Central Administrative Tribunal - Cuttack
S S Mishra vs Defence on 31 January, 2020
SOE a 1% TYACEK EE CO OA No. 703 of SO1y Member {A} i, dr. Gokul Chandra Pat Hon'ble ¥ = * Present HAN.
3 2 ¢ Pac a re pean} oo ?
ed a, "net hra, Member (9 3B y any as £53 aida pat tenes i Bengal). wal a Ee Mari ¢ fone Cs ~ aS tex Say "
PAD re a x.
Ry al, B & Mi. Swarup Kamar M ebryna bs Backmal, Pe 5 Hon'bi 4, Wo BASS OA N Nea 23 EE = at Gtr.
ve & t- Balam:
oy i a SEPTS ta, TH 2 LAP ' ct e ireinenice Panda, At Lae £
2.601 QA No. LAT 602 OA No. &e Raa $ ES a ee oS SAW, 2 = x car =e Buses AAS Da ana:
OA No.GO3/17 'ey 4 * tke WON ade Jay, ' 2, fe > > x v cara, ¥ bout 48 By ide ae wk Koprer ats 'S. 3 tenes s At Bishnumunda, Pck | OA No.608/17 RSS 8 an Sotory, yy pu me AY x Gorey aS F Pype-TL/ Ses a 2438, tied, PS 29 x * dy Se Ae) Fa t Gtr. Ne A ~% CG anal, AT win a8 3 Shes DA Nea.SO8/ 17 Ak, we x ~Babar t oe a ee o ~ aed po ictal el 2 ', Bs ry os sch ay cree # iy @.TOULLT POT {ET O.TOBALF OA No.607/17 ANo.GIO/IT OA No TOS! UT OA No.7 OA N O& No. 8 OA N Lt nnd ee "OA No.TO m3.
SHeK y R pe ond REN:
Xe +a } OA No. THAT é : r ne Le pe tek by s 5 a oie my " oe a ; oe jee 4 Sh BA 4 "oo Fat ax eed, Ri ee zt on aoe Bhs ea am So fe A ig *. ne caret tem, OO he red a ee. ay ae Fame mee oy 4 * vere Ke B43 eo 8 z pea os wd oo s ae he rs a d A spoat rs fons Lg deny ~ pkey pee > Est pa pend te rH 3 poe 2 ge, 554 ' ¢ ch whe g ie aS ts So et pa an : og a BA en Me St ae mG 3 des me EER. ve vere gt, SRS ce) ae ae . we 8S oes "pet rad u way "~ ; ces : adh " 3 wee a ~ ws a BO @ 2 "< te ea - of oF oes thd or rd rate) a4 xe tt vee ee mS RK, be gy eS ieee es We a os it or Be ye Oe z : aoe, Te 8 BoB pas, es * pi nA A he wt CEE tt Wg ran ws "4 bad oo oe Re ny ohh es we Se be ct Be ine weg te a Ao Ge ta oe z 3 te a Sa a ve o B eg be ot eh as a a uy tA or) wt we bE es Gis BQ i ws pa] s ret a won nee) a H o 7" Poa rod & « we OR OE : i " %, Seg Tre 4g CE nr & :
od te. : aos =o oe OR : pene ey, ee a iw ee (Nie, wt oD : ' wan on on, eames! x bef : ees ap s Bae fet te tee gee ba ¢. fos cebea. are i, ie a bee Mes, a ees nd : cane : ae 3 A # en Gh. Mey, cna le 5 yp oe 3 ac ' ¢ e ey wad ee fe oe Bs f cc Oe Bo aft e 5 a 4 oe th de B ES 7 bare ol ae . « OE gale " ad oe pee. ane Be eae OR wre oa thy a CAeE, pee beh. i BS i ee ae Dae ad wae $f $a te Es bes More cos uP 7 % ae a 4 Be tee ON Se fig eee ay . 4 is 4 . Bob Go E& ke tft Sa , Be Piel " Sans gS -; heh Spee be, ed et EY a a aA wey ies) : a nee, aoe Za my OS on ve wy OE 5 we SS ad wt id a fF 4 com ay ty Bee oy any a. Sand ng am) in ce ga Be nics US Iie ah fer er we 57 es ae FeAl a "f ; ie As Z 3 pe ae jee OS * xh " yak Se "t is " 5 ed eed rete % Y fha £0 nm. ey "rg OG we ty pS eet wo + Mes
3 a wh MS oes oe oo op £5 ee peak vom, we _ es we ee He ee fy Ua OS 2 fo _ o oe wee oo OF i aes ke we We ae a ay vee mS ed . an ee wed gs LG ae oe Bh 2g shed yo, oS ge BR Be af 'i ar x & mot a a ae roa ween teed tee cede 7 ts we Panes Sate * asi ee mye tS, . an ee) Ga ug (2 OG a fs tt & » te VR oe FS ical ar om es Me ta mm we ES a ay Pi ee es oe abo ae Ke Boy me Rp me oS fy BOS ae ies me aes Bp ot o oe: he ord eo Am Be wy ty a ae Gs a i oo 2 4s OS yee ane SG 3) oh hes: tee OS te "ws a fs, ta re yy r4 So ,:
K om ge Bok LD ge be of s Wee od x « bok Bs OF ty oy Fag ee fhe na a $3. $4 A * phe ae thy A 4, ee ee es yd z f ; ops way Og on beta, ' os Ded PA oe A es anes ee ge be a rg Aa a oct 5 oe fg oe Fe 4 on Bore ree tf > or To OR ned ORE ny , * thos rr ors weet eh gh a a ra ) 'hd beg : wed. aed ey ay ; one a rast at 2 hea n ae poe ES "4 ate oe ye ; EG 6 ' Fo fgea ™ SE aa rine it Ea ae nee ra ed a) ton Hes a 4 Smee! ~ HE 2B me 3 he
- oat a a @ Boe . B RP & fe as Beh pee 1. SA ees * pa wh rede GP fied Te % a ; if OES be oe Dy vee 4 vet tte OF ce te ; , 4 ee ay os} te ue 2G. rset 3 eo phy Ee , Ee . vhee ae fy UTE m, " tee pak rd tee OS ang he ES 2 fe ? ae Pal re fut 4G Ph? Om hi Mm pe mee eee EE ' oe Aime OE ees i OE yt eaten mo Beh Ove ra ke ge kere ot oe ae RE hy yt " oi, PAL SD ¢ lan eage. ¥ } ws, om " pK ry og wa ¥ fas we So A pee bi tae OO 8 tn SB, LY Oe Ty ms OS ok A ve my roa * "i 8 FRO TAIT a.TIO/LT Lee A Ne.f87/17 ANs.?OA No. 769/17
OA No.PTL/47 OA No.773/47 OA No as OAN QA N CAN 2 sdan = Balan tok IN heh oer a 2% aes DA Nos.
At-
ifP) iy >! B iy he nag ZVpeo ye SRISEES % Fg x w DA Ne. 60) OA No. G02 417 aunts s ek oy o "2
we x i i FY x sy +e eS eorarrcre re yt:
Soe merinal x.
erat 4 ars SRP S e a 608/17 GA No.GOUs/1LT & OA No 608/27 POPPED PPLE PILL OTL OE EET ITE acd a . © :
Lt od a af $ a ead le t K fod rast ' aad nah "4 ns coane an a "ft ao we 3 "ot i: "4. " Lat m4 Whey rf bee fe. 4 a, gs ro = eB rs ees pas nt 4 Cs es ie a " Hs Sao co tab m otter, . "a 4 ie se j geen. <e te re w% _ De Be fe a 4 ne one 3 pssss "aS aad 2 Lo o & . a Ba oe hy yet ty SL og o 4g
3 hd Spee we boc ane ae SE oh wa og. ae aed x a" set ee RS Re : xb ws ga a od Bh Re ER xt x i y ee 5 oth bh i mm m gt 5 a ih wif LE ow ws : B on . . oy op OM % 2S 4 aA ", fea" 83 Pos . cog wed tery a 2 mG -
Le i, " ' , od ert era tf Sod bs a " vs eet &. joie 6" fe "
ae Ry ft py re oy ie ok a hee = oe St ee. hae 7™ * yy es ea oO we Cs a tet bet et UY ra rs " te oy oy 9% ae / ; Pe We ot tae Sone Paes . et wi ; YS we Eas SS ae he sat 4 jo ae - oh ge ty f ad oo t3 A 1k 3 vere poo er meen Pa ¢ a 4 fe L he s i _ te ye ES he Pad 10k Fo iy tod 4 Sh ae % a " ye ae ty CH BG fe est ays 2 seb AD as 88 2% Be gy fe oe ho, : % ares Bee 4 pe Fe ne Ms ' re ge To Re. GF C mw OB Feat st m egg Feet aD 8 ee yp be ay bow ae Be eax gy ! * ' roomy ac Z Oh 2 me ue es , ee 0 bes eg ee TF --y coe oss a ams Smee oe ke ee} ¥ woes Roa yes be st ad io bor a be) a 3 Ghd wre Te ae uo aap is isd a be wet nner mr Or ee eg Ye ad gre, wae oS we : gm os a % ane oo ae Bi te oe pa BB ay ok oe ox za ce tg an res ban eek $. nt ees : s cs, be pase re , : aed aes "i ere. Bt fy reed doc ee n Bp oe & seat eed eens "Th eet eek, MT Ge Nt OD BOR ot oie a aco cet > soe BF ri to4 £ 1 oe < rom Ad we op SO me he ee ee ms S ~ iG (aa oa ME Os oe ba (3 oo, wei . i te sy mt pee 7 re ci mh wee ret set oF Bp EM es 04 rer BGS we 8 ra ge Bem a 3 OR SS a Ee Re "3 "2 od bee gs fen te he Ae fx re gw Tg a RS Sad 4 Sse OE os ed Sta 3 OS bei, Fae s os tft Bw ME = ao PH de gene So oe tna a ne } rem. ; " wo, we oD eRe RG a ; OE e fom 4 at "4, A 2 ' oy sed. @ wee we EO EE bet wok BO ch tere a 24, vet ae on OE * re Doral a a an one ? ae Be rane CY fag * ee es] Sg OE a wo re ee og po, Belew. re a, : ; Oe oe a mo pa BO Fe fo Roo A) oy oe @ tae Sk a ee ES aes any 2 Tt ga pain ae Sr ee fy pm, TE ~ Set Nae a Be wen ge ky Se es EE wee te aoe Gl moo OR LF S ra Sk pee ee Sh gee TL ieee oe ne ot wes ot ty Re Fe 4 ih et -- 'ae _ nee ee tae aes ee gst tee ee hg eae Oye i fh, te po pane * ' x as & x Me ee OT bed " Mecca a We rok ee ned o Fe Oe 7 eR go ag ree s Fe pe were eed af oe g venl! Seb aw ae Pee RP Soy ee EE YP oe o , Bao & t 4 ; rs iri 3 ot % Fad on mee b ct S$ ek rae oS Oo Se ny fe Et bey 44. : t So ont get perme se pat fe wt fa ee a ee Be ta OSS lao a wh Ely Se ot @ a} ¢ x re ; % Poot, Dac 44 », ae dou ve wa OF on fj I 5 3 2 a. ' oA. woeSe ad } peas) *, Z re " a: oe 'Sead yet ee a BP whi oe "be oe ke Mth com ne ae we Bt 2 wed os 4 Cee 5 & at oy 4 foe ee ee A aa oe fo ate wet. en °F, oO pe % pad weet ERR Ss E be 3 he OS OO es zt nee ess a fl be gh es a Be =A AE EES ® & Pos ORS ee oe Ba gS i : Nat hed hoe Rd tenet hf Es ¥ ? * j ', 5 ee 3 : vn Load ' t toad * ; ¢ Bamh hen Sad EE tel OEE , wt feck ond he Nut a yor Se fhe "E aw res % ES + i» } » a frei . :
head OE oes ie ry goed ad rad aa he .: oot et : a * : , es fy t i ag a ae "g Wy iid aaa! 4 eS ioe wo ina sei m3 608 * OA No.608/17 OA NoGoorry OA N OA No Tha.
ry oo ~ we aes & x, o, ae *s Pins w ES Py as . & 2 os Pa Feed as sa tas! hs Feed, Meee : ' ; he Lh eed x a Wh fy cere OS a ; : : x, ; Ly tow z or Paar a ise ae & co ard 5 , asd va 'A Z LOS i is me me (ores ae 3 : & ? ee ree ot Ne pc aes yah + : & i :
Cee . a "4 & oR j man few be oH eee ee ZA Aad Be fx "
mo moe fe Fo wa : ae fae Ot a og " "2?
as ; | fs Ag a 3 ha hf ; a % ;
fet on, a] pa me t. i" q JE re nnd % Neat Be
4 * Pes See ne o od pa ag Booed 0 & ett pong"
, th oom BS as BEB | wr 4S i a ee ge ee kk fone os ; & 2 ; mE OS Pa Mgt Han rt q wit ; wd 2G £4 ie Ee nd pot. bo " fn bd ia 3 :f '4 of i : " ~ } = Moe os 6 ¢ «w EO att oot enag sd "a Us week a o4 _ , eS re nt ~ ey : ; ms el fe | & i No.6.
A Nav' OA OA No OA No. aN ~2oure Rum vend of India, represented throuek is Secretary *, Mirustry af De North Block, Central Secret: ariat, New Delt Director of General, bydian Q: Sanee Factory, SB Bose Road, ad Manager, ing Factory, Bole ; ale BOs + Gandapatrs apals, PS: Saintala, Dist-Balaneir. Indian Ordsanc: Facte ¥, Balangir(®), Ar acomlapatrasalll, PS: Ssurmtada, DNet-Halanes sar, bhar, DEW NS1 frdian Ordnance Factary, Rolsneir{hy, At Bachnal, PS: Saiy tlale, Eat Balangir, Pa Tes Sosy Pr OFS. z oe "ee, nowt see greg aby Union af India, represe: through ie Secre x AY. ¥ t, New 0D Delenes. North Block, Censral Seoreteriat Dirsotor of Chey neral, Inchan Ordnance Factor Katkata (West Bernall.
General Man naper, Indian Onipans eS | Backory, BoheusriPy, At Badu, PO: Gandapecrapalli, Pe:
Worka Ms taser, Treclians Oren ve ' Rad ned, PO: Gandare atrapalh : Saige ly ax tot -Balangse. Sri (harvdra Bhar, DAW NS Inetian Greiriance Factory, Bokmpin, At Badmal, PS: Saints sila, [Mat-Rals ugh 2 GY et * berg Peg eS uo xb So Go ee as Bhs "OA No.706/17
OA No. 707 / e279 Potetonseccand qt, OA No.708/17 Direc mer of india, fepresented throngh ie Secret ary » Ministry al Defence, Nerth Blne Kk, Central Secretariat, New Bef. ar af General, Inclan Cie dingiive FF. actory, 3. . Be ose Road, ta (West Bengali. Genera! Manager, Indian Ordns ance Factory Badraal, Poh Gandapatrapadli, BS: Sain fala, Disk © Works Mana ager, Indian Ordnance Sac ne Badimal, £9: Gandanatra pall, PS: Sais Rashists . Maihs, DSW fSli Free ja, DNet-Balangir, Oudsianice Faotory, Sabniaia, Dist Balangir. Blanch}, At: Bacal! ee te Searetary, Misastry of retariat, New Delhi, f General, Indian Ores mmnoe Pactony, S. K. Bose Ro oa ekpe eot Boenest), Generat Marager, Indian Radial, PO: Ganda: patrapall, PS: Saintaly, angi Works Mana eer, Padian Grdnance ane Balangi(P, Ak Badraal, PO: Gari spain, BS: Sai ») Dist-Ralangir, Raj Rishore Sahoo, DEW Hay ; Factory, RolanginiP), At. Bad cial, PS: Saintala, | Unien of Trulia, represented throyeh its As Beretary, Ministry of Defence, North Block, Central seeretariat, New Dethi, & x By Ee IN » 30% BS N R . Bose <8 sarc este Ss
3. E a langir. wae : ~ Sal indian Pita cs) ict * op a a = oe a oeant eens se pee g ats ap rgd mot . m ae . . oe, haan os mS Fr ra) 5 £99 Ne. FGd/ iy 4 No. & + Da DA Na. 76 g Bee t .
A 8 S a ot os ; at ' wee ey Sew, "
' My - os .
; ty on Co ek vats as 'et wa a :
Pa ; ve wy a "og ors wh ' * v beg ea on iia 3 " XS Pa aed oh, ae aa ot a 3 we a Be, oe a CS ES iced Pad Dod A " as '6 4 a ee Boe eal eon ares Piet +. ae ae = bo ed as fis ies at . pa wt 44 Md as Fo at ponies ; so wwe cas we ery eA 4 Be i 4) td 1 Fe ee] mm gt x es ons ras = 3 'eee gt eka 73 ee ee we pa ma " BS us beg pen Meeee * immed Sy fet fe Pe es Mh oo eR ew Hire D4. 8h ER com ue SEE ra & Si Gy aE ge NRE we Kee wpe bar £ ce ae $3 a fe ge pred zB we OP ys me, me er Ee Re Dy we UD oe gh bend re, yo eet ae " ; re fd a ped ee lh Bk, ood be "ES 7 om sg oh 8 3 a ase bn AS * eee peg oe Ont 4 feed Nd we tat Bs n ae £4 aed we fe: ig ae o% , oa Soe ", Px "0 , yt oa ae » 6 ae ke, fon Be wh tat OS pee & % 3 Ey Roe Be hee fe ; arn 4 ae 7 £3 he Auk fated rage ee, ~, i, OU a4 % "3 A * Bee oe fe be ee Oke :
a ae oot % & ke S 'ig Pe, o on ee te mA ; Py pte, int hes 1, at a ae Ain. spe oom fool a oad tes caries Are see ee By fs wn we coed e & "yn 60 a gen Lee ie oa pee, Be pet Nd £3 £0 beak ee sc ro} wee 2M ws Ree Tg. nd wee 4 e323 Mo aed . ox AS ve oo a wee mm Ae 2 oh 43 years od keg gt Ol oome be eg wy ge ee Be 4 ee ha me ae tf aes fs 3 Fae eS 2 pee OS yet ey CX SEL ae na os Gh tat eo te Fran me ee 43 bea ets $ te BE eg pe doe i ee a ia fy ten ree heme sent * we Lp ee ot wee OD $a 3 Sa tet:
7. Oy 0S 5 eR oo Bs oe an ed i M4 a; vara fog Eh bee on Peet a: C od Sed if oh, Aes ee Sp Reo Ee oe SS 8S ey E LtFy se at ar ree bast et ro ' Wen a OS ans Te ae SS or ot oe ne Ee Ba paces baer ons rat wa ee fe 'ee ey a weet ew: rn Paes ry He won, 8G mn, oe . . a ty gs Fa wae we ina "3 os g G eh fhe SS cba ty AS ree A ? i on OT of tae G 'et ne 4 Sead her , eS * pode Oiog & is pat fs, ", z reed, Se RT ke Ge aw yee ae Na es long oe ee OR i a me Pa ead "ne os, oo a oe os pe Reet ye ee § * ~ The iS ; ya OND . eee RM fn hs cs te al bee 4 ve pe ¥ ' te % nM rks pr xt cara Me es at . ee > tat "Ch pend ce ey EE sect bod wwe Ye os x my os a on nook fo ee 34 be @ oe ge bake ORS a aed a CE od ee a Ae fe tre SP lt sg ry Re 5 A ae es ' ane SS we ok . te age we Gs 7 Oe - cas a 4 is : s im 42 a ee per ad a ke F Lo eS 2 Bi 52 eM. 6 es oe me SOE ci ed o en Ok 4 5a as te TR Se aa rs re OS Bone Fad set : oe al Rae ot Sn z Me: ms 'a © OO Da vars a , 4 he.
ped 56d a fat a rae: ao CE be ee we (8 eee Be ek ORG Bh eet, Oh, oh an ne? a eee oe RS Fo ee Co oe f Me Be tk ee ooh " ns aah Ba ke SO pie ee a Met Be bes ae SOME Se xe Son rn 4 o n tees as , wd oye ot we RO Ge eee eet oe cnr. ©:
Sin" neh het "al wh ~ hat f' Toke a rns id * ae 4 a awe 2 a er oa acs woe A, om mm, * Se aM, Fd by aoe S BS' 2 aw tS os 2 +3 x C3 ba Oy be ed aoe goo & ow raed 2 re : 3 m i lug ft A OES we St wh eS oa ORE i Lee oe An oe Wt ox " , Soy. UK. "Ty a en is bon " ca va > pao, 5 OS 4 cof wy 4 SS He cae od ew Be P ee OO Be EL ye BEM PEA be a OO ee RG @ hs bed Smee * ace! ete re et at QR Ew Ew A oe 23 a mo, . ~ red " MoM oe mw $ we z Se ; NR ener na" ke Mage ee I oes mek ke Sees Te, Me Nol o pe "go & Be ope artaar ; an OO we EER rr eae oe ons eee a gee oa, Ge Sd yee adn? Sams Aad, " a eek Beet 'aoe tet eae Ps oe £8 omar ome Ge hes oy GS ORG "ER ot seve Sak Bee ~ * teens Sor omy ao ee a nd cee fet Crm A er 3 mee mea cgs SF ay hs . te a ot an. FO RES Be Be ql pee - 3 ee oy EB ae pe PO aes ats as? sa oe ; be 05 TEE BE ee UO GO | 2s had yea wey ee EE . oS #4 3 ne A th ee yn fay a * wth, ose I Geo an tS te ag a3 88 e acd 4 po be ST. oe at ome oan ae AAFP oA me et OOD ke re ee OR OD oe S bo MG & : i 5 i ba ons a ome SO 3 4 rs wz Go he OBS exe sed <8 tong Ge wk ge be t + t 'ig: : . res ine "at fe vo ' 1 ¥ ered * : wes OS Pag oe : Ate mt GY Looe ch mA Re ws et oe Ooo A a eos "es rd " rag ¢ " 3 * ce eee ' x, 'aK oe. tp EA tant % 4 fF Lanett eet me at : fut ee fad TLS a a aa A $4 it wt i af ¥ ' z . eee me ars CE GK Md ia cee i we pee paves wg we . 5 be: 4 a a oad oa 34 io: ca a "e we pont ; ' Your " fe Fae) ' a Be 6] ay han se OF <E ic:
3 fei xs aS a S Wa & Ba) rt Soni te todd ai i 2 oi " a ne i o . a 3 pwd oe oH t JAS in th @ tala, Tithe i Sain <8 1 (for & 7 1, PS "4
Aq bere € x AAS cay eRe iy 3 4 :
3
o CA No? 72 {3 OA Na FT OA Ne. Fy porn 2047 "
a & Feet of a x OQ} sel] {CN Nas. € yy aa & TIRE x rs, C Be d Be! a MAy Rr.
ANEY, apat aha Mash inhapatra Bb x RM & A. Er, R hp eget Bs ee A al we os Lee pore Ba acs wt ded > 7 oe we SO ne ~ ied b we at te 4s BS at rs bey . an ne et ee foe ae Ab bow ih rtta a em ee be es ; as , "a 4s pose et wpe ae ad er a wt A pas = bee "4 ed bas a Pa wa i bee i bet weg ken Bb % re Gos fed oe 4 Se ? os peed a) 7 +e eet Ere gee Gwe oi Fp tf oS 2 4 SS Ss rae ye fNe the vee Zs a 5 ws Pal ye nll v4, ned. a ay be net wet [<aion 409 ae th Foose! feat bon ef " ie os ht A Sie. me 3 ty . io at oh et Es ey ay ear, aed ay oy a3 ra y &S se a we "og "0 os Kh. MM Bie ay fe AG Mgt kG vO we Be 2 2 B we & De Bp aa ecgd Zo ¢ « ay ae we 4 a iad i ote Os a ee Ly, ee at Zs cae ps fa we oe 8 OS Ue Pome: mG Zhe * eons a ane s4 o S.. e Poo me & = a fe OO Ae gS Go a og BE s * be 3 oe : ty, ES ke coe og oe ab ' 'ag og . feo At Py ¢ ord "4 fa] SG om ya en fetes: : very : f : as + ae) oe a be z ma tn oo ao oF xed ~ ot 5 * > aad, cogil a3 Rg) Be go 8 ay, he 7 8 het pan ' ie an ad a) cad aaad ro Be ts ts. ' a s 4 va Bay o bs aw Tas 'te 43 oi Pr * * ad vies : * bad $ oi Pod ner Fal te ES , fea to wee MER ret oe we» mw BR a wi a Oe tn, a 'Ae tad, Pet . DKA ~ 'ra . mo o 2 oes rir a) vs 7 ree) [oe a S a "rs GB ion a ae eg a » UE wk oo po coed ' oS 5 aes im Oh MB og ym OO S&S fe bod a5 78 ee te bed we a; a yy aS s "ak nM ~ iy whine é 06 Sp. By Py be. dee % cee] xe spat ¢ vt by vbed * if we veg 4 hes' id Pon Set Pog rage . ae ae rae on bac' : peer gy ~ Gt od aed Re Pa wie oF . £5 van ee bon LE aS oa rs ns Crs fin, A eS SOU reed be 43 mtu, Mba oe 17 rs a few hee mn ih 3 ty od Peel we fe fm shes 4 ene OER Ss pe 4 a a i es e+ Bi og, n 4 fh tend a t "anh ion Pass «fi os e, Pid AS "y oC ows es ay fp ye a nn ane By, iy Rags 4 ot wae roa ; os A s Ss ne , ts, 7 Wo age ee 3 fo we 3 pA * fon, Li Ge Fe Rie oe a a 6 weg 7 sae fe & Oe i FF 8 s rood ; eet ee Oe " SS 4 we ® % ond ws a z a3 a ee we ee ea OS ' ee Tags x ed veeeg ao By ES, te be eG Pe wea FS a oo Spore pees eo alg a Re vps be PES (a ons) a [oneal ge ae Og Re aa Be RS 4 Bho hee oy bey PA ns om eee © 7 oe wo ih re er tee SF 2S, a Roo A a t- tay te me FB we eo ke BG "RB a oe : Hi we oe ha? bs % ba foie pet OS omeed cme) wm tr "et oe Pst eo Bate gs 8G BeOS a. & an eS a. es asd be "ge : fa! oa ge te aes DS CS a fa or me MB we 6 2 ap . t aac as nae aye ee Sot om oe ye pee Oe ar 43 v4 * 3. t ° ae tad Oy tent By aa * we My. wi ae pas Hy. a o ee eons end ' ma gk es 4s bet ge ge ee : "3 ; a teens, of %, 3 if ¢ Bos Mee 2. See 4 ye tet e, cae Oost kb wy ao a ne Bw + ose ~~ 7 Be om ea L3 : whet ns a Dass vee ake aye, G Le x oboe o oC 7 a hee Se we wi nase nt: a Se on A a : i) a oeg Bf Bb th Bon be » fe oo rhe 88 ze & me e ben oF w= = 4 wo om we BG . ge 3 +2 Oe. we wn P yy cw ; ag re nd oe KS we te Pe ee ae ne : = pet se « 2, tol. anon Go; 7 het z SS & 3 A re) We fuoe $ Bay Sw ae * 'eS vim ey i ay Pa oy "s TAGE co od oa 7 ae 4 ro are get * . ' a hed. 4g ' yr, os g ¢ @ Fe a fe me me ee Z 3 wa eG tt ye cee fei 'oy! ne ted ap ie ee os ah ae : wm S ' ore eS 7 % . *. a e " 'y ", ry, % > o u% A ry Fe we gm © a, Owe EME a i as ba 8 mm, ' oe d nas et: ie we bea a "a4 pa 4 ct, eed one es in os "ae wey ty BD) a4 i Pac ny & Mage a a BEAR Om BA Os ROR at 8 B hom Bop Ee & a _ Be pea tae er Sena bat a fond my i "heh 4 "hed o eh prin, OA Lb j bad pac oad : & a oe Poared we 4a oh B 4 Ss, ~ BR ta Se! bad nae, howe " rn te uh ap ew. a att tn, a z GL. soir. cr ore, oe eS o £ ; a ee ve , b= 'rs s Vel ors be ho Rw aS Be Soe %3 as OG fhe foot oe aa CA he Uw ert % 4 bs ar ee LG *, te Re be rans ; z ie z agi ' pees w 2 et aged ue bk, a Re eA hora ne Sd ai ok fas fee oe bg RR ae : es Big mote i ene a fe BOE ve By me ft ag & 2 & @ "pe eeee whe Bo. &, os Weed. G an "4 ay ey | Wie xy 4 oe Po rs Mm os " aes rand oA By se tok ne % "K wee Saag is fe gs % aed £ Te sen oe fy hy ¢ oa E "ore w we ia pe) ee 8S De ~ 4 a is " Bat. oF 45 a oe te 'poo S», . vy ; i ® mH & im nn <r rn arn bad a2 G 6 me o & & . ot tes oy m oe tw a oo fe . me a = & 'ng a a is - oS & & bs Z Oe Us ie OF a eth ee com te we ; ' a te ey > tt beg eh ae 8 gee > r wi oa er ar ee ' & "ee ee FS ros a oars rh het ta tof 4 as Pet ees be ns oe OG t "nek a "eet ci bee Ff ab fs rs were pe Ea abe weg how we 6a es rat on % 4 Lanes " as) : . 4 an # ss wa. OR eh BE Ff € aes oo & & a Sg nm a a bas bags pad tf pay at eo cl Be fas b4 fat sap, Sot ep a pe ~ ees m™ mee "test FS Si em oe ee ae, 4 an one 'el fs te he ee a a an . Sy ae $xa7 Sep 1G be Paes we, ad wee, eee Hs tony AP ny, = a Ls ron a pore x 53 : Re ,. a Poot thd bg 'ae mer oe oe bor fentt SA Pd we 2 eae) awe ra os 3 we gn £ Pat ot, ig or ow. am Bee Cae paere , Aw vet ton, ae 1p a va Ly an 5 os, fen cat foes nt ee se roe ere wo 4 Bt wi bap * 7 ee, ¢ 'x as hak s weeo se Re pow pa be sa, we ay PE wae y - Rh, Se revs 25 by Gu, at icon! ek at ee a & eect moo om as oes a oF. Bae Rice a' A a a a gr wae oe me Wo yh ae S rad Pogue' ou Ba OS pen y & mo Go he co at oe 1 OR hm ma A BB Re Wi Ly Loags 5 * ad Fer pet ot ees aA 3 4k we pemmens as Lu nad BoA oes £
- Bad eds a 85 ~ 744 . a sy Fost oN Das Y. " . Soon . ae ae coy ee eS Ree tae bad we SBS "Sia hee poe Eon ER mS fering, Soe go Be ea & ke ne % oS Ch tae 4 a : Mg fi, ores 5 My eg are oe ba . fe Mg as &é £% te <F WA pom es oy pea Poe Ae se an Ne Bo Be ee pies am Bo nye he Eb Ea po * ie o te OR ae BO fet hed a oye Oe hoe, ah ao & J ot we EG 7 S ES we i : agi arn 2 'ag m7 ae ke OY co ea 2 Ea ry at Pa ve SF @ ee) be oS oi i coord ae Th $k ee ae ne oe KE, i Ce ed oa OO Boe Be & he wy wa an cn re?) aed 2. by rae RE ag oe re ons , ee OB OG Mp OF
4 Ze GO * Pn a ae ces "pO be ae JB ee ot oor Boe 6 fog s ge gg BEE Pe of ne 262 8 & 6 2 8 2B Be x Ped ; & Pa fori ee ge : be & SD ee i od os eo £2 Bo ae te gy mM eH RB 8 ane ct ty Te 4, © oa 0 ee " Shs ; ial G y a re a os 32 i ay wm HO ay sas Yow 4 Buss pa Dn. ; pes iS 45 eee 4 be on por 3 Hh Sed Ge reed oe) pon Fags ee oe ote oot ae res on oor ap fre - § ree MS ~ aa m @. & o . € 2 2 B a8 ince anon ¢ Feo wy of (CO nn ae be we "BR tS to, oy ' a ' pen a 4 4 ' "i ; 04 B eee uw tt 2» # #B ie eo Rm OW OB. 5 GF Bo BOB te bt i & 2 Be ran ae a ee a 4S & Be S oS oe LE ws z a aa a SEO ree ted: ad wae we he Se ply wy ve:
es ea pin, pny 3 te NE get a iy fe ED, Bo ok eo Gs « 5 * ee % fet Bo Bs ro ned he, Ps cn. 4p Oe eke Me Eg eo Be BR BS * a a Loo eG Bh BS * ns a Te cece' x Was i rh, Mex Len! tr ak =.
x "y este 2 BILE x an icant pel ce dosed by the wa:
ard Sey ew ofthe f < gE ¥2 2 8 ls ms Me 3 < Pk sf state cs Nod 26 Settled. Rj = ay tyaeds LPeRted: ¢ GR Gat Be "aririent £ .
Ae.
oA ae fad as ioe ed ahay a pon a4 MS xe "
(Annexure-B, "Af e £ SREP ee plac 3 .
Oe shy WHE + at
-
APTS Res, .
co PeNar to be a we wy a a TOP 35 dates meh 3 bee whether the is ded 8 aS per the draft gen fered to be settled wh ig rer?
TO :
On record. The quest Seachinge fed st at is ity } OTL x these case ah < seniority of the applicants Annenure-A/s] can be Cons led s h rannot be nsett B32 » rs #8} Rees that a ce "4:
% clan Shave t thes:
g c 9S, Secretary *y of t aced 3 x + N ROSE {Annexure nd Oru ROSeRE es aya § < R..
£ irk Srige BP Thon Wri aR Bs r ~~ it = By > ten Nokes i am:
the sen ATR sy N a a Cor & Ranjan a x oh t te » 2S. Fotw be Yow HE 3 ed the ch:
ne, iw 2 sae rt ae well as ryt = ay circulars dated AS 2015S eh STEER torn i RY Sy Se TR ahh 4 etsy 8 ge Counter ~~ & og ria th fo cother ar £ Et e383 and & er MG tate' = +t % ate € S hediced thar <3 A charw BOTS {Annemure-A/ 5} ofthe respondents, to ohaties Shah a TAS tinge tf 43 ae a isions 4s ENS ™ layin ou del >».
parc 3 ~ Fe GA :
e:
or modified in the Hght of the and Fi and the orders were "rROR ch to Govt. of } st proy
2.
x OAL Ne other docus ne x eth issal wntecd 'a ee h, the bee es yo tbe apnt . ade PORES = vi .
ey BLES ee poe Xe that ib is % sy tm thie date of 2 Rwy 3 x AS ze ig er ts npeid zv Tens oe SPOR ":
Support af his con whem the re > Stimarity based o TUS » Pest ay 3s for ly me 4 Perusal of the arc the oorrecs as 16 at Annexure-A/ 1 of the D S95 3 ion within et} es 2 ae we SEESY om SSE € ye ron Fp a a8 Or P44 i.
PEE ~ > x x oO SS Py SEN .
x w» GYSES he t refenke Further, the O So Of re Rf 2 oom) 3 the enppl > Sods < a x 2 LS & ay é :
;
Fa ?
ae ma inf 6 tod # ~ x Ssary for h SQTngripy et 7 on bee % woe the .
ye 2 N xf ro rs 4 fee rie be a ay x PERCY Wer In Ss :¥ FES @ & person h Rat of & n iow CFS HY ERES NEN RRweY 3 : oat SSETEE po st a = Wad:
3
iy a, TN.
poe ™ Sug in the cirewlar dated 7. 1.2016 that the cierular dated AMLOUS will not have rethes Spechve effect, by abating as urider:.
above referred ORR sereniar eters * hs ermina ari ada ssitial Psy R Baa oa Bone herchy clarilice © Hon'ble Supreme Cour 'Rases of settled seniority cannot be Mm 8 eaten of HASES he 4B Basted after adn gla me oft time', fi.
soaeet wa Jeacd to > by a¥ettect joan hy the Sng sation an behalf af the funtories upheaval in settled se sority vees, which will be against the Eis fran ret eee eet e ipresne Court in variows cases, Thos Set adowes dre i SHONS are to be tnd only in cases of paeraitinent taking place imskilind grade on or after the date of ise oF the: wravar af eves EDS 2OTS without recasting af seni corit Sraspenive afient pp or. tots, OBS ins WAS wausd by the responcent Na, 2, clarifying as under:
"Yhis haa reference ts th ahave cited: ONEX the gon: farity of industrial Bs ployer 8 Wi ee Brade vw ihout any Hnbege ta skid fo Hed OFB] etter N No Per? JUS Sern anliy SO 1S 1s dated Bs Pri 2d froot the dade of ; Ay f a Sater S49, aso aid pot finshuction / Pent ennvakilied ersule.
However, provisions contagied jn WS] Saenot be ignored at ary time lance, Poot Note No. ig and other provisions contained in SRO Ise af L989 aret IRS of 1904 Should be taken fm to account whenever 3 eniployes is considered for selection tor Pramont anand senicr empha campletedd probation: aLy Perig i ay, oe Ris further reiterated hat if there is any siserepancy dae te none implementation of relevant SRO provisines, such seBority s annot be treated as SCHiad seniority and necessary action Y taken by cadre oordredf ue suiitharity to remave the disc crepancy & :
iS. From the creulars/eclarifeations of the respondent No. 2 as extracted above, 246 clear Skat the cirmular dated? 4.8 éiieet except that when the pee 1904 (R/4} were not im plemented, the seri larity cannot be treated as seltied werority eral if can be corrected by the cadre contr uINg authorioy, Ginge the wrevlars as discussed above have not heen fmpugmed in this GA, the modifications of the seniority lst as on 11.2015 {A/i) as mentioned in the show fSause Holice at Annexure-A/2 fin which the grounds mentioned indicate that the SRO provisions were not implemented in respect of seniority of the persons - Bumed in the notice at Annexure-A/2) are permissible to remove discrepancles dee to Hon-buplementation of the SRO provisions as per the circular dated IV S2017 {Annemnre-R/S}0 ie a gee * % Bod a aa Ss 4 xt foes ah Gs :
& Kk hod, re] 4, go bse a oe oe cs Fed a me ba . Be & oe 7 .
bes Boom te od wee , Ae Sf pee 7 oe > ee " » 'tet ee Po "4 g ' : we ; cg ¥ w thee ms te a, sxe < sf - a : ae e on ® eA #4 ma ie aan y ' 2 Bans wh gee oe S vA Badd ohn Nae? Tee hood a EG "S ra oad tela a 4 we : a bani UD at a ag ve ord Jn Not gs = " "Le | ee aie) ped 4 oo ee a -
ty ao tT 3 bn
- = Lg _ fogs "oo on vena . = ae od ty. ba i. +t weet oe Set BH, % ¢ BE DB an Line & on a ™ -
mo apt at Es 4 Peg ;
an a Bp RE 2 a "
= i s ia ; & pe . a3 an im esd e & FE ow : fa H# €@ & & . & fe st tes ' a Ms as pod A pst teed A dnd 5 ' oh S QC eres whee 2, oe :
% a a Y " ; es lena ; a G "
oA iy tent os g hag ne tea, ; Ch,
5 oh yok ya 1% 7 tee aed fea wet qo wed 5 Bs t-, 4 ae ber 4 is :
3 hae 0, wt :
eal a oo ie a oS © : ;
Pe g neg * bite, be " on é Fe Z be e& pg & oo & : Moo¢ -
4%, a, ~ 2 & ca Be 2 oO 4 ; 4 co :
rone~) BO ee oy Ch , ane mee % oa ke peek acd wee The a vg Ot y ee ao spy Oy a Bs pas a ; a) Ip Nat ot pot a +e Pom pa & £ "& ° z bok Ex) i om ow | 6 :
- be os ragl ve Be os Pat ts be i 2 oF pe a :
S f toe ios Sab soe| wee ol 2 cine ~ :
| J ts 2: foe. "
ms # Se 3 : SG oor a oe ay : ve ae : : og A 4 os as , es i $ py eee aed e 4 a : oe a ty ont o?. es i : 2 A ga re a ms t i | : y Eas ot aie cat =:
: : . eae, * ya ; a ~ as 2S .* & , ar: % he Se, j yo tte a a , ;
we pet = 4 :
Be se co a BS me 3 S ro & peel wey i we Meg ES re wed aoe i nome gen tea fs i z 4 SS i B 3 a oS ie ow fo oeey ou "S we ed i Paar . Sth Sete a i ah OR :
ot io ern! H f peed i ber mg eve H * oe | " ap ot | :
' tS ond. i : ye i ro on ; f mB | Freed oe :
Ja £ i in iB i ; a3 i hej, * et 2 E : ea :
- fe py 2 teh 2 2 % beat fo t : | "iy 2 fd z :
Go cones a : : . ; eae 'net Re, tee ws : 2 2 : aes wn oo ee ome ; ie a Vee * j 2 & ; te £ ae, o oe o z a é ) i . s oe Z os . -
: <3 bs a a :
j ve op ms a ~ & e & 'mt OE ;
a 4 m 8 ?
og 2s. ; oy 5 & pote} : bed a y= teh he Hy = " whe, faa :
Bios 7 o & tet me Le i n L faa! reed Food ¢ AG GF j F he _ mf " . H is & fen, tne, ; TS * ae wed ok { A Md food oo ;
5 i ;
ot any oy 4 > aed ;
a D Got pom Seay 3 oo 8G i : vee : 5 v E & . So 3 | 2 My Pee fs. H a 7 *