Karnataka High Court
M.Ramadevi vs Bruhat Bangalore Mahanagara Palike on 6 November, 2009
Author: Ram Mohan Reddy
Bench: Ram Mohan Reddy
- --~w ~A ?»_-.-jg»-u» we: m--.mu--una~w ruurl uwuau ur RAKNAIRKR Hits?! (SOUR? OF KARNATAKA HIGH COUR1' 0?' K.&RNfl{EA}€A H¥GH
1 fl.R§HfiB£¥I
12:: ms HIGH scan? or rmnmwam arr aa:e:;;r.1,¢'z=e,§;:~-._v
nmsn '9:-us mm 96" am or RovmaEa;'_ "2é€é$--:.5 .
BEEORE
THE sow 31.: xx. ausurzcxf, 4.33912? é : 3
mac. w.99sgg_o9 :5'-'99;:6gcs,-"--'%~," %
z§.__ _ % _
WEI? mwrox xo.1s'§'5s%+*17;w53ie9¢'%5:33-figs;
BETSEER: '
AGES A§@§a42} .
4_ "
638,; "'i'!'_H i'-25Si_!'i V 'atarrcaoss
nm:I1.mz~i;x_m: s*mz*sj '_
£sz*e:asAmaz"-1::2eeu71--%% '
1wEn~mo:;'1" .336;
view-::mx:a.xaH,
120.11-, am: Bacmass,
':.a%:t'auaan, msaon
1?',!gN:zALeaa'5----&saes
j'.=+:;s§ .51 mas
' * $f€%'.. ¥€U}§IYfiP?&
H$;§€§ 3 Bhflflfig $0.9
jam mamas mews?
aria: Hazy, 21:9 s-mss
ztxmxux, Bhlifikisfiafi
E 563971
AH'3"'I-mélama
man saw? 56 YEARS
trims: S HAT!-M3 mm
30.7 RIC!-Eifififi was
... .. wwu um vu-awuaII"1Ilun'I uxxval uwwni 'bl!' I'!uP'§.lEH'§F'\Il'\fi..I*§ fifiufl !.,uUl.!lH"
~*%
-new
$A1;D%'IN BOYS HIGH SCHOOL: QUAJRTER3
BhfiGh&QRE
as uavm was
$0.64, 2H3 EATTERY
pm sax mxs ma mean
MEXR EAIAR
mecsxamas seam':
N ICRISI-933
1? H 8!'!h15f'I'INAGA.R
BAHQRWRE 5601327
mam suL'rAxa__ _
(awn. 1-ma cm ~.1.xra: mafia ,.m:;
H0. 112./21, 31m«c:'a9,s--3, NAGAR
om sunaam-mm: :
mvmnona 56eQ2--s._j;
Asst; _
sxmag c:~_::zux:swam_A '_
ma. .Qi;¥.'_:RTE2¥.§ ii*Ii:330h¥ 'aaaymx
,EE.HGa5;L{'33.E 55ss;2*:._ .
émn Fr or satmaa am;
K5§3 KEQUT '5"¥Ea3
__h'!G.EA'I'E Es-sans ans
" ms vQUkR'!'E?R:'5'g " mammmm
53555'-935
13'
" KGK3f3fi9UT 33 YERRS
s_g'e,._ Pf;%.RAS£}RAHPs§
..n*'.zce'.34, I-1' 930.12, M Qi1AR'I'£R5
Kfififlhflfihhfi
V " magma 56994?
H V §E$"ARAJ 8f0.H V VWEQKTESH
AGED Rfiiff £8 YERR3
8 $0.1, H NG.3fi T13 SHED
E38 Qi3AR'I'£R8 K0 %
BANGEALGRE 560947'
%:"':ei':é"'§:.s"<<s?~"".s xammn-w Wo...6'?'§:P'5....3k'r?(Lv W
. ..--....--..u-v. 5': "Wu wwwmw war nmmvmznnm wwan LUUNE UR" KARNAERKA HUG-H CUURT 03: F(AR?'~MeTA?{§s HIGH?
3.2
13
14
15
165'
..3..
5 RAJ?-KSBEECAR
AGED A8013'? 41 YEARS
S/0.$%"AHY EV3 QURRTERS
VIVEICRHAGAR P0
zconaaaawwann
EAHGALQRE 58984'!
H saxvansz y"m~»
Assn ABU 37 YEAR$ F
w/o.Lms M uunxsrzxv
231, K3 saansx ._
LRLEAGH aoan, awn cagss
aawsaacaz 569627 ' "
P Nana: CHRISTENA 7 ._ V=
M3313 AEGUT 36 if ;
nxa.2Unu3Hv?anM :. L~"~
5 xo.1 F Nc.1e, -.'V'
mus avakwsas KmaaugnmaL$;_"'
nAN$aLpa;&5§oQ471_" '_- "m*
&G£B_EfiGUTg59*YEAR3'~-w7
;H!O.fi*?3HKh?E£fi>RRQ
313:KuvEéu RAGag*."
JxhHALL1'Eh3Tw_*.«
aaxeancns*56sa1{;
SHz§$A"a§i
"*=as:a,Aou?-§3*Y:axs
'x¢.aa9u ass
' "»_H@Nmam$vxnILAvx
A2uxzA.§:v1 navnuw
I38 R&J!(I.%R R633
1'?
Bfisfififiiefififi $30843
'« c_a man»
" A339 A808? 49 YEKR3
';wzG.s RQEERT
' I} $50.51, 6'1'?! £22333, :5! 3 35%
WVE R 9'03?
EAHGALGRE 5€£3Q4'?
Wu.-mwm w, uwazn awwuna war nnnmmunnfl Hiuri LUUKI £2!' KARNATAKA HIGH CQURT Q5 KARNAWXKA H16-I»-E 1
i' 3
'.1
25
26
2?
28
29
N0.21, HEW CRPGRA?ION BLDG
H R moan C3085
BHNGALDRE 566692
PAEVEEK rag
AGED A35? 52 YEARS
wi0.M 5 Hagan
flG.946, A-31 Bflfi QuhRT5&$""
AUSTIN TOWN g
BHGRLORE 56604? '
?RATH1HA V/G Law: vanxarssfl _ '.1 A
AGE 47 YEAR8, 2
50.15832, RSYAL FhRI$;_°
xnnsnvan Clfifigfigflfififlfififlivfifififlfi
fihfiahbékfiwfifia 630- 2 :'V ' "_%;
nxhsuaa ._ _~w-X=
AGE 5§,$sAas,; ', -,'~y_
sis Qugatmks can§ousn,~,'
E3IEfififlr,E3fi$Ahqfi£~§6G°04?'
EABA¥pTHia¥fG_&ANKhR~w'
;AGE 4§£y§gg5'_ >, _.
Ews=Q%An?gn3'sdnrb¥an,
EfiIPUag,8£HGAhQRE~§66 947
V.§.s§éH:fifla?H3H8i°S!c savavau
; Am: 42 vgaas,
"'~mQ,20, E STREET,
5aa_LsHs, aamsaaoazuseo 925
'VfK§fiafi§a3 w/e B.CHInMBARAM
* a5a=$5 YEARS,
Hfigzfi, N s?azw,
u.$H3R?HIHA§AR, BaRGAbGRE«§63 32?
,AéR.n:Lfl Vfi
«tr.
%a£3'&0 %EAas
KQ. 144 2, I2??? CRO$,
7*«3ax3xn1nawkHEsnE aasmwg
Vfifi§EK:CULHE ?G9E
' '._gAMauxnz»ma2o4s
M
-um-mm: mwvuruinru I 'and! I \wVaaF'MD!\' Iull" l\l'%.fi.l'.f"III'\I\§' 31$!' 'u\}§.-F1'! 'J?' Q
43
44
-7...
HIi:I.aER 'i'PsN!( EURE EH55
'VA$AN'I'i<IN£.R, SAIEALQRE-$66 €352
49 FATHIHA DIG HUN'IAP?A
RSS9 71 YEARS,
BLWK 30.14,. H.N0.22,
MI Ligkfi 'HANK 3324113 8338
vasazww, mmsawnaessa "G53
41 2-zaaszsam if/{J ALL: acevx
A3513 as mas, "
BLOCK man, I-I.NQ..3E-,._
ms oumrsas, mammaam
B)\1'§GR£:GRE»-56$ 947 '
£2 FMEENABI W0 A.;"i~Mi!ERL ;
AQED 69 YEARS, --V 7': 1._Vy. ;
B:-3, FLAT '1, E.If..3 QUAIWERE, * '
xmannnnaana _ -,1» . §u: »V=;»
EAKALGRE I :"
swung m«a4sn=,.x'i..s:(c z.rms Aagzuz. mm?
AGE!) 33
w:::.1n;1,; c: sT'as:_s'I_$, --. ''
nA24<;ALokE-<-§69A 02?
uaazm ax 1.z.¥f'*%:=*§I:;sz-m 6%/e "'iaunA:~Lan2w
__AGEi3 ,5_%§ YEARS, V
" 'a:e:.*;.4§,'~s*;"-5:1 moss, """
V"'~.A?'rr-.23. m~i9I'.a_ mm,
va2m3:i£E*i*.,_ '1r:t~;%sr:t§Ac;ax,
nm3A.:}9RE--'$4;5¢ pa'?
narmz-44._s1:§r.;2:..%A A
man $1..YEAR8 wxo.mrsI-mam 1513'? RI {.353
:.~f«::-.x..-z_%:<T mm.
4% vyesmaman, magma-52
% .jmt3}.i;za; aAz
.3339 A5631' 491 'i'EAR$
T uifid Icarsraexam 3131*
'Exam TANK mm moan,
VfiS , BANGALORE-52
M
'"-"' '''.'!'--''-'''*°' '-'-'---"-'-'-*"'-'----'----''-4 -----'---I- -vvvni vo l\l'll\I'l'|!-P\il'\-I"! l'lI\3'II Mvu-nu wr nnnl-vninnn nuan uuung VF flflflflfliflflfl l'II§¥I"!'§
50
47 fi.VEHKRTESH
5333 ABOUT 36 YEARS
S/0 MAEAP?A
BLGK £0.15, HOUSE 80.13
K.W.$.QURRTER3, KORHRARGAEK
VEVKKHASER EDS?
SANGALORE ~ 568 O4?
48 K.'!'}i1RIJRAhR.
man 46 mass
3/e.:c:a.L::1»4u'r1-m " ._
Bmcx no.32,Heuss,Nc.'?....3*
mt. s.eua'mns,_vIvzxHA<¥$R. ms? "
BR2iGAL9RE-~é'?
49 R.?4EE!~iAK$Z'¥I
new igxssans § ~ j
n1o.Fg5HFa'{.mcyzas.m;w-- , '
3. if .:s . i»_t£%1'Efi3,MI_T*i._LiER "'!'AHK..3U:m RQAD
E?:?%EA{£QRE-3§E--
mmmsfimamw
M53!) 42"!fEP.R3 ' "
szo.:cn.mI4':a:_~_:Jt1>3V '_ . " ,
z.w.,¢:..%qJa:'s'as:;, mrzmaaaa ms?
.....
51
.45 Sf!) .' HO{l2§4gK.K!fiuéE.EA§BEV Ghkfififi ST.TEfifiRST©NN 84 '.s"r=Iv7~.L mm
- am: 3% was 5§5.KLCHEfl@¥Q ""c.:io.s.R.1zav1 :~:o.1,vm.1m1mmA:~z wmrxs s-1* V"VIVERIF%§R
-$7 Jrk v»ar"m|wrn'£¢"mll'1I'\4#""l .1 Isuzu . \w'%ul§.J!\l ur nnnwnlnnfl ruum Luulu Ur unxzvmaaw. rm'.-fir: LUURT OF KARNAYAKA HIGH C 56 5'?
53 msmma Am!) 52 1% m.3a/39,13? maoanzmnasazenna aaxamans--:7 54 H.381-EABIIEI Rfi-HASH?!-(Y REED 43 Y?
ID.299.I:AI.8AGH 3&9 3€.$.GARm3§, EEK?-BLQRE-27 55 nawmaw 9 Assn 59 YEARE , sxo.pnaxvzmu3n:=_ _ !EL299.LAH§%§iK£§fl.r K.$.G$dHKN e' f aAnauxnu&a1 V»w».;
M.SUBRAHAflI H._ 'W AGED 50 YEARS _.
s;o.nunzsw:u; a.:
NG.182.,v--=.' """
x.s.sansn _ .'M a:x:ea;Ax..eP;E~2': V JAIsJu...A _ BEES 51 YEARS _ __S/0.A$fi£8GAx %' , " E33 eopggxazwmx SHEB : »EJI?UR£, ' as§n*@1 vxa.
2gxmgLagm{4i<;' fia:nR 'VV .
K7a.nA5E§aAfi " '=s§*'s;A ammaxn ms 338:: 3322933, §mr«'.a?V.:.2:s._:;.:s::2s9.z-»«;'? ~ $,gfiHzswaM¥ «,m'Er3 49 YEERS VA 1489, 3K!) S'I'hGE,6'£"H ERIN M nwu -mm: I.*lnll"fiEIl" g wxvaavw at warn:-wufmwma was nrvcnrlr-IlrII'\a'& lll\i!l"I uvwnl \J'l' !'\l"ll§E'.Nll#%Z\.f'Iz E"!I\5'TI l..r\JIJfil M5!" RMKEVHIRRR "I13?! 5-u>'w3!a»3K5 $3?" ' -39- ALFYIN TGWH, ~é '3 G3 VA&H'3' 35% 46 YEARS ¥fO.B}'s.$ 3% 'PIX mm, , ?$?47
61 Anaaaxmr RE 69 YEARS wxo.:mr4 azremaanc ~ swam: _ Pm_ ~ , V annem-47 "
62 R.RAR.*§?'A!%.-
p.m42_..*:a:;.:2.$ . I s;0,ua,m_ _ PALAwa.Glfi?M-WM.
R@=.€*:{"c:PA 'i:*G£B@:,$'-Ih£1.*E«§£"AGE 42 'ms zajsie. t¢mL§fa_,1§c1§,2ea:'~«r;;t3ss , annuity PA mm, 63 n.ammm=u; " % AGEB 59 ' _ , 8f%3.NH?isRAm% _zsm . zzuucamn va LE 'ésrnsm, A. . . . . . ..
'KER GPA Hfihfififi, «;{?sNESH'd?;R ms 1:. sé;.:e'is; aA::' .
' A659 52 A g.;c.Am:s.z :e:;:.13az1,sz9mss mew " " ~ "aA;t~zr;A:.m1.,'rm1= BY sea Hoxma mamas 'Ass '4ow.s.s1e.c.s.PAun "H.'fi0.3,:--' ?£%, k ccwzmc :r:zz«rz.§s:~xm«u;.:;:,aA:e<;m-3":
.,AK';E§ .5'? YEARS .Sf0.i;hTE GQVM Wm? B30. 1? ELDER. 34 bk Mwwlcul -fr-gaejlwmum wa uu:r'IHmIn1ral'hlItl"'6hI|\fl"l mu'!-3!'! mvwnl Kl'? !\l"!*l§.l'Il"\IP§I\.li. ¥"¢Nu7!"1 EKJUKI ')3' Efiflxmmiflfifik 83 84 85 ?3$3NTH RAGAR Bbfififi RE? 3? GPA 80&DER C 3333, 38 YEARS fiffi C CHIRHA XDLANHKI B*N0.8, E38 QUARTERS, KBRAHSNRALA, B'LORE 56064? mmmsa sxo LATE Mzitéxsieanv I No.42, em CROS3, unset: GARDEN, 1 swag use 3? can 'Hanna 2:
macaw, 35 was, 3/0 xARum=:avm"..V * 130.1493, a.n.a.. mu: swmn, um§:;.A:';_ANnaJa.,.__ a nxxsawns-569047 " ~.
910 LJWE SHANHIEGAH, Ho.5"4;a.. 2DA,.'QU3a--.9_.mk«.._ M3$'l'I:~I mam, mam nxr 3*: cm». §~raL=nma_ 3.3. IQBAL APEUIEB, 3+5 -
sic mnnssua an-u;w.¢sAA, *_-n.n:o.21,,= s--:3a::~.V_ savnxxrr, unsona, ' sauces g" =.""<. "ea ' GHUIa33A!¢ 1111 we was am, se;.%74t/3V, -31: GERBER nmsmsaxnnz, az.cs:=;E~'--::f'.v., as1'~r___E~: ' GPA HOLDER Eaxvam 3:' 411:. aria 1-qnnrusur, " #1, 5-m.c:=:c;s_.:s CHELflVfiDIPAbY3;'RR¢.TCK7R3YA§ RQAD wsxanzfisa RITA _!~KA§GR;; fi';*O mars 9 J 1&tl:t£'1'IH, 52 was '-._ 'c'3:'i0*~..;& $E;\STINE, lwifiixsfifiéitiis, * Lazetazwzn «tax, sum my 3? an mwsa *_ P,$-,§ scuaa, 47 YEARS 51% P GERQGE, ,xs3a.s?w¢nu, Cfl? sxazrmaxrmmnfig AK.£WHI ?, mm: 556925 _ vv 'gé * =8?_ §HUB§im warn
- we SYEB Au H0214, mmvanm mm mm, nA1~::«:+% Rm 3'! ma aennsa .3 mm 51 was we amen mars comouxn 1'29: swam saxwaa, EAflBhLOR£F56€047 lFi\ » '*lW"" >2xwl'w3\n' w.r"uutr"c.n\JC"'\ an clue" I \¢"t.IUml'5I\l VJ!' AHRIVHIHBH VHKQF1 MKJWKI K)!" KAKNAfAKA MESH ( 88 89 96 91 D mam-rs-I:
370 D VENEGETARAKAN, $33.28/2, aasaa 81"R£E'l', BLORE RE? 5? GPA mam .
st-msxzramn, aevzms, we mm-yummy-::__ EVE casvoursm 'PIN 8353, EJIPURA " _ aamaneam-550047 "
AHSAVENI '-
160.17%}, mwt-ma man:-2, ism * cxass, unseen, 35933.35? E3533 Irif:§.::3$R ; miss an-mr, 43 wro'a_smsm'_A % 210.1174, 3---sc:.31, 3an'=r_mm xlsizw-éntmg 3.13.3. rm!' .
aananwm--s6oa§"~z._ s 9. m-manna V i sie E-ATE 1*; ._:'mF ;
sc: mm, 'nae av 52:». 1«m.ns;=+;" 3 SKRQJA ,_,5a we PURi}:35HGfP&£§¥é§' ?1__m:-t>;1£RE9__;" _3"~'-».gis::::., 40, H~m.2.. Ears Qumzfisns, P3WG.RL¢RE~45;§$U4?'--. "
b'f:5:{ Ii SF 239.13 Swfit, 1-nm:':c;_.. % xtenanahnmay, swim 9.39 3! ,GPA Hfiiciiflfifi mag 33 mans, 3/ca smsaa 3--439.23,; '-11:?!-7-11453.33, . 'as;-3 ' s;.5:;§3.§;ms~:snc47 % W70 '$39333 $3433., 39.133, $EPPH§GS RG33 REF 8'? 5%; REBBER 3%Es'IAN ,. 38v.Y%, V/G flfifllfiififi B 30.32, !'¥C5...'5, W5 £'.3fii!FQU'!§I3, 'fiF'I¥Wi€!'iR£§eAR gnamamaz-569347 is mxsmz we 1: WRIESSH 193.12, MIJHSPHGEQLLI 3:! aaxnmz, 32.093 11% B'! an Hmnsr: ms. mm? mo , 38 YEARS, 8/<2: sear-LAIAI4:
2.Nc>.32, I~:.xe.29, as QUARTERS, ...... nvvuvu .V-.7-<..f...-uun 'earl! swIMr'1nn'nM'IF'mif'I-l\£"Qi wuunflrnl uvunl VII" l\l\REU#"tll'%l\.P'% FIIKWTI Wm'!-.1?CJK! 'Jr ififlitflflifllklk A W E&Ht'£fi..GRE--56034 '1' 94 HmflN sit) 9 mums No.72, mwmm Guam *' R3 RE? 3? SP3 mum. B}%I"E mm mo , 30 mans s/o --.
BANGKQRESGOG4?
95 mmmn ALI Vb 3/o Mariam N Hw1~:,'ra§:*m2, Kw 3? can HoLvaxa'_sA1?Anmme;p;.¢.3?vEé9é;s;A' we warm it c LFKNASKR VIVEKNK§ARE5ST,a V'~ L m:smns»5%eeo4f:" % A ' 96 rz».nr% 9'! M "'~--«i."fisr'foA2§ xaxmxnnxypa, 9:c>.43, mama. ?@I}?LE FRRVRTTII PURPK, 312033 U/i) NARA3ImiAN,»_"--RI-aafia'-mam: ,_s'.IH£&, ROAD, swam ..
REP BY G£'fl"¢PFQ£'zEER"'fi ~~D@{INICA"a?E-EEKLINI 22 YEARS, B/£3 "A$«_z:*1'¢h*Y , 240.722, ;"Z4'!'I-I? cnessg,' L». 12.; ~ ' BAtiGAb0RE-'-!§6iX)4? ' ' "
F s§wxA;.:._A, A£l;z:;"Aa¢:u?"v.3£""v3ans __ar;o aaim V 6%! c&_.o's$A---L.AncAn, anamcmnmz, yP¢US"£'I_N '.?'G%i'H,_ REF 3'? GP)': i'f0I.:BER r& s%rx%a;'-..»_35 we xssnc: sws Q§.IIAR'i'-333;" ¥IV ?08'l', GAm aa::a:a.n:3ns~5'a:m*7 my 38013'? 46 was 'A %m =a;¥'A.-':23 1-mum s smvmam 57 mass
--ii'.!€>'-VSRIRIVAEAI4, 133.199, 23:9 mm man, A' 35233993 saunas, vzvmszman T --».gm~rc.;:uz.oa.s~56oe47 Sm: REFER'? as: magma, Aw.) ... PETITIGKERS C,' o H M 41"}?-vi H.-mn.w~» "nun wwvul ur nnnmnannfl wmvn MUUKU U3' KRKNRIAKA HIGH COURT OF KARNAYAKA H£Gi-E ( RN
-aux?-an D:
EANGALORE-$60 992 gi any 3? IT5 camxssxoxzn * 2 smmaav 2-smmrav or VIDHAFEA SGUEIHA, aansaneax °r,}, §ssfa$usxws:V_"= mac. 1: 9955/09 :3 §:..:ii;'£z3% ux :mA"*sEcu?::0n 5 at THE szxxwawzoa am, _ra..Iw'---M 151 'as, ..C'PC Fore conncaarzsu or nxL&3;t * *. .'.
xxscmr sssems 1s ait{L'§r$ u~mas%gcn-mg 3.51 or cm: FOR RWALLIHG ':fz~.'-E-s;z:>E¥1_:;§'r$:9._?'.."1.2699. '!'!~I$S:_ ;-tIé{:.".. .ir -".5 .5as1zVN:: §r:"""'s'oR cmnsns THIS 1 awfim am:-.:Ar..on£ mamumaaaa Pamm } '~ "vgfipiiaation deserves to be Jcejecztad... 939:, ms :coi.%mi"a;;;.s;3"Pr;-:$"~m:..nc§h':.§¢e:
n u 1 The 1': to condone tha delay cf'; the 2"' amplitaticn """ 'Qaamea 7.7.2099. The mreg$:I:Ié*e:1:2<£':_;§ wt in the affidmit:
amlimtim can hardly be 1:9 Laatiafacbory explazzation for the days in filing the aapyliaation to the mrdezc. an that score alane the bi wvwnl \ll nnnnmannn nmrn x.-uum wt" nnumnznna mas-i-I CQURF Q? KARN&¥A§(A mg!-H -13-
2. Ewing had & glinpfie at the a*{é';fEi:e§§$?;u entrant in Hiscfii' 9956309, I ground ta :e¢&ll the ozds:.fiat§dj§4§}fiG§§{f,in fact, the wxit petitions %§£§"&iQm§s#e$ §§?g_ final arder dated ?.7{2§c9 cg the §;c&iae that- an writ of mandamug 1:c>VAV.-dV:i°x1;se:<'.'~;~z;L__ tfié'*vx.a$§$¢ndenta to put up c:uc:rx,:3trz:§i:{:f._z:~1$* vAA'.&¢§;i1a;rters cammt be issued "interim stay of was operating in w,§yx§;43§i§{éfl6$;\. i ' amassing are accordfizxggtyfv ..... ' ICH3C3Ei