Karnataka High Court
Sri Shantilal R Jain S/O vs State Of Karnataka on 5 February, 2009
Author: N.K.Patil
Bench: N.K.Patil
2-5 H33 §§§G3,1CQUR'§' C}? K..i'*..§-?.E'~5.?C€'.§'~..§<,'.;~"-L SET BA§='~3{:§A§.'€}Ex'£.7£ '§:"\§'.';'-Earn ::sf 2%}?
-g_ :94 ms 3:954 swat as KARHA mm A r BANGALORE §.?sTEB T3533 THE 3TH DAY 3? FE8Ri¥x'iRY, 33Q9 sasms ?'HEHGH'3£.E£§R.JU37iCEN.X,PAT§£. k w.?.:a§a. gem rt}-F meg i:%P*M€3':--- ,. :
9 E"?'e;"é' *5}. £3 3*} 1 $Ri3§~%A%'-$T§LAi.%J5%%%:' _ _ ,_ , §'~"RQ%'~'RiE"€'i}f«'i QF sax; ma;-aw: ,S%*v',i'¢-;{,?é§.AL'-- A sexiagaae ._ 52:3 Ab%$ECé~%ATTRA RGAS. ' , . _ {;%§%KA?éAi3&iL%R :::%_m1< ' - ' ' _~ PE'§%"f2G%~£ER €52; 31: as 2: as a.a:;4s%;%»;g é:3e=;%:;;{i:a*;<%;:2._ _ ' :22» ET {:35 'E 3"miE car x;A:::e:g';a;<.a»T. 2.59 as: 35:3 55£§aE?z§9:~;*"--~ ~ SE%1'AR'§*%%?éf€? :3? AG;"e::::»£.,;:_**:f.:,é:z3E iazsmggxm $@z;'e:~:£; .sa.A:s.a3EemR $5539:
a;:.~v:e3;meRa 9:»; ~ _ ;%€§RiS;§LT%.§§3--'é£'§%§i3SL$QE ?s€AR§<.ET£?é€: QQ%'¢2E'v':3.'%'TEE « _ 2;? 3%: ;":fss§c9EIAR~:
' "::~s:s~:.ség:y~;za;s;%V;.a:g gems': :2 " ?i'f::«E "z';~:é:2z:":*:'..%2.!:z' '#3:: AGR %CL.2J%'iiR5a§. fie'2i%RKE"§'%f'éG 7 me, aA3'a.s%¢-:AvA¢4 ROAD *?,_,3..#;.s--;::
e,za;«:e;§;weaE ssms .. RESPQE {3£2'~§TS .. ;;i$%;i;'; 53%;; 22%. Kvmaaagsaazzmzm HCSP ma 2-: A543 2
- 32:. ans. "£H::aM2:.;a*.a:3.a Aw. FQR M; Ti»-HS $13?' 253 FELEEE §.}%a§SER: AR1'E£li.E3 22$ AMQ 22? G? "§'§~§E ;C$?<£€»T§?%}T3Qa;%' 23:? 3942345.} §a;m::g ":9 Q%..,%A$%% we QRQER 95:39:53 as'; THE 2533 RE.SPG%%§EE§T $3 23'! 32%'? £95'? C}? W £533 ?R'{}§iJC€+IQ A3 ZEE {ESE C{'}Ef£3J§' R'? é'~;§.€}EE %'?{} ayf 5.3% "$12"; Z§§i.}?1E€I*-7.}'i}¥f.'§' E}? EiAR_'.'€§x'§;3.E.é1 XE E%?x§*€§AL£}§£' 'éZ._?3;'~§$. 25% Cf '.l§{}'§ Q n 5...
sahmifieé ihat, fafiawéfig {fie saifi aréer, ihe insiant writ pefifiarz flied by miétiofier ¥'§"§§§i 3396 be éispmefi af.
3. $319 $i.1bm%s$%fifi made fiy iearnea' ..;*:s3j§;§:fi_f.sa5i;% "' appesarérsg far befh 3:8 parties, as stsieé 3§§3%£f'§',A4_:'i:$V 3 V' K en féééffi.
:3. in fise Eight (3% the $ub'm.%;ws%&§%A-vrfiafie ééunseé appearing fer '§ _oth 3'§$;;§2}'£fi¢{:§AVvvé§1.:p;'a, $2 i:r°2$tar2% wrii gefiiien $3 cfispesed oz: fofiovvéng %hg_;'3z"s:_ier dated 2"
Féhmary zaaaf%%%.s;~;%Lj%%§;%g;.mg§s;.2a%?? tgfiéssaizaas (ms Shiasa T?.s«:i'§?:1§fi€;6?¥¥;:%::3n§*. 3s%§ fitimfs Vs. Gevemmerzt :3? Ka§*i9§i€rté5§a; fly Beparfiriafit 33' ' fis§?§fiu§ti3?e 'Léifigi' :3t§1é%*§"' Std far the feasafis sicsfed %%%ere§'r{' éfiéfiéééwsi """
writ gryeiéiéara flied by péiftianer is é'%'$6weé A. x The impugned srdar dafed Eggg " "'V.:%'%3a'f2}er3*sb&r 2639 fiearirag an 3<m:'u"L%: ERA: SA:
,___",,_....._.,_........-..»-=---
"§T§'£ §2§i}?i§ {f€}§fR"£' 53°32" §';§&g:'<:;'§?4'§'s.§:.;'a ..é1;'§"§;"§;5;§§=:}£s§Q,{Z?§§i'"g; '§§,§'E-Ea}. Z.Zz'f','€} 23f 2€}i}'§ ..Ben§:'h'-------3--f" finis scum; fiatad 19*'? fiafifiéé in writ ixpmm gfiagriéiséfisrai Pmdsme %%3r%zet Eersémittw arifi b%%3.é§~rs}.
EYE £2351 €;%'}'La«..'§" A'? "v'=€'..?\}*3é3g 2&2} 5f 2%? 5 mi...
CHi:'i338:2'§fi8--89 passecf by ihe 2% respcmdenf véée f§\§"§i"?&){i}¥'@~:3g Er; sen far 33 ihe pe€%?ior%e';fW_§_;«f§'V: ':' ' I' $(')¥""¥€;éf"§'"t8d, is hereby set ssifieu V' ajéii) Mafia'? $'£'3i'°'I§S geccfid respzmdergt fer :f€.«z";§f3$V§fie_% sifés:3 mafia" afrgsh and take after affarfiimg reassfiégébéet fiea§Fé%§g is the gatéticfirzf ii:
stréci 133%. §§i§:vi*s%m?3s sf ;'~'~.?%:'§S.. §¥'i view {ha wefi §er:se§:ags;%%%A by this am: ma Am: é;'3$L:%::*:;tj; '§§'i:.'%¥£§d:§é1_§"'i§e awe: psssw by firié .$'&é*=af':;'i6f¥§a?駧;§' (F€.'s§'.S&ma§h&i:har vs. 313% A /,_,,,W...~...,.......~ I}? T?£:. EEEQEE C 53331? }i§§R?€AT.;fi':§;'3'~. AT 3J~'£-iii} .-<"~.L2':'Z?2'>L; 'xii atsf €§§£fisf?u¢€%§fi ffifihwiffi fififi car:*:§ie%e ihé " n A7s'fi.i*'r':é; 'é"S._駧§ 駧?§§fiS§¥ as Qasséfiie, 3% any mfg, fiermissisn granfeé fiy fhae jurégéésiésarm "$3,-
HE Hfiifiii £?<l'-E33? *5}? J' 5%, A'? §3~£?'s._!\§% °'»¥f&}§e:e. '2{:§ : 5; a; 5%..
«~13 ;'l£i3:}'9 {hr} The pefitiener éfi gérmfieé $3 §§§3%§c3%§6:"s séei-firsg sarmféefi {if fiw 3%;-at': ;v-... ': ' up céasfirucfiart a$ par §"ié ie:'n';$..,:s;}d t:§«;:?it3"%"§.§%€;~;%§:: ' sf flue 3%%fi€men'é mfére '$19 c::vz":%?3;§e%;é;r'fi séafig wiih 'Ehe requisiie §£"0¥';': ifié éate 9? re;£:e==i-5%? Lg? t'%¥s' "a:*:?7£*é:° Qfifi ifie som;3eie:'§ ta feaeéve ??'i&;~S3 §'f§6 aésfzd gp§'ss«é;§§r::p{%§%e arfiers fer sarscfi-r:;ni.§_§§3.V fif.i':'s€ 3§3'§§§i'§ ' %i*:?*z.§n駧é%e%y. {*5?i;:s%t%7$§9w,.V§§afééE§:§fierfierein is éérevzteé is $3 3{%'s.,_ 4'La2'3éeri§*§{ifi§#€:;£r.%l-affidfivii éefare ifie $e;:;és"::% %esp[¢naa;:~: is the efiecif that ha wéié w:i%h;§s*£ .3%£ 'flute: §§§'¥'§§'§ Q? nine "year frerfi 'Ehe date 62' campatefif aufhawéiy, faéiifig which; ii is enter: is E35 EEESQE C'€}§f§3SE' 5}?' AT I}$m.'§€§$L=:3§§i ?'.§'.?{3 af 2€}'=3'} .' ':§:,€?z;¢§s;§":3%f: ._"s'r: acasrésrzae wéih Em»: and is: ~. {c{£:2£*:*:p:%'§;é*;§%':;::a'~T§43§"' .i§§e e%§reai%<:;2s"'ss E$saefi by this Cezufit .;5L"§3:fi#5i3i ?'#$.'§618i2§$? (§é.%i.i-Tamnasheithar Vs. ET}: Eflilfi *lZ'f.f}§§E3t'.1' GE' A §',%'~Eif-,%L€};'{§i '-is?" 2éS',?{§ af 3%'? 4;-
the auiharétées 'EC: take f3§;'.')§"€i')§i'"§§?& §€fiiS§fi£"L accaréarsce wfih iaw. b {vi} 'F%':e secereé ra§§t:2r2c%fi:*r£._'e_$ mceéve the same and pisce sum-affidévéi §§Vefi by 'i3fi§:§*-;%§é%<E€ia;'§.é:'V._.aia:i<»:3_: the request befsré ;£%*sg"?2:€2'§§(é"i:*.C}:'§éf%*;$§fiaé ésfé maeténg and gram aréi:V " 9 é'§rect%ar*: %::f3 «vtéagééfifiziate the 3:
t:r3i*'1s'£:'t.i~:':'i.%¢:':;:_4_"':;--:1.s:3'é::§é§v§§%v¢'zss;3yV'=§3é gasfiaifig 3: any: r3ie,_'TA§€vé'£f?3i;§VA3V3 ;7 ér%9d_ c;=% arse year. F3§¥§fi§ which," .,%_f' is §':eé'ci{§a::;=_;§--.. (:;%2r%fj:; ihaf seaorsd ggfsfpéndefif é:";€é-'fled ié fake apprasfiréaié :i$'$:s=.,«fi""v.«V1'9'§§ Deeemaeer 2833' passed in Writ §'3'§2e Agrimsétiszai Pm fifiarizaet Cammifiéa '§'§E EEESEE Ci}{3R'§ €337 %';?u'iE€;'*~."§°;%§ié'& A? g'*.L£}§7iE 13.?-'I£~",E-'wigs, 255%} :35 ?§:}'3