Karnataka High Court
Mr Renwick Mascarenhas vs The Deputy Commissioner Of Income Tax on 4 August, 2010
Author: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
Bench: Ashok B.Hinchigeri
_...
3»: Ti-i% HIGH CQi_3RT 9:: §<_£1R§\éATA§<A AT 8ANGAL€3RVE:'~"-.._ '-..V
same 'rs-as 'ms cam my 0:: AUGUST 2e,:_{é' '
BEFGRE
THE Hasx;'5:.E MA Jusrzcg 53:S!-§€,?::§< 35.4Hisxit;-§:§rsE9{:"k[1"}%--Lja
war? PE"§'I'¥'1€'2§"§ N9. 22«fa;ia..5 af 2%; (f5~:'§") :3
smvsaw:
MR ggrayvzcx ;'v'3ASCARENHA:'£3... é
man AEGLET 35 vsaas _
sic: MR RUDQLPH MASQARENHAS * T
KOLARKHAN ESTATE A
SA?§§Aiv3ESH:«'€ARPE'TP{3v,ST V A.
csegcxmgsgwa " PE'1"ITIGi'°éER
{By 333: Q;'fig§§f§"¥*§,c§§!$géA'T8I, ';g%§'v'QCATE)
IV ' ' ' ' .
1, TH§ DEPRi;3TY"(§{i)M§¥i1.§"§éVS.f'@C3'§'4§'?'i7'g
<3; INCOME'-'T{'A}!; c::%a<:;=,m#.A%%
SHARAi}A SAP¥£%.;'D»'%':'?;~'s as-mvam
sHA:&z;%;ARL;zs:a:*rT ma;§_§Ms;< R; puszxam
"-zaagfims SFS 201
l\5
, V'"*f;4'5 §';;xL;:§C:§v[E§:v Qmcsa
3-+;:..5$,s;m; ;z:m4::.E;; "
SHAR;ABAV.$A';'~§U[3AYA BHA's.!A%\é
A V . sHA¢4';<Ap;;ss:,;fT ROAD, K R Fiifihfvfi
'£.~iAS5AN 1573 263;
'._3j; "§'}iE:,§$ii¢?D£,;CQ§e3MiSSIO¥\iE§2 er-" ENCOME-TAX
. *SH.r-'3.R£sDA SAMUDAYA BHAVAN
V" '~--. S§'§ANK;QR?*§§JTT man, K :2 PURAM
VJ --«.4 Ps"s3;SSAN ~ 5:93 231
"THE C<.Zi_MM1'S$i0NER_ GP
IN£IQME-Tfislii (A§'?§A£.,$)
633.55/3, SHILPASHREE BUILQZNG
VISH "Ef3HWAR.ANA(3AR
§'«1':'S(3RE W SKI 0&8 RESPQBEQENTS
(E9? SR3 K 'xi AR-'3iVI!'é£3 FQR M V SESHACHALA, i--ifQVQC~»€%'3:.E'}T.
THIS 'v\;'R_§T pmncw ES FILED UNDER ARTICi_E$~--22»§_}fi.§.?5,fi" .
22? or THE mr~ss7rruT;c::;N}3F IMMA ¥3§{A':'I;¥\£G Ta%.--QuA5H}j%'~mE.T
csemmumcarzorxs 0? "me 1" assmssmewr 9A"r';::>"'2:?;:§2.2c£39--« u
1.3%; FILE 5:35, THE ASSESSMENT 'YEAR 2$i3,§,$}'_-'(A§'§'%éEXL;iRE.V€:}_V A'
AND ETC.
'Ms WRIT PE'¥'I'i"ION CQMING (_'.)i'V€*..S-'--' ~f':3E~'; $RL§=:~,.'_Bc;, n"'E-'T3r-§"_iSV; "».
0:13'; THE COURT MADE THE FGLLGVWSE-536: A
The ;:2§£:§t§Qner's gfie-v;a:;j_£:e'=:_§s{V:Vt!j:_;ésft' :'!:,héé "t5-3_;srth Hre s;:::mde.nt
Cammissianer :2? Inccsrne Ta>;A.££§. 9§.--2eé§3.;$V§Ef.:Lhasv.':é§«i:.'v«--§ésp9sed of the
petitioner's $'g:pesa'é father submitg that thcsugh
the matter %s a:"'§._:._':ie1:'.%;V the 4"' respondent, he arcéers
C5332 ta '§assed,V"a$.:!f:ePre5§d§::§ Qffirzer was transferred in :hQ%mawh;:a.%»%A _ 2,' §{Ai5Ar':a'J§:3d, t§'1e_Eeame§ caunsai fest the re;-wcanéenis «.%.T.[{g;:«%3_r::it3 that {war 9:: ting §et§:§r:amr"$ agpeai mgzéé fig: be '._§3«ss'e§,.§:"§*?3e§e was rm PfeS§§Eir'3§ Gffiser, He submits that haw V. esffiqar is :s::x$:-ad is the Qffim <2? the Agpeiiate ' j_"{,*<;§9§i;';r:§ss§s;:r;9r. i-ie submits that the petit§csr:e:"s Qeaéiag aggseai " Vficauié be r,:%§$p«:;zsea' sf, éf fmsr wed":-,»:w;s time i3 grargted, RE}!