No.- 423843 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o-74/A, MES
Colony, Kodariya Road, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
34. Virendra Tomar S/o Shri Indar Singh Tomar DOB-14/04/1988, MES
No.- 423846 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o- Tejaji Mohalla,
Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
Page 13 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
14
35. Ravi Ranjan Kumar S/o Late Brahmdeo Mahto, DOB-02/12/1983,
MES No.- 423857 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o- 66/3, MES
Colony, Near Rajeshwar School, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
36. Conrad Joseph S/o Shri Morris Joseph DOB-10/02/1978, MES No.-
164691 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o- 66, New Rajat Green,
Near Lion Gym, Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
37. Amit Bavne S/o Shri Jai Prakash Bavne, DOB-24/10/1985, MES No.-
423859 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o- Garden No.106,
Gupta Colony, Luniyapura, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)- 453441
38. Manish Bavne S/o Shri Jai Prakash Bavne, DOB-24/08/1988, MES
No.-414151 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o- Garden No.106,
Gupta Colony, Luniyapura, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441.
39. Nitish Kumar Mahto S/o Shri Chando Mahto, DOB-01/05/1993, MES
No.- 423869 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o-Village Post-
Durgapur, The Giriyak, Dist. Nalanda, Bihar-803115
40. Rajesh Kumar Dongre S/o Shri Jagdish Dongre, DOB-22/08/1976,
MES No.-423845 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- Sukh Sagar Colony,
Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
41. Chandraprakash S/o Shri Banarsi Lal, DOB-02/04/1962, MES No.-
423593 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic High Skilled-II R/o- 46,
Regiment Bazar, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
42. Lakhan Meshra S/o Shri Rameshwar Meshra, DOB-05/01/1994, MES
No.- 423858 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o-109/2, Devgarh
Road, Rajendra Nagar, Hatpipliya, Dewas, 455001 MP
43. Akhilesh Kumar S/o Shri Sukhdev Kumar, DOB-25/05/1987, MES
No.-423756 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- H.No.14, Shri Vinayak
Vihar Colony, Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
44. Madhu Singh S/o Shri Chhagan Lal, DOB-03/06/1987, MES No.-
423757 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- H.No.287, Village/Post Kelod,
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
45. Sameer Khan S/o Shri Abdul Hafiz, DOB-02/06/1993, MES No.-
423789 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- 56 Banda Basti Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
Page 14 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
15
46. Vikas Singh S/o Shri Narayan Parsad, DOB-15/12/1989, MES No.-
423754 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- H.No.3226, Sarwan Mohalla,
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441.
47. Sunil Kumar Narwal S/o Late Shri Chaganlal Narwal, DOB-
15/08/1987, MES No.- 423655 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o-
H.No.116/42, Rishi Garden, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
48. Lokendra Kalosiya S/o Shri Anil Kalosiya, DOB-10/09/1964, MES No.-
423755 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- H.No.1671, Gokulganj, Mhow,
Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
49. Shyam Lal S/o Shri Jairam, DOB 15/07/1984, MES No.- 423788
Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- H,No.B-164,DHL Dongargaon, Mhow,
Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
50. Sunil Kumar S/o Late Shri Vinayak Rao, DOB-16/06/1970, MES No.-
423676 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- 36/A, Shraddha Palace,
Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
51. Shri Rakesh Brajwasi S/o Shri Babulal Brajwasi, DOB-25/03/1987,
MES No.- 423851 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- Police Line, Near
Railway Station, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
52. Rajesh Kumar S/o Shri Nathulal, DOB-03/04/1968, MES No.-423713
Working As- Mate Painter R/o- H.No.125/2, Malviya Nagar, AB Road,
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)- 453441
53. Ajay Gothwal S/o Shri Shyamlal Gothwal, DOB-15/08/1979, MES No.-
423733 Working As- Painter High Skilled-II R/o- Plot No.13-14A,
Sukhsagar Colony Extension, Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
54. Harsh Rajoriya, S/o Shri Narayan Rajoriya, DOB-21/05/1988, MES
No.- 423762 Working As- Mate Painter R/o-47/5, MES Colony, Behind
AGE E/M-01, Mall Road, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441.
55. Shri Pradeep Kumar S/o Shri Ramnivash, DOB-08/12/1992, MES No.-
423913 Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o- H.No.32, Village Rampura,
Post-Rupadeh, Teh. Seoni Malwa, Dist. Narmadapuram (M.P.)-461223
Page 15 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
16
56. Nitish Vishwakarma S/o Shri Pushpkumar Vishwakarma, DOB-
12/12/1988, MES No.-423844 Working As- Carpenter High Skilled-II R/o-
H.No.100, Kalindi Vihar, Borkhedi, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
57. Ashok Kumar S/o Shri Gendalal, DOB-17/08/1964, MES No.- 423567
Working As- Carpenter Master Craft Man R/o- Garden No.50, Ved Colony,
Simrol Road, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
58. Omprakash Windwar S/o Shri S R Windwar, DOB-05/08/1991, MES
No.- 423920 Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o-60/6, MES Colony, Behind
AGE E/M-01, Mall Road, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)- 453441
59. Chetan Sharma, S/o Shri Ramesh Chand Sharma, DOB-29/08/1991,
MES No.- 423933 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o- 76/D New
MES Colony, Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)- 453441
60. Anil Saraiya S/o Shri Bhurelal Saraiya, DOB-09/10/1993, MES No.-
423932 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Mukam-post-jasalpur, Distt-
tehsil-Narmdapuram (M.P.)-461001
61. Sohan lal Sharma S/o Shri Sarwan lal, DOB-15/08/1992, MES No.-
423929 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- Kerli Ki Dhani,
Jahota, Teh.-Amer, Jaipur (RJ)-303701
62. Anil Kumar Lilhore S/o Late Brajkishore, DOB-03/11/1985, MES No.-
423807 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o- TC-11/1, OLD MES
Colony, Post Office Road, Near Ganesh Mandir Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-
453441.
63. Dinesh Kumar Choudhary S/o Late Ramcharan Choudhary, DOB-
06/03/1979, MES No.- 164692 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled
R/o- Kerli 15, Annapurna Vistar Sec-B Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-
453441
64. Vineet Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Battan lal Sahu, DOB-18/04/1984, MES
No.-423836 Working As- Refrigerator MechanicHigh Skilled-II R/o-B-76
DHL Colony Dongar gav, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
65. Mohd Danish S/o Shri Shamim Ahmad, DOB-07/08/1987, MES No.-
423948 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o-73/D, New MES
Colony, Kodariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
Page 16 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
17
66. Rahul Barore S/o Shri Suresh Chandra Barore, DOB-27/06/1986,
MES No.- 423794 Working As- Refrigerator MechanicHigh Skilled -II R/o-
/61 Dharnaka Krishnpura Rishala Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
67. Shri Abhishek Kumar Suman S/o Shri Hem chand Sharma, DOB-
05/01/1993, MES No.- 423877 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-47/4
MES Colony Behind AGE E/M No.1 Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
68. Sanjeev Ninama S/o Shri Mohanlal Ninama, DOB-16/05/1985, MES
No.- 423790 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o- Shitla Mata Gali,
Kodariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
69. Ishaq Khan S/o Shri Fakira Khan, DOB-15/05/1983, MES No.-
423792 Working As- Electrician High Skilled - II R/o- 1495 Chander marg
Patti Bazar Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
70. Vinod Kumar Nasna S/o Shri Bhanwari lal Nasna, DOB-04/06/1992,
MES No.- 423926 Working As- Mate Electrician R/o- Ward No. 4,
Kacholiya, Jaitpura, Jaipur (RJ)-303704
71. Prakash Chand S/o Shri Hari Shankar, DOB-05/11/1988, MES No.-
375935 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- TF 119/04 Sapper Enclave
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
72. Hari Ram S/o Shri Bahadur Mal, DOB-15/05/1994, MES No.-423937
Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Napawali Neem Ka Thana, Sikar (RJ)-
332001
73. Radheshyam S/o Shri Devi Singh, DOB-02/02/1965, MES No.- 423396
Working As- Electrician High Skilled-1 R/o- Vill. Jamli Mhow, Dist. Indore
(M.P.)-453441
74. Rajesh Meena S/o Shri Heera Meena, DOB-04/10/1987, MES No.-
423934 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Vill- Bichpudi Post-Bamor
Teh+Distt-Tonk (RJ)-304001
75. Deepak Kulkarni S/o Shri Kashinath Kulkarni, DOB-23/03/1965, MES
No.- 423585 Working As- Master Craft Man Electrician R/o- H.No. C-409
Space Park Nepaneya, Indore (M.P)-455001
76. Mithilesh Kumar Mahto S/o Shri Suresh Mahto, DOB-07/05/1984,
MES No.- 423813 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-65/3 MES Colony
Near EME Work Shop Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
Page 17 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
18
77. Gourav Meshram S/o Shri Surendra Meshram, DOB-05/02/1992, MES
No.- 423812 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-54/1 Teligraph Road Near
Station HQ Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
78. Yogendra Singh Thakur S/o Shri Vikram Singh Thakur, DOB-
12/10/1985, MES No.-423804 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly
Skilled-ll R/o- Vill-Nanded Post-Kamdpur, Tehsil- Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-
453441
79. Saddam Hussain S/o Shri Jahur Mohammed, DOB-15/02/1992, MES
No.-701232 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Keshar Park Colony New
Garadiya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441.
80. Narendra Singh Yadav S/o Shri Dharam Pal singh Yadav, DOB-
30/06/1966, MES No.- А/14574950H Working As- Fitter General
Mechanic Skilled R/o-664A Kundon Nagar, Street No. 9 RR CAT Road,
Indore (M.P)-452013
81. Ashish Suryawanshi S/o Shri bhim Rao suryawanshi, DOB-
19/08/1991, MES No.-423935 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-83
Babu Gali Raj Mohala Mhow, Dist Indore (M.P)-453441
82. Raju S/o Late Chhotelal, DOB-01/06/1962, MES No.- 423580 Working
As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- H.No. 1244 Dhan Ji Shah Mhow, Dist. Indore
(M.P)-453441
83. Suresh Champat Rao Datir S/o Shri Champat Rao Datir, DOB-
17/10/1965, MES No.-423763 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- Kerli Teli
Khedha Mitra Colony Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
84. Ravi Singh S/o Shri Prem Singh, DOB-30/09/1987, MES No.- 423782
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled-11 R/o- Banglo No.
144 Simroll Road Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
85. Abdul Salam S/o Shri Abdul Wahab, DOB-04/05/1983, MES No.-
414047 Working As- Valve men R/o- 24 Banda Basti Mhow, Dist. Indore
(M.P)-453441
86. Mahesh Kanasiya S/o Shri Budhiya, DOB-02/02/1987, MES No.-
422756 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled-11 R/o- Vill-
Bagoda Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
Page 18 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
19
87. Bharat Singh S/o Late Ram Singh, DOB-01/10/1984, MES No.-422754
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o- H. No. 34 Shree Nath
colony Mhow Gaon (MP)-453441
88. Bhagawan Singh S/o Late Pannalal, DOB-15/03/1968, MES No.-
423621 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o-66/2 MES Colony Bihnd
Rajeshwar School Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441.
89. Rahul Mehroliya S/o Late Laxman Mehroliya, DOB-04/06/1990, MES
No.- 423780 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o-51 Mall Road
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
90. Deepak Dawar S/o Shri Bhagwan Singh Dawar, DOB-13/10/1992,
MES No.- 423786 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Highly Skilled-11
R/o-66/7 MES Colony Bihnd Rajeshwar School Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-
453441
91. Nilesh Godale S/o Shri Sunil Godale, DOB-29/11/1990, MES No.-
423808 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic High Skilled-II R/o- 19/5
Rejiment Bazar Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
92. Mukesh Yadav S/o Shri Ramesh Chand Yadav, DOB-24/02/1975, MES
No.-423701 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-11 R/o-Near
Sardar Vidyalya 1070/7 Kodariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
93. Prem Singh Thakur S/o Late Gokul Singh, DOB-25/08/1965, MES
No.- 423590 Working As- Master Craft Man Electrician R/o-302/16 Shivaji
Nagar Indore (MP)-452001
94. Mehmood Khan S/o Late Abdol Gaffar, DOB-20/07/1969, MES No.-
423674 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o- Plot No. 6 Sidak Nagar
Dongar Gaon, New Mhow(MP)-453441
95. Sourabh Godale S/o Shri Hansraj Godale, DOB-06/02/1992, MES No.-
423784 Working As- Refrigerator MechanicHigh Skilled-II R/o- Pension
Pura Garden 140/141 Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
96. Vinod Suresh Subedar S/o Shri Suresh Subedar, DOB-01/01/1977,
MES No.- 1588090L Working As- Mason Skilled R/o- H. No. 352 Vil.
Warshi Dist. Dhule Tel. shindkloda
Page 19 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
20
97. Satyanarayan Gupta S/o Late Balmukund Gupta, DOB-13/05/1962,
MES No.- 423592 Working As- Master Craft Man Fitter General Mechanic
R/o- 126, Sukdev Nagar Near Air Port Road, Indore (M.P)-452006.
98. Rahul Tayade S/o Late Damaji Tayade, DOB-04/06/1962, MES No.-
423624 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-1 R/o- B-41 Amarpali Town
Ship Sonya, Indore (M.P)- 452001
99. Mohd Ayaz S/o Late Mohd Yousuf Khan, DOB-17/06/1962, MES No.-
423611 Working As- Master Craft Man Electrician R/o-114/3 Juna
Rasioala, Indore (M.P)- 452001
100. Shashank Vaishampayan S/o Late Prabhakar Vaishampayan, DOB-
19/12/1962, MES No.- 423579 Working As- Master Craft Man Vehicle
Mechanic R/o- 119-B Silver Oak Colony (Anna Purna Road), Indore (M.P)
452009
101. Ellis Joseph S/o Late Joseph Micheal, DOB-29/01/1958, MES No.-
423545 Working As- Master Craft Man Refrigerator Mechanic R/o- 85 Nova
Classics behind Vaitnari Collage Bor Kheda Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-
453441
102. Kelash Chand S/o Late Jagannath, DOB-01/07/1960, MES No.-
413682 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-11 R/o- A-292
Samarth Park, Umariya, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
103. Ishwar Chand Gangrade S/o Late Swarup Chand, DOB-29/07/1962,
MES No.- 423541 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- H. No. 371 Kishan
ganj Old AB Raod, 'Near Gram Panchayat Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
104. Hukam Singh S/o Late Musaddilal, DOB-05/07/1962, MES No.-
423589 Working As- Master Craft Man Electrician R/o-491/15 Megdut
Nagar Indore (M.P)-452011
105. Muksh Verma S/o Late Ram Verma, DOB-19/12/196215/08/1961,
MES No.- 423610 Working As- Master Craft Man Electrician R/o-18-19
krishna Kunj Colony gujar Kheda Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441.
106. Shivnarayan Yadav S/o Late Babulal Yadav, DOB-05/08/1961, MES
No.- 423598 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o- 181 Hammal
Colony Indore (M.P) 452006
Page 20 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
21
107. Mahesh kumar S/o Late Dhannalal, DOB-28/12/1960, MES No.-
423601 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o-145 Addiwasi bhil
Colony Musakhedi Indore (M.P) 452006
108. Sohan Lal S/o Late Chotelal, DOB-02/07/1961, MES No.- 413755
Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o- H.No. 3251 Lal Ji Ki Basti
Garibpura Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
109. Brij Nandan S/o Late Sitaram Goswami, DOB-15/07/1962, MES No.-
420349 Working As- Mason Mate R/o-C 307/308 Sarthak Galaxy, Rau,
Rangwasa, Indore (M.P) 453441
110. Sushil Kumar Sitole S/o Shri Balkishan Sitole, DOB-01/01/1990,
MES No.- 423793 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-11
R/o-68 Rajat Green Kodariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
111. Santosh Kumar Betha S/o Shri Rajendra Prasad Baitha, DOB-
21/11/1982, MES No.-423798 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o-461Sai
Residency Sim Rol Raod Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
112. Ashwani Verma S/o Shri Jagdish Verma, DOB-07/01/1983, MES No.-
423781 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o-51 Ram Mandir ke pass Dongar
Gaon Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
113. Deepak Patidar S/o Shri Mangilal Patidar, DOB-04/06/1991, MES
No.- 423825 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o-1003 Near Sardar Patel
School, Kodariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
114. Jitendra Kumar Dawar S/o Shri Mannu Lal Dawar, DOB-
24/03/1985, MES No.-423789 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- Vill-
Badipura Betma Teh- Depalpur, Indore 453001.
115. Rahul Dubele S/o Shri Govind Dubele, DOB-14/12/1986, MES No.-
423795 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- H.No. 6 Krishnapura Dharnaka
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
116. Shrikant Sharma S/o Late Ramesh Chandra Sharma, DOB-
03/10/1985, MES No.- 423829 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-79 A
Nagin Nagar, Indore (M.P)-452005
117. Anand Yadav S/o Shri Radhe Shyam, DOB-17/10/1987, MES No.-
423806 Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o- T-6/2 MES Colny Near IB
Bunglow Kodariya Road Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
Page 21 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
22
118. Vikas Chouhan S/o Shri Kailash Chouhan, DOB-23/01/1985, MES
No.- 423779 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o-2092 A Samarth Park
Umariya (MP)-453331
119. Smt. Padma W/o Late Kishan Kamble, DOB-03/08/1969, MES No.-
423687 Working As- Mate Painter R/o-136 Keshavanand Colony, Kodariya
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
120. Smt. Ranjeeta Gamod W/o Shri Ankush Gamod, DOB-21/05/1992,
MES No.-423778 Working As- Mate Painter R/o- Vill - Khurdi (Awar)
Manpur, Teh- Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
121. Hukum Chand S/o Late Baldev ji Gohar, DOB-28/03/1960, MES No.-
413687 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o- Pensionpura Mhow, Dist. Indore
(M.P)-453441
122. Ramlal Barud S/o Late Gaburiya Barud, DOB-02/08/1988, MES No.-
423796 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o- A-87 Naya Mhow
Dongar Gaon Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441.
123. Mohd Nasir S/o Late Mohd Ismiel, DOB-19/03/1966, MES No.-
423652 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-1 R/o-184 Gram
New Guradiya, Mhow, Post Choradiya, Indore (M.P)-453441
124. Vikas Singh Parihar S/o Shri Shiv Kumar Singh Parihar, DOB-
01/06/1986, MES No.- 422773 Working As- Fitter General
MechanicSkilled R/o-47/3 MES Colony Mall Road Mhow, Dist. Indore
(M.P)-453441
125. Rajendra Kumar S/o Late Bhagirat, DOB-25/03/1967, MES No.-
423617 Working As- Master Craft Man Fitter General Mechanic R/o-40 Sai
Dham Colony Umariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
126. Zechariah George Williams S/o Late I. George Williams, DOB-
05/08/1966, MES No.- A/13967857W Working As- Mate Valve Men R/o-
Banglow No. 51 Mall Road, Mhow, Teh- Mhow, Dist. Indore (MP)-453441
127. Girdhari Lal S/o Late Nandram, DOB-20/10/1963, MES No.-423618
Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o-963 Pithampur, Dhar (M.P)-454001
128. Omprakash S/o Late Heralal, DOB-15/12/1960, MES No.- 423548
Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o-21 Krishnpura Dharnaka
Mhow (MP)-453441
Page 22 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
23
129. Mohd Jaffar S/o Late Mohd Yasin, DOB-30/01/1960, MES No.-
423597 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o- H.No. 80/16 Malwa
Green Signal Vihar Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441
130. Gopal S/o Late Mangilal, DOB-10/03/1961, MES No.- 423602
Working As- Black Smith HighSkilled-11 R/o-H.No. 117 Gawli Palasia
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
131. Rajkumar S/o Late Subash Chandra, DOB-31/03/1961, MES No.-
423539 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o-103 Telikheda Jail
Road Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441.
132. Bhagwan Karole S/o Shri Rewaram Karole, DOB-03/01/1961, MES
No.- 423641 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-1 R/o-177 Decent
Residency Near Malviy nagar, Mhow (M.P)-453441
133. Ramkishore S/o Late Ramtehel, DOB-20/03/1962, MES No.- 413610
Working As- Pipe Fitter HighSkilled-II R/o-138 Bhagat Singh nagar Indore
(M.P) 452015
134. Smt. Begam Bee W/o Late Jabbar, DOB-04/09/1968, MES No.-
423690 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o-16/3 Old MES Colony Post
Office Road Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441
135. Rakesh Girwal S/o Shri Ram lal Girwal, DOB-02/04/1984, MES No.-
423765 Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o- Vill. Khurdi Post Tehsil Mhow
Distt. Indore (MP)-452001
136. Laxmi Narayan S/o Shri Ballabh Prasad, DOB-05/02/1967, MES No.-
1577598P Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o- Vill.+ Post Ramgah, Rajgarh,
Tehsil- Zirapur (MP)-465691
137. Anand Chouhan S/o Shri Rameshwar Chouhan, DOB-10/07/1982,
MES No.- 423818 Working As- Pipe Fitter R/o- H.No. 102 Ward No. 13
Betma The-Depalpur, Dist- Indore (M.P)-452001
138. Jitendra Jadhav S/o Shri Gulab Jadhav, DOB-05/07/1988, MES No.-
423775 Working As- Pipe Fitter R/o- H.No. 118 Palak City Colony Jail road
Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441
139. Hari Shankar Gour S/o Shri Kailash Prashad Gour, DOB-
10/08/1964, MES No.- 194216 Working As- Mate Painter R/o- H.No. 36
Sanskriti Park AB Road Rau, Indore (M.P)-452001
Page 23 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
24
140. Mohammed Altaf S/o Shri Mohammed Ilyas, DOB-20/05/1988, MES
No.- 423785 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-11 R/o-
H.No. 23 Banda Basti Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P)-453441
141. Pawan Tamboli S/o Shri Suresh Tamboli, DOB-19/10/1989, MES
No.-433803 Working As- Pipe Fitter R/o-A181 Ayoudhayapuri Colony
Kodariy Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P)-453441
142. Khushiyal S/o Late Pyarelal, DOB-08/01/1964, MES No.- 423679
Working As- Mason HighSkilled-11 R/o- H.No. 291 Kishanganj Gram
Panchayat Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
143. Jiya Lal S/o Shri Babu Lal, DOB-03/12/1967, MES No.- 413607
Working As- Mason HighSkilled-1 R/o- H.No. 699 New Gauri Nagar, Indore
(M.P)- 452001
144. Jagdish Chandra Salawat S/o Late Mangilal, DOB-03/08/1967, MES
No.- 423573 Working As- Painter Skilled R/o-381 AB Road Jamli Mhow,
Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
145. Vinay Godale S/o Shri Vijay Godale, DOB-01/07/1991, MES No.-
423791 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-11 R/o-102
Anapurna Vistar Colony Kodariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
146. Sandeep Verma S/o Late Mata Prashad, DOB-08/09/1982, MES No.-
423797 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o-194 Rajat Green Colony Kodariya
Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P)-453441
147. Dinesh Kumar Verma S/o Late Sathiram Verma, DOB-02/07/1959,
MES No.- 423614 Working As- Master Craft Man Carpenter R/o-Oil Mill
Colony Gurjar Khedha Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
148. Bir Singh S/o Late Tak Bahdur, DOB-08/12/1959, MES No.- 413574
Working As- Mason HighSkilled-11 R/o-93 Gangla Khedi Mhow (MP)-
453441.
149. Mahadev S/o Late Lakshman Jadhav, DOB-17/04/1959, MES No.-
413605 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-1 R/o-61 Bhagirath Colony
Dhar Naka Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
150. Sri Bahadur S/o Sri Sivaji Ram, DOB-01/01/1969, MES No.-
Ex1581136A Working As- Fitter General Mechanic Skilled R/o-94/B
telekeda Anna Colony Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
Page 24 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
25
151. Suresh Kumar S/o Late Bhaggu Prasad, DOB-16/05/1961, MES No.-
413726 Working As- Fitter General MechanicSkilled R/o-160 Malviya Nagar
Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453446
152. Sheikh Khalil S/o Late Sheikh Abdul, DOB-01/07/1962, MES No.-
420420 Working As- Pipe Fitter High Skilled-1 R/o-TCB 54/2 Telegraph
Road Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
153. Kailash Chandra S/o Late Kanheyalal, DOB-18/10/1962, MES No.-
413760 Working As- Master Craft Man Carpenter R/o- H. No. 36-C
Penshanpura Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
154. Nagji lal S/o Late Gandalal, DOB-14/11/1962, MES No.-423506
Working As- Pipe Fitter High Skilled-1 R/o-39 New Guradia Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.P)-453441
155. Rajendra Loth S/o Late Shankar Loth, DOB-17/05/1963, MES No.-
602181 Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o- Ayodhya Puri Colony
Kodariya Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441
156. Yuvraj Gogliya S/o Late Rajkumar Gogliya, DOB-21/10/1982,
Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o-1671 Gokul Ganj Mhow,
Dist.Indore (M.P)-453441
157. Kailash Chandra S/o Shri Murlidhar, DOB-28/02/1964, MES No.-
423631 Working As- Master Craft Man R/o- H. No.-93 Mehta ki Chaln
Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441.
158. Md Naim S/o Shri Abdul Sattar, DOB-03/01/1972, MES No.-423686
Working As- Mate Painter R/o- H. No.- 51 Hadrabadi Basti Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.P)-453441
159. Chotte Lal S/o Shri Gopilal, DOB-12/02/1968, MES No.-423577
Working As- Painter Skilled R/o- New Mhow Dongar Gaon, Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.P)-453441
160. Yogesh Yadav S/o Shri Mangilal Yadav, DOB-27/03/1983, MES No.-
423787 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-11 R/o- H. No.
3160, Chota teli Mohalla Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
161. Hasan Ali Devani S/o Shri Mohd Ali Devani, DOB-29/09/1973, MES
No.- 1585239W Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o- TCB-54/03 Telegarph
Road Near Stn HQ Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441
Page 25 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
26
162. Kuldeep Baswe S/o Shri Kailash Chand, DOB-07/09/1991, MES No.-
423777 Working As- Carpenter High Skilled-ll R/o- H. No. 35-36 Vianayak
Vihar Colony Kodariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
163. Anil Kumar Chouhan S/o Shri Sitaram Chouhan, DOB-15/06/1988,
MES No.- 423885 Working As- Carpenter High Skilled-11 R/o- H. No.- 518
Maiviya Mohalla Kodariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
164. Ramshankar Yadav S/o Shri Ramdas Yadav, DOB-02/05/1988, MES
No.- 423820 Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o- TC-12/02 Old MES
Colony Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441
165. Vijay Kumar S/o Shri Balkishan, DOB-11/12/1971, MES No.-
423681 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic HighSkilled-1 R/o- H. No.-
62/07 Behind Rajeshwar Vidhalaya Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P)-453441.
166. Smt. Vandana Maurya W/o Ashok Maurya, DOB-26/06/1972, MES
No.- 164690 Working As- Mate Painter R/o- H. No. 167/A Royal Residence
Bhatkedi Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P)-453441
167. Kallu S/o Shri Babulal, DOB-10/01/1962, MES No.- 423475 Working
As- Painter Skilled R/o-H. No.02 Simrol Road Gujerkheda Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.P)-453441
168. Suresh Kumar S/o Shri Mohan Lal, DOB-08/03/1962, MES No.-
423664 Working As- Painter Skilled R/o- H. No. 12/55 Anna Colony Mhow,
Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
169. Abdul lateef S/o Shri Mohd Hussain, DOB-08/10/1962, MES No.-
423527 Working As- Carpenter High Skilled-1 R/o- H. No. 108, Patti Bazar
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
170. Rajkumar S/o Shri Ramdayal, DOB-09/02/1960, MES No.- 423556
Working As- Painter Skilled R/o- Oil Mill Gujarkjheda Mhow, Dist. Indore
(M.P)-453441
171. Israil S/o Shri Roshan, DOB-10/07/1962, MES No.- 423574 Working
As- Painter R/o-23, Banda Basti Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
172. Ramlal S/o Shri Ramgopal, DOB-10/10/1959, MES No.- 423508
Working As- Electrician HighSkilled-11 R/o- 25 Chandra Vihar Colony,
Umariya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P)-453441
Page 26 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
27
173. Subhash Kumar Songar S/o Shri Poonam Chand Songar, DOB-
01/11/1986, MES No.- 423822 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic High
Skilled -II R/o-86 ShivNagar Colony Dharnaka, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-
453441
174. Sanjay Katare S/o Late Krishna Katare, DOB-29/06/1979, MES No.-
MES T-44 Working As- FGM High Skilled -II R/o-255/01 Durga Colony
Telikhada, Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P.)-453441.
175. Sanjay Kori S/o Late Sitaram Kori, DOB-05/03/1980, MES No.- MES-
42880 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o-75/A MES Colony
Near MES IB, Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P.)-453441
176. Manish Kumar Saini S/o Shri Babulal Saini, DOB-18/05/1994, MES
No.- MES-423903 Working As- Electrician Skilled-1 R/o- 14/03 Old MES
colony near Amry Public school, Mhow, Dist. Indore(M.P.)-453441
177. Govind Singh S/o Late Bahadur Singh, DOB-04/02/1986, MES No.-
423823 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic R/o-TCB 54/4 Teligraph Road
Near Stn Hq Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
178. Ashok Kumar S/o Shri Late Asha Ram JI, DOB-29/09/1961, MES
No.-423599 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o-41A Kalindi Vihar
Borkhedi Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.P.)-453441
179. Poonam Chand S/o Late Shri Magi Lal, DOB-15/11/1960, MES No.-
413729 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o-81 Kalindi Vihar
Borkhedi Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
180. Guddu Prasad Yadav S/o Shri Arjun Prasad Yadav, DOB-
05/05/1993, MES No.- 195894 Working As- Mate Electrician R/o-63/7
MES colony near Rajeshwar school, Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P.)-453441
181. Amar Verma S/o Shri Raj Verma, DOB-13/05/1987, MES No.-423760
Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled-II R/o-33-Mahesh Nager DharnakaMhow,
Dist.Indore(M.P.)-453441
182. Ravi Kumar Kashyap S/o Late Pannalal Kashyap, DOB-09/10/1982,
MES No.- 422764 Working As- Mate Pipe Fiter R/o-326 Regiment Bazar,
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
Page 27 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
28
183. Dara Singh S/o Shri Mannalal Katare, DOB-05/06/1989, MES No.-
423882 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o- New Mhow,
Dongergaon Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
184. Sharad Singh Rajawat S/o Late Balwant Singh Rajawat, DOB-
28/05/1975, MES No.- T No-10982K Working As- Skilled FGM R/o-36
Suman Colony Mhowgaon Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
185. Radhey Shyam S/o Late Sewa Ram, DOB-25/08/1960, MES No.-
413724 Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o-103, Veer Maruti Nagar,
Mhowgaon Mhow, Dist. Indore(M.P.)-453331
186. Yogesh Kumar Verma S/o Shri Mahesh Chandra Verma, DOB-
11/09/1990, MES No.- 423907 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-63/8,
MES colony near Rajeshwar school, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
187. Mohan Lal Meena S/o Shri Prabhu Dayal Meena, DOB-01/07/1989,
MES No.-423905 Working As- FGM Skilled R/o-63/2, MES colony near
Rajeshwar schoo, Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.Ρ.)-453441
188. Vaibhav Sharma S/o Shri Ravindra Sharma, DOB-03/01/1986, MES
No.-423888 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o-72, Anand Dham
Colony Devguvadia, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
189. Raju S/o Late Munnu Swamy, DOB-12/10/1962, MES No.-413613
Working As- Pipe Fitter Skilled R/o-40decent residenvy kisnaganj Mhow,
Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
190. Mukesh Singare S/o Shri Raysingh Singare, DOB-05/09/1984, MES
No.- 423761 Working As- Mate P/Fitr R/o- T/11 Near MES IB Bunglow
Mhow, Dist. Indore(M.P.)-453441
191. Rahul Kumar S/o Shri Bhola Ram, DOB-12/02/1989, MES No.-
423915 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-76/C MES Colony IB Bunglow,
Mhow, Dist. Indore(M.P.)-453441.
192. Gyan Chand S/o Late Lotan Lal, DOB-26/04/1962, MES No.- 413593
Working As-Electrician High Skilled - 1 R/o-286 Kishanganj Mhow, Dist.
Indore (M.P.)-453441
193. Dharmendra Malviya S/o Shri Ghasiram Malviya, DOB-06/06/1983,
MES No.- 423830 Working As- Ref/Mech Skilled R/o- Aamachandan
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
Page 28 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
29
194. Antar Singh S/o Shri Amar Singh, DOB-04/01/1968, MES No.-
423388 Working As- Ref/Mech High Skilled -I R/o- 72 New Mhow Dongar
Goan Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
195. Gopal Javhare S/o Shri Prabhudas Javhare, DOB-02/11/1974, MES
No.-423728 Working As- Mate Painter R/o-4, Kunwar Mandli Dist. Indore
(M.P.)-453441
196. Ajay Kumar S/o Shri Sushil Kumar Prabhakar, DOB-06/04/1985,
MES No.- 423838 Working As- Mate Carpenter R/o-61/5 MES Colony Mall
Road Mhow, Dist.Indore(M.Ρ.)-453441
197. Nitin Joshi S/o Shri Satish Chandra Joshi, DOB-04/03/1986, MES
No.-423824 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- I/G2 Vastuapoitment
Aquwapoint Umriya Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
198. Sunil Singh Yadav S/o Shri Devi Singh Yadav, DOB-22/06/1982,
MES No.- 423809 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- House No 05, Kamla
Nagar Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P.)-453441
199. Jitendra Pardesi S/o Late Ramchandra Pradeshi, DOB-03/07/1971,
MES No.-423712 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-40,Decent Residency
Kishanganj, Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P.)-453441
200. Rahul Bariya S/o Shri Amar Singh Bariya, DOB-29/04/1992, MES
No.- 424448 Working As- Mate Electrician R/o- Mundla, Kalibawdi
Dharampuri, Dist. Dhar(M.P.)-454449.
201. Suresh Kumar S/o Late Sunder Lal, DOB-10/02/1960, MES No.-
413586 Working As- Electrician High Skilled-II R/o-268/B Samerth Park,
Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P.)-453441
202. Nand Kishore S/o Late Ramesh Chandra Shriwas, DOB-02/04/1962,
MES No.- 423588 Working As- Electrician MCM R/o- No 95,5-A Scheme No
78 Aranya Nagar, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-452010
203. Paul Francis S/o Late Awean Francis, DOB-12/05/1967, MES No.-
423706 Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic R/o-102, Rukmani Vihar
Mhow, Dist.Indore (M.P.)-453441
204. Chandan Biwal S/o Shri Ghanshyam Biwal, DOB-29/11/1988, MES
No.- 423758 Working As- Mate Semi Skilled R/o-48 Pensionpura, Mhow,
Dist.Indore (M.P.)-453441
Page 29 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
30
205. Rajesh Kumar Pandey S/o Shri Brijraj Pandey, DOB-28/02/1991,
MES No.- 423854 Working As- Mate Semi Skilled R/o- Vill & Post Mahuon,
P.S Bihiya Dist Bhojpur Bihar 802183
206. Bhupendra Singh Saini S/o Shri Sanwar mal Saini, DOB-
04/07/1994, MES No.- 423904 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Ratan
Shahr Post Islampur, Jhunjhunu (RJ)-333024
207. Sunil girwal S/o Shri Chhotelal Girwal, DOB-30/05/1989, MES No.-
423881 Working As- FGM Skilled R/o- T 7/1 MES Colony Kodariya Road
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
208. Sukhdev S/o Late Rupsingh, DOB-15/09/1965, MES No.- 423653
Working As- Carpenter Skilled R/o-T 12/5 MES Colony Kodariya Road
Mhow, Dist. Indore (M.P.)-453441
209. Mohd Babu S/o Shri mohd Gani, DOB-10/07/1969, MES No.-
423673 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter R/o-74, Hyderabadi Basti Mhow,
Dist. Indore(M.P.)-453441.
210. Shyamlal Pal S/o Late Dinanath Pal,DOB-24/07/1960, MES No.-
423603,Retired As- Electrician Highly Skilled-II R/o- H.No. 20,
Shankarganj Main Road, Indore (MP)-452001
211. Nripendra Singh S/o Jitendra Singh,DOB-06/09/1992, MES No.-
423906 Working As- Mate (Elect.) R/o- H.No. 568/5-A Sainik Colony,
Bhatta Gaon, Jhansi (UP)-284001
212. Rajendra Singh Chouhan S/o Late Lal Singh Chouhan DOB-
29/03/1963, MES No.-423608 Retired As- Electrician Highly Skilled-I
R/o-148A Sector-B, Near Sangam Nagar, Indore (MP)-284001.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Vijay Tr ipathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110001.
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Head
Quarter of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg Defence
Head Quater, New Delhi 110010.
Page 30 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
31
3. Chief Engineer, (Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service Central
Command Lucknow (UP) 226001
4. Chief Engineer(Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service, Jabalpur
Zone Lekhanagar Ridge road Jabalpur (MP)-482001
5. Commander Works Engineer (Head Quarter) Military Engineering
Service, 153, Ashok Marg, Mhow (MP) 453441
6. Garrison Engineer, Military college of Telecommunication Engineering),
Mhow - 453441 (M.P).
7. Garrison Engineer (Infantry School), Mhow - 453441 (M.P).
8. Garrision Engineer (Army War College), Mhow - 453441 (M.P).
......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri P.K. Chaurasia
Original Application No. 1117 of 2023
1. Nazir Ahmed Ansari, S/o Habib Ahmed, D.O.B. 1.7.1964, working as
FGM (HS-II) in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)- 482011
2. Basant Kumar, S/o Late Makhanlal, D.O.B. 7.7.1989, Occupation-
working as Mate FGM in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
3. Kuldeep Singh Marko, S/o Gautam Singh Marko, D.O.B. 7.6.1987,
working as Electrician SK, in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
4. Anees Ahmed, S/o Late Sheikh Nazeer, D.O.B. 5.7.1980, working as
Mate/Electrician in the O/% Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
5. Shubham Kumar, S/o Lakhanlal, D.O.B. 5.7.1973, working as
Mate/Electrician in the O/% Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
Page 31 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
32
6. Mahendra Kumar, S/o Badlu Lal Patel, D.O.B. 5.7.1993, working as
FGM SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services,
near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
7. Rajkumar Kanojiya, S/o Jagdish Prasad, D.O.B. 10.7.1985, working as
Vehicle Mechanic SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
8. Ashraf Ali, S/o Jan Mohammad, D.O.B. 3.4.1967, working as Electrician
HS-1 in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services,
near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
9. Sushil Kuma, S/o Late Jagatram, D.O.Β. 15.6.1967, working as
Electrician in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
10. Rajendra Uraon, S/o Late Dharmat Uraon, D.O.B. 23.1.1964, working
as Electrician HS-II in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
11. Sandeep Kumar, S/o Basant Lal, D.O.B. 14.6.1994, working as
Carpentor SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
12. Vishnu Prasad, S/o Bahadur, D.O.B. 1977, working as FGM HS-I in the
O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near COD,
Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
13. Rajeev Kumar, S/o Mahadev Prasad Tiwari, D.O.B. 10.10.1991,
working as FGM (SK) in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
14. Kamlesh Vishwakarma, S/o Sharda Prasad Vishwakarma, D.O.B.
16.9.1976, working as Refrigerator Mechanic HS-II in the O/o Garison
Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District
Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
15. Heeralal S/o Late Gend Ram, D.O.B. 06.07.1961, working as Mate FGM
in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near
COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
Page 32 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
33
16. Ramgopal Singh, S/o Late Ramsidda Singh, D.O.B. 20.3.1987, working
as FGM HS-II. in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
17. Kalluram Meena, S/o Jaganlal Meena, D.O.B. 18.7.1980, working as
FGM SK-I in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
18. Kapil Jain, S/o Krishna Kumar Jain, D.O.B. 20.8.1990, working as
Mate/FGM in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
19. Rakesh Kumar, S/o Mohanlal, D.O.B. 12.6.1980, working as
Electrician SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
20. Gendalal, S/o Bachairam, D.O.B. 10.8.1963, Retired FGM SH-I in the
O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near COD,
Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
21. Suresh, S/o Late Fakir, D.O.B. 1.9.1967, working as FGM SK in the
O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near COD,
Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011.
22. Rajesh Kumar, S/o Mohanlal, D.O.B. 2.5.1983, working as Electrician
SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near
COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
23. Reva Prasad, S/o Late Lalman, D.O.B. 11.6.1965, working as FGM SH-I
in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near
COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
24. Sandeep Kumar, S/o Kailash Kumar, D.O.B. 20.6.1983, working as
Electrician HS in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
25. Prakash Chandra Saini, S/o Bhoora Saini, D.O.B. 1.5.1995, working as
Mate/Electrician in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
26. Ramswaroop, S/o Birbalram, D.O.B. 2.11.1984, working as
Mate/Electrician in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
Page 33 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
34
27. Naresh Paryani, S/o Ashok Biryani, D.O.B. 3.6.1993, working as FGM
SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near
COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
28. Satish Kumar, S/o Laxman Prasad, D.O.B. 10.7.1973, working as
Carpentor SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
29. Vibhuti Raman, S/o Punnuram, D.O.B. 25.1.1983, working as Pipe
Fitter SH-II in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
30. Buddhsen Yadav, S/o Late Moolchand Yadav, D.O.B. 6.1.1966, working
as Mesian SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
31. Basant Kumar Bohat, S/o Late Makhanlal Bohat, D.O.B. 7.7.1989,
working as FGM (SK) in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, Near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
32. Sunil Joseph, S/o Late E. Joseph, D.O.B. 9.8.1963, working as
Mechanic HS-I in the O/0 Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
33. Sandeep Kumar S/o Late Narmada Prasad, D.O.B. 26.4.1988, working
as Mate/FGM in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
34. Ram Sundar Singh, S/o Sheshnag Singh, D.O.B. 5.2.1989, working as
Mate/FGM in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
35. Ram Singh Rathor, S/o Late Vijay Singh Rathor, D.O.B. 19.8.1988,
working as MGM in the O/0 Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, Districi Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
36. Ajendra Singh, S/o Virendra Singh, D.O.B. 12.2.1973, working as FGM
SK in the O/o ZEM Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services,
near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
37. Rajendra Prasad Yadav, S/o Late Ramlal Yadav, D.O.B. 1.7.1963,
working as FGM HS in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
Page 34 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
35
38. Anshul Sahu, S/o Ashok Sahu, D.O.B. 1 11.10.1986, working as
Mate... FGM... in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
39. Mukesh Kumar, S/o Mohanlal, D.O.B. 25.6.1979, working as
Electrician SK. In the O/o GE (West) Supply Depot, Sadar Cantt. Jabalpur
(M.P.) Pin Code-482001.
40. Trilok Kumar Katre, S/o Bhikam Singh Katre, D.O.B. 16.7.1984,
working as FGM (SK) in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
41. Dharmendra Kumar Sahu, S/o Shri Kunwar Singh Sahu, D.O.B.
5.11.1963, Occupation working as Carpenter HS-1 in the O/o Garison
Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District
Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011.
42. Swapnil Koshti, S/o Hariram Koshti, D.O.B. 26.5.1990, working as
FGM SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services,
near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
43. Abhinandan Koshta, S/o Khemchand Koshta, D.O.B. 2.4.1993, working
as FGM SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
44. Hariom Jangela, S/o Todelal Jangela, D.O.B. 11.9.1993, working as
FGM SK in the O/o अफ Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
45. K.K. Dwivedi, S/o Laxman Prasad Dwivedi, D.O.B. 25.4.1982, working
as Pipe Fitter SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
46. Kamla Prasad, S/o Phoolchand Kol, D.O.B. 15.4.1966, working as
Masin SK in the O/% Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
47. Abhishek Sahu, S/o Santosh Sahu, D.O.B. 10.11.1982, working as
FGM SK in the O/0 Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services,
near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
Page 35 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
36
48. Ankit Dhobi, S/o Balvant Singh Dhobi, D.O.В. Adult working as
Electrician SK in the O/0 Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
49. Puneet Kumar Soni S/o Kashi Ram Soni, D.O.B. 19.05.1986, working
as Electrician in the O/% Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
50. Ashok Giri Goswami, S/o Madan Giri Goswami, D.O.B. 16.10.1982,
working as Mate MGM in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
51. Umesh Kumar, S/o Late Natthulal, D.O.B. 1.7.1963, working as FGM
HS in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near
COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
52. Raghuvendra Singh Solanki, S/o Pancham Singh Solanki, D.O.B.
24.7.1970, working as Mate in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military
Engineering Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
53. Sirajuddin Ansari, S/o Late Minhaj Bux, D.O.Β. 2.7.1967, working as
FGM SK in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services,
near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
54. Sikandar Kumar, S/o Rajendra Prasad, D.O.Β. 17.5.1985, working as
Mate/FGM in the O/0 Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011
55. Tejpal, S/o Gururam Bhakar, D.O.B. 11.6.1995, working as Mate/FGM
in the O/o Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near
COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (M.P.)-482011
56. Munnalal Sharma, S/o Bansilal Sharma, D.O.B. 13.11.1965, working
as Carpentor in the O/% Garison Engineer (East), Military Engineering
Services, near COD, Ranjhi, District Jabalpur (Μ.Ρ.)-482011.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri N. K. Agr awal
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110001.
Page 36 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
37
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Head
Quarter of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg Defence
Head Quater, New Delhi 110010.
3. Chief Engineer, MES, Jabalpur Zone Head Quarter, Ridge road,
Lekhanagar, Jabalpur, District Jabalpur (MP)-482001
4. Garrison Engineer (East), Military Engineering Services, near COD,
Ranjhi, District - Jabalpur (M.P) 482011.
5. Garrison Engineer (West), Military Engineeringh Services, Supply Depot
Road, Sadar, Cantt. Jabalpur, District Jabalpur (M.P) 482001.
Advocate for the respondents: P.K. Chaurasia
Original Application No. 215 of 2024
1. Amit Kumar Rawat S/o Late Ram Kishore, DOB-23.07.1981, MES No.-
414053 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- Vill-Pathrota, The-
Itarsi, Distt- Narmadapuram (MP)- 461001
2. Amba Ram S/o Late Bhagirath, DOB-03.02.1965, MES No.- 413914
Working As- Master Craftsman (Electrical) R/o- Vill- Nignoti, Post-Panodnai
Distt-Indore (MP)- 452001
3. Ashok Kumar Saini S/o Shri Anadi Lal Saini, DOB-30.05.1973, MES
No.- 413974 Working As- Electrician (HS-II), R/o- Vill- Shyampur, Berasia
Road, Distt-Bhopal (MP)-462001
4. Khuman Singh S/o Late Naval Singh, DOB-01.01.1977, MES No.-
413975 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- MES Colony, CTO, Bairagarh,
Bhopal (MP)-463111
5. Munesh Kumar S/o Shri Duli Chand Singh, DOB-01.06.1981, MES No.-
124959 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II), R/o- MES Colony, CTO,
Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-463111
6. Raj Kumar S/o Shri Ram Sukh, DOB-01.06.1986, MES No.- 414136
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II), R/o- Vill-Raghaipur, Distt-
Pratapgarh (UP)- 230001
7. Ankur Dwivedi S/o Late Ramesh Dwivedi, DOB-27.04.1989, MES No.-
414138 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Vill-Kundeshwar,
Distt-Tikamgarh (MP)-472001
Page 37 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
38
8. Sukant Tete S/o Shri Anjelus Tete, DOB-16.11.1990, MES No.-414142
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II), R/o- Vill-Jamtoli Kalotoli,
Distt- Simdega (JH)-835223
9. Bijesh Kumar Mahto S/o Shri Girja Mahto, DOB-23.03.1982, MES No.-
414057 Working As- Fitter Pipe (HS-II) R/o- Sainik Colony, Bairagarh Kala,
Bhopal (MP)-462030
10. Ram Sahay Sharma S/o Late R N Sharma, DOB-01.01.1966, MES No.-
A-14598832N Working As- Fitter Pipe (HS-II), R/o- MIG-145, Sanjeev
Nagar, Post-ML Nagar, Bhopal (MP)-462038
11. Suraj Bali S/o Late Tilak Ram, DOB-06.10.1964, MES No.- 413890
Working As- Mason (HS-II) R/o- Prem Nagar, Nariyal kheda, Bhopal (MP)-
462100
12. Nand Kishore S/o Late Dharmagaj, DOB-14.07.1971, MES No.-
1581719H Working As- Vehicle Mechanic (SK), R/o- Vill-Jamoniya Teh-
Tonkkhurd, distt-Dewas (MP)-455116
13. Ashwin Ashokrao Lokhande S/o Shri Ashok Sambaji Lokhande, DOB-
12.12.1992, MES No.- 617355 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK),
R/o- MES Colony, CTO, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-463111
14. Sudhir Kumar S/o Shri Jai Karan, DOB-02.11.1990, MES No.-414202
Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- Vill-Chankprithvipur BKT, Lucknow (UP)-
226201
15. Amit Sharma S/o Shri Kishan Lal, DOB-23.07.1996, MES No.-617118
Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Blomiya Nagar, First Kolwar Road,
Jhotwara, Jaipur (RJ)-302012
16. Laxmi Bai D/o Late Sitaram Keer, DOB-01.07.1965, MES No.- 422455
Working As- Mason (HS-I), R/o- Shikhar Parvt Complex, CTO, Bairagarh,
Bhopal (MP)-463111
17. Rajesh Kumar Meena S/o Shri Soraj Meena, DOB-20.06.1996, MES
No.- 610648 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Vill-Amarpora, Teh-
Bijoliya, Distt-Bhilwara (RJ)-311602
18. Arpit Yadav S/o Shri Rajendra Singh, DOB-15.07.1989, MES No.-
617604 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o-61/8, Vill- Shahpur, Teh-
Shikohabad, Distt-Firozabad (UP)-283135
Page 38 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
39
19. Rahul Chourey S/o Late Jai Kishan, DOB-13.07.1993, MES No.-
617423 Working As- Mate Electrician R/o- Vill-Bamhangaon khurd, Distt-
Narmadapura (MP)-461990
20. Suresh Singh Kushwah S/o Shri Ramnath Singh Kushwah, DOB-
01.02.1986, MES No.- 615497 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK)
R/o- Prem Nagar Jourakhuri gali-3, Murena (MP)-476001
21. Naveen Meshram S/o Shri Babulal Meshram, DOB-28.06.1987, MES
No.-414188 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Vill- Dhadi,
Teh-Kirnapur, Distt- Balaghat (MP)-481115
22. Ranjeet Kumar S/o Shri Rajo Saw, DOB-12.03.1986, MES No.- 617361
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Vill- Ramnagar, Distt-
Lakhirarai, Bihar (UP)-811311
23. Rafique Miyan Siddiqui S/o Shri Laeeque Ahmao, DOB-01.02.1964,
MES No.- 413906 Working As- Master Craftsman (FGM) R/o- Saeed
Colony, Berasia Road, Karod, Bhopal (MP)-461445
24. Lakhan Lal S/o Shri Swarg Chhannu Lal, DOB-24.06.1961, MES No.-
420313 Retired As- Master Craftsman (Fitter Pipe) R/o- Sarvoday Colony,
Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-463111
25. Kumer Singh S/o Shri Narnyan Singh, DOB-10.03.1963, MES No.-
413895 Retired As- Fitter Pipe (HS-II) R/o- Behta Gaon, Bairagarh, Bhopal
(MP)-463111
26. Pradeep Kumar S/o Late Govind Dass, DOB-12.01.1963, MES No.-
413850 Retired As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- 54, Old dheripharam,
One tree hills, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-463111
27. Kashi Ram Kure S/o Late Sumer Kure, DOB-01.07.1962, MES No.-
413852 Retired As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- Kabitpura, Durga
Temple, Shahajanabad, Bhopal (MP)-462001
28. Bhawar Lal Yadav S/o Shri Kanhaiya Lal Yadav, DOB-01.02.1961, MES
No.-413733 Working As- Electrician (HS-II), R/o- Kailash Nagar, D-Block,
CTO, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-463111
29. Bhujbal Singh S/o Late Kamta Prasad, DOB-01.07.1962, MES No.-
413811 Working As- Electrician (HS-I) R/o- Sethi Nagar, Shoka Garden,
Govindpura, Bhopal (MP)-462023
Page 39 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
40
30. Siya Ram S/o Late Raja Ram, DOB-21.09.1962, MES No.- 420329
Retired As- Master Craftsman (Electrical) R/o- Vill-Pathrota, The-Itarsi,
Distt- Narmadapuram (MP)-461445
31. Kamal Kishore S/o Shri Ram Narayan Choudhary, DOB-03.06.1959,
MES No.- 413853 Retired As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- Housing Board
Colony, Old Itarsi, Distt- Narmadapuram (MP)-461445.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Vijay Tripathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110001
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Headquarter
of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg Defence Head
Quater, New Delhi-110010
3. Chief Engineer (Headquarter)Military Engineering Service, Central
Command, Lucknow (UP)-226001
4. Chief Engineer (Headquarters) Bhopal Zone, Military Engineering
Service, S. I. Lines, Bhopal (MP)- 462001
5.Commander Works Engineer (Headquarter) Military Engineering Service,
211, Regiment Rd, Teela, Jamalpur, Gautam Nagar, Sri Nagar Colony,
Bhopal (MP)- 462001
6. Garrison Engineer Military Engineering Services, Bhopal (MP)- 462030.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Surendra Pratap Singh
Original Application No. 216 of 2024
1. Deepak Rajpoot S/o Late Trilok Singh Rajpoot, DOB-09/08/1990, MES
No.- 609654 Working As- Mason (SK) R/o- H No-750, Ghamapur Sarkari
Kuwa, Jabalpur (MP)-482001
2. Sagar Thapa S/o Shri Bhim Bhadur Thapa, DOB-13/07/1995, MES No.-
617353 Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- H No-605, Shanti Nagar V.F.J.
Road Ranjhi, Jabalpur (MP)-482009
Page 40 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
41
3. Ramashish Pal S/o Shri Ram Charitra Pal, DOB-10/08/1994, MES No.-
155254 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK), R/o- Village-
Haridaspur, P.O.-B.T. Bigha, P.S-Amas Dist-Gaya (Bihar)-824211
4. Ravi Jhawre S/o Shri Narayan Jhawre, DOB-26/09/1990, MES No.-
414135 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- H NO-09, Village Bamla, PO-
Ubhegaon, Teh-Mohkhed, Dist-Chhindwara (MP)-480107
5. Manoj Kumar Prajapati S/o Shri Radheshyam, DOB-10/04/1983, MES
No.- 414057 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I), R/o- H No-18, Shiv
Om Green Park, Sanjeev Nagar, Bhopal (MP)-462038
6. Rajendra Kumar S/o Shri Shobharam, DOB-09/07/1982, MES No.-
414055 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II), R/o- H No 18, Shiv
om Green Park, Sanjeev Nagar, Bhopal (MP)-462038
7. Mrs. Nikita Chouhan W/o Shri Chaitanya Singh Chouhan, DOB-
25/10/1990, MES No.- 404312 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- Ward
No 06, Durga Mandir Ke Paas, Ram Nagar, Mohalla Mehara Gaon,
Hoshangabad (MP)-461001
8. Neeraj Kumar Rajoriya S/o Shri Siyaram, DOB-14/05/1990, MES No.-
283040 Working As- Electrician Skilled, R/o- Vill+Post-Mankenda, Dist-
Agra (UP)-283102
9. Vaibhav Dixit S/o Shri Surendra Dixit, DOB-16/06/1993, MES No.-
617289 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- Vill+Post-Bhimsen,
Dist- Kanpur Nagar (UP)-209305
10. Neelesh Kumar Pawar S/o Late Madhukar Pawar, DOB-24/08/1990,
MES No.-414134 Working As- Electrician (HS-II), R/o- Near Ashirwad
Bhawan, New Pahade Colony, Gulabra, Chhindwara (MP)-480001
11. Rakesh Swami S/o Shri Jawaher Das Swami, DOB-01/08/1993, MES
No.-617364 Working As- Electrician Skilled R/o- V/P- Kasumbi Jakhala,
Teh- Ladnun, Dist- Nagaur (MH)- 341304
12. Avadhesh Kumar Maurya S/o Shri Markandey Maurya, DOB-
15/06/1991, MES No.-617290 Working As- Electrician Skilled, R/o-
Vill+Post- Madhonager, Police Station- Paniyara, Dist- Maharajgang (UP)-
273158
Page 41 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
42
13. Nitesh Kumar Pathariya S/o Shri Shankar lal Pathariya, DOB-
28/06/1984, MES No.- 414117 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-
II), R/o- Gali No-04, Tawer Colony, Pipariya, Dist-Hoshangabad, (MP)-
461775
14. Shri Ram Singh Patel S/o Shri Tara Chand Patel, DOB-02/06/1973,
MES No.- 158479-5-A Working As- Pipe Ftr (SK) R/o-V+Po- Bararu, Teh-
Sagar, Dist- Sagar (MP)-470001.
15. Rameshwar Prasad Sharma S/o Shri Jeevan Lal Sharma, DOB-
25/09/1993, MES No.- 617370 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK)
R/o- Vill- Khain, Kalyanpur, Post- Khain, Teh-Karchhana Dist- Prayagraj
(UP)-212307
16. Sameer Dnyaneshwar Choudhari S/o Shri Dnyaneshwar yashwant
Choudhari, DOB-19/07/1992, MES No.- 414193 Working As- Fitter
General Mechanic (SK), R/o- Manewada Juni Wasti, Besa Road Nagpur
(MH)-440034
17. Ashish Hardaha S/o Shri Meva Lal Hardaha, DOB-06/09/1990, MES
No.- 414122 Working As- Electrician (HS-II), R/o- Ward No-12, Nanda
Mohalla, Bamhani Banjar, Dist- Mandla (MP)-481771
18. Manjeet Yadav S/o Shri Onkar Singh Yadav, DOB-01/12/1989, MES
No.-414152 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic Skilled R/o- MIG-302, F
Block, Sanjeev Nagar, Karond, Bhopal (MP)-462038
19. Ashish Kadwe S/o Shri Birbal Kadwe, DOB-26/04/1992, MES No.-
414113 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- 14/1, Turaborgao, Post-
Mahatpur, Teh- Amla, Dist- Betul (MP)-460661
20. Vinod Kumar S/o Shri Rambilash, DOB-15/11/1992, MES No.-
617120 Working As- Painter (SK) R/o- Vill-Jigni Purwa, Post- Lohari, Teh-
Akbar Pur, Dist- Kanpur Dehat (UP)-209121
21. Raju Singh S/o Shri Hari Singh, DOB-04/02/1987, MES No.-617288
Working As- P/F (SK) R/o- Vill- Badripur, PO- Parmadra, Teh- Deeg, Dist-
Bharatpur (Raj)- 321203
22. Suresh Chand Meena S/o Shri Badri Prasad Meena, DOB-15/04/1986,
MES No.-617391 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Vill-Fatehpur, Post-
Toda Nagar, Teh- Laxmangarh, Dist- Alwar, (Raj)-301413
Page 42 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
43
23. Pradeep Kumar S/o Late Ramesh Kumar Asret, DOB-01/06/1982,
MES No.- 422777 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Behind
Mahavir Tokij Etwara Bazar, Hosangabad (MP)-461001
24. Lokesh S/o Late Keshri Lal, DOB-20/10/1983, MES No.- 421904
Working As- P/Ftr (SK) R/o- 125/2 Tila Jamalpura, Behind Soni Bhawan,
Bhopal (MP) 462001
25. Saurabh Shrivastva S/o Late Ram Mohan Shrivastva, DOB-
13/08/1991, MES No.- 617377 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Vill-
Ghosaw, Post Dhoraw, Dist- Jaunpur (UP)-222136
26. Amit Kumar Kanaujiya S/o Shri Prem Lal, DOB-02/09/1985, MES No.-
617374 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK), R/o- H no 32, Satti
Chaurha Cantt, Kanpurnagar, 208004
27. Prakash Prajapati S/o Late Ganeshi Lal, DOB-15/11/1984, MES No.-
1448 Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- Bijoli, Bijauli Mauranipur, Jhansi,
(UP)- 284135
28. Harish Kumar Shakya S/o Shri Madhav Lal Shakya, DOB-02/01/1983,
MES No.- 414123 Working As- Electrician (HS-II), R/o- H No 62, Near of
Ram Mandir, Hinotiya Road, Sourabh Colony, Chandbad Bhopal (MP)
462010
29. Neelesh Sarathe S/o Shri Ramnath Sarathe, DOB-23/06/1993, MES
No.- 414154 Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- H No-10, Ekta Sai Dham
Colony, Karond, Bhopal (MP)-462038
30. Roman Lal S/o Shri Shyam Lal, DOB-25/09/1990, MES No.-414124
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No 108, Vill+Post-
Limora, Dist- Balod (CG)-491227
31. Mahesh Sarwan Deware S/o Late Sarwan Deware, DOB-30/05/1987,
MES No.-414189 Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- Ward No 03, At+Post-
Kharkhadi Teh- Kharkhadi, Dist- Balaghat (MP)-481335
32. Ajay Gujar S/o Late Basant Kumar, DOB-15/08/1976, MES No.-
413979 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- H No 385,
Kabeetpura, Shahjanabad, Bhopal (MP)-462001
Page 43 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
44
33. Gulab Chand S/o Late Maan Singh, DOB-07/11/1971, MES No.-
509327 Working As- Mason (HS-II) R/o- H No 2075, Raj Mohalla, Maika
Mandir, Mhow (MP)-453441
34. Raghuveer Singh S/o Shri Ram Singh, DOB-18/05/1991, MES No.-
617285 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Vill-Pitalpur, Teh Nimkathana,
Dist- Sikar (Raj)-332701
35. Kamlesh Kumar Meena S/o Shri Ram Swaroop Meena, DOB-
10/07/1987, MES No.-617367 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK)
R/o- Vill+PO Talab, Teh- Rajgarh, Dist Alwar (Raj)-301410
36. Mrs. Savitri Nanda W/o Late JS Nanda, DOB-31/12/1970, MES No.-
414094 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Raksha Vihar, Plot
No 298 Savitri Niwas Air Port Roasd, Bhopal (MP)-402031
37. Harish Panchal S/o Shpakbhu Dayal, DOB-25/11/1991, MES No.-
617380 Working As- Painter (SK) R/o- H NO 1503, Gaushala Road,
Nasragarh, New Delhi-110043
38. Rohit Kale S/o Late Ganesh P Kale, DOB-14/04/1995, MES No.-
617372 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Imdira Nagar,
Kanhan Teh Parseoni, Distt-Nagpur (MH)-441401
39. Mohd Faijan Raja S/o Mohd Hafeez, DOB-01/05/1992, MES No.-
414140 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- Vill Deogawan, Post-
Jhakharawal, Teh Deosar, Dist- Singrauli (MP)-486881
40. Shobharam S/o Late Heera Lal, DOB-09/01/1973, MES No.- 413981
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- Shahid Nagar Behind
Electric Office Near Sahu Flore Mill, Bhopal (MP)-462001
41. Azad Singh S/o Late Arjun Singh, DOB-01/08/1998, MES No.- 617422
Working As- Mate (SSK) R/o- Vill- Jarhaura, Post Jakhaura, Teh-Talbhat,
Dist-Lalitpur (UP)-284124
42. Subham Thakur S/o Late Ram Prasad Thakur, DOB-01/06/1996, MES
No.-617379 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- At Post-Kalunga,
PS-B-Tarang, Dist- Sundargarh (OR)-770031
43. Rohit Tiwari S/o Late Ram Lal Tiwari, DOB-06/06/1989, MES No.-
414163 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- C/o Mr. K P Gantam,
Prem Nagar, Gali No. 03, Satna (MP)-485001
Page 44 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
45
44. Ahmed Imran Khan S/o Shri Adillkram Khan, DOB-26/01/1989, MES
No.-414137 Working As- Pipe/Fitter (HS-II) R/o- Rizi Mohalla Jatara, Dist-
Tikamgarh (MP)-472001
45. Pankaj Pawar S/o Shri Panjab Rao Pawar, DOB-23/05/1989, MES No.-
424464 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Village-Junapani,
Post- Semjhaira, Teh- Multai, Dist.- Betul (MP)-460557
46. Tinku Kumar S/o Shri Sachidanand Singh, DOB-16/10/1991, MES
No.-617378 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o-34, Pioneer,
Coprative Colony, Pakri, Patna(BR)-800002
47. Hemraj S/o Late Moolchand, DOB-12/07/1967, MES No.- 413982
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- H NO 50 Subham Green
Colony, Patel Nagar, Raisen Road, Bhopal (MP)-462022
48. Virendra Singh Thakur S/o Shri Chandrabhan Singh Thakur, DOB-
06/03/1986, MES No.- 414074 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- H No
508, Near Hanuman Mandir, NariyalKheda, Bhopal (MP)-462001
49. Chhote Lal Gaur S/o Shri Ramsurat Gaur, DOB-10/03/1992, MES
No.- 414204 Working As- P/Ftr (SK) R/o- P-326/1, MES Colony, Bairagarh,
Bhopal (MP)-463111
50. RB Singh S/o Late Param Hans Singh, DOB-20/01/1967, MES No.- T
No 826 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II) Vill-Saraut, Post
Bhagar, Dist-Siwan, Bihar- 841226
51. Asraf Khan S/o Shri Asfak Khan, DOB-01/01/1994, MES No.- 414112
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No 763 A H/B Colony,
Karond, Bhopal (MP)-462038
52. Mohd Fareed Khan S/o Mohd Rasheed Khan, DOB-04/12/1985, MES
No.- 414119 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Η NO 45,
Avesha Enclave Befna Colony, Bhopal (MP)-462001
53. Ravindra Parmer S/o Shri Narendra Pratap Singh, DOB-26/01/1990,
MES No.- 414115 Working As- P/Ftr (HS-II) R/o- H No 16, Gali No 05,
Aishbagh Bhopal (MP)-462010
54. Sunil Kumar Mishra S/o Shri Ramesh Chand Mishra, DOB-
11/11/1979, MES No.-414052 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I)
R/o- H No 8, BDA Colony, Gulmohar, Arera Colony, Bhopal (MP)-462001
Page 45 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
46
55. Lawrance S/o Late Nigam, DOB-20/07/1976, MES No.-471098
Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- J 29, Gokuldham, Nayapura, Karond,
Bhopal (MP)- 462038
56. Himanshu Shekhar S/o Shri Sitaram Satoriya, DOB-21/09/1985, MES
No.- 414124 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- MIG-470, G
Sector, Ayodhya Nagar, Bhopal (MP)-462041
57. Sameer Ali S/o Late Sabir Ali, DOB-23/05/1990, MES No.- 414121
Working As- Carpenter (HS-II) R/o- H. No.-03 BadaBagh, Bhopal Talkis,
Hamidia Road, Bhopal (MP)-462001
58. Mrs. Shahjahan Parveen W/o Late Elahi Baig, DOB-24/08/1964, MES
No.- 413934 Working As- Painter (HS-II) R/o- Ward No 06, Rani Durgawati
School Ke Pass, BG Siding. Parasia, Distt-Chhindwara (MP)-480441
59. Laxmi Narayan S/o Shri Mulchand, DOB-15/11/1959, MES No.-
413891 Working As- Mate Painter R/o- H NO 543, New Chaukse Nagar,
Lamakheda, Bhopal (MP)-462038
60. Prakash Chand Batham S/o Late Pyare Lal Batham, DOB-24/04/1960,
MES No.- 413639 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- H No 16, Near Jain
Mandir Road, Shajhanabad, Bhopal (MP) 462001
61. Hira Lal S/o Late Dhani Ram, DOB-21/01/1960, MES No.- 420244
Working As- Electrician (HS-I) R/o- H No 11, Sanya Colony, CTO Road,
Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-462030
62. Tej Singh S/o Late Laxman Singh, DOB-09/07/1963, MES No.- T No-
1062 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No 145, Ward
No 02, Pooja Shri Colony, CTO Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-463111.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shr i Vijay Tri pathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110 001
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Headquarter
of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg Defence Head
Quater, New Delhi-110010
Page 46 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
47
3. Chief Engineer (Headquarter) Military Engineering Service, Central
Command, Lucknow (UP)-226001
4. Chief Engineer (Headquarters) Bhopal Zone, Military Engineering
Service, S. I. Lines, Bhopal (MP)-462001
5.Commander Works Engineer (Headquarter) Military Engineering Service,
211, Regiment Rd, Teela, Jamalpur, Gautam Nagar, Sri Nagar Colony,
Bhopal (MP)- 462001
6. Garrison Engineer Military Engineering Service, Dronachal, Bhopal
(MP)- 462038. .......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Surendra Pratap Singh
Original Application No. 217 of 2024
1. Dharmendra Singh Kushwah S/o Shri Balaram Kushwah, DOB-
21/12/1991, MES No.- 376234 Working As- Pipe Fitter (SK) R/o- Near Raje
Palace Hanuman Colony Gole ka Mandir Bhind Road Gwalior (MP)-474005
2. Amit Kumar Gour S/o Shri Sushil Kumar Gour, DOB-22/07/1992, MES
No.- 414107 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- House No 22, In front of
Mahakal Temple, Mahakal Colony, Bairagarh Kalan (MP) - 462030
3. Gaurishanker Vishwakarma S/o Shri Prem Singh Vishwakarma, DOB-
06/10/1965, MES No.-413916 Working As- Master Craftsman (Electrician)
R/o- H No 29 Phase II Sharda Nagar Berasia Road Bhopal (MP)-462038
4. Virendra Singh Pawar S/o Shri Daalsingh Pawar, DOB-19/09/1972,
MES No.- 413980 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- H No-200/201
Shanti Nagar Karond Bhopal (MP)-462001
5. Ranveer Singh Samota S/o Shri Guljari Samota, DOB-07/05/1994, MES
No.-414195 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Dhani Derawali Kalyanpura,
Post Jairampura, Tehsil Shrimadhopur Sikar, Rajasthan - 332715
6. Vivek Rav S/o Shri Gharitelal, DOB-28/07/1995, MES No.-414198
Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Village-Sankahari, Post Harbarbur
Ghatampur, Kanpur Nagar (U.P) - 209206
Page 47 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
48
7. Shubham Gupta S/o Shri Deepak Gupta, DOB-30/06/1995, MES No.-
617404 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- In front of Dalvir complex,
Nandani Road, Bhilai Power House Durg (CG)-462023
8. Chandrapal Singh Pal S/o Shri Siyaram, DOB-03/04/1992, MES No.-
617412 Working As- Electrician (SK), R/o- Village and post Salon (A), Tehsil
Bhander, Dist Datia (MP)-475335
9. Vinod Kumar Meena S/o Shri Makkhan lal, DOB-01/01/1986, MES No.-
414180 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Village Malera, Post Jatawali Via
Samode, Tehsil Chomu, Dist Jaipur (RJ) - 303806
10. Hemraj Meena S/o Shri Rameshwar Meena, DOB-08/01/1992, MES
No.-414197 Working As- Mate (SK) R/o- Vill+Post Ghoomana, Tehsil Sikrai,
Dist Dausa (RJ) - 303502
11. Shakib Ali S/o Shri Sajid Ali, DOB-06/11/1988, MES No.- 414110
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No-3 Bada Bagh,
Hamidia Road, Shahjanabad, Bhopal (MP)-462001
12. Shri Mohd Aasim S/o Shri Mohd Arif, DOB-05/10/1991, MES No.-
414104 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No 757 Arif
Nagar, Berasia Road, Bhopal (MP)-462001
13. Mukesh Kumar S/o Shri Shyoji Ram, DOB-11/05/1991, MES No.-
610644 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- VPO Hapas, Tehsil
Laxmangarh, Dist Sikar, Rajasthan - 332312
14. Rajesh Kumar S/o Shri LaxmanPrasd Dubey, DOB-05/01/1967, MES
No.- 421693 Working As- Master Craftsman (FGM) R/o- H No HD-27
Abhiruchi Parisar, Old Subhash Nagar, Bhopal (MP)- 462023
15. Kamal Kumar S/o Shri Gurucharan, DOB-05/03/64, MES No.-413983
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HSW-I) R/o- H No P-149/1 MES
Colony, SI Lines, Bhopal (MP)-462001
16. Hemraj Patel S/o Shri Patiram Patel DOB-19/07/1992, MES No.-
414155 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- H No-99 E-Sector,
Behind Manavdharma Mandir, Patel Nagar Road, Bhopal (MP)- 462022
17. Doulat Ram Raghuwanshi S/o Shri Maniram Raghuwanshi, DOB-
09/03/1994, MES No.-414150 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK)
R/o- H NO 229/2 New Si Lines, Bhopal (MP) - 462001
Page 48 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
49
18. Rajpal Godara S/o Shri Nemichand Godara, DOB-07/10/1988, MES
No.-414181 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Godaron Ka
Bas Dhania Bhorki, District Jhunjhunu, Rajasthan-333032
19. Gaurao M. Bhoyar S/o Shri Manikrao U. Bhoyar, DOB-10/10/1992,
MES No.-414192 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- AT.daheli,
POST Yelabara Taluka, Yavatmal, Dist Yavatmal (MH) - 445001
20. Tushar Yadao Kaleshwar S/o Shri Yadao Tulshiram kaleshwar, DOB-
22/03/1992, MES No.-414184 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK)
R/o- Mahakali Ward, Behind Padamashali Mandir, Chandrapur (MH)-
442402
21. Sompal S/o Shri Chaurilal, DOB-25/05/1967, MES No.- 41399
Working As- Pipe Fitter (SK) R/o- H No 07 Shahjanabad Kabeetpura Gali
No 02, Bhopal (MP)-462001
22. Mehtab Akbar S/o Shri Kamal Akbar, DOB-23/09/1993, MES No.-
414116 Working As- Pipe Fitter (HS-II) R/o- H.NO 75 Shansha Garden,
Nawab Colony, Bhopal (MP) - 462023
23. Shashikant Marskole S/o Shri Rajesh Kumar Marskole, DOB-
09/11/1992, MES No.-414114 Working As- Carpenter (HS-II) R/o- Village
Rantola, Post Chiraidongri(Railway), Tehsil-Nainpur, Distt Mandla (MP)-
481768
24. Sanjeet Kumar S/o Shri Prakash, DOB-06/03/1988, MES No.-617106
Working As- Mason (SK) R/o-Village Asadpur Karanjali, Post Deoband(UP),
Tehsil (Deoband) (UP)-247554
25. Smt Urmila D/o Late Shriaji, DOB-19/6/1967, MES No.- 413977
Working As- Mason (SK) R/o- H NO 780 Tilajamalpura Soni Bhawan KE
Piche, Bhopal (MP)-462001
26. Manoharlal S/o Shri Barelal, DOB-03/03/1970, MES No.-413938
Working As- Mason (SK) R/o- H No 232 Shiv Nagar Colony, Peepal Chowra,
Karond Berasiya Road, Bhopal (MP)-462038
27. Rupendra Gitkar S/o Shri Ramesh Gitkar, DOB-15/02/1990, MES No.-
414183 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Sivaji ward, Ward
No 16, Near Tondancamp Gate No.01, Main Road Bodkhi, Amla (MP)-
460553
Page 49 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
50
28. Azmat Khan S/o Shri Rahat Ullah Khan, DOB-13/06/1986, MES No.-
414111 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II), R/o- A-787 Housing
Board Colony, Near Hari Mazaar, Karod, Bhopal (MP)- 462038
29. Mohad Faizan S/o Shri Mohd Ameen, DOB-15/10/1978, MES No.-
414105 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No 12 PGVT
Collage, Pradosh Nagar, Bhopal (MP)- 462001
30. Jaspal Singh S/o Shri Tota Ram Mattu, DOB-16/09/1968, MES No.-
413959 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- P-611/01 MES
Colony CTO, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)- 462030
31. Mahendra Parate S/o Shri Tej Ram Parate, DOB-12/03/1989, MES
No.-414165 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o-P-608/01 MES
Colony CTO, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-462031
32. Avinesh Shekhar S/o Shri Sitaram Satoriya, DOB-16/08/1988, MES
No.- 423852 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o-F91/23 Tulsi
Nagar, IInd Stop, Bhopal (MP)-462003.
33. Dinesh Kumar Soni S/o Shri Dulichand, DOB-06/10/1976, MES No.-
414035 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No 04 Laxmi
Nagar Colony, Fool Bagiya, Bairagarh Kala (MP)-462030
34. Ravishankar Pawar S/o Shri Marotee Pawar, DOB-05/01/1977, T No.-
11541-B Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- House No 111
Vardhmaan Nagar, Data Colony, Bhopal (MP)- 462030
35. Niranjiv Kumar Agashe S/o Shri Chaitram Agashe, DOB-25/06/1973,
MES No.- 15390628M Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o-P-608/03 MES
Colony CTO, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)- 462030
36. Atma Ram S/o Shri Rewaram, DOB-09/02/1964, MES No.- 413904
Working As- Painter (HS-II) R/o- Makaan No 777 Bairagarh Kala, Bhopal
(MP)-462030
37. Ashad Khan S/o Shri Usman Khan, DOB-19/10/1972, MES No.-
413973 Working As- Fitter Pipe (SK) R/o- House No A-16 Gali No 03 Murli
Nagar, Housing Board, Karod, Bhopal (MP)- 462001
38. Arvind Singh Nagvanshi S/o Shri Ramesh Kumar, DOB-30/05/1986,
MES No.-414108 Working As- Electrician R/o- MIG-234 Sanjeev Nagar,
Police Colony, Bhopal (MP)-462038
Page 50 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
51
39. Ashok Kumar S/o Shri Dharam Das, DOB-19/12/1969, MES No.-
413901 Working As- V/Mech (HS-II) R/o- Makan No 114 Barela Gaon
Lalghati, Bhopal (MP)-462001
40. Nikhil Channe S/o Shri Yadorao Channe, DOB-05/01/1991, MES No.-
617393 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- War Nagar 08,
Krashn Mandir Ke Pass, Katangi (MP)-481445
41. Syed Uviz Hasan Rizvi S/o Shri A H Rizvi, DOB-11/07/1968, MES No.-
1580003X Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SSK) R/o- Kavi Rashkhan
Marg, Mugal Tola, Vidisha (MP)-464001
42. Bhaiya Lal S/o Shri Chunni Lal, DOB-05/08/1970, MES No.- 413984
Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- H No 09 Mathai Nagar, CTO Bairagarh
(MP)-462030
43. Subhash Tamiya S/o Shri Mahadev Tamiya, DOB-16/11/1961, MES
No.- A9704766 Retired As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- H No 202
Subhash Arth Danish Colony, Bhopal (MP)-462011
44. Omprakash Yadav S/o Shri Laalchand, DOB-15/02/1960, MES No.-
413739 Retired As- Pipe Fitter (SK) R/o- H No 35 Ghoranikass near Shiv
Mandir Ward No 20, Bhopal (MP)-462001
45. Shri Manoharlaal S/o Shri Kishanlaal, DOB-25/05/1961, MES No.-
413634 Retired As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- H No 1246
Khushipura Chandpura, Bhopal (MP)-462010
46. Smt Kanta Bai W/o Roshan, DOB-01/02/1962, MES No.-413903
Retired As- Mate Painter R/o- 27 Shivlok colony phase-2, Khajuri Kalan
Road, Near SOS Balgram, Bhopal (MP)- 462022
47. Tarasingh S/o Shri Nathuram, DOB-15/02/1960, MES No.- 413750
Retired As- Electrician (HS-I) R/o- H No 32 Gali No 2 Bhudwara Bhoipura,
Bhopal (MP)- 462001
48. Ravindra Chauhan S/o Shri Jawhar Singh Chauhan, DOB-
23/03/1960, MES No.- 413845 Retired As- Master Craftsman (Electrician)
R/o- H NO LIG 208 A Sector Sonagiri, Bhopal (MP)-462002
49. Mohd Maqsood S/o Mohd Majeed Khan, DOB-02/11/1963, MES No.-
413899 Retired As- Carpenter (HS-I) R/o- Gali No 27 Makaan No 849 C
Block, Sharda Nagar, Nariyal Kheda, Bhopal (MP)-462001
Page 51 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
52
50. Vijay Kumar Keer S/o Shri Mishri Lal, DOB-28/06/1963, MES No.-
413812 Retired As- Fitter Pipe (HS-II) R/o- Makan No 03 Gali 02 bhoipura,
Bhagwan Shah Marg, Bhopal (MP)-462001
51. Mahendra Kumar S/o Shri Mohan Lal, DOB-20/03/1963, MES No.-
970481,Retired As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I), R/o-P-234/3 MES Colony
CTO, Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-462030
52. Chandrabhan Singh S/o Shri Malkhan Singh, DOB-06/02/1960, MES
No.- 413625 Retired As- Fitter Pipe R/o- H No 508 NR Hanuman Mandir
Nariyal Kheda, Bhopal (MP)-462001
53. Rafiquddin S/o Shri Badruddin, DOB-17/08/1968, MES No.- 413888
Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o- H No 9/10 Near Noor Press,
Budhwara, Bhopal (MP)-462001
54. Vinod Kumar S/o Shri Ghishi Lal, DOB-04/01/1973, MES No.-
414014 Working As- Fitter Pipe (HS-II) R/o- P-17/4 MES Colony CTO,
Bairagarh, Bhopal (MP)-462030. .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Vijay Tripathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110 001
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Headquarter
of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg, Defence Head
Quater, New Delhi-110010
3. Chief Engineer (Headquarter) Military Engineering Service, Central
Command, Lucknow (UP)- 226001
4. Chief Engineer (Headquarters) Bhopal Zone, Military Engineering
Service, S. I. Lines, Bhopal (MP)-462001
5. Commander Works Engineer (Headquarter) Military Engineering Service,
211, Regiment Rd, Teela, Jamalpur, Gautam Nagar, Sri Nagar Colony,
Bhopal (MP)- 462001
6. Garrison Engineer Military Engineering Service, Bhopal (MP)-462030.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Surendra Pratap Singh
Page 52 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
53
Original Application No. 218 of 2024
1. Rajat Gajanan Hedau S/o Gajanan hedau, DOB-21/01/1994, MES No.-
617359 Working As- Fitter General Manager (SK) R/o- Q.No. 48 MES
Colony, Barki Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
2. Shailesh Buchche S/o Late Eknath Buchche, DOB-06/12/1991, MES
No.- 617357 Working As- Electrician (Sk) R/o- Q.No. 52/2 MES Colony,
Barki Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
3. Abdul Naeem S/o Abdul Laeeq, DOB-22/10/1993, MES No.-414118
Working As- Pipe Fitter, R/o- H. No. 938, P.G.B.T College, Bhopal (MP)-
462038
4. Malti Sarathe W/O Late Prasana Kumar, DOB-31/01/1965, MES No.-
413956 Working As- Carpenter (HS-II) R/o- Q.No. 36 MES Colony, Barki
Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
5. Ravi Kumar Naidu S/o Late Pyarelal, DOB-10/04/1964, MES No.-
413918 Working As- Fitter General Manager (HS-I), R/o- Q.No.B-53 MES
Colony, Barki Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
6. Anoop Kumar S/o Late Nabbu Lal, DOB-11/10/1966, MES No.- 413913
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I), R/o- Q.No.P-47 MES Colony,
Barki Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
7. Gaurav Kesherwani S/o Vasant Kumar, DOB-22/09/1990, MES No.-
617397 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- Q.No. 54/1 MES
Colony, Jatashanker Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
8. Kalu Ram Saini S/o Kailash Chand, DOB-15/04/1995, MES No.-
617396 Working As- Electrician (SK), R/o- Q.No. 54/8, MES Colony,
Jatashanker Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
9. Rajesh Kumar S/o Late Rampratap Mehta, DOB-05/07/1988, MES No.-
617356 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Q.No49/1, MES
Colony, Barki Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
10. Vijay Kumar Gond S/o Bechan Ram, DOB-17/07/1991, MES No.-
617369 Working As- Electrician (SK), R/o- Q.No 50/2 MES Colony, Barki
Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
Page 53 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
54
11. Dheeraj S/o Chutraram, DOB-10/07/1994, MES No.- 617368 Working
As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK), R/o- Q.No. 49/2 MES Colony, Barki
Road, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
12. Santosh Lal Kanojiya S/o Late Munnalal, DOB-26/03/1962, MES No.-
413795 Working As- Electrician (HS-II), R/o- Arvind Marg, Dafai Mohallla,
Ward No. 05, Pachmarhi (MP)-461881
13. Swarn Singh S/o Late Sadhu Singh, DOB-02/04/1961, MES No.-
413797 Working As- Electrician (HS-II), R/o- H. No. 25, Ram Ashram
Vihar, Jabalpur (MP)- 482001
14. Mohan Singh S/o Late Hanumant Singh, DOB-05/01/1962, MES No.-
413719 Working As- Electrician (HS-I), R/o- H.No. 124 My City Near Petrol
Pump, Sogahpur (MP)-461771. .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Vijay Tripathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110 001
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Headquarter
of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg Defence Head
Quater, New Delhi-110010
3. Chief Engineer (Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service Central
Command, Lucknow (UP)- 226001
4. Chief Engineer (Headquarters) Military Engineering Service, Jabalpur
Zone Lekhanagar Ridge Road, Jabalpur (MP)- 482001
5. Commander Works Engineer (Headquarter) Admin Office, Military
Engineering Service, Near Supply Depot, Sadar Bazar, Jabalpur (MP)-
482001
6. Asstt. Garrison Engineer (1) Military Engineering Service, Pachmarhi
(MP)-461881. .......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Surendra Pratap Singh
Page 54 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
55
Original Application No. 263 of 2024
1. Lekhraj Sahu S/o Late Govind Sahu, DOB-10/11/1986, MES No.-
423860 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- H No-131, In front of
Power Grid, Pathrota, Itarsi, Dist - Narmadapuram (MP)-461111
2. Pardeshi Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Gangaram Sahu, DOB-08/09/1982,
MES No.- 414158 Working As- Vehicle Mechanic (SK) R/o- Vill - Bhopsara,
Post - Ghursena, Teh - Nawagarh, Dist - Bemetara (CG) -491340
3. Manoj Rajput S/o Shri Mahendra Singh Rajput, DOB-03/07/1987, MES
No.- 610628 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Vill - Mohasa, Teh -
Makhannagar, Dist-Narmadapuram (MP)-461661
4. Arvind Singh S/o Shri Harikesh Singh, DOB-25/02/1992, MES No.-
414174 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Vill + Post - Jasapara, Dist -
Sultanpur (UP)-221819
5. Hivraj Sahadeo Maske S/o Shri Sahadeo Maske, DOB-05/04/1991, MES
No.-414178 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Post-Silli, Dist -
Bhandara (MH) - 441924
6. Amar Mandloi S/o Shri Gyarsilal Mandloi, DOB-01/07/1983, MES No.-
617400 Working As- Fitter Pipe (SK) R/o-392/02, New Panwadi Mohalla,
Ward No.13, Barwani (MP)-451551.
7. Nikhil Butle S/o Shri Giridhar Butle, DOB-25/07/1988, MES No.-
414176 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- 1, Bandu Soni, Sambhaji Nagar,
Nagpur (MH)-440022
8. Ramsuraj Patel S/o Shri Ramdeen Patel, DOB-22/08/1997, MES No.-
617358 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Plot No.250, Road
No.05, Kasturba Nagar, Jaripataka, Nagpur (MH)-440001
9. Sumit Prakashrao Bhoge S/o Shri Prakashrao Bhoge, DOB-10/01/1989,
MES No.-414179 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Petrol Pump (Jhana),
Teh + Dist - Bhandara (MH)-441906
10. Devendra Kumar Patel S/o Shri Laxminarayan Patel, DOB-
14/07/1966, MES No.-413908 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I)
R/o- Old Itarsi, Ward No.05, Patel Mohalla Itarsi, Dist - Narmadapuram
(MP)-461111
Page 55 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
56
11. Manoj Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Ramshankar Sharma, DOB-
10/02/1991, MES No.-414177 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK)
R/o- Vill+Post-sonvarsa, Dist-Baliya (UP)-277208
12. Akash Vishwakarma S/o Shri Hansraj Vishwakarma, DOB-
30/05/1991, MES No.- 422820 Working As- Carpenter (SK) R/o- Azad
Ward, Near Shanti Photo Studio, Pipariya (MP)-461775
13. Smt. Radha Bai W/o Late Madanlal Nagesh, DOB-23/05/1964, MES
No.- 413881 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- Dairu Form,
Kiratpur, Itarsi, Dist-Narmadapuram(MP)-461111
14. Smt. Rukmani Devi W/o Late Ramkrishan Rawat, DOB-25/04/1966,
MES No.- 471101 Working As- Penter (SK) R/o- Vill-Ghatali, Teh - Itarsi,
Dist-Narmadapuram (MP)-461111
15. Ashok Kumar S/o Late Sundar Lal Malviya, DOB-04/01/1961, MES
No.- 420353 Retired As-FGM (SK) R/o- Dewal Mandir, Ward No.4, Azad
Chowk, Itarsi Dist-Narmadapuram (MP)-461111.
16. Mohan Singh S/o Shri Chain Singh, DOB-30/06/1959, MES No.-
413866 Retired As- Painter (SK) R/o- Vill-Byavra, Teh - Narmadapuram
Dist-Narmadapuram (MP)-461446
17. Ramswaroop S/o Shri Gopal, DOB-01/12/1959, MES No.- 413590
Retired As-FGM (SK) R/o- Ordnance Factory Road, Vill - Pandukhedi, Teh-
Itarsi, Dist-Narmadapuram (MP)-461446
18. Raja Ram S/o Late Shankar Lal, DOB-22/08/1959, MES No.- 413804
Retired As- Mate Pipe Ftr R/o- Ward No.4, Patel Mohalla, Rajendra Pura,
Itarsi, Dist-Narmadapuram (MP)-461111
19. Babulal Parolkar S/o Shri Govind Parolkar, DOB-12/06/1960, MES
No.-413826 Retired As- Electrician (MCM) R/o- Deewan Colony, Ward
No.01, Old Itarsi, Dist-Naramadapuram (MP)-461111
20. Mahesh Kumar Sahu S/o Shri Motilal Sahu, DOB-30/10/1962, MES
No.-413870 Retired As- Electrician (HS-I) R/o- Azad Chowk, Ward No.01,
Itarsi, Dist - Narmadapuram (MP)-461111
21. Nathuram S/o Shri Ramkishan Rai, DOB-01/07/1960, MES No.-
420150 Retired As- Carpenter (HS-II) R/o- Shiv Nagar, Vill - Chandon,
Itarsi, Dist - Naramadapauram (MP)-461111
Page 56 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
57
22. Ghanshyam S/o Shri Baliram, DOB-10/01/1964, MES No.-413885
Retired As- Electrician (HS-I) R/o- Deewan Colony, Ward No.01, Old Itarsi,
Dist-Naramadapuram (MP)-461111
23. Omprakash Malviya S/o Shri Satyanarayan Malviya, DOB-
30/12/1960, MES No.- 413827 Retired As- Carpenter (MCM) R/o- Malviya
Ganj, Vishwakarma Nagar, Itarsi, Dist - Narmadapuram (MP)-461111.
24. Manoj Kumar S/o Shri Prem Narayan, DOB-16/06/1963, MES No.-
413896 Retired As- Painter (SK) R/o- H.No.8/29, Pyasanagar, Old Itarsi,
Dist-Narmadapuram (MP)-461111
25. Rambharose S/o Shri Babulal, DOB-05/02/1961, MES No.- 420414
Retired As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- New Garibi Line, Itarsi, Dist
- Narmadapuram (MP)-461111
26. Gangaram Sahu S/o Late Adikram Sahu, DOB-25/03/1958, MES No.-
413861 Retired As- FGM (HS-II) R/o- Vill - Bhopsara, Post - Ghursena, Teh
- Nawagarh, Dist-Bemetara (CG) -491340
27. Smt. Suman Bai W/o Late Kamal Singh, DOB-05/07/1963, MES No.-
471076 Retired As- Carppenter (HS-II) R/o- Plot No.410/1, Behind
Santulal Petrol Pump, Pathrota, Itarsi Dist Narmadapuram (MP)-461111.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Vijay Tripathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110 001
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Headquarter
of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg Defence Head
Quater, New Delhi-110010
3. Chief Engineer (Headquarter) Military Engineering Service, Central
Command, Lucknow (UP)-226001
4. Chief Engineer (Headquarters) Bhopal Zone, Military Engineering
Service, S. I. Lines, Bhopal (MP)-462001
Page 57 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
58
5. Commander Works Engineer (Headquarter) Military Engineering Service,
211, Regiment Rd, Teela, Jamalpur, Gautam Nagar, Sri Nagar Colony,
Bhopal (MP)- 462001.
6. Garrison Engineer Military Engineering Services, Bhopal (MP)- 462030
7. Garrison Engineer, Military Engineering Service, Dronachal, Bhopal
(MP)- 462038
8. Assistant Garrison Engineer E/M Military Engineering Services, Itarsi
(MP)-461111
9. Assistant Garrison Engineer B/R, Military Engineering Services, Itarsi
(MP)-461111. .......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Satyendra Kumar Patel
Original Application No. 472 of 2024
1. Vijay Bahadur S/o Late Shri Ram Charan, Aged -59 years, Occupation -
Service as Refg. Mech. in MES, R/o Sri Nagar Colony, 1/11, Nadipar Tal,
Morar, Gwalior-474006.
2. Md. Rashid Khan S/o Late Shri Amanulla Khan, Aged -57 years,
Occupation-Service as Refg. Mech. in MES, R/o Welder Sab Ka Makan,
Near Bihari Halwayi, Bawan Payega, Nai Sadak, Lashkar, Gwalior-474001.
3. Jayadevan V.K. S/o Late Shri Achuthan K., Aged -57 years,
Occupation- Service as Refg. Mech. in MES, R/o Soniya, Achukulangara,
P.O. Paral (Via) Thalasserry, Distt. Kannur, Kerala.
4. Mumtaj Beg S/o Late Shri Moti Beg, Aged -57 years, Occupation -
Service as Elect. In MES, R/o Nai Basti, Near Kabristan, Gali No. 2, Aapa
Ganj, Lashkar, Gwalior M.P. 474001.
5. Narendra Pal S/o Shri Bal Kishan Pal, Aged -51 years, Occupation
Service as Refg. Mech. in MES, R/o Near Alpna Theatre, Morar, Gwalior -
474006.
6. Balkul Bhushan S/o Late Shri Pooran Chand, Aged- 60 years,
Occupation-Retired as Refg. Mech. from MES, R/o Vill. & P.O. Darini,
Tehsil Shapur, Distt. Kangra, Himachal Pradesh-176206.
7. Roop Singh S/o Late Shri Durjan Singh, Aged-62 years, Occupation-
Page 58 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
59
Retired as Refg. Mech. from MES, R/o A-Block, Ward No. 7, Near Ganesh
Dairy, Hurawali, Gwalior M.P. 474006. .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri A.P. S. C houhan
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, South Block, New Delhi 110011.
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi 110011.
3. Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow, U.P. 226001
4. HQ Commander works Engineer (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior, M.P.
475110
5. Garrison Engineer (R&D) MES, Lucknow Road, New Delhi. 110001
6. Principal Controller of Defence Accounts, Defence Offices Complex, 6th
Floor, A-Block, Africa Avenue, New Delhi 110023. .......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Brij Mohan Patel
Shri Akshay Jain
Original Application No. 768 of 2024
1. Satish Rathor S/o Shri Bhagwan Das Rathor Age-37 Year, MES No.-
424369 Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS) R/o- P-930/1,
MES Colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020
2. Omkar Yadav S/o Shri Mahesh Yadav Age-27 Year, MES No.- 424479
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o- Sainik Colony Pinto Park Gwalior
(M.P.) 474005
3. Rahul Shukla S/o Late Shri Rambhan Shukla Age-31 Year, MES No.-
424489 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o-612/04 MES Colony
Maharajpur Gwalior (M.Ρ.) 424020
4. Deepu Rathor S/o Shri Rajaram Age-32 Year, MES No.- 404309
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o-D-139, B Shatabdipuram Gwalior
(M.P.) 424020
Page 59 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
60
5. Jeevan Lal Pal S/o Shri Durga Prasad Pal Age-59 Year, MES No.-
423480 Working As- Electrician (SK). R/o- H. NO. Ghosipura, Cantt Area
Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
6. Pinku Kumar S/o Late Vidyarthi Ram, Age-39 Year, MES No.- 424441
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o P-612/02 MES Colony AfS Gwalior
(M.P.) 474020
7. Manoj Kurmi S/o Shri Lakhan Lal Age-33 Year, MES No.- 404306
Working As- Mate Electrician (SK) R/o- 930/4 MES Colony AfS
Maharajpura Gwalior (M.Ρ.) 474020
8. Deepak Pal S/o Shri Ajay Shankar Pal, Age-29 Year, MES No.- 424430
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o- Village & Post - Fatehpur, Police
Station, Ranipur Distt.- Mau (U.P) 276402
9. Bantu S/o Shri Padam Singh, Age-30 Year, MES No.- 424432 Working
As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o- Village & Post - Ikran, Police Station
Chiksana Teh- Bharatpur, Distt.- Bharatpur (RAJ.) 321001
10. Yashpal Singh S/o Shri Tilak Singh Bhadoria, Age-60 Year, MES No.-
424373 Working As Mate R/M (SS) R/o- H.No. 366, B Suresh Nagar
Thatipur, Morar Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) 474006
11. Shishupal Singh Lodhi S/o Shri Kunwar Raj Lodhi Age-30 Year, MES
No.424445 Working As. Mate Electrician (SS) R/o- D-139. B,
Shatabdipuram Gwalior (M.P.) 474020
12. Mushtak Khan S/o Late Habib Khan Age-60 Year, MES No. 423426
Working As- Elctrician (SK) R/o-246/4 MES Colony AfS Maharajpura,
Gwalior MP 474020
13. Arun Kumar Rai S/o Late Shriram Rai Age-47 Year, MES No.- 424217
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o Saroj School Inter College
Near Ghas Mandi, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020
14. Prakashchand S/o Shri Maganaram Age-56 Year, MES No.- 423093
Working As- Elctrician (SK) R/O Shiv Colony Pinto Park Road Murar
Gwalior MP 474005
15. Satyapal Singh S/o Shri Jaskaran SinghAge-47 Year, MES No.-
11792-K, Working As HSK-I (Now Presantly Post Held) Mate R/M (SS) R/o
Page 60 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
61
H. No-19, S.No.-03 Pitambara Estate Near Holy Child Public School
Adityapuram Bhind Road Gwalior (M.P.) 474005
16. Pradeep Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Antram Sharma Age-46 Year, MES
No424237 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o C/O Anil Traders,
Randhir Colony, Bhind Road Gole Ka Mandir Gwalior (M.P.) 474005
17. Vijay Pratap Singh S/o Shri Saroj Singh Tomar Age-37 Year, MES No.-
424325 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Randhir Colony Bhind
Road Gole Ka Mandir, Gwalior MP 474005
18. Pushpendra Singh Yadav S/o Shri Kedar Singh Yadav Age-32 Year,
MES No.- 424368 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Sonsa, Bandhli,
Morar, Gwalior MP 474006
19. Rajkumar S/o Late Hardev, Age-58 Year, MES No.424044, Working
As-Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o Panch Sheel Nagar Shabda Pratap
Ashram Road, Lashkar Gwalior (M.P.) 474020
20. Gopal Singh S/o Late Hari Ram, Age-60 Year, MES No.- 423433.
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o Kheriyapadampura Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
21. Umesh Chand Saraswat S/o Late Gonda Lal Saraswat, Age-59 Year,
MES No.- 423338 Working As-Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- Navik
Nagar Nidaan Hospital Ke Pass, Tadi Bagiya Bhagwati Bag Agra (U.P.)
282006
22. Praveen Kumar Gaur S/o Shri Jagdish Prasad Gaur, Age-59 Year,
MES No.- 423457 Working As Ref/ Mechnic (HS-I) R/o- C/19 BSf Colony,
Bhind Road Maharajpur, Gwalior MP 474005
23. Mohd. Afsar Khan S/o Late Shri Salamat Ullah Khan Age-59 Year,
MES No.- 423475, Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Q.No-
241/2 MES Colony AFS Maharajpura, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020
24. Bhupendra Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Om Prakash Sharma, Age-60
Year, MES No.- 423067 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o-
Sudagar Sentor Morar Gwalior Mp.-474006
Page 61 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
62
25. Deviram Meena S/o Shri Dal Chand, Age-59 Year, MES No.- 424109
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-I) R/o- Nagla Gopal, Post- Tochgur
Dist- Alligar (Hathrus) U.P.204101
26. Dogar Singh Pal S/o Shri Gopal Singh Age-57 Year, MES No.- 423192
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o-380A, Suresh Nagar,
Thatipur Morar, Gwalior MP-474006
27. Ram Gopal Pal S/o Shri Devi Ram Pal, Age-56 Year, MES No.- 423171
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Gayatri Vihar Colony Pinto
Park Morar, Gwalior M-P-474005
28. Ajay Kumar Bijoriya S/o Shri Rajaram Age-59 Year, MES No.- 423362
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Sheel Nagar Bahodapur
Gwalior M.P.- 474012
29. Bhagwan Das S/o Late Prakash Age-56 Year, MES No.- 423242
Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o- Arya Nagar Morar Gwalior (M.P.)-
474006
30. Rakesh Kumar S/o Shri Ramesh Kumar Age-51 Year, MES No.-
424196 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o- Jawahar Nagar
Colony Kampoo Lashkar Gwalior MP-474001
31. Dhirendra Kumar Pal S/o Shri Hari Mohan Pal DOB-18-11-1992,
MES No.- 424429 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o-615-A, Virat
Ngar Ahirvan Kanpur (U.P.) 208021
32. Pawan Kumar Ram S/o Late Hiralal Ram, Age-34 Year, MES No.-
404314 Working As- Mate - Refrigerator Mechanic (SS) R/o- Saithary
Maharajpur Gwalior (M.P.)- 474020
33. Ram Akthyar Singh S/o Late Babu Singh, Age-63 Year, MES No.-
423035 Retired - Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Adarsh Nagar Pinto
Park Morar Gwalior MP-474005
34. Gemeni Kumar S/o Shri Bal Kishan Age-62 Year, MES No.- 423029
Retired - M.P.A, R/o- Garam Sadak, Morar Gwalior MP-474020
35. Shivkumar S/o Late Shrilaljit, Age-61 Year, MES No.- 423283 Retired
- Electrician (HS-I) R/o- Kanch Mill Bada Gate, Birlanagar, Gwalior, MP-
474020
36. Brajendra Kumar Shrivastav S/o Late Narayan Das Shrivastav,
Page 62 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
63
Age-61 Year, MES No.- 423395 Retired - Electrician (Wireman) R/o-315
Karamchari Awash Colony Mahalgaon Gwalior (MP)-474020
37. Kaleem Ahmad Khan S/o Late Khaleel Ahmad Khan, Age-64 Year,
MES No.- 423350 Retired - Electrician (HS-I) R/o- H.No.247/8,
Shatabdipuram, D.D Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474019
38. Prem Gaur S/o Shri Latoori, Age-57 Year, MES No.- 423407 Working
As-Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o- Village Rasulpur, Bhind Road,
Gwalior (M.P.)
39. Manoj Singh Sengar S/o Shri Vakeel Singh Sengar, Age-30 Year, MES
No.- 424443, Working As-Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS) R/o- K-2
Shubanjalipuram Bhind Road, Gwalior (М.Р.) 474020
40. Dharmendra Singh S/o Shri Ramdas, Age-61 Year, MES No.-376065
Retired - Mate Electrician (SS) R/o-245/02 MES Colony APS, Maharajpur
Gwalior, MP-474001
41. Pushpendra Prasad Singh S/o Shri Baleswari Prasad Singh, Age-32
Year, MES No.- 404308. Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS)
R/o- Gharaha Koraon Prayagraj (U.P) Pincode 212306
42. Manoj Singh Yadav S/o Shri Pratap Singh Yadav,Age-33 Year, MES
No.-424481Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS),R/o- Jaderua
Kalam Pinto Park Morar Gwalior (M.P.), Pincode 474005
43. Deependra Singh S/o Shri Shailenda Singh, Age-35 Year, MES No.-
424424, Working As-- Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS) R/o- Vill
Khatangi, Post Gamjateh Sadar, Distt.- Prayagraj (U.P.) 211012
44. Radhakant Awasthi S/o Shri Sumit Narayan Awasthi, Age-60 Year,
MES No.-423188, Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o-
Gayatri Vihar Colony Pinto Park, Morar Gwalior (M.P.) 44006
45. Mohan Singh S/o Shri Adiram, Age-59 Year, MES No.- 423275,
Working As Electrician (HS-1) R/o- Hurawali Bhind, New RTO Officer,
Near Ambedkar Park Morar Gwalior MP 474006
46. Kalyan Singh S/o Shri Shobharam, Age-58 Year, MES No.- 423318,
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II) R/o- Suryapura Hathikhana
Road Morar, Gwalior (M.Ρ.) 474006
Page 63 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
64
47. Jitendra Donderiya S/o Shri Maheshchand Donderiya, Age-39 Year,
MES No.- 424372, Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS), R/o-
Main Road Mahaveerpura Morena (M.P.) 476001
48. Sanjay Soni S/o Shri Shreelal, Age-30 Year, MES No.- 424433,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o- Prem Nagar Jaura Khurd Morena
(M.P.) 476001
49. Munna Khan S/o Shri Sakhawat Khan, Age-61 Year, MES No.-
423238, Retired- Electrician (HS-I), R/o- Jiwaji Ganj Kati Ghati, A.B. Road
Gwalior (M.P.)474001
50. Sanjay Singh S/o Shri Ramjeet Singh, Age-30 Year, MES No.- 404313,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o- Village Vdaiyapur, Post Chail
Kaushmbi (U.P.) 212202.
51. Saurabh Kesharwani S/o Shri Shatughan Kesharwani, Age-30, MES
No.- 424426, Working As- Mate - Refrigerator Mechanic (SS), R/o- Village
Kanaili Post Kanaili Dist Kaushambi (U.P.) 212216
52. Dinesh Kumar Yadav S/o Shri Dharamraj Yadav, Age-28, MES No.-
424488, Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o- Village Kushuwa, Post
Manauri Dist Prayagraj (U.P.) 212208
53. Rattan Singh S/o Shri Vijay Singh, Age-35, MES No.- 424444,
Working As- Mate - Refrigerator Mechanic (SS), R/o- Village Kanuka, Po-
Dharan Teh Bawal, Distt.- Rewari, (Haryana) 123412
54. Anand Raj S/o, Shri Lallu Singh, Age-31, MES No.- 424427, Working
As- Mate Electrician (S), R/o Village Ismailpur Kotwa, Post Maauri, Distt.-
Prayagraj (U.P.) 212208
55. Premraj Meena S/o Shri Dhanna Lal Meena, Age-35, MES No. 424442,
Working As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic (SS), R/o- Village Sunderpur,
Post Kankariya Teh Lalsot Dist Dausa, (Raj) 303503
56. Sandeep Kumar Singh S/o Shri Krishan Bahadur Singh, Age-40, MES
No.- 424330, Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK), R/o- Gotauna
Haidergarh Dist Barabanki (U.P) 225124
Page 64 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
65
57. Rajkumar S/o Shri Mukesh Kumar, Age-33, MES No.- 404307,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o War No. 05, Sutarpura Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
58. Sanjeev Tyagi S/o Shri Gyanendra Tyagi, Age-27, MES No.- 424491,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o- Seetapur Basti Ward No. 11,
Sabalgar, Distt.- Morena,(Μ.Ρ.) 476229
59. Gayatri S/o Shri Late Gotoram, Age-55, MES No.- 424376, Working
As- Mate Refrigerator Mechanic, R/o- Ward No. 04 Aantri, Gwalior (M.P.)
475001.
60. Namita Mishra S/o Shri Suraj Panday, Age-31, MES No.- 424436
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o-244/4 MES Colony Maharajpur
(Aes) Gwalior MP 474020
61. Balram S/o Shri Daulatram Age-59, MES No.- 423312 Working As-
Electrician (SK) R/o Gautam Nagar Chandel Dairy ke Pass, 02 No. Gali,
Nadi Partal, Thaipur Gwalior, МР 474020
62. Ganesh Pal S/o Shri Jai Prakash Pal, Age-35, MES No.- 426497,
Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS), R/o Jaderua Kalan Pinto
Park Residency Morar Gwalior MP 474006
63. Ramotar Meena S/o Late Omkar Meena, Age-31, MES No.- 404310,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Village & post Mirzapura, Teh:-
Lalsot, Distt.:- Dausa (Raj) - 303503
64. Monu Kumar S/o Shri Ramashish Sharma, Age-29, MES No.- 424446,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o H.No. 2278, Kartikey Nagar II,
Senthari Gwalior MP 474020
65. Saroj Kumar Kashri S/o Shri B.L. Kashri, Age-30, MES No.- 424439,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o I-724, Shatapdipuram Phase- GDA
Nagar-II, Senthari, Gwalior MP 474020
66. Rajeev Kumar S/o Shri Shivratan Pal, Age-35, MES No.- 424482,
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o I-724, Shatapdipuram Phase-1,
GDA Colony, D.D. Nagar Gwalior MP 474012
67. Radheshyam Kumar S/o Shri Kaliter Manjhi, Age-32, MES No.-
424480, Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Village Bangra Bujurg,
Post:- Pakari, Police Station:-Barhary, Distt.: Siwan, Bihar- 841438
Page 65 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
66
68. Mayank Singh S/o Shri Virendra Singh, Age-30, MES No.- 424484
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS), R/o Village Chirla Munjapta Post:-
Ganja, Teh- Sadar, Distt:- Prayagraj (U.P.) 211012.
69. Manish Singh S/o Shri Chandrabhan Singh Age-35, MES No.- 424485
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Village Chirla Munjapta, Post:-
Ganja, Teh:-Sadar, Distt.:- Prayagraj (U.P.) 211012
70. Parath Singh S/o Shri Balmukand Age-57, MES No.- 423447 Working
As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Shiv Colony, Pinto Park Gwalior (M.P.)
474005
71. Amardeep Kumar S/o Shri Radha Raman Kumar Age-33, MES No.-
424487 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o P-246/2 MES Colony, AFS
Maharajpura Gwalior -474020
72. Dinesh Kumar Agarwal S/o Shri S. N. Agarwal Age-58, MES No.-
423209 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o AM 59, D.D. Nagar Gwalior
(M.P.) 474006
73. Mahesh Pal S/o Shri Ramswaroop Age-58, MES No.- 423205 Working
As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o B.M.52, D.D. Nagar Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
74. Surendra Singh Nathawat S/o Shri Girwar Singh Age-33, MES No.-
424452 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o GL 1336, D.D.Nagar
Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
75. Rakesh Kumar Gole S/o Shri Shiv Namya Gole Age-58, MES No.-
423464 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o Char Shahar Ka Nak,a Indra
Nagar, Gwalior (М.Р.) 474006
76. Arun Yadav S/o Shri Veer Singh Yadav Age-32, MES No.- 424362
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o 96 Tyagi Nagar, Morar, Gwalior,
(M.P.) 474006
77. Manish Kumar Chaubay S/o Shri Jamuna Prasad Age-31, MES No.-
424477 Working As- Mate Pipe Fitter (SS) R/o W22 Bijauli Jhansi (U.P.)
284001
78. Pankaj Singh S/o Shri Pati Singh, Age-27, MES No.- 424463 Working
As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o 709/3 Mutti Ganj, Allahabad (U.P.) 211003.
Page 66 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
67
79. Soni Devi W/o Shri Monoj Adivasi, Age-54, MES No.- 424332 Working
As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o Bhim Nagar Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.)
474006
80. Ramkishor Rathore S/o Shri Ramdas Rathore, Age-58, MES No.-
423387 Working As- Electrician (HS-II) R/o GM-850 D.D.Nagar, Gwalior
(M.P.) 474006
81. Kiledar Singh S/o Shri Harvilas Age-56, MES No.- 423320 Working
As- Electrician (SK) R/o Ward No. 61 Madhauvan Nagar, Badaghon Morar
Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
82. Rambabu Kushwah S/o Shri Shri Gopal, Age-58, MES No.- 423445,
Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o H. No. B-18 Soori Nagar S.L.P. Collage
Ke Pass Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
83. Rambabu Rathore S/o Shri Bhavosi Lal, Age-58, MES No.- 423366
Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o Rishala Bazar, Morar Gwalior (M.P.)
474006
84. Pramod Kumar Goud S/o Shri Dayaram Goud, Age-58, MES No.-
423364 Working As-. Electrician (SK) R/o Gali No. 1, Aarya Nagar, Morar
Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
85 . Mahesh Kumar S/o Shri Chokhe Ram,Age-57 Year, MES No.-423430
Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o Santheri Ka Pura, Morar (Μ.Ρ.) 474006
86. Anil Kumar S/o Shri Leeladhar Age-58, MES No.- 423310 Working As-
Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Mothopura Morar Gwalior (M.Ρ.) 474006.
87. Ramnarayan Gurjar S/o Shri Hakim Singh, Age-60, MES No.- 423398
Working As Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o 29 Janak Puri, Bhind
Road Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
88. Natholi Singh S/o Shri Fundi Lal, Age-60, MES No.- 423089, Working
As - Fitter General Mechanic (SK), R/o A44/3 Shtabadipuram, D.D.
Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
89. Krishan Kumar S/o Shri Basant Kumar, Age-61, MES No.- 423452
Retired- Electrician (SK) R/o Shiv Colony, Pinto Park, Morar Gwalior (M.P.)
474006
Page 67 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
68
90. Mahendra Kumar Panday S/o Shri Govid Prashad Panday, Age-60,
MES No.- 423059, Working As Fitter General Mechanic (HS-1) R/o Shiv
Colony, Nahar Bali Mata Ke Niche, Naka Chandra Badani Laskar Gwalior
(M.P.) 474006
91. Purushottam Kumar S/o Shri Sushil Kumar, Age-62, MES No.-
423258, Retired- Electrician (HS-I), R/o D.D. Nagar Gwalior (M.P.) 474006
92. Shanti Bai W/o Late Raja Age-55, MES No.- 424353 Working As- Mate
Fitter General Mechanic R/o Tokoniya Morar Gwalior (M.Ρ.) 474006
93. Ubhay Singh S/o Shri Radhey Shivam Singh, Age-33, MES No.-
424499, Working As- Mate Pipe Fiter R/o 244/02 MES Colony, AFS,
Gwalior (M.P.) 474020
94. Shubash Chandra S/o Late Ramnath, Age-57, MES No.- 423415
Working As- Mate Electrician (SK) R/o Pinto Park Morar Gwalior (MP)
474006
95. Vinod Kumar Bharagav S/o Late Prem Narayan Bhargav, Age-46, MES
No.- T-7433 Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic, R/o Lal Sahab Ka
Bagibcha Morar Gwalior (MP) 474006
96. Raju S/o Shri Late Lokman, Age-57, MES No.- 423495, Working As-
Electrician (SK) R/o Nadi Par Tal, Morar Gwalior (M.P.) 474006.
97. Suresh Kumar Dewani S/o Late Ram Chandra Devani Age-56, MES
No.- 423225 Working As- Electrician (SK) 474006 R/o Suri Nagar Morar
Gwalior (MP) 474006
98. Pappu Baghel S/o Late Govindi Baghel Age-55, MES No.- T-7299
Working As- V/M (HS-I) R/o Golpahadiya Navgrah Colony, Gwalior (M.P.)
474001
99. Devicharan S/o Late Mohan Lal Age-36, MES No.- 424003 Working
As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o Khururi, Gwalior (MP) 474006
100. Rajesh Kumar Dhakar S/o Shri Siyaram Age-38, MES No.- 422800
Working As- Mate (- Refrigerator Mechanic) R/o Sheel Nagar Gwalior (MP)-
474003
Page 68 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
69
101. Ram Kumar S/o Late Bhagwan Das Batham Age-59, MES No.-
423420 Working As Electrician (SK) R/o Grass Bandi Murar Gwalior (MP)
474006
102. Jugal Kishore S/o Shri Balkishan Age-60, MES No.- 424012 Working
As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o Tyagi Nagar Morar Gwalior (MP)
474006
103. Raja Ram S/o Late Sumer Singh, Age-53, MES No.- 413963 Working
As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic (SS) R/o Mahthana Gwalior (MP)
474006
104. Bram Singh S/o Shri Tej Singh Age-57, MES No.- 424063 Working
As- - Refrigerator Mechanic (Mate) R/o Aditiya Nagar, Morar Gwalior (MP)
474006
105. Bhudayal Sharma S/o Late Shri Atmaram Age-55, MES No.- 423237
Working As- - Refrigerator Mechanic (SK), R/o Grass Mandi Morar (MP)
474006
106. Rakesh Yadav S/o Late Babu Lal Yadav, Age-59, MES No.- 423489,
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o Raghav Puram, Morar
Gwalior (MP) 474006
107. Pradeep Kumar S/o Late Shrikailash Chodhary Age-59, MES No.-
423440 Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o Rishala Bazar Morar
Gwalior (MP) 474006
108. Jitendra Yadav S/o Late B.L. Yadav, Age-58, MES No.- 424036
Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o Kalpi Briz Morar Gwalior (MP) 474006
109. Vishndutt Sharma S/o Late Ramratan Sharam, Age-60, MES No.-
423211 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-1) R/o Grass Mandi
Morar Gwalior (MP) 474006.
110. Chaman Lal S/o Late Balakdas, Age-49, MES No.- 412003 Working
As- - Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o MES Colony, Morar Gwalior (MP)
474006
111. Mehtab Singh S/o Late Karan Singh, Age-39, MES No.- 314852
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (Mate) R/o Mehgaon Bhind (MP)
475115
Page 69 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
70
112. Shyam Singh S/o Shri Gurdep Singh, Age-39, MES No.- 423828
Working As- Refrigerator Mechanic (Mate) R/o Tara Ganj Lashkar Gwalior
(MP) 474001
113. Bhagwan Dass S/o Late Batri, Age-58, MES No.- 424001 Working
As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o Kashipura Morar Gwalior (MP)
474006
114. Hemraj Singh Savita S/o Shri Matadeen, Working As- - Refrigerator
Mechanic (Mate), Age-38, MES No.- 422799 R/o Morena (MP) 476001
115. Prasadi S/o Late Devilal Age-60, MES No.-423304 Working As-
Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o Gole Ka Mandir Gwalior (MP) 474005
116. Dalchandra Basbaiya S/o Late Khuman Age-59, MES No.- 423451
Working As- Fitter General Mechanic R/o Tansen Nagar Hazira, Gwalior
(MP) 474002
117. Bhagwan Singh S/o Late Babulal Age-57, MES No.- 413940 Working
As- Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o Harnaampur, Thatipur, Gwalior
(MP) 474011
118. Mahesh Kumar S/o Late Barelal Rajak, Age-62, MES No.- 421545
Retired - Refrigerator Mechanic (SK) R/o Surya Nagar Morar, Gwalior (MP)
474006
119. Darashan Singh S/o Late Gulab Singh Rajput Age-65, MES No.-
419933 Retired-Fitter General Mechanic (HS-II) R/o Vinay Nagar Gwalior
(MP-) 474008
120. Phoolchand Morya S/o Late Ram Charan Age-63, MES No.- 423414
Retired - Fitter General Mechanic (SK) R/o Morar Gwalior (MP) 474006
121. Balveer Singh Couhan S/o Late Bajinath Age-61, MES No.- 424038
Retired-Electrician (HS-II) R/o Ashok Colony Morar, Gwalior (MP) 474006
122. Ashok Singh S/o Late Devi Singh Age-61, MES No.- 424007 Retired -
(HS-II) R/o Surya Nagar Morar Gwalior (MP) 474006
123. Rajesh Kumar Shrivastav S/o Shri Ramswaroop Shrivastav Age-61,
MES No.- 423326 Retired - Electrician (SK) R/o Parsadipura Morar
Gwalior (MP) 474006.
Page 70 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
71
124. Mahesh Chand Pal S/o Late Sevaram Pal,Age-62, MES No.-423215
Retired - Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II) R/o Bansipura Morar Gwalior (MP)
474006
125. Haricharan S/o Late Shambhu Age-54, MES No.- 424173 Working
As- Electrician (Mate) R/o Bada Gaon Morar Gwalior (MP) 474006
126. Vinod Sharma S/o Late Rambabu Sharma Age-47, MES No.- 421948
Working As- Mate Fitter General Mechanic R/o Sudamapuri Morar,
Gwalior (MP) 474006
127. Kuldeep Kumar Sonkar S/o Shri Phool Chandra Sonkar Age-36, MES
No.-424454 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Puraini Nijampur,
Puraini Manuri, Kaushambi (U.P.) 212208
128. Jassu Adiwasi S/o Shri Ratiram Adiwasi, Age-57, MES No.- 423173
Working As-- Refrigerator Mechanic (HS-II}, R/o Bheem Nagar Bada
Dullpur, Adiwasi Mohalla, Gird, Murar, Distt- Gwalior, (MP) 474006
129. Ravindra Kumar Katare S/o Shri Vishnu Charan Katare, Age-61,
MES No.- 423385 Retired - Electrician (HS-II) R/o Kuber Vihar Colony,
Indra Nagar, Thatipur, Gwalior (MP) 474011
130. Munna S/o Shri Chhigga, Age-60, MES No.- 423314 Working As-
Electrician (HS-II) R/o Kashipura, Gird, Murrar, Gwalior (MP) 474006
131. Pankaj Singh Dhakar S/o Shri Kailash Dhakar, Age-30, MES No.-
424456 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Ward No.18 Pani Ki Tanki
Ke Pass, Subhanjalipuram, Adityapuram Gwalior (M.P.) 474003
132. Chandra Shekhar S/o Shri Arun Kumar, Age-32, MES No.- 424451
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Ram Nagar, Char Shahar Ka Naka,
Hazira, Gwalior (M.P.) 474003.
133. Rakesh Singh 1 S/o Late Surendra Singh Age-35, MES No.- 424453
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o H. No. D-6, Ward No. 17, Indra
Nagar, Tansen Road, Gwalior (MP)--474003
134. Sunil Kumar S/o Shri Rajaram Singh, Age-35, MES No.- 424455
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o 245/03 MES Colony, Air Force
Station Gwalior (MP) 474020
Page 71 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
72
135. Kamal Kishor Nagar S/o Shri Gaya Prashad Nagar Age-56, MES No.-
423203 Working As- Electrician (SK) R/o Tikoniya, Morar Gali No.2,
Gwalior (MP) 474006
136. Pushpendra Singh S/o Shri Shivlal Age-33, MES No.-
404610,Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o. Gl. 575, D.D Nagar,
Gwalior (MP) 474020
137. Sanjeev Singh Bhadoriya S/o Shri Krapal Singh, Age-31, MES No.-
424250 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o Sainik Colony, Pinto Park,
Gole Ka Mandir, Gwalior (MP) 474005
138. Deepak Kumar Shukla S/o Shri Ashok Kumar, Age- 32, MES No.-
617371 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o. BM-204, Deen Dayal
Nagar, Gwalior (MP) 474020
139. Pradeep Kumar Lakra S/o Shri Tarciseus Lakra, Age-49, MES No.-
424208 Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o. EE 255, D.D Nagar, E-
Sector, Gird Gwalior (MP) 474005
140. Satyendra Singh S/o Shri Jhamman Age- 54, MES No.- 4183712
Working As- Mate Electrician (SS) R/o 244/01 MES Colony, Air Force
Station Gwalior (MP) 474020
141. Vijay Prakash Nishad S/o Shri Ram Karan Nishad, Age-30, MES No.-
424470 Working As- Mate Carpenter (SS), R/o GL 1051, D.D.Nagar,
Gwalior (MP) 474005
142. Salim Khan S/o Shri Nasir Khan, Age-59, MES No.- 423155 Working
As- Carpenter (SK) R/o Kashi Pura, Morar, Gwalior (MP) 474006
143. Suresh Kumar Sharma S/o Shri Khande Sharma, Age-59, MES No.-
423259 Working As- Painter (SK) R/o Shiv Colony Pinto Park, Gwalior MP
474020
144. Mahendra Singh S/o Shri Raghunath Singh Age-58, MES No.-
423378 Working As- Painter HS-1 R/o. 1252 Deendayal Nagar, Gwalior
(MP) 474020
145. Raju Batham S/o Shri Gyasiram Batham Age-58, MES No.- 423377
Working As- Painter (SK). R/o. P-5/2 Near Residency, Gwalior (MP)
474005
Page 72 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
73
146. Raju Batham S/o Shri Budhram Adivasi, Age-55, MES No.- 424126
Working As- Mate Carpenter R/o Bheem Nagar Thatipur Gwalior (MP)
474011
147. Sharif Khan S/o Shri Jafar Khan Age-61, MES No.- 423150 Retired-
Carpenter (SK) R/o Nai Sadak, Janak Ganj Lashkar Gwalior (MP) 474001
148. Devendra Kumar Tiwari S/o Shri Ram Prakash Tiwari Age-58, MES
No.- 423355 Working As- Fitter General Mechanic (Mcm) R/o D-19,
Basant Vihar Lashkar Gwalior (MP) 474007
149. Satendra Pachauri S/o Shri Rosan Lal Pachori Age-60, MES No.-
423392 Retired- Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o Maharana Pratap
Nagar, Gwalior (MP) 474009
150. Santosh Kumar Uppadhyay S/o Shri Jang Bahadur Uppadhyay Age-
61, MES No.- 423352 Retired-Fitter General Mechanic (HS-I) R/o. Naya
Santar, New Colony, Morar Gwalior (MP) 474006
151. Vijay Singh Paejwar S/o Shri Nandram Age-65, MES No.- 423280
Retired-Electrician (HS-I) R/o. C.P.Colony, Morar, Gwalior (MP) 474006.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Vijay Tr ipathi
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, Through its Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block,
New Delhi-110 001,
2. Engineer-In-Chief, Military Engineering Services, Integrated Head
Quarter of Ministry of Defence (Army), Kashmir House, Rajaji Marg
Defence Head Quater, New Delhi-110010.
3. Chief Engineer (Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service Central
Command Lucknow (UP)- 226001
4. Chief Engineer (AF) (Head Quarter) Military Engineering Service,
Prayagraj Zone Prayagraj (UP)-211012
5. Commander Works Engineer (AF) Military Engineering Service, Gwalior
(MP)-474020
Page 73 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
74
6. Garrison Engineer (AF) Tech Area Military Engineering Service, Gwalior
(MP)-474020. .......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri D.S. Baghel
Original Application No. 951 of 2024
1. MP MES Karamchari Sangh, Bajal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior M.P. Through
its General Secretary MPMES Karamachari Sangh, CWE Maharaj Pur Area
Gwalior (M.P), 474006
2. Mohan Singh S/o Late Kullaram, Aged -mp) 65 years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (SK), R/o, Sahu Ka Pura, Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
3. Rameshwar Dayal S/o Late Bansiram, Aged -65 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as MCM (FGM) R/o, Noorganj, Punjabi
Gurudwara Ke Pass Loha Mandi, Gwalior (M.Ρ.), 474003
4. Suresh Kumar Dubey S/o Late Ayodha Prasad Dubey, Aged -64 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-II) R/o Lal Sahab
Ka Bagicha, SLP College Ke Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
5. Ashok Kumar S/o Late Nihal Singh Sikarwar, Aged -64 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as MCM (FGM) R/o, Basant
Nagar, CP Colony Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
6. Mata Deen S/o Late Rajola, Aged -63 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as V/Man, R/o Nibuapura, Singhpur Road, Morar
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004.
7. Uday Lal S/o Late Ramlal, Aged -63 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as Mason (SK), R/o, Ambekar Park, Hurawali, Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
8. Amit Khan S/o Late Shakur Khan, Aged -63 years, Occupation - Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-II), R/o, GL-374, Deen Dayal Nagar
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
9. Asha Ram Nagar S/o Late Kishan Lal Nagar, Aged -63 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (SK), R/o,
Tikoniya, Bangali Colony ke Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
Page 74 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
75
10. Devi Dayal S/o Late Kallaram Godia, Aged -63 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (HS-II) R/o, Apaganj, Karigaro
Ka Moholla, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
11. Bijendra Singh Sengar S/o Late Malkhan Singh Sengar, Aged -63
years, Occupation - Retired from MES GE Gwalior as MCM (FGM), R/o, H.
No. 153, Line No. 02, Birla Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
12. Sajjan S/o Late Laxman, Aged -63 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (HS-II), R/o, PNT Colony, Bankhandswar
Mandir Ke Samne, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004.
13. Moolchand S/o Late Sitaram, Aged -63 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as Mason (SK), R/o, Shinde Ki Chawani, Hanuman
Ghati, Railway Phatak Ke Pass, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474002
14. Vijay Singh S/o Late Ramswaroop, Aged -63 years, Occupation Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as Mason (SK), R/o, Gautam Nagar, Nadi Paar Taal,
Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
15. Munna Lal S/o Late Ramprasad, Aged -62 years, Occupation Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-I), R/o, LA-83, Darpan Colony,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
16. Devi Singh S/o Late Tunda Singh, Aged -62 years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Mate (Mason), R/o, Kashipura,
Canttonment School Ke Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
17. Chiman Lal S/o Late Jagma, Aged -62 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as Elect (SK), R/o, Gram Patha Panihar, Tehsil Dabra,
Distt Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
18. Gopal S/o Late Sewaram, Aged -62 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as FGM (SK), R/o, Naka Chandrawadni Gadde Wala
Mohlla Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474002
19. Dalchand S/o Late Munnilal Shakya, Aged -62years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (SK), R/o, Nadi Paar Taal,
Lokman Ki Chakki, Morar, Gwalior (М.Р.), 474004
20. Rajendra Godia S/o Late Ujagar Singh Godia, Aged -61 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (SK), R/o, A
Block, Ward No 60, Hurawali, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
Page 75 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
76
21. RA Nair S/o Late V Rama Nair, Aged -61 years, Occupation Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (SK), R/o, MES Colony, Morar Cantt,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
22. Nand Kishore S/o Late Kalicharan Jha. Aged-61years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (HS-I), R/o, H No 25, Jhansi Roop
Road, Baradari Chouraha, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474 004
23. Gyanchand S/o Late Govind Dass, Aged -61years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Mate (Mason), R/o, Nadi Paar Taal, Naya
Moholla, Morar, Gwalior (M.P), 474004
24. Daulat Ram Sharma S/o Late Ramprakash Sharma, Aged -61years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Refg/Mech (HS-II), R/o, H
No 8, Hakchar Colony, 7No Chouraha, Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004.
25. Habib Khan S/o Late Razab Khan, Aged -61years, Occupation Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as V/Man, R/o, Kashipura, Canttonment School Ke
Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
26. Surendra Pal S/o Late Gopiram Pal, Aged -61years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-II), R/o, Prathvi Nagar, Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
27. Lakhan Singh S/o Late Man Singh Pal, Aged-61years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Mason (SK), R/o, Laltipara, Morar Cantt,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
28. Lalta Prasad S/o Late Manik Ram, Aged -61years, Occupation Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (HS-II), R/o, Pawansut Colony, Hurawali
Tiraha, Near Central Gyandeep School, Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
29. Babudin S/o Late Sardar Khan, Aged -60 years, Occupation Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (HS-II), R/o, Bansipura, Ward No. 02
Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
30. Jagdish S/o Late Ramkishan Shakya, Aged -60 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (SK), R/o, Gopalpura,
Kaladevi Mandir Ke Pass, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004.
31. Ratan Singh S/o Late Girdhari Lal Kushwah, Aged -60 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Painter (SK), R/o,
Kashipura, Canttonment School Ke Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
Page 76 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
77
32. Indresh Kumar Katharia S/o Late Ramdulare, Aged -60 years,
Occupation -Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (HS-II), R/o, Grand III,
403 Imrand Green Township HG Group, Khaarori, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.),
474004
33. Shriram Prajapati S/o Late Sarman Lal Prajapati, Aged -60 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (HS-II), R/o, 65 Ganga
Vihar Enclave, Hurawali Tiraha, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474 004
34. Hukum Singh S/o Late Hiralal Kushwah, Aged -60 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Pipe Fitter (SK), R/o, Goriya Bhawan,
Kashipura, Morar Gwalior (М.Р.), 474004
35. Srikrishan Pal S/o Late Chatrapal Pal, Aged -60 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Mate (Mason), R/o, H No. 72, Laaltipara,
Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
36. Naresh S/o Late Mithua, Aged -60 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as Pipe Fitter (SK), R/o, Risala Bazar, Harijan Basti,
Morar, Gwalior (М.Р.), 474004
37. Devendra Kumar S/o Late Babu Lal Saral, Aged -60 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (SK), R/o, P-156/1, MES
Colony, Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
38. Bal Bhadra Singh S/o Late Mukut Singh Bhadoriya, Aged -60 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-I), R/o, Laxman
Talaiya, Post Office Sabdhpratap Ashram, Lashkar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.),
474002
39. RK Nair S/o Late V Rama Nair, Aged -60 years, Occupation Retired
from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-II), R/o, P-150/1, MES Colony, Morar
Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
40. Lakhan Lal Gupta S/o Late Kishori Lal Gupta, Aged -60 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-I), R/o, Raghav
Colony, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
41. Ashok Kumar Rathore S/o Shri Badri Prasad Rathore, Aged -60 years,
Occupation Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Pipe Fitter (HS-I), R/o,
Rathore Santor Nadi Paar Taal, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004.
Page 77 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
78
42. Lakhan Singh S/o Late Durjan Singh, Aged -62 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Mason (HS-II), R/o, Bansipura, Ward No.
02 Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
43. Lakhan Singh S/o Late Bhajan Lal, Aged -64 years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (HS-II), R/o, Ghosipura,
Divaan Sahab Ki Chatri Ke Samne, Lashkar Gwalior (M.P.), 474002
44. Sohan Singh S/o Late Ramswaroop, Aged -60 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as FGM (HS-II), R/o, Gautam Nagar,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
45. Peru S/o Late Razab Khan, Aged -61 years, Occupation Retired from
MES GE Gwalior as Pipe Fitter (SK), R/o, Kashipura, Canttonment School
Ke Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
46. Smt. Koka Bai S/o Shri Badan Singh, Aged -61 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Carpenter (SK). R/o, Patel Petrol Pump
ke Piche, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
47. Jagdeep Singh S/o Late Ramshwarup, Aged -64 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (HS-II), R/o, 981/C-1, Bahar,
Shamshan ghat ke pass, Unnao gate, Jhansi Khas, PO: Jhansi, U.P. -
284002,
48. Jamuna Dass S/o Late Man Singh, Aged -62 years, Occupation -
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Pipe Fitter (SK), R/o, Bada Gaon, Near
Bijli Ghar, Khururi, Morar Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
49. Aslam Khan S/o Late Shri Sattar Khan, Aged -62 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Mason (HS-II), R/o, Ajmer, Jaipur
(Rajesthan), 302001
50. Om Prakash S/o Late Shri Janved Singh Aged -62 years, Occupation
Retired from MES GE Gwalior as Elect (SK), R/o, Laltipara, Morar Cantt,
Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004. .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, Department of Defence production South Block, New Delhi -
110011.
Page 78 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
79
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi-110011.
3. Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow, U.P. 226002
4. Chief Engineer, Southern Command, Pune - 411001.
5. The Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Road, Palam,
Delhi Cantt-110010
6. HQ Commander works Engineer (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior, (M.P.) -
474020
7. HQ Commander works Engineer, Jhansi (U.P.) - 284001
8. Garrison Engineer, Gwalior MES Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.) -
474006. .......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Akshay Jain
Original Application No. 1088 of 2024
1. MP MES Karamchari Sangh, Bajal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior M.P. through
its General Secretary. CWE Maharajpur Area Gwalior M.P. 474006
2. Sebastian Thomas S/o Shri EO Thomas, Aged -58 years, Occupation
Service as MCM (FGM), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o 22, Shakti Vihar, New
Darpan Colony, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
3. Rajkumar S/o Late Madan Lal Dhubkaria, Aged -59 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (HS-I) in MES GE Gwalior, R/o FL153, Deen Dayal Nagar,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
4. Anand Kumar Pathak S/o Shri Jagdish Prasad Pathak, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Durga
Colony, 6No Chouraha, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
5. Satendra Singh S/o Late Gajendra Singh Bhadoriya, Aged -59 years,
Occupation -Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Pushkar
Colony, Gola Ka Mandir, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004.
6. Ajay Singh Meena S/o Late Johri Lal Meena, Aged -56 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Gram/ Post
Jag Jivanpur Tehsil-Weir, Distt- Bharatpur, Rajasthan, 302001
Page 79 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
80
7. PV JIJI, S/o Late PV PP, Aged -59 years, Occupation Service as FGM
(HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Near St Paul's School, Morar, Gwalior
(M.P.), 474004
8. Ravindra Singh Yadav S/o Shri Jagdish Prasad Yadav, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Suriya Vihar
Colony, Pinto Park Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
9. Om Prakash Gupta S/o Late Ram Sewak Gupta, Pipe Fitter (HS-I), Age
58 in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Shakti Nagar, Chauhan Piyaoo, Thatipur,
Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
10. Ashmat Ali Khan S/o Late Enayat Ali Khan, Aged -56 years,
Occupation Service as Carpenter (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o
Damodar Bagh Colony, Bahdapur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
11. Ram Shresth Sharma S/o Late Ramlakhan Sharma, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as Carpenter (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Qtr No.
185/2 Alpna Takeej, Tikonia Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
12. Hari Singh S/o Late Pyarelal Kushwaha, Aged -59 years, Occupation
Service as Black Smith (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Dal Bazar Tiraha,
Tapu Moholla, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
13. Bhagwan Dass S/o Late Ramcharan, Aged -56 years, Occupation -
Service as Painter (HS-I), Age 56 in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Nadipaar Taal,
Katyani Gali, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
14. Sarnaam Singh S/o Late Shyam Lal, Aged -57 years, Occupation -
Service as Painter (HS-I), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Gautam Nagar,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
15. Asha Ram S/o Late Lajjaram Pal, Aged -56 years, Occupation Service
as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Karoli Wali Mata, Mahelgoan,
City Centre, Gwalior (M.P.), 474001
16. Suresh S/o Late Kaisariya Rajak, Aged -59 years, Occupation Service
as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Bansipura, Morar, Gwalior
(M.P.), 474004
17. Ramswaroop Kanojia S/o Late Arjun Singh, Aged -57 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (HS-II), in MES, R/o Suriya Ka Pura, Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
Page 80 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
81
18. Chatar Pal S/o Late Bahadur Singh, Aged -59 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Hathi Khana Road,
Banshipura Gali No. 1, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
19. Sukhiram Meena S/o Late Shrilal Meena, Aged -58 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Sainik Colony Pinto Park,
Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
20. Munidev Sharma S/o Late Keshav Dev Sharma, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as Pipe Fitter (HS-II), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o 3/7,
Sabdh Pratap Ashram, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
21. Ranjeet Singh Rana S/o Late Vikram Singh Rana, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as Carpenter (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Aditya
Nagar, CP Colony Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
22. Hari Om S/o Late Phoolchand Pawaiya, Aged -59 years, Occupation
Service as Refg/Mech (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Satyanarayan Santor
Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004.
23. Jagdish Singh S/o Late Harbhajan Singh Kushwaha, Aged -56 years,
Occupation -Service as Refg/Mech (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o
Suriyapura Hathikhana Road, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
24. Rajkumar Singh S/o Shri Durga Prasad, Aged -41 years, Occupation
Service as Refg/Mech (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o 137, New Basti
Godam, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
25. Ratnesh Khare S/o Late Ramesh Chand Khare, Aged -38 years,
Occupation Service as Refg/Mech (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Patel
Nagar City Centre, Gwalior (M.P.), 444001
26. Rajendra Kumar S/o Late Prakash Goud, Aged -59 years, Occupation
Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Arya Nagar Gali No. 1,
Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
27. Raju Kushwaha S/o Late Mishri Lal Kushwah, Aged -57 years,
Occupation Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Kashipura,
Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
28. Bhawani Rathore S/o Late Babu Singh Rathore, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o BM-123, Deen
Dayal Nagar, Maharajpur Road, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
Page 81 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
82
29. Chander Shekher Yadav S/o Late Hetam Singh Yadav, Aged -55 years,
Occupation Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Gram
Mohanpur, Post Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
30. Lallan Prasad S/o Late Hazari Prasad, Aged -56 years, Occupation
Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Raghav Colony, Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
31. Bharat Bhushan S/o Shri Tirath Dass, Aged -56 years, Occupation
Service as Elect (SK) in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Naya Santor, New Colony,
Morar Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
32. Srinivas S/o Late Devi Lal, Aged -55 years, Occupation Service as
FGM (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Galla Kottar, Sakhwar Samaj
Dharamsala, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
33. Gambheer Singh Yadav S/o Late Matadeen Yadav, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Badagoan,
Morar Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
34. Gurdayal S/o Late Budha Singh Pal, Aged -59 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Mohanpur, Morar, Gwalior
(M.P.), 474004
35. Smt Meena Devi H/o Narayan Singh Kushwaha, Aged -43 years,
Occupation -Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Kashipura,
Canttonment School Ke Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
36. Harnarayan S/o Late Shyam Lal, Aged -57 years, Occupation - Service
as Pipe Fitter (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Shree Nagar Colony,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.), 47-4004
37. Balmukund S/o Late Narayan Singh Raje, Aged -58 years, Occupation
Service as Pipe Fitter (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Gram - Ganeshpura,
Thana - Bijoli, Post -Badagoan, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
38. Santosh Kumar S/o Late Patiram, Aged 55 years, Occupation Service
as Pipe Fitter (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Shiv Nagar, Sirol Road,
Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
39. Umesh Kumar S/o Late Patiram, Aged -56 years, Occupation Service
as Mason (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Ram Nagar, Morar, Gwalior
(M.P.), 474004
Page 82 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
83
40. Suresh S/o Late Nainaram Kushwah, Aged -55 years, Occupation
Service as Mason (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o MES Colony, Morar
Cantt, Gwalior, (Μ.Ρ.). 474004
41. Smt Madhuri Sharma H/o Late GD Sharma, Aged -53 years,
Occupation Service as Vech/Mech (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Azad
Ngar, Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
42. Kamal Kishore S/o Late Shuklal, Aged 54 years, Occupation Service
as Painter (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Kashipura, Morar, Gwalior
(M.P.), 474004
43. Mahesh Kumar Thakur S/o Late Dayaram Thakur, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as Painter (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Tyagi Nagar,
Near Shukla Boring Ka Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
44. Amar Singh Kushwah S/o Late Deendayal Kushwah, Aged -42 years,
Occupation Service as Painter (SK), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Kashipura,
Canttonment School Ke Pass, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
45. Ragubhir Singh S/o Late Babu Lal, Aged -55 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Elect), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Gautam Nagar, Thatipur,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
46. Burju Ram S/o Late Soha Bichhu Ram, Aged -54 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Elect), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o P-7/5, Wheel line, MES
Colony, Pintoo Park, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
47. Raja Ram S/o Late Sumer Singh, Aged -55 years, Occupation Service
as Mate (Elect), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Gram Mehthana, Post
Jadoruakala, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
48. Papendra Singh S/o Shri Brajendra Singh, Aged -36 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Elect), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o H No. 120,
Patel Nagar Aditya Puram, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
49. Mannu Lal Pal S/o Late Gopiram Pal, Aged -52 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Prathvi Nagar, Morar,
Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
50. Gori Shankar S/o Late Natho Batham, Aged -39 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o P-151/3, MES Colony,
Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
Page 83 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
84
51. Harish Chandra Sharma S/o Late Ramlakhan Sharma, Aged -42
years, Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o P-
148/1, MES Colony, Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
52. Narendra Singh Rathore S/o Shri Mahendra Singh Rathore, Aged -33
years,Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o
Tikoniya, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
53. Arun Goyal S/o Shri Mahendra Kumar Goyal, Aged -36 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o D-1, Hariom
Colony, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), Η 74004
54. Madan Lal S/o Late Girdhari Lal Kushwah, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Pipe Fitter), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o
Kashipura, Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
55. Brij Mohan Verma S/o Shri Babu Lal Verma, Aged -55 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Pipe Fitter), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o BL-172,
Opposite Hardol Nagar, DD Nagar, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
56. Prem S/o Late Birja, Aged -45 years, Occupation Service as Mate (Pipe
Fitter), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o P-156/3, MES Colony, Morar Cantt,
Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
57. Jagdish Prasad S/o Late Mannu, Aged -59 years, Occupation - Service
as Mate (Pipe Fitter), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o Sankar Colony, Gole
Phadiya, Lashkar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
58. Ram Milan Prajapati S/o Late Tilak Ram, Aged -51 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Refg/Mech), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o P-150/2, MES
Colony, Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
59. Ajit Kumar S/o Shri Durga Prasad, Aged -34 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Refg/Mech), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o 137, New Basti
Godam, Thatipur, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474004
60. Vishnu Kumar S/o Late Kishorilal Rathore, Aged -56 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Pipe Fitter), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o
Gadipura Samsan Road Hazira, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
61. Laxman Singh Kushwaha S/o Late Bhagwan Lal Kushwah, Aged -51
years, Occupation Service as Mate (MTD), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o New
Vijay Vihar Colony, Kashipura, Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 47-4004
Page 84 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
85
62. Raj Narayan Sharma S/o Shri Jhandu Lal Sharma, Aged -43 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Vech/Mech), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o
Thapak Moholla, Ganj, Ward No. 5 Village- Gormi, Distt- Bhind (M.P.),
474004.
63. Sewak Singh S/o Late Maniram Singh, Aged -59 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Vech/Mech), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o H No 01F. Amaltas
Colony, Gola Ka Mandir, Gwalior (M.P.), and 474004
64. Om Prakash Sharma S/o Late Ramsewak Sharma, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Vech/Mech), in MES GE Gwalior, R/o P-
148/2, MES Colony, CTC Line, Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.) 474004.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, Department of Defence production South Block, New Delhi -
110011.
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi-110011.
3. Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow, U.P. 226002
4. Chief Engineer, Southern Command, Pune - 411001.
5. Office of the Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Road,
Palam, Delhi Cantt-110010
6. HQ Commander works Engineer (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior, (M.P.) -
474020
7. HQ Commander works Engineer, Jhansi (U.P.) - 284001
8. Garrison Engineer, Gwalior MES Morar Cantt, Gwalior (M.P.) -
474006. .......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Akshay Jain
Original Application No. 1111 of 2024
Page 85 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
86
1. MP MES Karamchari Sangh, Baijal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior (M.P) 474006
through its General Secretary, CWE, Maharajpur Area, Gwalior (M.P)
2. Mewalal Prajapti S/o Shri KP Prajapati, Aged -62 years, Occupation-
Retired as Refg/Mech (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
244 Sharda Vihar, City Centre, Gwalior (M.P) 474011,
3. Ghan Shyam Dass, S/o Shri Gokul Prasad, Aged-62 years, Occupation-
Retired as Elect (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o Sector
No.4, Store Area, Vinay Nagar, Gwalior (M.P) 474009,
4. Gajendra Batham S/o Shri Chhote Lal Batham, Aged-62 years,
Occupation- Retired as FGM (MCM) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Ramtapura Gali No.2. Gwalior (M.P) 474004.
5. Mani Ram S/o Shri Johari Lal, Aged 62 Years, Occupation Retired as
FGM (MCM) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Bajaria, Thatipur,
Gwalior (M.P) 474011,
6. Ram Shankar Sharma S/o Late Shri Puran Chand Sharma, Aged-60
years, Occupation -Retired as FGM (MCM) from MES GE AF Tech Area
Gwalior, R/o Bagiya, Gole Ka Mandir, Gwalior (M.P) 474006,
7. Ashish Franklin S/o Shri L.E. Franklin Aged-63 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (MCM) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, LIG-
1000, Darpan Colony, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P) 474011,
8. Pramod Kumar Jat S/o Shri Satyapal Singh, Aged-61 years,
Occupation- Retired as Elect (HS-II) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, C-114 Ganga Nagar, Meerut (U.P.) 250001,
9. Shiv Kumar S/o Shri Laljit, Aged -60 years, Occupation- Retired as
Elect (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o Kanch Mill, Bada
Gate, Birla Nagar Gwalior (MP) 474004,
10. Iqbal Khan Gauri S/o Shri Chhote Khan, Aged 62 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior. R/o, J-407,
Darpan Colony, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P) 474011,
11. Kalla Ram S/o Shri Badai, Aged - 60 years, Occupation Retired as
FGM SK from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o Kali Mata Ka Mandir,
Gol Pahadiya, Gwalior (M.P) 474001.
12. Bangali Baboo S/o Shri Gyani, Aged 60 years, Occupation- Retired as
Mate (FGM) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Bijasen Mandir Ke
Paas, Lal Tipara, Morar, Gwalior (M.P) 474006,
Page 86 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
87
13. Smt. Sita Bai W/o Late Shri Ram Prasad, Aged 60 years, Occupation
Retired as Mate (R/M) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Bheem
Nagar, Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P) 474011.
14. Kaptan Singh S/o Shri Ramdeen, Aged - 62 years, Occupation Retired
as FGM (HS-II) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Bheem Nagar,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P) 474011.
15. Naval Singh Meena S/o Shri Devi Singh Meena, Aged-60 years,
Occupation - Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Vill- Jagjiwanpur, Teh - Weir, Distt- Bharatpur, (Rajasthan) 321408,
16. Jamuna Prasad S/o Late Shri Dwarka Prasad, Aged -61 years,
Occupation - Retired as FGM (SK) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Sainik Colony, Pinto Park, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) 474020.
17. Ram Pal Singh S/o Shri Lochan Singh, Aged -60 years, Occupation -
Retired as FGM (HS-II) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill.-
Nagla Subash, Nademau, Tirva, Kannauj (U.P.) 209732.
18. Shanti Lal S/o Shri Jainarayan Shakya, Aged 60 years, Occupation -
Retired as V/Mech (HS-1) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, EE
255, DD Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020
19. R K Pachori S/o Shri Ramdutt Pachori, Aged 60 years, Occupation
Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, CL-78,
DD Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
20. Ramcharan S/o Late. Panchu Ram, Aged-61 years, Occupation
Retired as Mason (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o. Vill-
Parna, Post-Khursipur, Rajnandgaon Chhattisgarh 490011. Distt-
21. Teekam Singh Sengar S/o Shri Prem Singh Sengar, Aged- 60 years,
Occupation - Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior.
R/o, 239 New Colony No.1, Birla Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474004,
22. Manohar Rao Dokekar S/o Late Shri Hansraj, Aged 61 years,
Occupation Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior.
R/o A-18 New Saket Nagar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) 474004.
23. Prakash Babu Dohare S/o Shri Punnu Lal, Aged 60 years, Occupation
Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, P.T.S
Tighra, Gwalior (M.P.) 474001,
Page 87 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
88
24. Daulat Singh S/o Mitthu Lal, Aged 62 years, Occupation Retired as
FGM (MCM) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Galla Kothar,
Thatipur Gwalior (M.P.) 474011,
25. Mohan S/o Shri Ramdayal, Aged -65 years, Occupation Retired as
Pipe Fitter (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Shiv Colony,
Pinto Park, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
26. Jagvir Singh S/o Late Shri Chiranji Lal, Aged -61 years, Occupation -
Retired as R/M (HS-1) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Nagla
Gopal Post- Tochigar Distt.- Aligarh (U.P.) 204101.
27. Ram Singh Karoriya S/o Shri Tej Singh, Aged 61 years, Occupation
Retired as FGM (MCM) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, D-19,
Nitin Nagar, Thatipur Gwalior (M.P.) 474011,
28. Brijendra Singh Nirbhaya S/o Late Shri Ramji Lal, Aged 64 years,
Occupation -Retired as FGM (MCM) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Bawal House, Shinde Ki Chawni, Gwalior (M.Ρ.) 474009,
29. Ram Kishan S/o Shri Motilal, Aged 61 years, Occupation Retired as
Mate (Mason) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Bheem Nagar,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P) 474011.
30. Ajay Kumar Sharma S/o Late Shri Battanlal Sharma, Aged 60 years,
Occupation Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Maloo Marble Ke Pass, Bhind Road, Gwalior (M.Ρ.) 474020,
31. Bhagwan Dass S/o Shri Kundan Singh, Aged 60 years, Occupation
Retired as FGM (HS-II) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Shiv
Colony, Pinto Park, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
32. Mahendra Singh S/o Late Shri Hari Singh, Aged 63 years, Occupation
Retired as FGM (HS-II) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Adarsh
Nagar, Pinto Park, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
33. Rajkumar S/o Shri Banwari Lal, Aged -60 years, Occupation Retired
as FGM (HS-II) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Ashok Colony
Road, Nadi Paar Taal, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006,
34. Roop Kishore S/o Shri Gyashi Ram, Aged -61 years, Occupation -
Retired as Elect (HS-1) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o Narsingh
Nagar, Char Sehar Ka Naka, Gwalior (M.P.) 474004,
35. Natthu Singh S/o Shri Khachchu Singh, Aged - 61 years, Occupation -
Retired as FGM (SK) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Kashipura,
Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006.
Page 88 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
89
36. Om Prakash S/o Shri Dinanath, Aged 60 years, Occupation Retired as
FGM (HS-II) from MES GE AF Tech Area Gwalior. R/o Gautam Nagar,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.) 474001 .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma .
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, Department of Defence production South Block, New Delhi -
110011.
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi-110011.
3. Office of the Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Road,
Palam, Delhi Cantt-110010
4. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow UP - 226002.
5. HQ Commander works Engineer, (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior (M.P)
474020
6. Garrison Engineer, (AF), Tech Area, Gwalior (M.P) - 474020.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Akshay Jain
Original Application No. 1112 of 2024
1. MP MES Karamchari Sangh, Baijal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior M.P. Through
its General Secretary. CWE maharaja Pur , Arera, Gwalior M.P. 474006.
2. Akash Tagar S/o Shri Suresh Tagar, Aged - 28 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Pipe Fitter), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
Kamal Singh Ka Bagh, Behind Kajal Talkies, Lashkar, Gwalior (MP).
474009
3. Rakesh Rawat S/o Shri Megh Singh Rawat, Aged-32 years, Occupation
- Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior. R/o, Vill &
Post Panihar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
Page 89 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
90
4. Vijay Singh Rathore S/o Shri Mahendra Singh, Aged-36 years,
Occupation - Service as R/M (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, New Basti, Tikoniya, Morar Gwalior (MP), 47400 4
5. Sunil Kumar Mahour S/o Shri Hariram Mahour, Aged 41 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Retd Colony, Near Railway Station Banmore, Morena, (MP), 47400)
6. Bijendra Kumar Saini S/o Shri Manohar Lal Saini, Aged 36 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, P-241/3 MES Colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
7. Narendra Kumar S/o Shri Ram Sewak, Aged -34 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate (Pipe Fitter), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
GM-849 Chawla Market, DD Nagar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
8. Chote Lal Chaudhari S/o Shri Saryu Chaudhari, Aged-34 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, P-246/1 MES Colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
9. Ravindra Kumar S/o Late. Shri Charan Singh, Aged-34 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (Pipe Fitter), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area
Gwalior, R/o, GM 895 Near Kothari House, D D Nagar, Gwalior (MP),
444004
10. Vineet Kumar Mishra S/o Shri Ram Dinesh Mishra, Aged-31 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (Mason), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area
Gwalior, R/o, P-242/1 MES Colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP),
474004
11. Vidyanand S/o Late Basti Ram, Aged 33 years, Occupation - Service
as Mate (R/M), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, D-15 Subhanjali
Puram opp. BSF Colony, Gwalior (MP), 474004
12. Vijay Singh S/o Late Than Singh, Aged - 59 years, Occupation -
Service as Pipe Fitter (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
Tikoniya Chouraha Morar Gwalior (MP), 47-4004
13. Kailash Chand S/o Shri Dhan Singh, Aged - 58 years, Occupation -
Service as Mason (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Sainik
Colony, Gole Ka Mandir, Gwalior (MP), 474004
14. Suresh S/o Shri Khayali Ram, Aged - 55 years, Occupation Service as
Mate (Mason), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Tikoniya, Morar,
Gwalior (MP), 474004
Page 90 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
91
15. Devendra Singh S/o Late Mehtab Singh, Aged 51 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill-
Giragaon, Maharajpur, Gwalior (MP), 474004
16. Rambir Singh Gurjar S/o Shri Bhikam Singh Gurjar, Aged-44 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Vill -Giragaon, Maharajpur, Gwalior (MP), 474004
17. Har Narayan Singh S/o Late Shri Bharose, Aged 59 years, Occupation
Service as B/Smith (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Jail
Road Bath Kua Gohad, Bhind (MP), 474001
18. Lokendra Singh S/o Late Shri Kalyan Singh, Aged-40 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Ashoka Residency, Ram Nagar, Maharajpura, Gwalior (MP), 474004
19. Rajaram S/o Late Gopiram, Aged - 59 years, Occupation Service as
P/Ftr (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, H No. 145, New
Godam Basti, Thatipur, Gwalior (MP), 474004
20. Satyendra Yadav S/o Late Shri Rajendra Singh Yadav, Aged-35 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, 150/4, CTC Line, MES Colony, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
21. Mukesh S/o Shri Shankar Singh, Aged 54 years, Occupation - Service
as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, 45/1, Gol
Pahadiya Tighra Gwalior (MP), 474004
22. Banwari Lal S/o Shri Khachchu Ram, Aged -56 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
Madhopura, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
23. Rakesh Kumar S/o Shri Hetram, Aged - 56 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Tripti
Nagar, Nadi Paar Taal, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
24. Devendra Kumar S/o Shri Kalyan Singh, Aged - 41 years, Occupation
- Service as V/Man, in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, P-242/3
MES Colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
25. Ramesh Pandey S/o Late Ram avatar Pandey, Aged-59 years,
Occupation - Service as Elect (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, DM-187 DD Nagar Gwalior (MP), 474004
Page 91 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
92
26. Devid S/o Shri Ravindra, Aged 27 years, Occupation Service as Mate
(FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Nayapura, Jamna Road,
Bhind (MP), 474001
27. Yogesh Singh S/o Shri Mohar Singh Kirar, Aged-30 years, Occupation
- Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, 19-
Sankat Mochan Nagar, Parsadi Pura Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
28. Sourabh Sharma S/o Late Bhagwan Sharma, Aged-40 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior.
R/o, P-240/1 MES Colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
29. Rohit Ram Bhandari S/o Late Chittar Singh, Aged 58 years,
Occupation Service as V/Mech (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Adityapuram, Near Central Academy School, Gwalior (MP), 474004
30. Laxman Singh S/o Shri Netram, Aged 58 years, Occupation - Service
as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, D-534 Suresh
Nagar, Thatipur, Gwalior (MP), 474004
31. Jay Kumar S/o Late Laxman Prasad Sharma, Aged-58 years,
Occupation - Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, 246/3 MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
32. Ravi Kumar S/o Shri Hariom, Aged 35 years, Occupation - Service as
Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Outside Unnao
Gate, Near Ekta Colony, Jhansi (U.P.), 284001.
33. Vijay Singh S/o Shri Badri Prasad, Aged - 56 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Gautam
Nagar Nadi Paar Taal Morar Gwalior (MP), 474004
34. Krishna S/o Shri Shankar Lal, Aged 28 years, Occupation - Service as
Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, GL 1051 DD
Nagar, Kothari House, Gwalior (MP), 474004
35. Ghanshyam Meena S/o Shri Kirodilal Meena, Aged-58 years,
Occupation - Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, 26/1 Pinto Park Colony, Gwalior (MP), 474004
36. Jagdeesh Singh S/o Shri Premraj, Aged 58 years, Occupation Service
as P/Ftr (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Gautam Nagar,
Thatipur, Gwalior (MP), 474004
37. Mukesh Kumar Sen S/o Shri Siyasharan, Aged 38 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Katra
Mohalla, Ward No. 3, Alampur, Bhind (MP), 474001
Page 92 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
93
38. Ajmer Singh Pal S/o Late Harvilash Singh, Aged-58 years, Occupation
- Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill-
Mohanpur, Distt- Gwalior (MP), 474004
39. Pushpendra Singh Kourav S/o Shri Brajesh Singh Kaurav, Aged 34
years, Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area
Gwalior, R/o, Shankarpuri Goverdhan, Colony, Gwalior (MP), 474004
40. Atar Singh Pal S/o Shri Mutiyan Pal, Aged -37 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate (R/M), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, 240/3
MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
41. Jaidayal S/o Shri Narayan Dass, Aged 49 years, Occupation - Service
as V/Man, in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Pawansut Colony,
Hurawali, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
42. Raghuvir Singh S/o Shri Tikaram Parihar, Aged-58 years, Occupation
- Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Surya
Vihar Colony, Pinto Park, Gwalior (MP), 474004
43. Sunil Kushwah S/o Shri Shiv Charan Singh, Aged-37 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (P/Ftr), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, 243/2 MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
44. Keshav Kumar Jogi S/o Shri Ram Singh Jogi, Aged-27 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, 930/3 MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
45. Digambar Singh S/o Shri Prem Singh, Aged 34 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, 127/1
MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
46. Ram Kailash S/o Shri Mahavir Singh, Aged -36 years, Occupation
Service as V/Mech (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, 245/1
MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
47. Hazari Lal S/o Late Ram Swaroop, Aged - 46 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, С-495
DD Nagar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
48. Arun Kumar S/o Shri Ramlakhan Prasad, Aged 30 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (P/Ftr), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill-
Lokan Bigha, Purnadih Aurangabad, Bihar, 48100/-
Page 93 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
94
49. Devendra Singh S/o Shri Vishan Singh Rana, Aged 46 years,
Occupation Service as V/Man, in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
23 Jiwaji Nagar, Thatipur, Gwalior (MP), 474004
50. Rajesh Sharma S/o Late Ramjilal Sharma, Aged-43 years, Occupation
- Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, B-36
Shiv Siddhi Colony, Ram Nagar, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
51. Basudev Sharma S/o Late Shri Kali Charan, Aged-59 years,
Occupation - Service as P/Ftr (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Azad Nagar, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
52. Jaswant Singh S/o Late Bhoop Singh, Aged 59 years, Occupation
Service as Carpt (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, New
Ram Vihar Colony, Pinto Park, Gwalior (MP), 474004
53. Rajendra Yadav S/o Shri Radha Kishan, Aged -59 years, Occupation -
Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Pawansut
Colony Hurawali, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
54. Prem Singh Rathore S/o Shri Lajja Ram Rathore, Aged 54 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, B-15 Vivek Vihar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
55. Beer Singh Bhadoriya S/o Late Laxman Singh Bhadoriya, Aged 43
years, Occupation Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area
Gwalior, R/o, 27/2 Pinto Park Gwalior (MP), 474004
56. Rajpal Singh S/o Shri Nathuram Pal, Aged - 34 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate (R/M), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, 127/4
MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
57. Suresh Kumar S/o, Shri Chokhelal, Aged - 44 years, Occupation
Service as Pipe Fitter, in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, 242/2,
MES colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
58. Ajay Kumar Mishra S/o Shri Ramesh Mishra, Aged-33 years,
Occupation - Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, J-30 Dwarka City, Ram Nagar, Bhind Road, Gwalior (MP) 474004
59. Virpal Singh S/o Shri Laturi Lal, Aged - 40 years. Occupation - Service
as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill & Post-
Tundila, Teh Gohad Distt- Bhind (MP). 474001. .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma
Page 94 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
95
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, Department of Defence production South Block, New Delhi -
110011.
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi-110011.
3. Office of the Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Road,
Palam, Delhi Cantt-110010
4. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow UP - 226001.
5. HQ Commander works Engineer, (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior (M.P)
474020
6. Garrison Engineer, (AF), Tech Area, Gwalior (M.P) - 474020.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Brij Mohan Patel
Original Application No. 1113 of 2024
1.MP MES Karamchari Sangh, Baijal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior (M.P) 474006
Through its General Secretary, CWE Maharaj Pur Arera Gwalior M.P.
2. Rakesh Kumar Lavania S/o Shri Kashiram Lavania, Aged 64 years,
Occupation-Retired as FGM (MCM), from MES GE AF, Adm. Area, Gwalior,
R/o Sudamapuri, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006,
3. Prem Chand Kaul S/o Late Sh. Sumer Singh, Aged 61 years,
Occupation-Retired as R/M (HS-II), from MES GE AF, Adm. Area, Gwalior,
R/o, New Durga Colony, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006,
4. Pandit Lal Patil S/o Shri Sukhram Patil, Aged -61 years, Occupation-
Retired as Carptr. (MCM), from MES GE AF Adam Area, Gwalior, R/o,
H.No.2, Ambedkar Nagar, Mata Chowk Khandwa M.P. 450001,
5. Narsingh S/o Shri Jang Bahadur Singh, Aged 61 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (HS-II), from MES GE AF Adam Area, Gwalior, R/o,
Jaderua Bandha, Sai City, Morar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) 474006,
Page 95 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
96
6. Prakash Kushwah S/o Shri Babulal, Aged - 61 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (MCM), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
Hanuman Bandh Road, Sikander Kampoo, Gwalior (M.P.) 474001,
7. Ashok Kumar S/o Shri Keshri Prasad, Aged 61 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (HS-II), from MES GE AF Adam Area, Gwalior, R/o, Nadi
Par Taal, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006,
8. Ashok Laxmanrao Burande S/o Shri Laxmanrao Burande, Aged -61
years, Occupation-Retired as FGM (HS-I), from MES GE AF Adam Area
Gwalior, R/o, FL-401, DD Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
9. Gangaram S/o Late Shri Ramcharan, Aged - 60 years, Occupation-
Retired as Pipe Fitter (SK), from MES GE AF Adam Area, Gwalior, R/o.
Jaderua Road, Pinto Park, Gwalior (M.P.) 474005,
10. Krishan Govind Singh S/o Late Shri Jagannath Singh, Aged 60 years,
Occupation-Retired as Pipe Fitter (HS-II), from MES GE AF Adam Area
Gwalior, R/o, Goverdhan Colony, Gole Ka Mandir, Gwalior (M.P.) 474005,
11. Natthe Singh S/o Shri Buddharam, Aged - 61 years, Occupation-
Retired as Pipe Fitter (SK), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
Bheem Nagar. Thatipur Gwalior (M.P.) 474011,
12. Rajendra Batham S/o Late Shri Ramnarayan Batham, Aged-61 years,
Occupation-Retired as FGM (HS-I), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Bhairav Wali Gali, Raja Mandi, Gwalior (M.P.) 474004,
13. Bhujram Pal S/o Shri Tej Singh Pal, Aged - 61 years, Occupation-
Retired as Elect (SK), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Tej Singh
Ka Pura, Senthri, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
14. Tulsi Das S/o Shri Hiralal, Aged 61 years, Occupation-Retired as FGM
(SK), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Naugaja Road, Shinde Ki
Chhawani, Gwalior (M.P.) 474009,
15. Jyotish Panna S/o Duari Panna, Aged -61 years, Occupation-Retired
as FGM (MCM), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, FL-348 DD
Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
16. Uttam Singh S/o Shri Sitaram, Aged -61 years, Occupation-Retired as
FGM (SK), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Gali No.2
Suraiyapura, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006,
Page 96 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
97
17. Mahesh Singh S/o Late Shri Dipty Singh, Aged -62 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (MCM), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o,
Hanuman Nagar, Gole Ka Mandir, Gwalior (M.P.) 474005,
18. Santram Mahour S/o Shri Babulal Mahour, Aged 65 years,
Occupation-Retired as FGM (HS-1), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Mahour Mohalla, Purani Chhawani, Gwalior (M.P.) 474010,
19. Dinesh Kumar Mathur S/o Shri Fateh Singh Mathur, Aged -62 years,
Occupation-Retired as FGM (HS-I) from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Shivaji Nagar, Pani Ki Tanki, Amkho, Gwalior (M.P.) 474001,
20. Jandel Singh S/o Shri Ajmer Singh, Aged - 62 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (HS-II), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill.-
Girgaon, Dist. Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) 474020,
21. Salam Mohammad S/o Shri Hafij Husain, Aged -60 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (SK), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o.
Sutarpura, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006,
22. Hari Singh Garg S/o Shri Chaviram Garg, Aged 62 years, Occupation-
Retired as Carp. (HS-II), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Deen
Dayal Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474020,
23. Uday Singh Tomar S/o Shri Munshi Singh Tomar, Aged-63 years,
Occupation-Retired as P/ftr (HS-II), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o, Kusum Vihar Colony, Sikander Kampoo, Gwalior (M.P.) 474001,
24. Mansingh S/o Shri Laxman Singh, Aged 63 years, Occupation-Retired
as FGM (HS-I), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Kuber Ashram
Ke Pass, Thatipur, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) 474011,
25. Atar Singh Meena S/o Shri Ram Singh Meena. Aged 63 years,
Occupation-Retired as FGM (HS-I), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior,
R/o- Vill. Bhot, Teh.-Rupbas, Distt.-Bharatpur, Rajasthan 321404,
26. Parvati Bai W/o Shri Prahlad Goud, Aged -62 years, Occupation-
Retired as Mason (SK), from MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Bheem
Nagar, Adivasi Mohalla, Thatipur Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) 474011,
27. Layak Singh S/o Shri Bhagirath Singh, Aged 60 years, Occupation-
Retired as FGM (SK), in MES GE AF Adam Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill -1-
Mohanpur, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.) 474006. .......Applicants
Page 97 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
98
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, South Block, New Delhi - 110011.
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi-110011.
3. The Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Road, Palam,
Delhi Cantt-110010
4. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow UP - 226001.
5. HQ Commander works Engineer, (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior (M.P)
474020
6. Garrison Engineer, (AF), Adm. Area, Gwalior (M.P) - 474020.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Brij Mohan Patel
Original Application No. 1114 of 2024
1. MP MES Karamachari Sangh, Baijal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior M.P through
its General Secretary. 474004. CWE Maharajpur Arera Gwalior M.P.
2. Hiralal Kushwaha S/o Late Shri R.P. Kushwaha, Aged -61 years,
Occupation -Retired from MES, AGE-E/M (R&D) Gwalior as FGM (HS-II),
R/o, Taraganj, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474001.
3. Ganpati Rao Mohite S/o Late Shri Shivaji Rao Mohite, Aged -61 years,
Occupation Retired from MES, AGE-E/M (R&D) Gwalior as FGM (HS-I),
R/o, Sindhu Adarsh Colony, Sikandar Kampoo, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.),
474001
4. Ramnath S/o Late Shri Barosa, Aged -60 years, Occupation Retired
from MES AGE-E/M (R&D) Gwalior as Elect (HS-I) R/o Madhuwan Vihar
Colony, Khureri, Badagaon, Gwalior (M.P.), 174006
5. Babu Lal Gond S/o Late Shri Dayaram Gond, Aged-62 Years,
Occupation Retired from MES AGE-E/M (R&D) Gwalior as FGM (HS-II),
R/o Gram Chakreli, P/O Teh. Chakreli, Chhattisgarh 49501
Page 98 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
99
6. Gambhir Singh Rawat S/o Shri Ram Dayal Singh, Aged -63 years,
Occupation Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as FGM (HS-I), R/o
Shiv Nagar, Sirol Road, Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004.
7. Ram Gopal Mahour S/o Late Shri Brij Lal, Aged -65 years, Occupation -
Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as Mason (SK), R/o, 01/121,
Vinay Nagar, Sector No.4. Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
8. Rajendra Singh Takole S/o Late Shri Kirshna Rao, Aged -62 years,
Occupation Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as FGM (HS-I), R/o,
Nimbalkar ki Goth, Amma Maharaj Ka Mandir Gwalior (M.P.). 474003
9. Om Prakash Sharma S/o Late Shri Radha Krishan Sharma, Aged -60
years, Occupation Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as Elect
(MCM), R/o, 69, Prem Nagar, Fort Road, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.). 474003
10. Bhoop Singh S/o Shri Feran Singh, Aged -60 years, Occupation -
Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as FGM (HS-I) R/o, Post-Jigani,
Daulatram Ka Pura, Morena (M.P.), 474001.
11. Vinod Kumar Saxena S/o Late Shri R.P. Saxena, Aged -61 years,
Occupation Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as FGM (HS-I), R/o,
Nag Dev Ki Bagiya, Chandra Nagar, Koteshwar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474003.
12. Daya Shankar S/o Late Shri Gapole Prasad, Aged 60 years,
Occupation Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as FGM (HS-II),
R/o, Fort View Colony, Koteshwar Road, Gwalior (M.P.), 474003.
13. Chandan Singh Kushwah S/o Late Shri Kishan Lal, Aged -60 years,
Occupation -Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as Elect (HS-II),
R/o, Purani Basti, Amkho, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
14. Rajendra Kumar Benwal S/o Late Fakir Chandra, Aged -60 years,
Occupation -Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as FGM (HS-I),
R/o, 66/10, Defence Colony Gandhi Nagar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474003
15. Naval Kishore S/o Late Shri Bihari Lal, Aged -64 years, Occupation
Retired from MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior as FGM (HS-I), R/o, A/5,
Jagrati Nagar Laxmiganj Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474003.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma
Page 99 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
100
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, South Block, New Delhi 110011.
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi 110011.
3. Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow, U.P. 226001.
4. HQ Commander works Engineer (AF). Maharajpur, Gwalior, M.P.
474003
5. Garrison Engineer (R&D) MES, Lucknow Road, New Delhi. 26001-
6. Principal Controller of Defence Accounts, Defence Offices Complex, 6th
Floor, A-Block, Africa Avenue, New Delhi 110023.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Akshay Jain
Original Application No. 1115 of 2024
1. MP MES Karamachari Sangh, Baijal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior M.P.
Through its General Secretary, 474004 CWE, Maharaj Pur Arera, Gwalior,
M.P.
2. Rajkumar Kushwaha S/o Shri Shiv Prasad Kushwaha, Aged -35 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Elect) in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o,
47/5, Defence Colony Gandhi Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
3. Madan Kumar S/o Late. Shri Girdhari Lal Soni, Aged -57 years,
Occupation - Service as FGM (SK) in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o,
Parakh Ji ka Bada, Lashkar Gwalior (M.P.), 474006
4. Manish Kumar S/o Late Shri Upendra Pandit, Aged -27 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Elect), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o,
46/5, Defence Colony, Gandhi Nagar Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474003
5. Akhtar Khan S/o Shri Rashid Khan, Aged 51years, Occupation-Service
as FGM (SK), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o, P-3/3, Residency Line,
Morar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474 004
Page 100 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
101
6. Ravindra Kumar S/o Shri Ramjag Ram, Aged -32 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (R/M), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o, 47/3,
Defence colony, Gandhi Nagar, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.), 474003
7. Neeraj Rathore, S/o Shri Ramji Lal Rathore, Aged -34 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o,
New Sabji Mandi Gate, Rathore Colony, Morena (M.P.), 476001
8. Kamlesh Mewara S/o Shri Kailash Mewara, Aged -30 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o 46/2 Defence
colony Gandhi Nagar Gwalior, (M.P.), 474003
9. Neetesh Rawat S/o Shri Bharat Rawat, Mate (Elect), Age 28 in MES
AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o, Vill & Post-Karsena Distt-Shivpuri (M.P.),
473551
10. Rahul Kumar Dubkaria S/o Shri Rajkumar Dubkaria, Aged 34 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (R/M), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o,
Sector F Deen Dayal Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474004
11. Pushpendra Vishwakarma S/o Shri M L Vishwakarma, Aged -28
years, Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior,
R/o, 46/6, Defence colony Gandhi Nagar Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
12. Deepak S/o Shri Balram Singh, Aged -28 years, Occupation - Service
as Mate (FGM), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o Vill-Lahchura Ka
Pura, Malanpur, Gohad, Distt-Bhind, (M.P.), 477117.
13. Jagdish Prasad S/o Shri Bhagwan Dass, Aged -57 years, Occupation
Service as Pipe Fitter (SK), Age 56 in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o,
Ghasmandi, Lashkar, Gwalior (M.P.). 474003
14. Kamal Singh S/o Shri Ramjeet Dohare, Aged -36 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate (Elect), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o Ward No.15
Bijli Ghar Lahar, Bhind (M.P.), 477117
15. Pradeep Kumar Shrivastava S/o Shri Shitla Sahay Shrivastava, Aged -
58 years, Occupation Service as Elect (HS-II), in MES AGE É/M R&D
Gwalior, R/o, Jagtab Ki Goth Madhavganj Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
16. Chandra Bhan Singh Marawi S/o Late Shri Aktu Ram, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o,
66/6, Defence Colony, Gandhi Nagar, Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
Page 101 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
102
17. Uday Raj S/o Shri Umrao Singh, Aged -59 years, Occupation - Service
as Carpenter (SK), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o New Godam Basti,
Thatipur, Gwalior (M.P.). 474004
18. Rajkumar Manchanda S/o Shri Jaswant Singh, Aged -48 years,
Occupation Service as FGM (SK), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o, 62
Shivpuram Behind Central Academy School, Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
19. Bhagwan Singh Kushwaha S/o Late. Shri Ramcharan, Aged -55 years,
Occupation Service as Elect (SK), in MES AGE E/M R&D Gwalior, R/o
Jagrati Nagar Laxmiganj, Lashkar Gwalior (M.P.), 474003
20. Ravindra Ghorpade S/o Late. Shri Harishchandra Rao Ghorpade,
Aged -59 years, Occupation Service as FGM (SK), in MES AGE E/M R&D
Gwalior, R/o H. No. 7, Karamchari Avash Colony, Karoli Mata Mandir,
Mahelgaon, City Centre, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.). 474001.
.......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, South Block, New Delhi-110011.
2. Director General Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg. Army Headquarter, New Delhi-110011.
3. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow, U.P. 226001.
4. Office of the Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Road,
Palam, Delhi Cantt-110010
5. HQ Commander works Engineer (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior, (M.P.)-
474020.
6. Garrison Engineer I (R&D) MES, Lucknow Road, New Delhi-110054
Respondents.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Yogesh Parasar
Page 102 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
103
Original Application No. 1136 of 2024
1. MP MES Karamchari Sangh, Baijal Kothi, Morar, Gwalior M.P. Through
its General Secretary. CWE Maharajpur Arera, Gwalior (M.P)- 474006
2. Ranjeet Yadav S/o Shri Patiram Yadav, Aged -31 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate R/M, in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Behind
Varsha School Tyagi Nagar, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
3. Govind Bihari S/o Shri Rajesh Kumar Sharma, Aged 36 years,
Occupation Service as R/M (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
27/1 Pinto Park Gwalior (MP), 474004
4. Laxmi Narayan Rathor S/o Shri Suresh Chand Rathor, Aged 36 years,
Occupation Service as R/M (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
243/1 MES Colony Airforce Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
5. Gajendra Kumar S/o Late Shri Om Prakash, Aged-40 years, Occupation
-Service as R/M (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, 247/1 MES
Colony, Airforce Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
6. Mahendra Singh Pal S/o Shri Bhujbal Singh Pal, Aged-37 years,
Occupation - Service as R/M (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Tej Singh Ka Pura Senthri Gwalior (MP), 474004
7. Suresh Godia S/o Shri Ram Babu, Aged - 53 years, Occupation -
Service as Mate (P/FTR), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o. Lala Ka
Bajar Hanuman Gali Lashkar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
8. Dharmendra S/o Shri Kashiram, Aged 53 years, Occupation Service as
V/Man, in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Risala Bajar, Morar,
Gwalior (MP), 474004
9. Rishi Kumar S/o Late Shyam Kishore Singh, Aged 36 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (P/Ftr), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, 245/4
MES Colony Airforce Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
10. Anil Kushwah S/o Shri Ratanlal, Aged 34 years, Occupation - Service
as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, 7/2 Bheel Line,
Pinto Park, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
Page 103 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
104
11. Badshah Kushwah S/o Shri Dhaniram Kushwah, Aged 33 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, 245/4 MES Colony Airforce Station Gwalior (MP), 474004.
12. Vakil Singh S/o Shri Jagdish Singh, Aged -49 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, P-14
Bheel Line, Pinto Park, Gwalior (MP), 474004
13. Gajraj S/o Shri Bhujram, Aged - 45 years, Occupation Service as Mate
(FGM), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Tej Singh Ka Pura,
Senthri, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
14. Prakash Mahore S/o Shri Hallu Ram, Aged -58 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
Mahalgaon, City Centre, Gwalior (MP), 474001
15. Indal Kumar S/o Shri Vijay Kumar, Aged 33 years, Occupation Service
as Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior. R/o, Kartikey Nagar,
Face-II, Senthri, Gwalior (MP), 474004
16. Priyank Kumar Jangid S/o Shri Babu Ram Jangid, Aged 29 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, GM 582, DD Nagar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
17. Sudarshan S S/o Shri Subramanian P, Aged -31 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, 929/3,
MES Colony Airforce Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
18. Mata Prasad S/o Shri Tikaram, Aged -52 years, Occupation Service as
Mate (Elect), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Srinagar Colony,
Nadi Paar Taal, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004
19. Atul Gupta S/o Shri Suresh Gupta, Aged - 32 years, Occupation
Service as Mate (Elect), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, 7/3,
Bheel Line, Pinto Park, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
20. Dharmendra Kumar S/o Shri Shiv Das Patel, Aged -30 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Elect), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, DD Nagar, Chawla Market, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
21. Radha Kishan S/o Shri Gulab Singh, Aged -59 years, Occupation
Service as Painter (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Sainik
Colony Pinto Park, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
Page 104 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
105
22. Jeevanti Bhagat W/o Late Laxman Ram Bhagat, Aged -42 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (R/M), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, 244/3, MES Colony, Airforce Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004
23. Deepak Shankhwar S/o Shri Vishnu Shankhwar, Aged -33 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (R/M), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Gali No.2, MH Chouraha, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
24. Jagdish Prasad S/o Shri Babulal, Aged -57 years, Occupation -
Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Gautam
Nagar Thatipur Gwalior (MP), 474004.
25. Suresh Kumar S/o Late Shyam Singh, Aged -58 years, Occupation -
Service as Elect (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Gendewali
Sadak Jiwaji Ganj Lashkar Gwalior (MP), 474004.
26. Mahesh S/o Late Ramhet, Aged -57 years, Occupation Service as FGM
(SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Sector 2A, Vinay Nagar,
Gwalior (MP), 474004.
27. Manoj Kumar S/o Shri Mataru Lal, Aged -56 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, P¼,
Residency Colony, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
28. Attar Singh S/o Shri Prabhudayal, Aged -59 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Hardaul
Garden Ke Samne, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
29. Ashok Golapoorav S/o Late Khemraj, Aged 50 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (SK). in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
Laxmanpura, Tansen Road, Gwalior (MP), 474004
30. Raj Bahadur S/o Shri Rustam Singh Tomar, Aged -59 years,
Occupation Service as P/Ftr (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
Vill- Maharajpura, Distt-Gwalior (MP), 474004.
31. Madan Adivasi S/o Shri Buddha Ram, Aged -58 years, Occupation -
Service as P/Ftr (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Bheem
Nagar, Thatipur, Gwalior (MP), 474004
32. Pullender Singh S/o Late Sarnam Singh, Aged 58 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior. R/o, Adarsh
Nagar, Pinto Park, Gwalior (MP), 474004
Page 105 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
106
33. Ram Prakash Pal S/o Shri Mewaram Pal, Aged 55 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, 256
Sutarpura, Morar, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
34. Raghuvir Singh Meena S/o Shri Roop Singh Meena, Aged 56 years,
Occupation Service as Elect (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, 74 Janakpuri, Bhind Road, Gwalior (MP), 474004
35. Brij Mohan Meena S/o Late Girraj Singh Meena, Aged 58 years,
Occupation Service as Elect (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, 726/3 Pinto Park, Colony, Gwalior (MP), 474004
36. Maniram Mahadbar S/o Shri Khayali Ram, Aged 55 years, Occupation
Service as FGM (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Gautam
Nagar, Thatipur, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
37. Bharat Lal S/o Shri Jagannath Prasad, Aged -58 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill-
Siholi, Post-Bahadurpur Gwalior (MP), 474012.
38. Vakil Korku S/o Shri Ramesh, Aged 56 years, Occupation Service as
Pipe Fitter (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Bheem Nagar,
Thatipur, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
39. Maniram Meena S/o Shri Hareti Ram Meena, Aged 54 years,
Occupation Service as Elect (HS-I), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Jageshwari Residency, Bhind Road, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
40. Karan Singh S/o Late Dhan Singh, Aged - 59 years, Occupation
Service as Painter (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Shiv
Nagar, Gadaipura, Gwalior (MP), 474004
41. Deepak Sanotiya S/o Shri Mahesh Kumar. Aged 41 years,
Occupation- Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
Karauli Mata Mandir Mehalgaon, Gwalior (MP), 474071
42. Manish Kumar S/o Shri Chokhelal, Aged - 35 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, 612/1 MES
Colony, Air Force Station, Gwalior (MP), 474004.
43. Ramraj Prajapati S/o Shri Ram Khiladi Prajapati, Aged 30 years,
Occupation Service as Mate (Carpt), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior,
R/o, Vill & Post-Timawa, Teh-Nadoti, Distt-Karauli, (Rajasthan),322241
Page 106 of 111
ANAND
2025.06.27
PRAKASH
15:24:57+05'30'
DUBEY
107
44. Kamal Singh S/o Shri Nekram, Aged 48 years, Occupation - Service as
Mate (FGM), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill-Girgaon Gwalior
(M.P.), 474004.
45. Malkhan Singh S/o Shri Mukut Singh, Aged -56 years, Occupation -
Service as FGM (HS-II), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o, Vill-
Girgaon Gwalior (MP), 474004.
46. Raghuveer Prasad S/o Shri Ramvilas Prajapati, Aged 57 years,
Occupation Service as P/Ftr (SK), in MES GE (AF) Tech Area Gwalior, R/o,
Vill Senthri Gwalior (MP). 474004. .......Applicants
Advocate for the applicants: Shri Alok K umar Sh arma
V E R S U S
1. Union of India, through the Secretary, Ministry of Defence, Central
Secretariat, South Block, New Delhi 110011.
2. Director General- Personnel/EIB, Engineer in Chief Branch, Kashmir
House, Rajaji Marg, Army Headquarter, New Delhi - 110011.
3. The Controller General of Defence Accounts, Ulan Batar Road, Palam,
Delhi Cantt-110010.
4. HQ Chief Engineer, Central Command, Lucknow, U.P. 226001.
5. HQ Commander works Engineer (AF), Maharajpur, Gwalior, (M.P.) -
474020
6. Garrison Engineer, (AF) Tech Area, Gwalior (Μ.Ρ.) - 474020.
.......Respondents
Advocate for the respondents: Shri Yogesh Parasar
Shri Akshay Jain
ORDER
By Akhil Kumar Srivastava, JM.-
Since the issue involved in all these Original Applications is common in nature, they are being decided by way of a common order. Page 107 of 111 ANAND 2025.06.27 PRAKASH 15:24:57+05'30' DUBEY 108
2. When the above original applications were taken up, learned counsel for the applicants submitted that the grievance of the applicants are identical to the grievance of the applicants in OA No. 1228/2019- Guramit Singh and Ors. Vs. U.O.I & Ors which was allowed vide order dated 05.06.2020 by the Chandigarh Bench of this Tribunal and the same has been implementd with by the respondents. Learned counsel for the applicant contended that following the aforesaid order, the Pricipal Bench of this Tribunal has also allowed the OA No. 656/2023 - Suresh Kumar & Ors Vs. U.O.I & ors vide order dated 07.02.2025. Learned counsel for the applicants also cited the order dated 20.01.2025 passed by Principal Bench of this Tribunal in OA No. 2745/2022- Vehicle Depot Karamachari Union CVD Delhi Cantt through its General Secretary Harish Chander & Ors. Vs. U.O.I & ors and submitted that following the order of Chandigarh Bench, the OA No. 2745/2022 was allowed.
3. It is noted that the OA No. 1228/2019 was allowed in following terms: -
"12. A perusal of the OM dated 2.8.2017 would disclose that Ministry of Finance has taken a conscious decision that in supersession of earlier orders relating to various allowances viz. Clothing, Initial Equipment, Kit maintenance, Robe, Robe maintenance, Show, Uniform and Washing etc. Dress Allowance was sanctioned and category of staff, who was to be supplied uniforms and were required to wear them regularly like Trackmen, Running Staff Railways, Staff Car Drivers, MTS, Page 108 of 111 ANAND 2025.06.27 PRAKASH 15:24:57+05'30' DUBEY 109 Canteen Staff of Non-Statutory Departmental Canteens etc. was sanctioned a sum of Rs.5,000/- per annum and these various allowances were subsumed, no other allowance was to be paid. Pursuant to this memo, the DoP&T, nodal Department, also issued Office memo dated 31.8.2017, which clearly provides that Uniform Allowance/Washing allowance/Stitching Charges/Show Allowance etc. have been subsumed in Dress Allowance which shall be Rs.5,000/- per annum which shall be credited to the salary of employees directly once a year in the month of July. As per para 7, this allowance covers only the basic uniform of the employees and any special clothing will continue to be provided by the concerned Ministry, as per existing norms. In compliance thereto, the PCDA, Chandigarh, vide decision dated 5.6.2018 (Annexure A-3), clearly indicated that benefit of OM dated 2.8.2017, may be extended to the civilian of MES including industrial personnel. Again there is a letter dated 2.8.2018 (Annexure A-4), indicating that competent authority has clarified that Dress Allowance is payable to industrial/non industrial employees w.e.f. 1.7.2017. Thereafter, the applicants were granted the benefit of Dress Allowance for the years 2017-18 to 2019-20.
13. It is quite surprising that all of a sudden, the respondents have passed the impugned orders conveying that there is not even a decision as yet for grant of Dress Allowance to the category of the applicants and as such the payment of allowance already made may be recovered, as clarified by PCDA, Chandigarh, and as such impugned orders of recovery were passed, that too in violation of the principles of natural justice. A perusal of both reproduced OMs would make it clear that a conscious decision was taken by the Ministry of Finance, Department of Expenditure, New Delhi and then DoP&T (Nodal Department), pursuant to Page 109 of 111 ANAND 2025.06.27 PRAKASH 15:24:57+05'30' DUBEY 110 implementation of the 7th CPC recommendations, for grant of Composite Dress Allowance, instead of various allowances, which were discontinued, @ Rs.5,000/- per annum. The respondents have also not rebutted the averments made by the applicants that they stopped receiving the washing allowances from the date they started getting Dress Allowance @ Rs.5000/-per annum. Be that as it may, the fact remains that since a specific clarification has already been issued by the nodal Department of Personnel & Training, for grant of such allowance to the entitled categories, therefore, the view taken by respondents in withdrawing the same from the applicants and making recovery thereof cannot be sustained and as such the impugned orders in all these cases are quashed and set aside. The applicants are held entitled to grant of Dress Allowance and if any recovery has been made, the same be refunded to the relevant individuals involved in these cases. No costs."
4. Further, it is also noted that in para 11 of order dated 07.02.2025 passed in OA No. 656/2023, the Principal Bench has observed the following: -
"11. It is fairly admitted that the order dated 05.06.2020 of Chandigarh Bench in OA No. 1228/2019 as mentioned in para 7 above has been duly complied with by the respondents authorities. The respondents also acknowledged theat the issue involved in the present matter is squarely covered in the matter decided in OA No. 278/2023 vide judgment dated 22.07.2024 by coordinacte Bench of this Tribunal. In view of the above, no divergent view can be Page 110 of 111 ANAND 2025.06.27 PRAKASH 15:24:57+05'30' DUBEY 111 taken in respect of same set of employees of an organization."
5. From the above, it is thus clear that the order dated 05.06.2020 passed in OA No. 1228/2019 has attained finality. Accordingly, all the Original Applications are allowed in terms of the directions contatined in order dated 05.06.2020 as well as subsequent orders of this Tribinal cited above and the applicant are held entitled for grant of Dress Allowances. It is further directed that if any recovery has been made, the same be refunded to the relevant individuals involved in these OAs. All the applicants are directed to file a copy of order dated 05.06.2020 as well as other cited orders alongwith certified copy of this order before the respondents forthwith. Thereafter, the respondents are directed to comply the aforesaid directions within a period of three months from the date of receipt of certified copy of this order. No order as to costs.
6. Miscellaneous Application(s), if any, pending shall also stand disposed of.
7. The registry is directed to place a copy of this order in connected OAs.
(Mallika Arya) (Akhil Kumar Srivastava) Administrative Member Judicial Member Anand...
Page 111 of 111 ANAND 2025.06.27 PRAKASH 15:24:57+05'30' DUBEY