Karnataka High Court
Mallappa S/O Sangappa Kumbar vs The State Of Karnataka on 18 April, 2012
Bench: K.L.Manjunath, Ravi Malimath
E ST,, t I p t
BENH I HPA
4DM 9 8 PY APR 2
9 FO9BLEM UTC P PITH
AND
THE HON BLE MR JUSTICE 'TA MI lIlA
MFA N 0949 2 ii PC
MIS VL 202 2
¶1 WEE
C
:2:
I. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
BY ITS DEPUTY COMMISSIONER. DHARWAD
TQ & DIST:DHARWAD.
2. THE KARNATAKA HOUSING BOARD
BY iTS COMMISSIONER. CAl) VERY BHAVAN.
BANGALORE-9
3. THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER
KARNATAKA HOUSING BOARD, CAUVERY BHAVAN,
BANGALORE-9
4. THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
KARNATAKA HOUSING BOARD, CHANAKYAPUR1.
HUBLI, TQ:HUBLI, DIST:DHARWAD.
5. SANGAPPA Sb CHANNABASAPPA KUMBAR
AGE:66 YEARS, OCC:AGRICULTURE,
R/O SUTAGAflI, TQ:HUBLI, DIST:DHARWAD.
6. RUDRAPPA Sb SANGAPPA KUMBAR
AGE:39 YEARS. OCC:AOR1CULTURE,
RIO SUt4GA'TfI. TQ:HUBLI. DIST:DHARWAD.
RESPONDENTS
ICOMMONI
(By Sri.K.B.ADHYAPAK AGA FOR Ri AND R3;
SRI C.B.PATIL ADV. FOR R2 & R4;
R5 AND R6--SERVED)
THIS MFA IS FILED U/SEC.43 RULE 1(r) OF CPC.,
AGA1NST THE ORDER DTD:02.1 1.20 10. PASSED IN
O.S.NO. 141/2009, ON THE FILE OF THE Ii ADDL SENIOR CIVIL
JUDGE AT HUBLT. DISMISSING THE I.A.NO. 1 FILED 1.1/0.39
RULE 1 AND 2 OF CPC.
MISC. CWIL NO. 102027/2011 IS FILED U/O. XXXIX RULE
(1) & (2) OF CPC., PRAYING TO GRANT TEMPORARY INJUNCTION
RESTRAIN THE RESPONDENT NO.1 TO 4, ITS MEN, &
SERVANTS FROM INTERFERING WITH THE PEACEFUL
POSSESSION & CULTIVATION OF THE LAND MENTIONED IN
4
'F. . s r\fl ,'1%4: T i: Th
1
' T I.
r 4 F
ThP .'i 1-t.iL ''VD'.. 'N '-' '!_,M.S4
'
', iKVAJflJNTIfJ 'z\'
IC
JUDGIENT
ihe aripeidflts ho urre plaifltdTs 'ii U.S
NI ' OotFti ott Il
d
1 itu iScio 1
I it, H Mi 1 e fic.. Us pral trier (fr' )L1 I
Rule .ur! read with section Wi CPC. qurtioning the
a dtwr trs )f u r r,as_ 4 n 4 Nc]
urcit )rer 'XYIX'tt s .
)(k Ii
2
1 a ' r il s r I
4 senara e p.ssessio' it their sh •rr.
rs fi s'.?
r4pLt tk..' t! ' hi aft. Ic --
a • 1
•. ..•. •. • ,. •'
, . • ,
:. '..2a..a.F ,
4
j •_ 411•.
C K
• •• •1 I--
• I
LI CD CD CD HU HI U F rt
9? Cr 9? CD LI
c rr CD SR. HI HI HI
5 Cr Li LI H
U CD DC CD HI a LI CD
S S Cr Cr Cr CD Cr
L Li 45 CD Li Li CD
a
6 C5 Li rU CLI
Li CLI LI CD CD HI
5 -- CD HI
SDo LI CD Li DC
r Li Li 5 cCr c45 Cr54 " aCr
r
DC 45 HI Cr HU HI rF Li
Li Cr 45 LI rt
CD Li" 5 DC Cr
HU CD LI 45 Li Li" Cr DC
HI !.
en
CD 54 --
CD rt
5CD Li Cr LI
LI Fin Cr
Cr HI rt DC
U" LI HI Cr
g .y' Ui U LI Cr
HI" Cr CD -- U LI L5CD
Cr U" LI
54 Li ES CD rt
LI 45 LI 54 54 LI HU
a DC CD Cr Li Cr rt rt
" HI CD DC CD Cr CD LI
CD < Ui UI rU
CD U CD -- CD Li"
9? LI Cr LI rt
C, Cr CD
H CD
-- CD
iga
a
5 b Li HI o
CD Li CD < Cr LI
£H CD 54 54 CD Li
1 CD DC CD
54 54 Cr LI Li -9? HI HHr Cr
c.
Li CD DC CD
U U Cr Li LI Cr 54 Li" CD
--" U rt
--" HI
CD Cr ••• CD U -- CD CO CD
Cr Cr LI U U Li" rt
CD CD " HI
.
Cr. : Li rF Cr DC CD
--
LI 5CD LI en CD CD H-- U CD Cr Cr. -- LI -- Li CD HI.: H"
r U CD Cr HI 5 Cr LI • 9? Cr en in U CD Cr rt
-- -- HI DC CD en CD CD •-- en HrI r±
- CD DO LI CD CD Li LI 5 " CD 9? HI CD -- U Cr CD rt HI Cr H HI LI Cr rID = CD U" LI CD Li Li Cr in Fin U Li LI CD CD y CD U" U CD H+) HHI DC Li -
Li" HI CD U U -- U
U • U
CD U CD CD rt
•45Li"Cr Cr E• Cr
Li DO CD
CD CD LI -- UI CT Cr
LU U CD DC Li CC HI
a U in Li LI U C
Li" U in LI
Cr U LI U Cr Li LI HI CD H
CD Li Cr Cr HI Li LI•
LI HI Cr Cr Cr CD Li 54 HI
Cr CD Cr CD Cr Cr a: at
Li CD HI CD LI 54 Cr HI CD
Cr CD Cr HI CD CD rt
-HI HI LiD. Li HI DO LI UI U"
CD Cr Cr LI LI .
U
Cr Cr Li Li
Li Cr Li U LI LI Li
E
t
S Cr Cr
9?Cr 5Li CD Cr CD Li • Cr Li
CD CD CD CD
Cr LI Cr CD CD Li LI
DO Cr Cr CD I DC Cr CD U HI Cr Cr to
H r< H rt
rt Ci CD) H H t H CD rt
2 CD
H El
H H H• H H"
t CD H
CD _, h<4
% <4 1 rt CD H. CD CD H
CD CD
H CD H" H $ Cr H rt
CL H H H" c Cr H H H DC C <
H CD <4 ,..
CD CL cC CD <4 <4 <C
CD H" CD CD H CD Cl)
H CD H" <C S. rc
H H <4
<C <÷ H H" <4 CD
B El H" CD H
(<C
H" B c B H"
a <•,
H c H CD B B
BH BH"
DC H" CD CD
H
BH
H t H ç H <e CD CD rt
CD
BH
<< Cr DC H g H H H CD H $
El
BaSE5
DC rt
%DCH" CD CD CD CD Cc" Cr Cr 4 DC CD CD c CD H fl( < <4:
Ct CL <_ CL 5 5 'H H CD H <4 CD BBB5 rt j y DC H CD c CL H << <C B CL CD H" 5' El H" H H Cr CD CD CD H" CC CLI 4- -- CD DC <1 H Cr CD . --"
i Cr H H H, H H:
CD CD CL rt CD CD H H CL <4 -i H CD ' Ht CD j <4 H BiElss <C<4B CD H, CD <4 CD H H H B H a H, C H CD 5 H a H H CCC Cr CD H" n, H H <4 CD CL H c"
. 5' <, H i CL H , Cr CD <4 <4 5' H" CD H"
:4 CD
<4 H CL. Cr DC CD
•CD 5' <4 <4 CCC) CD CD CL CD
C) C/C DC DC <r H 5'<4 CD
5' DC
CD
<- - H"
CD Cr <H H CD H" H CD CL CD DC H H"
CD : <4
CCC Cr CS rm <4 C/C H i CD
H H Cl H rr Cl) H C-. C- CD Cr
DC DC CD CD
5' 5 <4 <<' <4 C
flH HSBBCC5'
H :.
<4 CD CD
CD <4 H" CD H
"
n <4 5' <4 <4 CD --e Cl)
DC 4
-- H <4 <4 H
DC <4 <4 CD H
2 El CrC <4 H ---
<4::. H" H" CL
<4 <4: <4 <4 < CL
Ci) < (4-
H <" CD H
CD 5' CD H" CD H" H" H" H"
<4, Cv CCC DC
9<C CD CL CD H CD CL H Cr
DC CD CD H DC CD (CC) Cr
z r± r
CD °
CD
t
a a ::t CD
CD CD CD CD D
CD CD
CD t (D• CD CD
CD CD rt t CD
CD CD r CD CD DCD
CD CD ND CD CD
CD CD CD- CD
ND CD CD .CD
rt CD CD
CD
CD CD rt
CD CD
CD CD CD
cD• CD Z
--*
CD rt
aCD• P CD
CD --
-4
a eCD
-- -- CD
CD U ND
ND rt : CD
CD CD
--
CD - ND
ND CD• CU
r CD
CD r
Fe 2 CD CD
CD CD CD o
ND CD- CD -- CD
CD CD
--
Ui CD ND
CD CD
a, CD CD
CD ND cr a
CD -- rt
ND CD ND CD *
CD rt ND
- CD
D' CD rt
(_4.
'--4 ND
CD
4 L--
1 •( ND
ir)
4 a CD
9--. 0 CD CD
4 4_._$, (_L9 (02• c-< ND
((1 rt t
ai ND CD
an - CD CD
t:tl CD CD (CD
-- CD N
a rt
CD
CD rn CD
CD -
- CD CD
r
.
CD CD-. CL