Karnataka High Court
National Insurance Co Ltd vs Smt Laxmamma on 10 January, 2011
Author: B.Sreenivase Gowda
Bench: B.Sreenivase Gowda
' ' 'V gagzeza 3% *§"§%% §%§§§% fifiiéfi? §§ ._ ? fig §§§§§§§§'¥ Efifisi ' "§"§§ ?§1%§$ ?§§§ Efifié §§§§%§ §§.§ §§§g§§§§f§"§§§ §5§§;§§§§§ § Egg'? gag gfi _ §§§é§§§§ 3 A ' ~ ' *%g"g$%:.3 gm wszmg 33$; figzgégé § éfigg-ia § 'ffifigafiifi g §;§§;a§;'T T' T g §%,$§§§' §? 3% ' V * . §$};%"':;§g ::.%§,:,%2;:é'§¥§" 3% £3 §§"§~E;
§fi.'"'%-2% §%%:R§;., '=§%§%:é&:;:'<:r°%f §£ Q?
.. " :'§%:E%% $2:
"?%% §§§§f%§%§?2°"'% gf §$§fi§§§§ §§§§ %§$%%2@:§ ggméiéégé §%%§ §§%$§§}?§§§,:%.~3? §§'%§§§§C;:a;é%?§m§;§ §§g§§?a£§*§'§§ 3% $3? %§'§% ééfi fig? §i§§%%"%§""?駧"'E«;%;'°§5$i% §§§r%§é:%,"§%é§% §*§§%§§*$§ fig %§ §§%§%§ %?% .%;@..%é2 éifsé :::§;§§s';*s Egéftiéiégggg §§§'"§:'°§ i§§§ ?§*§%:§§:§§z ég "fig $3 §%§§%§ if; %%%a& £§:§§§% §$%%%%§§'°:§ ggai - ' V .A .' $1?'--E_§g:Z§§§$'§" '§% §&:2§ ':?;§,3§ & %§%:§§% fiéfi *§;';?V%:s;!?:;a§§§%::§A:' §%;§s$§?L%.§§A;% §§§§m§§;%':§§ fig; ?§ef§§'§ §§§"%;§§§"%§ a amgg §""§§?%¥§§§ §§:égi駧§;"§ §'§§§§ fifi fig"
'--....%§§*;§é§'§:~éj;z;f:'9%$ §f§:e§§ §?a£§§§§§§f iézég §:*%%;%§*" §§ § ffgfi §;';;§?§ %§%?%%§§% _ %é§ga§?%§%§ ?g:§§%§§%::*§%;:@§;*§ fig, V4'§*&§$§§-V? A}§§'§. ?:@§§%§a%§%§ _;r*§@£§a§i;} $§ fififigfi §:.%éa§§%3: §'?'$%% fig ggmg ii? § fififi? §¥%§ §§§%§%§§ §§§§fi§% %%§§§%; fig g gzfigfzggg égggr gag §§§§ %:§*éa§i ggazé; Egé §%§§ §§ éggfig ' §§§§%§-Ea, Eség %%§§§§ fig gm §§'%§§§§@§'% fififié i%§ ¥"E'%§§%§? afiiiégéagz fiéfifi % £§§§§"§"% §§%%:%§§*z a $5 %§§%§$ ya §%g 2% §§§§§§§'%¥' §§%§§%§§§§;'§:%;§~__:"'..,A iééggfi :%@ §§§§§§§ mg §s~::§§::§ égsii ;§§_§*'a:§.%§%*:§f§-§_§é $3: fifiii §§%f§%'§ gf ifig ?f"§§%%§%§§;-- 1§§§%§§' éfimi 3%? Egg Q? gag mg wig? §$%'.*s_§ Efifi ?i'§§i?%§?* éfiiiéififi gag ififi %§%g&€i§:g '§§§$§*'§§ "¥§§'E§ T T %§§&§§% gm '§"'§*é%s§g§*:-gi %§;§§_;:':,3§§§§»~ §'*§§§§s:§%*§$§*§, ggézfi §§'iE'E?"§?駰'?§¢ 3 §§"'§ 3% §%§ §§§§;:.§;:%; §é:§§_:%'% §§:§@$s§§§§§ §% 52% 5': a ffigé a? fig §§§;+:§§§§§_§§{f%%;%§%§ izggés gféggg §§§* §%::?£i§%:_§%% égiééii ;éE§§§§§§:'ys_§§.§;@ §?§§§§?%§* §§§§§§@§§ :§§%%%%$ '%2:%2§f§§§i%$':"' - %:?:;a$ _%§%f° gm':
fifififéfié 'Egg ii:%3VI?§f§§§%;4é':'§§_§VV"§$__gag: §§é§§ fif §§%§'-E: §;§§§§'%§%§s§*"§fé§;--%:;:1::?i%§;"§ "E" §$§§%§$§..___§§s%* Em §§"§$§§?%?' $i§§§§%%§% $3? $23 '§§§§§.:_ §§§§%%%%:é§f@§§§ 352$ ::>§§:
gggggfi
--.. 'a.»*%;;'§s%§fi§%:§_.A:§:§:% wag: $2-§ _§§ fiéaééfiégggé aé fig flag ?a*§§§;§:§§ ég as: fig §é§§%§§*§§ gagggiasm gig a:§m§§§:§§§§§:"§ %§;%'*3§§z%g%%"§'%§§§%%% E23 §$§ gag? afié §§":::g2§§". fig §ié:F°"§§§§" $2? §§§$?'§§§Z §§%§ §"§ fig fig *%:'T€r:§§Ai';§%é§aé§ §§ gm fig §*§§§?%$? agizfig §§%§ §%% §;?'%§s*§ fig? §§%§%;:§§%§ $5 ' §§;§§§i§¢ §i§$§ § aigisg géiiéiéfi $§;§§§§§ 3% 33% §§§§§%§§'%%§ §a§§§2z:%§§ L fag ism 'm§:s:;:2§%;%kLLk%% Es: §§:%:§ Ea? E??? mg %%%;é§s* §§§% gfifi §%§§§'%§§é?§"§ §§ :§zm;:§éé§:§§y§§T%%:§§%é'% " afiggré 3% wéaaéé fig §%%& S. jag fiég aéiggé-g::?3§"§%§§£a;%'§:§§';§§:%g%§2 iéfifi mg §%§§§§;§§ 9% §% méagg £§:%§§§*§:r: §§2'€:§3:V::§§j'§§§é§*:%§;_t%%%;'L '*'i;*"%%§.i_1'§%:;£';§§§§%§ %%§§§ §§§§ §§$%§§§ fig %g%%:é %:§ ggégaai §m§5r; fig :-
éiégg 52%; $2 §:§§§%§': 3% §§$:
§§%%§§" §%§2'i;:«i§§:*': €:§%§::V:§§"?i;%%%é:§§%?€%.?;i§§§ 2%? %%§§°§:§?%§ ag a fig: '%§§?§§§§" _¥§§§ %:§:*:§.'-- §§é%;$§;%§;% §%§°' igéasgziég §E§§§§§ :.'j'§§E§§.§"§§§=:i%.§9§:§§ a.;%%§« A§§"2§$§'"§é%§§§§:§§%§§§§*§@ §§ §:%:$ mag {:25 %%gg =.*§%:§%§é.%"@§'§:*§v.§*:s§'v z?:§%::é §§'%i:§¥'§%§ §§ fig §§§:::f§§i§§%'§T.§%§%§% 32%: gig mg §%€9.r §§€§§%§"§£§ ii': %§%a Eéfiz %§§§;:駧€:_°1~s§%z:, $2-% §%$%'§§§§ wag §%E§%§fi ag § :?§$%% «?§§;?*é'§§%::2§f,"""A_« §§§"§$§§§?§§§§ §%;§§ %§s§- gg Efi §%%;?%; 'i%*e§- aigig Q?
-..;¥a{1:'¥:§§a;:%2i §§ éfig gm $3 fig 5 figié §§%§"§fi§?"' §§§§ fig §§'§*z€§7§§§E§ fiéiééfiiiiifi % fig $%§§§§%.%*%§%§ §*2§§ §'§'3§$??"§§ §%§§§§§'» gag? ?§§§%§§§ 3% 3%?
$3; 32% "§"?§§';£§§ 3% -
mg gmgazi %2:§-:% §%%$§§§§% gas? $5 §@:§§* £§'¥§%§"£§'i iwgs $2? ég 3§§§§*§ §§%§ agzé %§%;&§*@.._§§ §*f§£;:s "§:%§§%' . fig-€'i:§§%,. fig §§§§§%" §%%.§§§%§§§§ iiéfii fig'-§§§%%T§s% §§%%?§% §§%%"% §§i§§*§§;§§§ §26:§ %%&§%.§§§*% 35%?' @§ izég 5% %$ fiaéagaégé §§%%*§§'§$ éfig §*§§§§§§ é-Ezgga §;:%::%€:%§§§$§ fig? ':3? §"%;§§ $3 Nuomvt §§ §?§§ gaéfiw '?§§§§§ §§§§ $3» "?§'%§;§§2§§ mg §§.%.3§3§§§?§¥~V.§z§§ :?§':;*::§@fVVA:§%;§f§§v"%§"§;§ ;;%§a§;§a% §§? ?%§%駧§§§"§ fig §§§§;§§§?:§§§:;%§é%§A'~:§_§:%§§§* fiééég ~§"§_i§§:§i %%i§:§§§§ '--.?§;zf;{;§i§{% u .:§::a:.;:.%:§§:§§%§;§§§%" %§% §§§:§%§%.$. Q? V§V§%;é.§;"" gigzzagggég fifm §%€§*§§f§%{%iT'L»V%:;:«:s§%;§%':i§§§;_ 'gigs? §%§¥%' §§'s;:§ §§@§§§§§ fig" i§§§ §§.§g --. §%%駧'§%§ §§*$§§§'§'§ ';§:§?:$@§ afié$§§%a:§$§**"§':'§::'§:fs féa 9%: §'%% §§%§§§' géfig fiffifi fifigrg ég-;':~%3_ §§§§§__'§E§% §**§§3':§§§%§z%g '§§%sa:§§% Qgfififfififigm %%%§é?%:§~s:._'*§$§§m§%§ §$%§%%§ ég $?E Egg _§'§§§§§§§°' gégéaf fifiéfigzéjé-é§;_':*§§%§.%:?§:§:§ §i§§'1%f§i§%§§: §§§§§*'§%§ mega?" §§§§ §§ £§§&%'E§%§""§€§-g 'e%§2§ §§'*'%%%%"" §§§':.%§E§:§2:§:§§§§§ ézgafifg §§% £35': 21% §§%%$§" géfig, iigg .§-ééi §§ 駧'§:.§§":§§§§ ?%§ $$§"§%§§§:§%%:.§§§: §=s%€$§:§%§ '%§*'i.;%%;'ag":..f'i"§'j§%%é§;;::%§ ég Téggg flag: 31$: fiiéfi §§§§%"§ §§ 3% §§? ffifiiéifliéfigég §*;*g.%% aaégarfifié 5%? 'E§'§% '~..f'§i;?*%%a;s%:-£3 % %%*?a gas" %%'?§'.'%%§§"'f§ %% mg fififi %é:§%:§%* V :%&§<é:§§;:%§. §% ffiéééfififi fag %% gar %'fi%"""%iji§§; §;§§§%%§ %? fig ggé §ra'§§ H §§;§§é":':;%;€*' A' rag E3 2% E??? ..
gag §"2E§§jf§;=fE3§§"§§:§§ §§"%§§ ig %.;%§a% §§'§"%§§§%"§§Z §§ i.§§§%?§§ %§f:%;%§ $2?' g§§2§§§%%§;?§:; 4 33$ :25 gaé aséségag EEQ §§$§§ E? ' E; gag: %E$%..§§§'§ §'~ §§%§..§§§%éa§V':?'%;§§;§%%§§ §§§'¥%?§§ 'éggg Q? Eg §§ iiéfi fififigéfigfiiififi §%§§§'§%§ m§s§§;%;4."_%%}é §§'*§ gig: fig §§%§§§§' ggéfig fiééaéz fiééé %%"§*§';'§i.§~,:;a£:.a£'%s§é£g E3 fig §@:f%§§%;§:%§&;%1%:_§§:%§§:§§§§§§§_ §§ %§§§§ ??§§§;§%a:§ ég gfiggé ggfi :*§§%§§§i§a§%A§'7%':.:§*:-a§:<§:.:%_'§§%§§--giiggag fa; éasi fig §§é¥§§§§?'§ ég mg %§§§§%;%§£% ;%§"':5%2§%§.°'%'§:?§;;%fi§§ Vi;;'%; fig ég E §?§ gékaésgé $2 gag?
__'§"%:$ 3§é;§f§sé%a%sé§%'.éé%:%§[:§:£§§§§ g? 5% "§§§§§:_:?§§§ am T '=~..__%§'g:§§§§;'3 §%~.§§é% éfiifi gff §§"§§%?%§§ ig §.§§'*2§§??§%é gaé §§%%% z%% ég 5 * :§'$*§§'ia:€§§§' '» . §§*§??g %§;§;»z:%g»;;§::§; £5: §§:%2 :52 2% $5; ?5§'":§ §§§%§%§§::~§§;§:§:'$§::;:§ ig §%§§§§5§ %§%§§ §§§§§% étg fiégga .-
§§%%§§é-afég 'mg Q? §§§%s§:".Hf§%%'§é.T "v~. sgagafééé §§%a%§:*§§ '§§§r%%§5%§§.:A[§§§é{§;5§i" "
g fig? iéga "§r:??§:;§§§§ gm $2 $133: »A§:g;§s§g§- 'ééééefé vég,