Legal Document View

Unlock Advanced Research with PRISMAI

- Know your Kanoon - Doc Gen Hub - Counter Argument - Case Predict AI - Talk with IK Doc - ...
Upgrade to Premium
[Cites 0, Cited by 0]

Karnataka High Court

Habeeb Khan vs Oriental Insurance Co Ltd on 13 January, 2011

Author: Subhash B.Adi

Bench: Subhash B.Adi

AA! 1,
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE

§_)A'I"I?,-I) 'I'I'"§IS "I'i~{I?3 13"?" DAY OF JANUARY, 20? 1

B EFORES

'mp: I--'IC);\3'E3LE 3\fER.JUS'I'IC1%l SLEBE--IASE---1 Es_A;:,>.%~---- f   T'  

MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL No.547o/:?{oo7~J:'V: "  H
BE'§'W§:Z1€N:  ~ '  V V

I~13.beeb Khan

Aged 24 years  

S/0 Mohammed C:'h()L1SE', Ahmed E{h£1_1'i'»._

C/séksiam Pasha  V'

No.30, Viveshwam iayout.

43" Black, I)<3dc§a B'as{.i, _  f _ "  , 

Bangalare W55.  ~        ....APPELZI,AN'I'

{By 31::.Gm::u:§.i«1a:at§;..Ad%;.L " "

AN 1):

1.

T116 C.)I'i€I]1_.EA3.Al'1;1S]71f;£1E1LT€ Q. Ltd, CBO»? §?'ee1'1)/21.' h 1 G0 i'e;>.€'i_ Raad ," Je11a}'1--:1}ii---.Cf'0é$, Ch0kkaSiI;.«ndr.a, }":3a:1'ga'§Q1f'.r?; ~57 By '.51'-S Marigax'. ' ~ " .

kvigiizjzg-112zi2h, l\/Ie1jVO§" **** V ' S3/0 Ré1I1'1:1'r§;3._21 .L V-01:1 TAN'o,_1%1.,3V,_New No.73.

._ III Stage, I\§ef.ir New ~13-'ai1.t:I*1£~1.ya'th O'ffi(:e isange-s_._1'ore 85. . RESPON D1~:N'1S {E35}Sr;1.E}3.S.U1'21€:%$h, Aci"v.f(JI' R~I', R»2 S€§'\--'("3d] m:>1>§'::s\:; I«%'II,.::I:> {,EN¥)I€R SI%;C3'T'§(')N §'?3[.I.} «:3? MV A{','i' A£f}AiNS'II' 'I1'I{i§L ,.;1.:'I:>(.;M'EN'2'AND AwA.R1:) 1"_')A'£'I€Z) 15. 20.2006 ;>Ass:«:I3 " MY-'£ii E\3ff.).6052/053 <;)\% 'rm:-: FILE OF 'm:«: XII Ai7}DI..J'{ED(}£§.

--.M'HIv1§3§2£z.M.A<::':1"'. C:{i){_ER'1" (:2? SMTAIAJ CT:A[§E$E£3S. ax/§§s:'1'I'ec>I>c:2Li'I"A:\.% Asraiasx, 8AN(}AI..€I}RI€ [${"_';C'.I"I~8]§ P,£~\I'~i'1'I..-'Y A1,L<i)wIz~s(':; *:"I>£Ir: (1%/AIM . 'P%:'I":'I*I<3N §="<:;)R C0Pv'i§3E§?<§SA"1"I(I)N AE\Ei) s:3{:Ie:2«::;\:<3 I:N}~1'm\:'c;:::M.1aN'r =1)?' ' <::0M§>Ia:\.¥3A':'I<)N. "

A} T}-{I-E-E .2'-'xPI-31?.-:'x1, IS C30§\«"§§Nf_I'z GEN' FOR (')RI'.)ERS 'I'H'iE'5 DAY, '1."'i:'iE', CO'L?E'{'I' I§)E*ZI,I§\r'"f3l'RI%E§') '§'§"{Ii', F(i)1.I.{i)'\'v'I§\§C§:
JUUGMENT '§'1i1.e1"<% c.ie1a}.«*' of 11. days in fi1i.1'1g; 2:'1'1¢ appea'i';-.'I"§T:Q_i.1§h"

c:om.€:s't1'z':g 1"esp011c1e1'11, serveci and :*e:press31"1i.<3<:§...no"uQ13j£§3C:.t.i_(>ass'"

aye flied. Cause s;t10w1"; accep'a.£-3v.:i. iI)£:§ay _;;-.m:;a':me¢:'.._:vm,:;s,;¢:=gs 7 C(mss'ide1*eC}. on n1erii..

2. This is c1a§r11a;r:{.'$ e1});>ea.1fi1_L:'%§:c~i§j11g" "<::.{3r;%2i::1c<;~f%31e11t of Compexisatiora ibr' the il1"j1.v1I'"<}.»~1'..V:"S'L1i'i%€.I"€j§d.i. ia--3_ zac#:ide1':t. on 23.8.2005. Tz'i.bu:1aiA0r1 has awarcieci c()m})ensat.i<)n unsaE;isfit':ci with the 53;-z.i.d ax/*2-'2?;r(l..1::'aVs Ii'ii3c.1_{."I';[is: ._2i}i>'}3e21Vig. V

3. In.£%:11r£:r has n't')L=S: CE1_;iTiA1¢'1fi,;§;eci the award or the liabiiityp Hence. oniy qu€~*:st;i0r1Vt1'1_31.7;11"i:%és for C(}11Sid€Y&UOI1 in this appeai : . . . . . .. 'V V _t'c>.v4LU!:1etAi5ier the cslaimani is €niiiled_]br enh.ar1Cemeni of Co--r}'ip€I'1SC1,iii_0I1?; V ' ' :1. i<3xs;_'1§'€S 2=m,<:§ P7 two d1'sc11a1"ge s'L11.m1':a1'1'es p1'0d1.1Ct":d by <;1.éiii*;.'a211'1£. amt} the evi.d.cr.nc<--3. of PW2 {.1362 do<:'t'.01' clisclcmes é':.h21E.. ___%':1"'1<: C;1ai1':'1a.;3¥;. E12151 $1.1f'"f<3I;ed 1.}'lI"€(:? i11j1.,1}fi€ff5Z

i) C)(>1'1:>.;::c'> £11331 .<.'«mg:'11er§%.a;} 1.'raCt.&.:'1*r:. :s}1;1i"i'.[R) f€I_"£'11J.I'. ii.) C(31.§11'1':im.1t.<*:(i §"1"2::ct:1::rc3 pm,>:ir1'1aE ii:1.1n1er1,1ss (R) arm, iii} "i---iyp0i01e:1';i{é. sh.c;r<:k.

mg"

5. PR-'Z }121s s'tat".ed 1.113%, the ()1E'i.iI1'1E-1&1'; W'E:1S i11p221E.ie:%-f';_ on I[E1§'€€ o(~r:e2:sie:2)r1s. E"{<: e=1ci:11it%;c'~td on 16.1 1.2005 Lxzzder graf'zi1'1g; xx.-':13 a.pp1i::?d {.0 121:: right': .i"m'11u1' dlild 17:36. (:.E4::1.ir1'1e1:Vi1;'--2 désschaxgeci on 9.12.2005. $10. was €'.E','.~'z"I"'{<'_'»?_T' a£s<> é1'Ci*n§f)ii'.t.xecE_2'(>221-._V V 24.1.2006 and on 26. 3 .2006 exf.em.2=.1l If=;';*»«';;1ti}i);21" Jwz1:S;~.1*é;'uCwjed"'a.1'{é1fi above the knee: PO}? cast was 'I? 1155' to the hcy-sp*;t.a} on 8.7.2O06;__a1'1d z_1;A'1V_(1:<>;:1A'x>xr_c*'1',*;1,_VL:1e%§éss.z§%.f§,r Vfgvlzkeaixnexlt. and discharged on that there: is 30% ciisabiiiiy to t.h4(_»:'\.=.;f.i1()1e,'i:i»é)t%1--3%:;': t.11ai'., he was ear:1ing }{s.6.0Q0 was zigecfi abom, 22 years. 1'1v{)'\,§'-fQfivg,*i}1:"::.{}4 age of the <t}ai:1?:ant at. 24 years, i--E1¥:: ct1a=;mant at, Rs.3.000/~ by app1yi.ng ;*ig;§hT.~-- :11 u11'.1'p'1iei".. 112$"-déi,er111ined 1055 of fm.u:'e eanléngs gt. Rs. ;'.4;;2';4».oo/--. ., '2 2' 1:.::é1'.r:"_1:2cA1'" -counsel for {he cIairna.n'i. sL1b1néi.s that'. 2 cEai1m1§1*i, wziséj 'b1isi11ess1na1'1 and was ea1':1ing, Rs.E3.,O00/~. 7". On 1111.6 Oi.h€iE" hand learned COUEISCE1 z1;3;3c%2a.ré:1g for Lhe "i1'i's;~.;m3_.r_.é3L.1b1'r1it1,c:d ?;.}1e1E; the i11j1.11*y 1"nig__§m. not imve even aff-c:1ct,€:d . .éf1'2¢;=.__f1.11*1cii(>:'1zii ciziszaiaiiiiy. islvezn <)fi,11€:1*wise, bi,1Si1"1(:SS Could. be done ~ by the <?1.ai:I1az':%'. :;=.v:31'1 1-.1131: the ?.,:'i}:)z:11z1.1 I12.1ss 'i..a.1«:e1'1 20% cfissz1bi1i12y whzicéh 01': the: mghx-=?1" :+si.de.-E anti! ::~;uE31z1.i.1.I.e(i t.t1.21i,, ilk: awa1*<:i is j L: SE. an (I 1'€:E-1f5€i)1']£1b1E'..
E = /F
8. iI1S{.)fE1I' 1iaiui*e {if diS£1biIif.}? c:()1'i(7€i"1'i<~:d, no d0ub:'.~.._t.he doctor 112'-15:; st,2ii'ec§ 30% (iissziiiiéiiy. 2155 far as }'.£'}('.0I1'}(: >()'i7."L"i.}{3£=:,, ciaiiiiemi CC)I'1(',€'1'1i1€{1, t4§'1€1\'}-w('} no eviciencre. 'i'i"1c'. '1I.I 'ib1.1§'},2V1'iVV"'-- righfiy iiakeai Rs.3.00U/~ as I1'101"1i.h1}*' "'i'I"1'E?{)'1'}:7it"','. Diéii-"EE4)i1ViV'E§--§:".i£§v., ('.O§'}€3C1"}'1€'.d. ii. has; 1'eaI}'y :i.i'i'cct' in eai'iii.i'ig'._C-éipziciiégy' Q1' ..11(}é'.';'._iiL'. (iaiiiiot be made out. He. being 8 business. even U'i01)§;i'1 the ;_i.ribi1iig1.E-----i;iA€i~s; ggltgiiiifid'":t0ii'1p§ii.se1tioi1 on the head of f?..1LLl.§'€?. 10553 (if / --. howevei', Ciainiarii, is ('31'1flil'.1£';'('1"E'V('§3'V'. I3{s.:ifVC)V;0C,iQ,/if" head of }3ai1'i and siifieriiig. for aiflother Rs. 1.0.000/3, ._VE.v('}'\'X*L'T1:1:;(§E:>a:'1.: he is <::iit:.ii.Ie:d for anc)t.hei' __:'.m91v€:ya1i(:e and Iiouiishiiierit 'c11'i()l'.h€I' Rs.:"§.GOU/# is 2i?J'j;1r.dE?€1,éiowards loss of earning during laid 11p_pei'ie.d i'i{)i"t1i1fi§:§Vi:s g1'ar1t<:c£ arid towards this ciziimaiai' is i':i1\., 5;~;i,EC?i':%_§ 5 n'1o1ith3 income: i.e.. Rs.'I5,OO(}/W. In all.

(If1€1i."1})€{i7V.1'?'.4.:\"&§'i'}§.§:fVi€d for RS.60.000/- over amfl above the Vc_oIi'i.pei'i~a3at:%.Q'i'i z»m%z,11'(ité€} by the t:;'ibi.m2:i1 with i1iiei'e5t.. Séfwi RIDGE'