Karnataka High Court
Shekappa @ Chandrashekar vs The State Of Karnataka on 29 June, 2010
Author: Jawad Rahim
Bench: Jawad Rahim
{B35 f:?»r':£;<( §}§E'i§3 E{.um2;;zi5Vvf§_C{}P§ E IN THE HIGH CQEIRT OF KARXATAKA CIRCEIIT BENCEE AT DHARWA§ mrrgn THIS THE 29th may 0? JUNE, 2919 BEFORE THE Hozcmna MR.JUS'f'ICE JAWAD_R§H.I.M:.A.:" T CRIMINAL PE'I'I"I'I_0N N01; '9?52'§1 mt: 1-Ir: -- .1: = ' _ BETKUEEN:
Shakappa C§':a:1drashe1s:ar $,/0, Samgappa Age: 2"?' years, 020: Agr:%<ii:§§E..%.f_ur<:
;'{}.§§1a&raf.€s%2w21r, Bagafl«<::}L _ I The SE23 ti: 5}? §<{aa;"r1a3{'L$.'é~;g2.M _ V' Thrazggh 952?}, 'BjéEag§i_; §$$ Circuii B€:r:€:2:a, Dvha.r:...>v2é§._ ' ' -- 'V . PETiTE®I'~§'E'R §%ESP{}NE)E.l'€"E"
éf*:~:..:§;:;«V.4 <:§{2~::;§_§~_r~@,_L PE'%"E'"§'§{}i'€' £3 FELEI; Ujié 482 C2? <;:§§9§3.':::' $E'E*L';E"<;§P€€3 3*-<:> {EL-fxééfi $5.5 EZNTERE E'E€{){;'EE.?;}§E*~£{§f:§ ;a<;;:::'i=a§:;'§%___vm:::;~" P§'E'E"fi{fif¥§'£'§R EN <:.<: §'a?{'.§'2:'§?;'f2{}€Z}9"3 ijm ?E§I%';: '?_f£LE GE? He:§_Hx:*gLE €'I'i}'UR;"E' gmfiat, 3:;A<;.:. A v '§'}§ES {3E€H?¢E3"NAL §3§1"F§".£'E{}§'~€ C{§?a£§i\E{} {.333 Ff??? {f}Ri}F:Z§€E§ J.1i'2A{_i':§--::sa%'; ':'§:§;: {§{f}UE%'i'E" Ezféfafiifi mg: §~*<j>LL<:>2é2:§«;e::;-; z-~.:
ORBEER The p€ti'£é0n€:r as-'E":z:> is: faxing iihékfgé-3 far the <3.{f"€;;r_2C::§.s3 'El1'}J:E§§1é.'ib§{5' undizr S€:c:?tio:3s 34%} 362, L304 zqfw E;%e«::E,'ic2"::{j£3.<é§ égf IPC, is saszskinggg q:,'zashi:r1§,§ of Ehe pr:3c:e<:c§.i.n§;é.eu.VEr?" €_Z.{T" ;xn:;'25?;'20@9 on cm file 0:' JMFC, E§:iag;§_:A'{:zv5;zi':_g::-éi --Cg;::;.g;:;;%;é;::::_ 2 prgceadings},
2. 'E'h6 pmsecut§<m_ 02:86 ('$1 x@;g<3rt of Mahadevi submitted ctamplainamz Paiictz Station} ir:A._'s»?E'1ic}:ir.VV--V<,:.l.':§'v husband $hi:z;a_ppaV 212$' :: §?§;§;%:""'br<§i§z€rS tzamfifg-'3 3€'a§ia_ppa., AEE were: resi.d:%z':g t<:}§§Cih€3":._%1n<'§V sf gaipelim-ii $0 {ha agr%<:uEtu.r2:§u32:'ndQ .'fha%:.':€i:s§;2§;t&"é:rose bei>,m=<:en Shivappa and
-:}th.::r.s; _§<fsr c£§v3'.15-§g;::'V<>:" pé"-{§;3 {::'t}; 23..I'1€§ hencé they ééffi Eéving .s5a§:;a:*a.:§<%§}?fA;'L'. Ff-'}w€xr5r,V"'E§hiv21ppa§ {ajirzce deeaased} éemandeci S§'}£%'V;i§E':,_'E1i": i'E:%g3M g:"2%«,:.;_;;:k;.r{y amgi §;t0:"1'i:"35b23':i::sra fa: p2w::--§3&§;m€ni; 9;? 1:>9zn;_ T'hs*_ 1:>:"::§..§"::3:"§~: déé fiéfi. agmsa T326}; 'i;*2r'€Ti3 waziééngg £51"
{}f§;E}{}i"E?.1ZE§,v§§}A"I. E0 i»<::'§§ him' {$13. 2:3.3;?.2§{}8 {iuférig §a.zz°a2 0? ._ EZ'%fg2;%.::1r:':';w..-'1%:e:é fir: E3155 *=.zi1.Ea§;s:':§ Shi*a;~2_§3pa ;me:% his; Eaméia' .__"'r:2s:z::;:':::-3:2; E35? :3":€:.£:' h::}::&;é3 magi avers? "-fi;'é'E€I{§§'Eii{§§§ sir;-zmzs. fit' ihzszé La) iime, as; the itézéidreiz wéréz feeiiizg sleepy; {E16 Csmpiziizzarxi Esfiahadevi sand her §'E'L1SbE3f}d Shivagpa Wfifli 'i:<>Wa.re:*£$ the bangs is Eeave {he ChfldI'€;'1'1.. Vkfbiifi éiéiésfgs wszsre on t§2€'[ v¢;%,.}:
3.V£e1had:;?vi E':{)E§{T€i'd ha? h'L1:;ba:3d"s ':32"<)*;h<=3rs (€iCC''ZLE§3€i«d.''§§5?%{f§V§'T} '' ware f<}H{:swi3*:g them. Thereeifter, $h2'_Vapp:;1 ai${§'..§:12r~§:p"€Aét€c§*-«T zhsy vmu§C£ harm {ha i"a1mii3r and .s1a€~;E<:::€éiAAVI%}I2:E%g1:§&ev:f't§:; 'i;:a;,:§9ths:
Chiidrssrz home and ran away {rum E:h_ff"§1&1€€3. _';1xs§ :»va":';M running; 'zhe ezccuseai foiicywweci *;:5;h';i>%..r;1ppa,'.. ;'is:g?{:§1xx?E3.il€;" the complainant and 216:" d£Ta:'.,Eg:{'1'i("3If""Ez.';:%'>'::;':i' é;}1:_311;€:r f:ea.:*'~"a Sized beienging to Mr. Parappa BézdigézgET.r<2mv.:bc"'said 913.56 {hey gavv ihe accugfsd 52§:2;_mlt_%.%1g ca.r:V-;:.r:qL:.ez1'§ to which he S1lf§€ff3{§"'§--E?j'§,fi'f£€SI'Zifhfi'"€;§}'Efip§;fi?:?i;é'ii'if baing scared returned; hsméz e1nt§.Wa:it€V<§ §}:;:{"";}2VaT.$:».5§[a.{;+E':;= _;':.£gh:.( Next day :~:hc;3 m-'€§":§;. ice {ha E§pG{. 21nVéé»._'sa:.:; hat? A§'j;%.;1:=3f_n~;1n& was dead, {)2} theit basis ..Vcc>mp§.3£§nt ?";>y-$13 §<>e:§g§€--:§i{ an-& ihfi bmtézers W€;'*§"€f §:iI:'}f°€1§gZf:€{§ as; 'r_:;zc<:*u«:s€:§ E~E:;:3.'.'};"'~tc:} 4.' P€:2::fii:£<m::.r axszis ms: 49* Ei€:€§,iS3i<'fé. 'Phi:
s:.21$~é3A' '*3-'E%V§:§v'"_i§€T}§§i§'§;}'§E'{€C§ E0 éiauri (>5 S:':s;siam; in .i§.C=?€<é';S{};32{}"}@ 21:15 i;hr€-ti eaccusazs-d aways? put §f'§§:'£E. $536; z1%3$:::£>nd§n§.
3;.»-<::"s§<;sn Z Burirzgg "aim? aria}, 'aha pf'{)S{fC'LZ"ii€31"1 exzimirmd 8 E.-3-'i'Cf1€fSS€f'S 2'-111:3 pizzctézd z"<:=i§em<:<:* O1"; 1?} d{3Cum€:ntS 23;éTd_ E_§ :21:ai::*:"i2z§ <éb}e:<:tS. Evéakwgtvazj. dégirzgg $16 I::2"i.:33, I\;'§2aE12::fiéi:i..'~§~--P§%f M c{:mpiain:1n.t, her ci:22L1ghté3:r BEi}'2"i§<{1<;£%; - PW2 _%:::.:t.:j§_é"<':.cViV 1*-'1s::'3:=:I:éi:*. ' " "?'he:; r<:t§"&<:i;cd from their s?;;.21'i<':r§1€§1i:; E2121}; éifiélgfiéd' E~_»Ié};..£'»._t<> A' i:>geth{--31" kiiied Shivappa.
4. 'E"he Esamesgi {$51} xfudVg%;;:A'f%>_L:a§% :%i§"'§.3':1V{5'Ai'§"3'iE§§Z"3.Ei'{i:':§'§ £iS§€C1:-'S in thé 5-rvjdences J':h:::' and acquittaé three ezccuged Maiiappa' E-E{)v.:€:ve3:; as charge wag Spilfi 313$ (rage in pending <:0mm2?';ta.1 pmceediatzga. _iFi'<:7;<;<;::je<.?"3=3{:ks":'g quash the §§1"<>cesdi::gs cm 2&5 gmu.r1d ma;_: tfisre' is ézai'-:21é«:--%;_:5%.E¢i§ :0 pI'{}{3€f3d agaéns': him anci if {he §,%'§.E1'1€SSé&1._a§€' {f}'{3'3"1'E§}'1€Ed, f§'i€f/ may mpfiat {he S§&1}"fi€3 " i§:€§_"_~.__§'i;E:'p Eiumar, ?Z§'ié£*. §<:z2m':s:3d ifiksvi. Piéagzier .:s3§ré::§'é:r1t'§.'3V:g {E6 ifiiiatii <:§<}::*::; mi): disap'L2%z3 i:h€:.€; z:<:<:u;:§<3z:§ E\§:}'§ :0 'm'f:s:__> w:?::*i::~ f22:'i:':g the Charge 9.2:. $226 Esaznc aiézegaiéikng ass {E16 _ [§_::s:"{.%*ii:}';':%:.:*, 2:::'{-3 §§;'f'aE"1'§.€i€:§ 2;ar_t<:;;%;:%i:é;a..E in iihér; irizzi 33:: %;.h<:° i%¥<3ss;i{.;::s; Judgje in S.,{'LI'=E::>,E'>{},i";'§»E{,'v{'}<,§, Cap}; 5}? i;}'2.e jzzcigggmezgi defied 2t?§.{}¥--}52.€){}€9 is z':is;<2 pmciucziéd.
{.1 E hzsvat alga) ggzzxle ihrazsugh ¥;h{:- an-*id<3:1ce of P'%£&z'__1 « Mahadevi and PW2 « E§£i:€;'é.§;<.i<é.:§.: 89:31 are-3 aiiaged witneS:§c$, but. have ttbaaéijg miracéed fmm i',£fk:ir wsrssion' Thsjg" have gi'€€i;"3 21 clean chi_T;»A*:s:3_the '_¢1ic:c:1,i%3':::.«f:i»N€;...§=:::}"_ 3 and abmia-*@d 'mam Sf aii the a1EEc:ga§ti0:::$,T ~'§'%1§S~_hia:i--.f{m§:;§§i'£¢5T in the a<':qu.§:iaL The petitien€5':"_ié;---gfzew ikicimg cE:_ar;:§:é"--i--:2..s:V;o§ii 'dip C2186 C'C.N<3A2S?;'2(}C%9. Undflgifi-b£e'<i1Y, <}f:'~c_Qmm§§t':aL he W111 have :0 be sub"§e:cEeCi"«--t§€ Elfiéii, 2; '$p;¢a£<:in§_3;, thew i3 :10 impedimént :<:._c<}r:dLm-:--.,t}::3 iziai ;;.g"a§n's%;* But 'the qL1i3$5'i§§{"}}":.':_ §S a§«'E§£'é;h€:;"Vw<}§:h"*;j;_1,1r_§;>;}8<:* will be served. This is; becausse §¥'1¥1--andVVP\;352V_ha§5§'::«,§;jV~'dep<>se:E fizz favgur Q1" azccxised Neiai {<3 3 %r: 'E§§,Cy§T\$<;v;._E3{}j2i}C%§7 may re:-:§}ea'c; 'iihe Sé},£'£'E€ i7€:'1"E*3§€3§'L E"%.»*e:':~'E;hé3; cha.ng«3.§;;h;§:%z v:':11<3§0z:. anci Eadie: the §€i;it§:}m';~.z" 21$ tE1éé"--;3;_:§s;:1:é§za:12it4V{>3Shivaggja, £1 Eé'L'£€:?h £2139 21.3352, iii". WEN; bi? {}%'§§ff:%€ii__:Ei 'E:::{"2z,C<;:::%'§é1".{Emir azersmil, 'a}r::e:é2"a;§s3{i= i',§E€§"=:'3 vxxffi be %.v~:<) '¢'{ffE§§.'Q§3S3 «:m<_% ?-Z.-zi fa'v{}L:r <32'? gmr<:2s<:€:':;zi:;<:>;r:: and {H25 in §2zv<}L:z° ¥:::f§.I:1{3 e1é:;;t':j£:;€:c1':. '§§es;3Z£§<-35;), :1? 132525; aaztzm fa iisniim' 3133?: {':'éz'§{iCE"}{f.éEf d§éf§{3:"£:z";.°i. {mm wizzffi %i:%';e},:' E221'-Jet ;3:§:"<:=2:<i§; gév{;=.:"1 £22 (xi S33, f'€0.:"§()€;"i2Cr{)§}, ab:-2,1: L::3{i{:L:E3{.e%d1§~* they xvii} be ésxpaéging Eh€:'1:::«";€h?es Ea p€:jLZE'}" b€CEZii,1${3 whéith of {he &;t:2at<~:m<m.f_;§s:._tt*L1:3 b<:w:e'>m:':s; i.mm21i€:"§aL The w:,:*_$; .fac*';' {hat ih-<:r€'.';%}.i'i"£'§u«"-<3;_ vezséarzg wiii z'::~:p<3s6 them {Q &1+C¥,i{)r1, 2?'. i am sure that {E25 xxzitziesaséa '.r:{)t";::'t%;'=rnpi Caurse. In the rézguiifi if the triéfii. _:};S~..{7"(}Z'i€iA1.L)'iCVC:fZ'3C"'§z bu~fIVI:..}vb7é"<:}17V:§}r 21 foztnal iriai and the vérrgjcybjsct 'ax-f'1Z"E:§»..'}i::s.t:: Easing (35 this xritraarf E am S813Sf\§%£\§\~%f:a§,//fiééhfi'Vf§3.§4€3Vis¥§f3%f:ViI1f§S¢ if aiiawssd tr; Cuiminaie in {r%.aE,._?,E*1€: E°€:;',i*-'¢;'zi'£..'s?:$:'1§§§§ ;3r9se<:133;iorL Bang of this money of the State', :53 be:s€;3c:.%u::j,3e xsk§.EE<.§:é' %a;«. giiks q%;1i€tuS $0 thia p@§iti<>z1. :8, 'The ' pet:'?;i{}'n_ M £»s4VV'[2-z§.Eé;$;v€d5 The }f)£'{}C{"3'€:3d?;f'1gS in <:x<:,:'-m2:"§"2;?';3.§>{;f; ¢::.1:i;::"f:;:é 8f the €.jE*:'§E?;'€3 Béiaggé jg hereby' V igugzghgéd V32; fa?' iéixgz psiftimler is C{>§1C<3§°I'lf3§;; gab ,5'