Delhi District Court
Criminal Case/934/1999 on 27 March, 2008
1 ! " # $&% %'$( ) * +$ #, -.
"/102/13 4*52 687:9;5)<.=20
! > ?@ BADCFE)GHA.A
GI52 BJ KLGLKLGLKME ONQP29;5R3 PS/
T U V%W0D=2X.?OY) Z[7\9
] ^._\` a!b ced@fQ_Icg_IhO_Icga d a!b"_jiO`lk[^OfQ`"m:n.nporqtsQorq.q ] ^._\` a!bTu `Of(`!vxw cedOyz_jit` a v|{!`!v m:np}.orqO~2oHq. ] T T
0. <23 5YB (=Q?@ ?2./r<23 Pp0t53 $OK.GC <23 .02/13 ?2DPp?D l95p59?D= $)&J.K.\A.A ?2&/r<23 ?213D=2Pp3 Pp <23=20D 3 ?2./r<23 PF?D &Y0O9=20D=F/ $& + %W3.3D7@ 9=2XD< . <23=20D 3 0..D713t5p5?2 $2 /H t687:9;5)<.=20W¡ GH?¢# <20D7£0D 20OYB¤ +PpP2Z&53. 7GH?¢ £E@¥D¤ %W0D=2X.?OY) Z[7\9¤.# 3OY<&9
3. <23 ?213D=2Pp3 Pp?D &Y¦0D9§=23. $ "GI52 BJ KLGLKLGLKME ONQP2953 +PS/H 1 <23&Y3.0 ?2./r<23 0.PFP2Z&53. $¨.Y¦3.0..3[=2?2/OXOZ[9;Y /© X. <23 \9=20OYR?D7£.3D7 $ª Pp«OZ.9 //13. <2 <23 .02/13 ?2!5ZQPQ< ?D7£.3D7 $ Kp&\DC2r&.[¥ ¬ ® u*¯°T±²u D³ ´ µ ´¶±tµ u® ¬ ] ¨ $ K2 ·T7:9¦32 7£3t5Z[ 3 ?2t/r<23l10.PS/x5¸?2t/r<23².7£3t53D=F/!Pp0t53 0D7£3l/\<Q02/!?D= &J.K.\A.A¢02/!0 ?OZp/!Ot B@¹º[ »02/t/r<23Pp?D7\=23D7@?2T Y?.PQ¼p¤O%W0D=2X.?OYQ Z[7\9 # 3OY<&9B¤0.PpP2Z&53.½¡¾0t5¿1?OZ[=2 9=À2?O5F53t5p59?D=Á?2 ?D=23Â&Y0t5M/\9PüS02//10 Pp?D=F/10O9§=&9=2XlE.Ez«OZQ0D7 /13D7 ?2//\Y¦3O5)¤)?2 Pp?OZ[=F/r7 © Y§9«OZQ?D7r p /13D7Ä7£3.XO9;5M/r7£02/\9?D= ?2 ! ¤ 9=FÅQ3t5M/:9X.02/\9?D=¾¡¾0t5Pp?D=2OZQPS/13. 0D=2 PQ<20OY§Y0D=¾¡0t5 \9§Y¦3.9= Pp?OZ[7 /H D *?D &Y32/13¶532/ ?2,PF?D.9¦3t5¢¡¾3D7£3>5Z[.&Y§93.V/1?Æ/r<23¿0.PFP2Z&53.@ T/13D7 <23.0D7:9=2X®0D71XOZ[ 3D=F/:5)¤ PQ<20D7£X[3z¡¾0t5lr7£0D 3.®0.X[0O9§=(5M/ /r<23Ç0.PpP2Z&53. 1?D7 /\7\9¦0OY.?2T?2£3@=2PF3Æ "G|52 @J KLGLKLGLKME> ONQP2953È P/ © ©Ç-)@ T7£3..3.Pp3t5p5R?@7 /1?W¡¸<&9PQ< 0.PpP)Z.5R3.&Y3.0..3.=2?2/DXOZ.9§Y /©¨0D=2 P)Y0O9 3. /r7:90OYB C[ T7£?t53.P)Zp/\9?D=9=V5Z[.2?D7 / ?2¾.713t5R3@=F/ PF0t53É32NQ0Dl9=23.¶/£?Q/£0DY 9 N¡¸9 /r=23t5p5R3t5'9B B3@ @@ÊÉK Ë Z&5<&9§YD6 7r O95¸/r<23¢OZp/©?2\9Pp3D7r¤)¡¸<2?Ç<20t5 2 Ì.ÍDÎ2ÏtÐÍ.Ì ÑDÒ2ÏOÓpÔ"Õ£Í.ÖO×;ÐMÔrÕ£Ñ2Ô\צÏ@Ø Ï2ÙÄÚ!Û Ü ÝtÞOßtà.á@âäãLåxæ à PW-2 HC Havel Singh, second IO, who proved the site plan, Ex. PW2/A, arrest memo, and personal search memos , Ex. PW2/B, C and D, and other aspects of investigation.
á@âèçêé*ÏDØ(ÐëÔHà ì2Ï.ÖOר2Ì.ÍDÕ í ר2ÖDî î2ÑtлÌ.ÍDÎ2ÏtÐÍ.Ì ÑDÒ2ÏOÓpÔ Ì.ÍDÎ2ÏtÐ× Ô Ï2ÙTÐRÑDï Î&ðÍÇÌOÓ.ð ñ ÐÍ.ÑOð¦Í[Ìò¸× ÔrîÔrî2ÍÇÐÍ.ÑOðtÏ2Ù ó¨í ô Ý"רÔrî2ÍõÍ2ßQö2×;ÐÍ Ï2ÙÙ\צöpÍ ÏDØ¢ã÷.øã[ãø\ù.ù@Ý(×§ØFÔ1Ñ.öSÔHà á!â¶ø£úüû.à8é*ÏDØ(ÐëÔHÝ í ÓQÌ.ÍtÐ)î[ÝDòWî2϶î2ÑOТöFÏDØQÌOÓQöÔ1Í.ÌÉÎ2ÍDÕxÐÏDØ2ÑOð ÐÍ.ÑDÕ£öQî ÑDØ2Ì ÑDÕ\Õ1ÍtÐëÔÉÏ2ÙÉÔrî2Í Ñ.öpö2Ó&ÐÍ.Ì@ݲý.×Ì.Í ÞDß[à¿áDò¾þåÿ ÑDØ2Ì Õ£ÍtÐ)Î2Í.öSÔ\× ýQÍOð ñtà á!â¶ø é óWÍ.ÍDÕäí ר2ÖDî[ÝÉ×;Ð Ô\îQÍ Û ÝÇò¸î2Ï î2ÑtÐ Ù\Ó.ð§ð ñ ÐÓ[Î.Î2ÏDÕ Ô1Í.Ì¿Ôrî2ͽÎ.Õ£ÏtÐÍ.ö2ÓpÔ\צÏ@ØÆýQÍDÕxÐ×ÏDØ¿ÑDØ2Ì¿Ô1ÍtÐMÔ\× Ù\×Í.Ì ÑDÒ2ÏOÓpÔ î&×;ÐÉÒ2ÍO×§ØQÖ ÏDØõÎ2ÑQÔ\Õ1ÏOð;ð§×Ø2Ö¢ÌOÓpÔñõר Ô\îQͲÑDÕ£Í.Ñ Ï2Ù øjÒ&ð¦Ï.ö ÝÄóWÑDØ2Ö.ÏOðÎ&Ó[Õ:×QÑ2Ô ÑDÒ2ÏOÓpÔ tàB÷ Î[à ï ÑOð¦ÏDØQÖ)ò × ÔrîöFÏDØ&ÐëÔHà í ÓQÌ.ÍtÐ)îüÑDØQÌÀí Ó[Õ rÍ.Í2Ô¨ÏDؽþ .øã÷.ørù.ù@Ý ÐÍ.ÍOר2Ö Ñ.öpö)Ó.ÐRÍ.̽î2Ñ2ý.ר2ÖüÏDØ2ͽÎ&ðÑtÐëÔ\×öÆöFÑDØQÍËרüî2ÍDÕWî2Ñ@Ø2Ì@Ý+ÑDÎ[Î.Õ£ÍDî2ÍDØ2ÌOר2ÖVÔrî2Í Ñ.öpö)Ó.ÐRÍ.Ì@ÝêöQî2Í.ö ר2Ö Ôrî2Í SÑ2ÔÔ1Ñ@Ý Ù\×§ØQÌO×§Ø2Ö ú.ú OÓ(ÑDÕ Ô1ÍDÕ Ò2Ï2ÔÔ\ð¦ÍOЮÏ2Ù,Ôrî2Í ð§× OÓQÏ@ÕrÝ ÐÍDÎ2ÑDÕ1Ñ2Ô:ר2Ö Ôrî2ÍÇÐRÑDï Î&ðÍ@Ý ÐÍ.ÑOð;ר2Ö Ò2ÏQÔ\î Ôrî2ÍÇÐRÑDï Î&ðÍ ÑOðÏDØ2Ö)ò × Ôrî öpÑtÐRÍÎ.Õ1ÏDÎ2ÍDÕ Ôñò × ÔrîÔrî2Í®ÐÍ.ÑOðtÏ2Ù ó¨í ô Ý Ù\×;ð§ð§×Ø2ÖÆÓ[Î Í2ßQö2×;ÐÍÈÙ£Ï@Õ\ï óWørþ&ù@Ý ÞOßtàÄá@â åxæ Ý ÐÍO× Qר2ÖzÔ\îQÍ ð;× OÓQÏDÕrÝOý.×Ì.ÍÉÞOßtà á!â®ú)å ÿTÝ Î.Õ£ÍDÎ2ÑDÕ\×§Ø2ÖÕ:Ó SÑ@Ý ÞOßtàTá!â åIé,ÝÄÖ.Í2ÔÔ\ר2Ö®ÑÆöpÑtÐRÍ>Õ£Í.ÖO×;ÐMÔ1ÍDÕ£Í.Ì Ô\î[Õ£ÏOÓQÖDî öpÏDØ(ÐMÔ1ÑDÒ&ðÍ@ÝèöpÏDïlר2Ö Ï2Ù é Ñ2ý2ÍOð í ×§Ø2ÖDî[Ý î2Ñ@Ø2ÌO×§Ø2ÖüÏ2ýQÍDÕÔ\îQÍüÌ.Ï.ö2Ó[ï ÍDØFÔ:Ð)Ý öpÑtÐͽÎ.Õ£ÏDÎ2ÍDÕ Ôñ ÑOðÏDØ2Ö)ò × ÔrîÑ.öpö2Ó&ÐÍ.Ì Ô1Ïõî&×ï'ÝO×Ì.ÍDØFÔ\× Ùñ.ר2ÖÔrî2Í¢öpÑtÐÍ Î.Õ£ÏDÎ2ÍDÕ ÔñtÝ ÞOßtà áÄøã Ô£Ï á ø£ú.úÑDØ2Ì Ï2Ôrî2ÍDÕOÑOÐÎ2Í.öSÔ:оÏ2Ù ×§Øpý2ÍtÐMÔ\×Ö.Ñ2Ô\×ÏDØ[à á!â¶ø à é*ÏDØ(ÐMÔHàTí Ó[Õ rÍ.Í2Ô¾î2ÑtÐÈÖ.ÍDØ2ÍDÕ£ÑOð§ð ñÌ.ÍDÎ2ÏtÐÍ.ÌÏDØ Ôrî2Í ÐÑDï Íð;ר2ÍtоÑtÐ á@â¶ø @à í Ô£Ñ2Ô1ÍDï ÍDØFÔ Ï2Ù Ñ.öpö2Ó&ÐÍ.Ì ÓåIÐÈþ ãÇé Õrà*áTà é òÑtЮգÍ.öpÏDÕ£Ì.Í[Ì@Ý ò¸î2ÍDÕ1ÍO×§Ø'Ñ.öpö2Ó&ÐÍ.Ì Ì.ÍDØ&×Í.Ì Ôrî2Íz×§Ø2öQÕ:×ïlר2Ñ2Ô\ר2Ö¢Í2ý&×Ì.ÍDØ2öpÍ ÑDØQÌÐMÔ£ÑQÔ£Í[Ì Ôrî2Ñ2Ô Ð)î2Í î2ÑtÐ Ò2Í.ÍDØlÙ1ÑOð;ÐÍOð ñ²×ï Î&ð§×öpÑ2Ô£Í[Ì²×ØlÔrî&×;Ð öpÑtÐÍ@à Ï)òÍ2ýQÍDÕrÝDÐ)î2Í¢ÌO×Ì Ø2Ï2Ô ÏDÎFÔ.Ô1Ïð¦Í.Ñ.Ì ÑDØpñ Í2ý.×Ì.ÍDØ2öpÍר î2ÍDÕÌ.Í2Ù1ÍDØ2öpÍ@à Û(î2Ñ2ýQÍõî2Í.ÑDÕ£Ì'Ôrî2Í ÑDÕ£ÖOÓ[ï ÍDØFÔ:Ð ÑDØ2Ì öpÑDÕ£Í2Ù\Ó.ð§ð ñ'Ö.Ï@Ø2Í Ôrî.Õ£ÏOÓQÖDî Ôrî2ͺգÍ.öpÏDÕ£Ì@à!8Ï Î.Õ£Ï2ýQÍ»Ôrî2Í Ï2ÙÙ1ÍDØ2öpÍ " åIÐ2à# ã å ãLåLãMú ÞOßQö2×ÐÍ æ+öSÔHÝ Ôrî2Í Î.Õ£ÏtÐÍ.ö2ÓpÔ\צÏ@Ø ×;ÐÁÌOÓpÔñ Ò2ÏDÓ[Ø2Ì Ô£Ï Î.Õ£Ï2ýQÍ»Ôrî2Ñ2ÔõÑ.öpö2Ó&ÐÍ.Ì ×;ÐÔrî2Í ÐÑDï Í Î2ÍDÕxÐÏDØ ò¸î2ÏÇò¾ÑtÐzÙ1ÏOÓ[Ø2Ì ×ØÉÎ2ÏtÐpÐÍtÐpÐp×ÏDØÆÏ2Ù,ð§× OÓQÏDÕ ò¸× Ôrî2ÏOÓpÔ ÑDØFñÇýQÑOð§×Ì Î2ÍDÕ\ïl× Ô!ÏDÕ8ð§×öpÍDØ2öFÍÈà ÚO×§Õ:ÐëÔ Ï2Ù ÑOð§ðÝDØ2Ï Î&ÓtÒ&ð;×ö ò × ÔrØ2ÍtÐpÐò¾ÑtÐ$ rÏOר2Í.ÌÈÒFñ Ô\îQÍ Û êר Ô\î.×ÐöpÑtÐÍ@ÝV× Ô ×;ÐlÔrî2Í öFÑtÐÍÇÏ2ÙÄÔrî2Í Î.Õ1ÏtÐRÍ[ö)ÓpÔ\×ÏDØÔrî2Ñ2ÔÄÔ\îQÍÇÑ.öFö2Ó&ÐÍ.Ì 3 %'&)(*&,+ + -/.,01.,213 . 3 &14 57698 : ; <1=?>A@B&,21C ;D:E+ F)-HG >JI7.D:K0 GB% 0 G < 0LGM(N&
-/.)(?G 3 .,2O4 G &D:P+ : & < . &,213 QR&,2OS +1.,-T(U;,2V(W%X;DF : 3 81.Y&1Z &DGK: &,8 : .[4\01.,-/. > 01;]%'. Z1.,-^>V21;_(?GK21< .,-/.`.1abac;,-d4H(B(U. .,Qe(f4c;g01&1Z .h81. .,2iQR& 3 .h8OSB4\01.hj k 4/; l ;DGK2m&,2OSn+ F 8 :KG <B%!G 4\21.)( (e.DG 4\01.,-o&14 4\01.g4HG QR.n;1ap-c. <O;1Z .,-dSg;,-q&14 4\01.`4 G QR. ;1aEGK2OZ .)(r4 G C &14 G ;,2 s tDF -d4\01.,-\> &)( +1.,-E+ -/;)(U. <1F 4HG ;,2u< &)(U.u4\01.v(U.DG w1F -c. QR.,QR;g%X&)(A+ -/.,+1&,-/. 3$81.1ac;,-/.x(U.,213DG 21C - F =O=y& 4c;{zq|7>p8 F 4^>D4 0 .x(}&,QR. a GK2 3)( QR.,2O4 G ;,2~4\01.Jtjd2 F)QP8 .,-D;,2mG 4^s7;]%'.1Z .,-\>U4\0 GM(fac& <y401&)(#21.,G 4\01.,-
81. .,2 QR.,2O4 G ;,21. 3WG 2 4\01.v-/.,+1;,-d4!F9( ? -\sz s 21;
-RG 2 4\01.-HF = =y& > % 0 G < 0< -/. &14c.)(u&N3 ;DF 8O4n-/. C &,-/3DG 21C*4\01.YQR&,2 2 .,-`&,213Y(U. DF .,21< .[GK2 % 0 G < 0h4\01.G 2OZ .)(r4 G C &14 G ;,2{01&)(81. .,2< ;,213DF <y4c. 38OSA4\01.j k#s 5 ;II .,2O4\-dSh-/. C &,-/3DG 21C+1& 4 -c;D:M:KG 21C_;1a 4\01.v01&)(i81. .,2A+ -/; 3DF < . 3A;,2A-/. < ;,-/3 > % 0 G < 0 aHF)-d4\01.,-f<1-c. &14c.)( 3 ;DF 8O4%B01.14\01.,-4\01.&D:K: . C . 3< &)(U.+ -/;,+ .,-d4bS %'&)( & <4 F &D:K: S`-/. < ;1Z .,-/. 3Pa -c;,Q4\01._& < <1F (U. 3i;,- %B0 G < 0mGM(X4\01._(U&,QR.i;,21. &)( 4\01.(U. &D:;1ao4\01. < &)(U.+ -/;,+ .,-d4bSh&)(B%X.D:K: &)(#4 0 .81;14b4 : .)(B%X.,-/.J&D:M(}; ac;DF 2138 -/;,=y.,2m% 01.,2A+ -c; 3DF < . 3JGK2E4 0 .A< ;DF -d4 ac;,-.1 0 G 8 G 4HG ;,2A01.
21<O. 4\01.
+1;)( (?GK8 GK:KG 4bSR;1a,< 01&,21C .E;1a,< &)(U.g+ -/;,+1.,-d4bS#< &,2 21;1481.g-HF : . 3E;DF 4^s j2i4\01.)(U.<]G -/<1F Qe(r4c&,21< .)(1>D4 0 . -/. < ;1Z .,-dS_a\-/;,QY4\01.& < <1F (U. 3 GM(A3 ;DF 8O4ba F : &,213jq&,Q ;1a74\01.$;,+ G 2 G ;,2n4\01&14~+ -/;)(U. <1F 4HG ;,2{01&)(hac&DGK: . 34c; + -/;1Z .R4\01.E< &)(}.E& C &,GK2V(r4 4\01.E& < <1F (}. 3g81. S1;,213E&,2OSm-/. &)(U;,21&,8 : .E3 ;DF 8O4^s .,21< .
>jD01.,-/.,8OSi& <O,F G 44\01. & < <]F (}. 3`ac;,-,4\01._;1abac.,21< .(]01.01&)(P81. .,2 < 01&,-/C . 3i% G 4\0 s 7.,- o&DGK: 81;,213A< &,21< .D:M: . 3 s,| F -/.14bSg3DGM(}< 01&,-/C . 3 s &)(U. + -/;,+1.,-d4bS 81. <O;,2 aHGM(U< &14c. 3 4/; 4\01. (r4c&14c. >&)( +1.
-- F : .)(1s tDGK: . 81.
< ;,2V(?G C,21. 3R4c;_7. < ;,-/3_ ; ;
Qms
¡ 55 ke¢5£X¤pIjd5¥ ¤nk#z7¤p5
ke¢p¥ke5O¦ 6\§,16\¦ § § ¨,s ©\ª¬«Bp«®
«R¯
«B°£ª«R± ²
³ ´ µ·¶\¸p¹)¸qºb»¼µ ½
¾n³ ½ ¿o»dÀ µ·¶^½ µ ´UÁ ± ´
ºb»