Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 2, Cited by 0]

Punjab-Haryana High Court

Hsiidc vs Jagdish Chand Gupta And Ors on 17 December, 2021

Author: Anil Kshetarpal

Bench: Anil Kshetarpal

       IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
                      CHANDIGARH
207+208+216+227
                                     1. RFA-1062-2020(O&M)
                                      Date of Order: 17.12.2021

HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                                  ..Appellant
                                      Versus
RANDHIR SINGH AND ORS
                                                           ..Respondents
                                                 2. RFA-1074-2020(O&M)

HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                               ..Appellant
                         Versus
SATBIR SINGH (DECEASED) THROUGH HIS LRs AND ORS.

                                                           ..Respondents
                                                 3. RFA-1101-2020(O&M)

HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                                  ..Appellant
                                      Versus
GUGAN AND ORS.
                                                               ..Respondents
                                                        4. RFA-3-2021(O&M)

HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                                  ..Appellant
                                      Versus
VIKASH AND ORS.
                                            ..Respondents
                                  5. RFA-1116-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                               ..Appellant
                        Versus
SMT. PREM KAUR AND ORS.
                                            ..Respondents



                             1 of 6
          ::: Downloaded on - 16-01-2022 00:33:49 :::
 RFA-1062-2020(O&M) and                                  -2-
other connected cases.
                                  6. RFA-1118-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                        Versus
POOJA AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                  7. RFA-1121-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                        Versus
SMT. KAMLA AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                  8. RFA-1122-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                        Versus
JAGDISH CHAND GUPTA AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                  9. RFA-1123-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                        Versus
SMT. NEELAM AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                 10. RFA-1124-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                        Versus
SMT. REKHA AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                 11. RFA-1125-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                        Versus
TARUN KUMAR AND ORS.                        ..Respondents

                             2 of 6
          ::: Downloaded on - 16-01-2022 00:33:49 :::
 RFA-1062-2020(O&M) and                                  -3-
other connected cases.
                                 12. RFA-1126-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                         Versus
BALKISHAN AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                 13. RFA-1128-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                         Versus
TARUN AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                 14. RFA-1129-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                         Versus
SMT. POONAM AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                 15. RFA-1131-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                         Versus
SMT. RUCHI JAIN AND ORS.                    ..Respondents
                                 16. RFA-1139-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                                ..Appellant
                         Versus
NEERAJ KUMAR AND ORS.                       ..Respondents

                                 17. RFA-1141-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                               ..Appellant
                        Versus
BALKISHAN AND ORS.
                                            ..Respondents
                             3 of 6
          ::: Downloaded on - 16-01-2022 00:33:49 :::
 RFA-1062-2020(O&M) and                                          -4-
other connected cases.

                                 18. RFA-1142-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                               ..Appellant
                        Versus
KIRAN AGGARWAL AND ORS.
                                            ..Respondents
                                 19. RFA-1143-2020(O&M)
HARYANA STATE INDUSTRIAL AND INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION LIMITED, SECTOR 6
PANCHKULA (HSIIDC) THROUGH AGM
                                               ..Appellant
                        Versus
SMT. KAMLA AND ORS.
                                            ..Respondents
                                 20. RFA-2177-2021(O&M)

BALBIR
                                                             ..Appellant
                       Versus
STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
                                                          ..Respondents
                                               21. RFA-2178-2021(O&M)

AJIT KAUR W/O LATE SH. OM PARKASH THROUGH HER LRS
AND ORS.
                                               ..Appellants
                          Versus
STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
                                             ..Respondents
                                  22. RFA-2474-2021(O&M)

SURAJMAL DECEASED THROUGH HIS LRS AND ANR.
                                                            ..Appellants
                       Versus
STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
                                                           ..Respondents

                                               23. RFA-2648-2021(O&M)
KAMLESH
                                                             ..Appellant
                       Versus
STATE OF HARYANA AND ORS.
                                                           ..Respondents



                             4 of 6
          ::: Downloaded on - 16-01-2022 00:33:49 :::
 RFA-1062-2020(O&M) and                                               -5-
other connected cases.

CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL

Present:    Mr. Pritam Singh Saini, Advocate
            for the HSIIDC.

            Mr. Navneet Singh, Advocate
            for the appellant.

            Mr. Shivendra Swaroop, AAG, Haryana and
            Ms. Vibha Tewari, AAG, Haryana.

ANIL KSHETARPAL, J(Oral)

The hearing of the case was held through video conferencing on account of restricted functioning of the Courts.

The learned counsel representing the Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Limited, has pointed out that the lead case arising from same notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, has already been decided in RFA-1059-2020, titled as "Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Limited Vs. Sandeep and others", decided on 06.10.2021. These appeals have been listed with the office report that the service of notice on some of the respondents is not complete.

Normally, once the lead case is decided and there is no enhancement, the landowners do not contest the petitions and such appeals remain pending with the Registry.

Keeping in view the aforesaid facts, these appeals are disposed of in terms of the decision in RFA-1059-2020, titled as "Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure Development Corporation Limited Vs. 5 of 6 ::: Downloaded on - 16-01-2022 00:33:49 ::: RFA-1062-2020(O&M) and -6- other connected cases.

Sandeep and others", decided on 06.10.2021, with a liberty to the unserved respondents to file an application for revival, if they feel aggrieved.

All the pending miscellaneous applications, if any, are also disposed of.

December 17, 2021                                      (ANIL KSHETARPAL)
Ay                                                           JUDGE


Whether speaking/reasoned                  : Yes/No
Whether reportable                         : Yes/No




                                  6 of 6
               ::: Downloaded on - 16-01-2022 00:33:49 :::