Karnataka High Court
Basawaraj vs The Spl Lao on 16 September, 2009
Bench: N.K.Patil, C.R.Kumaraswamy
3:»: THE: HIGH QQURTT {>13 §{ARNA'E'A£{f&_ 5 CIRCLUET BENCH AT GBLBARGA "
IZ)A,'I'E";§ THIS THEE 16'1"?' was 0;»?»s§39':*E:s§éé;§i<a -i2§sé<;s .".5, PRESENT ' ms I~{(}N'BLE ry:R.a'é.:§-'§:;_sE AN'.i§.PAf"Fi LA ANB_._. " % ;
tmg §~§a:;r~s'BL§ beiR..}§?:g%?1<:E: ::.:%2'L§§ijz§:AR_AswAr5Y :v§.P.._A.cRf$5».:~E'®.s-14%Q_2ij;2Qb%gs; 4 ';§:_"M.EA.1§«zQ.;:5489j.2*0C%2_i' 3:."§*'.'xg;;.r~€G';-.i,§4&-9_;;20@2mac) mpg c3;0%.:§¢;.%3 1%' 2c*cqg:-- % 8E,*W2;E:E:"::::" ' '% V%
3. ;3A$Av¢é§i<A§j§- V' ° 3; :::;;;m~zU;:v:;s2: my ' A§€';%:§%s1:*i;3i$':2?;13sa§>?g$§ ' ' _s;.:} <Zi_H;r§?§.§3RAS¥£E?"FY §s<2'§m.%;%s,«:a.,;:@i";::¢t :15: AGE, V ®€3C»:..fiGRE~€'§{E'LTURE,
-V Rié} V§;N"'§<g:* BE§*<EP~E'UR, mg; 35 D{S_'§": GULBARGA '?§"£"«?;RE.iSEN'? Rggifiizm arr ...JQ'..v;:,;,aGE gamma, " fr-zgi QHIWAPUR, ~ ':;s§1s'§~: augmaaa, Mamas %&jE3C'§'G§%S '' {By Sré S.S.S,%Jg§ANS%EE;'?T°¥, Amt} * '3$@駧:
En} f5s;5'vi{§:
3. ma 89;, LAN}? A{:.QL;§S§Ti0N 0FFf§I;":ER, _ MAJOR & MWQR IRRfGrA'l'EE}N PR--C>JE{?l'i",.. -6 1. ' Mm wazezzm soumiga, A. ' auggafifia. * . THE'; EKECLETIVE Ei';i'~§{"§~EN£3E§R,"-., "~.
MENQR ?i§~2RiGA'{"IGN §>§e0{;E::::':,___"'-..V_ -- EWAN»-E-SHAHE, * " 'A fiULBAR<;A. _ ,;=§§E;SP<f}N§€§'~f'§"'S {Q {BY Sri. M4KUN:AR..,_mA §%<;;3;..2§v§:s9gs§§fiE_néf§"§'3;- Mm <:E;.Q8;>F:L§',;;3 'Life, 4.1" REELE 22 GP' C?C AGAENST 'E'H§£'JE}DG'1V¥_.EN'}-TVj--;fi1\$D,}'W§?:§£RZZ> DATE?) 1*?,4,20:32 PASSEEJ EN Lg<3..:~i§Q.5:2":4;i:é§8"0Nfmfi mg 0? THE: 1 AS131" .~CWI--L_ 3. J:J"i:;€:rE:"~..b 2($3;"e,:13;4';ww« GULBARGA PAR'E'L..Y ALE.-rC}¥§sJI:5é€.'} 'E'_i~§E'..--RE,:}~'§Z:'%f:?%%'5?.E P_rZ*Z"I"E'i'E{};%\§ 301:2; ENH2%.E'€€f3ED C{§EvZPE';§*€'Q~"§:3§?§{}?% ;§;3%I'::>L4S:;*v:;E?:'§z:__::~:{; §?'U§"i'§~§ER E;N;m§é<:e:ME;:~é'§'~ gs? caégiygsggafiesé.' M.E.a.:.::§f54$9*§. 2§z3é2:
'*;i§r.§§': 31533.? fi€Qfi§Si"§'§{}?*«§ {}F§'§CE3E€, ~.%%§»i;ai':>§i3':3t;'»--fs#:§';%::>§e ERR§{}A'§'£GN PRC§J£~;';C'I'j, Miss: 1fE.§§§_4L§_--,§*é SQLEQRA, GU'L§B,é%.;§§€C}'F§.
K " ' ":':~%.€ Ei':€§:c2m2;§; E§\EGE?§EE;R, _ Va;:::é:s:;>R §RRiG&'£'E€}N ?E{}éE€§'§"', '<.:2is;%:~%:;~$m;«;:, figzsmmsjggg HA9pgL:,A:fi'-s.
1' jggar" :=;§:§.§»;1i<::;:szm§, saga §~'{§E*€ EQESEE} :'§?~5D:
E. §ASAW?2R:§J, Sjf) CHANDRASHBTTY E-€'E;Vz%NASEDI}§¥PPfi, S} (3 CHANL3§€£§SHE'E"§'Y E€}'§'§ §e'§.53aJOg fié EKGE, €.}{":C:: AGRICULTURE RIO 'JENKAT BENNUR, V T11}: 85 EHST; GULBARGA AT PRESENT REiS¥E}_§?€G AT; _ V VELLAGE S<>m~ém::., "
TQ; (EHET"§'APUR; 'jg; 1. -
EEST: GUE.BA§3€3;%"~..,__ " » ..RESPGNUE§*«%TS {B}; Sr: s.%.v3%;'3A§&é;:§'S%:§£?Té V,-._}és.:jv.~;V.... MF;% '§«='ELjE§ .:j;'A3§$V.T:"5'4{Ti;<.':::>§r ;,,A.Ac'2', gagams? THE Ja:DGM§:§~éT";3N::: A%_h?'A:§D.__!1.§*§;:?;4.:2::£:2 PASSEEEE EN Lfidil :~:s:}.5;:?:z;.ii9<;:8 €;}_?§ "i*m;: §e>§.';,E' GE: mg: E A§;Z}L, é£'jE'%;'1E;- ».§{§E"§C:E3 {}UE,,TB§§R'€};%_PA.Rf'E'LY ALL€)"WEN{} '£'HE§ R{=ZFEZRE}?'*%CE ?E§'§'§'F§{}?§$:F'@E!*§; B§'éEi?i§"\E¥7CE-E €GEV§PE}?€8!%.'Ti{>E'§. ':9:«:j§:..é,fE» ""'§§§1Q §%€z%.'E"§'E3§%S 3% zsamim <33? :2-'s:}R ®§€.e3%::;"§$"I;%*js::_s,"§;>A5:*, §§.%<;.?fiTEE,, 4., EJELEVEREE '"§'%§i3.':
§'<:L:,a;}1:.;::~;_e:;;' ~ -
u JUfiGEEH?
' _ V ifiaeugii these "EWG maiigrg are pestfifi in Ehfi sifisrs iigi, are iaigezz 1;}; fag' fjaai fiisjsesa}; wfih the cazisaui Sf figs "§aa:*:1€§. 601311563}; a§Z)§€3i"§1}g £93" '£16 Cra$s~=:;bje¢*sors 311$ the Essiarrzeé ;%{}z% appgafifig E £2 appsllant in '£215 €0I}.};§€£'3i€§ __M,____,,_,,__,,,,,,,.,d;_....»-aw-as apjgxeai and rfispondfifit ii': the Crass Qhjacfiozi a11a:¥i.4'§3~;?:§§_"?:iE:-six"
gmunfi "that tha gubjsct matter ifivoiveci ii} ihg fifasééz Miég -- ciiraztiy cgyvertté by the ju&gme:-:11! ax2.ki1»A é.%§?ard'--«_pa:;3£§:fib«igyvVtifatis C-mm in MP3 :\za.:3491;2@<32 datefi :i'..9j:::;fb9. . ~. "
2, The instant cr0ss§5?g§é:cfi0n appfiai arisfis 011%: of tine comgiiafl ciataii :?.4.-meg passed in Lac :~»:'1c=,%5;éf:?'j £313 of the E Addi. cm: Jutige g':s§,;{f.' Q3333: §.:%;;3ha;<g.s;_'..i§"« ..
3.,» """ '°'rE§A1Vif§::'i§iVS§£f3fi7iJ{"C.:'{}f§S bi:j<=:::r'iio:1 is pI"€S(3:I1't€{i by the cross Obj.fEC'f,Qf :»,:e :é};{i:g+:;}t;§1;é3;:'i{:cf:fie::s3.i on the gmzmci that thé amsmzt at-1vé*3z:::f::A§i:%fi $3.3: %}:ic... ..f€eferz:§1ce Cauri is maéaquateg flWE:=':f:_;:'a§*-gs; '§ji%;€ :S%a%:______§j;as ;3res£;a'€,::(§ fix: appeai sszsiikfing m{§zi»%i§ca:i<:.:2g37f. €516 jmigmszzié: amzi award pafisaii $3}-r" {ha R€féI"€'3€3.Cé' §'§<>,'::17é§"V<:on€£:1{iéflg that {ha amimni azrgarded fig
-- €Xs$§53§1:*t*--., ' 4' " figs 333%; 31:"; S§a?~Ea.'fi2E measurrixzg 13 acres E2
-- gi3fi%,a$s sémateii 3: Vankai Bfiiifiiii' Eaiflk, Guibarga éiséxici:
* VV Eiéég '@6513 n{'>?i;§:3&{§ 3116; acqaiireé §:§»'" {ha Siam fiimugh the: 313' mgpendfini far €116: ?"i1§I"§{)Sfi 9f:s11s':3"":1{':ii0:1 (bf Khajé Eéézeizwoxf / Watflz Tank Vida pr$}.im3?.3:1arj;' Iiotifisatian iiateei imueé. and ptzbiishad under Sectizzrz 4{}.) sf . zfixcquisition Fact, fallevmdg by the f§:1ai__ I10:ifiéé'£i;_§:1L 'i$S'11€(§.v zmdei" Section 5(3) of the L.A..A<::t. 'men passtzd ihe Lé:{1€i__ Aéq%1§si:i0:; A~i3§§51;<:V€:?f gs:
mspmxxdfintj IS'? apgaeiiani. Not sgztisfiéd. ifiia award passed '$3? {he LAG, fileci an appiicatian uniimf Sec'iis;~*::.._ :i8{;';} @453. fie': $6eking I'€f€I'Ei1CEf :fe:21: -.¢:z}?§a'i1fue:9::5Ii: of_ f'h6' ~é€3ni§eflsati0n 011 the gY€31iI1€1v"€}(i£i'E"T}£la€} <:t<;V}é;;;e=;:3}::~3t%0§: é"s7s;'a;:':i$d ia: madequatex 95.51 " 4"§'%1£' flifiiufi after cmzsidezézig '£16 era}
2.-mii §:{?v€?§:'im.€fi'§;é?§I'fg;"'{i93i{§€£'i€3€ ans'? ethér maieriaia 91: rficard, 'V'ai§:§¥~:€fi;E"-"Li}:éM' ~;&}3§},}:~(Z£:?g"§i;OIi ii: par': azzfi awaxded :3, sum 0f '£0 31$ izyigaied iazzé 312$ E3.3:"§,{)G§j~ §}€A:"~.%C§€ ~§'.'"}'_ £13? Eanii. Fefiéixig aggzievsfi by {ha awarfi Csf V"~.amm1§§:%;i_:3%}}é: Cr::3ss-Qbj&<::'*t:0r }3€C€SSiia'{€é {Q present ingtafit scaiezing fiflhflflflfimfifii. Whereas, fim appe§}a;1*£fStaie Ems presenifid {ha apgmai Saaiiifig mefiificafiazg 9f the j31fi.gmeI1i azgaé awarfi passefi by the Qefemnce Cauri comistmiing ihai "the zzmourgi axvazfiaai is €§{C€SSi§;'€.
-«.
39. '?h:*. c1aim.a§:§sfCmss~eh}&€i@rs are €:1ti?Js;i::=::i:"'<?L{§"-_a sum of §€f3.."§,fi:'3gi§§€};'--- $35? gem 1:9 3.1:: ~ Sum 35 E%$.E,1§,4€)§;'~ per éiifffi ;ffes;p€--C§i'"'oif _'::i'i§*v rfispczcfivaéy. "§'§:e judgment and :01; i1?éf{=_'-§:1"<.=_..:1"<'*.';1:V~:T_' €ii)11rf. stamis mcadifmd "£0 {Em<éfia;*€sai€i~_e3£:'£e;at.=' }§§;c¢3;"'{ii1:gi}%' the éixstaxzt e::mss»ob§€cti0:1 SiaI1éiSf"fi.iSf§{)S€i€} (}f.' I
13., ficwevfir, it c§'0sS-0'Sj6:Ct0I'$ 33$ 13.233: e:1§:i%1€d jEE§r_.31:1t:::t93"2*faf£r t'§i§V".€'1€}';.';fi?j,f',7';§{E'1'"i0C:i of 1762 days in ffiéng th€:_r..::{;s_f5s~.:
.22, _ Vi€g i*§1€£3é. V§é£{}§fi_i:; psrmitteé is fiie mama) af ap}§eara1':s.::§:: 'Ear §"€s$§;2:3§;riie*;1_:9s'<f%§0. 1? and :3: wifixm fc;':";:* wefiiés, _____ Sd/..
IUDGE saj./a 313383 y.%i%%%'W%%%i~vn