Karnataka High Court
M/S Ozone Properties Pvt Ltd vs The Addl Commissioner Of Commercial on 9 November, 2010
Bench: Manjula Chellur, Aravind Kumar
EN "I"E.--{ER I:Ei{}§"E Ci{}E§I:€'i' {E}? K37§.E€E'€z3:'E3EK'5%_& Etfié-';§\l{7§;"':.i',,-{:§E¥';.E%§ §§1§':T§EE_} 'iI."§"'£h'.-3 '§'E"H*Z E:'¥"?""§ EBAY SE3 ?§C}"\z'"§*-S§\£H%EfZ§{,, EC? E"R§3S i;iN'E' '.E'§~~E§iZ H{3N*§%L,E§- E\/H-EiSx}US'.E'EC£-3 :xz§_ga:.xmH,.A <:§-:j:";._::g...,L3:é' ' ;'§7:'*€ D T§~--£'}:5«: E'~E{>N'E'3LE3Z 'M.R. J U S".I."§Cf is; -;s;:"em;"1_r\s_E§>i §§§_T'1'§;!1Y.,%'?'--;.E_\>:
srzta. N<)..19 <3¥' ::0 .172: A' 3 E3 E55.-'.i"~.5J E1 E1'? :
M,/Sm GZGNE P§a20;é£;z2'1'H§,8----E'%"\;**§'. "L.zM:':"§a::i.};v-.. . N0. 5 2 /' *2 ii , RA';f§--~1r».rA'*;w1~::Nmag" » .__ ._ *-
ome'. RECHMONI) £<é_<:}Ai§;-- «L * ' Cmz, Smii'-I@N¢ " 5 E-EANGAE,OR'£E3,.__ "I1-1£z0U<;1=i'--: 11,, H --
Af:5F--1'K>"E'§'~JE ';:-§A.JA:: LEAEEJ. _ A'iJ'E"j{:-:3 «;.'2I_{1;<';::7*%.;>;_ '?:~=;*%:£c;"::I;:'~;' :1': mi.
X ' _ .. ,.A§5'153£§;LLAN'§' {B}; Sr: .E{z?:n:e-1E_._%§ égzzci' ~~3{£i1'I'3&1{.§'}, KL}-§{§it;*$Ki'% , - ., V 5m.§i' ;Af:i;>.::§':.,--._ C{§E§«T.?\/E§SSI(}l\iE%Z,?€ <12?
- g:@.§¢§.,§/:'§.:§2<::A:, *mxz:.:& 2:<>:\:::»a . h T K '%i%E_E'.§:%J§¢§EN{:%R _ Qwgrag :;>.§TT%:1fix:iAG-gm?
;3.;:=§~£.;GA:,C;§zz'«:.
V. _ " .H;2::a:$:'){>N;;>§f:N*::
" --. §5§§§;' Séi "§Z_E{§ '%;"'?;'.{I§E-i_§"_f"£'§.'iI'§l§'E§1 €'}.!-'%~A,.q§ €'3€fi{ i} :3? 1.316 'E'h§s.% 21;:-;7>a%z;aE. is; ffiifii :md<:.3: S<'%<:i.§<:>n K2-:m21t.a}«;2z V;'::h.:c Aiicisgi 'E'z.1:>; §':€'.'§§ 2=z§;;'::é1.'1s§ *;.1"1.e:-2 {>t*<i<:-r:f..__c§z;1ie£§ .£.8~i2Z--i£Ui}9 pE%.E§3E':§f;'.E§ in ZAC--1./§13<ZiIii)~1jSI'\»'E§5%~€§3g'2{}{}EZ=Eli} {rm §:E1e fi}.::>; af ihif.' Acidi. {3{3mmis;ass3§T<>1T1r:%1" GE" C<3:1::':2<;%3'°<?é:{E $<3:':z<:--E. E3a:'2g;a}<3re. * 35:-2;
"§"'§%2£..<;-.3 a=:p}j}ea3 <:c;»m:ir1g GEE E713?' »57ad::1.isa "§{:i"é*, ; %NJE§LA CHELLIER J; <ia~:§éve:rs:rci::1'1e b£;'{)j3f'i<j;m}§;T:'1',§§é;:_ V Jubagjgm A h "
'E"hs:: f<)H:3w§:3.g q:.:.s3$1i<}11sV-£:=*i"ééiw é-ujfir r21'§s'<-:e:i..Ai1":_.€1r:::* a1;)p:3:»1§ 131.6111 0 i \\\/'"%m A. "
Vi;h €?i.E'§€:"f E;' '£:1:;,_ §hc.,_fz'rc E.::':~ ";11j_:._c§ e::_irc:'L1r:1:§;'i.a.1'1.<:ese; of the case, ?_3vhe2fé :{1p;3~:%;1i's.;_ §:w:r'ib:*es thst Kar1'1z1t.e1§§2: ,5-'ippefiiaie "£V:ib:._1_:2211 22:15'.§§é:1d§;z1g_.fc>;~ c1c:<;:i.si<m ciL§1fi:'ég; w}.1i.c:th films:
£.I¥1{V;§:'%:_ Aé:s ;VéE:ft%Ey;i3~' _é:L' ban' E01' €r:>:e:"2::%e:;i.ng iflhe pawez' :3? Q 'V :*<.:%1-'§.&;i<;zi ggfifir i3eL:§:i<)1'3. {$1.53} {E3} c:f'E'.§1s3, E{VA'§' £5§{'.'i., vs,»-"iifi iii 3--:'1::>i A.'Ii3.Ii}"§E)L,'IV'i;iHJi W "[.{} £1 :'<:vis7;{.>::1. ;'3%'méa:e<ii:é;%_§ w'i1.%;{>u£'. gmgi arise aggeiiilsi. {he s;as:',¥:'E€c.1 g.);"i.:'1(%§pi<e:§s 0?
~ 'i.f»f":f;.@%';'.E1;:;%1" in mi"; .{21_{t'i.fT§ ;:1:'1{,': (iiiE"€f?_.1.§.'E":$3'.£?s,§'}{T€iff:§ af 1.§'§.£;? é:as<;a *1-&:E1€::*<»:: ?'3.55% 0.? 1E;}<:% ':}':.';'i.Ei 12;} 212%: in iht': Eéfé" 532314:
Vk5E'7E§{7E_} E°%Ei?llE},.§Z"_:t:"f:i§ 'r35; EE.':é:% :;T§§_3§'}€:§§§£1E1§. § f{'1€;T£'E1E§€?}i"%3;*f3 213:? {ix} E':':i.s%:°:":a':'.iveEj;. %5'\76§3 in i.E"1€< €?'«J€§.'§'E§.. §;§.1:=% §:';'1z'1ss«:f€:z' <1}? 26.45943 9? Esufli. up g-$621 in 8'? pa:"§«§ in €3}:€'?§'E2£E'}§§€ Ear g)<;:"'€é{)r: <}f z.m~divicEec§ in*:.«:%res"i. in izgzmii hfstid {:0 bi: *'JSaE:;f,__€:.r'if§£::'E:;.a53;'~ V ii. wcizfigi bt'. p1'G§}ez' in Ufléfl fads:-3 zmcfi {éi:'{itu;fi'55i':;a,:§€::':éa'* : éE:<:*. £3;-2559 mm. :0 gzlkm-" ':.E1e:*: €§€{£;;»<t?;.ie>1'; £53§""'éééé'»;2..:":"1;:3*:;,:;";'£,:~§_ pzrid X §}ET§§F&1E33:% 'LE1? z°%:;;j§s31.c>::'ei§ :<.~.;'q.b--€{§;:';%..;=i2*zéi3_£.{>ifs'WE'E:--g:§1_ iiegg A' be:':1fa. éi.h."€&1d}.f sL1b§€:i?'t,é3r£i to I':££;>{;_u%';{£L=*::* '{'.E":{?';';-, E{'Jr3'~,..T"V -;5«;«;:.§;-; " ZZQQS' as; ihe S-;2m'1{--": w<';:;1é§._ §{§E3;C§ ' £10 d_<>'i;a..':31<::,_V'i:a:2e:z:.*i.é~;>'1f2 wllich i$ §m}:=€1'n1is5ibE.e L,1;1.dé§ji.i';t: C<>§:§Ssf;.i.1.{i1';1<>nf2? 2;. This. appeai. is §fi§;E=,c}[' b3".'§,}1s;j_ 'L2 _ag;§_;§:*§<3ved by aha firder sf {he "If1"'i'b1:.ma2 §1§~~vZ1':§:;C;':5. 1V'}';:§E«I.§?.«63 ,/ 20439 20 é;1t€:c:i of vappfiliam :2': brief' ES fihai he is _;§:{);jer{yif':i.i:i?e:§Ei;;§}:"J_. am} €:m:r3:'<:*c1 éntci 2-2. Jami. E}€=veE€>g)::1s%Vfi':,_4!A§§{:*=§¢;':;%§é3;1'i.VA::_€*e*'i€.E1 E'v'§,fs ?vianayE1.:X EI1§,{iE"££3'€§'S E3'1'iv;-Vzfié 'V:{'..s.§mi£,€d"; .. Maiiay i?ifi?€$ anii £\/ifiiziéss EEBEE M/55 rx €§'2€:';.'<fi':";=1E :§:}{}E"£V§3'2'f§.:€E%f.E()I'1 Ccmpzan}-' awe? 'éhfis {}Wr1m":-;-3: of {he iztmii in ;;zfi;<3§g€§£'{;'2:;"«,_.E*;é% ' "§°%:i:::.2.§.§. Si.' 5:-2,22%; 2;:L"§'2z;';§;;{31&1:?:'1.i 21 ${}§U--'J«Eii'€;' 'E'é%':3§::":A:§Ee:3 3%,?' *--§?%£::"'E{ 133* :'':am'::;% 2% ®::*:e:}:'":€:: ?1°<>§>&?:;"é.i€8
-- E7':-*i.,Li';":'1Er)--:::§""Ems; §:»:;*;s::'z pazfi 2.1;.) '$33: i.?§t: ;2:pp<':':}.;em§. {4?.:}:'::§>.2m§; and in £'Ls.:r:.%;:e;°2mc€ <>f éiize seaici 2:g;§:'ee::';t:r1t E)€'ix3;-'tT€f£'i %;'.E::'»:r p.>;»1:"'%;'.§@ss af¥;.€3:' <:<}:12§3I6't.i<>n 53%" '£.h€ p:*«::g7a:%cE;_ 26.45% <}§%}1e 'miaééé. up z':V::=:3:1 i:>_-3 $0 be '£r2ms§e:':'ed 4:0 the Ezsnszd <m,»*:1ez*:'~; in Kim: 0'? ij<,3'E"1i<?h__§.h%:§i 12u":a:i in {he a;3p::>.H:m'z.° Tiié'. buihl up 2f:_,:°<;>,:;2. _<§4f°2'{:"3')~.Fj53?}x€;' v§3_:I£;spV3i@g§;*j H159 a-xppeiiarfi remaizzed with the {Eeveeiopé:<~21;)g:seivE'é;a'3§*gi';i'n=:i°':t§ie same was not %':'rar1sfer:'{5:d {iii f;(>€i'aj.f;~ E'; is §L1,;ff:E1e§=' 1321:5563 of the appeilani ihai. he has :15':-,.. ;£.akr3n 'Lip;E1'i'1§'._§EOE}E5E.'E'§i£":§f0I'1 work and .m{:s'E. Oi" iihe C(>I1SiruC'LiOi~'1. W'f5 1.'K 5wa._é:=_T§c';éj;€:Vd€;\d (war to 55u.b»~ =7?-r <:0r1'E::°ar::t0rss wE10*wj<%:'e all r£»wi;§ie%rré€i . {§CE1§(i:fI'"S amd they have ciiscliatgggcgi ._§'.hc;jii"'--"1;.;=.:e;_v4'§§:ab'i«1.ii3;-..._:5a3 fag' as wcxks <f%<>mu'aa:tt'.s dame by ?;.h€:':1: f<>r.. $1.116 :a;;:é';ia<3§{"i':i:';f;.w é '~"'{'hE% mss;;j:>eCi'.ir;;g; a1zz£.h<}:'it'[y w§':<> izzsperariied 'iéixaa §?p?§)=*.';',§_§&5.E}_'5.A,iS.'}¥fé}72fi"§iS€S an 28~E.E~2UG§ 2:133 hzsfi me §'3<:-nefii: of \§<2:":?V_f};_§V;«2g;§"<2%f §fi4;iiIj§: fr.'€E{3OI"{§S 0;? é:§':<«2 'i,:'a;'1s5a<:ii<;z: bu: hz>xx>exge,r, :71': _ i?£3;ZTi':é" E53 aihe '€32>:z1z:§:28.i{3:1 '§'§'"1Ei'{, %.h{-3 ':.;°3.::3.S21{:£,i0'n a4.,'§..2°a{.%é,s:é 2% mx .}§2:?':é.iE__i*::j,7 é§':'3{§e;* €=.::i.:'§,~* 23 sf Ehfi s3§:»<"Eh $e:th::%£E:i:E€:? {.0 §{'W'{£" EGQS 3"'.
.. . , .
{'3 21nd ;:1<':<?<}:"{i§1'1g§£}: 'm1c§e:' E3€:E{'f{§€.}§'3. $79 .2: I"1€}§§{f',{"? <'iz.1'§.§%{§ 8~»8A2{}G? etaisséis '32:.me. La ':36: §s~;s3m=:<E. Tiigis Weiss diii}-"' :"£"g:~§§fir:i '::E}~:": As8::?:*-3$€<% s701'1§'.:3:'1d.i:i'1g ihzzi. .;'2€ii.§'1¢;*:1' I':§":€fi§; h:1xr;;;..._§;_Q1.§§ " '.j';:rV'iy« §;:s§'<)g7>€:'?..:\: I191' :°::?<t&iv€:'{,§ 21:1}; €ac§'~:2'1;T2<;?<;% Em rziriise f§§_'s '{'::~*::f sl~;;é{§'e <35 i.§'":v:*_' p:*<:>p<3:'E'.§,-H §":'3:?1'€f:)':*c?, iii:-3 EL§.__Z§T"Ef€:7X'E.1 E$.?('i'§ €:x'c:§12:1zT:g€ E3é?%§'.xw%«:>:1 iihe kmd. 0.vme:*s«2"2.m%;'§._ E.'§1€mS's;*E€?€e£3" xvii} :s.mV§.'-.. 21i1.*a1e:%':. the '$21); §i213f3i1£§.j+,»':
41. E---1{1w.xzev€r& §?.E"1r;>I ,»5§é§':ae$s.:i::g /g[::«'i.vE1=:}i"'i€.y <12'; 4§-E--2GQ8 was cc3:1fe;:.red wiih {ha jL11f;;ss,c3';i<:1.i;3%;': :10--"'<>:j:';«{i;1<§--i. zmciii. by {.119 C(EH3EI:T§£§E§i(}'é'"i{3.E3' sf"f*Z%;:Z':;ziI:':ii::"c§.a§""E'3x. §?.t-:i.1.<-zrzliimg '{ih€% 5:3:«;?u"rs.e <3bj€=C1§:<311 " 'EfE'1e; ${;3 §;>'c:§?;:;1'§'j'=.1;f6§§:s3i£:d {he s?s2:::'1'1e (:<);"1E€§3{§i.1.1.;_;:f thai;
ihey 3:};-1V@ given":>2f£'§:f 2{"§'j*~ii_5*?/E: of {E16 bL,1.i.11. up €:U'{i'£3; :"<if,£a.i:1iE":g 1"z:*.$'L;a:sf $326. ':3::.é1'{'f €43 £?.ii'€32i wiiilmgé. am}; E'~,2£iE€¥ EEE 3l3'<Jm.:3" <35 am}; V' €342-6:: €§Z'E<';j'§§,ECt1'§E}§:;§ f:,E1<3 i3'a?.::ée1' of this i.3..nd <;?:»<{:<3.p*: €x:T:§':21:1.§__§%;';§:§ this-:
A ' £:<§'z'.:;.--s:2.ti:":.1<§:':i<:§j§~_:§Iz"a:»;3: wifiiét: 'Eh:-3.m for 'ihfifi u.:'3{[E£\r§<i£ec:ii £m:£:=re.ss£ in ii}? §.2r:i.*:;i '¥3'<;%E§§--:':;.g§iz.::g.{<3 the: {mm-?z"$ G? aim ;>:~sj;>€:"%:y. §"E{',3':-*¢"€:'."".;-"€I°. the 5is».s:,§%:%§~;§:;;§ .}§;.:.§§%"::>z"'£E.y' h:':':ki E.h.;::€ ii: v§<:%w 01" 26545 % '§'}':.:ih. up 4:32: "«§?:}:"i"'E7ii'§_§:€:'F}E~if'?i:i:§':V <5'?
1§";;'r'é.L§:&§* Ezéigzivy "§.3'1.§§;i.v"5{:3EE§.§E"€f ?'3.55ya N3 aszxla E3:%§'n.;__§ E'1z-arxziiifi <22,»-*€:" is the <:}'2,>iaz':e:':3; as-E" 3.21%? Ezzmsfi zmd £22 £236 Eighi {>5 peiyniazli. GE.' V2:I'i<}:.:sfs ;7.1m'}1.::::'é,s 2:m1:}a::'1§':é:':;§ {.0 E%f.5§~',45 C3"<>r<:%:'~:-; zuid €)d€.§ to vaifimxs §:'§1,i.b"C()§'§'{.'§'€3.(fE%3'§'"E$z ii. «*»::'i'~;f..i:22§£fg:"§'1V§;C§"
32126 as; the gg<>0c§s~3 in ihe §;1*L:2;3{::°%.3£ haw: §);:$.::'e_;a%§¥'~--..:>::--._1%lu<éT1"i%2* {3wz"2<:3'5; 0? the '}é:;:§':d.
5. Agggrictved by {he saarifiig gt: <?21r:"i':§ -
E3ef{>r€< tbs: Jmni Co:":1:11issi.c3§ié:9:' offu CVi'£}';'31';';§:1t'?vI':'(Eiiéfi3?.V§§ T&§_X€S §'€:§E.e3*z3s.i.mg the gmurld '5<}§_;%. .UR<}1"ti<)nvV;>i' %he buiii. up arse: or L1:3Ci.i.xrigi¢d i11tc§;fQ§§s":L.i;1 v'?fi;:EV'V1b<:fT};;2--;f1;§' ownersé. The ;='ap§3eiEa%r;é"Z%:'1t'Ei;:;=r§t:y"?I1'm}.'€§i~.§;i*;21'a'T "EH63"'i.r21:1sactii.9r: in cgtxastiem {tarmac bf? tfcrmed:65:-a:111s:<C%'T'z:«.;?s"'3. $21.16 as: Ehezf is $01,221 absgznce @f1"e(:€i;:>t. {5'£'T_:1i0::€:§,r_0§f'.p':a2y£_a€11i. GE <.:01T:§3i.de=:r2:i.3;{):'1 Wh:i.(:§1 is Q?' pE2r2a:_:j§i<>i1ni: <:m;'1L€é:ié_{:raf?§:):1 {.0 arrive 31%. at {?<3m*J:L1£ai<}.n wh«=:%%E*;:»:r 2: §)€iET§{'iC"UI&%'.E'T' ::i2i;13._ssae:t%'§z3n wcmid 2~?r:'t:0Lz::'£1, is 322%: 0:' msi. "E-is av b:,2.i7;E, up E}f{'f3E1 ':"::%E.a:i.m3d by '§;hf;':
22;§g}€,§_§;::':i.~ w_2;i}'%; A1131. ézzé, afi ';.m'z'2ssfe:r§°s3,ci amté ii 0w':.'1.ed by' %';h:* ~a§§§3&§Z2i£:?;i,_ 3 :1z:{i 2:z;"3'§7;<%}.E21_.:';.'£. has; :'1::»£, z.::':€E&'::"£.z:k€:'n 31:23? {:0:1$f'.r1:2.e::'i.§.{>:1 22;-*m"E<_ by §"é'.$e§§" 'mm, hzamircégi {R-'€3i" f5¥_i{',§'}. w:>r§»';$ 3:10 513%~::<}:T;i.mcE.<>rs wha am :*eg§sm;'€{§ e:§eaEe::r$. 'E'E1:%:*a%Ef{>x?<;;: "£315? Appeiiate? s'§z.zé.h<}1'it.§«' v'ir*£,ua."§1y aC<:e:pi,s3d 21% the: <1c}:::,'te*n'§j:i<>f{};s1TL}? aw '£16 2;~1p}:seEE£-mi, by $3 swim' ci21E:€c§ 292088; _E:--§c_A4_'r<--:Zie§s1;_;_3aTi":"
sev€raE jL1{ig::11€:z:t 0.? 'aha Aperx €<:>u3f'L azzfzfi {ii'S;::§:9=;g§'L'1i:S3r§;<:€,§"figs case Eaw s-:4} fa}: 21-5; E}ha1rz1pu;i:Sug21:"'-Eviifl whigflfif, .:r--1?;;a:=§ z'£'.Iie飥. up::);': by the Ass.SeSs'i.ng; Aa1tE19rii.jy9}»
6. ezppellam: i§13 s.pi1:.e ._mor1i§.m:y bsézaefit after the order m'? the :;«qJgJe]i;1i;é"2;t;;:.E:z€:fi§§?','v,~ieikeifi befere thfi '§'ribun;1'£" V§§y'AT§f§'§i;;1§§ Sf:;"?1T1/-X31.0/'fZC'Q'€$" c0r1E.«::;3ding {hat 6:: "she 8JE€F§1E1i:i',f€f"§3}£3V£1.ff£ii;E1§§§E§,1'1'"1E3L%j['€. the appecilam in the gmundss of 21ppeaE; s;'u"a;r:*::iiV:€<i__ eiE;:iig§...~'§viih 'E,h<;% alppeeii p€t§"{.i(>n;, the first .§'§p§:e'§«?E2:€.<;:. A};'{E1{)E;i:i.§f....h£?;8 not :"€;c<>:'der:§ any i'in{§.mg;§ of ssuegth 'Ei,§.'5;i€;:',r~'-E12i§l§"*'»'-';€:'i~ f;j1€~.a:dér1_;_§s and t4he?e§"c>r€ he goaighiz fur i»;\ ' fi {§i::":S;'i€%e2:'a%¥;i§'}j:3 }:)f' saiiéh 21Eé€;'::;1i.ive péeziciizzgg made by fiha ap§>&liE:,;:§i'..§ ?'h@: 6: ':%.i.r€: ggr<}m':ds 9}' Z1:§}§,")€;'.21§ wm.:§<i e:mE§;' rafer €40 ,.fv.3£A'§t.%;%:":;12:°é.:ivs:% 1329213 mist'-*:{i by "EL§1€' z2.pp{:E§2::'1€4 ;1:.3.{£ ii? C§{3QE~E moi. 3', » K3; .
2,:
1'ew:raE iizé-.* «:;§€?ii£~1i§:«s <3'? Eheié ;1i"§.<:':"'1'1ai'ivt;% ;;';§ -222, E----f§<>wc\,.v::=t:f;"vE.§%£;:'i'}<j%{i {:e:>ur'1$eE for m: 21p§.3«:;%§§21x'3.i. §\.iI:°.I'<Za.m.2-zéh. bring»; E:'} '<::'s_.2:(Az3:'{'§§.'§<w:;§."Ei. * was an the §5:~sssu<;> of '§'.1.1I'I}{)V{';I' .'¥'1'71E%6iE? E}? 'aiie./Z.>:'X$é?<:?_SSE:'i§§ V 1":ni§§<3:"§£';_*y" basésed 01'} €:E'1a:t mi-11'§§€£. vaEi'.:,¢=, E§§;'. '§,E'mf ASS. fi;:.:§.h<}1f§£y' :;:E*:,€?;":'T:£1€'iv€ }3i€;'EiE-'% 'S.-?'1e:j::% :*a:'§~${t{£ . E>{:§k;:r"»;-}.'~»E.§'j;»:? i%Z:":'s.~:'%;w Ap;:1€:H.aE.s;a A'L1'2E'2{>:'§£.:,r whicl: aw-é1";L%:__i:i'<3,i'. 525:. an {ra2:'1s;§i(.Ee;5é?(§ by the .iE1'$t". 2-1ppeI.§21t.€ aL1i,E.1()r.é'a;.y",-- 'I'-E[g}w<;%\.?'[_<5é:f, 'v~::Ag{.:i'3»1'1'1iI:'.s; hi? wmzld bfi wi'1'hCi:'z:W'3Ing '§.h<é.:aaid 2i_'[}§'}€.E1}:§1C¥€3'vf€?1:"€?_"E.}§,{3v'_'?§.'§'.fi:2vi.i'i'§E11.
"X. SLflfiss:Cgl{1,63;:'11;f§%j,I_' §fE1{3. '..§:'€i~";2".?';,':§i('){'1£r}3.]i a.'L1{,}f:0ri'i.y Lmdel' Su{>1:1<:r£L:"15e'ar§é%:j§<)né£}j §:<3*{,%.:-+3z*:%'=,: i.ss:31T1'ééE:i' '21 s:=3E:1{>w ::au.s5€: }J1(}'{'i(f("3 {.0 {he _§i)E"€E-}€?I1:i'_ e1;_<?e1jc%}E2i1f1;i *3.1.'é;x1)'S--' fe\,?'é:é1'si11g the <'>pi:'§i<31'1 of the firs': élppfiflziffi£11.iT§:1{)fifl:£ V 2i%'1'»iCi""'»2iSKiI1§ 211:1 expiama£.i.c.};'; i.';"'(31;2'i: {he :1ppsj:Eiz>;.3114 as?-;s;«:2-=;5;Ve:'r:%' 'wK§; ighgiil. ;r:w:::'fl..§0'1'1 of iht'. %;:e:vz;?}E. up zuea ha{nci.€:CE."%(>Ve;-I E0 i.%1.é~W{§x>17r.:s3:":s C;:mn.<}'£: be '{:€3m1&%d 23:55 2?: {§€€£':'1e€§ ' E=E§% ;1§::é:~::3é*e§%?:°£:: L0 'She §3r:3p03"éim':z:E16: <:<}5::§ <3? '%')2.2i.§L LEE} 8;i."€8. '§.££'E<';E§§;'_§'§}EC;Z§,{EC'€T3LEE'}'§' €:§'1{: E.<}i"a§ caasé zirsf ihc": C:;>:é5£.z":1<;:§Em': §31.:": '::p""é?,%§,.-" :.§*3;~«:§é 2a§.§§3:?E12i:'11. €}z:::ée 2-'ag§a.:é:3. {.3-:.1e 2;1§:é;:)6rE§:a.ix'11. :'::?i'E:<?i'a'i<3£i hiss de:éf€::1i':ar:a %:hE:'E, €..§':€3::"é3. was}; :10 éT'§€i?IE"itiZ'§'§'. GE E§E1§€f in §.:"a;:':s:~:a:7E,§{)n. §3§*.'é.'w'€€:'1'1 Eiim and '€'.h.='-3: L-'c3;E"E{§ €)'¥E€.-'I1€f1"E§ ::%:><<":_§:§'§.E"
81.6 §}r{::je€:i' :3f<é0:1s£z'u<:1imt; <t<}§11pEei:ee:§ wiih 'i:§E=:::'~.F?1,;£fiI";_1:_ Sfifviszgbwi <_:<}mm=::i.<;1"s whn are :"eg§sE'<3::*e.c§ deaizztrss, 'rm V_(}iE3L€::'._ é:<Zjf{i'§?iT::§{ whai.:--.;<3€ver W'21E§ {§{>n@ 'my i..h..:é }}§€S€'I'"}'. '.§1§§p€EE£iE"i§i.'T}lfif?ff3§§1;'%§. que3s'£;i<}:é :2? any wirprks (?{)}f1'{'£'Ex{2f ' ~v..I;5x:~i::gV' :j§2:<:a:;:E:;::c%f"..:Vbja" "Ehe ap'p<:Ha'nt does not 'c1§'iS4.';" 213:1 so a_1:_-:_:§'»€;hmje E55 29.1.2} ;€ViV€a::::n§:~¢:,i saie 213; {.228 R€g§.is:3'ie.r€d céeaiflsé' Evha.' ciifi. 'i.h§-»,S11bw<:<>:1*m;1<::. 'W{)rE.§ must. haw: paid the ;*eSpe<:{,.iv€§ iém: zit" _.'é11f§€:v.ff:?}t§'.L'é1.¥1E, poim <2? 'tiI};1€. Howe»-*e1i. i_§7T..('3."E'€ViSi(}13a;[ a{§;:E.h§§rit'y._has¥§2b'E. zxccepfed the dfiffifiééfi ifE1iS¢d 15:9-"ih§3 ";1,;j;'3s=;§i'22..r1£.af11d based 01"; Ehf,' play; that éhésre me 55116 of <?:;.r;s*Ei :V"1,xg;:1i.i'<;-,.c_i'éi'rea?:. r<:E:21i:':ed by 'E'i':<:é bufiéer to any bL3§ys:~::_ Exésirj i..hé:"e. mus: be an £}§)'p{}'I"f1U1'1.§fl§J {,0 {ha 2%;S;:::;é:ss's§3i'a?=.<>% f§,}:mE£;f§' fc)ri..h 2:}? {ha bagiiss 0%" 3.<;:{:{>2,mE.s and <3'{.hs3:* eév-.§de@t:1<:€% v.,i'E<:;:'1t: ix:-%e~::Ed be, §E€C{3fSS£=21Z"}7 €10 E1§"§T'§V=i'3 at 552,103":
(7{}§'i{'§%-E§'¥i{}§E'§f}a§:;%d an {ha f'§<:%;'z:22.2 Z';£";£i§€£'§é1} $0 be §'"L:;*m?.sh.{:{§ E33;
" "~.__i.'£i':»&_'- 2:s§s»;<3.§=3;~.:g%;:: He is??? 09911 Eévy sf ps:'n22jiL.y 21:24:? §.I1i.e:°£:s3§. €19 ézézsa A*;1.§.E2{>3'iE.};' 213 the ;'%sss:;€3$S§:";g_§ ;mi'.§':a>'ri§:j§z Was; 8.§~3{§§€d ice :'€€><ar:r1in+.:= {£13. 12;'";21'i"i.~:*r and '£10 *::2.:ke 221§}pr{:;}3'£é.1i;z=% {§E?{T§S§€3!7i E';--t%_ _"§.hE:"_ £i§.§.h.:. of i'.§':€»:. <3'r3s~:,effv:-1f_.§0'z1s:; IE'£(::'Ldf3 €332 {he r::%v1'si<3n;":E E3,¥..1..'§.:~'L""l¢C}§"_'§A'_L.V§-"; 'T
8. E.'§u1'i11§§ the C€)LI§"S€ of $z§f:3tz1i.s's§{%1.*1.:; fiE"::i z;ppéEE3_n1. 11213 L"
_;_:a1'ed'L2{:eti capy sf" {hes <2xc:i':21r1g<:% {i :°«::gi$1':£:r*ed an 3842-2609 %3t3~é€'y's;-/*<:%:§3r';;._bihéhV"aisssvei;;_§:;rVV':~--§§£i':i" {he Eand <mn1e'rs5. .;'ikpp2:reI1i,1y ,af1d ghis-:-' <:1i§z:::,1r1ix$:"2i'. was zmi. the subj€3(:E 1E1ai'1e.1.' Of"SC;1:L:§§11yi'»b:}7nihéi' E3.'L1Eh(}E"iiiES referred to abavc-.' {3':__aEE desd macs?
hzwe some s1;bv;<'cqL1%:_n? i.t}p:fi_C):;[email protected]. ".i"f1eref01'e i'.1.he.I'e W213 120 C§'{§3HC'?é§5§iC}}T.}:f'§{:3F"iiiiiiifi é1;?g;§'eIi2:'n3;"'£.'c;'"place 1.he3§§-2: e:ior::ur:1€:;z?;,s beimfe 212133 0§ ::h<: a'L1~E:Er:;1~:i:i<ésT;.. V. Eiié has also given me; the iist <31' '{:f£'1€:: sub--<éGm:*a<:1ers Whig :«,rz:é Sa'i.a:E {C} have {fX€;'i£E{.'fl.€{§ v.21:*ious "'.§3&1i"E1€€_' 5<.Qf gigs: :§é3:1::~s.Tz.:f_:.L:,':;L<:>:1 and 2': {?0'I'E"1f;'.S to 23i.bOZ3§'. «¥R.__S;'.miEa1'Ey E26 ézsms givéiri the :§.eE:.ai§s,-1 0%' '£326 payK:1é:":§;?L'E. :;;:a:§;iTje. vazrimis Sub~<::m1E:§'z:<t§.<}:°s;D A§'E'.€r iths peréigai 'Qf E4§':t:'e.:1f:::je Eéseé W53 ::a'éé:* éhai. :§<3mz:* <33' aha wcwks ::<}:3€;..1'a{:f., ,wi€;%};"£;é;é§._§}.z':<3 $33; perz~sG.z"::5; W;'}{é weém Rafi. 1*€g_{§1*:=:'té3z*<3ci deaifirsa as; 11:} itjd :i§;21€' {t.:?;r1's,~r;: E105' bi: VV ' :*:?gis£42"ai':§e:>;': E"£'aEI7{§b{i'I§' furniahssd émsssé .:I§e:.g"::?}:<:;9 The firssi é§p§3e§§a£"e .:'mE.§;{:rEi:}s* }}1£1§§2§}' {I16 {if-3ci.&a'i<}:z in 1,h.e {.?e1s;e": €321" C131' '£8 Gexm-é:"21E S{,<,}:"€${P} EJ1'i{§., §'fi¥§){)}7i'€€§v-'if? "{7!&{--}6 7'§ '€,%:'hf;E§"i'.iE1 E': W;-33 E2635? fizaé if i'.§'}€: £252':$i€ief23.i',i<}:'.:' :§s:';'~:':<.>*-Li, i1?:_¥i>7;:?:«.§%:g2'._ bu': Sfiifiifi 0'€h€::° v21%u;a1bie {:c>.:} s:ideraé.:io:1 'qr ".:g§l5%V€7;I'1u£'Vii"1:.'£_2;€ 9? b::z.1'i.<5::_ 1';h<31": ii, was I301 $2 seam .Er3-:1.:é'<;rd g:.p011 'iT1:§'s.e-,pr§v1*:cip1e {he first Appefiaie AL:1.E"1{3rH:y"E:feJc§ i.--Ir;_a"iiV } 'kifxzy <3.:F_E'ax cam oniy be paid on lhérr zlciuzil £1iI}O'{.17f1fVOE- ;S:'i1'€'«§§'Z7i£"f€V-1"'€f3f§§'§.Y€:C§ or reircivable by ihié s{)Ij_i.ai;v UIjTd_€i'._ the Riff. azzd Us c:r0::1si,é£.ute 2:
t:*a:1sa&%:i,ie1f7. nf Vsei.§eV._s4i'171piéigrééar v:¥.€7 goods; fer {Em purpossz of the Am, {he é,i"é133.5emtEié';--:1 ':~5¥?:u1.1E"i;i'.._ha.*v€ all the i.:1gr€.ci31é:z":'€'.§;~: <2!) sale as SE}<3{3§':5i:Ef'£."f_ uI1§€§'._§§é€i'?;§{)1£§ 4 Of 1.h«;=: S2-lie of G<:u:)d5s ACE. E§3€} z1-:iEf:JZ:iE1 i:'"':i§'§::z:i{3§=; 22 §)§"i{?.€;', in mm1<~3~§; gazzid 91' p2"€_>m§:?-'e3:€;>,{E :§1L2f;:a.;a3§j,J e1g:*§'e{§" :.;.§:'-->;é §§5;.-*%.E:€ buyer aznd s_se§§<:z'. A<':e;:<:z'{ii.:':g;: ':0 {ha iirsii '1EL3'€z'§§,'§i.§;i§} ezmaig. in $.63 ;'3:"<3§><;=z'1Ly €392' ?3,55'§/2%:
A;};)'e::§E21E,§::'A:.:'i_}§f:.<§:*E":y éha %;"2%.n§2:C.é.i.0:2 i_nv»:":I've:'s :'ha';* :.'2..nC§e::*.z.'E.21k§z:g 31%;? EE§}.§.§i',§2iE?z§. ':mi§{§{:z° GI" :§€:v'<::'E<>§;e:° for :%;>g€.;.h2mg§e £2'? 2€3,§»5% m:::i:'.v:'<:§{:r{'; §;':%:.<;%:"'$..<si.
m=j§:'<§§:§, * }:;{;:e{2«rj:
, f§§91<}.%'.::§f;5,é ' §1'§E{§ V in the f:.a.z'1d aim-'~*:ss 3.10:" z1::1.:;>:,2_ mi 3:} szzkz '§'%3a?;:e=.i':}2*c% 21:3 sssaé. assiaiie §..¥:?2é3 Em»-jj§.; «of {.21}; on E,h<:é 21.<3ssz.:;1:1€:<.i '-.;'é3;.1LEi;? as; it, is EE§@;,:};.;V2£:." '.§:e :'z:év§e;ic;1';22§ a.ui:i'2ar'ii.y' has 110%"; at 3.11 §,_,_2;0:'1e i:*:'1,e:.> ibis;_g§é§pé;s<;:i.*-s';§_""£E3_¢%" _ 1'23;-Li E61' e'mc*'E if: ;.3r<><;.~€€:{.ie£i E2) (3%:-*{.§i€§€% iézs: .1"by"~.pEa:':i:f;g r€EE2m.<::=% 0:3 E'.}§"§2m':paz 1° Szzgaz' §,,:;2".§'1iLtc§ ;.3_n.<_:§_jv €3,531';1;1%:§.§é;'£V:§'g=:_:::V.:. 53%' 'f:'3.{:i€: TELX.3 UP,
9. Now" L1Ii:31maa.e1j;; {he E1LlVi1;iEi.f:;:%i.}; ::ii1":i:~<:%;@d the Asse$siz1g f'5sLl.T:.§"iOfi'E$';;E' 1:':C} ai" zAa;c:V<gv<>u:1E. and 0:-hes" may-gr:%.21i which xx;-f§)Vt_i:1<Ai_ L'€'(3(}3"C'E by the A.ssse%s;s¢::':€.A'"E;2[. §5i;f<fie';5":f:~:é; 2i:e:Qé.';i.2:£z1Wiréffiezt ex.a<:':'.§y the na1.:u.z"<:. af %.1'21:1s~;21C1;-_i_c:n éihai; V\[-f.?;"1":e '€::1_.'L.7c':¢':c§_. i1'11'0 ET}€iL\V€f&'.'E1 the §>a.rt1'£3s, by rirézze 95 aé::g:hva12';gC_ :§.§:(~:'c§..~'Vx>azhic:h came mtg existmzcze in «_ E}e<Vf':5§':}b:;:' $3309 5i'1;«w.r}.:.,;'.£€§ Ex->3 XEIEEEBTG ::§£:;-1:' far *éiE:1<*: ;1u1,E1:>r'iii@:a 'i7{v§ F§'%:3{;'fff'}€f:VC:.2£" {£3 '§?..1_1{)VJ 'Ji.?hr'3i',h€§" {he »:i<:s<:zm1&%:'zi sf erxcémnge.
a':m>':',--:.~':7ut::-7». '::;--%::1--y A?:'>:<:E12m§.,;s% 0? n;;:%f::m3: gjzzé, foréh by iiziz §€é3..E'E1€£f 'V «:%e:;E.,1;:2é.é:';3; Vf?Q:r" 'E.E1€ Z7:p§."}€§£i£'i? or E,é?1"'fi'ES§ {f>f€X{3E'§.£f1x1§§<% déisd zm1<};:.r1';. :~ea;'>~»." , " *.§t.§ 's;e;:?:'T:1€E.E"2§:1-5 eise w§.1:.c:%2 'ax,-*<}a:.¥L::§ z1'£'.i,m<:'::: '%i':::3 E22 J':*a3cii@m:s 93' Eff:
ES' Wéih 'i.h.<~:%s:;<-3 <:2E}s;se:°v3.t.§{>:':$ wag? <ii.s;:):3scé 0.5' "§:.h:'~% §")i"E%E-£1.11, apgyeraé E"€H§£:i.3'§E§%§'§§_§ %';:h::*. E'EiéTiE.E.€3K" €10 "iE"E€ ;k:ssse;sssi:.2§, 1*'-¥LE,":V'.--:?_1'( }'i'".§:.?:l},--'. .E_%t:>¥,.h {he péiruess am? at iébfifiy €10 raise aEE C:o:':'£:e::.%'i*c;z:s.;f;1£$=s§;€:Ev. 'E3€~:f'z'2:"€: us-3, '§'%";€t Asssessegingif A'1.m§':<)rii.'y 5§3§}£1i}; n_<.;%;_.._.§fj's::,p::tfSL:a&<3CE by 32:23,-* €}fi..E'1c% :3E>s;€::'v.21E.io:':s; made by 2.3%; 421;é,{§«'i'{.'1S§;:a§E.;*£:_§'23:j_'{.o' :5»u:1a:§ Shall *t:aE<:€-i inéo c:>13.s»3ide1"gsE'.ic}z: eiié {he {fir}§'.s::;?I,£ci:'2$é*.':.h22*£ Wouid be: §}uE':. farm §)s%i'0re ii, b§}"=$.h'e pe2:r'i.2;Es;_ H1; .:;_:2e3:g£.i01":. Ass £238 mafzer £53 not c<';;és,i;cic%1"<;>.::E' 0'.i:':L- ;1'1<§i=i'g'§; a11{;E 2is 2%: are :*ema2';di.11g the: n'1a1i,%;e;' back. ' é'd 5£4h.2%_[ 'f'~;S+$€::ssi:1g§ a:,:ih.0;"i1y qL1eS1é0r1 0£';1:2_3w"e_;'i:1g§ Eéfzfii q'u.;.;é--.Sf;.i'QfiSje;:.E v]a\>§? wmfid '1'"1»:"}f;: E--':E'iS£?. Q:'£§.e;.iez:i1 ;E.C(E0.f€fi.I1g.}y'§"- ,_ 3..
s%%f¥