Karnataka High Court
Sri. Girish Kumar Naidu vs The Commissioner on 25 November, 2024
Author: B M Shyam Prasad
Bench: B M Shyam Prasad
-1-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU
DATED THIS THE 25TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2024
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE B M SHYAM PRASAD
WRIT PETITION NO. 24656 OF 2023 (LB-BMP)
BETWEEN:
SRI. GIRISH KUMAR NAIDU
S/O M KUMAR
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS,
RESIDING AT NO. 108
4th MAIN, 1st BLOCIK,
IYYAPPA NAGAR,
K R PURAM
BENGLAURU 560 036.
...PETITIONER
(BY SRI. KIRAN KUMAR R.,ADVOCATE)
AND:
1. THE COMMISSIONER
BRUHATH BANGALORE
Digitally
signed by MAHANAGARA PALIKE,
ANAND N
N.R SQUARE,
Location:
HIGH BANGALORE 560 001.
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
2. THE EXECUTIVE ENGIENEER
MAHADEVAPURA SUB DIVISION,
BRUHATH BANGALORE
MAHANAGARA PALIKE,
RB H COLONY
OPP PHONIEX MALL,
MAHADEVAPURA
BANGALORE 560 048.
-2-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
3. THE ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER
HOODY SUB DIVISION
BRUHATH BANGALORE
MAHANAGARA PALIKE,
BANGALORE 560 048.
4. M/S SRI. LARVEN ENCLAVE
2nd CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
5. M/S LAKVEN HOMES
3rd CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
6. M/S LAKSHMI PARADISE
3rd CROSS, ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
7. M/S VIKYATH MANOR
4th CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
8. SAI SAPTHAGIRI ENCLAVE
1st CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
-3-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
9. M/ JAIN GRAND
2nd CROSS, ALFA GARADEN
COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
10. M/ S VIKYATH SROVAR
1st CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
11. ANJANA NIVAS SATHYA
1st CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
12. M/S SVSG MEADEAR
2nd CROSS, ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
13. M/S DELHIPRASAD NEW BUILDING
(PRATHIKA SIDHARTHA ENCLAVE)
3rd CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN
WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
14. M/S S R HOMES
7th CROSS (L/S )
ALFA GRADEN
-4-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
15. M/S SAI PARADISE
7th CROSS (R/S)
ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
16. M/S SRI. SAI GREEN
7th CROSS, (R/S )
ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGLAURU 560 048.
17. M/S SAI ENCLAVE
2ND CROSS
COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI, HOODYWARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
18. M/S SRI LORVEN ELITE
1ST CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
19. M/S SAPTHAGIRI GRANT
2ND CROSS,
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI, HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
-5-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
20. M/S SAI TEJA GARDEN
7TH CROSS (R/S)
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
21. M/S SLN SUMRUDHI
3RD CROSS
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY
WARD NO,. 54
BENGALUR 560 048.
22. M/S SHAARINI
NO.C 85, 4TH CROSS
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY
WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
23. THE MILKY MIST
2ND CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY
WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
24. M/S JAI PLATINA
4TH CROSS
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY
WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
25. M/S TEJA RESIDENCY
3RD CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN
-6-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
KODIGEHALLI HOODY
WARD NO. 54, BENGALURU 560 048.
26. M/S SLV GOKULAM
7TH CROSS,
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI HOODY
WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU 560 048.
27. M/S SAI SHYAM ENCLAVE
3RD CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO.54
BENGALURU-560048.
28. M/S R M R BRUNDHAVANAM
3RD CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO.54
BENGALURU-560048.
29. M/S SRI BHAGWAN ELEGANCE
7TH CROSS(R/S)
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO.54
BENGALURU-560048.
30. M/S SLN SERENITY
3RD CROSS GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD
NO.54, BENGALURU-560048.
31. M/S S S RESIDENCY
7TH CROSS(L/S)
-7-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD
NO.54, BENGALURU-560048.
32. M/S R R RESIDENCY
2ND CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD
NO.54, BENGALURU-560048.
33. SAI NIVRITHI
3RD CROSS, ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD
NO.54, BENGALURU-560048.
34. M/S SRI KRISHNA ENCLAVE
4TH CROSS
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD
NO.54, BENGALURU-560048.
35. M/S SAI SHAPPHIRE
7TH CROSS,. ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD
NO.54, BENGALURU-560048.
36. M/S CALLISTO RESIDENCY
7TH CROSS(R/S)
ALFA GARDEN
KODIGEHALLI
HOODY WARD NO.54
BENGALURU-560048.
-8-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
37. M/S SRI SAI DELIGHT
4TH CROSS,
ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
38. M/S SREE SAI GANESH RESIDENCY
6TH CROSS R/S,
ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
39. M/S SRI SAI SUKRITHI
4TH CROSS,
ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
40. M/S SAI TEJE SEREIN
7TH CROSS,
R/S ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
41. M/S SRI KARTHIK PARADISE
3RD CROSS,
ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
42. M/S DB LAKVEN SPRINGS
2ND CROSS,
-9-
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
43. M/S SRI SAI DIAMOND
3RD CROSS,
ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
44. M/S JYOTHI NIVAS
3RD CROSS,
COCUNUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
45. M/S VASUDHA PARADISE
3RD CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
46. M/S SAPTHAGIRI LOTUS
2ND CROSS,
COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI,
HOODY WARD NO.54,
BENGALURU 560048.
47. M/S TEJA RESIDENCY
2ND CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
- 10 -
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
48. M/S SAI BHASKAR ENCLAVE
2ND CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
49. M/S CHETAN CAMPINES
7TH CROSS (R/S) ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
50. M/S J P HEIGHTS
3RD CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
51. M/S SVS PARADISE
6TH CROSS, ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
52. M/S VAIBHAVA DSILVA ELITE
3RD CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
53. M/S PRATHIKA ENCLAVE
1ST CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
54. M/S BHADAS BLISS
5TH CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
55. M/S LAKVEN MEADOWS
- 11 -
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
2ND CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI HOODY WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
56. SRI SAI PARADISE
3RD CROSS, ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, HOODY
WARD NO 54,
BENGALURU 560048.
57. M/S SRI LORVEN EMESALD
2ND CROSS, COCONUT GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
58. M/S PRATHIKA NANDAVANA
5TH CROSS, ALFA GARDEN
KODGEHALLI, HOODY WARD NO. 50
BENGALURUR - 560 048.
59 M/S ASHRAYA PROJECTS
SITE NO. C- 69, KHATHA NO. 8/C-69/41
KODIGEHALLI, HOODY WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
60. M/S INDRA ENCLAVE
6TH CROSS, ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
61. M/S DANDA SWAYAM PRABHA AND OTHERS
(GPA HOLDER M/S CALLISTO DEVELOPERS)
SITE NO. 2, C-73 KHN 17/C-73/40
PA/442, 79, 5TH CROSS, HOODI VILLAGE
WARD NO. 54, BENGALURU - 560 048.
62. M/S SAI ARADHANA
NO. 85, 4TH CROSS ALFA GARDEN,
- 12 -
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
KODIGEHALLI, WARD NO 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
63. M/S SRI GAYATHRI ELITS
4TH CROSS, ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
64. M/S SAPTHAGIRI ASPIRE
1ST CROSS, ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
65. M/S PRATHIKA PALAM SPRINGS GARDENS
4TH CROSS, ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
66. M/S SRI GAYATHRI PRIDE
4TH CROSS, ALFA GARDEN,
KODIGEHALLI, WARD NO. 54
BENGALURU - 560 048.
...RESPONDENTS
THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227
OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO
DIRECTION ISSUED TO THE R1 TO R3 TO IMPLEMENT
THE DEMOLITION ORDER PASSED BY THE R2 VIDE
DATED 23/08/2022 UNDER SECTION 356 OF BBMP
ACT 2020, AGAINST THE R4 TO 66 AS PER ANNEXURE-
H, H1 TO H62 RESPECTIVELY.
- 13 -
NC: 2024:KHC:47966
WP No. 24656 of 2023
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR ORDERS, THIS
DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER:
CORAM: HON'BLE MR JUSTICE B M SHYAM PRASAD
ORAL ORDER
The petitioner has filed a memo which reads as under:
"The undersigned counsel for the Petitioner submits that, the petitioner filed this Petition before this honourable court to direct the respondents number 1 to 3 to implement the Demolition order passed by the respondent No.2, meanwhile on 12-03-2024 :¸ÀA:©©JA¦/ ¸ÀPÁC/ ºÀÆG«/ 573/2023-24 Respondent No.3 issued the above letter stating that as per the legal opinion of BBMP LAW department, The demolition order already issued by respondent No.2 is not as per law and same cannot be executed, so they have undertaken to issue fresh notices. The letter dated 12-3-2024 has been produced to kind perusal of this honourable court, due to this reason, the petitioner is willing to withdraw this case with liberty to file fresh suit in the interest of justice and equity."
- 14 -
NC: 2024:KHC:47966 WP No. 24656 of 2023 In the light of the afore, the petition stands dismissed as withdrawn.
Sd/-
(B M SHYAM PRASAD) JUDGE AN/-