State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Girdharlal B Lutharia vs Hukamchand R Gupta on 2 November, 2007
61/ 0/ue».3 <i.3'~il3l ['+Lcu"«>.L:~:L smart gyazm :>_L°m, :2»maL<:us,.
' 1 vzwilca rm--3eo,/9,00% f SD" -. ' . ma -, .. , f\r\-I m... ......--"x...
'01. Gift, -~ vu-c'"{L~<.rl-¢xlut \"L't)'l'1K7l --_g<+.L am Is' c-jsanfauu +s.u"mi 2m_ris;«;-rm §'-C164 -Vlg zhulrsra (1) gsmia am. {wt 3,; 1'1, :¢c1.~1'<';.'+<»ue{, mrt fitviut méi, 35101 its, gist.
(2) 1L%l~'£l% Tacz-:~mi'i-e can.
A, <tu;--*i.«t3, 5:. '-w'r34',sa«.__. .§;|4*l-C:Ié9.1,; / .9 [;s;«~+.a'1 [am re-am, in 213., L. ?ci§:t.L. ,--v.
:,,d \_., 0I."I.'~1u1.v."La1.<a gunman 93" Mai min:
8,. *1,;_;i-;~m., 2:223:13, . '. -" J'! '0t*l~<.1:'l.L. c:\My Documents\20l¥?-CASEXO(','TOBF man-2005. dot caslc-it :- élfiét-a dais :-- qélaafl 2391. #31. nu; mu}-sra <12$~ :-- cu.-'1:-uzll 2:12;. 1:. ms. 512:: :~ fiwmxil 2991. '>31. 31,<+1ou~{l w'w-¢2s{l=1{E1 ell-wit-1 Ill. 3.2116 63.851 :--~ Iiweaflula aflrzzcirz rd. 52:18" rt-2-3r:'iE1' %g:I.2_Z:w_:_2.zf¢_:!_x'€flc2:2~2 ~'~: 6 Qt Ct :~ ('1) aletvfl wila nus»: gmtt Hm 'W48 vfl s<=m--=m Ezara gm aumqwu rio¢2--e vu-"<51 gee. [mm was ctsm lltqmet
-itanru <m.'lu-- 1c/3./3.002 ru 21°; sic: gwil rum' eufl etc-Lrfl mite: zfiaca E9.
(2) gal silzus. 1132. szcuui azuéteil M.-1 A gum m=~uru<su ~t'<»La--<1,a MR 4 ruail-1 eigum at-1 «gas aa °a'qJ.<-ma 6?.l<1<:tL=bt;l amaii eaiqtelvl 31. $940,000/-- qga um «aigtil «mils e 2 ru cam; zusilct =g,s<1q.x-11 gs». szqmi 2»u€teil zufi fiuzlsct 2-Lmxqmwfl ¢2"iau~a"1-1 W113 2u--m'1swu'« 11?: 31. a,ooo;'« M <'::e.'lqvaru uueivu
31. 1,ooo/- '~ll9l gzeqqzrii gsa s9.cu=ti =~»uE1c-{L <»u3'lru 2u=ucuuu=r»it euit Mans 21% aflzua 2:. azqw 294:1": ec".. A ?:i3:'.i(3 C :\M\' Doennnnts\Z007~CASEXOCTOBEi?.\360--'Im6.doc amtcttuu vie-r--:--<: 1; =33', €1.25 égaag egg. C'§'«t21&:i £-2'tu.uZ1r£l é.§1.:'sd gstemi vflia yam. $3.
(a) élétvfl -'wile: gal mmqtm -im--~a ~u.=-A sia 9 anti ?@ zmucuwu -{cu--- 2 can 3 £3 £1 got -$-"¢'1iI.l'E.3ti zmucuuu
-it-c2--'1 2:131 e: mi rot-1 ouél-u M12 gate: :3, aflumi mnuqtmt c1213: vflék gm ueasmvtl (win: sia ®.
1101 softens -ic-t2--3a2/cc wile; vi. aeo/oe ru §l}§Llfla_lf{|.1 z; ('1) name kqc-miiva «it.
25. 'l?.Q-'L23, 3.1. uicissa sluzla, [3-s"l?.'1 21131211 ml, flat ah, gut.
(1) 2"LaLot§».21ous3'=témt 3>.E;2?t,--21=1.<gg 81-1, -"¢>i'3a.'1 ( SR3) gtoufi'. (3) alga cteiuouef §s&lq.t
3. "Lo, 21°zro1q~t,=tL!2'L3g2L--2:t={9Zr=i1 (3') 5l~L?.[3['E.Gll.i3 ¥.L¢t°fl01.liS uzcttailau
3. =rR.<vfl.,/2 9, eféaofln (IL) sitaemal otsgouzf °ar1cmo{1au
3. ao,°41w=flg2m12uqél, iea. 2%-1 tum, °gvtL3Lc'a. (E) [?1:;°m am. l3't<"r>L'1 3;. 41/2, zuiat s;-Eta, r_§e.:>.g2L 21¢, -'<'rti.°tl€LL{L mnatqn.
C:'\My Docu!Iient¢\200'f-CASE\0C'T0'BF,ll\36D--1f|06doc
(e) ai1:>.m'l gtutzlmt I5. <'g%lR°l1vtlél(3%{, 2»uri,s;«;1u. 53.3 :»,"n,..s, =gg5,g--gc~uS (c ) Ofla Htzlqta g§*>lLcH<>uz';" Mflifiil'-ti E. *1, azamsu. E93%.3lé» 21¢, '«>m:2<-i1 ((1) mzfeie nftr-u.<wS 251%]
23. [%r3'm task, eiiéim Djts, *ti?§3£g§:L 2:1".-.z*.c-$12.. (10) '*1jy'*i.li5 °a"1.u5%'UfiL1.I.«¢cU'1L 3:. '43{--'1c, [ecu €l%U15L2t$él&,'8'ilSL étélafi Iuét, glad. (<11) otisu u'L H€5ctL 3;. EM, 2?m.*jg§ ém, 2»i€1.e."I. ( aw) fj;»I,s?. (11) 0t3lCll*l?.Rl °zflcm°zr<=u.2S' =11:
Es. l.?mL[E1en. e€L%uL:.a'l, am 215, gym.
(13) gnmicil €*t3¥.C{l*tE.L%{ H13 (ax) ?rt[71ét [<imc--L °«*tL~"lt'i $>;"mv2;"L:St E1--1"L&9."I.qmi '2<I2uéz.r-v. in 1:, %1mI,qwr_I_ -44612-1 W133 cfl1{'."é:.s-Aura": & 2:131 %La-ucuvu. *i-'1~L'~l 2 '12.' {HL uqzésaa (55132 <s2<-as cvmqcu ecu "owl «1La'iw--2»3:"»u'<:~g vu zfm !§'H1*1L ruit fivlélia um wits» 623%: £==:"tw.=.:;'L:;». *1'».r:>r._a -EI.v.ri1 un.'lz"L saqvfl 2:m:'1 sifl, 1 éwfl H213 sliea {Hz :4. 10;' r;';-'L C:\My DocI|mems\20fl7-CASE\0CF0BER'.366-Z006.doc .31. a=;,ooo;'~-- 'll QR 'vale sic-u Catalan 155% fig-i'L*'i~i roiii» sfinflqtzéls sYv€1,%a=1vazt'1'eu=+.1q_u_uI,L -1'<»u'.»A-=4 -1"» séuvfmi Faun wvfi $l=~i=1fL 3361 9:1"! €141 as?-1 wgt gm:-L edl =.~m, r'{l1'*t'.£ %{£,*tL€LL'1Lt ri'«c.;.--q surfl iszlzuélvtl in g; gi1_;§ 2?i<:--iLa'«'1~ra zzwm mag <*{l3."tl'a in zitc-{Le rt szcu Et-{L .§I.<:+1q:>,"t mat '1 am Qwét s;2flau.sa.
sfiet 23 wt $fl?{lE.'ti qgmi °zrt2u:vu. 1;J:r':t 20m 2 €12;-{1 .i1:{'r42;'1 '£llHtCLU'3lL?<;L 5'<'Iemfl-1 Ioutfl aim cit '+u?c'«<»t2~<:I¢ Hi '«»u2L:7; its étavfl [sad at. 1311+,-'-- MS eém 24% EL Emit 2Lau.L ém, MP1 6.1151 31.
't,uo,ooo/-- ~-(1 ajuqs 2-a3' aim Ha; 2mLa:4.t<:u23"L :.'"c~aaz,"u"1 ='d§. kieitét -1 32¢-u v.~§.Iqm'1 $14131, §;..s'«2+1r1 ucu m.31.r:1 979, 5:24}. a+«IL»+.nTc1IfluI.u/'09:. =eui-1 ate *llF'L'lLHl 924.1%' e; .
(*3) 2u=u.cu<Iu 'i*'1t7c'-'i,3,'o',x9 2»:-E (1 L-'u9»{i~": -ma <-mqqmi Mtfic-fl wig; %u=1Lcu0u v1"c.us+-'1.,3,>r 2431 6:; -1u«»i.:2?e, 12:5 mm 2g 3% 't?iL (ta) -'bu amrfi gustit °zs"mi L::mu<u<ru r:<»+.:.~c vu (man °z£cu<-1 9:131 *ac--flr.-EL V1131 émi ¢9.'1*«u:z:7L23t =51: :-1é'1{s'"t,3.«2 Hie 'fl_'3!i %u>ucu<»u51 saga bttftrst elqvfl (15%? Came: «M M szluzzlw. $1 -aaisléa vtét btmqt mém await-1'; gmlkfx sial viefi. 291 «(egg
-iU=Lci1 °8LzSi»t is [dkcu-1 51% émvu ~:y:L2LHL =*¥+.dI|. «gm 9% £9 '3,
---~ ' -, ." ." .'~ .. _~,' .\I' .' '- . .3' .3...
ewucum *t°tv._--~3 mm 7: vu-"vi \i'L'<.'1'":. '1,3.:,»'Lo at ["i.~§.\I. aw «mm.
I'; \My Docum: nts\'LG07--(?ASF\0£"F OBFFU3 so-2005 (film:
@ {W6 %ttHtd.lUlL 'i0R~2,1L,€.'iO 2'11 Ta' ruit vilalret mil atia 'l'. étcusfl ?1,H51 a_s:{"I24,esz.'HVi.u"I% .94]. aaquni :2m,€4c-4 (9, vxzu3_ ;>+rmq_wn vim -5: 3; W-Rm ezzilca. 59. 1?1'rcuv1, s-am $?.'1.?{L*E1'. d§'.$'?i:'. £3'; '-Mia'. gmcu qfxi 'M31 EM r;:«,LC'm 3. &:u'+u»u'uu vi<»+.:¢~»a «xii .5 61 cmét emuqtuu *i°t§i--'t -u isnqieea eh. a.«:>;"t.uJ.21_v+.i, aw. gaqqt °2rcu<»{u2 23. 2wtLruvu2»{'1ila'L anucuvu +i'-1:; 3 «.125 ezetafi -"sn-Jr-,1 sia 23 Pmét 2tLHlclLULL ~im--<L "earl £4; '*3 an-32+': bu 7<7t'H','L<'n.."ti . '. . I ' + . '":"'"'W.% %u=ucw'Iu 't¢'t5i--3. avid 3 £9 cm-1 msrst éxtl nag (PH Lflrdla azqtal nrttclat £9. -"nu .=sL=~m'l rftéla 0i.°2f<tl zumruvu 'i9t%~'i 2l'ta.rZ--"a3 3301 .=;i¢'lqLe.1 c:.2é94'.l [?:m,n.-1, cuéleusfl. 2?m.aeI."L.ams. =11.«_5€11 ms-2. wlc-u.
£9 =»u slii viifiéiva =e»t-Ti ewucuvu =3{aé"s gm $;),ll4'Jlo,4?:tg'1:!: lr'U=ru~+. qsletaflhii-{I ac-M1 ziirwuzqtai :a»u~1<«1 aw'; 'LL $l3L'7;i ~:i:u§7L C'-tcI,I.H't :2:u,r'4c-:1 £9.
(a:-) 1%: em >smc4;--a-1.: 'fawn 1.9".<a.9{'. 2~'m.=x,.<v.,3E-+11 3;»: "st 'é.et'I<:{l fiél mm 3121''; eefla 9 3«. mi 3191 amcuaii "i€"i.;L'"i *qc~<«1"Ls c-fl=fl'a.s Téu-112?: it u<»<a15s 2333; "hit-7. msqmi, '»»u_w.v. 5+ cu2't~»+.--a.3/u,'<rw_. -u zefw °t:§.LQ Inlet ea: wig; V5': 2,-.13-.:C'; catzlba 1/Kit? ru Qlvs EH41 Czufigct éwilltizfl flaxqi Q23 ggcu eat .' 2313818: vmxlrugi 2»w1«;;i Emil EH31 alam 9434.1 W1 s<Iu.ri"!.-n. r.¥I.t5u.-21 Emu mé mm 321% <s--2'1=u€l-11 ésau mi? .s:mw.«a-L-.e,-.z.a,:1<;«.a~ee.\-t sail (':\Mv hm.-ur'sIenI::\2€}fl'7-CASE\\'7(T'l"0BFR'§360-2006.doc rteil Gmlrfl oflfl stile: Rlcfl $3 3, an awn &3.'lzLt2',1~1 312$ 51:. avlceita mile: rt aimlzil aimfita 213142: .&2vu,2 o§1cwu'l $1241 :1o:t.«.s.s;r{l a4Mmiam&a1 2123 213 ML au 31*! same. aw «mm aeélsdi tauvi émi ziflcéravta Emtvt qélewilvfl uem s.<;«L'l:a=ti Va' (193-t «mug aim 24-} am wlletvit Ema Em 32¢: (ma 3:2 «:3; titan @1531 £9 «Evil <-{tall eefla min} Eat-u =3},-.9121» ma Pugh; .a~2<:.L~1't °x31'1 an.-run wail. Ml am-11 33:21 °.r1ui \'m--e ai [Etkcurt »s'L2='1 A qmvfl -fin zfltll £9 3:, sad ¢2'1zu2'l--i1 42$ ag elite: em. s}u--fl-1: 23; 21:15 zéafirarfl w.a'l -rlsét «mi zmucuvu rim. ~a 2:13: B' rm ctt-2'11-1-1/rim: 2:1 Ftcgt nu? rniteu £9. at 3:31 -"e3'e€Lc?1~e~u {Emu-1 ctaletaaak mi 21u.'té<% amucuuu --ic-12-1 waits <alH1l>.s surll-ii :3 2:19: :1 éuvfl éifiazlal zma egg 8: 2g s:'a'a $5 24% sum we $501 vg tum uimrlsaac wet ;>.*g..r,-13:4:-3 F1 «ma :79 3», 2um,cuuu~1'l .§u«fl2$l "3 2323; bmza =u'3.c~u L-mi g um: ':t:§.l?. mid! é».-£1. éuélsct owl smwfl qiauu 221;; weuét nL<g,v. take; 2% A [Efizuvt <=1:«-.=~m1 gstetni °ar9u&c-t fztnlsct zmuqlm 1612-'3 -Mr] 7; (314-7_id cm <34. smfiaazl g. 7<'.'laLQ*t uécu Aw eta-u 2»'n1c3.+2 2212.513 301 a2'1:m-.»1La1m1qLuL1 -it-£1-x9 aflzlmzlata agzlw cuzlt-¢--*u'2r/2'2:
ail f3u21sctm=uq1uL1réotQ--1 éuvfluivfl [did 21.6 aziteu. E13 wnzuet
93. %tL?_tlCw!I.l *i5LQ-'{ :?Lac312x gut 4-2'lzu2~1L [9-.'~=1L~i qélc-tail am;
C:\M}' Docmhcntn\Z(I)7-CAS1?,\O(.'TOBlEIl1360-1(l(|6_x|cc wrnaud $3 3, wvlghfl new 2121 maomu um Q A éurfbs $322121 zrtuia {iv A sin-{ha aha Csaut muqmi mudet wail alaéais siurilas 29133 @501 .512? sviqtél 321-1 wuqtai wda -tea 312913 #1 «L2 étmfbs alga «lav: 32. rir-L-2-u slain': ck s«a=~1--3o3 $501 Mmcuni 'aauét £9 £1 ém €¢ twig, an aft '-flulé Ru-3 Qt'-lrli $15; mat; -wit. an-I wigfifl 6il°erl £2<lL51"J uhiasazl °?r émrfl =z»vflc4.=1i 21*1&?aru [5l"--Ctlrt cuiletail 01% 23 aim 23 31 2»u%u:«.<;m mam} -ml 2:131 aefl ¢~2'laue.'l«fl £_~2'lu_1e-11 new eeeftrzmi §ltS aw. ruoxg -551 mu (mm 61 ezcufioh °.fleSaIl aft new 2.2m&<x *7'; 212i zlilé vu éiltaazfl Q3 szqmi utaet 93 an-% and zumcuuu ~--i<-ua----~*1 ril u«-41;. eilzilés éurtlni uam qbutvu smirsea 31121 mi cmcvua 2; 82m em 3441
8. m:L"tvm--1/tr/Lcsx 211 tné-2 =1': °?m1 (34414-1 sacuni made: 23 Mi '=3; Ftcgct atiteu M91 29m'u$~e alien El-u wit s.sLFE:,ea. (9. *6-ljeicvld St, Curt 14:81 :3 2:, «flit séuvflas é's§§a2'1vi1 [iL.rs§Lmc:Luim&.a12§ uzg {lg c-uni 2) 3:, gm ¢=.'laweIl23t '=3' zézfiva 521% cm 23 22131 =% Evwurt $1221 2»utu2<;LrI mvfl eumcuuu *{'€-I2-3 2:131 2: 51 M12 95: ea :31 t:t*€1*l&<El em'; 2% an &9<1.i{'£'-l2id'ti. 2?u1<~1-z-u Ewan cmélezsflzk °3' zwucuvu vi:-124 sin-{lvu uleulsaet U3; safe 9 A -a°il2a§ éuvfl ctzsail artui aruucunl 34.13.61. :3 PL 'mi E1 e.~L'§l§<:l we sun. 9 3*.
<'u2'Luc--_--aa/u/can vu 21°; u.<»<«fl.a 523 ram utlaa «mi a g;s"'a C :\Hy DocmnIn!s\l007-CASE'\0tTl'0BER\360-2006.doc \ uletilsani °2:I§L1c'1eL 23» 3, -"cu anvil etc-M1 ;LL:;'b»t-- fitmrgx 2;": '«.|V°»fl-ug; '«>+.n,1lr:L @1q:'u_"I_ i_:'1c:C«1 auineen £9 :3+2.r§¢ fauiusm c-M t§,§lEsci\l .§urc'.1o*, visa (saw.-it %s' W". .s1=i<-4:511 $9 <*L'% 3»-I.-321$. Dru. C3'~¢:.'u'm e,::ctLCi=o' =Z3m '«cJ'Lc-i =«a'+1 L3,3ql.3<i Q16 €ts_;i m'ue'»1£7i 5:91 M21 1» é.LC:t'1.l 2§u1.€4.va (5; a_«.m,I.cu<n.t -11r»+.9.--»:é> mi EL'<»{r+¥+. u.<-cm 5té,l% Him e«u:>Z ctL2'1~»z--1/wax ail an nu}; 2,-wise'. 3125' {%'*.:;;t sad' gsaeu mi 3123 s2'1zm.'l-{l s"uStv§L ggxqnafi mi '>aqu'm;: 52 N1 sum mil. ?>tl'i mm 3% '>5 emvu vivirira smuiaaz *1 »:§u5' 3'34;
'\ 1 Emvfl .=?nS <2rcc.m.L«21 aufl '1 (3u«:é<t aim gufa. ~>_y2te'm~t': mi (acre cu HI.a1n,L wail. °?s2i1 $%Tu,I1'».'l,3'1 Hi;'bu, ah. a§i.c-fir: mu. mu. 3;- 3311 'J' Q5133 -"vim (P191 aailsssii v.»a5iL =a.<?i13{t '==u?i *é.'.":'.*U wiles. <3u,2"La«\t amei'm=. wig; szcfl I43 93 flail EL 2»tc~»i;'1 g.a=-l s;>.cu=+.i 23131 :3).
1 3;; 5, ~; ;
(1) «ac-141 wfla °sqir;;t€L élt'=t'1L zluléra 9; gm. é,s:>'"I3w.e9+.i %1mLqLvurio1'«:.~® érti St gzcfl °2r '{'f)j2 szczmi am {9 2::-4' 4% 32 6;'. 925* gm salqtani szcmti :»u<?{c«fl amLqL<»1L 'i°t-'<.,--»t9_'fl R1,.-gm.-«C: gs H, as. saqtni 2»ué1 25.
(9.) =»tv.1c-Lvubwi M51 3125' 52: cum ?vtL€{xi1 ML.
f':\Mv Docunu-nl:'2E|n7-('ASFi\0(YTDBFR\260-2006.doc
- 10,-
(a) mare «Q3: alcfl 2°g=>tm am 233:, €m=§L 2:11 3[3t%l~t°ii .31.
x N -\ K W. '\ V 'JHAMF ','x n '<.
Q'-L.ooo_,«'-- mu amen 7&9 cu d. «W1, up. <1 get! 343. W9 '%"r.<'--l?-?«.H 2»u%;aL Qiilltcufli. 2:131 £9 E, St-£1 :a.sL<att;?i1 .2951 £1-{L (3152. '>5: em.' ~~.£::-
'\'\"\ mucgjt rim til 8: ma. zfiftéravti ~mv€1 &?tss1L'ara 'iii? 213 3u't"*4iL'-irarit q§1,c--s.2l1 ?=La?i_%'«;..23i..<~'+.&;3%,V um. aacit.
("$141. '$1. 5fJLC'Li<'{.L"€l ) ( et'1v1.L5m ifltfi 'J 5a;+o4_:v_ 'inmza ('f:\M§I Documz:nks\2007wCASF\0C['UBER\36I!-20(36,dnc