Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
C Samal vs Steel Authority Of India on 25 July, 2023
of 2019 £ DANO. 260/00308 Ooo VESGTS, d about amal, age 5 ¢ a arimial B "} ~Ve "?
dee PF OOS SAPD ot : ? f ¥ $ ms + ey Jane N Deputy "y te tain Mishra, |.
x x ' Hah £ espondernts:
ar tie & bE R pm} ns ? 3} rs 'i hoon ;
ooh i #, a "noond a pry a cass ms g :
Pramod Kumar Das, Memh B any.
2018 (A Copp Py > fa ee Naat "25 ; ts. aa pre a rey Id wed ae, r, as the .
POW Pay Gl SONTE i S x ry % qual a ahave eanthnu re Employes was ¢ i} eath, where g j < Ger ¢ ud § es af .
72°} ays ay 2S uch deperider ¢ & G Wi a pe then & wd MuTHE y Ry the Cor vu and the 4 fa 'a eee ; = e es eee 5a Hy eee on i Pope' oe oe Panga 5 we Eecead + hacags Sag heed otoee, cans an é ca "bed. peed ; ; cay tone ca wy Le vet ne bok om : ee gr 'aot 4 5 oat oe whee dad ws ihe anne 4 boned tad ae nd ~ he £ sage yee wae hy ad te wend Dane va wer, ee rap we Bp Ay Pants oat wines, aA oad. ee we Sen ay nea.
pot aap tithe aa weet a iy we "2 Foe ed ES Dn gs pee Fs ie - homes ve Ge pA on wes peed re twee wines ey ae oe. wes. yes, aera foe ane rene rae feos Mag geet we A oe oben od thee! eee weere net re ae on, woe ' Ee Hees nares , os pan Sty, Seed Gs ot a omen are " Le oe, es we, 4 o y * pao went tans ¢ ' 4 poe (OS So New ok pa ' oe on intent ns ast, o~ Bp Ft i Ly Wy ES yor ite Ke aa vet : a aye, on, ty eee Son 'od ccuaa' awe te nae: or bon cS bes, Bae book yan we Spe peed on ne niet a rs not hee a4 aS Sy, er. See ans wine: is, : wees, lod: ond : CR apy cB ey wn ress tree Sena: 'al ween 108 Sona eee x as 2 oad sa fe] tot Meee. roy boat vite ¥ rar a o te fm eee eS on bey te ot a eal woe gt a er BS a3 A Sat Ment oe as, fe pict cS Ca on, So "ES n. as " a am Pcs! net roe e oy Sot? if g Be ae, tan 2 eS ae fos ee ne od oy Ft as "se oy i, ona' A neh poe Fond nee: ft CS mead = Me no SA ted Cn ead ae wae wy 5 a woneks * we Ly ake P a ee 'nadt mpd é eA 3 con nad t z 3 he ona hed: "ah wt Top icend 2 cage we; ke woud Pee x . ors ' he 23 ore pian ; "« re bees: ba ty Pees os re ees Nee mie 5 * pees ee Bett heat oe i, Bere, pei est " ed ad aes Sew, peng ates aa yom k # pan pon ret gre. bes] oo 'se 'haat fy. ae wet Tn on vw Leen: ye Noe oes tS pete Pa, "3 "asi we es 4, - » oe 3 Sear ehed & wet 3 Tie fe , re oo bea tt ee pes 3 ' - ceed fae) % of: gen = ee, bos ". Pi oad ¢ " eM Se sont eee aaa! es Lt we eee ' fis ween: ewe, we BOK pone ht wean, Sack a3 te Be ers bas og bod 'eh , pS ad pan "5 we we a rs eetine r, Fad no, Pe ae aed ep wh, ' Bea we, Oe ete, reat a Me ee ied res cot ween PA sp caoad aD on, pe : pics " hes mn baal ae pears ue oe nae det ao eh be, we cae am oa , ai Re ee a Te ae oon et oo 'ond psa Z 2 . vee ek wa ep he open pa Prog wet Ma bet ~ re, rs, teed nl tet Bee we aod yee on wey " pay tS rd pene. er sew. Ly Socios Eat ontaer Sos ee ™, cad Ln rama ew, ane take hls Wa tn, we ca oo call pee. ton. wines sitter oe 'eet aT "enna pee per yee ae! Soe po ee es pa 3 ae Nera whee Spee fond fon coe ge ' ceggie> Mied sees ig "e me ee « Fee eek eer pagd weet wo ait y ie, 5 - ree thy oan ¥ 2 ap tae we oe bas x ws oo ene - 4 bod iors a POS ens wnee Hs 7 , : 3 "nn a ae rat She feed AGP. yt ' oo. he a3 gE er 'cat Sat canal on. pars ets ge aged tee pe the apo fey inna! bens * ed . tne 04 "A on Gb Sat go we Bp oe io wes OO ifs ve es "Sabon decd ge pgs Reed an cee rd 8 Poa oe. ay Sy S a ty eed: pbeds * Fes eeg post ve od fone Nae wget "ot oo a ? 4 tae 3 wy beck i) "tt we a3 me bes Pe ee id at wee Sat os, e ie BY apes Seat ewes pte a tp ths a "7t a we, eset oa ° 14 hed eed ae ei ee ae *. oS ¢ cad Ca <7 he syed 65 s nyt book ied te tS passe) om re, " chet fed & ween oper hey Sa abd wy ad pon Wt "rheee wo, OG oe vo, a Ped . es Fasc as Seboed one vy oe a ted ht 14 ae SA nn & oan "he wer Lies pos sere wet ern as m= fe oe ea hee "SS " te we es pe we pot Sow, wheat aed bees shod th Sot "ae a hee , wee: ona a, ares then ey pa Ee TS oy nk Sa ms Snob on haaaad an i nee oe; Faaga ine, on pos pean ne Tp fon ae if ye wey che pa Pre: prod por poe 5 ee poe. bon ees Le God oe tg OR coon, "Kan peed ne peed on Pad £ bond Sect ve ' " 4 Dae a ee * e ew, feve oe a feo orn ab f " ¢ Soe ie athe pare a, v. Praed raced ie3 wit Tee ood bok 5 pe head. oat ae oi seid Spat re. ran, Lo fen veer, Woo an = ae ip mo Ry renee eee:
at A 0 wen, a a Che 7 a 564 We os oad we stonk se ne Pay Gos ape ie, oh: * a, oad Ae: oa 2 £3 'nae "wh hag . cans oe a: niet"
ge oe oy / oe n ree pio Pre Py er Big wr acl poe ee en i aks as ea cod he ea ad se wo te Eo eS Sy it wry we apt, poet ad Sod rere Padi wey mann: sy i ~, een, IO ete sors et oS Lt hk wd on pare "tee: ee Sep ere errs Pedi Pape ae 4 = ne Ae es 'set pw te om wy ae ae; baited haat Sit Foc pon ee oe at = Se ae Sah ty eens we eoek Pao ie ~ hy med ' pies. oe ; "ee 4 Whe 'awit 2 bed Ps 'od he , ce £3 ae pos pe oe an wee si con? anon . "ren: (tt lon bene) one Sa Riad aa Denad ook ated coaaeal pn ° Peed baie on, ecw 4 Sooe ood Seas Ngee * by . 66 ve on % s Leneers ny , be o as 2 wes teed no oe Nea "ait "ey hed Sine pe ie. ea Son mm 'teen * ined pan oy Und x ab, eee pa £05 yo wn rn ae eee ns ew Koad as < rant Bat pang gs ae OL, hoa ' er we aes cpeeve % 1 oe ° z pam rn » Oy sped sete, Be ony on oS oi wy Nat Lone pied rn if ee: my &%, ae is per wos net "moe ner? Bo ams ra pee, want Lt ot wy tS we tft a at L on eae et, sd edt i) si Ts Ws A 3 poe th os tock ron yen if Aa po "hd Ls onaad at oA Oy zy hoes ' fab tb vane ay hk oe Brot pera Past , ae eigen ny ae mm baa laa we ine wet oo pal 5 wries . ed pee . ' ; haa' . P pies Bes ee oma? shee ore rs wet ON shoot toh we itp ox Pas , Oo] * ene Gotee Sai eo ea Ly 7 ow. seed eed te £ Shana asl ers ot Cecad? oS wr a a "aeee y ne ys pen: pee - Faas : + snes a nee 2 fh, 3 wy whet, oe be deol Aes "be eh Lap nieed, ae 'al? on on "adh pinen, 1 ug So weet yar xs ay vo ded aon 'ah wt, nope 03 rhea at an * as pw haw. veers £ ee "ont oy nod we. yen ' ? yee Cat 13 "fs Se ae 0S a bow yon, pees cand at "nat : Lt a3 ned ae vd oz ~ > fod he T6 t Ss P toed Fae ~ roma se ty oft ven on 1S ty ' ed a mann we aw Snap Nat : ween, need Sat wat ry ee feos pes 'ad pan ok 3 ve +, eA -- woes othea i, ad whe oa ot pa p01 a eee "4 ber 8) ed om had adh on pas ha when aod a] ~ a peed ee FS pa , Set rod oo eet La ood oy an x we 2 Sy es Lh pond et wrod pond w on, oy o ot ty. org "i ae 4; ~ viedk poo oy ; wy a an an. ae wi. Manoel , wd peed ia ee : Reet regen, i", raagl wees, vey nb, weeny ws ; gf Lt Rk 'eah cane) oad , > awl 'ned pated aed n ae prt aan m ¢ Lg nee * eee 7 . ve .
4 Br fo . bea a ey td on "res es pad oh "aed on Wee , ray 0S oa a} on 2 , fay pe, vopk wend t ond wi, iS gee ae) oone ¢ 4 : AS ft Pong Der "4 'ne re 5 bees) f z . he ae book yo nee r "taf WA Pacd ron foe " e be 4 wheel ness 'vad eed a ta frees pa eae fe ions sent os ia Ay ~ vate pa ra) a bed vpee pa tit Aes x 7 feveds, ped vetek rere tage Oud oer, ieee peed ee doe Shed par fans, _ w pate x po men om oan a3 ane ae ren, Ie es es cats Faas as, reed, ed - St Tey AOpAd. on, aa i ned ee ma? poe wa nt 2 sheet GP pe, £ pees al Poca me ea ae ae Peand ad ied 'cast ee pend pers von oh 5 one tpn 5 Sewvwet gee wry wee hi Brad 4, per} wee ; pee. sal ae. ot . oat . ee we feat Seat reel hs reve, reagi aA soot ry anet hood et ben, Pa en Soa. tov, a few aw x, at vee vee yee red foes ceed , Sens coe 4a ee, 'ead ga . ted al dae as) cae ioe4 4 a3 a, ec ial on, aw as tess iwi anes my ae hewi pad oe eee] ity As ne ths Pais wed as . 'cor een tp os pe-g Pa Nett "A, oS as raed "Kad pa wy poms ie ot * 'ne ered reed ot "ae food we oe 2 wr fs pa fee wre, ax 4 ic os pars aed whoo aS Tew ene Dew Seek ie ew etn pow [an hoe, a3 seen 'deed ; wy an' ae mn ned ~ an By wen we aa fa 'aah i raped A % ow, Eo 'ee! ae oy oe oe m y ue lees hep aes & pone ae net r ay et ae a ae yr! ot = base ind) reel a8 rer, Peeee ony Er che peewt ond we Nant wetete we ra past eet ad re aged : + ap) cot panen rae Le mt al ware ~~. red eee oe Z "ee 'eid, "see tA Ps cael ce Saas rises oS mo ead th ene, oS ~ on. oa on * om re, . tte a Ly ; A 2 es. aon o, oa van a £3 oe ar ° a ee arent a3 ae cee bet re "ee on a E heat o ¢ i . food f% is rr. wee aod Sed Oe ia ad Fane ae ad set caw) sree, beet - ons ms x ron Sob a =) foe on be bee fs on peal } ih, t ve ; oe Re 4, g os Saber eet ead fem) ay tt te fon inge tend 3 no con Be oe a4 on ow Bt oa y eres thy " Feed tena. wad Foal lead ene nds rr dood * 4 at we 7 " een weer, preneg oer! * BS heed = Shee i rata _ rae ated, 'ead wees neh tee, Ls on "ot Te pee, oy jeee uf Se, oa) Bed vid re et iste ye deod weed bie "tees, 'nad ae mn Le oa A len) wens doa bse foo 7 a ad pan 5 areas , z jaw an Ae yaad L = a whee ra) pont pe a ~ bok pan ws cont as ree oo sf ; phot doa A noe aon nee, ees, ban Nes, "ee Faddaa' pee 'saa career! im wees! owen, +44 om ihe aie a we Pat Aun oe eA on Ae wren Le 43 2 owen ms Caed ee ea at "range "3 wae. on, ws A it raed haat ; ¥ nen, wee aed, ine oy ve ye A ue mt me me vn oO co is os "my aagl nee pg ony ral rine, nea rons, 497 q Sat on, 2 we ca ing ad cae ar oat ; . Fes pa ners 'odes "eee, rm 0% we "eeaatt - ae aot ww he ng we "ad os Faced nd weed. ae thy pen, 'sek : : a , $ we iy eat . o~ va in ae paps cand 4 3 P >. Kas Coat ane teat fb % a ot leaded nape, 4 7 cong ee 2 te ares, i Le soot tel: beac : stand bee pon geod pie Saat z ay; od Fes! ge teed am po ee nek " 'nat ae fore Pad gre aa oe ete, caved 2 bead pe pens oo", aeeens peers rh tad wah x" t "ae, 3 met a ne ae few LA wre x "ae re Enea ed me we nae na the n pod sa oe ' wo ae Iyen Sad rae we ge ane as yw . oes pegs sere, ae haves ; eed o Regd roe) wa peer ; (hen, ' . ood: aw, : aS io a vt joa fee ee Be 'se oon seco ae Paad wea ™ ¢ nelson toed ' -- on. oo heey 'nae oe Aya - rm yee heed ns, -- wy nex ohn ye sess reg i OS - bows a6 ate, Se "< ae t wees ra oy zee ge es pon, rows oye ot fs ey 85 oe ted "ed Lo aad 3 . on, ' ' et 1 a ye o mee? fee yee es toed Cena ee oO haseod rons $7 on Ne? ine. Boot Fay} Le thy d i ~. os ge, ree, Ped seat pee xo en Pa wy a eres ees, ane wy pred ond eaowe Ca ne ae ee Gt are ok = rete Seeslas ns ane eee hs lesead th pa 3 4 O85 Mg "E fee pa peed , an, '<i od ' fess seed. whee eng, ; Seti pass a ia joe we, wen "newt ra Paid ay ey on ye ws is 'ned pedae ws, ae Fan is load oteee 3 debilitating disease! cal imealidation of an ra Yin paragraph 2.2 ee ergy ae neh ey ek FPO) SENsciched x disease[s| w Ww bn noe be cover od under the & ; ne the date an which she: Committees docle ye s 'madically hawaii'. Ho an cmployee dies duc to d ase or otherwise before declaration of 'medical invalidation' by the Committee then such death shall be conshlered as 'natural death' and the dependent family members shall not be considered for compassionate employment but may avail benefits wider Employees' Family Benefit Scheme, considered for compa: slonate employment However, the dependant family menibers may avail benelits ander EPESS ~.
Yeoyrrt be ee eb ey akyend ta das exgvl af Wt seep e obs Here is me diaarbt that chs scheme of POLL covers the y the dependent family member on grees weave yroomt fae i d by this Circular.
on sf a a see Fe Se Se gens A Pras AS TRS » Bara 24) of the aforesaid SONNEI, TELS are cy one of the dependant family members of an employee on his/her f medical Invahdatian', declared by a duly constituted Corrurities of the management for the can be granted cormpassionate enyvoyment and cane of the disease mentioned wake oD mn the Scheme is sidiering from Incapacitative Cardiac Disease, Le. (i) ischaemic Neat » Here pi this cane, i is not the case of the applicants that the deceased empleyvee was with any such disease and was declared medically invalid by the medical board fcommmittes before his death, Rather, the employer was admitted to haspital at G30 am and in a very short thre he died at we of death as reflected in the OV.1 am an the same day and the « x death certy fe (8/1) is cardia respiratory failure. As per para 2.2 of the aforesaid Scheme, since the enyployee's death was sudden and he ie os as yrot under treatment hur the disease mentioned therel Kes oe eet ene ws ptt oe ae on VG wee pees & " in a iy, apm om cans as oe yer Base pair 5 Soe "ee root heel aS * eed nnninns eo Wane, Ger aes ae onaae ft % oa we ees had pees et ; ea F bg ae i aaa oes, won = ee e. pos:
me work pas hs ete pan, ; ee nein re my noo me a noes oo ee "
Feng ice Feat ees. oa ee foes en i ot, 4 Me 4 oe ke ce = . bot Chem es eames . Ss. BS Pn oan 7 Sede ee ae) oonnae® y Poni ra 4 % 5 tt ee Ca age weet oes % " Escien ved ele, ", cate os " ee a teat oe LZ aes yee TS apn. nite ot ones H 'epee. oe weees 2 ont F ghlin Plbre aaa gas ", 2 Res Ue ak oy pee Sey ered pee Fd { BS a fo Be 4 \ ae So °ad .t fabs ee. thet reo, vied $4 oe owen ee Se ES sesh a8 oh a orn Fh * 2 read 'nepat? hd ag oes hes Ag ed yor pow Aes ye 4 4 gt ° ate ne Meek, er ie n en eed eee sane Hee 5608 Seed CONS eters : os er ead a & coe a sae mre seh > owt es Bax an a hes ", Ie 'tenth ae pe LS Fang o £ a5 a Aes we at oom Be fon wae an at * :
pas a . an Poet yt nner pied sheet: wae ont pees GB rv v4 eer 'cad. as oe ced pes ate EE ed LS ay 4 rs 'et Ned. ae ht on aoe oa af , 2 'a oe oe mr wee. eed pees er of o on raat * Be oe er = an fr pees adie uf: he - Kod] ope on 3 te ba Co ug heat aie wenn, as we nape ny aed "hese a "al jee,