Karnataka High Court
Smt Sunanda W/O Bharat Naik vs Bharat Naik S/O Sakrappa Naik on 31 January, 2011
EEK?" '§'E---IE E["iI€}§--E {?{}i,,?R'£" OE' KA_§{§'€A'£'A}§;X {f§.E42£Z"£.;-'I"1_"' E:3I.€Z1'€Ci'E---I H1" €}{fl,.£:$:'a§1{{}i¥ _' _' Ef3aia.*{i *é:hi§s; I,E"z§:% 3':-'"'? £122}? <>§Q,!a.:":.z.;a3;:°§,-23 20% E ' ' I' ' E--f§E.§E'{}RE*3 Ts--iii H<)1x_?*}:_%:.,;:-": ?v'£§%2.JLEE§'"I"E€3I§ .:'§§'€;:%E',_§ wag:-;%$_:2;?:;.%';v. 2*-2:I>:;.«-'cf Nz}. 155;'2r;:i:;fa E-3EZ'.E'¥£-'E3E1'€: "
E . S:11i:.S:m21:1{ia , 'fix-";' <}.E3h21:re1?;: Nzziii, Age ab<>a.:i: 3i §:*f;':£1.I'S. ' Occ: AdV<)<:ai;€:, " 'M , R,f<>,CI /{}.,$§1E1I3E.1Si11§§}"i R;1f{ h€3C}§; ._ Eia.ri,1n<3.s}:1 N 21§_3;211.1?; E.'5€&1}f"S£1f' f'viIa1::;:i3ZL1*-:.__ <;.F€?'V§fé':},I"-'ii }f€<}z2.d?," €}i;j;.§'Er:2::2:'%-jilah ' V' an ._ I _. ._ V 24 §IgiisE1:.'12uri, Df /'£7.e1:*;1"i.fi';:ii3r;:.} "
zigaa "
_M.i:mr;._Sm{:§3,Ai:*;_§.z':§):';A v _ _ h by hear V:"3a;E'.'r.1;r2j;3 {Z4 a~.1§;;;:f€fé:::.%'*1'--.zu':{i 211€}'i'h'L";}Z" i;E':.s;=r 'EM-3% ps::€£:iii:;;< >':'2.;<:.*."3:i' _ " ' Sm? K S iJE.§T2.I:'§_1'1'€f8& s.xig' ~:};._Ef%E:%.a:'*~.:é:_~'{,V E\FaiE<; * _ ' Gd Pe€;£i':£e:3:1sm'-5-5 {.E%'%y_ Sf': «i{§.E'%a;:%'i:é::'}:§;2_§ 'E§_:?1mz1.:"",, Adv fog" :E§ri '\;'€;%e:"@s;§"; B E3E1§J,i§:, fxaiz»-:3 :X.N§'}1 _Ii'§h;':_2°:2:% E'sE:%:E}<;. ::;',5{_:;f:§§;:;:E§s'as*g};__>;: ;?\§2;2i.}{y szixytié §:3€%§_,r _;rz:£:=3. {Eat:{i?2:5r*:1é<:r2fl §Zz":§;§:§.:2€~:&::", ' :3';-531$. ?:§;:§ :1 :"a.:"' Néézyjszzz, 2" g' 9. §.{:,::':1¥Ess:c rs: '§'zmx:i;:2( K'§'€;.€?£i'~§f;_.h.7 . W4 :' :'''fi?{{:;§.3§:s~a§. ,, R€i5~;%§}{Z}§'E §i:*::::$;, ' 3?: 'J ?€gt§.<E21§g<_;1,§ {Egan !%.{ii:Z} éfxk I») 'I'h.Ess; E42P}~"'C is; fiiegi. 1..1:ci:<:§e'z' E§é:%:::':§::£<:>1'z 19(4) mi" §?'.221miEy {",'<:u:'{ F101;, :*21$;.im.'>" {:3 II1{3Ci.if¥' the in: 31.:;'::r':e?:{i ordesr cimezri 2'?¢E§.2C?GE§ ., E5 , gyzzsaséigi E313; the F'z::;r:i.Ij;' {f:m.zri. afzzcigeé at". G1.z§'r>:a.rg_:j2z in C11, E'viis<:. N<3.4?;'2Gf§5 ems? {Tf{."§'I'}.E3é?qL.1€31'1?Ij€ E33 plezrzséégi tic} €:':I:":.21..:2<:::'~.329 zr2f1221':%"}.'é:<3:12?:.:'1<%€: 2£n2<)uI';€':. _p22;!2z.}3Ie 133;-' E1151 ea :*r:?s-§;p<3:1:."i€:I";E. .f£g<f;'-_i1.E*j:_r:=; ;;3<%i:§t.i<>:'1&:.r5~;: at $4159. §£}.GG{};'«« §:>..m. E0 €z1<:E";. GE' £1335: p{%'E.it;i{}§j'}._£§::'§3 ."_ '2 "i"I':is RPFC c::«:>mi1':g 0:"; E1:::" 11 ea-1.:'ing__§ §:E":is§ {§21y';.__'E,h«:j*»{fk:>€13:"é:
§}a_.&e;s:':seci t:.he::= §*<:;§1G"».x.ri:'?:g-.'"{:
ORi')EZR "i":'1e'3 pe{4i:.i{me;"s in C:'LMi:3(:';' §€'.:}z.4'??'2.é0F§ the Ee:am.<3{§ Di5si:1'i<:~t. Jugigez {;';hlE3z::*g22 {}1€3rei:3;1i?:°i,éé'r .:*e:f%3.;"r¢3:<:§ £10 3.5.-is «*¥5"TaxIii3Yi.,'%f30iJiXfi*.A '_£T::r sahafl} have
-Sfihighii far e3:'zhz:m:é:%1:1<:w':t in éficgf'gziiézi.::"i'£2g§';;:1;1:";(:::. fé-:'v¢a1'<:ie:i in iiheér fa_'v0ur by fhgif in téaigé Said <:aSs:.
The Eérgaiiy :C{}?;E%T'fL V 5-£112; <2? RSSFSO ;'-- §:>-m. in £235;-*{:::.:r 01?' _§;:<§i:i§:.E.{;;L.%i<":=zf_:' §'J,:>",;.§AA":;3#%i€i5.»LV Rs;,8G€}/'~ gm. in f2w<:rur cf EA.':={.'kfZ'f'°"é§'3V's'g3{'".VEV:'Efi"'3v3"'{f"i3i};" bséiizgg: file wife 21:16: nr:m.€:::' {ism *5;
2, E~ia%;::_:':fij I=%;§'3e a2:"g1.::T;:2<:=:'1i::2~'; GE Sift'. '€63-,€::'e.%;%.ss;}': E3 Pazéiig " '§§::%.v:';;"3.3_.{>."-=:§n <':<>:m:hs.:.€E fin' Iiihe z*m:i:+;:fz}:": p<€=i:ii,§<:s:'mr§ 21:':(;"£ Sr: R 'K,-' ._E;::*§;.:g§::2:s;{:§.:7«.,5E::3%e:a:'mé<§ <_:<_}L,::_'1:a:::E §":i:ar §;§'1{f :*£;?s%;-;§:2{"3.:'*:<i;e§'1§;;e HELQ:
ii} U:':£i<_}z2'£3t;.:::z:§l,'§5 t".E':e £?22m'2i§}«' Cmgrt. é?x@r<tiss<%é,_ m_§1..£i"E°5i§{fi{"_§?,§{}I'1 {<5 g};:'a:'":_€: mami;e::"::'1g7:.:f;::€ by V'Erft,.;i.€:?_ V S€T*{'fi§'.i{7J§'1 i?' if €;%'1<:> fizéii. E: is; by Viz'§:1.::? of ;Ef'}'é'iI§'{..?::iZ),EiT!1"*2 '}'{2}{a} of tihe Adi. '(hm that E'2;.:j;1i}},;' C_;:£%_ii'"i;' '_ j1.zr§s;::E;i<:*;,i£:s1': £10 é;'?Xe:',I"{?§:--S§EE jg3<:sxws_rs{=_{>f" ,2'sr?E;iggi':;::i}aj::§:- €:;=": izhisz I'f;'5§_§E1.I"{i. W_he:'1 $:=z<:t:ie:f::j.1_ 12E§{v;'é*:A)"~:3f €7f€3ci'<é prcsitribes 126(2) of i:he.=t iifiiéiiéfi pzfiss.-:<t:'i.b§%3 '-i"hi {;%"
pm<::<3%d'z1r€ "E53 ':38 '§'<::i}0§va2€i 1'€é_§§aifd.,i:::g§ r:3:":e:i:*<i¥.i;1;_g..'E<)f' {;'.'%£".id€;'.Z1Cf E12. 21 g):"c)r;:<;*:c;*,%:E--§;1':;_;f_ i.£";iii§§1;'§'v€3C}v-- E;E1;f£"§f;'}:' Sstcigiaasz 221%} t.he::;:'e{)f and X-Vi'1.§_'f.1'} Se:g::I..*Léf_;?n ;"~:._'<;s1'f' firie Am:
£331? {}i1t'}.E-3 'thai: t._f:%;<:%'gg:éj<:vié=;i<m§. {:»i t...h'{e9§3g:;<:is3Vf'ssh21.iE zipgsiy ':3 £.hz: ;3:'"<:»<::_.a«':{::*i:%.;1_*;:g;T,% f;,:i'2ci§::f€?_i":eipi:«é§s" «:3»? the Czzxie be:=fc>:'§: t':E*:tfi%"'?:%.;§;f:,§13,:' €';":€')i:::'**L.~, i'i: £5 zifiéézi' i:E'2::1.': izhzyzzgh the:
pz*<3(:s::€:{£ingg is: é:ii's;.';éfz»:;§:9{é v£ffé%::=fcVi§z1"€;:_ the': Family Cc>':2z'%: and 310:: 21 E\x§2i§-_g'i.s1:;.:'21£;€%'; §.i'; 2-': §3:;"<3::é::;é<i§1":(;g; ugzciész" S¢<:'::i€}1"; 32.5 r«",=;$'"»19',}":§? éL"s3.:fE»a%;'é'}1<:é' .E<"a iii}? €:"§::r~":L:r*:: 'i::m::::1{i £10 'V"~§"::1§<:mg°fig-:<:% p:f<)<:a?{ié::%:%"'p:"e§:<:;*iE:>§e<£ in S&<:i;i{>:1§.26 <3?
iiiifzzis'"£§.<}{§€?;"é;%;>Eézr 21:»; £37265 mzzmfiizzg af €'«J§{§€3'E£'.'é;% is <2<::"1 €,~=::::r:1<::iEifq;._IfE:i%:*E': is 22:} £;:.M':s~3€é{};'2 of i§3{§{}§1$3§S§i{?£1{E_"'y"
Ei;g%€:.z€%@.s?:'1..__'i:%?:::f: g§2*::_::r.§_§;§{}z':s <>§f fiific Eaifiii £2-iiéfi *£%1€: éiaéziszé <32"
" éiE':.:3 <}va":'*v;§ffi§c£E:':g§ §:fi%;=:<:*.'§: :3? {mt p:'<;vé$§:}§2ss of *;:he:=% z'5§~:::i: in "«§:°%::§%:?%e:?~_:":z':v;% 251:; §§€:%g':*i.i<;:':1 126 sf €h.<;=.=. Cozzie {§3*22.§°:5-2 -- 3} §'}éi§i"?;{:* emzi {%:s.Eiim_'__{ z2p::m {E10 pa'-%'z.iE.i<>:'1€2r ':10 fiizsr 21:':
21i'i7ici2-$31.1" faigiily ii'}.eg2;;¢iE anei t:m?1*<:r:f%'>':*<:~ i;E1%;%: or{'§e:z° E1.Ei§}§ '::.<3 bi': 5?\{§.'{. ziaigia s:2<>ié2E:§ am. t:§';21"{ g;ro::1mi% zemd §:"1;"=. 'é'E'12':€: \:E<:%2a»* «:3? fizi-:: §1"££3.'E".'€'.E?§' E:.h<;%:'& mi: E"i{'3{3€E%E§E€§T,§£' -f€:%;2~ :%1'zi<3.r fi'1':'.<; a.:r:3; kiwi <2? di§v?{'.'1..1.S~é§é§§{3I'E in ;"€§2:i:.i<>:': jj ' .z:':i-?:'i.%T:.5.; of the pm: iE.)rw2::_':'r;ir3{§ by 111%:
'1'?/:e:;"€~sf°(>rs& ii: is; aticzézzr i'.E321'£; this §£1€.*;:+;%::.{_i 'E*a31'11*.Ey C<m:f":. :<:sh<m.1e:§ be :?:eE; :i:'l"2{:"'. 'E'}A€f£2.~';?;.<L?.I"
s;hm.:i{i %:><;:< :7~:3:miE;E;s::c§ %>;~u':k 3,2,6'jv§T'~.§*4J'.if,ET§I3: 1£iir§?{i:€1vi'{}'§};'*€{}H f{}.H{}V=z' :';E:_<:r pm:;::3z:iu:'e ;3:°<~,>s;<:.:*£b§}.Lé:E«.;'¥fi>_=?}.='. uSe<§{:1{>;:V§ 'i'f2;6 g{>f the: Cadés zmd fi"?:u{;',i"€f~'.2'3:§§',%:.'.'.:£"'~."'§3I{'{§€%é%;?%i"'i§} §§is:g:><;:s3é3VV:<:>A§.'7f,E*;.c3 ::a.§s€-3 zicéiizynfizig '{1} E2?:_ut"
3.1, R€iS €ai:é'.si"m§1*x : '£'.«€"%-H52-'.*"~¢'u",'l§'{1€-1*""V E; §*:: Vzéijemé €i€<:§s3;<.:»n 0f the Di*v*iE.'~3§{}"ETi ifiezigth .3}? fEv'}"1'§..°';§.'*..€:{?§%..'§§"Z;, Ev...g1f}?1-' 0%" Eihe <:<}r:s's%d§~_>1*€::% <>pim?:2r2; t.E':a1':: ::;h£;% E<'a1mi§§rL<€£a>:.m4ii" <:'{_;:'ns:;i:§':;.i:é{E s<iI*i.£>a.1;e=; <e:_°:m':" in £?1{',(1é3pt§§§.g{_§ %::h_a=_-3 az§'f§c§2§3?:i' <0? *: §?1'::*:__ Vp<i*%;.ii,3£e:mr:::" 21%; ha' :3:*v§£i€%§1<":t2 in €;?Z'*:é3;v§f':";iE?::8;'§.i§§}:'.;:iZ';rj{:L§T1§%?.§ aimii ii: <:<>:n1:*s1?i:é:€:{£ fa: 1:*i;E':€r sse:'£m,z§ ezrmr Ea':
:*::%c:£>:'{%i';';_;§;'--$19:,fi.f§:"3;€2§€fe:?: <72? '§',§'.'};€;'? g><';:€V:§é.§e:>'n<":':":'~; in §.'}}%'3, €ibft§{3}ZTi{.'.€Z? of the T:<:*:32:g::3§:1§f§e.:éi; z V'%a{'ii,§'1_:;}:.: :1 re::f:{}:"<E§;":;§ its; s§a%;.is2~:§;:a{;:%.§<>r: Ehzéfii %:.§::& C '1a='.:?$ §}ij§§1.{:¥.i%:'3.§; v.:;;a5T-g =;¥'§§Ef§,:iE§? 23.2*{;>iéE:':;§ 3::-7;"<:§{:i*:: {:::'§"' w§'§§f1.fl§js,--' V_'j:I:::§;§;Eé;:{:'§'§§§':gg; E9 E?;§'ié2fE"§{T§ t:E'";:=:r {§f<::z.::'%; on 'é.?:é:i< iiiéfifi? £321.": W':fT2:.§{'.":E'": $2.21: é%;;.:%--ee w_..=A, a**~---A5: ""' fi:':a'E <>:*v:i::r ":0 '£35: p22s~.=,:s~;;<::d Ei3y *€§":.<~é E*="2';1.m..iEy <ii<>m"§"... .E-£<::mt§::3 '£1226 §'z>}i<}:>s:'img§:
{}R.Ef)E:R "§"E1e ;'ev:?:+si{>':3 p<:ii'£'.f§z,>':1 £53 2;11§(:>W<a>{§, ff ' i_111p2.2§;r:¢%€i JL:z:§gma:;*r1E: azzii C».r§i£3r_ pa5s$e<:i '$3; the §'21.:11§._"E§«* Ce:)::.:"*£: is :§.1§::':'?i_fi:;§f' 'I'he mai:i:m" 11%: E'~i*:'fi"i€i§".3€i€d €19 '%v_%j1::::._§2z:"%iiv§§';g_ cL'i<.f:f;z'»:{§ 21 d§r<~3<:i:§<3r; is r*e:<:<>z'=:i ::*;i{iarz§:V:%.J: T-;%}.;;r§:V:if%:8 fir": sET:"§c:E: <:om_pi_i21m_*;s;': 'wix%:3i; Seciéiimz $263.29 {bf C.vrQ2'f%{3___ 8%" this rnzauin':.€:'1':;':'fi:i:-ct inQ1-<i£f<}é?¥f§:;;:":;:e w':Z%:'h Ezmf. That :"e:e~:»p::»£'1€?§.§:r1'-£:,' *hu's;ba.z'2d €35 'Shes: W §}£iEili§.i€)E1€§"'"§'§EaZ§ £"z§;'?;-_E3€'é":.* cf:.§:»§{iTf,i{}1'1e%I' N02. {:h€ :"nin£3r §Ea.::g5§'_;:é:--:*.:j, s;§*:Va;;.3,'V1AA';;:'2:§I fin {.§*";:;>::;1 «:33: €§€":f}(}S§'£i wiih i:_E3e '=F'4 xi;-iii? :,j:Zic::u.t§f§'. ea H:§*i.::"at:2' <3i' R3, 7;{},i}@Gg'-- xxg-*ii;h§n fm.;:° *'?i~;.-=5:-5 '§';:<§js:<3;E,Ar:;éii;r:,=§,z €',<.}2a?;;::"{§&a a22;r:'::-éerars otf EE"iEi§Z":§Z€f§1E:EE"£€f{'?
2:33;? E3213? :19 i'.E'2{:%:1/1. §%;5;«;"E,GG®;'¥ €'3'%fE":?."}--'"
:z'1<}:§€?.E'2 ..__'i'.{fi:%;%?;=:':'{.§sé; €'.ii.éF§"f:?§'1.§ EE'E.§f-ii§E§'.€'3§'"i2£E§{3€ p{*:§":€i§:'3§_§ " '{%§:;s§3<;sis§sE.V__ E}? zfiaaé ':':z;;2£:"2i.:%':3;*::_'é<7:: p§::€:§%:33<:>:.':_ 2;::'fs.{:E §_E'":£r~. .. n _, ...»./ Wt -
:?m:;Z;"<3 22rn<é1mi' $0 paiii =:>z' €§{?p€}Sii'C(§ by him safizzii ':39 21€i;'1.2ss.mci '{,{}wa:"€i;s: E31E'zii'1'{I€£'?Fl£3.fl{'i€;'f 'éihzzi ztray be Ezeiti }}€§.}"EEZ'f§EE: E33; him e:"£;Zm~:° to Eyath iihca pe'{:it.ie:3:':c3:fs:; in"
21" }}t;éi.i%i<>:'1<3:' {xii}; in {'{?I'i'}1S of the fixlai {}r{ic=%1f_.i§V;:€§"i*:§:%_' ' gazzaesegi in '£T.h:=: f~T§2:ii{§ <:2»,1.esr:. N0 ()§'£,§£*,E' ';fi§:% '§('} {::<§:»'si'js.»; :: , Simfre it old EIIEIIEGI', 'ilhif E§iSp{)E_-36 :3»? *Lb:';% 82131:? 3.33 €éx;g%3§i'§..§;§c3L2.;§é}§? pw3§7era:b§y wfihizz f(}1.E§'_.§H(}I1§b.g;A."f3C{E"{}A "€§a1::<:J§c3E' .E.'€3(T':€'fIi§}§ {xf stopy' of this .
2% zéopy csf this :>;T'§i{-%:f Sifiléfiiv'§Z§€frV:;f%a£§:fi'E1: ff.}i'i.,§T};."§'§§£§3L €10 iihss §?'afz;1:1i§}f Cimrii Ebg' 2Z:1§'};3r;{1§::i":§.;é¥%": 21:95'<?e:in1p'E:ar1{f€%';'V B€)i1E"§ $1.:-"=:' pé;.r€'.ié:t::s_ :SS§ §f2iHV4"é1§;§'pii'£1§' 'ir3€fi3:3;*<>. fi3.€;": Famiiy Ceazré:
1,v:§.1':§'}€:':';__:,%f.. 21: .3'"::,z' fé§."E."?'.§ié3°,E"EiT§§'.'i§3§'¥ §'%:.'1 (MES. 20 E E . 3 § gag "
EEEEEGE ' ; AE§E%::'z':.