Central Administrative Tribunal - Mumbai
Rajendra Ramchandra Gandhi vs M/O Finance on 26 June, 2019
oe : : 4 C4 Ma BIGMNDIG IG TS VINISTRATIVED PRIBUNAL PBA AN No 21 O/S0S9S/2019 . y ~ 3 CH OF . . Date af Decision: 26" June, 2019 CORAM? RVEIAYRUATAN, TEMBER (4) RUN. SINGH, MEMBER (2) i. Rajendra Ramchandra Gandhi, working as Appraiser at New Custom House, Sallard fo, Mainbal and esidlx ng at 4/88, New Custaum Quarters, "ive 2, Matunga, Mumbai 400 019. I r Fy © 2. Bhaskar H Paunikar, S working a8 Appraiser at New Cusiom House, Batlard Estate, Mumbai and reanling at B-102, Ganeatri Apot., 1S Floor Gpo. Prasad Hotel, Tisgaon Naka, Kaly an (Rast), Dist. Thane 42 $306. . Appllerris (hy Advecate Shri Fieky Nagran u VERSUS lL. Lhnon of fadia, through Seeretary to Government of India, Mirustry of Pinance, Department of Revenne, North Block, New Delhi 110 OG1. 2. Charman, Central Be ard 0 oF Exeise o& Customs, O Ministry of Finance, 0 epariment P Revenae North Blo ok, New Delhi 110 O01. 3, Principal Commr, OF Customs (Gen A). New Custom House, Ballard Estate Mumbai 400 001, New Dethi L1G 066. wo - Respeaderis ORDER (Oral)
Per: Ro aykumar, Mdember £4) Heard the learned counsel far the apriicant.
a, The applicant has filed this OR under Seotion ef the Administrative Tribunals a oh we 5 ty . tpt Oo @ +) may act ra ret ert 15 AY i Lg fy ' +) | he a a oN Q 13 cs s " n vO v wo Ag NS 4 4 we : y wed dat gt " of wy * ea o A @ Qe os bed nan 2 ie) seed wer} A y us a , i 2 5 cs SD La E % bet #2 7 oy 4 "4 oa oe) aS ft a yD re . i 4 "ef gS a @ $} et, yy ta cs see is : i vt ae ie 0 oy ey A ® 3 etoort (Eg ~ 6h ip 0 C y t * t3 : ° : ms i" : i we "
ke it "3 g oO sel i a 2 43 "en ° ort aad ) > " ai i : si) : Lt ig Saat oe vd i ai = 2 Gi td ° Mi wh a we S | yy re co } " "4 wy " apy Ba a ee oo Cs v a iz 5 " a a L
2 a ° S a + -- uy a m 3 hd oo y cet a 1 w ue xy Sn 43 Sy yt Gh ai ct Ye 43 ie ma m +4 " "? 4 id i ad 5 hs ae Z crn nee ro tw Oy aod greed Go ' fon tet ' 3 eged y G £5 co a od : a -- ved G a % 3 Ly Ka vod . peed Sf os " . a, topee en * an iA :
tt eG sO 4 ~ im go 8 8 oe © ] 04 hy cng o ng , cn it we oS i 'S on "i iG ip Z yay ' a a : ' " :
* . , < ued os v 4? ' of s v 4 "4 ra (rs ee &. wy 3% on ved ¢ : at a he . wee oy eM Boy s we ot wo FG gm toe 7 re uD co ad e ey wet rw 4 UL 5 ret "4 tM 43 fed 5 od * "ye m & 4D rs ~ t a q a " 5 CO 5 aed ut y . at ra) co co MN ae 4 vy a) «5 3 wy a ao wee > 5 aa + is a ged et 5 "Ys us a - 6 5 "s | e f wy eA Se "yy ong el vis on oO i ne + - i «3 or x Ld Y Lh r4 i 4d , > 'et a) i oy Pe aj - ops gy a Pog aes Q ~ 8 8 * 7 a co cf A on « ced i oe Ye 4 a fa ~ 2 ae) O i) an L) C ne Y » of GP ae ei reget . . ed "s id wy oe ra) fs 5 eN rg Le wp Ay en os 4 i wy ot i ; a oe 2 ble eh Ys cde oA a wo Gy ue ive i 1G bs Os iy 4 vA QZ wD ia oF ea Oy a Ld Y it * ved iB " ™ gy
44 oj ayel bed ee ° : ; ic ER red "rt mt te y G & G o eh Oo 3 it rt 2 4a A bb aoe Y rer wert ' ed 4 ect Pid eh oF g eee ot tb + os a gw mo Og ed 5 OS a me y e gj 44 of oe te y ra) Sef OB U £3 4 syed ee as on an . ml Oo % ag 5 wn " «ed te 6 is ad a i 43 fe " % iy ie ~ eel: wt m Os LA vay ws D ¥ G t3 % i ms ve iy ra vd "4 fet tC rs Meg co oo "se ved o . Z ry fay ce Om ' i bay 3 G romp a oy G A r wn pod a oo % i a x ea td m5 ' ® ' Et @ i © osee4 © 6) ms i i "C3 g aoe uw ON 4; wt Sdy Cy ret Pee, , tr; i ot oly - beet ~ g cS ee ae rr ts w y f re - ° oe we 1 Med it . 54 G wh wn g et OF Fy scp * fx ; os rh i re - 2 me Ch res oy z a < tad <4 a or 2 @ "fl a o 4 ee ro ot ns $3 C3 Ch he e vy a 3 ¢ gj eapee a wae "i on weed 1 xo rae cis ons 42 03. g ae SA aft © ways 10 Dp + wy Sod iy a3 hot ay « \ 4 ay ay i g ue be om § ca da oO a ' 5 oo i a OU ra % : Hl CH ee! vod "0 in fe} i at ny et *O "4 eet wet . Oo Eee) Ay whet » syed g " ~ - :E DO ew Mm Me Mw OO HS "fh mo 6 bo 4 HS ; ' * g 4 ;
UES a ms Es wh an wy Q a w ~ ot "tn, my ed a3 ced oy a cs wy KS ved a a ce = 0 #] x os ry Re a . a as 8 43 at ad ~ 5 os ery a crs 24 . 0 +A oD " ey ea a é ee . wy C. ~ mg oS ry ' "t s fn nh cones Bg os "3 ved ea is YL O o ve ire SS 45 : eo : a ar Sn 7 "ce uo a "4 is 3 i $4 o + nen ag a ' : a a _ i oe > as oy ah me "A 3 +4 C} tra? era 4 rt 6 ot gy 3 " "Gam oe *, i f $ 4 rey, 3 a P bei we fobs ci ad "ch oo Bae 8 Ss ! 3 mt a + ou u wm td a nae . mo ~ a o a ny oe Fas ted 3 a c Soy " w 33
4. ee rf uu "75 % a 4) 'horad at y md ey me oy 4 JA aed ot "4 fy + oO a) ws a Get bs : 6 fn ior be ~ p? ad ns ' ne ved is) Ma ae a = ~~ @ + et om ™ e a od 3 re i @ .
* 2 } Zs ? ' C3 a Le ved i * fly (ad hed <i Bed uy * Py a 6 2) 4 o 3 G aS 3 O tt i oh on a Lo bey G} : 3 Hed " ~"
L Os me eS 2 Ny el Q , ~~ oe goog "i wr ae csar a Ne 2 hee ans oS a ay 4 fea Cy r 4 weed cc on 64 ae h 3 O O os LO} > rs a@ ° oo oy cs ct et «ed 4 to ren aE fot ay ape e remy s | M ay ats te ee ii ory : mene 4 . ' + Og Fo Seen ws wD ty tase oO 3 oD Lad " eae. od oo 2s G3 yon ki we bee % ' 5 = he A oa ¢ be oO ' 1 oo, 8 _ ° Sook . cs ay 4 pies" | aos sy cot 4 3 *; ic i 4d @ xe 5, mens lee 1 see a ; it 2 5 we ew 3 a " ted fe a fav "aoe o mM Md ~ CG me ~ j ve ghee Bag 6 o m 4. 8 A 2 a i vel 4 sr Q A tis en Oo &® BP me @ Gort uM em a " ny U3 Ld 4 XS oy Dy * "Yong ag a "KG veg S 4 a Be O24 a4 2 'be fg "ee E eH oS rowed 3) a a 4 "O Oo "ene wd