Karnataka High Court
M/S Iffco Tokio General Insurance Co Ltd vs Sri Gadarappa on 23 November, 2010
Author: L.Narayana Swamy
Bench: L.Narayana Swamy
§g¥fV_S§§: mvbg I1'? 3% fifi' €;'$£¥R'§"€3§"' §3fi{§'E§ '£'HI$ 'E33 :23*"§ E#&'1'?' Q? §?Q'%?'S%@ERg 231% Bgfffifig
2. ma HQFCQ ':'$I§€3 §&'@AL fisxsismszcfi m :;m 2%. zzziag BEisé;¥A.?*~§E .;r£.$g3§i;r."f-1? '*~ T W amg §@§,3§?,3a$y _ ._ ' am gagavaxga Eéfigk $33 ??;:?e:«,?$- ;""§'§'E£,Z-§~=7'§§ ' {§€¥'§'§'QE»f 2&2: 33%;: «4:~;«»§$&';32§; A f ~ §2:3'i%'$:'z'i2u&,:£m fi:.'E'E*%'§§_$.,, V 3% gnaw, 3'%'i~":$ms1%<; _ - * % A §é.13*~Efl§§;"E:flIaz.-';E;<_¢- §5::>--e352i'»ijf V' Rafi §T§' :§?"f;'§ §a%2-$;§i:'m'§:;L i K... Asgmzca V? «:73? 3., i'3Z;?'1%§é;$%:T$R £ "
2% may; awry? 9?: Vfiam " * =.,§f€¥ .&E£§§AL§.Jf Vfilgfifi . _ ':§"A.L§3'Q ERE §,§i.$E3E§§s.flfii 3% gm £23533'? 3; 2 ggfi, 2%: Lzifijfiififi §:a§,a§::s;. mg:
Sfififigfififi Tg§i.§§§K, 3&1? A1&§A$;RE BI$'}?RI{C"§' :3"? SEE ; § R AE~E'fi.}%E§§W;%fiR& &§'§. $33 $2 .% -I SE3 : Kséziagsgwrfi §«*@§,w$.s£«:s % ' ' §%R§.,2} "F;€§S gm :3 mm 853 may £3? §.:§§."'§' J§§ T Am mairggfi EA:m:2§«a'§:.;2§s§_§ §§;3s€;z§':;€ 3:;m::% ::x§m4s..s'2$s$ 31%: mg 9? $:*s.r§;~;;:.;*§@- {js:«mj3~é'..} v ' mmfi ammmam gw.駧§sa3'= 4%. ciézwfifla-z-saégax 5?
3.s,2.,¢z§3ew. 'iwm :- ':i.é;-..fR.a:$,§ '*§'E;£...%:§A1"E Q? ymmaxm §§.gmmz";;f<:;:s:. L' .
'ZEIS §a,§«*.A$_m§ma§,_§;*-gs may Egg caim §Em'vEg§é$ 'gag §§"QIgE.€l:;*§?§?i'$v$ _'~_ V' 7' Exzsigrazm c2;s.12gng:;ig% gm mam éatafi 2§.§§.2$@@ 4' an iha fflfi «sf fim fiévii gaaafgi % %% Jz3§~§% %%€f%w£'¥€3% §é"m§éii§:mk&r§ Etffiiifif VA hm awmflfi gféé awflfig fim .. gm afififi éf '§2 fi1»§§$%}' as fiam {Em {Sam fif wtiiimn with gm $3- 3* Tfm g£"fl'£AI§. izafimzl by féw ayggefiaxzi Ezmzzrwms Qzamgpaw is with tar '£2335 ?§$E§fifi ¢§' my aim fiumrigkafiaw, 'F§m afiatzéizzg 'w§fn.¢;:§a flzzmzégiwhaw-'-.}1% gfiad in 5: giaam Wham it waa mi pwmffisé mfg sf which it r@ in. v:i,$§&fi§:?. fif stigulatmé in tha 933.13%} V' raga' man §mm-2.':-a_-saw fa ? ~m§*.§;%mm % ~ "
. .. - wimem raéims sf it was net: yamimé;
' . > vi-5 Ema refierrfig in Exfigi -~--= £1145 ;j;7:_¢§z;§g siigulatw 3 m:2fi£'£.im*': far 3% 23% fif fii aam wiftl fim Egg beam wafiuead mzfi maxim: as k % ' ax.§z.'2§§:aaag;:r&m:1m H u ' L ..'§?€*s2§.;§1% is pkg 3,, ffiéiifi £7' 5 «fia akgetkmr 3.. zw "§'a3;uk 331$ aasa was r Cr,§ef?'i"[% $31' the sfiésxzm mzdfi Swémm i?;;"?"§, 3&4 {fie} $3." wad Wifi': Sawtésn 3.8"?' 35%? &€::£.
3"}. in suggmfi: $3' %2i$ :h§_ Qcmsiei mfemmé the sf tide rgwrmé £26: Q54 AC3 2&4 batwzffaéii C&;'E";3§&33'-:55' V5: ii,-."'5~i wwfiin fixes: éutsricbwifiw 'wifiz Efifiiiififii V in éeath sf tam §n§we& haé mi: whizgig mfi figiai m swam fzfixfi' "-fargéthar rawrwé it:
kéia asaurazm Qempam % mfzhamg ma aim. the , Saar: in time @515 naferraé; s*e.2.§:*a wag ' H H 'T 532* my vifi§a*u§m1 6? the 'by fzfia Qzba ughaxaa iizgia ma: gm Emarmzm : 2 I';
Tbs fmi rmgmsgfiegzii. ««~ .- Ema aufimififi VT Ehs awmé 3-?
fifiré afizzm ggmvfi agzxfifir $::Emm&m *5.» §.'%§ ef 1%?' 3% fie mffifiafi ta fiw ' m§ar%é, fit; §€% §:€'g§ 1&3 mad suhmfitfied timt gf g magma mm ,. ' § ami rmwf '£3523 samé.i$~;:z;_m "
7% fix: Em suhmxg' Elia: Smfin 1*}? 35 §e§"J fiat " rejeswdg Er: tfififi s5$m.z::::r..mé'¥:mA _ avaikbie fingiw Smtisn % %' :43%{:%; kg: amiiabkfi E5 aim ffififlfi upan in figfi Qfifi Km 13%? Wham it %Z*@1¢ if: krmch asf zggizg tiw "$.§;2z§.i.t'fmzm §m mt amém fim gngumxm ffgm aw c@mg§m$5€.§;€:2*: sswaffifi fiaafimz 3%? {Q} 23 mt 'E the 313$: :i%'::a1€'%__"i§. jiggfi' rem-mé ti: gem am . V .& 8% E {Em imzmei an &t.Tf:; afiéam 5% 51% gw Ex«s.§J; afifi RE 3% aiauiigt it 5% 5:
in, the £. $5 pa Exgfilgiim xmumxm £3. ram fig cm: rm gm %mit Whig}:
Em afikzisla pi{§§}' €§;3;:1§,§ ifi wiih tim wwt, H :33 _ * "§*a§izk, fa}. saga it cxrfisfi sfigulatafi 3:2»; $23.2, rm fig mt liakia w my 2% am Ffi azmk ahaga 321%: péacsg ef $3 Lam mahiaige is met mrmffimé ta E1: gig: in a };'.33§z$:2B whem be Ema "*'%m:t._.§s:: éfism mt mam: amt Iwurarm mm the 223% in aanfi*a"m1t§a3§3, af tiw . é "ii gm: aacifigrnié, ?$ mkea géam 'mfgné j . wzé fig par :&e mxfiéfimm :2? fiw ifi Kéiifigzi ffif Whififi ..5".'-,'if',"";£.,'-'If.',".
'I:¥§fifif 2;. :f=':'=:=5.-:' 5 it 3%: fifim 11% V5? f:.,=!£:}k§'r"f(' $22 Cd¢:«'u"n3":1*#'««J'-W , :3"
maée Efifik, Rs it is mfarrfi fay iha gppaiiazai Qmzilaai flat fim _§z..2dgmt1i am by 22513 gem mm 31:: 266% am 2::;§% by fix Qzzpmmm Q-aux: mg ACLE Efifig it is aahfiarmliy heié that when mama mg m eméaie is giimi éz:§1aa§§'%%§:§§é*§*,%E§g:i*$ ' L k :39 germit mad an amuzzt cf J 2:113 mafia iiafifieg Hawmamg J y
4 . _' V awmr E: éiraamé is mgagamagzgsggx éjiyj {Q f-*{:£1-m" ,= :2, §§;"£i*1'"rsg a~ :~§%:e we: Emve gmm fsifimugiz gm éafiutztefi xgsmé mw&r§_.:§"§:§T* 21$ aiamamé. Wm % J c':L§.ca..J O 2] 2? €531!' :.Z£">W»*»"'*"
fha gf mg is: ghguié have E3322 A far V fiipasemas.
'i.' 5 {Em rm ta 3% mama 2:3 gwa ma fig wwmfifi iim pwmnai éxgsmgmg Tha Z Ezw aéemeé 3. wmrg mifitigfiar and tha ~_ ' $%:§i:a:?§Z$ mxfitmipfifi '§§'€§'i3.§{§ 7% ?i Tim 31$: amm.1nz3 %m€$ Qlfifififi €§?fifi§§~ * §§%'§5 Tfis K. m mwaréa sf mmfig 24$ §§§§fi§%§«:
< mkgn piaw; tlmn ihfi ~s« mmwrjsafinn uxfim sthfl tami asmgansatmfi is :%'&2.,1$¢§ '33 %:,'z§>,%sfxz:L-§ 1353, E paw tfzm ffiihwizg ' H' ' Vv ism tribuxmé is axmmféfigfiy, fimésxzt > 5} Fiz.;:,<ra 'fa "Una 8f;>¢*黢1'li.01n7-*;V m "
IUDGE 'V V' ,6) £aF.:j'§ L' Y Ghélfi Elf . , ' ..~'.:l,§.r:_,3 2'23; ,3 0 if