Karnataka High Court
State Of Karnatak Athrough The C P I vs Muddappa on 18 June, 2012
Bench: K.Sreedhar Rao, B.S.Indrakala
fig
%"
:),<x.
, ,
«£2
,,, /,
fa
"*5z»"§E'z~
.¢_ 4 J.
V1.5',
I:
{RE §£{'}§.f%E¥E{3;?~§
1..
5:1 §:=;':';%= wzga Lg Qfigfgzifezaa §§§%g%,:§:E-A. :%:::'§¢ 5*: .
.532: {E 1%"
gm ._ {j:s<::':::
V. '"
éiféii 3: :"':{}§€§<:E,.,?§ '§'i,'E%3iS'E' R {E R;~':E'2/E§€.f':§, :5 §f}i;,{,'}§} §_,??<7€}.s'X ;f':s§:wa§=%:v':g%::%\I: :a;;:':«*;§<; 5&2 ':'§i%Zfi§{E%} (FCC: z'a{1sE%§{TUEf§U§€§S'? -
£35.; 7} §~35E?\;'1I¥£!':L '?{§ §}§ffG§§? i§E€*iE§:
E G;EE?If3;% ;"x:;':;::
g' ,,\ Y' » g, E': 5:5; ~= E .
{1} C C i ,5': {E RE {I {S ,.;:..
R W , W x -
. WW"! WM' WW vw-ww 5' N/[:3 W W Sgamsga 3i§--:%m:>m :3 ;'KF:/:zE'%"§iE.>§> :':€i}i?i: 'izéizxzzc a:>:::<:
":"."><_ .» /2 "< / '7 z"25:.)f§;;.
- "v';=z--:T%E:>..s% " __ §}:f::zz.EV§%:a%;-::;:V ?€_;i':}'}'%§i 9}, 3 ,3 V E £:{i}i?2: 535-3 E" £2333;
{f3{§€': Ski; E~E;E{f: if Ef§i,§ iii?
{i§*§;':f'2é §'2§;K%'?§': ' zfigté: 22':
fifié .:*7':?x¢'i5'¥§§'££§;3§';"x E} §i'\fE%I§€:T&'§?:?aTVE Z\l§%':i!'--"é§fA£~-.
3&9 EC: 22 ':''§i;'';?€E3 {} CC: 1E€}§€:*C 25 EIEEE E«Z§S'§ §~i,2"€.} §~2fk?25EE"Ez':E 'ii; §}§§*§}§f} i§E%i E€§f;:'S§'§ SE/J§%Ei"{:'a fzgjiaé: :28 85%} SE*EEVL»'7':E3?;?:
213:} ii: 28 ':"E§f:E~Eii' ilééiii: z"'1.{L§E{%CfiE§j§'E,E§?li§E4}'E' V . §7*%;'{"é EV%:zEE¥«'1?i'~};éi.V E}EZ{}Ef3'%;£ a.
gakmagf, ,: 38 5 §E£§R@éE§§AiA§.
fijgéi: 4%;
5 {E EE§;E.;E§.§,..«'£,Jl;:ia,§'}g}i[% fa .233: 45 'z' "€1;X§#?.Sr3 QC C: Xvi; E93 C i'§'E§ §¥\3é,€s'§' E4-Z55} i'1'{z":§'§§l\'z'g§; 'E.'{;% §}§SOEf}§,§§}{}fi : s E} §?Zi§§§§'%?':s'E;"§?£§ N;':E'}%§{ §';%;2E§;*:%l":L§'%V;VV J ».
;":;,:a*: «ééiié ;"{Té E§ig'a§,J:§V>%Vi<": E} 39217 §lfiZ§?;:€§s*:?%§E f"=£fa?'z"§< fifiéi: iii} YEiZf'£€~i£ GCCE: !'a{}§€f:Ci.}L'E'§ERiifi' ._ %{,f{} §~?;.z":E\:EE'*§[X§,, "El; EEEZGEE éjiéiififi E3} Rig ?§'}:% 2/§:f.3;€;?Z V " ._ T :~3;;si> ":*§:N:i£;:?a:§s.;a :>>:xx:z$i:é: V fs.{}§§Z :25 '%:"E£z'%§%"iE~} - 956:: f:G§€%{Zi_I'? 1 Egg? .'E§w73:i, W _
7. ' 5 V <:;,G:ge:.:,:"' - ....
, E, IV , 'E'§"E £8 E'? {T} 3%? E93 LE1 esz:,';::;: {E§£éEF«€'§' 'lE'{:: 2% £521 :%:;:.;a ::2<:es:;xs1 E 3:35 §>5KSf§§:§i} :32? :'%§;%§}i"
5* £223 {J1 {>22 §{'}i" iémfzé :.I§€;f?§§"s,/'€;?E":'Ti{T1£ §'<>E%:3v=«;§:':: ' ;;a"
I?
y \ r J') WM /M' IWWWIK c U WWW' VMWK t. "2 Wm M w vm PM-4 W 4 M p./|""
«M WW ' YWWK WW' M. % M /"''"m » .../ » «W "3 SEES €$f~E§%aE§N'§' 'fizz? :}g::ia::'§;::§ °§2>e:::éV:s V " E 02: §'b1§£i2iiZ>{E3 ;:1:~::i:;::;'2§E 2.9?) 9:723" €;?é=:§ é;ji;:i):*:1gt3§zéégizzézfzi:r 4 »E5'2%5'§' zzzéié ;'<::E2:§'¢§vr::a; pwzz, éaigéé Pififi/§,, ."'%?E'i??§ 5'. "?:a: :6 *#s{::;:2_se {::;;zz:¢:{%' :§E'£'§'}é;E{i ii/"iEf§":
::*a%;'<% s+;<;wi22§f:j iééaé Eazfizsé 'E"E1:/;?:"';;§.<:s.::: z::~.;:%'{§ 7::
{fiéiéiifijé 2ar€32:z;3(;:'::s Eéiw L'V::é1':5§ _9<j%§§a:iéf:i:<3§: :--.;{,::wi:3 < 4:: §":{:s+;;:§:'i%,2;2§. Ejgezgiz Eiriéfifj' §':i"é:'z 3; '§J}::'i we: %;?:;,2 2: {E 2'a«;<?: 'f§;'1<,%:*%%;§<i<%:':s:V V§E""2« J a,'"'v"§{§i,T'§'E{fif? <2? 5' "
'NJ ::_E:2;%<E ikézéz ' ?gE<f::":<f:%a*% :13? §:%'x«*' 2 ;:§ <i;§*§s;<1?§<'}é;s;'::+: $32212 §,V§:a% :;i:<%<LtzVV:s:i~;§=<:V§ 2:
zggzxi E39: :~;:H:s1+';':V;;2é:2 sesémgfimfi r§::*;;T:_s.:*:?<>$:
x §L£'E%LTf§frEf%i'355 i"E?_7:iEEi"?(f,;§ in éizaft é'§*:'*3.;~:% "
5; '§E::;% §,z:::Ec;:}:%:V1d<::nz 135% C ~:'1;;::~:c :%:'2:'i§;? «:>§_ i ::~::? "
372:3: {;Z?}{2lii"§'i§%'§,{?{E, '?E:;a*t% <:Ei:%;<V:§,<V:s:-,;=:? 13%;: §}£:E§'§i{'T§,§>2,':%§<'}§E 21:25? <:>v<%r':1 v""h E? )"':£'.:%, $5; an{% 5': '§'§1e;é:"{% aim: :53, n 'f ..3j;:'&:":s_a?;4 ::iE':{;%:' 2i€[ti'7Eé§}%§§;",'€§ §§é::'3<§":::e2 ::;22:I;:€;: M :ji:"{Esr:§ :3 as:
V . ;::Ng:::~{:e:i 'E. 3» % Evfifififi §@5$€$3Rn:;zmd &uEfivai§2g;%K3E3fi§i'¥ @§tfi@ ascugcfi Qgéhtfi"
§fifQ{§$% éééaz <xe:::;£::§:u1zz§?
»Ev§a:Ea&;' §¢5§3QE@a%w€5 >a;a::*: {fé}§EEéiS% is: 332::
wnxiu9%x Eh: QHQSKGB Q?
3&3 cezw ia@e£ iééif«.§':'E£1£E.,iEE:"§2i§E% zimzié Eéztsssé 22%;; e.;%;2§.:2é:3e::<:E :E::2:;;% §::_§a2§"§{&s:«; 3:2 Eéis :2::E:~;a §;,E:;*:%, s;%2z5e'«;:€r ifs? aw:<:>:::"1é::%:€ Ea, w<:s:f:{§ 82:';€€?§§{I§§"'§€f?&§,¥?£ <:%s:;*a;:E::§*;ia§': 3:93 5: §}§"i';7?'§'§'1{"',€,¥§§,§§,i?{§ ::*3:.--.'§§E§€'ii,,§?_,. '§,'§'E€':1"if*;'/§V*{)E'{'7"=, *:E§::> .::<:{::::s§;*s;§ aim %i;'{%:§s:% ii; %::>g% <:@:V:2»€§7V%Vv:%<;§ §'{'[,I:%".E" "§§"1£'T'/ a>§é%;%::(:s::s; Efififii %,vhi<:§: 222%}? 'marge <:E':;1:"§:%éi, 3:": éh{3:*<;z:§,§':V: C{}§EE§§{§€§fE"£i§§{f}£'"§ 2:}? i§'E{:? {?"'=.7i%i'§é?E;"i{Ti€;f §<}i§{>:»*%:§,;§;" {'§f(?£iZEE$§EE;Ei1{7€S :ai{2:1%:§ :?§i:1<ii§3é:;gi;r i} '7éE1€§£3 2 721:8 §21EE€§ r:%§se;§':,1§;:':% ?::%é:*%A,r sezséz W215; $37136: fer i;:>2V2:"%;;é §[i<>13 2i:::=::§ it " 't§<%<'::"{>a%{'E .é:'€* E72; "<;§éL:.;:* ::::§ ';E'2<;% 2;:<é<j:z::%e;<%<%. £2: {E245 :;%v§{f%e:é;,';<it<: *2? $5 '.s&1:é:"::Ef:L':.é;*%>:i':' 33312:; 'éE;f:<=% z;:<;:<%{:5%» {E wag/::"{% in 3:22;:/ess-;s%$s=;§<3;2 {sf {E28 §.22.1::<;§ zmd $73535; weilrzfaé {ij::§'i€:»';:;.:¢f' " f%é,;':§'1"E€:?, <%<<iE 2;: §3::»;.?2{} z;i"z:;:z:¢ £31} £2 335i} <i:2::s9::';;*a€7 $s;>:,,1:3%,{r:' 1:ifi?siE'§?:g}E.é£i§EE.§T'-{:3 9533232 2316 é%€f:CE3f:3€§. 7:3§«'%fE zzmié ::»éE";er:s {TZ:';1:":3€ 4 ' ;'1§é'si§ f:'}7%3;§; Si? 6? iii: ééévzi: %;é{';:'L éE":;4:i[ v:':"::;%:: éi3:;% ;z<:%::z.:s~:§%zi ggssg *='9*:':;%<:_§; :' 35> '£329 E2i::%s:iZ% 253525;? i;%:>:é;:%éiéé%a*§% .§§{}§"§ §:>{:%§za?a;:<;i%:V: é gT:s;;'::*::Zs::~a 22:}. 5&3. ::12{:§V*'£;--:E' f3"%,f£E§€§?if§E'":€3{":§ '?%z;::: §J3:"i}E:§€%{?éEEé<§E/E as .:-sé/1é.31,:¥:§ §;?:";é:: §£§A':::E :'z:%'g;}<::"%;; w§:i§7?; w:;;':.;§<§ §::;::z'i§€.;<i_e;_A . "'§'§'1:% \Wf'WW?l\%4m\!/t»\Wanv»(/-vv\mu..
M \..u pm WW4 ,.m M pwnl " £2"; :E;2:> {:23 %;§;2s:% {}§§€;?2'Ei'i{if? zzazéaé 31$ ':9 ¥.'v'?E<f} Es; :"E':<f:
{A §°f:?t§§Ei?{,3:i%:'i£€% aimeii §E":é:%§r Eézésevaé <;€3%,;?s§:'-a:é«:%; {ii §,}2:Té:"§f§Eiifééé, 11; ii; 2?:{:i:V:V:§'éi;;:?<:§ éfilzztii i[E1<:% 2a1>:;7<::.1:-:s;%::f§ W'€3§'{j <%2:2§%E%i2;2§ _L:f'1€;% §2;::;3<§ '€326 E':§"éi}S;€f{i7E.Ti§i{}§'1 hzézs :20: f21eZf'§.}Zé;:%s;?;V28:3}§:;;%2é%:;:; g§*?§1i'%S§f%3 05 'iE:é= §sm:s:3<:::é§<;>:3 r:7':':s5;<;% {E/15%: :.:€;>:":;*:::: {>iE:£:%:";~;
.\ 'E <:22.z:':sé 255%: s:i;€a{§,'i_'§.; E7V€E§.;?GQ$ éA;:>.._<:§:gg;Vé;%<;:'a; 2.' V ::~":é{s;2. $3235 E': L;
"V:%;:'§'ér§ acgzéiié namyaé :;ha:V _'§§"{}i§§€§§1;_%7;é%,i'§V §3€€:§:E"CX(f"E'E€i,§1§§E§ <25 w<>:*{issa 91" 'i'h£--: f:E,{?€.?§,E_E§é€?{E j;:2€r:~5<}:':s;e 5:z;;%:"=g/*6 €§g:§¥:22u::~:§'f:€;s:§__:E":.€ <;§:::--E;é aiéié '€3J'€:?§'€ iii §;§<};%;3s:ss£:<;:é <24? igézss , in«.%;§:.:%"~--:%:;L::"s§€: 2:sss;e;a::_,:Eé,$ ééésrt :;E$<§:a:%2:s>{e::::': --E%:~2s:f;::§2;:
2:.:§~;é:f:":.,éE:%éi%;QT*E.§f::é2>;7§s€ 331:-f: §}':?%f E ?"%fif 'ii?'{':§'€f §'§éE3J%:i i:::§u:'"*;s%s+;:.; E3 35; :V":V§,;E¢:%:::E. 5 EC? $2"; '$23 s3:s'§:i'§:€:"::.:a F' 5:} 27:at:::;i%:,::~:.%:%:;§_ ::"::§§:£:;:2,>£:;>§:% %;E1e:':
aumlwa F} ii"; zflsi} in EEK, €:V*i:£€::{%€ iEL:1%.; :;:<:t{:usc:~i:§ %':2f:s:§ f.%':*.{Tf{);;':v'{':%;V{:~.ii} gééaréé "
mxmmmmmmm E " ._;:Eé:%::%$;?:f:§€ai" %i:2:;§::f:s:::':; "$6 %;A'::;:/Ea: %;;E:%3§: 32:3 :::::':i:j§. :/326%};
§2::§a;::% §ETi§_}§§€i'.:3;'2'§i{f}2"1 ;;:1::E a%,:2:; 7 :[:h;:;<2 :'§":<>w" 'iifiaé §;,§'i§'E{§€EE'Eii}*' 65% :9? §g:1i1§V <3? éizst 2:<:<::25ses:i <32 '$16 342222": :3? iéxa C::_>:::$121::":::.::"é§}" ' I O:/1 §3:"€;;2:2(E 2*',':IE€£}}7E?33i& Wéi filnaii am; 2,:€":<?;:;: .%;:E:%§%" :21;,%;::§~:§3':%{§Z'*V« 'J%5§'?§"€{/E in ;:sé::%;:?a=:t<%f'::§ §>@ss€.%si<'}2: a:';{:§ {:23E':/iv:::,:V%s:2§;; oi" a;i1*:.:;é'~ :.%3%":£%:V§ ziéiasir pasaseggien Wzzseg é;E:3:%21V§.s::":%3{.*»g E5312' EEK'?
2%"
:'%:»@::3;.d EEG? héfiffif €:x:§:'c§s6<;§ :~:;?:*:Ef{§§§é--:3<:€ ii} }'f2E'{>§{%<T1':, iéké? gsssgsiegiczn as? 3§,}:€:;1§€;:3{§ ?;b;€:,;::>z31;g3E;::§:V':zgzm 2.::2gE ::>iE'zs::':\; 5:33 b€é§§g€:"€:1'a§;;t 2}; ?;;€:; 'i./'§'?}$i:§_§'§' E1E.{§'Ii';E€f :5 {Eé5;~;g;c:es:+;i%s;i=; {E/::2zz';. E2 a;":Ea%;i::' fifiaéz 7i,h_é?.é?'i}'3i'a;$§i%7{}€3€' {>411 §'Efi.i';';z:2:*<;§, :EA127:':; §}§?x;'% gmsgi G:/§':€::":~,+; .:;2:'a::% é22f:::2::i%iiE ééésé §*'E§%i g:§;€é3%:,:5s::s€§"« «.;}€i"S{§§'fE:§ 'i;EE'}€ii€'§" aiizzé; s::s§ :§>E%'E ' 2 Efiagszrisgra aim "i;Z%::%§:": §E'E{'f£§,,E{§{§E":f,§: :22: %,,§":§:% £%.::{::';:*ci:i:§g§§: 3316 gzgépezzi £55 eéismzigsszi §;:;:*':3é;:sziaigiiiééfiésg '£3363 ;22.z:i%<:2::s:?ai'§. 33:? a'-é:3§i,%;k>::i §;«:§:» %::%;<i;§«:£:>% '§L:€'3;€;i? §.f}€fE/'§€§'§W§§,, §:>§ §3%;'f;a?;2%;€ {i,e§€:2<::s:; "SE26 :"<3;1${m.3 giarsn E33; :§":a% ésigéé §:{);g,t::té_ "£22"
::§%<gzi:i£;:§::g :E':§:=: E}?/{'?i,§§§{5€:§ 2123; 31:3'? §"3i% §2.:53§,§i§é;cé:::% E331':4
i"%;,':?'i.i%.£€,.1é'§i1fE%S Siaéiééi Egg! :23. ':f?::% E:(ZC§iEfi%'i,23.§ 35) .:3~e:'% V' 4 E §'§ mwm»emwmmwmmmWm.'_.