Karnataka High Court
Govt Of India Ministry Of Defence vs P Ravindran on 11 August, 2011
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, H.S.Kempanna
i zg THE HIGH C563? 0? KARNATAK$ AT BA§GA$GRE mgwgm T513 wag 11" gay G? Aaaagwg 2e::V yfigm "
$33 fiON'BLE mg. $fiS$:CE K.L. fiANJ§§gffiff éfifi TEE HQN'ELE MR. Juswzcg a§$, KEM§A§m§ 1 ft wax? yawzwzam No.617i£§§§6 %S=¢R%}' EE?WEE§:
3? SECRETAR§" " ;"'.: , _ . _ SQSTE BLQSK yaw §ELEZVli* =7«mf 1 SQVT CF IESEA MIN£ST Y S? mmfifiggaf 2 $33 BIRE§TQfigéfi§E§§$ a :u HQ 332%-R- }§§§Q§"Q*I ' " « 33% §E§fi£v1_ [ 3 $32 3i§E$T@R_"
fig QGQAV§EQ§G fiEw QELE:*: '.5 Q §w.TH§"$§§§R§LLER"'" """
' .:@§%§LagR§$E ay gUAL:$§ H"ggsUg$§§$*2L§aTRmN:cs g $;EAm§g'gAx§ALQRg 5. ?E§ET§GNER$ {By Afivggaée srz: 3 ?9AH$S§ SEE?TY§ . A' T .:;2§ §§V:§§§A§ uH_$f§ § &§§A EAKR =_ 'gggfi éE®§T §§ 333 §@@§%&%@%%&%%%@%FWWW?Tw jéfi 35 37 38 3?
'=$HARéEmAN«:
8
segg CGMPLEX s.K,@ARmE§ BENSQN TOWN EARGALGRS 45 H K VASRTHAKBMRRE CRARGEMEN I AGES ABOUT £6 YRS WORKING AT SE§IOR QU&LI?Y ASSURANCE ESTABLISHMENT {ELEc?R@§:§$§,'7' SGQA CGMPLEX S.K.GABEN BENSQK TOWN BANGALORE 4§_ SANAT KUMAR aaagsgmax : _ AGED ABGUT 42 yas.'m_ _ }a WORKIHG AT SENIGR QaAL:Ty§f. L_n . A§SURANCE ESTABLISHMENT ggamctfegzts} NQ.19fl3 NA?EGfi§L sTA§:§Mrj;_ ' 'V NEW BELH: 1;"g_T * :2? w "J-- ____ H B m GURUERA5§a' cagasmmgg :_";;__ AGEQ ABOUT 33 YRS _ z . waaxzwg AI maxygcngfigwg-3? QUfiLITY ASS§RANQE«(EiEC?RQ§§C§}° J.§.NA$AR 2A§Q&L§RE_j. § R_g§:vfimR§*- v AQE3 A§Q§? é3 yas "§GgK:§§,AT"sE$:@R QSAL£§Y ASSERARCE Esfgggigfimamw'{ELEc?R@%1€s; msgg cawyzgx S.KK§AR§Efi . sgN$a§=$@w§ ggaggaaag £5 ' $"$3K§fi§R "cggagmwgfi :5 $2 $33 J;§@R§:fig AT SE§IQR.Q§&LZTY éfifififififififi gswggazggmgfiy {§&E$?RQ§:§S} ,"§$§A €®fi§LEX g K §AR§E§ 'EE§$G§ %aw§ E§§Q£E§RE éé W?
§'%§g§\\%?}> .. :75» éi $2 $3 44 $ SURE$H Cflfiflflfia QUPTA CHERGEMAfl E £923 %BQUT 39 YRS WORKERS AT SENIOR QHALITY £SSfiRAECE ESfABLISfi%ENT ELECTRONECS HQ,l9fl3 NRTIGNAL S?ADIUM NEW SELHI 1 SUEHIR EEQBRAR CHARGEMAN X AGED AEGUT 39 YRS woaxzms AT CQNTROLLERATfi&§F gUALxf¥5 ASSURANCE ELECTROEICS J.$,EAGAR BARGLGREg A R MENDULE CHARGEMAN 1_ v_ 1 . . , .«, AGED ABo§@;38g?Rs{ g ~'"~A%?-m- woaxxma gm SEQEQR §fl§IT¥{ ASSURANCE E$§aaL:s$fiEm§«EL£g%RowIc$ QC? JA3gL§$§':;_ - .4 _ } V MAHESH' CH$RGEmA& I'_ ._, .'~» AGEB AEG§T"36 YRS"_ § WQRKEEG RT ¢G3TRc;LER&Tg Q? Q§ALE?¥ ASS§RA§CE ARGQRED vgaxcaz ELEC?RQEZCS *.C/®.Eggvy,vEH:C£Es §ACTORY £5 .§VAQ§_CfiEEK&I 3% §3aR@Ema§;£ AQEQ $393? 3? YES .¢'»@@RK:mG?g$ CQ§TRGLLER§$E $3 Q§fi§ETY ',§$g§RA§cE ESTAB$I$RMEE§ gggcyaagzcs ."=§$gg§c@%§LEx gag aaasgg .}.§$§$@N ?aw§ EAfi$éL$RE £5 V"E ¥ vggg§?aa %§BE§V ' Cfigfifififififi 2 ¢~ %§%$w§%%f%x&& 4?
$8 §§ <3 v %Asn'g If} AGEQ ABQQT 52 YRS WGRKING A? CQNTRGL£ERfiTE SF Q§ALlT¥ ASSGRANCE ELEC§RONICS J¢C-§AGAR BfiNGALORE K C KGTNALA CHARGEMAN I _~m_' _ Assn AEQUT 45 YRS I '~"
WGRKING AT CGNTRGLLERATE a§%Qa§Li??z'" A ASSURANCE EsrABL:sHMEN$.gLacwa§m:c$_£pA"
N§al9fl3 NATIGNAL STADI NEW mmnar 1 SRRANJXT szxaa QHARGEMAN 2 AGED A308? 58 yas _ WORKIHG AT sgaa %jgfi§ fi __ , 1549 sEawoa'3a 3 ~_ {=7 WA'J»-,§ cKAmB:GARaV35i_g *' * --"TV §SH0KVKHM§R SAfiflE» W 'a mmm$mfi§jVf 3 AGED gEQu?.62fzRs_',f RETIREE FROM $R§Q§&@:?E ASS§RAfiCE ESTABLEQHMENT"EEECTRQNECS fiaga C§M§LEX MAfi©v:KAsgmgaAR=sEcfiflmERAaAn § .sfiAR§$M&M_:a "&g$as>As§§?V5:vyRs ws§x:m$*§%'$@g§ReLL§aA$E Q? Q§§LE?¥ As$§RAm$Ej§LECTR@N:cs £3C;§AQAR Efi§§£L@RE ;K"ag§mé Kfiafiga *§§gR§EmAfi I «f.A$$§'§BaUT 33 333 §QRKZfiQ &? $Q§TRQLLE§§?E §§ §§§LITY u"§SS$RA§$E gzgafiasfizcs J $,§A@g§ EAESRLGRE gr 52 §3 5% 55 B R Jfifififiv CHARGEMAH I AGEB A363? $4 YRS HGRKIEG &T C@fiTRQL$ERATE 0? QUAEITY RSSURANCE ELECTRGNICS
5.C.NEG%R.BANGALQRE K ASRQK KUMAR CH$RQEMA§ 1 AGEB ABQUT 52 YRS waaxxws AT camwRoLLERg%g Q? QHgL:T§,'5*~ ASSURANCE ELECTRONICS fla€vflAGAR EANGALQRE R PRAKASH CHARGEMAN I -_ AGEE ABOUT 43 yRs,""-'1 ,._ . ,» woxxzms AT;CG§%RS&LERATE°Q?TQ§AiIT¥ ASS3RANCE~ELEC$RQE:$$_ _ ' £,C¢NAGAR ggfisazeafifg 4.:
J wI§SQ§"»j CEARGEMAK :* ._ _ , a AGEE A303? §?"$Rg~_*,» waazxaa a? cGfi¢RGLLfiRATE 3? QGALET¥ Ass§gAmcE*g:£C?RGN:Cs 3¢C§NAG§R EANSALQRE $=C $AmA§°v $;;g§<::;EE25;;:»:'V" 3: "
'A@E§ §g§§§53é gag %$EKE§G.&$ €§RTRQL§EATE as §§&&ITY A$S§RA§CE'ES?AEL:s§MEE? ELEC?RG§IC$ *,fiA$TIE$$ ?K§,CQMMl§$ARI£§ gagg 'u_g2LaA?A 22 'fi'§§§&LA fifiéfifigfiafi 3 '"§$xm AE@fi% 33 333 §@RK?EG fif €Q§?fi§LEER&?E $§ Q§%LZ§¥ 63 G MURGGAN 64 55 56 CHARGMMAN Z AGED ABOUT 51 YRS WORKING AT CQNTRQLLERATE G?
QUALITY ASSURAECE ARMOURED VEHICLE ELECTRQEICS cxo HEAVY vggzcgas FACTQRY gvam: CRENXAI 54 _M» 3 BOSE CHARGMMAN I AGEfi BGUT 54 YRS _--, WORKENG as SENIOR QUALITYg"* QUALITY A$SURANCE ESTAE£ISHME§T EL£cwRafi:cs HASTIN$S ?.Q céwg:$3AR:A°'"
RGAD KOLKATA 22 R G SAHU _ _ ""
CHARGMMAfi :;'>_j _ AGEE ABOU¢-52i¥R$' Wemxzma AS sEgIGR«g§§Li$i;u:
ASSURAHCE EsTA£;:sfiM3&TwEg$c§RamIcS DGQA c0M§LEx vKfiGRoL:' MUMBAI,83' 9RNAB KaEAR%§§a§7 =fi CHARQgmAm':_' _: * Agxfigaasuf 52 gag ' =woRK:&§aAsz$mN:§R"§uAL1$§ AS3SR£§CE E$TABLESfiMEfiT EL€€?RG§:CS "gg§§iN$3 §§@ggQmm:s$AR:Af ROAS K®§gg§§»22_gf 3 §"vEmi:.¢g:
fiHARGfifiA§ I W$GE§flAEGfiT 5% Egg §@RKi§§ Ag S£§I§R §§ALETY r;assmgA§c2 ESTEELZSEEEET Eggafaaazgg "«'u§§.:%g13 figfzafigz Sfgfilfifi $2? $323: 1 #g Q, gm, €€§§i§ %' - ' :- L2 1 vs ?4 ?5 ?5 §GQfi CGM§LEX S&K.GRRBEN BEESQH TGfiE BEEGELGRE 46 J sgaanzv CHARGMMAN E AGES §BQU? 45 YRS RETERED FRGM SR QUALITY ASSURA§CE ESTABLISHMEKT ELECTRQNIC3 3GQA.COM9LEX I _ ; MAEQVIKASANAGARTSECfiNDERAB£D:§T7 M MUKOPADYAY CHARGMMAN E fifififi ABGUT 4? YRS_ ASSURANCE EsTAELIsgmxgfwgiagwfiegzcs"" HASfING$ 9.9 CGMMf£SXARIA§ K$1A§;_ KQLKATA 22 '~ '"': ~."T% 1 s K AJRA;" *"
cHARGMMAw~:u __,v.__ _ ASHE ABa$$,é§ YRS47fn' W: , W$RKIfi§ AS tQ3$ROLLERA$E_Q? QUALITY AssUmA&cE~§§Mo§Ra§kvgH1cLE ELECTRQEICS ago HEA¥¥ vEfi:¢Lg$g§AC?§Ry AvAQI*CHEw§A:*§a_v," ' H N NA$E§DRA' 5 Qflfififififlfifi :~.
"=.A@mfi gangs 38 YRS .§egK:§G AS ¢G§wRaLLERA§E 3? QUALITY 'I"agg§RagcE*;E$TRe§:cs J}a;xga%R'§&R@Aa5RE M fiaafiafgi V.Cfi§R§E§&§wI »xg§$§ 3% Sagas "_fiQRK:§@ RT §Q§TR@LLEE§?E é? QQALZTE &SS§RANCE{ELE€?RQ§ECS} uV_$;$5 ggggfi 'ggfigggégg w£?**:
Eifififififififi ?§ 83 81 $2 M 9 SATHY£MGR?HY CHARGEMANMI AGES 38 YEARS WQRKING AS CGHTROLLERA?E OF QUALI?Y &SSURANCE{ELECTRQ§ICS} Jbfl, NAGAR BAEGALORE R SHERIFF CHARGEMAN~E AGEB 61 YEARS WGRKING AS CONTRQLLERATE G? QU§LE§Y7 %SSUANCE(ELECTRG§:CS§_m' $.c. NAGAR '= * BANGALORE M A MAERNA GQ?ALArKRI$Hfi$§_ ' caaaazwaugz-_f L , 5 u"~= gags 55 $3333", .
wGRKIMGiAs,$QfiTgQ:3E *?$,éE-QSALITE ASSURARCE{ELE£TRQNIC$§. } EANQfiLOREV 7 s K Rgmnga Kfléfi "
cfiAR@EMAE»: _ AQEJD " 43 YEARS "'» wQRRz£§ AS COfiTR$LLERA?E G? guazxry , RSS§R£§$E§ELECTROfiICS} ;?,Q;_"@;§3fi§_' "'g2§$Lég§. V V83 € fi Afi§Sfi§A sggaggmaguz '&$ga 38 yaggg 'wQRK:§g As C§§?R®EL§RATE as Q$gL:§y 7%$S$RAN€E{ELE$?RO§E€S} $,a. xaaga "'*ggEg§L@aE gg. 84 85 8% 8?
K CfiANBRAH CE§R$EMAfiwI AGED 45 YEERS WORKERS as comraoznaggmg 9? QUgL:Ty _W >u ASSURA§CE(ELEC?RQNICS§ J.c. NAGAR BAflGALORE __W_ SMT K ANITH& CHARGEMAN~I _ AGEE 33 yagag '_*, ~ . _ WORKING AS caNTRaLLERA?E,©F QGAR:T?5 As$URANcE(ELECTRQ§:cs}VN ' v. J.C, NAQAR 'v. * BAN§ALORE PRATHIBHA EAiKWADg . , .2' caaxsmmgxmggygfiznfizz $E§ag.fl-wj RBTIREB_knag?$E;§33L:§y,As3URANcE ESTABL1SBMER$ (ELE¢$R0fi1$3;'BGQR CQM?LEX wmmm§wmm@$V _'W_ 5 SEC$fifiERAE$Qm5§§_GQ§ R C BARAD§R'V CHARGEMAN%I '_ A§En_38 2EARS_5 woggifla AS fiQ§TR$&LERE@E Q? Qfikilfy '"=.As$§RxcEgELEcTR@N:c3} .§,c._Na@g%»_ 'V_§&§$ALQRmV,; V"vr3g
3.$ gggéépf cggaagmgfizw '».A$E§T§: YEARS "g wagxzfig A? SEHISR QULI?Y A$S3RA§CE "' EgT§EL:saME§§ {ELEC?RQ§ICS} ,V._."§A$§:m$S §¢@ C§MfiI$$ARZ%E Raigfi "ax _$fiz$&?$w?§§ $22 8?
93 91 92
K G §ARAB cmggammawmz A329 59 YEARS WORKIfiG AS SEEIGR QUALKTY &S$fiRAECE ESTABLI$HMENT{ELECTROflZCS} agga QGMPLEX, vzxaaanx MUMBAI~4GOO83 bw 3 P VESWA KARMA CBARGEfiAN--I AGED 55 zagas wokxxms AS SENIQR QUAL:f§ §ssURgm§=5 asTABL1saMENrgELEcrRam1cs;},'~ 'w GCF, §ABALAy$R«482 @Q1;' * SM? 5 VAN:
CHARGEMAN~I V 1 ._ . , . ,» AGES 3? YEARSg-RETfREEVFROM*SR¢Q3&LITY AssURANcE,Vvu'gg.*_fl_xz 5 iv . EsTABL:sgMEm?§ELEc§R§§:€s§'wsQA§c0MpLEx MA§ov:fiAsAHAG&g_ f. ".U 5 sEcUN$ERA3A§e59§'aQ§j SQENLAL -
V _ . .' AGEb_58 yEAas,_RE:§REa yagw $3. QU&L§TY>§S$§R&R$E $STABL§SHMEET J "{ELECTRQNIQS, QGQA CGMFEEX fiAfiQVIKA$&RRGAR 'fiségsgnggggagégse §§§ svx§E§$§ §fiés§ saaagggafiwz «,*%§En 53 YEARS '»§aRK:§@ Ar SENZQR Q§§LE?Y Assa2aw;T *E5rA§L:sxfiE§wggagcrgamzcs} .1;fis§:§$g, @9@u camzgsaaxg? Razgfi ."»uug§LKA$gw?a§ $22 Q4 9E §6 §'?
a °£.C,"N$QAR x_§m$mm a SURESH K&fiAM c§ARGEMAN«:
AGED 38 YEARS NQRKING AT SENIGR QUALETY ASS§RAfiCE ESTABLISHMENT{ELECTRGNECSE EGQA C9MpLEx, 5 K gamma Bamsam TQWE, BRRSALOREWQE M K BASAVAIAQ CHARGEMANMI AGED 55 YEARS, RETEREB ERQM sR.QUAL:§f§"' ASSURANCE ESTABLISHMEET{ELE$TRGfi£CS"' EGQA COMPLEX, AMQv:KAsA§A@AR,_ " SECEHEERABAEWSSG fiQ3_ f * v TILAK SHARGEMANWI _ _ 1 »: ag_ -«,' AGED 58 YEARS; RETzaE3'ERQM SR gaaazry ASSURANCE»E3$ABLESHMEN?{ELECTR$NICS DGQA coM§LEx;,MARevEgAsAMA§AR sEcUNpE3g3Ap¢§g§_eQ9_'" 5 J BAERAJ:'.
caAR$ExAN»: _ __ »_ . AGE5 55':gARs'_'z 2') woaxzgs AT c§mmR@LLERATE CF QflALE?¥ ASS§RAN$E{E§E$§RG§:CS} §AéAa:é%E&g§"
Cfifiggfififififi gggfi 33.yEaR$ «_Vw@Rx:&gfg$ C®§?RQLEER&TE Q? Qfignzfy '»§sg§§AN§a{$;§c§R0§:cs; 7J;Q,f§A§§R .1;gg§$aL$RE %%§§ 5» %?g