Karnataka High Court
Commissioner Of Central Excise vs M/S Federal Mogul Tpr India Ltd on 25 August, 2011
Bench: N.Kumar, Ravi Malimath
uu«ww;>\wj_\w_«;1\9.\§ fi€?HE%fi£%§CGURT{¥*KflR%AT&KA#§"§fiNGALQRE mrrgg THIS mg 25"?" was Q?' wags? 2iC}"1'E. '_"'--._ "--V PRE§E%?
WE aommg ?v%R.Ei§STf3:€:§__§%xé,K_i}Vi'%?E§%*~§'.';V. A533 V mg HGWBLE :~4m:;',$;§*£s::;_E §"g{§E%¥E.4w:vE%%};{:%-,fi§VN'i;'£' <:EA;;#:x2@*1V:2}j"_:;;F;M;a~e1:§:@ M * A 3E"F'WEEF§: é V C§€~'EMESS§O§\&EF_'Z;--€}F cEm§.'Af:a% VfEi><.{II$ fE'. "
B;'«\¥'«§G;A¥»GREx-£15" €1.35»? zvugsgzm E;¥€fi}.T'E' x CaR,BU£LQ_I§§*£€;L?_,: Qjgggms _R::fi2,AD; V BANGALGRE ~: 5_6O a:;m_;'-Jjj; é' ...APE3E§.,LA.£\§°E"
{av §R:V"VE%é'¢Liz;'g":%é%sfmb%::',:x§:§%~;$§<;:m:'%'§;EaD*:', wvacara) Afifiz W5" Fgagm r»£z0$3"g;:;E*;'*R:-- Egisguégé" :;m,; 8Q_i_"}§A aaaggwzsm R@A?.3g _ '§El'E,A£*§!%§'s§§<v,'%;
§£fi'€€§AE,§§}RE ~e _'§€§i.E,€3'é4}5 ,a.§?i;E§i3G§\£BE§'\2"§"
{%§~§"'._%A§§;:' T":~.:;i;L;£s<$§«::v:: §<i§E€,&R£N ma SR3 Li;=;§R:9H;:.:2;;ma;, ,:32gi.i§CA?E§; >4<>§<3§<>%<>§< §':Z*§;% fééaé i§§"§=§€§" ggatémz 35$ 0% we fieréiraé §;;::t,, Efiégé arégmg mi :3? side? datefi §§.£'j%§.2G1€.E §*'a$':£3§__:3r: Eiay arfigr f'-éa$.38§ 3:. 38"?;'2§1@! gzaying fig L ' W°1>?#_k\°4i'é'0_§'~|'¢\\V£§ § 3 as 3 ajécéée Ehe quesééan af fiaw atateé €§"§€?'&§F':, 538%: as%_§& 'me *;'ES?$J%:" am'; wdar 5303.386 am 38?f2@:i§ "€.%Tat€d i:§,§5a2§iGg Thig CEKX; <:Qm£:*2gi 9:"; is?' adméggés-;€.. %<E.§i'\/'EAR. 3&5, deiéxserefi the if:3§%m«::§ng:»~ guagmég: =,k This agpeai is fééed by _'£%2eV4§*g\,}"e.z*ss;e §§'f's_a.E:§ér:7g%'Vri§ "*:%I?ié--..L srder pagsgeé Egg ihe T:'éba::'*:a%"'::i:V:V%V§"i%:%'% a£§$*m{_e'::i§2*:é2§®§EcatE0n V flied éy ihe &$S€$$&é"~..fG?'«"§§$'é_§'if{f:E V§':'._';:=i'efiVéA§€I}V§E'E 9% the ammmt énveiveé in t§*:és'T-5;a;m?§é:ba¥: §{3"{_Z'*.7'f:\f€E"'§,r' iheresf is gtayeé 33%? '3Z§'}%'3: €§§"$§{3S;§:§1__C%3€{i';§";::'é Q,__"3éCflgp_3S?é Q§%fi§_§entfl Exase Ac: lgéé daaés .§;~;ét.E*:' d;:é§{§v::'s§i:;'%géniéing' aweaé GE duty demanded 0:
§ena§iy«E?é:%g§e:f, r§é'_;§:siVa$ i£E'Efi€i*§":"
"'_3'i5F. wading ggggefis; sf £553;
. e$'""§e:'%aif;» ievisfl' ~ ";<'§:f'2_;3re 55:3; agpéai :,::?@'er mfg {Z}"23§£'e:; A §f2€ "é;fe£é§:'§§o;? 5:: orfier apgesafeé gggffigf rgigées éggiéy fiuéy demarzdeaf 5;? ffififiéflf 92' @955:
.9?-f§§"£'§? are 335 Lsnésr 3:35 CQf?§"§"Q§ sf' éerszinraf azcége gaséfgariiégg 9;" gay gengfzgr feasisa' :,s:::3'§:"
55:53 figs, 5% Qfiffifif? fiegizzms 5:25' §;},$aa:':":":§ 1,1 3% //// --
&'§L.5i§"3G§'§E§: ':9 émpigzsfi gush canfiiiéareg ag E: fieemg fit is 4"'~ 4 M. we agrxgéaé, $§"'§&§E be éemgéteé as a FLEEQ. $3 gn Efiéiefiiffifi ifi that ru§e,, 3% first prewga is S@C'§iEGi'2 3§--? zerzferg an {$38 5ii€§"§SE"§i:i§:$, is dispenge with gush éegggfii §ub}@¢': %:jé'---,su{:h csaéétéaflg 33 he éeems fit {:3 imgaga 3% a3 tg3..._$::?:ég%:;§:"r'§ {he interegig 9? aha ,z*e2;&:"2:,2ea "me gecand ;QE'f§:'~.;'.%VS0 f§'E§'%<§§*§.§C_ V' sblégatery fgr Csmmiggésnez" §f fi: Vp§Ee alE5,_Vt£:*_ aggéicazéan within 33 dayg {mm :%v2j?r.;:a..Ad' "a_te c§ :i:..;:'Afi':%n§V;:. §A§*~~.;?:é'--..L C§'°:0$$€'5 is exeraise éis;ser:s§;é'é3g.VVV§:2;§':i*s su::h__ ?ciAe35:«0§§';; in i§ETT1S Qf the firs: Qmvégsfi in A E*:arm0:"1§mjé_ the aferesaéé greviijééééé"*mfa_ke§f §t_ 'x,<éry ciéévr ithafi éegssét of duty §eman{d:ed<-er -;3_eE*':§jEi:_\g%"--§¢%;;:»»E4eV;:§ is a soafiéiien gregedent far <:@r:s5E.{§&rEr1gZ""i:§}V7& a§'g?isi;at§é%: 9;"; meréig. Ea gageg Whfifé gush :§e¥'§§"§f3ré.;z'w.§f--.j:aK $r"§é?2aity masses angina %3a§"ds§:%g ta Sufih f§é.:;>[:°"§'<:»?§S;..V_§isé':;r&'?;.§@rs ig vesirefi Eifiiih éghe 3L£€?';O§'"E§'}«' 5% ééggenge arz.%§€tj?€ Ag is cigar fram the Egnguage gmgisyeé is; tha §'§si§§:§~ grezxégag mat snag we ai.€:E"":@§"ét';! €§"§®@$E$ $3 {:%.:i_g;;:%1';::":$@ %;%*'§§§"E guah QEEEQEEEK afi ebéégaiésn E3 sag: an 3% E g; --
L,/' A W%§'.W's: . ' égl § 3 § 3
§?2a§% éegsgéi: the amezmé, mshésh is the guigjgcé maitfi G? the agpfiaé befare the Trébugzafi.
6. Ir; terms <3?" the abéve ebgervatés_::§,._%'E'2e' 'zséfipéeaf "
is flgpasefi $1-fk firs"?