Rajasthan High Court - Jodhpur
Naresh Chandra Masar vs State Of Rajasthan on 26 July, 2019
Author: Arun Bhansali
Bench: Arun Bhansali
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT
JODHPUR
S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 11010/2019
1. Naresh Chandra Masar S/o Raman Lal Masar, Aged About
36 Years, R/o Mandela Pada, Tehsil Garhi, District
Banswara.
2. Mukesh Chandra Meena S/o Ram Lal Meena, Aged About
29 Years, R/o Banslai Tehsil Arnod, District Pratapgarh.
3. Asha Ram Meena S/o Chunni Lal Meena, Aged About 26
Years, R/o Banslai Tehsil Arnod, District Pratapgarh.
4. Kanti Lal Meena S/o Asharam Meena, Aged About 22
Years, R/o Banslai, Tehsil Arnod, District Pratapgarh.
5. Leemjee Jhodiya S/o Rupa Jhodiya, Aged About 30 Years,
R/o Boriya Post Chhoti Sarwa, Tehsil Kushalgarh, District
Banswara.
6. Veer Singh Jhodiya S/o Lahling Jhodiya, Aged About 30
Years, R/o Boriya, Post Chhoti Sarwa, Tehsil Kushalgarh,
District Banswara.
7. Nangji Ram Bhagora S/o Westajji, Aged About 43 Years,
R/o 16 Mahudi Pada Kota Mangari Po Dungariya, Tehsil
Ghatol, District Banswara.
8. Kokila Kumari Pargi D/o Mahipal Singh Pargi, Aged About
21 Years, R/o Ojariya Post Metwala, Tehsil Garhi And
District Banswara.
9. Bharat Kumar Meena S/o Nana Lal Meena, Aged About 36
Years, R/o Bado Ka Fala, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
10. Suresh Kumar Barod S/o Heera Lal, Aged About 30 Years,
R/o Bado Ka Fala, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
11. Sunita Kumari Pargi D/o Haliya Pargi, Aged About 23
Years, R/o Ojariya Post Metwala,tehsil Garhi, District
Banswara.
12. Som Raj Garasiya S/o Kesha Garasiya, Aged About 28
Years, R/o Ajroli Post Manpur, Tehsil Jhadol And District
Udaipur.
13. Priyanka Meena D/o Ishwar Lal, Aged About 24 Years, R/o
Daiyawara Post Deri, Tehsil Kherwara, District Udaipur.
14. Pramila Kumar Dindor D/o Premji Dindor, Aged About 27
Years, R/o Lasada Post, Tehsil Garhi, District Banswara.
15. Ranchod Lal Dodiyar S/o Udaji Dodiyar, Aged About 31
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(2 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
Years, R/o Karanpur Post, Tehsil Garhi, District Banswara.
16. Mahesh Kumar Parmar S/o Lemba Parmar, Aged About 26
Years, R/o Pagara Vaya Damri Pagara, District Dungarpur.
17. Kamlesh Kumar Bhatat S/o Shankar Lal Bhatat, Aged
About 32 Years, R/o Khermal Post Ramgarh, Tehsil And
District Dungarpur.
18. Rajendra Kumar Meena S/o Lal Singh, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Suveri, Tehsil Kherwara, District Udaipur.
19. Arvind Kumar Barod S/o Kanhaiya Lal, Aged About 25
Years, R/o Amali Fala, Post Narwali, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
20. Anita Kumari Ninama D/o Mohan Lal Ninama, Aged About
29 Years, R/o Sarodiya, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
21. Indula Kumari D/o Fatah Lal, Aged About 27 Years, R/o
Upli Sigri Post Nichli Sigri, Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
22. Heera Lal Kasota S/o Kalu Lal Kasota, Aged About 29
Years, R/o Upli Sigri Post Nichli Sigri, Tehsil Jhadol,
District Udaipur.
23. Ramila Kumari Bodar D/o Mangi Lal Bodar, Aged About 28
Years, R/o 35, Kakarmala Post Upreta, Tehsil Jhadol,
District Udaipur.
24. Naresh Kumar Grasiya S/o Kusha Ram Garasiya, Aged
About 22 Years, R/o Rupavato Ka Fala, Tehsil Kotra Devla,
District Udaipur.
25. Tej Karan Barod S/o Parmeshwar Barod, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Devaliya Ada Post Narwali, Tehsil Ghatol,
District Banswara.
26. Mohan Lal Ninama S/o Dhuliya Ninama, Aged About 32
Years, R/o Data Odi Pada, Bori P, Tehsil Pipalkhunt,
District Pratapgarh.
27. Chagan Lal Meena S/o Hera Lal Meena, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Banslai Post Tehsil Arnod District Pratapgarh.
28. Dinesh Kumar Ninama S/o Bhogji, Aged About 30 Years,
R/o Suwamna Naru Po Dungariya, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
29. Sohan Lal Meena S/o Moti Lal Meena, Aged About 40
Years, R/o Naya Tapra Post Kangarh, Tehsil Arnod, District
Pratapgarh.
30. Rekha Meena D/o Daya Ram Meena, Aged About 26
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(3 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
Years, R/o Karan Puriya Post Kuradiya, Tehsil Semari,
District Udaipur.
31. Arjun Masar S/o Roopa Masar, Aged About 40 Years,
Regniya Po Narwali, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
32. Ramesh Chandra Bargot S/o Manegiya Bargot, Aged
About 45 Years, R/o Sona Magari Post Jagpura, Tehsil
Ganoda, District Banswara.
33. Gopi Lal Meena S/o Kanti Lal Meena, Aged About 30
Years, R/o Pahadi Post Kantoda, Tehsil Sarada, District
Udaipur.
34. Ranjit Kumar Meena S/o Shanker Lal Meena, Aged About
34 Years, R/o Kanbai, Tehsil Kherwara, District Udaipur.
35. Heera Lal Meena S/o Kanak Mal Meena, Aged About 30
Years, R/o Borikua Post Tidi, District Udaipur.
36. Narayan Lal Meena S/o Himmat Ram, Aged About 29
Years, R/o Moti Kakar Post Jawad, Tehsil Sarada, District
Udaipur.
37. Gopal Lal Patela S/o Babu Lal Patela, Aged About 30
Years, R/o Futala Samret, Sagwara, District Udaipur.
38. Rekha Meena D/o Ram Lal Meena, Aged About 35 Years,
R/o Bichala Fala, Sarera, Tehsil Kherwara, District
Udaipur.
39. Udai Lal Meena S/o Kailash Meena, Aged About 27 Years,
R/o Barapal Po Upla Goyra, Tehsil Girwa, District Udaipur.
40. Surajmal Meena S/o Harak Lal Meena, Aged About 26
Years, R/o Gojiya Bavji Fala Post Tidi, Tehsil Girwa,
District Udaipur.
41. Sita Meena D/o Babu Lal Meena, Aged About 27 Years,
R/o Harsawara, Tehsil Kherwara, District Udaipur.
42. Sundar Lal Ahari S/o Kurichand, Aged About 27 Years,
R/o Vagdari Post Khempur, Tehsil And District Dungarpur.
43. Priyanka Meena D/o Laxman Lal, Aged About 28 Years,
R/o Bhagor Post Kalyanpur, District Udaipur.
44. Priyanka Kumari Ahari D/o Praveen Kumar Ahari, Aged
About 27 Years, R/o Asariwara Post Thana, Tehsil
Kherwara, District Udaipur.
45. Manisha Bodat D/o Nathu Lal, Aged About 25 Years, R/o
Kharadiwara Post Adiwali, Tehsil Kherwara, District
Udaipur.
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(4 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
46. Roshan Lal Patela S/o Shankar Patela, Aged About 23
Years, R/o Samret Post Sagwara, District Udaipur.
47. Chandra Kumar Meena S/o Punam Chand Meena, Aged
About 34 Years, R/o Baiv Post Bori-A, Tehsil Peepalkhunt,
District Pratapgarh.
48. Lal Shanker Meena S/o Dhanji Meena, Aged About 25
Years, R/o Kargachiya Ghatol Badana, District Banswara.
49. Basanti Kumar Doki D/o Raman Lal Doki, Aged About 21
Years, R/o Kundli, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
50. Mani Lal Gamar S/o Kailash Narayan Gamar, Aged About
22 Years, R/o Amaliya, Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
51. Ashok Katara S/o Varseng Katara, Aged About 33 Years,
R/o Saliya Po Shergarh, Tehsil Gangadtalai, District
Banswara.
52. Magan Lal Katara S/o Vala Katara, Aged About 33 Years,
R/o Saliya Shergarh Post Tehsil Gangartalai, District
Banswara.
53. Pavan Kumar Katara S/o Lal Singh Q, Aged About 29
Years, R/o Saliya Po Shergarh, Tehsil Gangartalai, District
Banswara.
54. Kavita Kumari Meena D/o Bhagwati Lal, Aged About 26
Years, R/o Oda, Lodawal, Tehsil Sabla, District Dungarpur.
55. Anjana Kumari Meena D/o Motiya Meena, Aged About 26
Years, R/o Kotiya Oda, Ummedpura, Post Bhekhared,
District Dungarpur.
56. Sita Kumari Meena D/o Ramchandra, Aged About 22
Years, R/o Unthel Tehsil Arnod, District Pratapgarh.
57. Abhay Kalasua S/o Ramchandra Kalasua, Aged About 32
Years, R/o Bijor Po Padoli Gordhan, District Banswara.
58. Beena Kumari Ninama D/o Kodar Ninama, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Khadankad Post Bassi Ada, District Banswara.
59. Kesarimal D/o Kamaji, Aged About 36 Years, R/o Bijor
Post Padoligordhan, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
60. Sumitra Meena D/o Udai Lal Meena, Aged About 21 Years,
R/o Zawar Mines Neva Talai, Tehsil Sarada, District
Udaipur.
61. Kalu Ram Katara S/o Rakma Katara, Aged About 35
Years, R/o Bijor Post Padoligordhan, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(5 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
62. Rajmal Katara S/o Ramanlal Katara, Aged About 30 Years,
R/o Bijor Post Padoligordhan, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
63. Sohanlal Ninama S/o Kachru Ninama, Aged About 32
Years, R/o Nayan Tehsil Pipalkhunt, District Pratapgarh.
64. Shanti Lal Ninama S/o Eshuram Ninama, Aged About 26
Years, R/o Ward No. 7, Rodapada Kargachiya Badana,
District Banswara.
65. Kamla Kumari Bamaniya D/o Ramju Bamniya, Aged About
28 Years, R/o Khadiyavani Po Parthipura, Tehsil
Pipalkhunt, District Pratapgarh.
66. Dinesh Chandra Damor S/o Tejkaran Damor, Aged About
25 Years, R/o Odwadiya Post Padoli Rathod, Tehsil Ghatol,
District Banswara.
67. Rajmal Doki S/o Prakash Chandra Doki, Aged About 24
Years, R/o Kundli Post Runjiya, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
68. Dalsingh Garasiya S/o Hurateng Garasiya, Aged About 31
Years, R/o Jher Badi Post Jher Badi, Tehsil Gangadtalai,
District Banswara.
69. Rekha D/o Vijay Lal Bariya, Aged About 25 Years, R/o
Bheem Khora, Post Tandi Badi, District Banswara.
70. Priyanka Kumari D/o Shankar Lal, Aged About 29 Years,
R/o Fhutiya Dungari Miyasa, District Banswara.
71. Keshar Kumar Damor D/o Val Chand Damor, Aged About
24 Years, R/o Amali Ota Po Devda, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
72. Laxman Lal Damor S/o Ladu Damor, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Tandi Nani Post Saliya Shergarh, Tehsil
Gangaratalai, District Banswara.
73. Natwar Lal Roat S/o Veerji Roat, Aged About 27 Years,
R/o Surajgaon Via Khadagada, Tehsil Sagwara, District
Dungarpur.
74. Rakesh Kumar S/o Vijaypal, Aged About 31 Years, R/o
Saredi Bhilan, District Banswara.
75. Dharmi Lal Meena S/o Dheera Meena, Aged About 32
Years, R/o Bedanpara Post Saradeet, Tehsil Jhadol,
District Udaipur.
76. Ramesh Kumar Meena S/o Premji Meena, Aged About 37
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(6 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
Years, R/o Salawata Post Karalan, District Udaipur.
77. Rahul Garasiya S/o Mani Lal Garasiya, Aged About 24
Years, R/o Bijuda Post Shishod, Tehsil Bichhiwara, District
Dungarpur.
78. Kaushik Kalasua S/o Babu Lal Kalasua, Aged About 22
Years, R/o Rohanwada, Fala Nayagav, District Dungarpur.
79. Sundar Lal Gamar S/o Halu Gamar, Aged About 28 Years,
R/o Upli Bassi Post Phalasia, Tehsil Jhadol, District
Udaipur.
80. Prakash Chandra Gamar S/o Kanhaiya Lal Gamar, Aged
About 33 Years, R/o Aamliya, Tehsil Jhadol, District
Udaipur.
81. Vikash Meena S/o Banshi Lal Meena, Aged About 22
Years, R/o Khokhadara, District Udaipur.
82. Anandee Lal Gamar S/o Kanhaiya Lal Gamar, Aged About
28 Years, R/o Amaliya, Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
83. Mohit Pandor S/o Nemi Chand Pandor, Aged About 20
Years, R/o Amliya, Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
84. Ragu Mala Pander D/o Nemi Chand Pander, Aged About
24 Years, R/o Amliya, Tehsil Jhadol Phalasiya, District
Udaipur.
85. Naru Lal Katara S/o Bheru Lal Katara, Aged About 26
Years, R/o Nayarahat Post Godana, Tehsil Jhadol, District
Udaipur.
86. Rajesh Kumar Meena S/o Motee Lal Meena, Aged About
27 Years, R/o Ward No. 4, Kumharinyo Ka Pather, Raipur
Jangal, District Pratapgarh.
87. Prakash Chandra Baranda S/o Magan Lal, Aged About 23
Years, R/o Nichli Sigri, Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
88. Neelam Kumar D/o Chhagan Lal Kharadi, Aged About 34
Years, R/o Kunda Po Kherwa, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
89. Rajender Singh Kharadi S/o Singa Bhai, Aged About 41
Years, R/o Palisoda Tehsil Bichhiwara, District Dungarpur.
90. Vajee Kumari Meena D/o Hurji Meena, Aged About 32
Years, R/o Sadakari Nichala Fala, Tehsil Semari, District
Udaipur.
91. Jitendra Kumar Parmar S/o Bansi Lal Parmar, Aged About
27 Years, R/o Nagar Post Adiwali, District Udaipur.
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(7 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
92. Jaswant Kumar Kasota S/o Bhagwan Lal Kasota, Aged
About 25 Years, R/o Garanwas Post Som, Tehsil Jhadol,
District Udaipur.
93. Ranjana Baranda D/o Himmatlal Baranda, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Tapana Ghodi, Tehsil Rishabhdev, District
Udaipur.
94. Ram Lal Meena S/o Dhanna Meena, Aged About 30 Years,
R/o Bujon Ka Khera Post Raipurjungle, Tehsil Arnod,
District Pratapgarh.
95. Geeta Kumari Katara D/o Dharmi Lal Katara, Aged About
28 Years, R/o Som, Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
96. Sarda D/o Vasudev, Aged About 33 Years, R/o Kharadi
Fala Post Kanbai, Tehsil Kherwara, District Udaipur.
97. Tulsi Kumari Kharadi D/o Hakara Kharadi, Aged About 25
Years, R/o Kawader Post Peepalbara, District Udaipur.
98. Ganesh Kumar Bhagora S/o Nathuji Bhagora, Aged About
40 Years, R/o Kota Magari Post Dungariya, Tehsil Ghatol,
District Banswara.
99. Laxmi Ahari D/o Bheema Ji, Aged About 40 Years, R/o
Kali Ghati Post Pandyawada, Tehsil Semari, District
Udaipur.
100. Rajesh Dabi S/o Kishor Dabi, Aged About 31 Years, R/o
Navatapra, Tehsil And District Banswara.
101. Mohan Lal Parmar S/o Hakaru Parmar, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Panasi Chhoti, Tehsil Garhi, District Banswara.
102. Mewa Kumari Meena D/o Punaji Meena, Aged About 37
Years, R/o Jalpaka Fala Dher Fala, Tehsil Rishabhdeo,
District Udaipur.
103. Vijendra Ninama S/o Bapu Lal Meena, Aged About 33
Years, R/o Kanela Post Devda, Tehsil Ghatol, District
Banswara.
104. Banshi Lal S/o Narayan Ji, Aged About 30 Years, R/o
Kehri Post Devda, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
105. Ganga Ram Ninama S/o Mangi Lal Ninama, Aged About
30 Years, R/o Talayapada, Tehsil Pipalkhunt, District
Pratapgarh.
106. Vardi Chand Meena S/o Mohan Meena, Aged About 29
Years, R/o Bavdi, Tehsil Pipalkhunt, District Pratapgarh.
107. Keshari Mal Damor S/o Nagji Damor, Aged About 35
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(8 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
Years, R/o Bavdi, Tehsil Pipalkhunt, District Pratapgarh.
108. Ajya Meena S/o Janki Lal Meena, Aged About 22 Years,
R/o Datla Kund, Tehsil Pipalkhunt, District Pratapgarh.
109. Radha Kumari Meena D/o Laxmi Chand Meena, Aged
About 28 Years, R/o Gumanpura Post Dhelana, Tehsil
Rishabhdeo, District Udaipur.
110. Sanjay Kumar Meena S/o Shankar Lal Meena, Aged About
27 Years, R/o Sunarvav Jhunthari Post Jawas, Tehsil
Kherwara, District Udaipur.
111. Shripal Meena S/o Havala Meena, Aged About 31 Years,
R/o Anat, Tehsil Dhariyawad, District Pratapgarh.
112. Shanti Lal Meena S/o Maniya Ji Meena, Aged About 37
Years, R/o Bhaga Dera Lodiya Dhariyawad, District
Pratapgarh.
113. Lajvanti Meena D/o Punja Meena, Aged About 31 Years,
R/o Dhelana Post Tehsil Rishabhdeo, District Udaipur.
114. Dinesh Kumar Vihat S/o Magan Lal Vihat, Aged About 27
Years, R/o Rata Pani Post Gamdi Ahada, District
Dungarpur.
115. Surendra Kumar Manat S/o Kodar Ji Manat, Aged About
46 Years, R/o Gumanpura Basti Ratapani, Tehsil
Bichhiwara, District Dungarpur.
116. Sita Kumari Meena D/o Ramchandra, Aged About 22
Years, R/o Unthel, Tehsil Arnod, District Pratapgarh.
117. Babu Lal Meena S/o Rakhama, Aged About 29 Years, R/o
Padliya, Post Kachotiya, Tehsil Pipalkhunt, District
Pratapgarh.
118. Ramesh Chand Bhil S/o Chunni Lal Bhil, Aged About 41
Years, R/o Kirat Post Damana, Tehsil Jhadol, District
Udaipur.
119. Anil Kumar Meena S/o Mohan Lal Meena, Aged About 30
Years, R/o Larathi, Tehsil Kherwara, District Udaipur.
120. Mahendra Kumar Vadera S/o Thawar Chand, Aged About
32 Years, R/o Dhdhawali, Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
121. Sugna Vadera D/o Jagmal Vadera, Aged About 33 Years,
R/o Chechlaya Post Gorana, Tehsil Jhadol, District
Udaipur.
122. Narayan Lal Bhagora S/o Nathu Bhagora, Aged About 35
Years, R/o Bhagora Pada Badana, Tehsil Ghatol, District
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM)
(9 of 10) [CW-11010/2019]
Banswara.
123. Tulsi Kumari Charpota D/o Amraji, Aged About 34 Years,
R/o Dayot Pada, Tehsil Ghatol, District Banswara.
124. Nana Lal Loor S/o Hariram Loor, Aged About 27 Years,
R/o Badarana Tehsil Jhadol, District Udaipur.
----Petitioners
Versus
1. State Of Rajasthan, Through Secretary, Department Of
Secondary Education, Government Of Rajasthan, Jaipur.
2. Director, Elementary Education, Bikaner.
3. Chief Executive Officer, Zila Parishad, Banswara.
4. Chief Executive Officer, Zila Parishad, Udaipur.
5. Chief Executive Officer, Zila Parishad Dungarpur.
6. Chief Executive Officer, Zila Parishad, Pratapgarh.
----Respondents
For Petitioner(s) : Mr. Jogendra Singh.
For Respondent(s) :
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN BHANSALI
Order 26/07/2019 This writ petition has been filed by the petitioners essentially seeking similar directions as given in the case of Kamlesh Kalasua & Ors. v. State of Raj. & Ors.: SBCW No.13016/2018, decided on 25.03.2019.
This Court while deciding the case of Kamlesh Kalasua (supra) directed as under:-
"Consequently, the writ petitions filed by the petitioners are allowed. The respondents are directed to redraw the merit list pursuant to the advertisement dated 12.04.2018 for Teacher Gr.III (Level-I) for TSP area based on the principles laid down herein-before.
It is made clear that except for the marks obtained by the ST candidates of Scheduled Areas in (Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM) (10 of 10) [CW-11010/2019] the REET/RTET, the restrictions on migration as applicable, would apply. On redrawing the merit list and on migrating the eligible candidates presently selected against the TSP (ST) category to TSP (General) category, the vacancies which occur in TSP(ST) category be filled up by the eligible candidates. Those candidates, who are now selected pursuant to the above exercise, would be entitled to all notional benefits based on the appointment accorded to the candidates, whose names appeared in the select list dated 01.06.2018. However, the candidates would be entitled to monitory benefits from the date they are accorded appointment by the respondents.
The entire exercise be undertaken and concluded by the respondents within a period of two months from the date of this order."
A perusal of the above direction would indicate that the direction is neither petitioners' specific nor subject specific and, therefore, apparently there is no cause for the petitioners, who have approached this Court seeking similar relief as granted in the case of Kamlesh Kalasua (supra).
In view thereof, no directions are required to be issued in the present writ petition as the entire subject matter stands governed by the above order.
The petition stands disposed of accordingly.
(ARUN BHANSALI),J 33-Rmathur/-
(Downloaded on 02/09/2019 at 12:29:21 AM) Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)