Central Administrative Tribunal - Delhi
Manoj Gupta vs Defence on 12 March, 2025
1
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
Central Administrative Tribunal
Principal Bench: New Delhi
O.A. No.187/2025
This the 12th day of March, 2025
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ranjit More, Chairman
Hon'ble Mr. Rajinder Kashyap, Member (A)
MANOJ GUPTA, (GROUP A) AGE 56
S/O LATE JAI PRAKASH GUPTA
R/O AGF-16 ANSAL TOWN MODIPURAM MEERUT
WORKING AS EXECUTIVE ENGINEER GROUP A
COMMANDOR WORKS ENGINEER MEERUT CANTT.
250001.
...Applicant
(By Advocate: Mr. P. S. Khare)
Versus
1. UNION OF INDIA,
THROUGH SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
SOUTH BLOCK
NEW DELHI 110001.
2. THE DIRECTOR GENERAL (PERS)
MILITARY ENGINEERING SERVICES
ENGINEERIN-CHIEF BRANCH
INTEGRATED HQ OF MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
(ARMY)
KASHMIR HOUSE RAJAJI MARG
NEW DELHI 110010.
3. SECRETARY
UNION PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION
DHOLPUR HOUSE,
SHAHJAHAN ROAD
2
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
NEW DELHI - 110069
4. AT SL NO 131
MES NO 405515
ANAND SINGH.
5. AT SL NO 132
MES NO 186260
VIKAS SINGHAL.
6. AT SL NO 133
MES NO 486850
ASHISH RANJAN SINHA
7. AT SL NO 134
MES NO 270059
KUMAR ANAND V ARDHAN
8. AT SL NO 135
MES NO 611702
MUKESH CHOUDHARY
9. AT SL NO 136
MES NO 486849
MOHAN SINGH YADAV
10 AT SL NO 137
MES NO 439686
HARIOM GANGWAR
11 AT SL NO 138
MES NO 608060
M NAVNEETH GOPAL
12. AT SL NO 139
MES NO 405514
BANSH RAJ PATEL
13. AT SL NO 140
MES NO 300482
ROHIT SATHI
14. AT SL NO 141
MES NO 405508
ANAND RAM BIRIA
15. AT SL NO 142
MES NO 300480
KRISHNA NANDAN KUMAR
16. AT SL NO 143
MES NO 439687
MANISH KUMAR
17. AT SL NO 144
MES NO 609537
AMIT SURENDRA SAKHARE
18. AT SL NO 145
MES NO 300485
3
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
YASHPAL MEENA
19. AT SL NO 146
MES NO 439205
RAJESH KUMAR
20. AT SL NO 147
MES NO 186263
KASHIPRASAD
2l. AT SL NO 148
MES NO 609540
MESHRAM YOGESH SAHADEO
22. AT SL NO 149
MES NO 270058
YOGENDRA KUMAR
23. AT SL NO 150
MES NO 439209
ROHAN SONKAR
24. AT SL NO 151
MES NO 270069
ARJUN PATRO
25. AT SL NO 152
MES NO 439212
HITESH
26. AT SL NO 153
MES NO 300491
NITIN SHARMA
27. AT SL NO 154
MES NO 700003
PAWAN KUMAR
28. AT SL NO 155
MES NO 486852
RAVI RANJAN UPADHYAY
29. AT SL NO 156
MES NO 186265
AJEET SINGH
30. AT SL NO 157
MES NO 186266
NEHAMEHTA
3l. AT SL NO 158
MES NO 439692
AMAN GARG
32. AT SL NO 159
MES NO 486854
AVINASH MISHRA
33. AT SL NO 160
MES NO 609544
4
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
MUTHAKAPALLE V RAMIREDDY
34. AT SL NO 161
MES NO 405518
RAHULSHARMA
35. AT SL NO 162
MES NO 607500
MASUD ALI
36. AT SL NO 163
MES NO 300436
NARAIN PRATAP SINGH
37. AT SL NO 164
MES NO 260326
PRADIPTA THAKUR
38. AT SL NO 165
MES NO 439213
RAVISHANKARSHUKLA
39. AT SL NO 166
MES NO 439691
RAI SAURABH KUMAR RAMCHANDRA
40. AT SL NO 167
MES NO 400622
SAN CHIT
4l. AT SL NO 168
MES NO 195987
RAJ KUMAR GARG
42. AT SL NO 169
MES NO 700002
PRATEEK MATHUR
43 AT SL NO 170
MES NO 300492
SHANTANU GUPTA
44. AT SL NO 171
MES NO 400623
MOHIT K DUBEY
45 AT SLNO 172
MES NO 439696
ABHINAV SHARMA
46. AT SL NO 173
MES NO 300494
MANISH GARG
47. ATSLN0174
MES NO 300490
NITISH PATHAK
48. AT SL NO 175
MES NO 300498
SHALINI AGRAWAL
5
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
49. AT SL NO 176
MES NO 270068
TANUJBAGLA
50. ATSLNO 177
MES NO 486853
ALOK AWASTHI
5l. AT SL NO 178
MES NO 405516
GULAMABBAS
52. ATSLNO 179
MES NO 405517
AJITESH PANDEY
53. AT SL NO 180
MES NO 270070
MANORANJAN SAHOO
54. AT SL NO 181
MES NO 611709
SHAILENDRA SONI
55. AT SL NO 182
MES NO 439690
SANGEET SACHAN
56. AT SL NO 183
MES NO 608575
RAJPUT SATYENDRA RAMACHAL SINGH
57. AT SL NO 184
MES NO 405519
RAKESH BIRLA
58. AT SL NO 185
MES NO 266129
RAJESH KUMAR
59. AT SL NO 186
MES NO 439694
PARAS RAM PUNIYA
60. AT SL NO 187
MES NO 486855
DHIRAJ KUMAR
6l. AT SL NO 188
MES NO 266130
ASHISH KUMAR
62. AT SL NO 189
MES NO 439215
BIJENDRA SHARMA
63. AT SL NO 190
MES NO 486856
DEEPAK KUMAR
6
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
64. AT SL NO 191
MES NO 300499
JATIN
65. AT SL NO 192
MES NO 300497
ADITYA
66. AT SL NO 193
MES NO 439693
HIMANSHU
67. AT SL NO 194
MES NO 125415
M VIDHYASARTHY
68. AT SL NO 195
MES NO 300495
JUGRAJ MEENA
69. AT SL NO 196
MES NO 611710
MANOJ RAM MEENA
70. AT SL NO 197
MES NO 300506
SHUBHAM PANDEY
7l. AT SL NO 198
MES NO 486859
SAURAV VISHAL
72. AT SL NO 199
MES NO 300502
KUMARANKUR
73. AT SLNO 200
MES NO 300508
AKSHAY JAIN
74. AT SL NO 201
MES NO 300500
VIJAY NEHRA
75. AT SL NO 202
MES NO 439216
ABHAY MISHRA
76. AT SLNO 203
MES NO 300505
MOHIT MITTAL
77. AT SL NO 204
MES NO 300507
HIMANSHU MAKKAR
78. AT SLNO 205
MES NO 300504
ASHWANI MITTAL
79. AT SLNO 206
7
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
MES NO 194710
BOMMAGANI VENKATESH GOUD
80. AT SL NO 207
MES NO 300501
YOGENDRA KUMAR
81. AT SL NO 208
MES NO 300503
VINAY KUMAR
82. AT SL NO 209
MES NO 43921 7
PRABHAT KUMAR SINGH
83. AT SL NO 210
MES NO 486860
RAJNISH KUMAR RANJAN
84. AT SL NO 211
MES NO 616201
HAPPY RAJA SINHA
85. AT SL NO 212
MES NO 300510
RAHUL SINGH
86. AT SL NO 213
MES NO 611711
JITENDRA KUMAR MEENA
87. AT SL NO 214
MES NO 300509
AMIT KUMAR MEENA
88. AT SL NO 215
MES NO 300511
SUNNY KUMAR CHOUDHARY
89. AT SL NO 216
MES NO 612231
BANDI SREENIHAR
90. AT SLNO 217
MES NO 611108
KARAN R NAIK
91. AT SL NO 218
MES NO 486372
AKASH AGRAWAL
92. AT SL NO 219
MES NO 300524
TWINKLE GUPTA
93. AT SL NO 220
MES NO 811715
ANILKUMAR
94. AT SL NO 221
MES NO 611714
8
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
YOGENDRA SINGH
95. AT SLNO 222
MES NO 256153
ANKIT KUMAR
96. AT SL NO 223
MES NO 700010
SUMIT
97. AT SL NO 224
MES NO 439701
MANJUL KUMAR TRIPATHI
98. AT SLNO 225
MES NO 300532
SACHIN SINGHAL
99. AT SL NO 226
MES NO 405534
ANUBHAW MISHRA
100. AT SL NO 227
611109
MMD PRAVEEN NANDIKATTI
101. AT SL NO 228
MES NO 436874
ANUBHAV KUMAR
102. AT SL NO 229
MES NO 486881
ASHOKKUMAR
103. AT SL NO 230
MES NO 439226
AJIT KUMAR
104. AT SL NO 231
MES NO 300533
SANDUEP KUMAR SINGH
105. AT SL NO 232
MES NO 405535
SAURABH GUPTA
106. AT SL NO 233
MES NO 439225
ASNISH YADAV
107. AT SL NO 234
MES NO 700008
JAINESH KUMAR
108. AT SL NO 235
MES NO 1190126
MENUGA MANJUNATH
109. AT SL NO 236
MES NO 194712
GUGULOTH BHAVSINGH
9
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
110. AT SL NO 237
MES NO 266149
ASHUTOSHPRABHAKAR
111. AT SLNO 238
MES NO 607783
SWAMI DHANESH ASHOK
112. AT SL NO 239
MES NO 190125
DASARI SIDDHARTHA
113. AT SL NO 240
MES NO 300522
VIJENDRA ARYA
114. AT SL NO 241
MES NO 300521
RAHULMEENA
115. AT SL NO 242
MES NO 300529
LALIT KUMAR
116. AT SL NO 243
MES NO 283115
MUNINDRA PEGU
117. AT SL NO 244
MES NO 300517
ANKUR SHARMA
118. AT SL NO 245
MES NO 270085
KAUSHIKDEY
119. AT SL NO 246
MES NO 300534
AMANDEEPSHARMA
120. AT SL NO 247
MES NO 439229
VIPIN CHANDRA RAI
121. AT SL NO 248
MES NO 270089
GALIF AFTABUL MAMOOD
122. AT SL NO 249
MES NO 194723
ENDLURI CHANDU
123. AT SL NO 250
MES NO 300544
RUCHICHAUDHARY
124. AT SL NO 251
MES NO 700012
MANISH SHARMA
125. AT SL NO 252
10
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
MES NO 300549
VKJYA
126. AT SL NO 253
MES NO 616518
ANKITGOYAL
127. AT SL NO 254
MES NO 612235
KUMAR ARCHIT
128. AT SL NO 255
MES NO 700018
VIKAS TANWAR
129. AT SL NO 256
MES NO 300540
AMIT
130. AT SL NO 257
MES NO 266156
SAGAR KUMAR SINHA
131. AT SL NO 258
MES NO 300545
AYUSH TIWARI
132. AT SL NO 259
MES NO 125421
MITTA HARSHAVARDHAN REDDY
133. AT SL NO 260
MES NO 700014
SAGAR MAHESHWARI
134. AT SL NO 261
MES NO 611720
SUNNY BOTHRA
135. AT SL NO 262
MES NO 300541
MAYANKAGRAWAL
136. AT SL NO 263
MES NO 264806
SAHIL RATUSARIA
137. AT SL NO 264
MES NO 190131
SUSHIL KUMAR SINGH
138. AT SL NO 265
MES NO 300537
PRANAV
139. AT SL NO 266
MES NO 609551
KULDEEP SINGH
140. AT SL NO 267
MES NO 300535
11
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
BUDHARAM
141. AT SL NO 268
MES NO 486879
VIVEK RANJAN PANDEY
142. AT SL NO 269
MES NO 616213
ANKURGOYAL
143. AT SL NO 270
MES NO 300543
VIPULKUMAR
144. AT SL NO 271
MES NO 700021
GAURAV TIWARI
145. AT SL NO 272
MES NO 270087
DHAWAL SRIVASTAVA
146. AT SL NO 273
MES NO 439230
ASHUTOSH PANDEY
147. AT SL NO 274
MES NO 611111
NIRAJ KUMAR YADAV
148. AT SL NO 275
MES NO 609550
MOHNISH KUMAR SINHA
149. AT SL NO 276
MES NO 300547
KAVITA DHIMAN
150. AT SL NO 277
MES NO 439706
PRAKASH KUMAR SINGH
151. AT SL NO 278
MES NO 439220
VAIBHAV PODDAR
152. AT SL NO 279
MES NO 607787
VINOD KUMAR MEENA
153. AT SL NO 280
MES NO 439707
KAMAL KUMAR SAINI
154. AT SL NO 281
MES NO 607786
DIVIJ SAHANI
155. AT SL NO 282
MES NO 512504
PUNEET DHLMAN
12
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
156. AT SL NO 283
MES NO 300539
JITENDRS KUMAR MEENA
157. AT SL NO 234
MES NO 194724
SHASHANK BURMAN
158. AT SL NO 285
MES NO 700020
NITESH KUMAR SINGH
159. AT SL NO 285
MES NO 700017
GHANSHYAM MEENA
160. AT SL NO 287
MES NO 486880
BRIJENDRA GAUTAM
161. AT SL NO 288
MES NO 439713
ANKIT SHARMA
162. AT SL NO 289
MES NO 194727
VISHAL BAJAJ
163. AT SL NO 290
MES NO 300552
PAWAN KUMAR GOSWAMI
164. AT SL NO 291
MES NO 300555
RAKESH KUMAR YADAV
165. AT SL NO 292
MES NO 300553
SACHIN KUMNR
166. AT SL NO 293
MES NO 300556
MANISH PANW AR
167. AT SL NO 294
MES NO 611112
KUNDAN KUMAR
168. AT SL NO 295
MES NO 194728
NEERATI MAHESH
169. AT SL NO 296
MES NO 700022
GAURAV MEENA
170. AT SL NO 297
MES NO 300557
VIJAY KUMAR MEENA
171. AT SL NO 298
13
Item No.11 (C-1) O.A. No. 187/2025
MES NO 439236
SHUBHAM RANA
172. AT SL NO 299
MES NO 485885
DEEKSHA VERMA
173. AT SL NO 300
MES NO 226138
BOJJA HARANATB
...Respondents
(By Advocate: Mr. Rajeev Kumar for R1 & R2 and Mr.
Shivank Pratap Singh for R3)
ORDER (ORAL)
Per: Justice Ranjit More, Chairman:
Mr. P. S. Khare, at the outset, states that during the pendency of the present OA, the respondents modified the impugned order and also revised the seniority list. Therefore, he seeks leave to withdraw the subject OA with liberty to the applicant to file a fresh one.
2. In view of the above, leave, as prayed for, is granted. The OA is dismissed as withdrawn. No costs.
(Rajinder Kashyap) (Justice Ranjit More) Member (A) Chairman /yy/